Top Banner
Technische Universität Darmstadt, Fachbereich Elektrotechnik und Informationstechnik Schloßgartenstr. 8, 64289 Darmstadt, Germany - URL: www.TEMF.de Dr.-Ing. Herbert De Gersem Institut für Theorie Elektromagnetischer Felder Lecture Series Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation in the framework of the DFG Research Group 575 „High Frequency Parasitic Effects in Inverter-fed Electrical Drives” http://www.ew.e-technik.tu-darmstadt.de/FOR575 Dr.-Ing. Herbert De Gersem summer semester 2006 Institut für Theorie Elektromagnetischer Felder
66

Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

Jun 01, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

Technische Universität Darmstadt, Fachbereich Elektrotechnik und InformationstechnikSchloßgartenstr. 8, 64289 Darmstadt, Germany - URL: www.TEMF.de

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

In

stitu

t für

The

orie

Ele

ktro

mag

netis

cher

Fel

der

Lecture Series

Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation

in the framework of the DFG Research Group 575„High Frequency Parasitic Effects

in Inverter-fed Electrical Drives”http://www.ew.e-technik.tu-darmstadt.de/FOR575

Dr.-Ing. Herbert De Gersemsummer semester 2006

Institut für Theorie Elektromagnetischer Felder

Page 2: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

2

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rGeneral Information

• Contact: Herbert De Gersem– email (preferred): [email protected]– 06151-164801– room 133 in this building (S2/17)

• Schedule– almost every Thursday: 15:00-16:40– (also at Thursday: 17:00-18:00

Seminar Computation Engineering)– exact schedule + contents of the lectures

→ website: http://www.ew.e-technik.tu-darmstadt.de/FOR575

• Examination: on demand

Page 3: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

3

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rGeneral Information

• Schedule– next Thursday 27.4: no lecture !!– next lecture: Thursday 4.5– see website: http://www.ew.e-technik.tu-darmstadt.de/FOR575

Page 4: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

4

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rForeknowledge

• Electromagnetic field theory- vector algebra + grad/div/curl- Maxwell laws + potentials- analytical solution techniques for PDEs

• Electrical machine theory- DC, induction and synchronous machines- rotating field theory, equivalent circuits, DQ-axes- ferromagnetic materials

• Numerical simulation- linear algebra, systems of equations- analyse, approximation theory

Page 5: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

5

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rStructure

Simulation techniques• overview• FE/FD/FIT discretisation• static simulation• non-linear materials• time-harmonic and

transient simulation• modelling of motion• permanent magnet material• field-circuit coupling• hysteresis models• coil models• optimisation

Examples• DC machine • transformer• induction machine• linear machine• synchronous

machine• single-phase motor• magnetic bearing• reluctance machine• magnetic brake

lecture series

Page 6: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

6

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMethodology

at every simulation step• machine-theoretical considerations (e.g.)

– relevant ↔ unrelevant phenomena– linear ↔ nonlinear behaviour

• field-theoretical considerations (e.g.)– formulations (magnetoquasistatic, full Maxwell equations, ...)– spatial effects (→ circuit and/or field simulation)– skin depth (→ grid resolution)– alternating and/or rotating fields

(→ scalar or vectorial hysteresis model)• numerical considerations (e.g.)

– computer configuration, algebraic solution methods– discretisation error (space/time)– loss of accuracy for derived quantities (torque, ...)

Page 7: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

7

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rRelated Courses (1)

electrical machines– SS Elektrische Maschinen, Antriebe und Bahnen

(Binder)– SS Elektrische Maschinen und Antriebe I und II

(Binder)– WS Electrical Machines and Drives I (Binder)– SS/WSDesign of Electrical Machines and Actuators with

Numerical Field Simulation (Binder, Funieru)

Page 8: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

8

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rRelated Courses (2)

electromagnetic field theory & field simulation– WS Technische Elektrodynamik (Weiland)– SS: Verfahren und Anwendungen der Feldsimulation

(Weiland, Ackermann)– WS Electromagnetic Field Simulation

(De Gersem, Gjonaj)– WS Finite Elements in Electromagnetism (Munteanu)

Page 9: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

9

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rLiterature (1)

international journal– IEEE Transactions on Magnetics– IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion– Archiv für Elektrotechnik

international conferences• ICEM : Int. Conf. on Electrical Machines (2006: Crete)

• Compumag : Int. Conf. on the Computation of EM Fields (2007: Aachen)

• CEFC : IEEE Conf. on EM Field Computation (2006: Miami)

• EMF : Int. Workshop on Electric and Magnetic Fields (2006: France)

• SPEEDAM : Symposion on Power Electronics and Electrical Drives (2006: Capri)

• IEMDC : IEEE Int. Electric Machines and Drives Conf.

Page 10: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

10

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rLiterature (2)

books– J.P.A. Bastos, N. Sadowski, „Electromagnetic Modeling by Finite

Element Methods“, 2003.– K. Hameyer, R. Belmans, „Numerical Modelling and Design of

Electrical Machines and Devices“, 1999.– M. Kaltenbacher, „Numerical Simulation of Mechatronic Sensors

and Actuators“, 2004.– E. Kallenbach et al., „Elektromagnete“, 2003.– ...

Page 11: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

11

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rForeknowledge

• Electromagnetic field theory- vector algebra + grad/div/curl- Maxwell laws + potentials- analytical solution techniques for PDEs

• Electrical machine theory- DC, induction and synchronous machines- rotating field theory, equivalent circuits, DQ-axes- ferromagnetic materials

• Numerical simulation- linear algebra, systems of equations- analyse, approximation theory

Page 12: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

12

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rSoftware

• semi-analytical- SPEED

• field simulation (commercial tools)- Ansys → TUD-EW- Maxwell (Ansoft)- MagNet (Infolytica)- Flux2d/Flux3d (Cedrat)- Opera (VectorFields)- EMStudio (CST) → TUD-TEMF

• field simulation (tools at university)- FEMAG (ETH Zürich) → TUD-EW- MEGA (Univ. Bath) → TUD-EW- Olympos (K.U. Leuven) → TUD-TEMF- Dido (TUD-TEMF) → TUD-TEMF

Page 13: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

13

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rOverview

• semi-analytical techniques (overview)• magnetic equivalent circuit• rotating-field theory• equivalent circuits + standard tests

• analytical model supported by field simulatione.g. reluctance machine

• magnetoquasistatic formulation• discretisation in space

Page 14: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

14

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMagnetic Equivalent Circuit (1)

Ω

= ⋅∫∫rr

B dAφ

= ⋅∫r rV H ds

Γ

Ω

magnetic flux [Wb=Vs]

electric current [A]

magnetic voltage [A]

electric voltage [V]

Page 15: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

15

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMagnetic Equivalent Circuit (2)

µ

S

l

φ

mV mV mVtN

I

φ φ

reluctance= magnetic resistance

coil= magnetic voltage

induced currents= magnetic inductance

m m=dV Ldtφ

m m=V R φ m t=V N I

me

1=L

Rm =lRSµ

Page 16: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

16

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rShaded-Pole Motor (1)

coil

short-circuited ring

squirrel cage

stator bridge

Page 17: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

17

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rShaded-Pole Motor (2)

Page 18: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

18

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rShaded-Pole Motor (3)

stL rtL

( )st rtφ

+dL Ldt

mV

m=V

stRrtR

( )st rt+ + φR R

φ

air gap

air gap

ag+ φR

Page 19: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

19

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMagnetic Equivalent Circuit (3)

• but- ferromagnetic saturation ?- eddy-current effects ?- motional parts ?

Page 20: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

20

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMagnetic Equivalent Circuit (4)

B

H

1B

1H

µ1ν

BmR

=l

B Sφ =

ferromagnetic saturation

Page 21: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

21

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMagnetic Equivalent Circuit (5)

Ampère∂

= −∂

zHJrθ

=E Jθ θρ=z zB Hµ

Faraday-Lenz1 ∂∂ ⎛ ⎞− = −⎜ ⎟∂ ∂⎝ ⎠

zz

Hr j Hr r r

ρ ωµ

2 2 0′′ ′+ − =z z zr H rH j r Hωµσ

Ohm

magnetic

l µ

2=S Rπ

φ

mV

zH

rz θ

modified Bessel equation

( )( )

0m

0=

lz

I rVHI R

ξξ

1+= =

jjξ ωµσδ

skin depth( )( )

1m

0

2=

l

I RV RI R

ξπ µφξ ξ

( )( )

0m 2

1

12+

=l I Rj RR

I RR

ξδ ξµπ

Page 22: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

22

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMagnetic Equivalent Circuit (4)

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 5000

5

10

15x 105

frequency (Hz)

abs(

Rm

) (A

/Wb)

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 5000

10

20

30

40

50

frequency (Hz)

angl

e(R

m)

reluctance + eddy currents

Page 23: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

23

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rAir-Gap Reluctance (1)

θ

( )mr θ

m,tooth0

=l z

r δµ

slotm,slot

0

+=

l z

hr δµ

slotting

Page 24: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

24

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rAir-Gap Reluctance (2)

θ

( )mr θ

ct m,1 m,212

= +r r r

t

m,2

sin2=a rλ

λα

λ

( )m ct0

cos≠

= + ∑r r aλλ

θ λθ

m,1r

m,2r

Page 25: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

25

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rOverview

• semi-analytical techniques (overview)• magnetic equivalent circuit• rotating-field theory• equivalent circuits + standard tests

• analytical model supported by field simulatione.g. reluctance machine

• magnetoquasistatic formulation• discretisation in space

Page 26: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

26

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rRotating-Field Theory (1)

( )zj θ

θ

current shield air-gap (magnetic) field

rz

θ

( ) −= ∑ jzj j e λθ

λλ

θ

( ) ( )−= ∑ j tzj j e ω λθ

λλ

θ

Page 27: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

27

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rRotating-Field Theory (2)

= ∞µ

0=µ µ

( )zj θ

( )rH θ

= ∞µ

r

zθδ

Ampère

( ) ( ) ( )+ − =r r zH d H j Rdθ θ δ θ δ θ θ

( )=rz

dH R jd

θθ δ air-gap (magnetic) field

( ) ( )−= ∑ j trb b e ω λθ

λλ

θ

Page 28: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

28

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rRotating Fields (1)

re im( ) Re cos sinω= = ω − ωj tI t I e I t I t

Page 29: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

29

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rRotating Fields (2)

( )( , ) Re j tt a e ω −λθλ

λ∈Λ

⎧ ⎫⎪ ⎪θ = ⎨ ⎬⎪ ⎪⎩ ⎭∑u

( , )tθu ( , ) Re ( ) j tt e ωθ = θu u

θ

ω angular frequency

wave numberλ

synω

ω =λ

wave velocity

Page 30: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

30

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rAngular Slip Frequency

′θ

mt′θ = θ +ω

( )( )m( , ) Re j tt a e ′ω−λω −λθλ

λ∈Λ

⎧ ⎫⎪ ⎪θ = ⎨ ⎬⎪ ⎪⎩ ⎭∑u

s,λω

angular slip frequencysame amplitudessame wave numbersdifferent frequencies

( )( , ) Re j tt a e ω −λθλ

λ∈Λ

⎧ ⎫⎪ ⎪θ = ⎨ ⎬⎪ ⎪⎩ ⎭∑u

θ

Page 31: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

31

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rOverview

• semi-analytical techniques (overview)• magnetic equivalent circuit• rotating-field theory• equivalent circuits + standard tests

• analytical model supported by field simulatione.g. reluctance machine

• magnetoquasistatic formulation• discretisation in space

Page 32: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

32

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rEquivalent Circuits (1)

induction machine

stator

stator endwindings

rotor

rotor ring

shaft (omitted)

cooling ducts

stator slot

rotor slot

Page 33: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

33

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rEquivalent Circuits (2)

equivalent circuit

XR1

U_ 1

I_1

R2'1σX

h1X

I_ 0

2σ'

I_ 2'

RFe

I RFe_ (1-s)

sR2'______I_µ

Page 34: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

34

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rEquivalent Circuits (3)

no-load test

R1 X

X hE

I 0

U0,line3

P03

RFe

Page 35: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

35

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rEquivalent Circuits (4)

short-circuit test

R1 X 1σ R'2Xσ2'

Rk Xk

I kPk3

Uk,line3

Page 36: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

36

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rOverview

• semi-analytical techniques (overview)• magnetic equivalent circuit• rotating-field theory• equivalent circuits + standard tests

• analytical model supported by field simulatione.g. reluctance machine

• magnetoquasistatic formulation• discretisation in space

Page 37: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

37

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rReluctance Machine

Page 38: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

38

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rDirect- & Quadrature Axis

direct axis quadrature axis

seen from one of the phases

22 tt

m

NSL NR

µ= =

lL high L low

θ

Page 39: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

39

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rModel

( )( ) ( ) d tu t R i tdtψ

= + voltage in a coil

( ) ( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( )di t dLu t R i t L i tdt dt

θθ= + +

m( ) ( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )di t dLu t R i t L t i t

dt dθθ ωθ

= + +

mechanical velocity

inductance L(θ) dependenton rotor angle

electromagneticfield simulation

torque ( ) co

ct,

i

dWT id

θθ =

=

Page 40: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

40

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rApproach (1)

(first try)• magnetic field simulation

→ magnetic vector potential formulation• transversal symmetry

→ 2D model• lamination→ no eddy currents → static simulation

• important ferromagnetic saturation expected→ nonlinear simulation

Page 41: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

41

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r2D FE Model

electric boundary conditions (Dirichlet)

electrical boundary conditions (floatingpotential)

nonlinear material

applied currents

Page 42: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

42

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rSimulation (1)

1.27 T

spatial resolution for the permeabilitynot sufficient

Page 43: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

43

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rApproach (2)

(second try)• magnetic field simulation

→ magnetic vector potential formulation• transversal symmetry

→ 2D model• lamination

→ no eddy currents → static simulation• important ferromagnetic saturation expected

→ nonlinear simulation

• local saturation→ adaptive mesh refinement till e.g. the relative change

of the magnetic energy < 1%

Page 44: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

44

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r2D FE Model

4.25 T

Page 45: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

45

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r3D End Effects (1)

coil

magneticallyactive length

end parts→ ‚fringing‘ effect→ leakage inductance

yoke length zl

aktiv z>l l

assumptions→→ leakage inductance independent of thesaturation and the rotor angle

aktiv zγ=l l

Page 46: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

46

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rApproach (3)

(third try)• magnetic field simulation

→ magnetic vector potential formulation• transversal symmetry

→ 2D model• lamination

→ no eddy currents → static simulation• important ferromagnetic saturation expected

→ nonlinear simulation• local saturation

→ adaptive mesh refinement till e.g. the relative change of the magnetic energy < 1%

• end effects, compute and→ compare 3D and 2D models→ linear simulation (smaller grids)

γLσ

Page 47: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

47

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r3D End Effects (2)

linear simulation

Page 48: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

48

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r3D End Effects (3)

leakage flux

adapted scaling

Page 49: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

49

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r3D End Effects (4)

linear models

2magn,3D 3D

12

W L i= 2magn,2D 2D

12

W L i=

3D,d 2D,dL L Lσγ= +

2D2D m

( )( ) ( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )dLdi t di tu t R i t L t i t Ldt d dtσ

θγ θ γ ωθ

= + + +

3D,q 2D,qL L Lσγ= +

Page 50: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

50

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rApproach (4)

(fourth try)• magnetic field simulation

→ magnetic vector potential formulation• transversal symmetry

→ 2D model• lamination

→ no eddy currents → static simulation• important ferromagnetic saturation expected

→ nonlinear simulation• local saturation

→ adaptive mesh refinement till e.g. the relative change of the magnetic energy < 1%

• end effects, compute and→ compare 3D and 2D models→ linear simulation (smaller grids)

• automate the whole procedure in order to carry out parameter variation and optimisation steps

γLσ

Page 51: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

51

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rEnergy

-30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 00

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

rotor angle (degrees)

mag

netic

ener

gy(J

)1 A3 A5 A7 A9 A11 A13 A15 A

Page 52: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

52

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rCoenergy

-30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 00

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

rotor angle (degrees)

mag

netic

coe

nerg

y(J

)1 A3 A5 A7 A9 A11 A13 A15 A

Page 53: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

53

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rTorque

-30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0-2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

rotor angle (degrees)

torq

ue(N

m)

1 A3 A5 A7 A9 A11 A13 A15 A

lower accuracy

Page 54: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

54

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rOverview

• semi-analytical techniques (overview)• magnetic equivalent circuit• rotating-field theory• equivalent circuits + standard tests

• analytical model supported by field simulatione.g. reluctance machine

• magnetoquasistatic formulation• discretisation in space

Page 55: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

55

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rEM Field Simulation

full Maxwell equations

wave equationWelec Wmagn

τPloss

Welec

Wmagn

τPloss

electroquasistatics

Welec

Wm

agn

τPloss

magnetoquasistatics

Welec

Wmagn

τPloss

Page 56: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

56

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rMagnetoquasistatics (1)

• neglect displacement currents with respect to conducting currents– Ampère-Maxwell

• magnetic vector potential– conservation of magnetic flux

• electric scalar potential (voltage)– Faraday-Lenz

DH Jt

∂∇× = +

rr r

0= +∇×rr

B A0B∇⋅ =r

B AEt t

∂ ∂∇× = − = −∇×

∂ ∂

rrr

Ar

φ

AEt

φ∂= − −∇

rr

Welec

Wmagn

τPloss

Page 57: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

57

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r

Ampère

parabolic partial differential equation↔ elliptic PDEs (e.g. electrostatics,

magnetostatics)↔ hyperbolic PDEs (e.g. wave equation)

H J∇× =r r

( )B Eν κ∇× =r r

( )s

∂∇× ∇× + = − ∇

∂ r

rr

123J

AAt

ν κ κ ϕ

1B H Hµν

= =r r r

J Eκ=r r

conductivity

permeability

reluctivity

Magnetoquasistatics (2)

source current density

Page 58: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

58

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rOverview

• semi-analytical techniques (overview)• magnetic equivalent circuit• rotating-field theory• equivalent circuits + standard tests

• analytical model supported by field simulatione.g. reluctance machine

• magnetoquasistatic formulation• discretisation in space

Page 59: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

59

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r

• Weighted residual approach

• scalar product :

Spatial Discretisation (1)

Ωin

vectorial „weighting functions“vectorial „test functions“

( , , )iw x y zr

( ) sd dΩ Ω

⎛ ⎞∂∇ × ∇× + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟∂⎝ ⎠

∫ ∫r r

rr r

i iJt

wA wAν κ ( , , )iw x y z∀r

( ) s∂

∇ × ∇× + =∂

rr r

JAt

Aν κ

( ),u v u v dΩ

= ⋅ Ω∫r r r r

Page 60: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

60

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r

• → weak formulation

( ) sd dΩ Ω

⎛ ⎞∂∇ × ∇× + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟∂⎝ ⎠

∫ ∫r r

rr r

i iJt

wA wAν κ ( , , )iw x y z∀r

( ) sd dΩ Ω

⎛ ⎞∂∇ ⋅ ∇ × × + ∇× ⋅∇ × + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟∂⎝ ⎠

∫ ∫r

r rr r rrri i i iw AA A w w wJ

tν ν κ

( ) ( )v w v w v w∇× ⋅ = ∇ ⋅ × + ⋅∇ ×r r r r r r

Gauss

only first derivative required„weak“ formulation

sd d d∂Ω Ω Ω

⎛ ⎞∂∇× × ⋅ Γ + ∇× ⋅∇ × + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟∂⎝ ⎠

∫ ∫ ∫r r r r

rr r r r

i i i iw w w wA JtAAν ν κ

Hr

Spatial Discretisation (2)

Page 61: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

61

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rSpatial Discretisation (3)

neumΓ

dirΓ

Ω

Jr

t 0H =r

n 0B =

dirA n A n× = ×r rr r

( )t 0H A nν= ∇× × =rr r

dirΓ

neumΓ

Dirichlet BC at

homogeneous Neumann BC at

nB n B⋅ =r r

0=

( , , )iw x y z∀r

0= dir0: ati iw w n∀ × = Γrr r

neum dir

d di iA wAwν νΓ Γ

∇× × ⋅ Γ + ∇× × ⋅ Γ∫ ∫r rrrr r

Hr

„natural“boundary condition

„essential“boundary condition

Page 62: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

62

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rSpatial Discretisation (4)

• discretization

• Ritz-Galerkin method

• Petrov-Galerkin method

= ∑r r

j jj

uA v

„shape/form functions“, „trial functions“

dir( , , 0 at)jv x y z n× = Γrr

( , , ) ( , , )j jw x y zv x y z =rr

( , , ) ( , , )j jw x y zv x y z ≠rr

( , , )jv x y zr

unknowns, degrees of freedomju

Page 63: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

63

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rSpatial Discretisation (5)

• nodal shape functions

• edge shape functions

( ), , =x y zϕ 11 ( , )Nu x y 2 2 ( , )+ Nu x y 3 3( , )+ Nu x y

( ) m n n mv x N N N N= ∇ − ∇r r

n

p

m km

n

nN∇

mN−∇

Page 64: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

64

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

r

• discretization( , , )iw x y z∀

r

jik= if=

[ ]⎡ ⎤⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤+ =⎢ ⎥⎣ ⎦ ⎣ ⎦ ⎣ ⎦

⎣ ⎦j i

jji ij

duk u m f

dt K and M symmetric,semi-positive-definite

sd dΩ Ω

⎛ ⎞∂∇ × ⋅∇ × + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟∂⎝ ⎠

∫ ∫r r

rr rr

i i iv v vAtA Jν κ

jj

jA vu= ∑r r

sd d dΩ Ω Ω

⎛ ⎞⎜ ⎟∇ × ⋅∇ × Ω + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟⎝ ⎠

∑ ∫ ∫ ∫r r rr r ri ij j i

jj

j

dv v vv v

uu J

dtν κ

jim=

Spatial Discretisation (6)

Page 65: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

65

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

Inst

itut f

ür T

heor

ie E

lekt

rom

agne

tisch

er F

elde

rSpatial Discretisation (7)

sd d dΩ Ω Ω

⎛ ⎞⎜ ⎟∇ × ⋅∇ × Ω + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟⎝ ⎠

∑ ∫ ∫ ∫r r rr r ri ij j i

jj

j

dv v vv v

uu J

dtν κ

∇× = ∑r rj qqj

qcv z

sd d dΩ Ω Ω

⎛ ⎞⎜ ⎟⋅ Ω + ⋅ Ω = ⋅ Ω⎜ ⎟⎝ ⎠

∑ ∑∑ ∫ ∫ ∫r r rr rr

p i iq jj

j ip jqj p q

z vdu

z v vu c c Jdt

ν κ

m

n

p

FE, ,p qνM FE

, ,i jκM s,))

ij)

ja

FE FE+ =) )))% s

ddtν κaCM Ca M j

Page 66: Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation · Finite-Element Electrical Machine ... • Electromagnetic field theory - vector algebra + grad/div/curl ... „Electromagnetic Modeling

Technische Universität Darmstadt, Fachbereich Elektrotechnik und InformationstechnikSchloßgartenstr. 8, 64289 Darmstadt, Germany - URL: www.TEMF.de

Dr.-

Ing.

Her

bert

De

Ger

sem

In

stitu

t für

The

orie

Ele

ktro

mag

netis

cher

Fel

der

Lecture Series

Finite-Element Electrical Machine Simulation

http://www.ew.e-technik.tu-darmstadt.de/FOR575NEXT LECTURE : THURSDAY May 4th

Dr.-Ing. Herbert De Gersemsummer semester 2006

Institut für Theorie Elektromagnetischer Felder