International tobacco companies David Simpson Director, International Agency on Tobacco and Health Visiting Professor, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine Honorary Fellow, Clinical Trial Service Unit, Oxford Editor, News Analysis, Tobacco Control journal
45
Embed
International tobacco companies David Simpson Director, International Agency on Tobacco and Health Visiting Professor, London School of Hygiene & Tropical.
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
International tobacco companies
David Simpson
Director, International Agency on Tobacco and Health
Visiting Professor, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Honorary Fellow, Clinical Trial Service Unit, Oxford
Editor, News Analysis, Tobacco Control journal
World’s smokers
1.2
1.64
0123456789
billions
1999 2025
SmokersPopulation
From the US Bureau of the Census and World Bank, Curbing the epidemic: Governments and the economics of tobacco control, 1999.
Imperial (UK), incl. Reemtsma (Germany) ; ITC India (part-BAT);
Monopolies, e.g. Tekel (Turkey), Sampoerna (Indonesia), etc
A brief tobacco industry history of the tobacco epidemic
1940s +50s
1960s + 70s
1980s
1990s
2000-2003
- scientific evidence forces health-related scientific research
- development of government health policy; - industry scientists lose power to marketing executives
- expand international activities; - use toxic reduction health policy as hostage to preserve advertising
- litigation increases; - Minnesota case releases millions of papers; - health advocacy increases
- ‘We’ve changed!’ programmes, e.g. BAT’s ‘Social reports’; - FCTC process puts tobacco on health agenda worldwide; - continue to expand markets as fast as possible
Two unique aspects of the tobacco industry:
The product: highly addictive
very dangerous, at any level of consumption; largest cause of disease, disability & premature death
The people: self-selected group, not concerned by scientific evidence of diseases caused by tobacco
One simple truth about the tobacco industry:
The companies will always fight every effective health policy measure
Senegal
Cape Times, South Africa, Oct 1993
Trinidad, 1998
Uganda, Tanzania & Kenya, Dec 2001
- “We don’t want kids to smoke”
- global ad code (self-regulation…)
- “Let us back into the scientific community”
- community aid programmes
Tobacco industry ‘We’ve changed’ strategy:
Tobacco industry ‘We’ve changed’ strategy:
“We don’t want kids to smoke”
Industry ‘Youth Prevention’ programmes:
- public relations strategy: improve image
- ‘proactive’ - industry avoids ad bans
- programme says little on dangers of tobacco
- programmes shown to be ineffective*
- “adult activity” - may encourage kids to smoke *
* DiFranza J & McAfee T. The Tobacco Institute: Helping youth to say ‘yes’ to tobacco.• J Fam Prac 1992,34(6)
“The youth program... support[s] the [Tobacco] Institute’s objective of discouraging unfair... federal, state and local restrictions on cigarette advertising,
by...”
US Tob. Inst. 1/1991
• “Reinforcing the belief that peer pressure - not advertising - is the cause of youth smoking.
US Tob. Inst. 1/1991
• “Reinforcing the belief that peer pressure - not advertising - is the cause of youth smoking.
• “Seizing the political center and forcing the antismokers to an extreme…”
US Tob. Inst. 1/1991
“The strategy is fairly simple:
“1. Heavily promote industry opposition to youth smoking.”
US Tob. Inst. 1/1991
“The strategy is fairly simple:
“1. Heavily promote industry opposition to youth smoking.
“2. Align industry with broader, more sophisticated view of the problem - that is, parental inability to offset peer pressure.”
US Tob. Inst. 1/1991
“The strategy is fairly simple:
“1. Heavily promote industry opposition to youth smoking.
“2. Align industry with broader, more sophisticated view of the problem - that is, parental inability to offset peer pressure.”
“3. Work with and through credible child welfare professionals and educators to tackle the ‘problem’.”
US Tob. Inst. 1/1991
“The strategy is fairly simple:
“1. Heavily promote industry opposition to youth smoking.
“2. Align industry with broader, more sophisticated view of the problem - that is, parental inability to offset peer pressure.”
“3. Work with and through credible child welfare professionals and educators to tackle the ‘problem’.”
“4. Bait anti-tobacco forces to criticise industry efforts.”
US Tob. Inst. 1/1991
Industry youth programmes:
Uzbekistan
Industry youth programmes:
Middle East
Tobacco industry ‘We’ve changed’ strategy:
‘global advertising code’ (self-regulation)
“We have analyzed the 9-page agreement and believe that the multinationals' strategy is proactive and is a way to improve their image.”
- Herzog B, Credit Suisse , investors’ briefing.
Oct ‘01
Tobacco industry global advertising code
- a Wall Street analyst’s view:
Tobacco industry ‘We’ve changed’ strategy:
“Let us back into science”
- make health policy dependent on tobacco
- split the scientific community
- tie up research resources on non-tobacco topics
- corporate ‘blackmail’ against legislation
‘Tobacco industry ‘We’ve changed’ strategy:“Let us back into science”
“We all decided not to accept the tobacco company [money] in the end & now trying to find alternate source of funding …
“Some time I feel isolated in Pakistan when I give my strong feelings against the tobacco..”