This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Who is The Luse Companies?Luse Companies started 1923. 4th generation is actively running the company
Our Primary Utility Services Include:
Substation , Fossil, & Nuclear Firestopping
Transformer Protection
Power Plant Heat Rate Recovery Repairs
Nuclear Mech. Insulation
Nuclear & Fossil Abatement
The Live Electric and Substation Environment
Luse has installed fire protection in over 230 energized substations during the past three years, without accidents, injuries, or lost time incidents. Customers include ComEd, PG&E, PECO, DTE, Beta Steel, & Ameren to name a few.
WHY IS LUSE QUALIFIED TO WORK IN YOUR FACILITY?
SAFETY IS LUSE’S FIRST PRIORITY
FIRE: The uninvited guest to the dance of electrons
Proactive decisions help ensure the electrons keep flowing:
▪ Install fire protection enhancements.
▪ Learn from root cause lessons of others:
When new cable is pulled, restore the fire protection system, (i.e., rebuild penetration seal).
Plan for the restoration of fire protection items and schedule time for their repair, not just time to pull the new cable.
Implement a periodic fire protection inspection program.
PLANNING FOR FIRE EVENTS
Utilities are undertaking a proactive campaign to help ensure the electrons keep flowing. Some first steps to take are:
▪ Learn from root cause lessons and review industry practices
▪ Implement a multi-year fire protection program
Passive Fire Protection
Fire Plans and Fire Department Training
Detection
Suppression
FIRE: The uninvited guest to the dance of electrons
Planning For Fire Events
FIRE: The uninvited guest to the dance of electrons
Planning For Fire EventsPlanning For Fire Events
LUSE FortiFire® System restores Barrier Compartment
SUB-STATION BASEMENT
LUSE PROVIDES FIRE PROTECTION ENHANCEMENTS
SWITCHGEAR ROOM
FIRE
COMPARTMENTS HELP KEEP FIRE IN ROOM OF ORIGIN
Cable SpaceHatch
12kV Circuit Breakers
Cable DuctCable Duct
Station Battery
(DC Control Power)
To street12kV Power Cables in
Cable Space
Grade
12kV Bus
Control Wire
To street
Substations with Cable Space Areas
Environments can be challenging
Dealing With Challenges
Finding Solutions
Creative Problem Solving
THE FIRE DOOR HAD A HOLE IN IT
Some field conditions go beyond unique. This door opening was sealed with a combination of firestop materials restrained by steel plate (painted yellow) and door frame.
The door closes against this seal assembly, providing an enhanced level of fire resistance for this untested configuration.
The cost of one substation fire exceeded $7,000,000.
A similar fire event in a sub-station where LUSE’s turnkey package had been installed, helped reduce repair costs to less than $300,000.
It makes sense to consider spending a little now to save a lot later.
$
Sub-station repair costs after a fire
Fire Protection upgrade costs
Proactive Approach Reactive Approach
The Live Substation Environment
Job Brief / Safety meeting 2 times a day
Perform "lessons learned" job critique at end of shift
Underground Electrician can be part of work crew if required
Field survey spots unique design conditions prior to arrival of work crew
Hazards identified before the work starts
Use of designs and procedures, validated by years of hands-on experience
LUSE staff certifications include:
OSHA 30 OSHA 1910.269 OSHA 1910.331-335 NFPA 70E Confined Space Entry CPR / First Aid
SAFETY IS BUILT INTO LUSE WORK PROCESS
Stop - Think - Act - Review
WORK SAFE AND SMART Respect Equipment Zones
PENETRATION SEALS ARE THE LAST LINE OF DEFENSE IN A FIRE
Recognizing Fire Barrier Deficiencies
Unqualified or missing penetration seals (firestops) degrade the fire rating of the floor separating the switchgear room from the basement.
Examples of degraded fire barriers can allow passage of fire and smoke through the floor openings, creating problems for the operation of switchgear and/or the total loss of sub-station.
Smoke can travel up to 420 feet per minute, making containment essential.
THE DEGRADED FIRESTOP PROBLEM Problems:
Sealant degradation
No seal installed
Unqualified design
Combustible material
Solutions for the Substation Basement
The vast majority of Firestop Systems are designed to be installed from above the floor.
In substation basements, “above the floor” typically means inside a switch gear or bus cabinet.
LUSE has performed penetration seal upgrade work in over 230 substations.
This experience created a library of seal designs engineered to be installed from underneath the floor.
The LUSE library includes seal designs for different floor types, including:
Hollow core floors3 inch concrete slab6 to 9 inch concrete slabConcrete on metal pan deckMetal floor
LTT Firestop Instruction
CABLES THROUGH HOLLOW CORE FLOOR OPENING
SEALED FROM UNDERNEATH FLOOR
FIRE RATING:
3-HOURS
SMOKE SEAL:
YES
BARRIER TYPE:
HOLLOW CORE FLOOR
BARRIER LINING:
CONCRETE OR STEEL
BARRIER THICKNESS:
8 INCH MINIMUM
OPENING SIZE:
≤ 6 INCH ROUND
ANNULAR SPACE:
0" TO 3-1/2"
PENETRANT(S):
POWER OR CONTROL CABLES
INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS:
HILTI FS657 FIRE BLOCKS (ITEM E) INSERT FIRE BLOCKS INTO HOLLOW CORE FLOOR. USE FULL 8" LENGTH AND PUSH BLOCK INTO THE OPENING SO IT ENTERS THE UPPER PART OF THE FLOOR (ABOVE HOLLOW ZONE). THE BOTTOM OF BLOCK SHOULD BE FLUSH WITH BOTTOM SURFACE OF OPENING. ACCURATE CUTTING OF THE FIRE BLOCK IS NECESSARY TO FIRMLY ABUT CABLES. BEVEL EDGES OF BLOCK SO NEXT BLOCK ABUTS THE PREVIOUS BLOCK. SHAPE BLOCKS SO THEY COMPRESS AGAINST THE CIRCULAR SIDES OF THE OPENING. KEEP GAPS AS SMALL AS POSSIBLE.
HILTI FS-ONE CAULK (ITEM B, C OR D) INSTALL CAULK INTO ALL GAPS BETWEEN CABLES AND CABLES CABLES AND FIRE BLOCKS CABLES AND OPENING FIRE BLOCKS AND FIRE BLOCKS FIRE BLOCKS AND OPENING INSTALL CAULK TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT POSSIBLE
HILTI CP 643N FIRESTOP COLLAR (ITEM F, G, H OR I) COLLAR SHOULD BE LARGE ENOUGH TO COVER OPENING IN FLOOR. TRY TO KEEP A 1/2 INCH GAP BETWEEN CABLE AND COLLAR.
3/16" CONCRETE SCREW (ITEM L) WITH 3/4" OR LARGER WASHER (ITEM N)
FILL GAP BETWEEN CABLE(S) AND CP 643N FIRESTOP COLLAR WITH FS-ONE CAULK.
PLACEMENT OF SEALANT MATERIALS:
Based on Hilti Engineering Judgment xxxx DESIGN HC - 4
8"
NOTE: DO NOT INSTALL FIRE BLOCKS IN HORIZONTAL LAYERS. EACH VERTICAL FIRE BLOCK MUST LINE UP WITH THE FLOOR AREA ABOVE AND BELOW THE HOLLOW ZONE. THIS IS DIFFICULT TO ACCOMPLISH BECAUSE THE BLOCK CAN GET "CAUGHT" BY THE TOP OF THE HOLLOW AREA AS THE BLOCK IS BEING PUSHED INTO THE OPENING. ACCURATE CUTTING AND PLACEMENT IS NECESSARY TO FIT RECTANGULAR SHAPED BLOCKS INTO ROUND OPENING WITH ROUND PENETRANTS.
New Penetration Seal Design Drawing Format
LUSE ENHANCED FortiFire® DRAWINGS
Photographs are used to describe field conditions, helping personnel to choose correct firestop design for the specific field situation.
New installation directions are based upon installing sealant from underneath the floor.
Design limitations have been expanded by sealant manufacturer to encompass expected field conditions.
LTT Firestop Instruction
POWER CABLES THROUGH OPENING IN CONCRETE ON PAN DECK
SEAL FROM ABOVE AND BELOW FLOOR
FIRE RATING:
3-HOURS
SMOKE SEAL:
YES
BARRIER TYPE:
CONCRETE ON PAN DECK
BARRIER LINING:
CONCRETE W/ BEVELED EDGE
BARRIER THICKNESS:
7 INCH MINIMUM
OPENING SIZE:
≤ 40 INCH X 30 INCH
ABOVE OPENING:
OPEN (NO CABINET)
ANNULAR SPACE:
MINIMUM - 6"
MAXIMUM - 20"
PENETRANT(S):
THREE 69KV POWER CABLES
PHOTO OF EXAMPLE OPENING:
INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS:
18 GAUGE SHEET METAL PLATE CUT SHEET METAL SO IT OVERLAPS ONTO PAN DECK A MINIMUM OF 2" AND STAYS AWAY FROM CABLE 2-1/2". USE 3/16" CONCRETE SCREW WITH 1-1/2" STEEL WASHER TO FASTEN PLATE(S). ONE FASTENER EVERY 8 INCHES.
MINERAL WOOL (4 PCF DENSITY) (2" THICK) PLACE MINERAL WOOL ON TOP OF SHEET METAL, MAKING SURE CABLES ARE ENCAPSULATED. FILL ENTIRE AREA OF OPENING WITH MINERAL WOOL.
HILTI FS657 FIRE BLOCKS INSERT FIRE BLOCKS INTO FLOOR OPENING. USE 8" LENGTH AND COMPRESS BLOCK IN PLACE THE BOTTOM OF BLOCK SHOULD REST ON TOP OF MINERAL WOOL. ACCURATE CUTTING OF THE FIRE BLOCK IS NECESSARY TO FIRMLY ABUT OPENING AND CABLES. CUT BLOCKS SO GAPS BETWEEN BLOCKS, CABLES AND OPENING ARE SMALL AS POSSIBLE.
HILTI FS-ONE CAULK INSTALL CAULK INTO ALL GAPS BETWEEN CABLES AND CABLES CABLES AND FIRE BLOCKS CABLES AND OPENING FIRE BLOCKS AND FIRE BLOCKS FIRE BLOCKS AND OPENING INSTALL CAULK TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT POSSIBLE
.
PLACEMENT OF SEALANT MATERIALS:
Based on Hilti Engineering Judgment xxxx DESIGN PD - 2
NOTE: STAGGER FIRE BLOCK INSTALLATION (IE BRICK WALL).
Penetration Seal Instructions KNOWLEDGEABLE DIRECTIONS
LUSE incorporates lessons learned into our training programs, to continue to increase the high quality of our work.
LTT Firestop Instruction
GENERAL INSTALLATION GUIDELINES
EXAMPLE OF INCORRECTLY INSTALLED FIRE BLOCKS
PHOTO SHOWS THE WRONG WAY TO INSTALL FIRE BLOCKS. CORRECT FIRE BLOCK INSTALLATION INCLUDES:
FIRE BLOCKS NEED FULL 8 INCH LENGTH INSTALLED VERTICALLY IN HOLLOW CORE FLOOR BARRIERS.
THE SIDES OF FIRE BLOCKS NEED TO BE ACCURATELY CUT SO THE GAPS BETWEEN ADJACENT BLOCKS ARE SMALL.
THE ENTIRE OPENING NEEDS VERTICAL FIRE BLOCKS INSTALLED.
FIRE BLOCKS ARE INSTALLED LIKE BRICK WALLS, WITH THE JOINTS STAGGERED. CAULK ALL GAPS ON UNDERSIDE.
CUT FIRE BLOCKS TO CONFORM TO OPENING AND PENETRANTS
STAGGER JOINTS BETWEEN FIRE BLOCKS
CORRECT FIRE BLOCK INSTALLATION PROCESS CALLS FOR JOINTS TO BE STAGGERED, SO CUT THE BLOCK IN HALF WHEN INSTALLING THE SECOND COURSE. PHOTO SHOWS AN OPTIONAL BEAD OF CAULK PLACED BETWEEN THE BLOCKS, PRIOR TO BLOCK INSTALLATION. FIRE BLOCKS ARE FRICTION FIT IN-PLACE. THIS EXAMPLE SEAL IS IN A SOLID CONCRETE FLOOR THAT IS ONLY 6 INCH THICK. THIS EXPLAINS WHY THE FIRE BLOCKS IN THIS PHOTO HAVE BEEN INSTALLED WITH THE 5 INCH DEPTH PENETRATING THE BARRIER. HOLLOW CORE FLOORS REQUIRE FIRE BLOCKS TO BE INSTALLED WITH THE 8 INCH DEPTH THROUGH THE FLOOR.
CUT, TRIM, PLACE AND/OR STUFF FIRE BLOCKS
INSTALLING FIRE BLOCKS AROUND PENETRANTS IS THE MOST DIFFICULT ASPECT OF THIS SEAL DESIGN. THE FULL EIGHT INCH LENGTH OF FIRE BLOCK HAS TO BE PLACED WITHIN THE HOLLOW CORE FLOOR. INSTALLATION MAY BECOME DIFFICULT AROUND THE PERIMETER OF THE OPENING WHERE A FIRE BLOCK CAN GET CAUGHT BY THE TOP OF THE HOLLOW OPENING. LARGER PIECES ARE EASIER TO PUSH INTO POSITION, COMPARED TO SMALLER PIECES. WORK FROM ONE SIDE OF THE OPENING TO THE OTHER. PLACE THE SMALL PIECES BEFORE THE BIG PIECES. IT IS BETTER TO TRIM AND CUT A BIG PIECE THAN TO INSTALL MULTIPLE SMALL PIECES. KEEP GAPS AS SMALL AS POSSIBLE
ACCURATE CUTTING OF FIRE BLOCK IS NECESSARY
SHOWS ACCURATE CUTTING OF FIRE BLOCKS ON LEFT SIDE OF EXAMPLE. AT TOP OF OPENING, SHORT PIECES OF FIRE BLOCKS WERE INSTALLED, DUE TO THE CABLES RUNNING THROUGH THE OPENING AT AN ANGLE. THIS CREATED AN OBSTRUCTION. THIS OPENING IS READY TO BE CAULKED.
FIRE BLOCK INSTALLED HORIZONTAL INSTEAD OF VERTICAL.
SMALL PIECE OF FIRE BLOCK INSTALLED INSTEAD OF 8" LONG PIECE. INCOMPLETE FILL AROUND CABLES.
CUT BLOCKS ACCURATELY TO FOLLOW THE CONTOUR OF ROUND OPENINGS AND PENETRANTS. STAGGER JOINTS BETWEEN BLOCKS.
APPLY CAULK TO ALL GAPS. INSTALL AS MUCH CAULK AS POSSIBLE INTO ALL GAPS. RULE: THE BIGGER THE GAP, THE DEEPER THE CAULK NEEDS TO BE INSTALLED.
The Substation Basement
Installation of firestopping in substation floor (ceiling of basement) to maintain the fire rating of the floor slab.
Firestopping work performed from underneath the floor.
Custom LUSE/Manufacturer Firestop Designs
Trained Installation Personnel
Working safely is our first step
UTILIZE NEW FIRESTOP DESIGNS
Example basement and fire barrier penetration seals
Testing is foundation of Penetration Seals
TESTING FIRESTOPS
Test slab being removed from furnace. Note that cable bundle in center has burned through.
Firestops are tested to ASTM standard E814.
Test calls for temperatures of 1,000° F in first five minutes of test, climbing to 1,925° F at three hours.
Cold side temperatures are monitored during test.
After fire exposure, the test slab and seals are subjected to a powerful hose stream blast.
COLLAR HANGING ON SIDE OF CABLE TRAY IDENTIFIES CABLE LOADING WHERE A COLLAR WILL BE INSTALLED
PENETRATIONSEALS Preview of Common Installation
1st step INSTALL FIRE BLOCKS/PILLOWS
Three power cables penetrating hollow core floor, as shown below.
Install Fire Blocks/Pillows into opening, so 8" depth of goes through floor.
Top of Fire Block/Pillow should reach upper portion of opening (area above hollow core).
PENETRATION SEALS Four Steps of Collar installation
2nd step INSTALL PREMIUM FIRESTOP CAULK
Three power cables penetrating hollow core floor, as shown below.
Install Caulk into all gaps between: cables and cables cables and fire blocks cables and opening blocks/pillows and blocks/pillows blocks/pillows and opening
PENETRATION SEALS Four Steps of Collar installation
3rd step INSTALL FIRESTOP COLLAR
Three power cables penetrating hollow core floor, as shown below.
Install Firestop Collar
PENETRATION SEALS Four Steps of Collar installation
FASTENING COLLARS TO BARRIER
Collars are connected to concrete barriers with concrete screws and washers.
The fasteners should be evenly spaced around the collar.
Approved sizes of fasteners and washers:
3/16 X 1-1/4 CONCRETE SCREW WITH 3/4" WASHER 1/4 X 1-1/4 CONCRETE SCREW WITH 3/4" WASHER
LARGER SIZE WASHERS ARE ALSO ACCEPTABLE
PENETRATION SEALS Firestop Collars
4th step CAULK INSIDE OF COLLAR
Three power cables penetrating hollow core floor, as shown below.
Install Caulk inside of Collar
PENETRATION SEALS Four Steps of Collar installation
Large Openings are easily addressed with Hilti Firestop Materials
FIRE BLOCKS/PILLOWS ARE BUILT TO PROVIDE FUNCTIONING INSTALLATIONS IN DIFFICULT ENVIRONMENTS
72" x 48" opening, prior to wire mesh installation.
36" x 48" opening. White spots are concrete dust from drilling holes for mechanical fasteners.
Problem Solving
SEPARATING THE STAIRWAY FROM ELECTRICAL HAZARDS
LUSE constructed 2-hour fire rated walls around stairways, providing a safe haven and exit path for this building.
This work included a 90° rotation of existing stairs to allow the construction of the new wall in a congested area.
LUSE invites the opportunity to help solve problems in your facility.
Problem Solving
DEALING WITH CHALLENGES
Problem solving is part of LUSE’s scope
POWER CABLE JOINT PROTECTION
Cable Splices
FIRE CAUSED BY CABLE JOINT FAILURE
Problem:
Cable connections (joints / splices) have overheated and exploded.
Loss:
Fire and molten metal from cable fault knocked out adjacent cables, shutting down other power and control circuits.
Circle shows area of previous joint failure.
White material shows partial coverage of new EP3990 Wrap to
protect adjacent cables.
CABLE JOINTS
Cable Splices
POWER CABLE WRAP SOLUTION
The Power Cable Wrap solution involves wrapping the joint (plus one foot on each side) and the adjacent cables above and below the joint.
Upon exposure to fire, EP3990 Wrap forms a char layer (similar to ceramic cell structure) which helps protect the underlying cable.
This wrap is not designed to contain an arc blast.
CABLE JOINTS
CONTROL CABLE PROTECTION
Protect the Control Cables
Problem:
Burning power cables have damaged control cables routed above power cables, degrading ability to operate station.
BURNING POWER CABLES THREATEN CONTROL CABLES
Power CablesPower Cables
Control CablesControl Cables
Protect the Control Cables
EACH SUBSTATION IS DIFFERENT
When burning power cables are envisioned, the hot gasses will rise and then be deflected by the FB3600-UT Silica Cloth.
This installation prevents the cable tray from acting like a large frying pan, where the control cables are cooked.
Talk about cooking!
This hanging pile of spaghetti will take some thought to come up with an appropriate method of protection.
Protect the Control Cables
The FB3600-UT high temperature fabric provides thermal protection for control cables inside of cable tray.
Air gap between fabric and cable tray shields cables from direct flame exposure.
Cable drops / cable bundles are individually covered.
Heat radiating through closed steel hatch cover (during basement fire) melted the battery, resulting in failure of sub-station backup power.
Loss:
Damage to backup power system prevented operation of switchgear, leading to larger outage.
Radiant heat through metal hatch melted and
shorted out battery
Protecting back-up Power
SOLUTION: RADIANT ENERGY SHIELD
Open hatch in process of having radiant heat shield fastened to steel plate.
Closed hatch with radiant heat shield.
HATCH PROTECTION
ACCESS HATCHES ARE DIFFERENT STYLES
The size and shape of access hatches varies.
A single pattern does not cover each type of hatch.
Hatch Protection
MAY USE MULTIPLE PIECES OF BOARD
Multiple pieces of Firestop Board may be needed to cover the underside of a hatch.
Due to obstructions (opening handle, hinge, hand holds, safety barrier hinge, etc.) the entire hatch will not be completely covered.
Only portions of this example have wrap strip installed, because steel strengthening of hatch creates two compartments.
1
2
3 4 5
Hatch Protection
Transformer Cable Drop Penetrations
OIL INTRUSION PROTECTION
Open cable penetrations below the transformer "dog house“ can provide a path for oil, water and fire to enter the substation basement.
The sealants LUSE uses to seal these openings are designed to resist oil, water and fire.
Several solutions are available:
Cable Trough Water Mitigation Sealing
THE NEED TO SEAL CABLE TROUGH
Water inside of cable trough, moving toward opening in substation basement wall.
Water cascading into basement and cable tray.
Wooden board will stop a large rodent,but not water or oil.
Cable Trough Water Mitigation Sealing
THE CABLE TROUGH SOLUTION
This cable trough allowed rainwater to enter substation basement on regular basis.
Shows installation of perforated PVC pipe embedded in grout dam. The drain pipe connects to station sump pump.
Urethane foam was placed on top of grout. The foam allows for future cable pulling with no damage to grout dam.
Side walls of trough show marks from “river” of water that flowed into substation basement.
Cable Trough Oil Mitigation Sealing
In the event of transformer rupture, the cable trough provides a path for burning oil to enter the substation basement.
The yellow arrows track the potential path of oil that can drain into the trough and then flow into the substation cable space.
As of 10.12.12, no products or engineered systems reviewed have been able to 100% resolve the burning oil problem while allowing for ease of cable removal & replacement.
Oil Filled Equipment Hazard Within 10 feet of Building
Auxiliary transformers often contain oil.
During an abnormal event, oil can flow down conduits and enter the substation basement.
Sealing these conduits to prevent burning oil from entering the cable space is a prudent action.
Aftermath of auxiliary transformer event that propagated fire into substation basement.
Oil leaked into basement following embedded conduits in concrete slab.
OIL INTRUSION PROTECTION
Oil Filled Equipment HazardSWITCHGEAR ROOM
SUBSTATION BASEMENT
AUXILIARY TRANSFORMER
OR OIL FILLED EQUIPMENT
EXTERIOR WALL SEAL
BELOW GRADE EXTERIOR WALL SEALS
EXTERIOR WALL SEALS NEED TO BE OIL, WATER AND FIRE RESISTANT
AUX POWER CABLES
OIL INTRUSION PROTECTION
New Compartments in Power Station Tunnels
ELECTRIC POWER STATIONS
LUSE Installs Fire Protection
in live 138,000 volt environment
New Compartments in Power Station Tunnels
Silicone Elastomer used to seal 138 kV Cables in new fire walls.
Silicone elastomer penetration seals were originally used in nuclear plants. Project engineer specified the technology in this T&D application, due to robust nature of seal design.
SILICONE ELASTOMER SEAL
New Compartments in Power Station Tunnels
Flexible boot seals allow for pipe movement.
3-hour fire rating.
Flexible boot seals provide considerable pressure resistance.
FIRE AND PRESSURE RESISTANT SEALS
Flexible boot penetration seals were also used in nuclear plants
FLEXIBLE BOOT SEAL
Weather Protection
Silicone Sheet and Caulk provide leakage protection in concrete roof.
Weatherproof seals cover fire rated sealants installed in plane of floor.
Silicone materials provide excellent UV protection.
PREVENTING WATER LEAKAGE
Weather seals encapsulate 69 kV power cables as they penetrate concrete deck.
Multiple electrical conduits penetrate slab
Structural Steel Fireproofing
Mineral wool board fireproofing eliminates adhesion problems common to spray applied fireproofing.
"Dry" material is easily installed in retrofit applications.
MINERAL WOOL FIREPROOFING
STEEL TRUSS IN PROCESS OF BEING COVERED
Fire Protection for New Sub-stations
LUSE personnel have decades of fire protection installation and management experience