CHAPTER-IINTRODUCTION1.1 INTRODUCTION OF THE STUDY
Today, in every organization personnel planning as an activity
is necessary. It is an important part of an organization. Human
Resource Planning is a vital ingredient for the success of the
organization in the long run. There are certain ways that are to be
followed by every organization, which ensures that it has right
number and kind of people, at the right place and right time, so
that organization can achieve its planned objective.The objectives
of Human Resource Department are Human Resource Planning,
Recruitment and Selection, Training and Development, Career
planning, Transfer and Promotion, Risk Management, Performance
Appraisal and so on. Each objective needs special attention and
proper planning and implementation.For every organization it is
important to have a right person on a right job. Recruitment and
Selection plays a vital role in this situation. Shortage of skills
and the use of new technology are putting considerable pressure on
how employers go about Recruiting and Selecting staff. It is
recommended to carry out a strategic analysis of Recruitment and
Selection procedure.
With reference to this context, this project is been prepared to
put a light on Recruitment and Selection process. This project
includes Meaning and Definition of Recruitment and Selection, Need
and Purpose of Recruitment, Evaluation of Recruitment Process,
Recruitment Tips, Sources of Recruitment through which an
organization gets suitable application, Scientific Recruitment and
Selection, which an organization should follow for, right manpower.
Job Analysis, which gives an idea about the requirement of the job.
Next is Selection process, which includes steps of Selection, Types
of Test, Types of Interview, and Common Interview Problems and
their Solutions, Approaches to Selection, Scientific Selection
Policy.Recruitment and Selection are simultaneous process and are
incomplete without each other. They are important components of the
organization and are different from each other. Since all the
aspect needs practical example and explanation this project
includes Recruitment and selection Process of PSC and a practical
case study. It also contains addresses of various and top placement
consultants and the pricelist of advertisements in the
magazine.Main purpose of this study is to critically analyze the
function of recruitment and selection process of PSC and for this
purpose various books, journals, articles, reports have been
reviewed. In the process of collection of data, I adopt two
techniques i.e. on-side & off-side. Under the on-side method
different staffs have been interviewed and under off-side method
different information are collected by using internet, library
source, many friends and teachers. This study mainly focuses on how
PSC function on more effective way in order to increase efficiency
in hiring and retention and to ensure consistency and compliance in
the recruitment and selection process. PSC generally consider
Affirmative Action, Equal Employment Opportunity and Diversity are
not to be considered separate actions or initiatives in the
recruitment and selection process. Instead, they are key variables
which are woven into each step of the process of recruitment &
selection.
1.1.1 INTRODUCTION OF PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION (PSC)The Public
Service Commission (PSC) of Nepal has a long history as a stable
and independent constitutional institution. The origin of PSC began
with the Application Bureau under the Constitutional Law, 1947. The
objective of the Bureau was to ensure the recruitment of qualified
employees to the government offices. The Bureau was to consist of
such members as are nominated by the Prime Minister. Nevertheless,
the arrangement did not last long as the country was already under
the wave of democratic movement. In the history of PSC, the decade
of 1950s is significantly remarkable because the Nepal Interim
Constitution, 1950 was promulgated in 1950 A.D. and in accordance
with the provision of this Constitution, Nepal Public Service
Commission was established on June 15, 1951 A.D. with a view to
conducting examinations for recruitment to government positions.
Later in 1959 A.D., the Constitution of the Kingdom of Nepal was
promulgated and brought into effect. This Constitution also had a
provision of PSC with the authority to select candidates on the
basis of merit. The Constitution of Nepal, 1962 redefined the
function and scope of PSC. The Constitution of the Kingdom of
Nepal, 1990 had also a provision of an independent PSC. Likewise,
the current Interim Constitution, 2007, has also a provision of an
independent PSC. As the previous constitutions, the current
constitution also assumes a fairly competent civil service with
clear mandates to PSC to select competent human resources and
ensures impartially in civil service management. The constitutional
guarantee of the civil service is enshrined in the Article 153,
which states that the government would constitute civil service and
other necessary government services to run the administration of
the country.
If we make a comparison of PSC-related provisions among the
previous Constitutions and the present one, they do not seem much
different as far as their functions are concerned. However, from
the stand-point of the role, we see a lot of differences and find
the current PSC in a very strategically significant position.
1.1.1.1 CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONSRegarding the PSC, the
following arrangement has been made in the part 13 of the Interim
Constitution of Nepal, 2007(www.lawcommission.gov.np).Article 125
Public Service Commission There shall be a Public Service
Commission of Nepal, consisting of the Chairperson and such number
of other Members as may be required.
The President shall, on the recommendation of the Constitutional
Council, appoint the Chairperson and other Members of the Public
Service Commission.
At least fifty percent of the total number of the Members of the
Public Service Commission shall be appointed from amongst the
persons who have worked for at least twenty years in any government
service, and the rest of the Members shall be appointed from
amongst the persons, who have done research, investigation,
teaching or any other significant work in the field of science,
technology, art, literature, law, public administration, sociology
or any other sphere of national life and who hold a high
reputation. The term of office of the Chairperson and the Members
of the Public Service Commission shall be six years from the date
of appointment, subject to Sub-clause (a) of the provision to
Clause (8) provided that-(a) If, before the expiry of his or her
term, the Chairperson or a Member of the Public Service Commission
attains the age of sixty-five years, he or she shall retire.
(b) The Chairperson or a Member of the Public Service Commission
may be removed from his or her office on the same ground and in the
same manner as has been set forth for the removal of a Judge of the
Supreme Court.
The office of the Chairperson or a Member of the Public Service
Commission shall be deemed vacant in any of the following
circumstances:
(a) If he or she tenders resignation in writing to the
President;
(b) If, pursuant to Clause (4), his or her term expires or he or
she ceases to hold his or her office; or
(c) If he or she dies.
No person shall be eligible to be appointed as the Chairperson
or a Member of the Public Service Commission unless he or she
possesses the following qualification:
(a) holds a Master's Degree from a university recognized by the
Government of Nepal,
(b) is not a member of any political party immediate before
appointment;
(c) has attained the age of forty five years; and
(d) Possesses high moral character.
The remuneration and other conditions of service of the
Chairperson and the Members of the Public Service Commission shall
be as determined by law. The remuneration and other conditions of
service of the Chairperson and the Members of the Public Service
Commission shall not, so long as they hold office, be altered to
their disadvantage.
A person once appointed as the Chairperson or a Member of the
Public Service Commission shall not be eligible for appointment in
any other government service. Provided that-
(a) Nothing in this Clause shall be deemed to be a bar to the
appointment of a Member of the Public Service Commission as its
Chairperson, and when a Member is so appointed as the Chairperson,
his or her term of office shall be so computed as to include his or
her term as the Member.
(b) Nothing in this Clause shall be deemed to be a bar to the
appointment to any political position or to any position which has
the responsibility of making investigations, inquiries or findings
on any subject, or to any position which has the responsibility of
submitting advice, opinion or recommendation after carrying out a
study or research on any subject.
Article 126 Functions, duties and powers of Public Service
Commission:
It shall be the duty of the Public Service Commission to conduct
examinations for the selection of suitable candidates to be
appointed to the positions in the civil service Explanation: For
the purposes of this Article, all services or positions in the
Government of Nepal, other than the services and positions of army
officers or soldiers and of armed police and police personnel and
such other services and positions as are excluded by an Act from
the civil service or positions thereof, shall be deemed to be the
civil service or positions thereof.
No permanent appointment to any pensionable position in the
civil service shall be made except in consultation with the Public
Service Commission.
The Public Service Commission shall be consulted:
(a) On matters concerning the law relating to the conditions of
service of the civil service;
(b) On the general principles to be followed in making
appointment and promotion to the civil service or positions thereof
and in taking departmental action;
(c) On matters concerning the suitability of any candidate for
appointment to a civil service position for a period of more than
six months;
(d) On matters concerning the suitability of any candidate for
transfer or promotion from one service to another with the civil
service or from any other government service to the civil
service;
(e) On matters concerning the, permanent transfer or promotion
of any employee working in any position which does not require
consultation with the Public Service Commission to any position
which requires consultation with the Public Service Commission;
and
(f) On matters relating to departmental action propose against
any civil servant.
Notwithstanding anything contained in Clause (3), matters
falling within the purview of the Judicial Service Commission
pursuant to Article 114 shall be governed by that Article.
The Public Service Commission shall be consulted on the general
principles to be followed in the course of making appointment and
promotion to any position of the military service, armed police
service or police service or other government service.
If any public corporate body intends to seek advice of the
Public Service Commission on the laws in force relating to the
conditions of service of the employees in the service of such body
and on the general principles to be followed in the course of
making appointment and promotion to any position of such service
and in taking departmental action against any such employee, the
Public Service Commission may advise on such matters.
For the purposes of this Article, the expression "public body"
shall mean any corporate body of which the Government of Nepal owns
or controls fifty percent or more of the shares or assets.
The Public Service Commission may delegate any of its functions,
duties and powers to any of its members, a committee of such
members or any employee of the Government of Nepal as to be
exercised and complied with subject to the specified
conditions.
Subject to this Constitution, other functions, duties and Rules
of procedure of the Public Service Commission shall be as
determined by law.
Article 127 Annual Reports:
The Public Service Commission shall, every year, submit to the
President; an annual report on the works it has performed, and the
President shall arrange to submit such report to the Legislature-
Parliament, through the Prime Minister.
The annual report to be submitted pursuant to Clause (1) shall
set out, inter alia, the details of examinations conducted by the
Public Service Commission to select candidates throughout the year,
details of examinees who have passed such examinations, details of
advice made to various corporate bodies, details of advice made in
relation to departmental action and punishment proposed to be taken
against and imposed on civil servants, statements whether such
advice has been complied with, details of advice, if any, made in
relation to the general principles to be followed while making
appointment and promotion to any position of any government service
and while taking departmental action concerning such position and
details of future reforms to be made in the field of civil
service.
1.1.1.2 ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTUREINSTITUITIONALIn order to
support the Commission, there is a Central Secretariat (CS), headed
by the secretary. As an executive head of the secretariat, the
secretary is responsible for implementing the decisions of the
Commission into effect as well as for monitoring, coordinating and
controlling the administrative and fiscal activities of the
Commission in Conformity to the laws currently in force. Presently,
there are five divisions in the Central Secretariat, i.e.,
examination division, question-paper moderation and recommendation
division, administration and planning division, testing techniques
and curriculum division, and legal division. Each division is
headed by a joint secretary. In addition, there are five Regional
Directorates (RDs) each in a Development Region, nine Zonal Offices
(ZOs) and a Kathmandu Valley Application Collection Centre (KVACC).
Directors (joint secretary level) in all RDs and office chiefs
(under secretary level) in all ZOs as well as KVACC are deputed as
the chief of the respective organization. All the employees working
in CS, RDs, ZOs and KVACC belong to NCS.
Human Resources
Altogether three hundred and seventy one positions of civil
employees have been created for CS as well as RDs, ZOs, KVACC. Of
these positions, 86 positions fall in the various hierarchies in
the gazette level whereas 215 belong to the non-gazetted level and
remaining others belong to classless category.
1.1.2 MEANING OF RECRUITMENTRecruitment refers to the process of
attracting, screening, selecting, and on boarding a qualified
person for a job. Recruitment means to estimate the available
vacancies and to make suitable arrangements for their selection and
appointment. Recruitment is understood as the process of searching
for and obtaining applicants for the jobs, from among whom the
right people can be selected.
A formal definition states, It is the process of finding and
attracting capable applicants for the employment. The process
begins when new recruits are sought and ends when their applicants
are submitted. The result is a pool of applicants from which new
employees are selected. In this, the available vacancies are given
wide publicity and suitable candidates are encouraged to submit
applications so as to have a pool of eligible candidates for
scientific selection. In recruitment, information is collected from
interested candidates. For this different source such as newspaper
advertisement, employment exchanges, internal promotion, etc. are
used.
In the recruitment, a pool of eligible and interested candidates
is created for selection of most suitable candidates. Recruitment
represents the first contact that a company makes with potential
employees.Definition:
According to FLIPPO,Recruitment is the process of searching for
prospective employees and stimulating them to apply for jobs in the
organization.
According to Costello (2006) recruitment is described as the set
of activities and processes used to legally obtain a sufficient
number of qualified people at the right place and time so that the
people and the organization can select each other in their own best
short and long term interests. In other words, the recruitment
process provides the organization with a pool of potentially
qualified job candidates from which judicious selection can be made
to fill vacancies. Successful recruitment begins with proper
employment planning and forecasting. In this phase of the staffing
process, an organization formulates plans to fill or eliminate
future job openings based on an analysis of future needs, the
talent available within and outside of the organization, and the
current and anticipated resources that can be expanded to attract
and retain such talent.
Recruitment is the discovering of potential candidates for
actual or anticipated organizational vacancies. (Decenzo, and
Robbins, 1993). Recruiting is that set of an organization used to
attract job candidates who have the abilities and attitudes needed
to help the organization achieve its objectives. (Ivancevich, and
Glueck,1989).Job analysis
The proper start to a recruitment effort is to perform a job
analysis, to document the actual or intended requirement of the job
to be performed. This information is captured in a job description
and provides the recruitment effort with the boundaries and
objectives of the search. Oftentimes a company will have job
descriptions that represent a historical collection of tasks
performed in the past. These job descriptions need to be reviewed
or updated prior to a recruitment effort to reflect present day
requirements. Starting recruitment with an accurate job analysis
and job description insures the recruitment effort starts off on a
proper track for success.1.1.2.1 Purpose and importance of
Recruitment:
Determine the present and future requirements of the
organization on conjunction with its personnel-planning and job
analysis activities.
Increase the pool of job candidates at minimum cost.
Help increase the success rate of the selection process by
reducing the number of visibly under qualified or overqualified job
applicants.
Help reduce the probability that job applicants, once recruited
and selected, will leave the organization only after a short period
of time.
Meet the organizations legal and social obligations regarding
the composition of its work force.
Begin identifying and preparing potential job applicants who
will be appropriate candidates.
Increase organizational and individual effectiveness in the
short term and long term.
Evaluate the effectiveness of various recruiting techniques and
sources for all types of job applicants.
Recruitment is a positive function in which publicity is given
to the jobs available in the organization and interested candidates
are encouraged to submit applications for the purpose of
selection.
Recruitment represents the first contact that a company makes
with potential employees. It is through recruitment that many
individuals will come to know a company, and eventually decided
whether they wish to work for it. A well-planned and well-managed
recruiting effort will result in high quality applicants, whereas,
a haphazard and piecemeal efforts will result in mediocre
ones.1.1.2.2 Process of RecruitmentThe recruitment process consists
of the series of steps through which applicants pass. Each step
serves as a hurdle which the successful candidate must cross.
Fig.-1.1 Process of recruitment
Source: Agrawal, (2010)
Locating Sources of Recruitment
This step identifies sources of qualified candidates. They can
be:
Internal, within the organization
External, outside the organization
Attracting qualified candidates to apply
This step encourages candidates to apply for the jobs. A pool of
qualified candidates is developed.1.1.2.3 Sources of
RecruitmentEvery organization has the option of choosing the
candidates for its recruitment processes from two kinds of sources
(Internal and External Sources). The sources within the
organization itself (like transfer of employees from one department
to other, promotions) to fill a position are known as the internal
sources of recruitment. Recruitment candidates from all the other
sources (like outsourcing agencies etc.) are known as the external
sources of recruitment. The Recruitment Sources in the recruitment
process are the sources of candidates. Generally, the HRM Function
recognizes two main sources of candidates for the job positions:
internal and external sources of candidates.1.1.2.3.1 Internal
Sourcing
Internal Recruitment is a recruitment which takes place within
the concern or organization. Internal sources of recruitment are
readily available to an organization. Internal sources are
primarily three Transfers, promotions and Re-employment of
ex-employees. Re-employment of ex-employees is one of the internal
sources of recruitment in which employees can be invited and
appointed to fill vacancies in the concern. There are situations
when ex-employees provide unsolicited applications also.
Internal recruitment may lead to increase in employees
productivity as their motivation level increases. It also saves
time, money and efforts. But a drawback of internal recruitment is
that it refrains the organization from new blood. Also, not all the
manpower requirements can be met through internal recruitment.
Hiring from outside has to be done. Internal sources are primarily.
Such sources are: Promotions &Transfers Promotion is an
effective means using job posting and personnel records. Job
posting requires notifying vacant positions by posting notices,
circulating publications or announcing at staff meetings and
inviting employees to apply. Promotions has many advantages like it
is good public relations, builds morale, encourages competent
individuals who are ambitious, improves the probability of good
selection since information on the individuals performance is
readily available. Transfers are also important in providing
employees with a broad-based view of the organization, necessary
for future promotions.
Employee ReferralsEmployees can develop good prospects for their
families and friends by acquainting them with the advantages of a
job with the company, furnishing them with introduction and
encouraging them to apply. This is a very effective means as many
qualified people can be reached at a very low cost to the
company.
Former EmployeesThese include retired employees who are willing
to work on a part-time basis, individuals who left work and are
willing to come back for higher compensations. Even retrenched
employees are taken up once again. The advantage here is that the
people are already known to the organization and there is no need
to find out their past performance and character.
Dependents of deceased employeesUsually, banks follow this
policy. If an employee dies, his / her spouse or son or daughter is
recruited in their place. This is usually an effective way to
fulfill social obligation and create goodwill.
Retired Employees
At times, management may not find suitable candidates in place
of the one who had retired, after meritorious service. Under the
circumstances, management may decide to call retired employees with
new extension.
Methods of Internal Recruitment
The methods used for internal recruitment are:
Job Posting
Job posting is the most common way. It requires that management
post or otherwise circulates listings of available job openings.
The listings provide information contained in the job description
and job specification, as well as information concerning
compensation. Employees indicate their interest formally, either
through their immediate supervisor or through the human resource
department. In some organizations, the job posting program is
coupled with a skills inventory, this inventory of employee skills,
attributes, and performance data is used to match current employees
with the requirements of the job openings. Human resource Inventory
Search MethodsIt is a search of human resource inventory currently
employed in the organization. It tells management what individual
employees can do. The information includes in the inventory about
each employee is:
a) Personal: Name, age, sex, marital status
b) Educational qualifications/professional qualifications
c) Training undertaken/special skills
d) Employment experience/current position held/seniority
e) Performance ratings
f) Language spoken
g) Capabilitiesh) Job and location preferences
Human resource inventory can be manual or computerized. It is
searched to quickly identify qualified employees within the
organization to fill up the vacancies.
Advantages of Internal Sourcing
There are various advantages of internal recruitment which are
given as follows:
Easier to assess applicants since more information is
available
Less costly and quicker than an external search
Promoted employee is already familiar with organization
policies, culture, etc.
Signals to employees that career opportunities exist in
organization
Improve employee morale and organization loyalty
Lower costs for some jobs
Less likely to make major changes and upset the apple cart
Disadvantages of Internal Sourcing
Narrowing of thinking and stale ideas (inbreeding)
May not help turn company around
Training will be needed and learning curve will occur for the
job duties
Internal politics will occur (e.g., possible discontent of
rejected applicants; new subordinates discount new boss knowledge
and expect special treatment; etc.)
Difficult to do with rapid growth
Affirmative action goals may be more difficult to achieve
Ripple effect
Smaller talent pool / fewer applicant1.1.2.3.2 External
SourcingThe external recruitment sources bring job candidates from
the external environment using different techniques. The oldest,
but still pretty efficient is a newspaper job advertisement. Many
HRM Professionals do not believe in the power of the newspaper
advertising, but for many jobs it is still one of the best
techniques with the best cost/income ratio. External sources of
recruitment have to be solicited from outside the organization.
External sources are external to a concern. But it involves lot of
time and money .The external sources of recruitment include
Employment at factory gate, advertisements, employment exchanges,
employment agencies, educational institutes, labor contractors,
recommendations etc. Such sources are: Press AdvertisementIt is a
popular method of seeking recruits, as many recruiters prefer
advertisements because of their wide reach. Want ads describe the
job benefits, identify the employer and tell those interested how
to apply. Newspaper is the most common medium but for highly
specialized recruits, advertisements may be placed in professional
or business journals. Recruitment advertisements can also serve as
corporate advertisements to build company image. It also cost
effective.
Professional or Trade AssociationsMany associations provide
placement service to its members. It consists of compiling job
seekers lists and providing access to members during regional or
national conventions. Also, the publications of these associations
carry classified advertisements from employers interested in
recruiting their members. These are particularly useful for
attracting highly educated, experienced or skilled personnel.
Labor Contractors
They are used to recruit casual workers. The names of the
workers are not entered in the company records and, to this extent;
difficulties experienced in maintaining permanent workers are
avoided.
Consultants
They are in the profession for recruiting and selecting
managerial and executive personnel. They are useful as they have
nationwide contacts and lend professionalism to the hiring process.
They also keep prospective employer and employee anonymous.
However, the cost can be a deterrent factor. Walk-ins, Write-ins
and Talk-ins
The most common and least expensive approach for candidates is
direct applications, in which job seekers submit unsolicited
application letters or resumes. Direct applications can also
provide a pool of potential employees to meet future needs. From
employees viewpoint, walk-ins are preferable as they are free from
the hassles associated with other methods of recruitment. While
direct applications are particularly effective in filling entry
level and unskilled vacancies, some organizations compile pools of
potential employees from direct applications for skilled positions.
Write-ins are those who send written enquiries. These jobseekers
are asked to complete application forms for further processing.
Talk-ins involves the job aspirants meeting the recruiter (on an
appropriated date) for detailed talks.Methods of External
Recruitment
Once the labor markets and recruiting yields have been
determined, the best means for contacting, informing, and creating
interest in potential applicants must be selected. The firm may
select one or more recruitment strategies to accomplish this. A
recruitment strategy consists of a plan combining recruitment
personnel, resources, and recruiting methods. Some of the methods
of external recruitment are given as follows:
Print and Electronic Media Advertisements
Employers use newspaper advertisements for many reasons. Such
as:
Job openings can be announced quickly.
They are fairly inexpensive compared with other methods, and
more than one position can be included in the same
advertisement.
Newspaper advertisements offer flexibility to employers
(free-timetable, blind advertisements).The use of electronic media
in recruitment has also increased. Radio, cable TV, and electronic
bulletin boards have all proven to be effective competition for the
printed medium.
Public Employment Service
Public employment agencies are an excellent source of
blue-collar and hourly workers. There are some agencies who list
all those individuals out of work who are eligible and wish to
receive unemployment compensation, as well as many first-times or
less steadily employed job seekers. Private Employment Agencies
Private employment agencies can serve as an excellent source of
qualified applicants for a wide range of job openings. These
agencies typically specialize in the skill level or profession of
the applicants that they provide, and they charge fees to either
the applicant or the organization (fee paid) for successful
placements. Such fees vary from established fixed fees to
percentages of the successful applicants yearly salary.
Advantages of External SourcingThere are various advantages of
External recruitment which are given as follows:
Provides new ideas / fresh perspectives
May bring new insights from other industries
Initiate a turnaround
Hiring experienced employee can reduce training needed
Internal politics may be avoided (e.g., less upsetting to
present organizational hierarchy)
Allows rapid growth
Increase diversity
Only hire at one level
Bigger talent pool / more applicantsDisadvantages of External
Sourcing
Less information available on applicants
Search takes longer and costs more
Outsider takes time to become familiar with current systems and
organization culture
Destroys incentive of present employees to strive for
promotion
Can hurt employee morale and loyalty
May have to pay more for the job
Current organization members may fight new ideas 1.1.2.3.3
Third-Party Sourcing
Third-Party sourcing involves using a placement agency or
headhunter to find qualified job candidates. These third-party
sources use various techniques and tools to find appropriate job
applicants, such as extending offers of imposed salary compensation
and more flexible benefit packages. They are useful in specialized
and skilled candidate working in a particular company. An agent is
sent to represent the recruiting company and offer is made to the
candidate. This is a useful source when both the companies involved
are in the same field, and the employee is reluctant to take the
offer since he fears, that his company is testing his loyalty.1.1.3
Meaning of Selection
The process of interviewing and evaluating candidates for a
specific job and selecting an individual for employment based on
certain criteria. Employee selection can range from a very simple
process to a very complicated process depending on the firm hiring
and the position. Certain employment laws such as
anti-discrimination laws must be obeyed during employee selection.
Selection is the process of choosing among people who apply for
work with an organization. No organization can function effectively
without the right quality of people. Selection is the process of
choosing the most suitable candidate for a particular position from
among the prospective applicants. The goal is to select the right
person for the right job. Selection follows recruitment. It is
concerned with hiring as well as rejecting the applicants.
Definitions:
According to wendell French, selection is the process of
choosing among people who apply for work with an organization
According to Werther and Davis, The selection process is a
series of steps used to decide which recruits should be
hired.According to DeCenzo and robbins, Selection activities
predict which job applicant will be successful if hired.
Selection is a two-way process. The employer chooses the
employee. The employee chooses the employer. An optimal fit between
the job and the person should be achieved by the selection process.
But selection must be differentiated from recruitment, though these
are two phases of employment process. Recruitment is considered to
be a positive process as it motivates more of candidates to apply
for the job. It creates a pool of applicants. It is just sourcing
of data. While selection is a negative process as the inappropriate
candidates are rejected here. Recruitment precedes selection in
staffing process. Selection involves choosing the best candidate
with best abilities, skills and knowledge for the required
job.1.1.3.1 Essentials of Selection Procedure
The selection process can be successful if the following
requirements are satisfied:
Someone should have the authority to select. This authority
comes from the employment requisition as developed by an analysis
of the work-load and work force.
There must be some standard of personnel with which a
prospective employee may be compared i.e., a comprehensive job
description and job specification should be available
beforehand.
There must be sufficient number of applicants from whom the
required number of employees may be selected.1.1.3.2 Process of
Selection The selection process differs from organization to
organization. The Employee selection Process takes place in
following order:Application form Evaluation
The candidates who clear the preliminary interview are required
to fill application blank. It contains data record of the
candidates such as details about age, qualifications, reason for
leaving previous job, experience, etc.Preliminary Interview
It is used to eliminate those candidates who do not meet the
minimum eligibility criteria laid down by the organization. The
skills, academic and family background, competencies and interests
of the candidate are examined during preliminary interview.
Preliminary interviews are less formalized and planned than the
final interviews. The candidates are given a brief up about the
company and the job profile; and it is also examined how much the
candidate knows about the company.Selection Tests
Written TestsVarious written tests conducted during selection
procedure are aptitude test, intelligence test, reasoning test,
personality test, etc. These tests are used to objectively assess
the potential candidate. They should not be biased. Classification
of Tests on the Basis Of Human Behavior Aptitude or potential
Ability Test
Such tests are widely used to measure the latent ability of a
candidate to learn new jobs or skills. They will enable us to know
whether a candidate if selected, would be suitable for a job, which
may be clerical or mechanical. These tests may take one of the
following forms:
Mental or Intelligence Test measures and enables to know whether
he or she has mental capacity to deal with new problems.Mechanical
Aptitude Test measures the capacity of a person to learn a
particular type of mechanical work. This could help in knowing a
persons capability for spatial visualization, perceptual speed
manual dexterity, visual motor coordination or integration, visual
insights etc. Psychometric tests these tests measures a persons
ability to do a specific job. Achievement TestIt is also known as
proficiency test. They measure the skill, knowledge which is
acquired as a result of a training program and on the job
experience they determine the admission feasibility of a candidate
and measure what he/she is capable of doing.
Personality tests
These tests aim at measuring those basic make up or
characteristics of an individual which are non-intellectual in
their nature. In other words they probe deeply to discover clues to
an individuals value system, his emotional reactions and maturity
and motivation interest his ability to adjust himself to the
illness of the everyday life and his capacity for interpersonal
relations and self-image.
Selection InterviewInterviews are a crucial part of the
recruitment process for most organizations. Their purpose is to
give the selector a chance to assess the candidate and to
demonstrate their abilities and personality. Its also an
opportunity for an employer to assess them and to make sure the
organization and position are right for the candidate. An interview
is an attempt to secure maximum amount of information from
candidate concerning his suitability for the job under
consideration.
Reference Checks
Offers of appointment are subject to references and security
checks. The references given in the candidate's application will be
taken up and a security check will be conducted. Security checks
can take a while if the candidate has lived abroad for any period
of time.Medical or Physical Examination
Medical tests are conducted to ensure physical fitness of the
potential employee. It will decrease chances of employee
absenteeism.
Fig.-1.2 Process of selection
Source: Agrawal, (2010)Hiring Decision
Those individuals who perform successfully on the employment
tests and the interviews, and are not eliminated by development of
negative information on either the background investigation or
physical examination are now considered to be eligible to receive
an offer of employment. Who makes that employment offer? For
administrative purpose the personnel department should make the
offer. But their role should be only administrative. The actual
hiring decision should be made by the manager in the department
that had the position open. A reference check is made about the
candidate selected and then finally he is appointed by giving a
formal appointment letter.1.1.3.2 PROBLEMS IN EFFECTIVE
SELECTIONThe main objective of selection is to hire people having
competence and commitment. This objective often defeated because of
certain barriers. The impediments, which check effectiveness of
selection, are perception, fairness, validity, reliability and
pressure.
Perception: -Our inability to understand others accurately is
probably the most fundamental barrier to selecting the right
candidate.
Selection demands an individual or a group of people to assess
and compare the respective competencies of others, with the aim of
choosing the right persons for the jobs. But our views are highly
personalized.
Fairness in selection requires that no individual should be
discriminated against on the basis of religion, region, race or
gender. But the low numbers of women and other less privileged
sections of the society in middle and senior management positions
and open discrimination on the basis of age in job advertisements
and in the selection process would suggest that all the efforts to
minimize inequity have not been effective.
Validity, as explained earlier, is a test that helps predict job
performance of an incumbent. A test that has been validated can
differentiate between the employees who perform well and those who
will not. However, a validated test does not predict job success
accurately. It can only increase possibility of success.
Reliability: -A reliable method is one, which will produce
consistent results when repeated in similar situations. Like
validated test, a reliable test may fail to predict job performance
with precision.
Pressure: - Pressure is brought on the selectors by politicians,
bureaucrats, relatives, friends and peers to select particular
candidates. Candidates selected because of compulsions are
obviously not the right ones. Appointments to public sectors
undertakings generally take place under such pressures.1.1.4
Placement and SocializationPlacement involves assigning a specific
rank and responsibility to the selected candidate. It implies
matching of job requirements with the qualification of the
candidates.Placement is allocation of new employees to job. Proper
placement builds a competent and satisfied work force. Not only the
person should be suitable for the job but also the job should be
suitable to the person. When selected candidates report for duty,
they should be placed in the right job. A misplaced employee is a
frustrated employee. Promotions, transfers and demotions also
require placement actions.The first placement is for a probation
period, usually extending from 6 months to 12 months. Orientation
and pre-service trainings are given to the employee during the
probation period. If the performance is satisfactory during the
probation period, the employee is given tenure (permanent posting).
If the performance is unsatisfactory, the probation period may be
extended or the employee is asked to quit the job. Some employees
may themselves like to quit the job during the probation period if
they are not satisfied with the job or placement.Proper placement
leads to following benefits:
Reduced employee turnover, absenteeism and accidents.
Improved employee morale and job satisfaction.
Better adjustment to job and work environment by the candidate;
performance on the job matches the expectations.Socialization is
the ongoing process through which an employee begins to understand
and accept the values, norms and beliefs held by others in the
organization. It is simply the process of adaptation. It makes a
fit between the employee and the job in the organizations cultural
context. It ensures that the performance of roles by employees
conform to the value and norms of the organization. It is learning
the policy of organization. Socialization is the process of
adaptation or adjustment or assimilation of the new employees in
the organization. It is the process by which person acquires the
knowledge, skills, and decision that make them more or less able
manners of their society. When a person becomes a member of an
organization s/he needs socialization. Initial period of
organizational socialization is very much important to both
organization and employee. Employees future career development is
strongly influenced by the development of values, attitudes, and
behavior patterns during this period.1.1.4.1 Process of
SocializationSocialization is a process of adaptation that takes
place as individuals attempt to learn the values and norms of work
roles. Socialization can be conceptualized as a process made up of
three stages namely:Pre-arrival Stage
This is the period of learning in the socialization process that
occurs before a new employee joins the organization. The
pre-arrival stage explicitly recognizes that each individual
arrives with a set of values, attitudes, and expectations. They
influence values, norms, and attitudes of employees. They shape
employee perception.Encounter Stage
The first entry of the employee into the organization is the
encounter stage. This is the stage of socialization process in
which, a new employee sees what the organization is really like and
confronts the possibility that expectations and reality may
diverge. In this stage, there is possibility between expectation
and reality.
Where expectation and reality differ, the new employee must
undergo socialization that will detach his/her previous assumptions
and replace them with another set that the organization deems
desirable.
Metamorphosis stageThis is the stage of change in which, a new
employee changes and adjust to the job, work, group, and
organization.Finally the new member must work out a problems
discovered during the encounter stages. This may mean going through
changes-hence this is called the metamorphosis stage.
Socialization/metamorphosis is complete when new members become
comfortable with the organization and their work teams/groups.
Fig.-1.3 Process of Socialization
Source: Robbins, (2005:496)1.1.4.2 Purpose of Socialization
Socialization is a process of adaptation by a new employee to
job environment and organizational culture. Its purposes are:
Fig.-1.4 Purpose of Socialization
Source: Agrawal, (2010:153)Improve PerformanceSocialization
helps new employees to understand and accept the organizations
culture. This helps to achieve better employee performance.Increase
organizational stability
Effective socialization provides favorable impression about the
job and the organization. This results in low rates of employee
turnover. This helps to increase organizational stability.Reduce
Employee Anxiety
New employees suffer from anxiety. Socialization helps them to
internalize the norms, values and attitudes of other members of the
organization. They learn about dos and donts. They also get
familiar with job environment. This gives them a feeling of
belongingness and acceptance. The anxiety of new employees is
reduced. Employees feel confident, satisfied, and committed.Screen
out deviant employeesSocialization process ensures that deviant,
rebellious and norm-rejecting type employees are screened out. New
employees which are on probation and of wrong type can be spotted
for screening out during socialization.
1.2 Area of the study
Human resource management is a process consisting of the
acquisition, development, motivation, and maintenance of human
resources. Hence, it is a foremost part of the organization. The
report deals with the recruitment and selection process in terms of
theoretical point of view and the practical use. The study allow
learning about the recruitment and selection issues, importance,
modern techniques and models used to make it more efficient. The
study helps to learn the practical procedures followed by the
leading organizations. Moreover the study helps to differentiate
between the practice and the theories that direct to realize how
the organization can improve their recruitment and selection
process. Since PSC is regarded as one of the most credible modes of
recruitment. The objective of PSC is to ensure the recruitment of
qualified employees to the government offices. So, it has a wide
area of the study.1.2 Issues to be Addressed / Questions to be
AnsweredThe objective of PSC is to recruit Competent and energetic
people effectively. The research questions which served as a guide
to the study are: What are the recruitment and selection practices
of PSC?
What is the effectiveness of the recruitment and selection
practices of PSC?
How do recruitment and selection practices affect the
performance and development of PSC?
What are the challenges associated with the recruitment and
selection practices of PSC?
What are the ways to help improve human resource planning and
development?
What are the various steps involved in recruitment and selection
process of PSC?
How many people are regained during the period of establishment?
Is there proper utilization and mobilization of the human resources
in organizations?
How to regulate the employees skills (managerial &
mechanical) in PSC? What is the situation of HR supply in PSC?
1.4 Objectives of the StudyBroad objective of this study is to
know overall about the Public Service Commission and recruitment
and selection process of the organization and other specific
objectives are as under: To know the prospects of recruitment and
selection procedure.
To analyze the functioning of recruitment and selection
procedure.
To study the changes in recruitment policy in the
organization.
To know how the company fulfills its manpower requirements.1.5
Need of the StudyHuman resources are vital for achieving
organizational objectives. Better people achieve better results.
Organizational effectiveness depends on the performance of people
working in organizations. So, it is necessary to find right people
for right positions at the right time. Since recruitment is
concerned with searching for prospective employees and stimulating
them to apply for the job and selection concern with choosing among
people who apply for work with an organization.This study helps in
following ways:
It helps to study the perceived effectiveness and efficiency of
the recruitment and selection policy implemented in PSC.
It facilitates base for future research on the recruitment and
selection practices. It helps to study the current trend in HR
supply in the organization. It helps to study about the enrollment
process of PSC. Due to the given reasons the field study is
conducted in order to know more specifically about Public service
commission.
1.6 Organization of the Study
Organization of the study includes chapter plan, methodology of
the study, research design of the study, sources of data, data
analysis tools and techniques. It simply organizes the overall
procedural work of the study. It deals with collection,
presentation and analysis of data which ultimately leads to major
findings.1.6.1 Chapter PlanThe field study is presented into three
major divisions also known as chapters to make the presentation of
study more clear. First chapter contains introduction parts of the
study. It includes introduction of the study, constitutional
provisions, meaning of recruitment, purpose of recruitment, process
of recruitment, sources of recruitment, internal recruitment,
external recruitment, advantages and disadvantages of internal and
external recruitment, methods of recruitment, third party sourcing,
meaning of selection, process of selection, problems in selection
process, concept of placement and socialization, process of
socialization, purpose of socialization, issues to be answered,
objectives of the study, methodology of the study, limitation of
the study. Similarly, second chapter contains presentation and
analysis of data, recruitment process of the organization,
organization structure of recruitment committee, human resource
management system, total working manpower of the organization,
major findings. And lastly third chapter contains summary,
conclusion, and recommendations.
1.6.2 Methodology of the study Various methodologies were used
in the process of this field study. Primary and secondary sources
of data were used in the research. Questionnaires were used in the
collection of the primary data. Secondary data was sourced through
the use of books, articles, journals, and handouts on human
resource development. Electronic search engines such as the
internet and Encarta encyclopedia were also used. For this field
report the various methods are used such as questionnaire method,
survey, direct interview with the responsible personnel related to
this report. A recommendation letter was provided by the PSC. A
meeting was arranged with the recruitment nanager of PSC and other
staff member. The teacher of the campus as well as the staffs of
PSC gave various suggestions and consultations. The annual report
of PSC also facilitated various important information which was
used according to the need of the study.1.6.3 Research designA
research design is the specification of methods and procedures for
acquiring the information needed to structure or to solve a
problem. It is the overall operation pattern and framework of the
project that stipulates what information is to be collected from
which source, and what procedures. The research design is a
framework or a general plan for the study guiding the collection
and analysis of data. It is the strategy of obtaining information
for the purpose of conducting a study and making generalizations
about the problem. It is a blueprint specifying the method to be
adopted for gathering and analyzing data. The main objective of the
study is to analyze the way how they selected and do recruit to the
necessary manpower of the institution and proved suggestions on the
basis of order to fulfill objectives. A research design is the
arrangement of condition for collection and analysis of data in a
manner that aims to combine relevance to research purpose with
economy in procedure.Definitions
Kerlinger (1986): Research design is the plan, structure, and
strategy of investigation conceived so as to obtain answers to
research question. The plan is the overall scheme or program of the
research. It includes an outline of what the investigator will do
from writing the hypotheses and their operational implications to
the final analysis of data.Burns and Grove (2003:195) define a
research design as a blueprint for conducting a study with maximum
control over factors that may interfere with the validity of the
findings.
Parahoo (1997:142) describes a research design as a plan that
describes how, when and where data are to be collected and
analyzed. Polit et al (2001:167) define a research design as the
researchers overall for answering the research question or testing
the research hypothesis.
1.6.4 Sources of DataThe data for the survey are collected from
two sources. Such sources are primary & secondary source of
data.Primary source
Using personal interview technique primary data were obtained
through various questionnaires. A formal meeting was conducted with
Mr. Ramesh Sharma (joint secretory) and Mr. Tika Dutta Niraula
(member) in order to get first-hand information. A simple question
answer session was also conducted with other employees.
Secondary Source
The data were collected from various booklets, pamphlets,
magazines, websites, reports submitted by the seniors, annual
report of public service commission and other published journals
etc. Different presentation regarding PSC and interim constitution
(2007) also facilitated necessary information required for the
completion of this field report.
1.6.5 Data analysis tools and techniques
As argued by Saunders et al., (2009), data collected can only be
useful if it has been analyzed and interpreted. Before the
analysis, codification, classification and the tallying of facts
was done. That is, the results of the study were presented
according to the various research questions that the study focused
on. The objectives serve as salient headings in the process
Different data collected through primary as well as secondary
sources are analyzed using various tools and techniques.
Statistical tools such as charts, tables, diagrams, graphs are very
useful tool to analyze the available data and to predict about the
trend and the hidden fact in the relation. So, different related
tools from the statistically tool are utilized in terms of research
objectives in employee recruitment and selection procedure. 1.7
Limitation of the study
Though the study is made in a much systemized way, some issues
were hindrance to the field study. Some of the limitations are
given as follows: The time to complete this report was very
limited.
Data collected cannot be asserted to be free from errors because
of bias on behalf of the respondents.
The accuracy of the study is based on the information given by
the respondents.
This report is prepared only for fulfillment of requirement of
bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) program.
CHAPTER-IIDATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
Data presentation and analysis is the second most important part
of the field report. In this part various information are collected
and presented in form of tables, charts, graphs, bar diagrams. The
sources of data were primary as well as secondary sources. Primary
sources were questionnaire, interview whereas secondary sources
were annual reports, journals, reports of seniors, websites etc.
Only presentation of data might become difficult for others to
understand so analyzed interpretations are presented in this
chapter.
2.1 Selection ProcessThe details of work processes and methods
in order to be adopted by the PSC to perform the mandated
institutional functions, such as-design of curriculums and
selection tests, conduction of tests, delivery of advisory
services, and hearing of complaints have been provisioned in the
Public Service Commission Act, 2010 and Public Service Commission
Procedure Rules, 2010. The major activities of PSC include-
collection of statements of vacant positions from the concerned
government organizations on yearly basis, determination of ratio of
positions to be fulfilled through competitions of different types,
advertisement and notification of vacancies, design and conduction
of selection tests, delivery of advisory services and hearing of
complaints against the decision of the promotion committees. For
all the civil service positions to be fulfilled through open
competitive examinations and internal competitions, the major
selection tests are written examinations and interview, with some
practical tests in the case of a few technical positions like
computer assistant/ engineer, driver, etc. and non-gazetted class
two (nontechnical) positions. The process of candidate selection is
also shown in Figure-1
Figure-2.1 Candidate Selection Process
Source: Annual Report of PSC (2007-2012)Curriculum design:
Curriculums for every post are designed by the commission. In the
process of designing/redesigning curriculum, the commission takes
the views of the concerning organizations (ministries/departments),
and experts. When the task of designing/ redesigning the curriculum
is over, it is published and for the easy access to the concerned
people, it is immediately uploaded in the website of the commission
(www.psc.gov.np). So far the curriculums of various classes/levels
and service group related to all the services of NCS are
up-dated.Collection of vacancies: The commission collects the
vacancies from the ministries/departments/offices as per its annual
calendar following the provision of the Civil Service Act and
Regulations. Determination of the methods for selecting candidates
to fill in vacancies: After collecting the number of vacant
positions belonging to various services/groups/posts, the
commission determines the methods for selecting candidates as
provisioned in the Public Service Commission Procedure Rules, 2010.
The methods in practice are written tests, practical test (only for
a few technical positions) and interview. Apart from these, the
Commission can adopt any other method if seems appropriate.
Advertising notices: Calling the applications from the interested
eligible candidates for each post by each method, advertising
notice is published in the Gorkhapatra (National Daily), Weekly
Bulletin of the Commission and the website of the commission (www.
psc.gov.np).
Application registration: The interested eligible candidate can
register duly filled application form (in the prescribed format)
for the vacant position advertised through the commissions notice
within the time-frame at any of the offices mentioned in the
advertisement/notice. Along with the application form the candidate
has to submit the photocopies of all the required documents and the
examination fee for each post.
Construction of question papers:The commission nominates
different experts from the roster updated every year by the
Commission for preparing questions for written and practical tests.
Throughout the process of nominating experts and the activity of
constructing raw as well as final question sets secrecy is
maintained strictly.
Conduction of written tests: The written tests are conducted
very carefully focusing in the credibility of the Commission as
well as the seriousness of the competitive examinations. The
Commission has formulated and enforced the Directives for the
conduction of its examinations in order to maintain fairness in
each and every activity related to written tests. All the
arrangements related to written test must be based on the
directives. Before handing over the answer copies to experts for
evaluation the symbol number of the candidate is coded two times by
two different officials secretly so that the evaluation can be
obviously and strongly fair. The number of papers for the written
test ranges between 1 and 3 carrying 100 to 300 marks. For all
technical gazetted positions, two papers each of 100 marks are
provisioned. In case of gazetted class one and two positions, one
paper is on general subjects related to administration, development
and respective service and another one on technical subject related
to respective service/group, while both papers are on respective
technical subjects in case of gazetted class three positions.
Likewise, all those applying for the administrative positions
belonging to gazetted class one and two are required to go through
written tests on two-papers each carrying 100 marks, one on
subjects related to administration, management and development and
another on the disciplines related to respective service or group.
However written examinations for class three officers
(Administrative Service, Foreign Service, Judicial Service, Audit
Service and Legislative-Parliament Service), to be fulfilled
through open competitive examinations, has been arranged into two
phases. In the first phase, the written test is given for one paper
of 200 marks. Only those candidates who obtain at least 100 marks
(50 percent of the total marks) in this paper are eligible to
appear in the second phase written test in which there are three
papers, each carrying 100 marks, are to be attempted. Among these
three papers, two are compulsory and one is optional.
Declaration of the result of written tests: The result of the
written test is published in the notice board of the Commissions
respective office, the Gorkhapatra (National Daily), Weekly
Bulletin of the Commission as well as at the website of the
Commission. The notice includes the time, date, and place of the
further examinations such as practical test (if any), any other
test(s) between written test and interview, and interview.
Practical tests: There is the provision of the practical test
for a few technical positions like computer officer, computer
assistant, driver, etc., and non-gazetted class one and two
(Non-technical) positions. Likewise, there is the provision of
taking some tests such as informative technology skill test, group
discussion, etc. between the written test and interview for
non-technical gazetted class three positions.
Interview: Candidates for all positions, who have passed the
written examinations, must attend an interview. The minimum full
marks for interview being 20 is added by 10 marks for each paper of
100 full marks; accordingly.
The final selection of the candidate: The final selection is
decided by the performance of the candidate in written examination,
other tests between written examination and interview (if there
is/are any) and the performance of the candidates in interview. The
required numbers of candidates are selected on the basis of merit
of the aggregate performance.
Recommendation for appointment: Preparing the mark-sheets of all
forms of tests of each candidate of the particular
advertisement/notice, the merit list is prepared. From the merit
list, in the merit order, the candidate(s) in required number
is/are recommended for appointment. Besides, the merit list for
appointment, the merit list of alternative candidates and a list
for temporary appointment is prepared and published in case of the
advertisement for the positions in non-gazetted (class two and one)
and gazetted class three through open competition. However, it is
notable that there is not the provision of preparing the list for
temporary appointment in case of the advertisement related to
inclusive recruitment.
Table-2.1
General performance of the commission (2007/08 to 2011/12
FYs)
S.N.ActivitiesFY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
1Vacant positions dealt with35923665452518643156
2Advertisements/notices published112012241408783912
3Number of applicants27157725165130046386168175122
4Number of question sets designed140984010046411286
5Number of question sets moderated101696612167721211
6Number of advertisements for which written examinations
conducted9119511122132216
7Number of answer copies
examined57486542849423551230361084292
8Number of candidates selected281838362387263532
Source: Annual Report of PSC (2007-2012)It is obvious through
the above table that the institutional activities of the PSC have
been expanding in the recent years. The number of positions to be
dealt with has increased from 3156 in FY 2007/8 to 3592 in FY
2011/12. Likewise, the number of notices and advertisements has
increased from 912 in FY 2007/08 to 1120 in FY 2011/12. Similarly,
during these five fiscal years, the number of applicants has
increased from 1,75,122 in FY 2007/08 to 2,71,577 in FY 2011/12
causing increase in the number of selection tests from 216 to 911
in these years respectively.
Figure-2.2 Vacant positions dealt with
Source: -Table 2.1In the above figure it has been shown that the
numbers of vacant positions are 3156 in FY2007/08, 1864 in
FY2008/09, 4525 in FY2009/10, 3665 in FY2010/11 & 3592 in
FY2011/12. The numbers of vacant positions are highest in FY2009/10
and then it decreases in the coming years.Figure-2.3
Advertisements/notices published
Source: -Table 2.1As shown in the given figure the number of
advertisements/notices published has increased from 912 (FY2007/08)
to 1224 (2010/11) but again decreases to 1120
(FY2011/12).FIGURE-2.4 Number of applicants
Source: -Table 2.1
It has been given in following figure number of applicants are
increasing yearly but in FY2008/09 there is the lowest number of
applicants that is 86168 but highest in FY2009/10 that is 300463
But again decreases and then increases to 271577 in
FY2011/12.Figure-2.5 Number of question sets designed
Source: -Table 2.1According to the given figure number question
sets designed were 1286 in FY2007/08, 641 in FY2008/09, 1004 in
FY2009/10, 840 in 2010/11 & 1409 in FY2011/12. It shows the
question sets designed has been increased and decreased also.
Figure-2.6 Number of question sets moderated
Source: -Table 2.1
As given in the above graph the number question sets moderated
were 1211 in FY2007/08, 772 in FY2008/09, 1216 in FY2009/10, 966 in
2010/11 & 1016 in FY2011/12.
Figure-2.7 Number of advertisements for which written
examinations conducted
Source: -Table 2.1
As shown in the above given figure the number of advertisements
for which the written examinations were conducted is highest in
FY2009/10 i.e. 1122 & lowest in FY2008/09 i.e. 772.
Figure-2.8 Number of answer copies Examined
Source: -Table 2.1
As shown in the given figure the number of answer copies has
been increasing with the interval of time i.e. 84292 in FY2007/08,
303610 in FY2008/09, 235512 in FY2009/10, 428494 in FY2010/11 &
574865 in FY2011/12.Figure-2.9 Number of candidates selected
Source: -Table 2.1As shown in above given figure maximum
candidates are selected in FY2010/11 and the lowest numbers of
candidates are selected in FY2007/08 i.e. 32. In the same way
numbers of candidates selected in FY2008/09, FY2009/10 &
2011/12 are 2635, 2387 & 2818 respectively.2.2 Major
FindingsCommencing the above study the researcher drew out the
common facts and judgments i.e. findings regarding PSC. These facts
and findings also create difficulties for the researcher but it is
also the responsibility of the researcher. So, the major findings
that the researcher has drawn out are specified as follows:
The organization uses an organized system for selection
procedure of employees which starts with curriculum design proceeds
to collection of vacancies and then determination of the methods
for selecting candidates to fill vacancies takes place and then
different advertising notices are published then the application
forms get registered then different question papers are constructed
onwards written tests conducted then the results are declared
afterwards practical tests are conducted then interview session is
conducted which results in final selection of the candidate and
finally recommendations are facilitated for appointment. In the
process of curriculum design the commission takes the views of the
concerning organization.
In the same way the advertising notices are published in
Gorkhapatra, weekly bulletin of the commission and the website of
the commission (www.psc.gov.np).
The number vacant positions were highest in FY2009/10
i.e.4525.
The advertisements/notices published were highest in number in
FY2009/10 i.e. 1408 but then it decreased in passing years.
The total number of applicants was greater in number inFY2009/10
i.e. 300463.
The number of question sets designed was highest in FY2011/12
i.e.1409 as compared to previous years. The number of written
examination conducted was greater in FY2009/10 i.e. 1122 but then
it started decreasing.
The total number of answer copies examined was highest in
FY2011/12 i.e.574865. The final selection of the candidate is
decided by the performance of the candidate in written examination,
other tests and interview.
The number of candidates selected was highest in FY2009/10 i.e.
3836 as compared to previous years but then it again started to
decrease and were 2818 in FY2011/12. There are two sources of
recruitment of the organization. They are internal and external
sources.
In the internal sources the organization uses employee
referrals, human resource inventory system, and promotion. In the
same way external sources include walk-ins, advertisements etc.
Total no. of employees working in the organization is increasing
with every passing year.
Chapter-IIISummary, Conclusion Recommendation
3.1 Summary
The purpose of this study was to find out the trend of
recruitment and selection process. This report is prepared for the
partial fulfillment of requirement of degree of the bachelor of
business Administration as per the prescribed format of the P.U.In
this report chapter-I includes introduction of the study,
introduction of public service commission, recruitment and
selection process, importance of recruitment, various methods of
recruitment, third-party sourcing, meaning of selection, essential
elements for selection process, process of selection, problems in
effective selection, area of the study, objective of the study,
limitations of the study. Objective of the study is to know the
prospects of the recruitment and selection procedure and to know
functioning of recruitment and selection process etc. Likewise,
chapter-II includes different data related to recruitment and
selection procedure such as number of vacant positions,
advertisements/notices published, number of applicants, number of
question sets designed, number of question sets moderated, number
of advertisements for which the written examination conducted,
number of answer copies examined and finally number of candidates
selected. All the data presented are true and fair enough. PSC has
been recruiting efficient and skilled manpower to increase the
productivity.
3.2 ConclusionPublic Service Commission (PSC), is the main
constitutional body involved in selecting meritorious candidates
required by Government of Nepal for Civil Service Vacancy. PSC is
regarded as one of the most credible modes of recruitment. The
Constitution of Nepal 2007(2063 BS) has regarded the commission as
an independent constitutional body.
There are various supporting issues of national-building process
as well as strengthening democratic political system. Among such
less attention-paying issues are the representation of socially
marginalized groups- Dalit, Mahila, Madhise, Janjati and Apangain
Civil Service of Nepal. Thus, the paper has been developed with an
objective to expose the need of the revision and prepare new
curriculum acceptable even to the disadvantaged groups. Some major
conclusions on the perspective of researcher are given as follows:
The recruitment process of the PSC has been improved with the
interval of time.
The advertisement publication medium has also been
diversified.
The candidate selection process has become systematic and
organized.
The no. of candidates to be selected is increasing with the
interval of time.
More competitive staffs are being selected due to effective
selection process.
It has provided an opportunity for the disadvantaged &
socially marginalized group to show their tallency and hard
work.3.3 RecommendationsAfter the deep analysis and surveillance of
public service commission, the researcher found the performance of
the public service commission quite sensible in the area of
recruitment and selection process. However, for more improvement
and to make the recruitment and selection process more effective
following things are recommended from the point of view of the
researcher: Nepotism/Favoritism should be avoided in the process of
recruitment and selection. It should select some more media to
publish advertisements so that more candidates get informed about
the vacancy. The candidate should be selected according to his/her
skills, efficiency, credibility & knowledge.
It should not ignore the socialization process as the
socialization process helps to make the employees familiar with the
organization. Every employee should be cleared about their roles
and responsibilities at the time of hiring.Recruitment
Attracting qualified candidates to Apply
External
Internal
Locating Sources of Recruitment
Application form Evaluation
Preliminary Interview
Selection Tests
Selection Interview
Reference Checks
Medical or physical Examination
Hiring Decision
Career
Metamorphosis Stage
Encounter Stage
Pre-arrival Stage
Turnover
Purpose of Socialization
Improve Performance
Increase Organizational Stability
Reduce Employee Anxiety
Screen out Deviant Employee
Vacancy Demands (Ministries/Department offices)
Decoding
Second Coding
Question Construction
Percentage allotment
Annual Calendar
Advertisement/Notice Publication
Conduction of Written Examination
Interview Board
Application
Recommendation
Interview
Written Examination Result Publication
Evaluation of Answer Copies
Double Coding
First Coding
Question Paper Preparation/Moderation
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
Expert
19
_1460681879.xlsChart1
112012241408783912
FY2011/12
FY2010/11
FY2009/10
FY2008/09
FY2007/08
Sheet1
FY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
Advertisements/notices published112012241408783912
Category 22.54.42
Category 33.51.83
Category 44.52.85
To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of
range.
_1460682184.xlsChart1
101696612167721211
FY2011/12
FY2010/11
FY2009/10
FY2008/09
FY2007/08
Sheet1
FY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
Number of question-sets moderated101696612167721211
Category 22.54.42
Category 33.51.83
Category 44.52.85
To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of
range.
_1460682328.xlsChart1
57486542849423551230361084292
FY2011/12
FY2010/11
FY2009/10
FY2008/09
FY2007/08
Sheet1
FY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
Number of answer copies
examined57486542849423551230361084292
Category 22.54.42
Category 33.51.83
Category 44.52.85
To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of
range.
_1460728256.xlsChart1
281838362387263532
FY2011/12
FY2010/11
FY2009/10
FY2008/09
FY2007/08
Sheet1
FY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
Number of candidates selected281838362387263532
Category 22.54.42
Category 33.51.83
Category 44.52.85
To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of
range.
_1460682220.xlsChart1
9119511122132216
FY2011/12
FY2010/11
FY2009/10
FY2008/09
FY2007/08
Sheet1
FY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
Number of advertisement for which written examinations
conducted9119511122132216
Category 22.54.42
Category 33.51.83
Category 44.52.85
To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of
range.
_1460681956.xlsChart1
27157725165130046386168175122
FY2011/12
FY2010/11
FY2009/10
FY2008/09
FY2007/08
Sheet1
FY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
Number of applicants27157725165130046386168175122
Category 22.54.42
Category 33.51.83
Category 44.52.85
To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of
range.
_1460681838.xlsChart1
35923665452518643156
FY2011/12
FY2010/11
FY2009/10
FY2008/09
FY2007/08
Sheet1
FY2011/12FY2010/11FY2009/10FY2008/09FY2007/08
Vacant positions dealt with35923665452518643156
Category 22.54.42
Category 33.51.83
Category 44.52.85
To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of
range.