Top Banner
Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR
44

Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

May 21, 2018

Download

Documents

doanxuyen
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Intro to Dams in WI

Bill Sturtevant, P.E.State Dam Safety Engineer

Wisconsin DNR

Page 2: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Topics to be Covered Definitions Regulations Terminology Owner Responsibility Dam Safety and Floodplain Management –

Design and the Dam Failure Analysis Hazard Ratings Historic Failures

Page 3: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

A Dam Is….

…Any artificial barrier, together with appurtenant works, built in or across a watercourse for the primary purpose of impounding

or diverting water.

Page 4: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

A Watercourse Is…

A running stream of water; a natural stream fed from permanent or natural sources, including rivers, creeks, runs and rivulets. There must be a stream, usually flowing in a particular direction, though it need not flow continuously. It may sometimes be dry. It must flow in a definite channel, having a bed or banks, and usually discharges itself into some other stream or body of water. It must be something more than a mere surface drainage over the entire face of the tract of land, occasioned by unusual freshets or other extraordinary causes.

(Hoyt v. City of Hudson)

Page 5: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Wisconsin has over

3700 dams

Page 6: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Reasons to RegulateAuthority in Chapter 31, State Statutes

Protection of public rights in navigable water - Public Trust Doctrine

Protection of life, health and properrty from unsafe dams.

Page 7: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Statutes – Codes - Guidance Chapter 31, State Statutes NR 300 – Fees NR 330 – Signing NR 333 – Design Standards, Large Dams NR 116 - Floodplain Management Program

(116.08) NR 335 – Municipal Grant Program NR 353 – Wetland Restoration Projects NR 336 – Small Dam Removal/Abd. Dam Grants NR 331 – Fish Passage

Page 8: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Dam Regulation Permitting new dams Dam transfers Levels and flows Plan approval for repair/reconstruction/removal Approve EAP and IOM documents Process

abandonment permits Safety Inspections Emergency response

Page 9: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Classification

Waterway Type - Public Trust Navigable vs Nonnavigable

Size - Public Safety Large vs Small

Page 10: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Large Dam

Structural Height > 6 feet …and…

Maximum Storage >= 50 acre feet

or

Structural Height > =25 feet …and…

Maximum Storage >15 acre feet

orAny dam that causes a significant threat to life or property

HS

Page 11: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Basic Dam Terminology

Definition of a dam Spillway types

Primary / Principle Uncontrolled / Fixed Crest Gated Auxiliary / Secondary /Emergency

Other Common Dam TermsGate TypesHydroelectric Generation

Page 12: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Types Of Dams

Embankment Earth fill Overtop Protected

GravityButtressArchMasonry Timber Crib

Page 13: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Earth Fill Dam

www.damsafety.org 3-13

Page 14: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Concrete Gravity Dam

www.damsafety.org 3-14

Page 15: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Concrete Buttress

www.damsafety.org 3-15

Page 16: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Masonry Buttress Dam

Page 17: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Concrete Arch

Page 18: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Timber Arch Dam

www.damsafety.org 3-18

Page 19: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Timber Crib

Page 20: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

2-20www.damsafety.org

Parts of an Embankment Dam

Groin

Toe Drain

Outlet Left Abutment

Secondary (Auxiliary) Spillway

Primary Spillway

(Inlet Riser)

Reservoir

Upstream SlopeCrest

Downstream Slope

RightAbutment

Outlet Conduit

Page 21: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

www.damsafety.org

Cross Section Terminology

2-21

Page 22: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Freeboard Storage

Secondary Spillway Storage

Primary Spillway (Flood) Storage

Beneficial StorageRecreationWater SupplyIrrigationFlow Augmentation

Sediment Storage

Permanent Storage

TemporaryStorage

Storage Terminology

Page 23: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Spillways Types

2-23www.damsafety.org

Primary (Principle) SpillwayUncontrolled or Fixed Crest

Page 24: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Whistle Tube Spillway

2-24www.damsafety.org

Page 25: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Ogee Spillway

2-25www.damsafety.org

Page 26: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Labyrinth Spillway

Page 27: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Gated Spillway

2-27www.damsafety.org

Page 28: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Auxiliary (Emergency) Spillway

Page 29: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry
Page 30: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry
Page 31: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry
Page 32: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry
Page 33: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Owner Responsibility

Operate and Maintain in Safe Manner Perform Periodic Inspections 31.19 Prepare and Implement EAP/IOM PlansObtain Appropriate Permits/ApprovalsCoordinate Operation with Others Keep Informed About Regulations

Page 34: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Dam Design

Watershed hydrology and hydraulics Soils investigationConsideration of desired functions of

impoundmentHazard assessmentDesign capacity requirements Structural design of key components Stability analysis

Page 35: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry
Page 36: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Dam Failure Anaylsis

Used for three purposes

Identify the innundation area and determine the hazard potential

Determine the design capacity requirements

Incorporate into the Emergency Action Plan

Data intensive analysis done by engineering consultant

Page 37: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Dam Hazard Rating

Hazard potential classifications are: High hazard – probable loss of life

Significant hazard – significant property damage but no loss of life

Low hazard – no loss of life or significant property damage

Base hazard rating on existing development and land use controls, not condition of the dam

Page 38: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Historic Dam Failures

- National Weather Service

Page 39: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

JohnstownPennsylvaniaMay 31, 1889

Failure of the South Fork Dam caused an estimated $17 million

in damages.

Fatalities: 2,209

- National Weather Service

Page 40: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Baldwin HillsCalifornia - December 14, 1963

Damages: > $21 millionFatalities: 5

- Richard Levine

Page 41: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Canyon LakeSouth Dakota - June 9, 1972

Damages: > $60 millionFatalities: 237

- National Weather Service

Page 42: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

TetonIdaho - June 5, 1976

Damages: Unprecedented ($400M-$2B)Fatalities: 11

- U.S. Bureau of Reclamation

Page 43: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Toccoa FallsGeorgia - November 5, 1977

Damages: $2.5 millionFatalities: 39

- National Weather Service

Page 44: Intro to Dams in WI - University of Wisconsin · Intro to Dams in WI Bill Sturtevant, P.E. State Dam Safety Engineer Wisconsin DNR. Topics to be Covered ... Buttress Arch Masonry

Remember...…Be Dam Safe