Historical Fiction 2003 version

Historical Fiction

Fall 2009ELE 616 Research in Children’s Literature

Define historical f ict ion?• historical historical fictionfiction– A narrative in the form of a novel set in a specific place and

period in history, or based on an event or sequence of events that actually happened. The characters may be completely fictional, but if they are known to have existed, their feelings, words, and actions are reconstructed and to some degree imagined by the author. The presence of dialogue in a historical work is usually a clue that the account is fictionalized.

– For more information, connect to the Historical Novel Society or try the historical fiction section of Genreflecting. Click here to connect to the Google list of historical fiction Web sites. Compare with nonfiction. See also: Scott O'Dell Award.

Historical Fiction 2

But, what is Historical Fiction, forsooth?•““The historical novel has always been a The historical novel has always been a literary form at war with itself. The very literary form at war with itself. The very term, implying a fiction somehow term, implying a fiction somehow grounded in fact – a lie with obscure grounded in fact – a lie with obscure obligations to the truth – is suggestive of obligations to the truth – is suggestive of the contradictions of the genre.”the contradictions of the genre.”–Quote from a review, cited in “History is but a fable agreed upon: the problem of truth in history and fiction,” speech by Richard Lee to Romantic Novelists Association

Historical Fiction 3

What is History, though?• Whatever else it may be – it is NOT truthWhatever else it may be – it is NOT truth– Each decade throws up new approaches to

history, finds new or previously overlooked sources and gives entirely new weight to the facts they do agree on.

– History, in other words, is tailored for its audience.

– The facts that survive are absurdly inadequate. The interpretation that is put on them is a huge distortion even of those few facts. • History is but a fable agreed upon

Historical Fiction 4

What is History, then?• History is not quite the out and out truth History is not quite the out and out truth

that it seemsthat it seems– At its best it is only one historian’s selection of what

he or she BELIEVES, at any particular time, is most relevant from the body of material that survives. At worst – well at worst, it is no more than the sort of bigoted opinion and blatant manipulation of sources that we’ve recently seen exposed in the work of holocaust denier, DAVID IRVING.• History is but a fable agreed upon

Historical Fiction 5

Where does that leave Historical Fict ion?• Historical fiction is the most primal, the most NATURAL Historical fiction is the most primal, the most NATURAL

of literary formsof literary forms– Historical fiction . . . is the artistic form that springs from this

impulse to give a shape to the past. But it’s not JUST to give a shape to the past. It is to bring part of the past ALIVE into the present.

– . . . all historical fiction . . . makes us feel, as a protagonist, what otherwise would be dead and lost to us. It transports us into the past. And the very best historical fiction presents to us a TRUTH of the past that is NOT the truth of the history books, but a bigger truth, a more important truth – a truth of the HEART.• History is but a fable agreed upon

Historical Fiction 6

Differences between history and historical f ict ion• Andrew M. GreeleyAndrew M. Greeley– History and historical fiction are necessarily not the

same thing. The purpose of history is to narrate events as accurately as one can. The purpose of historical fiction is to enable a reader through the perspective of characters in the story to feel that she or he is present at the events. Such a goal obviously requires some modification of the events.• Quoted by Cindy Vallar in Historical Fiction vs. History• See her selected Articles on Historical

Fiction vs. History (scroll down page)

Historical Fiction 7

Problems with writing Historical Fict ion• The Problem of DefinitionThe Problem of Definition

– just how “past” is “past”?

• The Problem of “Truth”The Problem of “Truth”– Historical Fiction or Fictional History?

• The Problem of BalanceThe Problem of Balance– How much “authentic” detail?

• The Problem of AccuracyThe Problem of Accuracy– How do you avoid errors or

anachronisms?

• The Problem of ProvenanceThe Problem of Provenance– Where does the story come from?

Historical Fiction 8

Fall 1998Historical Fiction or Fictionalized History?Problems for Writers of Historical Novels for Young Adults

Joanne Brown

How do these authors do it?• Making it Making it real: bringing historical real: bringing historical fiction alivefiction alive– The challenge for me in writing historical

fiction is this: How can I see, hear, feel, taste, smell, and know what my main character experienced? I have always done this through a combination of book research, exploring original records, searching for artifacts, doing interviews, and reenactment. I am an experiential learner. I am also somewhat dyslexic, so the book research can take me just so far. Touching real original records and artifacts can often transport my imagination back in time in ways that no microfilm ever could.• Carbone, E. (2007, June). making it real: bringing historical fiction alive.

Teacher Librarian, 34(5), 27-30. Retrieved October 27, 2007, from Academic Search Premier database.

Historical Fiction 9

Teaching Histor ical Fict ion

•

– To help you build good fiction into your social studies program, you’ll find: • Seven Reasons I Teach with Historical Fiction • Tips for Choosing Good Historical Fiction • Fifteen Fabulous New Historical Fiction Books • Is Pocahontas Real? Discovering Where History Stops and the Story Starts

Historical Fiction 10

Another sensit ive historical f ict ion topic• Deconstructing the Myths of “The First ThanksgivingDeconstructing the Myths of “The First Thanksgiving””– Myth #1: “The First Thanksgiving” occurred in 1621.– Fact: No one knows when the “first” thanksgiving occurred.

People have been giving thanks for as long as people have existed. Indigenous nations all over the world have celebrations of the harvest that come from very old traditions; for Native peoples, thanksgiving comes not once a year, but every day, for all the gifts of life. To refer to the harvest feast of 1621 as “The First Thanksgiving” disappears Indian peoples in the eyes of non-Native children.• Judy Dow (Abenaki) and Beverly Slapin Revised 06/12/06

http://www.oyate.org/resources/shortthanks.html Recommended books from an Indian perspective “Books to avoid” about Thanksgiving

Historical Fiction 11

Useful background books from Native American viewpoint• Guests Guests by Michael Dorrisby Michael Dorris– Moss, the Native American hero of

Michael Dorris' book Guests, learns to recognize the complex emotions within himself and his elders when his tribe invites white settlers to share the harvest feast.

• Turtle Island: Native Curriculum in Turtle Island: Native Curriculum in Early Early Childhood Childhood ClassroomsClassroomsby Guy W. Jones and Sally Moomawby Guy W. Jones and Sally Moomaw– “Throughout this book, we have often relied

on outstanding children's literature, usually by Native authors, to introduce positive, accurate images of Native peoples to children.”

Historical Fiction 12

A Reenactment SiteHistorical Fiction 13

Debbie Reese on Reenactment• Native Americans and ThanksgivingNative Americans and Thanksgiving– Due to lack of time and resources, teachers often

recycle activities from one year to the next. I think Thanksgiving reeactments are one of those things. Developing new ways of teaching about Thanksgiving will take time and money. Before that can happen, however, teachers must learn more about Pilgrims, Indians, and "The First Thanksgiving.“• See also Thanksgiving Lesson Plans

Historical Fiction 14

Another resource

Historical Fiction 15

16Historical Fiction

The End