Top Banner
The impacts of excessive heat on preterm labor HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE CISA DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL HILL
19

HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Aug 21, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

T h e i m p a c t s o f

excessive h e a t o n

p r e t e r m l a b o r

HOT AS BLUE BLAZES:

ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATIO N AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE

C ISA DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY

UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL HILL

Page 2: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Kovach, M., Konrad, C., Fuhrmann, C. (2015). Area-level risk factors for heat-related illness in rural and urban locations across North

Carolina, USA. Applied Geography. 60, 175-183.

Heat -Re la t ed Il lness Ra t e s by Zip Code, NC 2007-2012

Page 3: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

9 oftop 10are in the Southeas t

Al l of s outheas t wi th

exception of V irginia in

top 20 & exceed

national average for

preterm births

Percent of Pre te rm Births

2011-2015

Page 4: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Associations with Hist ory of pret erm bi r t h

Mul t ip le bir ths

Smoking, a lcohol, or drug use

Late or no prenatal care

Diabetes or hypertens ion

Infection

P r e t e r m

Bir th

i n N C

S ources : 1 ) “B orn too s oon and too s mall in North C arolina. ” M arch of D imes F oundation, M arch 2015 ; 2 ) B erkowitz ,

G S , P apiernick E . 1993 . E pidemiology of preterm bir th. E pidemiological R eview 15 ( 2 ) : 414 -443

Page 5: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Pre t e rm Birth Ra t e s by Zip Code, NC 2011-2015

Page 6: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Previous work on excessive heat impacts

to pregnant women

Focus es on single events

Examines impact of al l t emperat ure ext remes

Western United States or overseas

Findings:

1.Heat waves associated with pre-term birth but how much

depends upon strength and length of exposure

2. Impacts range from <1% – 2% increase in risk for each

increase in degree interval (most common association with

heat index)

3. Heat Index highly correlated

Page 7: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

1. Descr ibe t he relat ionship bet ween excessive heat days and pret erm

delivery (< 37 weeks ) in NC, 2011 -2015

- Max temp

- Min temp

- Mean temp

- Heat index

- 1-5 day lags for each

- 3 day cumulative for each

- departure f rom normal

2. Determine thres holds at whic h health impac ts occur for each

meteorolog ic al variable

A im s

Page 8: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

1. Populat ion: al l l ive, singleton births in NC during 2011–2015 heat

seasons (May- September)

2. Expos ure: P RISM data was provided for each available variable; other

variables calculated f rom thes e provided variables (heat index, mean

temperature, lags , and cumulative variables )

3. Outcome clas si f ication: b i r th cert i f icate data from NC Vi tal Records was

obtained

4. Other variables : maternal age, maternal race, maternal ethnici ty, pr incipal

source of payment, acces s to OB/ midwife, b i r th weight, region, urban acces s

(determined from C ensus)

Methods

Page 9: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

S tatis tic al Analys is:

- Case-cros sover study with t ime- strat i f ied referent select ion

- Cox Proport ional Hazards

Descr iptive Statis tic s:

- Individual and county- level summaries of pre- term bir th

Binomial Generalized Additive Model:

- To establ is h thres holds at which impacts are experienced

M ethods

Page 10: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Sum m ary

Statistics: Preterm birth, NC

Page 11: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Results

Threshold: two degree temperature groups of analysis

Odds Ratio: increased percent in odds of preterm birth associated with temperature threshold (upper and lower confidence interval ranges at 95% confidence interval

Percentile: placement of respective threshold temperature among regional distribution of temperature

Statistically significant associations:• Max temp• Min temp*• Mean temp• 3 day cumulative for each

• No significant differences in race, slight differences by region

Page 12: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Where to go

from here?

Heat Early Warning S ystem

Unders tanding changes in r isk

Engaging with pregnant women to unders tand

contextual factors around r isk

Page 13: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Suggested thresholds for warningsY el low: temperatures at which any impact to preterm bir th is detected

Red: t emperat ures i n t he 90t h percent i l e wi t h not ab l y hi gher impact s t o pret erm bi r t h

Page 14: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Where to go

from here?

Heat Early Warning S ystem

Unders tanding changes in r isk

Engaging with pregnant women to unders tand

contextual factors around r isk

Page 15: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

*Stat ions que r i ed : Asheville, NC; Hickory, N C

Note : Asheville, N C d i d n o t reg is te r a n y even t s a t t h r e s h o l d t e m p e r a t u r e s

Page 16: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

*Stat ions que r i ed : Raleigh, NC; G r e e n s b o r o , N C

Page 17: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

* Sta t ions quer ied : Fayettevil le, N C

L o w t h r e s h o ld f r e q u e n c y v e r y h i g h – th is g r a p h rep re sen t s t h e p o i n t o f 4% o r grea te r increase in o d d s

o f p r e t e r m labor

Page 18: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Where to go

from here?

Heat Early Warning S ystem

Unders tanding changes in r isk

Engaging with pregnant women to unders tand

contextual factors around r isk

Page 19: HOT AS BLUE BLAZES: The impacts of preterm labor · ASHLEY WARD, PHD CLIMATE INTEGRATION AND OUTREACH ASSOCIATE C ISA DEPA RTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA AT CAHPEL

Special thanks

Co-AuthorsCharles Konrad, Director, Southeast Regional Climate Center; Professor, Department of Geography, University of North Carolina at

Chapel Hill

Jordan Clark, PhD Candidate, Department of Geography, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Rachel Woodul, PhD Candidate, Department of Geography, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Jordan McCleod, Climatologist, Southeast Regional Climate Center