Intellectual Property for Accountants A Definitive Guide to IP for the practising accountant Presenter: Nick Weston William Buck, Melbourne 25 November, 2014
Jul 10, 2015
Intellectual Property for AccountantsA Definitive Guide to IP for the practising accountant
Presenter: Nick WestonWilliam Buck, Melbourne25 November, 2014
This launch of the Nicholas Weston White Paper, IP for Accountants provides an overview of intellectual property (IP) and the various types of rights available
We outline of each type of IP protection and the levers that drive the economic value of IP
The session will conclude with a brief overview of how accountants with a basic familiarity with IP can advantage themselves and their clients
2
Intellectual Property for Accountants
Agenda
• Types of intellectual property• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
3
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual property
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
4
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual property
Intellectual property (IP) refers to creations of the mind: inventions, literary and artistic works, and symbols, names, images, and designs used in commerce
IP is often represented in the form of patents, registered designs, trade marks, copyright, circuit layout rights, plant breeder’s rights and trade secrets
Domain names and some forms of data can also be IP
IP for Accountants
5 World Intellectual Property Organization http://www.wipo.int/about-ip/en/
What is intellectual property?
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
6
IP for AccountantsIntellectual Property
A patent is a temporary monopoly (generally 20 years-subject to possible extension for pharmaceutical substances) in a technological innovation granted to the patentee
Not more than 18 months after the lodgement of a patent application, a detailed description of the invention becomes available for public inspection
Types of Intellectual Property
7
Patents
Three criteria for a granted patent• It must be novel • It must be non-obvious• It must have commercial utility
In Australia there are two types of patent applications available
• Standard Patents • Innovation Patents
Types of Intellectual Property
8
Patents
A Standard Patent
• Specification consists of a description and claims defining the monopoly conferred by the patent
• There is a need to clearly set out at the filing date how each step of
the invention across the scope of the claims can be carried out and tested
• Claims define novel articles, parts of articles, substances,
compositions, living organisms, methods of therapeutic treatment or other uses of the foregoing, and/or manufacturing processes:
• more than one these claim types may be present in a single
patent
Types of Intellectual Property
9
Patents
A Standard Patent
• Subjected to examination for novelty, inventive step and other matters
• Maximum term (subject to possible extension for pharmaceutical substances) is 20 years from “the effective filing date”
• In addition to a written description, the specification must provide sufficient description to enable a person of skill in the art to practice the invention across the scope of the claims
Types of Intellectual Property
10
Patents
Innovation Patent
• Consists of an abstract, patent request and specification, similar to standard patents
• Specification has the same description requirements as a standard patent but can only contain a maximum of 5 claims; all can be independent
• The novelty test for an innovation patent is the same as for a standard patent, however, a lower “innovative step” test applies
• Maximum term is 8 years from the effective filling date
Types of Intellectual Property
11
Patents
Innovation Patent
Not as commonly used in Biotech Industry, because, unlike relatively simple mechanical inventions, biotechnology inventions
• are difficult to describe and• are inherently unpredictable and • can have up to 200 pages of specifications
Types of Intellectual Property
12
Patents
Patent Cooperation Treaty - PCT application
There is no such thing as an International Patent. A PCT application is a virtual application in every country that is a member of the Patent Cooperation Treaty. Each PCT application then turns into a national application in each country
It reserves a priority date for the invention to give the owner extra time to determine where the invention should be protected. The owner can do additional marketing and/or research to find out where they would have the most success in selling the product
Types of Intellectual Property
13
Patents
Patent Cooperation Treaty - PCT application
• PCT provides for an application in a signatory country to be filed as an international application
• Also provides for a preliminary non-binding examination
• A PCT application can progress as a national application in each designated country
• Signatories include most of Australia’s major trading partners
Types of Intellectual Property
14
Patents
Types of Intellectual Property
15 http://ipparalegals.com/media/blogs/experts-quill/what-is-a-pct/
Typical PCT process
Types of Intellectual Property
16 QUT-2004
Typical patent process and cost
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
ProvisionalApplication
PCTApplication
NationalPhase Entry
Examination Renewals
Months0 12 30
Patent granted
Cumulative cost
Defence>$1m
• An Australian patent registration only applies in Australia, it does not apply overseas
• It is common to file in each nation protection is required
• In order to gain a commercial advantage within the Biotech industry, there is a need to market in the U.S.
• There is a need to use the stringent U.S. standard for fully describing the invention
Types of Intellectual Property
17
Patents
In the U.S. there are three types of patent applications• Utility Patents• Design Patents • Plant Patents
In the U.S. the patent will be granted on an application filed by the first inventor of the claimed invention
Types of Intellectual Property
18
Patents- US Patent System
Utility Patent Protects the way in which an invention is made, how it is used or how it functions
- Expires 20 years from the effective filing date
Design Patent Protects new ornamental design for an article of manufacture
- Expires 14 years from the date of grant
Plant Patent Protects distinct and new plant varieties- Expires 20 years from the effective filing date
Types of Intellectual Property
19
Patents
• The biotech/pharmaceutical art is crowded
• Scientists may be aware of non-patent literature• A new generation of scientists is turning to the internet as a
vehicle to post raw experimental results. Such promiscuity with
research data undermines the very integrity of the scientific endeavour
• ‘Publish or perish’ vs. ‘publish and perish’
• Patent literature may be in advance of scientific publications
Types of Intellectual PropertyIdiosyncrasies of protecting biologics- Patents
20
• Examination is a different standard to peer review
• Without the rewards provided by the patent system, researchers and inventors would have little incentive to continue producing better and more efficient products for consumers
• Association of Molecular Pathology v Myriad Genetics (2013) • Naturally-occurring DNA is not patent eligible • cDNA is patent eligible because it is not naturally-occurring
• In Australia, business as usual? • APO continues to allow patent applicants to claim genetic
material• Genetic material must have been isolated
Types of Intellectual PropertyIdiosyncrasies of protecting biologics - Patents
21
• Gene Patent Eligibility Before Myriad (USPTO Utility Examination
Guidelines) – 2001
• An inventor’s discovery of a gene can be the basis for a patent on the genetic composition isolated from its natural state and
processed through purifying steps that separate the gene from
other molecules naturally associated with it• Patent Eligibility of DNA Fragments – Post Myriad decision (2013)
• Fragments of genomic DNA are ineligible
• Fragments of cDNA also found in genomic sequence are ineligible
• Fragments of cDNA not found in genomic sequence are eligible
Types of Intellectual PropertyIdiosyncrasies of protecting biologics - Myriad deci sion
22
Data protection as a biologic from date of regulatory approval
• 5 years Australia• 6 years China
• 10 years EU
• 12 years USA
Intellectual PropertyIdiosyncrasies of protecting biologics - Data protec tion
23
Types of Intellectual PropertyIdiosyncrasies of protecting biologics - Hatch-Waxma n Act extension (U.S.)
• Provides a patent term extension for patents covering human drug products that are subject to FDA approval effectively a credit for the time the FDA spent reviewing the first drug application• extension is for a maximum of five years or 14 years of effective
patent life, whichever is less• must be for a patent that claims either a:
– drug product, which means the active ingredient and any
– approved drug using that active ingredient
– method of using a drug product
– method of manufacturing a drug product24
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
25
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
A trade mark is a sign used, or intended to be used, to distinguish goods or services dealt with or provided in the course of trade by a person from goods or services so dealt with or provided by any other person
Types of Intellectual Property
26
Trade Marks
• A trade mark can be a phrase, word, letter, name, signature, numeric device, logo, colour, symbol, picture, aspect of packaging or shape, and even a scent or sound
• It can consist of words or images alone or any combination of the above signs
• A mark must not be ‘deceptively similar’ to a registered trade mark:• Trade mark infringement• Schedule 2 of the CCA 2010
• A good trade mark is more distinctive than descriptive, and is not defamatory, not a geographical name, not a common surname, not scandalous, not contrary to law
Types of Intellectual Property
27
Trade Marks
• Scope of Protection – Common law and Registration• Common law rights rely on reputation• Registration of a trade mark provides the right to
exclusively use, license, or sell goods and services under the mark
• 45 classes of goods and services with a fee payable per class – ask attorney for a fee schedule
• Broadly worded applications make render the registration vulnerable to attack for “non-use”
• No maximum term for which a trade mark can be registered but must be renewed every 10 years
Types of Intellectual Property
28
Trade Marks
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
29
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
• A domain name is an internet address that typically comprises a name followed by a domain. As an example, our domain name comprises our law firm’s name <nicholasweston> followed by the ‘.com’ generic Top Level Domain or gTLD suffix
• Many Australian businesses prefer to use the country code (ccTLD) Top-Level Domain ‘ .au’ so that they are more visible to Australia focussed searches
• First come, first served
Types of Intellectual Property
30
Domain Names
• A domain name may be eligible for registration as a trade mark
• Registration of a domain name typically grants the registrant an ‘exclusive right’ to use it rather than outright ownership
• System is administered by ICANN
Types of Intellectual Property
31
Domain Names
• WHOIS searches• Domain name registration agreements contain a term to
abide by ICANN’s Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy or UDRP and its procedural rules or the relevant ccTLD dispute policy
• In Australia, the relevant policy for a domain name with the suffix .au is called the .au Dispute Resolution Policy
Types of Intellectual Property
32
Domain Names
• UDRP/.auDRP• Domain name disputes can be resolved by administrative
cancellation or transfer of the disputed domain name by way of a lower cost means than litigation that start at $1,500.00 plus attorney fees
Types of Intellectual Property
33
Domain Names
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
34
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
• A design is a feature of shape, configuration, pattern or ornamentation of a product
• A design registration is used to protect the visual appearance of manufactured products
• The registration of a design provides that party with the right to exclusively use, license, or sell the design for up to a maximum of 15 years
Types of Intellectual Property
35
Designs
Types of Intellectual PropertyDesigns
• Aesthetical in nature
• Technical features not protected, still need a patent to protect the technology
36
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
37
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
• To be eligible for protection, a plant variety must adhere to three broad criteria• Distinctiveness• Uniformity• Stability
• Commercial novelty• the variety must not have been sold in Australia for
more than one year before the application
Types of Intellectual Property
38
Plant Breeder’s Rights
• Plant Breeder’s Rights provide commercial rights for 20-25 years to market a new variety or its reproductive material
• Selection from nature or discoveries naturally occurring are not eligible
• The variety must not have been sold in Australia more than one year before the application
• Must not have been sold overseas for more than 6 years before the application
Types of Intellectual Property
39
Plant Breeder’s Rights
• Plant-made pharmaceuticals – growing medicines in plants
• Modifying algae to produce biofuels, or grow on salt lakes- reduction of environmental footprint and minimises pollution (climate change)
• Increasing farming efficiency through high yield crops
• Reducing natural toxins in plants
Types of Intellectual Property
40
Plant Breeder’s Rights - examples
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
41
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
• No system of Copyright registration in Australia
• Many different types of Copyright protection• Literary works• Artistic works• Dramatic works• Musical works• Cinematography films• Sound recordings and• Broadcasts• Performance rights
Types of Intellectual Property
42
Copyright
Protects: • textual material (“literary works”) such as journal articles,
novels, screenplays, poems, song lyrics, laboratory workbooks and reports
• computer programs (a sub-category of “literary works”)• compilations (another sub-category of “literary works”)
such as anthologies – the selection and arrangement of material may be protected separately from the individual items contained in the compilation
Types of Intellectual Property
43
Copyright
Protects: • artistic works such as paintings, drawings, cartoons,
sculpture, craft work, architectural plans, buildings, photographs, maps and plans
• dramatic works such as choreography, screenplays, plays and mime pieces
• musical works: that is, the music itself, separately from any lyrics or recording;
• cinematograph films: the visual images and sounds in a film, video or DVD are protected separately from any copyright in works recorded on the film or video, such as scripts and music
Types of Intellectual Property
44
Copyright
Protects: • sound recordings: the particular recording itself is
protected by copyright, in addition to, for example, the music or story that is recorded
• broadcasts: TV and radio broadcasters have a copyright in their broadcasts, which is separate from the copyright in the films, music and other material which they broadcast
• performances: a performer’s consent is generally required to film or record a performance and to broadcast or otherwise communicate a performance
Types of Intellectual Property
45
Copyright
• Expression vs. idea• Expression protected – not ideas• Your independent creation as you expressed it
• Copyright protection is free and automatic
Types of Intellectual Property
46
Copyright
• Types of intellectual property• What is intellectual property?• Patents• Trade Marks• Domain Names• Designs• Plant Breeder’s Rights• Copyright• Trade Secrets
• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
47
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
• Confidential information or ‘trade secrets’ includes information such as a formula, pattern, compilation, program, data, device, method, technique, or process, that• derives independent economic value, actual or
potential, from not being generally known to, and not being readily ascertainable by proper means, by other persons who can obtain economic value from its disclosure or use, and
• is the subject of efforts that are reasonable under the circumstances to maintain its secrecy
Types of Intellectual Property
48
Trade Secrets
• Common law protection of confidential information
• Confidential/proprietary information• that has commercial value to the owner because the
information is not generally available to public, and• owner takes reasonable measures to keep information
secret
• No formal filing needed
• Trade secrets may include inventions not yet patented or portions of a work that are not fully protected by copyright
Intellectual Property
49
Trade Secrets
• Essentially 2 types of trade secret categories:• Inventions or manufacturing processes that do not meet
the patentability criteria and therefore can only be protected as trade secrets. • customers lists or manufacturing processes that are
not sufficiently inventive to be granted a patent
• Inventions and manufacturing processes that would fulfil the patentability criteria and could therefore be protected by patents• SME will face a choice to patent the invention or to
protect it under NDAs or CAs
Types of Intellectual Property
50
Trade Secrets – examples:
Patents Trade Secrets
Protects against independent discoveryNo protection against independent discovery or reverse engineering
20 years of protection Protection lasts as long as secret
Scope for publication of development No opportunity for publication
Enforcement: infringementEnforcement: breach of confidence, breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty
Protection can be broadened beyond specific discovery/development
Protection specific to particular secret
Types of Intellectual Property
51
Patents v. Trade Secrets
• Types of intellectual property• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
52
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
• There are accepted rules of thumb and forms of analysis to arrive at royalty rates
• An annual royalty can be tied to sales, gross profits or a licensee friendly nett revenue basis. One can fix it, cap it (annually or over the term), index it, tie it to a ‘most favoured nation’ type arrangement, or a combination of these and other techniques
• A ‘stacking’ term might be the go to cap a royalty or divide a fixed fee if a licensee is at the early stages of commercialising IP and full commercialisation will require other third party licenses and the number or amount of those third party royalties is unknown
The levers driving economic value of IPLicensing and royalty rates
53
• Rates tend to reflect profit margins, ‘runway’ or duration of the profit, as well as risk and is informed by industry norms, exclusivity, non-monetary factors (such as grant backs or off-take agreements) and RoI analysis.
• In turn, royalty rate is invariably a function of the value of the IP assets
The levers driving economic value of IPLicensing and royalty rates
54
• Registered rights are easy to identify• Intangible rights such as know how (which can include the
talents, skill and knowledge of the workforce), training systems and methods, designs, technical processes, customer lists, distribution networks, and so on are equally valuable assets but the earnings and profits they generate can be devilishly tricky for accountants to identify and allocate
The levers driving economic value of IPValuing IP rights
55
• Intangibles are not generally depreciating or CGT assets
• Treated as income from the supply of a service
• Valuation of intangibles means on disposal money received as capital rather than income
The levers driving economic value of IPValuing IP rights
56
• Cost method
• Market value method
• DCF/NPV models
The levers driving economic value of IPValuing IP rights
57
• CGT – cost base = costs incurred in developing or acquiring the IP
• Tax deductions require a clear link between the expenditure related to the IP and producing assessable income
• The cost of developing IP assets such as trade secrets, know-how and confidential information are usually in the form of salaries and wages, which are usually tax deductible
The levers driving economic value of IPTax implications and benefits
58
• Types of intellectual property• The levers driving economic value of IP• Aligning IP with your role and business strategy
59
IP for Accountants - OverviewIntellectual Property
• Most inventions involve small incremental improvements to existing technology
• A successful R&D operation will be directed towards commercial outcomes
• Commercial considerations and IP are the complementary driving forces behind any R&D strategy
IP for AccountantsAligning IP and your role with business strategy
60
IP for Accountants
61
Product
Methods, Processes, or Techniques
Flow Chart, SourceCodes
Name / Graphics / Logos
Algorithms
Business Plan
Marketing / Product Launch Time Table
Designs, Drawings, etc.
Trade Secret
Trade Secret
Patent
Copyright
Patent
Trade Secret
TradeSecret
Trade SecretTrademark
Copyright
Copyright
Copyright
Trade Secret
Copyright
Copyright
PatentSource: Boeing 2011
Aligning IP and your role with business strategy
• If the principal aim is to maximise profit margins, then the strategy must involve the protection of the products, processes or services which are identified as being most relevant to those margins
• If the goal is to penetrate new markets, then the policy may involve generating new IP, and managing how that product is marketed, produced and protected
• Or the intention may be to realise cash rewards for a significant R&D investment, which can be achieved by licensing
IP for AccountantsAligning IP and your role with business strategy
62
R&D Tax Incentive
• 43.5% refundable tax offset where aggregated annual turnover (AAT) $ < 20M
• 38.5% where AAT > $20M but < $ 20B• Overseas R&D spend needs to be less than half local R&D
spend but can get advance finding• Core and supporting activities• Apply within 10 months end FY• Guidance products
IP for AccountantsAligning IP and your role with business strategy
63
• Stamp duty (jurisdiction shopping)
• PPSA (check for security interests)
• FOI (dig deeper)
IP for AccountantsAligning IP and your role with business strategy
64
• Oppositions• Appeals• Injunctions• Adverse Examinations, Tribunal, AAT (including adverse IP
Australia findings, or ITAA and R&D Tax Incentive assessments), Federal Circuit Court; Federal Court of Australia, High Court
IP for AccountantsAligning IP and your role with business strategy
65
• Know what IP is and take steps to manage it
• Triage, prioritise, plan for discord
• Monetising IP, calculating royalties and drafting licence agreements is more science than art
• Get professional help
IP for AccountantsAligning IP and your role with business strategy
66
Nick WestonT: +61 3 8616 [email protected]
White Paper IP for Accountants available for download on the www.nicholasweston.com website
IP for Accountants
67
THANK YOU