Top Banner
HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, Isidora Jankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL Global Systems Division, Boulder, CO http://rapidrefresh.noaa.gov/hrrrtle/
27

HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Mar 18, 2018

Download

Documents

nguyenkien
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

HRRRTime-LaggedEnsemble(HRRR-TLE)Update

TrevorAlcott,Isidora Jankov,CurtisAlexanderSteveWeygandt,StanBenjaminESRLGlobalSystemsDivision,Boulder,CO

http://rapidrefresh.noaa.gov/hrrrtle/

Page 2: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Initial&LateralBoundaryConditions

Initial & Lateral Boundary Conditions

Expanded RAP

13-km Rapid Refresh (RAP) –21h (NCEP in July 2016)

39h (testing now at ESRL)

3-km High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR) –18h (NCEP in July 2016)

36h (testing now at ESRL)

750-m HRRR nest Wind Forecast

Improvement Project Experiment (ongoing)

Prototype 3-km storm-scale HRRR ensemble (HRRRE)Testing Spring 2016

3-km HRRR-Alaska

Testing now at ESRL

3-km HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE)

RAP/HRRRSuite:Hourly-UpdatingForecastModels

Page 3: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

01z +0 +1

+0 +1 +2

+0 +1 +2 +3

Time-LaggedHRRRx2013ColoradoFloodCompositeReflectivity(dBZ)

valid02UTC12Sep

00z

23z

02zMRMS

Page 4: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Exp 3-MemberTime-LaggedEnsemblewith2-hourLatency

00ZRun(notready)

23ZRun(notready)

22Z(mostrecentavailable)

21ZRun

20ZRun

PeriodEnds06 Z

PeriodBegins00Z

Page 5: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

MoremembersMorespread

LowerskillShorterleadtime

MoremodelsMorespreadUsefulspread?

Memberweighting

Givesnewestdatathehighestimpact>3runshaslittleadditionalimpactevenat100%weight

Time-LaggedEnsembletrade-offs

Page 6: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Prob

ability

PrecipitationAmount

Model

Observations

AddressingBiasandUnderdispersion

Page 7: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

LowBias

HighBias

Spring2015

Page 8: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

“Quantile Mapping”BiasCorrection

1.00”≅ 99th%ileofanalysisclimatology

99th%ile ofmodelclimatology

≅ 1.23”

Page 9: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

=2weeks=1month=2months

Page 10: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

40km≅ 13-grid-point radius

553pointsX3runs=1659ensemble“members”

Increasingspreadwithaspatialfilter

Page 11: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

3vs.6Time-LaggedMembers

Page 12: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Results:Probabilityof0.5”Precipitationin6hoursMay-Aug2015

Over-confident

Under-confident

Page 13: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Forecastsvalid22-23z

10 - 11 hr forecast

9- 10 hr forecast

8 - 9 hr forecast

Forecastsvalid23-00z

11 - 12 hr forecast

10- 11 hr forecast

9 - 10 hr forecast

HRRR 11z Init

HRRR 12z Init

HRRR 13z Init

Probability (%)

Combiningspatialandtemporalfilters

Page 14: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

RecentChangestoHRRR-TLE

• 24-hforecastlength

• Newsevere,flashflood,aviationproducts,allexperimental(ofcourse)

• Conversionofallfieldsto40-kmneighborhoodprobabilities

• TestedinWPCwinterweatherandSPC/HWTspringexperiments,andWPCFFaIR

Page 15: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Neighborhood/SpatialFilterAlgorithmDemonstration

50forecast/analysispairs

biascorrection

RawmemberQPF

Bias-correctedQPF

Page 16: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Neighborhood/SpatialFilterAlgorithmDemonstrationBias-correctedQPF

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Identifygridpointswherebias-correctedQPFexceedsthe

thresholdofinterestandmarktheseasa“hit”(1)

Page 17: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Neighborhood/SpatialFilterAlgorithmDemonstrationBias-correctedQPF

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Alsosetneighboringgridpointsto1.Simplified

exampleusesa1-grid-pointradius,butrealproductsuse40-km(about13gridpoints)

Page 18: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Neighborhood/SpatialFilterAlgorithmDemonstrationBias-correctedQPF

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Nowapplythespatialfilter(typicallyamuchlargerradius

thantheneighborhood)

Page 19: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Neighborhood/SpatialFilterAlgorithmDemonstrationBias-correctedQPF

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Inthisexample,48%ofpointsinthespatialfilterradiusare“hits”.Repeatthisforeach

member,andthefinalprobabilityistheaverageof

48%,A%,B%...

Python“fft_convolve”function

Page 20: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

http://rapidrefresh.noaa.gov/hrrrtle/

Page 21: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

PrecipitationProducts(exp)• 1-h,3-h,6-hPQPF• 6-hprobabilityofprecip exceeding100-yearARI• 3-hprobabilisticrunoff• 1-h,6-hprobabilisticsnowfall

Page 22: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

HRRR 23z 13hr pcp fcst HRRR 00z 12 hr pcp fcst HRRR 01z 11 hr pcp fcst

ConsecutiveHRRRrunsproduced>6”precip in~12hrs06hrQPE>6”

Houston,TXFlashFlooding12UTC18April2016

HRRR-TLEforecasts>60%probabilityof6-hrQPFexceeding100-yearaveragereturninterval(ARI)inHoustonarea

Page 23: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

ConvectiveProducts(exp)• 4-hprobabilitieswithin40-kmofapoint:

– Wind>50kt /Hail>1in/Tornado

• Hourlythunderstormprobability

Page 24: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

AviationProducts(exp)• Hourlyprobabilityof:

– Visibility<5,3,1mi– Ceiling<3000,1000,500ft– IFRconditions– Echotops>25000,30000,35000ft

Page 25: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

FireWeatherProducts(exp)• Hourlyprobabilityof:

– Drythunderstorm– 2-mRH<5,10,and/or15%– 10- or80-mwindspeedorgust>20,25and/or30mph– Combinationofaboveconditions

?

Page 26: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

Hazard ModelField TruthHeavy rain QPF Stage-IV/MRMS

Heavysnow Explicit snowfrommodelmicrophysics

National snowfallanalysis

Thunderstorm Lightning threat3(graupelfluxandcolumnice)

NLDN

Severewind 10-m hourlymaxwind mesonet

Large hail Verticallyintegratedgraupel

MESH

Tornado Updrafthelicity,0-1-kmshear,SBCAPE/MUCAPE

stormreportsandMRMSrotationtracks

Visibility/Ceiling/EchoTop Visibility,cloudbase,echotopheight(18dBZ)

ASOS,MRMS

Red Flag- Fire 2-mRH,10-mwind URMA and/ormesonet

Page 27: HRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update · PDF fileHRRR Time-Lagged Ensemble (HRRR-TLE) Update Trevor Alcott, IsidoraJankov, Curtis Alexander Steve Weygandt, Stan Benjamin ESRL

HRRR-TLE: Project TimelineOrganization/Experiment Hazards Platform Timeline

WPCWWE PQPF,Snowfall,Snow Rate NAWIPSandwebsite January 2016

NSSL/SPCEFP/EWP Tornadoes,Hail, Wind NAWIPSandAWIPSII May 2016

WPCFFaIR RefinedPQPFandFFguidance NAWIPS June2016

AWCSummerExperiment Initialaviationhazards:ceiling,visibility,convection

NAWIPS August 2016

WPCWWE RefinedwinterhazardsandPQPF NAWIPS January2017

AWCWinterExperiment Ceilingandvisibility NAWIPS February2017

NSSL/SPCEFP/EWP Refinedsevereweather guidance NAWIPSandAWPSII May 2017

WPCFFaIR RefinedFF guidance NAWIPS July 2017

AWCSummer Experiment/OPG Refinedaviationhazards NAWIPSandAWPSII August2017

Initiate NCO‘on-boarding” All IDP Late 2017or2018

ProductDevelopmentTimeline

EngageNationalCenterTestbeds

HRRRE-TLE

28Jun2016 17thWRFWorkshop 27

HRRR-TLEisakeycomponentofthisUSWRP-fundedproject:RefinementandEvaluationofAutomatedHigh-ResolutionEnsemble-BasedHazardDetectionToolsforTransitiontoNWSOperations