1 Kew Gardens Interchange Infrastructure and Operational Improvement Project Grand Central Parkway PIN X051.60, Contract No. D900043 Draft Request for Proposals (RFP) Informational Meeting March 8, 2018
1
Kew Gardens Interchange
Infrastructure and Operational Improvement Project
Grand Central Parkway
PIN X051.60, Contract No. D900043
Draft Request for Proposals (RFP)
Informational Meeting March 8, 2018
2
Presentation Staff Eric Celia, PMO & DB Program Director
Norm Schips, PMO Project Manager
Mike Liona, Hardesty & Hanover
Preliminary Design consultant
Olga Kleyman, R11 Project Manager
Kathryn Conlon
WSP Procurement Support Consultant
3
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
Department’s Designated Representative for this
Procurement is:
Donelle Mastropietro
Attn: Kew Gardens Interchange
Contract Management Bureau
New York State Department of Transportation
50 Wolf Road, 6th Floor
Albany, New York 12232, USA
email: [email protected]
4
Project Overview & Need
Project Goals & Scope of Work (Part 3)
RFP Content
WZTC (Part 3)
Status of ROW (Part 3, Section 6) and Utilities (Part 4)
General Contract Information (ITP)
Alternative Technical Concepts (ITP)
Procurement Schedule (ITP)
One-on-One Meetings (ITP)
RFP Content & Submission Requirements
Quality Control & Quality Assurance (Part 2)
Evaluation and Selection
Additional Information and Submission Guidelines
Questions and Answers
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
Agenda
5
Project Overview and Need
Mike Liona
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
8
Major deficiencies include: Ramp entrances controlled by stop signs
Insufficient storage lengths
Ramps with poor/non-standard stopping sight distance
Roadways with inadequate merge and weave conditions
Ramps with sharp curvature resulting in low travel speed congestion
Steep Roadway downgrade conditions
Roadway Geometry does not meet current standards
Structural Deficiencies – Spalling and Delamination on concrete decks
Congestion and Higher than average accident rates
Safety concerns with Pedestrian Accommodations
Inadequate closed drainage system for storm events
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)Project Need
10
Project Goals / General Scope of Work (Part 3)
Realign and widen the mainline GCP, JRP and UTP to address
alignment deficiencies
Reconstruct the ramps connecting the GCP, UTP, JRP and
VWE
Eliminate Three Existing Stop Conditions
Address drainage deficiencies
Address existing Non-Standard travel lane widths, shoulder
widths and SSD
Includes six bridge replacements
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
11
Project Goals / General Scope of Work (Part 3)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
Provide ADA compliant facilities for Pedestrians
Maintain/replace existing Utilities
Remove & Replace ITS
Lighting and Signage
Construct cut and fill type Earth Retaining Walls
Provide accel/decal lanes at merge or diverge locations
Traffic Signal Work
12
Multi-level Interchange – complex interconnectivity
View looking North along GCP Connector Ramps
SB VWE
SB VWE to WB JRP
WB GCPConnector
WB GCPConnector
SB VWE
View looking East along WB GCP Connector Ramp
EB UTP Bridge to
remain
EB GCP ML over WB
GCP Connector
NB VWE
JRP over GCP
13
Preliminary Design Focus
Eliminate 3 existing stop conditions
EB GCP to WB JRP exit to be off of EB GCP mainline
Layout of substructures to not preclude future 3-lane GCP mainlines & 3 lane GCP connectors
14
Drainage Considerations
East Side tie-in to DEP system via 66” CSO
West Side tie-in to DEC outfall #1 - downstream analysis
Existing 66” CSO running
to north
Existing Outfall #1
15
Additional items of note
Reference docs and monitoring data on groundwater – west end of
site has high GW table
NYSDEC Preliminary downstream analysis – ref doc
Preliminary pump station analysis for west end overtopping
mitigation (Indicative plan)
Preliminary analysis of local low point drainage mitigation on GCP
connector ramp (Indicative plan)
WZTC stages are to maintain all existing number of travel lanes
during construction
Current Contract 2B contractor currently on west end of site
22
Stop Condition #1 Eliminated
Existing EB
GCP to WB JRP
Proposed EB
GCP to WB JRP
Existing Stop Condition –
EB GCP to WB JRP
24
Stop Condition 1 - Existing View, Looking East
Existing Stop Condition –
EB GCP to WB JRP
Existing EB GCP to WB JRP
Existing SB VWE
to WB JRP
25
Stop Condition 1 - Proposed View, Looking East
Stop Condition
Eliminated
Proposed 2-Lanes EB
JRP to EB GCP
EB GCP
Proposed 1-lane
from SB VWE to
WB JRP
Proposed WB GCP
to WB JRP
Proposed EB JRP to
UTP Merge
26
Stop Condition #2 Eliminated
Existing EB JRP
to WB GCP
Proposed EB JRP
to WB GCP
Existing Stop
Condition – EB
JRP to WB GCP
28
Stop Condition 2 - Existing View, Looking West
Existing Stop Condition –
EB JRP to WB GCPWB Union Tpke. Bridge
Existing WB
GCP
Connector
Ramp
From EB JRP
to WB GCP
29
Stop Condition 2 - Proposed View, Looking West
Stop Condition
Eliminated
Proposed WB GCP connectors
From EB JRP to
WB GCP
30
Stop Condition #3 Eliminated
Existing WB UTP
to WB GCP
Proposed WB
UTP to WB GCP
Existing Stop Condition
– WB UTP to WB GCP
32
Stop Condition 3 - Existing View, Looking East
Existing Stop Condition –
WB UTP to WB GCP
Existing WB GCP connectors
Existing WB
GCP
Mainline
EB GCP
33
Stop Condition 3 - Proposed View, Looking East
Stop Condition
Eliminated
Proposed WB GCP connectors
Proposed
WB GCP
Mainline
Converted to Pedestrian Access
to WB UTP Sidewalk to QBlvd
EB GCP
34
RFP Documents:
Instructions to Proposers
Part 1: D-B Agreement
Part 2: General Provisions, Section DB 100 and Appendices
Part 3: Project Requirements (Scope of Work)
Part 4: Utility Requirements
Part 5: Special Provisions
Part 6: RFP Plans (Directive and Indicative)
Part 7: Engineering Data
Part 8: Special Specifications (Including New DB Specifications)
Part 9: The Design-Builder’s Proposal
Part 10: RFP Addenda (If Any)
Reference Documents: On Department’s website (Not Part of the Contract
Documents)
Request For Proposals (RFP) Documents
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
35
Kew Gardens Interchange Contract 2B (D263208) VWE Mainline Viaduct Replacement between Hoover Ave and 72nd Ave Substantial completion December 2019
Rehab of the Van Wyck Expressway (VWE) Viaduct – Contract 1 Reconstruction of LIE/VWE Interchange Start of Construction December 2019
Rehab of Jewel Ave over VWE Bridges & Retaining wall Repair Construction through 2019
Jackie Robinson Pkwy Installation of Intelligent Transportation System TBD
Rehabilitation of 3 Bridges in LIE/Grand Central Pkwy Interchange TBD
Project Coordination – Part 3, Section 1.4
36
NYCDOT Office of Construction Mitigation and Coordination (AKA.
OCMC Permit)
NYC DOT Department of Street Lighting
NYC Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP)
NYC DOT Traffic and Signals
NYC DOT Highway Division for Local Streets
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
Agency Coordination
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
37
Right-of-Way (Part 3, Section 6)
All permanent work shall be within the existing Highway owned
ROW
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
38
Project Requirements (Part 3)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
Section 16: Pavement PCC
ATCs for Alternate Pavement Types will not be Approved
Section 18: Highway Design
18.3.2 - Design Requirements – “Additional Design
Requirements for the Proposed Roadway Geometry”
18.4 - Design Exceptions and Non-Standard features
39
Design Builder shall implement Work Zone Traffic Control and
Closures Restrictions in accordance with Section 15 of Part 3, Work
Zone Traffic Control Notes provided in Part 6 – Directive Plans, and
NYCDOT OCMC Stipulations included in Part 7 – Engineering Data.
Any changes to the OCMC permit must be performed in coordination
with NYSDOT, MTA/Short Range Bus Service, and NYCDOT
Traffic enforcement agents shall be provided, associated with the
anticipated detour route, in accordance with Special Spec Item
619.22970011
Work Zone Traffic Control (Part 3, Section 15)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
41
15.3.5 – Closure Restrictions
All Lanes must remain open at all times.
Pedestrian Traffic must be maintained at all times at all locations where
pedestrian access through the Project area currently exists
Lane Rental Item has been included in this contract
Item 800.06090115 – Fixed Price Lump Sum – See Part 8 for Item Specification
Work Zone Traffic Control (Part 3)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
42
SCD Forms
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
OVERALL PROJECT COMPLETION (See Note 1)
ACTIVITY
Design-Builder’s
Latest Milestone Completion
Date from SCD Table 2b
(See Note 7)
PROJECTED
COMPLETION DATE
(MM/DD/YYYY)
(See Note 7)
LIQUIDATED DAMAGES
AMOUNT (PER DAY)
(See Note 3)
PROJECT COMPLETION$ 25,000
Table SCD - 1
43
SCD Forms
Kew Gardens Interchange
Table SCD – 2a – Phase 1, East Area
PHASE 1, INTERIM COMPLETION NO. 1 (See Note 2a & 3)
ITEM
TRAFFIC MOVEMENT FEATURE
MANDATORY
COMPLETION
DATE
LIQUIDATED DAMAGES
AMOUNT (PER DAY)
(See Note 2a &3)
1*MAINLINE EB GCP (FROM EXISTING BIN 1-05575-B TO EAST END OF PROJECT LIMITS)
December 31,
2019$50,000
2*MAINLINE WB GCP (FROM EXISTING BIN 1-05575-B TO EAST END OF PROJECT
LIMITS)
3 MAINLINE EB UTP OVER GCP
4 EB GCP TO EB UTP
5 EB UTP to EB GCP
6 EB UTP to WB UTP
7* EB JRP to WB GCP (FROM EXISTING BIN 1-05575-B TO EAST END OF PROJECT LIMITS)
8* EB GCP to WB JRP (FROM EXISTING BIN 1-05575-B TO EAST END OF PROJECT LIMITS)
9 WB GCP to WB UTP
*The Segment of the completed roadways and bridges may not be fully opened to traffic at the Phase 1 milestone completion date. However
they shall be completed in conformance with the permanent alignment geometry as shown on the Design Builder’s approved design plans.
Table SCD-2a represents the Phase 1 East project area mandatory interim milestone completion date requirement for the specific project
traffic movement features. All features included in this interim milestone shall be completed on or before the mandatory completion date.
The Design-Builder will coordinate & schedule all work with the Department’s contractor for contract D263208.
46
SCD Forms
Kew Gardens Interchange
Table SCD-2b represents the Phase 2 West project area interim milestone completion dates required for the itemized specific project traffic
movement features. All features included in this interim milestone shall be completed on or before the project completion dates provided by the
Design-Builder. The Design-Builder is informed that the Completion Date for Contract D263208 is December 31, 2019. For this reason, the Design-
Builder is informed that the Phase 2, West project area is not available to commence with physical construction until January 1, 2020 for the
purpose of computing and tendering the Design-Builders proposal. Subsequent to award the west area may become available for physical
construction prior to January 1, 2020 as limited by written approval by the contractor for D263208 and the Department’s Project Manager.
Table SCD – 2b – Phase 2, West Area
PHASE 2, INTERIM COMPLETION NO. 2 (See Note 2b & 3)
TRAFFIC MOVEMENT
FEATURE
DURATION
(Calendar Days past available
date of West End staging area)
(See Note 4, 5, 6)
MILESTONE
COMPLETION DATE
(MM/DD/YYYY)
(See Note 4, 5, 6)
LIQUIDATED DAMAGES
AMOUNT (PER DAY)
(See Note 3)
INCENTIVE PAYMENT
FOR EARLY COMPLETION
AMOUNT (PER DAY)
(See Note 5)
MAINLINE WB GCP (REMAINING
LENGTH)$11,000 $11,000
MAINLINE EB GCP (REMAINING
LENGTH)$12,000 $12,000
MAINLINE WB UTP OVER GCP $11,000 $11,000
WB GCP TO WB JRP $9,000 $9,000
EB JRP TO EB GCP $39,000 $39,000
SB VWE TO WB UTP $12,000 n/a
47
SCD Forms
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
SB VWE TO QUEENS BLVD $12,000 n/a
EB JRP TO NB VWE $39,000 n/a
EB JRP to WB GCP (REMAINING
LENGTH)$39,000 $39,000
EB GCP to WB JRP (REMAINING
LENGTH)$39,000 n/a
WB UTP TO WB GCP $11,000 n/a
SB VWE TO WB JRP $12,000 n/a
WB UTP TO QUEENS BLVD $11,000 n/a
EB GCP TO SB VWE $12,000 $12,000
NB VWE TO WB GCP $15,000 $15,000
REMAINING PAVEMENT RESURFACING
WORKn/a n/a
LANDSCAPE NOVEMBER 1ST, 2021 $1,000 n/a
OVERALL LATEST MILESTONE
COMPLETION DATE FROM ALL ITEMS
IN TABLE 2B
(see notes 6 & 7)
N/A N/A N/A
PHASE 2, INTERIM COMPLETION NO. 2 (See Note 2b & 3)
TRAFFIC MOVEMENT
FEATURE
DURATION
(Calendar Days past available
date of West End staging area)
(See Note 4, 5, 6)
MILESTONE COMPLETION
DATE (MM/DD/YYYY)
(See Note 4, 5, 6)
LIQUIDATED DAMAGES
AMOUNT (PER DAY)
(See Note 3)
INCENTIVE PAYMENT
FOR EARLY COMPLETION
AMOUNT (PER DAY)
(See Note 5)
48
SCD Forms
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
Detour Assessment Table SCD – 3
IMPACTS TO TRAFFIC (ROADWAYS CARRIED)
PROJECT COMPONENT
(Carried/Crossed)
TRAFFIC IMPACT DURATION
DETOUR ANTICIPATED (CALENDAR
DAYS)
(see Note 9,10 and 12)
LIQUIDATED
DAMAGES
AMOUNT (PER
DAY)
(See Notes 8 & 11)
EB GCP to WB JRP (Ramp D)Max Allowed 40 days $39,000
49
SCD Forms - Notes
Table SCD-1:
Project completion date will be computed from latest date in Table
SCD-2b plus 90 calendar days
Table SCD-2a:
Project East End, Phase 1: Mandatory work listed completed on or
before 12-31-19 or pay LD as noted
Table SCD-2b:
Project West End, Phase 2: Populate the Duration and Milestone
Date
LD’s apply if late
Incentive payment for early as noted in Table
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
51
Utility Coordination – Existing Utilities (Part 4)
In accordance with Part 4 – Utility Requirements, the Design-Builder is
responsible for:
Verifying utility facility locations
Identifying and resolving any conflicts not yet documented
Coordinating with utility owners for utility relocations
Providing stakeout and final layout of utility relocations
Protecting existing utilities
Cost to repair damages to utilities caused by the Design-Builder
Informing the Department of all meetings and correspondence with
utility owners
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
53
Quality Control and Construction Inspection Requirements
Part 5
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
54
Directive Plans (Part 6)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
Architectural Wall Treatment Details
Ornamental Steel Picket Fence Details
Precast Deck Panel Details
WZTC Notes
Landscape Protection & Restoration Notes
Landscape Protection & Restoration Details
55
Indicative Plans (Part 6)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
Underdeck Lighting Mounting Details
Drainage Downspout & Splash Block Details
Existing 36” NYCDEP Watermain Removal Plan
Utility Conflicts Map
Regulator Replacement Detail
Access to Existing 66” NYCDEP Drainage Chamber
Pump Location Plan-Flood Mitigation Location 1
56
Indicative Plans (Continued) (Part 6)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
NB Connector Drainage Plan 1
Flood Mitigation Location 2
Shared Use Path Plans (1, 2 and 3)
Shared Use Path Profile
Shared Use Path Typical Sections
Conceptual Landscape Development Plan
Plant List
Existing Lighting Control Cabinet & Service Point Locations 1
through 7
57
Project Details - Summary
3-level interchange and interconnectivity of ramps/staging
implications
Goals of eliminating 3 existing stop conditions via use of
added acceleration lanes and improved geometry
Engineering data for design criteria tables
EB GCP to WB JRP exit to be off of EB GCP mainline instead
of GCP connector (as currently exists)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
58
Layout of substructures and alignments
Not to preclude future 3-lane GCP mainlines and future 3 lane GCP
connectors
Drainage - DEP system east side
DEC outfall #1 west side w/ downstream analysis
Reference docs on groundwater table, downstream analysis
Pump station possibility
Local low drainage on DCP connector
Project Details - Summary
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
59
Project Details - Summary
WZTC to maintain existing # of travel lanes during
construction
Current Contract D263208 contractor on-site
Project end limits
West end: MTA rail bridge low clearance, tie-ins to existing narrow
roadway
East end: GCP Cut section within existing Retaining walls
NYCDSL - Signals at WB UTP and 141st and WB UTP and
Vleigh place intersections
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
60
Changes from Draft to Final RFP
Bridge Scope
Change to “may” be expected to construct 5 new bridges
Quality Manager
Clarification of expectations
Refer to ITP Section 1.14 and Part 2, Appendix 113A
Duties and Responsibilities
Reporting – Monthly Report with status of all issues
Status of all QC Records, CI, SM Utilization
All issues, including NCRs and process improvement
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
61
General Contract Information
&
Instructions to Proposers (ITP)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
62
Lump Sum Design-Build Contract
Best Value Selection Process (50% Price, 50% Quality)
Project Completion Date shall be the earlier of:
March 1, 2022; or
The number of days past NTP proposed by the successful
Proposer on Form SCD (ITP Appendix E)
Escrow Submission of Bid Documents for Successful Proposer
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
63
The Department has undertaken a due diligence study to
determine whether there will be a public benefit to
implementation of a Project Labor Agreement (PLA) for
the Project.
Any PLA will be issued to the Proposers and included in
the RFP.
Any provision in the RFP inconsistent with the provisions
of an approved PLA shall be superseded by the PLA to
the greatest extent permitted by federal or state law
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
64
Liquidated Damages will be assessed for:
Failure to achieve project completion
As noted in Form SCD
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
65
There is a Schedule of Prices and a Work Payment Schedule provided in the
RFP.
Schedule of Prices (Form SP)
Construction Work
Design Services
Construction Inspection Services
Quality Control Services (Material Testing)
Utility Work
Traffic Enforcement Agents
Force Account Work ($10M)
Site Mobilization (4% max) - % of Construction + Force Account
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
67
Work Payment Schedules (Form WPS)
Breakdown of Construction Work Items
Input by Proposer (100% max)
Progress payments subject to DB 109-2; Payments for Design, Construction Inspection and Laboratory activities per DB 109-2.2
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
68
Stipend to Unsuccessful Proposers 50% of Qualified Costs, $475K max
Must satisfy criteria in ITP General Instructions:
Pass all Pass/Fail Factors
Achieve at least 60 points on Quality Factors
Proposal must be competitive and reasonable
Proposal was not selected by the Department as providing
the Best Value
There is a Buy America Clause
There is an Iran Divestment Act Clause
There is a DBE Participation Goal of 14%
Environmental and construction related permits by Design-
Builder
Contract Information
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
69
Alternative Technical Concepts (ATCs) are proposals from the
Proposers to design and construct the Project in a manner that is
different from the Contract Requirements and which:
are submitted to the Department for review, consideration and
approval prior to Proposal submittal;
have significant savings in time, and/or reduction of traffic impacts,
and/or community disruption, and/or project costs, and/or
environmental impacts, and/or other beneficial impacts to Project
parameters; and
offer, in the Department’s judgment, an equal or superior Project.
ATCs
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
70
Proposers may submit on a confidential basis any number of ATCs
for the Department’s approval using Form ATC.
The Department may provide ‘Conditional Approval’ of an ATC.
The Design-Builder is solely responsible for obtaining approvals
from any local municipality, public agency or permit issuing agency
for ATC concepts which would affect their facilities, operations or
issued permit.
April 24, 2018 is the final date to submit ATCs for consideration.
ATCs
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
71
Anticipated Procurement Schedule
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
72
One-On-One Meetings: At least one meeting will be offered to
each Proposer; Dates have been set aside for:
March 28-29; April 12-13 (tentative); Are more needed?
Note: These will be 2 Hour Meetings
The Department reserves the right to disclose to all Proposers
any issues raised during the meetings that may materially affect
the project.
The Department will not disclose information pertaining to an
individual Proposer’s technical concepts, proposal or ATCs.
Additional One-on-One Meetings may be held if required to review
ATCs, or if the Department believes it is warranted.
One-On-One Meetings
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
73
RFP Documents:
Instructions to Proposers
Part 1: D-B Agreement
Part 2: General Provisions, Section DB 100 and Appendices
Part 3: Project Requirements (Scope of Work)
Part 4: Utility Requirements
Part 5: Special Provisions
Part 6: RFP Plans (Directive and Indicative)
Part 7: Engineering Data
Part 8: Special Specifications (Including New DB Specifications)
Part 9: The Design-Builder’s Proposal
Part 10: RFP Addenda (If Any)
Reference Documents: On Department’s website (Not Part of the Contract
Documents)
Request For Proposals (RFP) Documents
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
74
RFP Documents:
Instructions to Proposers
• General Instructions
• Appendix A – Project Information
• Appendix B – Administrative Submittal Requirements
• Appendix C – Technical Submittal Requirements
• Appendix D – Price Proposal Submittal Requirements
• Appendix E – Forms
• Appendix F – Conflicts of Interest Policy
• Appendix G – Abbreviations and Definitions
Request For Proposals (RFP) Documents
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
75
Quality Control is the Design-Builder’s responsibility.
The Design-Builder shall appoint a QC Manager responsible for
QC Plans for both Design and Construction.
Design QC shall be the Design-Builder’s responsibility and shall
be performed in accordance with the QC Plan.
The QC Plan is a living document and will be further developed
and updated throughout the Project, as described in RFP Part 2.
Construction Inspection shall be performed by an Independent
Engineering Firm (hired by the Design-Builder).
Materials Testing shall be performed by an Independent Materials
Testing Firm or Laboratory (hired by the Design-Builder).
Offsite Plant Quality Control will be performed by the Department.
Quality Control (QC)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
76
Design and Construction Quality Assurance is the Department’s
responsibility.
The Department may perform QA on any of the Design-Builder’s
design and construction activities.
The Department will establish and maintain its own staff, or
utilize an independent consultant, to perform QA of the Design-
Builder’s design and construction work.
Offsite plant Quality Assurance will be performed by the
Department.
RFP Part 2 describes in detail the Department’s QA role for the
Project.
Quality Assurance (QA)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
77
Pass/Fail Evaluation Factors
Legal – Financial – Administrative – DBE Compliance - Price Proposal (Bond/Conformance)
Quality Evaluation Factors (50%)
Design-Build Organization and Process (20 Points)
Key Personnel (13 points)
Overall Design-Build Team Organization (7 points)
Design-Build Approach to the Project (40 points)
Project Understanding (5 points)
Design Solutions (20 points)
Construction Approach (Means and Methods) (15 points)
Schedule (40 points)
Initial Baseline Schedule (10 points)
Project Completion / Impacts to Traffic (30 points)
Price (50%)
Design-Builder
must obtain a
minimum score of
60 points on
Quality Evaluation
Factors
RFP Evaluation and Selection
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
78
Proposal Format Compliance:
Proposers shall comply with all formatting requirements stated in the ITP in
Appendices A, B, C, and D, including page size, section length, and font size. In
addition, all Proposers shall comply with the following format requirements:
The inside and outside surfaces of all binders, and both sides of all dividers,
shall be solid and shall contain only text; no pictures, renderings or graphics
shall be included.
All narrative pages, Initial Management Plan components and forms shall
contain text only and shall contain no pictures, renderings or graphics.
RFP Evaluation and Selection
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
79
Photographs, visualizations, and/or renderings, if requested in the ITP, shall
not contain any text.
All drawings submitted as part of the Proposal shall include no narratives or
text other than notes or call-outs which would typically be included on design
drawings.
External web links are not to be included anywhere in the Proposal.
Failure by a Proposer to follow the formatting requirements stated in the ITP
will result in the particular page(s) being deleted from the Proposal before
technical evaluation.
A Proposal may receive a lower score as a result of any pages removed.
RFP Evaluation and Selection
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
80
Submit ALL Forms required:
Do not alter any Form unless indicated on the Form.
Do not add any appendices or attachments to the Forms.
Do not include photographs or illustrations unless specifically indicated.
Do not submit the following with Proposal:
Form SA (Stipend Agreement) => 20 Days after Proposal Due Date
Form BDEA (Bid Document Escrow Agreement)
PAB (Payment Bond (Labor and Material Bond))
PEB (Performance Bond (Faithful Performance Bond))
Additional Information – Submission Guidelines
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
81
Responses to Proposer Questions will be posted on the Department’s
Project Web Site.
Reference Documents are Posted on the Department’s Project Web Site:
https://www.dot.ny.gov/main/business-center/designbuildproject43
Reference Documents include:
Additional Information
Project Final Design Report;
Record Plans;
Boring Logs;
Hazardous Materials
Reports;
Utility Plates;
As-Built Lighting Plans;
Potentially others (To be Determined)
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)
82
Department’s Designated Representative for this
Procurement is:
Donelle Mastropietro
Attn: Kew Gardens Interchange
Contract Management Bureau
New York State Department of Transportation
50 Wolf Road, 6th Floor
Albany, New York 12232, USA
email: [email protected]
Kew Gardens Interchange
Design-Build Project (PIN X051.60, D900043)