Top Banner
fMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average • Baselines SNR and CNR Block vs. ER 1 light year = 5,913,000,000,000 miles?
17

FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Dec 19, 2015

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

fMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment DesignLecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR

• Visualizing data• Trial triggered

average• Baselines• SNR and CNR

– Block vs. ER

1 light year = 5,913,000,000,000 miles?

Page 2: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Localizers scans define ROI

Page 3: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Sample data – selected voxels, impulse response

Subject 3

Subject 4

Subject 2

Subject 1

voxe

l

time (seconds ... scans concatenated)

Scan 1 Scan 2 Scan 3 Scan 4

Page 4: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Sample data – ROI average

Subject 3

Subject 4

Subject 2

Subject 1

voxe

l

time (seconds ... scans concatenated)

Scan 1 Scan 2 Scan 3 Scan 4

Page 5: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Sample data – response average (60 trials)

Subject 3

Subject 4

Subject 2

Subject 1

time (seconds)

Page 6: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Sample data – response average (30 trials)

Subject 3

Subject 4

Subject 2

Subject 1

time (seconds)

Page 7: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Sample data – response average (15 trials)

Subject 3

Subject 4

Subject 2

Subject 1

time (seconds)

Page 8: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Effect of averaging

Subject 3

Subject 4

Subject 2

Subject 1

NM

Error bars are S.E.M. (M)

Page 9: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Analyzing each scan separately

Subject 3

Subject 4

Subject 2

Subject 1

Page 10: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Baselines and contrasts

20s block cycles 10s block cycles

Page 11: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Trade-off between CNR and block length

20s block cycles, 40 repetitions

10s block cycles, 80 repetitions

More contrast, fewer samples

Less contrast, more samples

Page 12: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Signal-to-noise ratio

• Thermal noise– white– independent of voxel size– independent of tissue type– independent of voxel location– trivial with 3 x 3 x 3mm voxels– a problem with 1.5 x 1.5 x 1.5 mm voxels (1/8th volume)– for the sake of argument:

• SNRthermal,3mm = 160

• SNRthermal,1.5mm = 20

Page 13: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

SNRthermal: block and ER design

Page 14: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Contrast-to-noise ratio: block and (slow) ER design

2.10083.0

01.0

3.70083.0

06.0

ER

ERER

block

blockblock

N

CCNR

N

CCNR

2.10083.0

01.0

ER

ERER N

CCNR3.7

0083.0

06.0

block

blockblock N

CCNR

Page 15: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Response estimate: single voxel (SNR = 120)

Page 16: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Sample data – block experiment

Scan 2Scan 1

time (seconds ... 2 scans concatenated)

voxe

l

ROI average predicted from HIRF

Page 17: FMRI: Biological Basis and Experiment Design Lecture 17: Baselines, SNR & CNR Visualizing data Trial triggered average Baselines SNR and CNR –Block vs.

Block response estimated with different HIRFsHIRF HRF