River Avenue Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Michael J. Carroll Mechanical Option Primary Advisor: Dr. Bahnfleth H.J. Heinz Distribution Center
River Avenue
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Michael J. CarrollMechanical OptionPrimary Advisor: Dr. Bahnfleth
H.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Presentation OutlineBuilding Synopsis
Client Concerns
Goals of Project
Mechanical Systems
Mechanical System Selection
Daylight Addition
Roof Framing Redesign
Conclusions
Questions
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Building Synopsis
Total 150,000 ft2
140,000 ft2 Warehouse
3 Offices, 2 Break Rooms, 2 Sets of Rest Rooms
Built 8/2000 11/2001
$14 million cost
Addition to Prior Warehouse
Adjacent to Allegheny River
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Client Concerns
Open Floor Space
Storage for Canned Food
Temperate Climate
Freezing of Cans Near Intake Louvers
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Goals of Project
Provide Economical and Efficient Working Environment
Supply Zonal Air Conditioning
Impart Daylight into Warehouse
Design Roof Framing for Daylighting Clerestories
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical Systems
Existing Mechanical:
3 Duct Heaters
12 Intake Air Louvers
13 Exhaust Fans
Air-to-Air Packaged Heat Pumps
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical Systems
Existing Cooling:
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical Systems
Existing Heating:
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical Systems
Proposed Mechanical:Geothermal Heat ExchangerGround Water Heat Pump SystemSurface Water Heat Pump SystemZonal Heating and Cooling Control
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
1425 Tons336 TonsWarehouseZone 4
210 Tons20 TonsConveyor HallwayZone 3
12 Tons2 TonsWest Office AreaZone 2
11 Ton1 TonEast Office AreaZone 1
Quantity of UnitsUnit SizeDesign Load RoomsZone
Zonal Heat Pump Sizes and Quantities
Mechanical Systems
Proposed Heat Pump Locations:
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical Systems
Geothermal Exchanger Heat Pump:
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
$443,775.66
$5,587.50$2.98$1.94$1.041,8751-1/2" Fiberglass with Jacket Insulation (LF)
$12,000.00$6.40$4.03$2.371,8751" Copper H2O Pipe (in Linear Feet)
$103,538.16$2.64$2.03$0.6139,2191-1/4" Polyethylene HX Pipe (in Linear Feet)
$24,000.00$12,000.00$2,800.00$9,200.00210 Ton Heat Pump
$3,275.00$3,275.00$1,350.00$1,925.0012 Ton Heat Pump
$2,425.00$2,425.00$1,100.00$1,325.0011 Ton Heat Pump
$292,950.00$20,925.00$6,425.00$14,500.001425 Ton Heat Pump
TotalUnit TotalInstallationMaterialQuantityUnit
Geothermal Heat Pump Equipment Pricing
Mechanical Systems
Geothermal Exchanger Heat Pump:
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical Systems
Ground Water Heat Pump
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
$366,816.34
$5,587.50$2.98$1.94$1.041,8751-1/2" Fiberglass with Jacket Insulation (LF)
$12,000.00$6.40$4.03$2.371,8751" Copper H2O Pipe (in Linear Feet)
$5,274.00$14.65$9.60$5.053602-1/2" Sch. 40 Steel Pipe (LF)
$13,354.84$6,677.42$2,336.88$4,340.5423 HP - 150 GPM End-Suction Pump (each)
$7,950.00$7,950.00$590.00$7,360.001110 GPM Plate & Frame Heat Exchanger
$24,000.00$12,000.00$2,800.00$9,200.00210 Ton Heat Pump
$3,275.00$3,275.00$1,350.00$1,925.0012 Ton Heat Pump
$2,425.00$2,425.00$1,100.00$1,325.0011 Ton Heat Pump
$292,950.00$20,925.00$6,425.00$14,500.001425 Ton Heat Pump
TotalUnit TotalInstallationMaterialQuantityUnit
Ground Water Heat Pump Equipment Pricing
Mechanical Systems
Ground Water Heat Pump
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical Systems
Surface Water Heat Pump
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
$1,043,501.50
$5,587.50$2.98$1.94$1.041,8751-1/2" Fiberglass with Jacket Insulation (LF)
$12,000.00$6.40$4.03$2.371,8751" Copper H2O Pipe (in Linear Feet)
$703,264.00$6.40$4.03$2.37109,8851-1/4" Polyethylene HX Pipe (in Linear Feet)
$24,000.00$12,000.0
0$2,800.00$9,200.00210 Ton Heat Pump
$3,275.00$3,275.00$1,350.00$1,925.0012 Ton Heat Pump
$2,425.00$2,425.00$1,100.00$1,325.0011 Ton Heat Pump
$292,950.00$20,925.00$6,425.00$14,500.001425 Ton Heat Pump
TotalUnit TotalInstallationMaterialQuantityUnit
Surface Water Heat Pump Equipment Pricing
Mechanical Systems
Surface Water Heat Pump:
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical System Selection
Which is the Best Heat Pump Solution???
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Mechanical System Selection
Ground Water Heat PumpAdvantages:
Less Drilling for Wells than Geothermal Piping
Less Piping required than Surface Water or Geothermal
$76,960 savings over Geothermal
$676,685 savings over Water Source
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Daylighting
Existing Warehouse Lighting:
190 - 400 Watt Metal Halide Fixtures
140 - 180 Watt Fluorescent T8’s
= Total 101,750 Watts Installed Warehouse Daylighting:
3 Sets of 3’ high windows length of Warehouse
Visible Transmittance of 0.50
Window-to-wall Ratio = 0.36
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Daylighting
Summer / Clear Sky Illuminance
275 Fc on Floor130 Fc on
Can Sides
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Daylighting
Winter / Overcast Sky Illuminance
30 Fc on Floor22 Fc on
Can Sides
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Daylighting
8.6621.5930.22Total Illuminance (fc) =
4.0416.983.321.3025.60Illuminance (fc) =
0.600.600.700.700.60LFF =
0.82LDD =
0.900.900.980.980.90BF =
0.850.850.910.910.85LLD =
0.96RSDD =
0.870.870.800.870.87CU =
36,00036,0009,2005,95036,000Lumens =
301269050190Luminaires
F01(metal halide)
F01(metal halide)
F10(fluorescent)
F02(fluorescent)
F01(metal halide)
Luminaire
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Daylighting
Summer Month Peak Savings:
64 kilowatts$186
Winter Month Peak Savings:
25.6 kilowatts$75
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Structural Redesign
Existing Roof Structure:
Pre-fabricated Wide-Flange Steel Beams
Redesigned Structural Members:
New Joist-Girders 3 sets of 3’ high windows required
(= 2 clerestories)10’ opening for clerestory for length of warehouse (737’)
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Structural Redesign
Joist Girder on West/East Exterior with ClerestoriesModified 60G12N6.7K
Joist Girder on Interior with ClerestoriesModified 60G12N13.4K
Joist Girder on West/East Exterior Walls with No Clerestories60G12N6.7K
Joist Girder on Interior with No Clerestories60G12N13.4K
Roof Framing Supporting Clerestories36LH13
Roof Framing Throughout (excluding Clerestories)32LH06
North and South Exterior Walls24K7
LocationJoist Size
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Structural Redesign
Modified Joist Girders
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
Conclusions
Ground Water Heat Pumps are Economical for the Pittsburgh EnvironmentHeating and Cooling provided in all spacesDaylight reduces Power Demand, and Provide Natural SunlightJoist Girders supply needed strength and span Warehouse requires
Michael J. Carroll Mechanical OptionH.J. Heinz Distribution Center
AccoladesThe AE Department
Dr. William BahnflethDr. Jim FreihautMoses LingM. Kevin ParfitJonathan Dougherty
LLI TechnologiesJames White, PEMarjorie ConradChuck Boyle
Mosities ConstructionTom Edwards
Star ElectricBob Kalan
AE Colleagues