Top Banner
i APPLICATION OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON GEOSYNTHETICS REINFORCED SLOPE SHARON LEE FUNG CHOO Master of Engineering (Civil) 2013 Faculty of Engineering
24

Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

Jan 17, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

i

APPLICATION OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON

GEOSYNTHETICS REINFORCED SLOPE

SHARON LEE FUNG CHOO

Master of Engineering

(Civil)

2013

Faculty of Engineering

Page 2: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

ii

APPLICATION OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON

GEOSYNTHETICS REINFORCED SLOPE

SHARON LEE FUNG CHOO

A dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements

for the degree Master of Engineering (Civil)

Faculty of Engineering

UNIVERSITI MALAYSIA SARAWAK

2013

Page 3: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

i

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

First and foremost, I would like to thank my almighty God for giving me the strength and

wisdom to complete this thesis for my master’s degree. Besides, thanks to my mother, Madam

Liaw and my family members who encouraged me to pursue my studies.

With this opportunity, I would like to extend my appreciation to many individuals for their

gracious support to me. Without them, this thesis would not be completed as planned.

My deepest appreciation goes to my supervisor, Assoc. Prof. Dr. Siti Noor Linda Taib for her

personnel guidance, supervision and comments throughout this thesis. With her encouragement,

I had a better understanding towards the topic chosen for my thesis and also have a clearer

direction towards the work that needs to be done.

I would like to thank all the lecturers who taught me the geotechnical courses, Prof. Kaniraj,

Dr. Norazzlina bt M. Sa’don, Dr. Fauzan b. Sahdi and Puan Dayangku Salma for sharing their

knowledge with me as it has enhanced my understanding in this discipline of Civil Engineering.

Besides, I would like to express my appreciation to my coursemates, Lee Shyue Leong and Lim

Hung Ling for their help and support throughout the period of completing this thesis. In addition

to that, I would like to thank another coursemate, Mr. Bong Shun Tat who is a Geotechnical

Engineer with seven years of experience in this field, for sharing his practical knowledge in

slope construction and slope stability analysis. Apart from that, I would like to express my

Page 4: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

ii

sincere appreciation to him for guiding me in using Plaxis Version 8.2 for the validation work

in this thesis.

Not forgetting my ex-coursemates such as Gilbert Wong, Willie Chai, Ivy Sii, Gillan Lio and

Law Dah Lit for recommending me a great supervisor in this discipline of Civil Engineering. I

will cherish the good times we had studying, struggling and playing together. Best wishes for

their future undertakings.

My gratitude goes to Executive College for granting me the study leaves to pursue my master’s

degree. Many thanks for the tolerance from my Director of Study and Heads of Department

throughout these periods, especially in the arrangement of time table for my teaching. Thanks

to my colleagues who are very supportive in many areas too.

Special thanks for this group of friends who prayed faithfully for my studies such as Lai Sia

Ing and Lydia Tan.

Last but not least, I would like to say a prayer of blessing to those who supported me throughout

these periods.

Page 5: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

iii

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the study is to apply the Horizontal Slice Method (HSM) in slope stability

analysis for slope reinforced with geotextile. This is a new method which can resolve the

problem of direct influence of reinforcement on the inter-slice forces encountered in the

Vertical Slice Method. This new method had been used in past researches done by Nouri et al.

(2006) and Taib & Craig (2007). The results from their research had shown close values with

the conventional methods. The simple formulation of the HSM comprising of (2N+1)

unknowns and (2N+1) equations suggested by Shahgholi et al. (2001) were used in this study.

Factors contributing to slope instability were identified as the factors would influenced the

formulating of the equations for vertical forces and horizontal forces in the slope. The factors

were slope geometry, soil properties, groundwater condition and configuration of reinforcement.

A spreadsheet had been designed using Microsoft Excel 2007. There are four sections in the

spreadsheet. Namely the data input, data generation, data analysis and result. With the trial and

error method, the factor of safety is found when the equilibrium of the horizontal forces for the

whole wedge of slope is achieved. Validation work using Plaxis Version 8.2 was carried out to

test the reliability of the spreadsheet. Six slopes had been designed for the validation work. The

deviations between the factors of safety from Plaxis and the factors of safety from spreadsheet

were ranged from 0.6 % to 3.27 %. The deviations were considered low, thus the HSM can give

values close to the existing software. The results from the spreadsheet had same pattern as the

results from Plaxis Version 8.2. This also confirmed that the spreadsheet had been prepared

with no error.

Page 6: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

iv

ABSTRAK

Tujuan kajian ini adalah untuk mengaplikasikan Kaedah Hirisan Mendatar ke dalam analisis

kestabilan cerun yang diperkukuh oleh geotekstil. Kaeadah in merupakan kaedah baru yang

digunakan untuk menyelesaikan masalah pengaruh lansung tetulang terhadap daya – daya

antara hirisan yang dijumpai dalam Kaedah Hirisan Menegak. Kaedah baru ini pernah dikaji

oleh Nouri et al. (2006) dan Taib & Craig (2007). Keputusan-keputusan daripada kajian mereka

mendekati keputusan-keputusan daripada kaedah konvensional. Ini membuktikan Kaedah

Hirisan Mendatar dapat memberi keputusan yang memuaskan. Rumusan ringkas daripada

Kaedah Hirisan Mendatar yang terdiri daripada (2N+1) anu dan (2N+1) persamaan yang

dicadangkan oleh Shahgholi et al. (2001) telah digunakan dalam kajian ini. Faktor-faktor yang

mempengaruhi ketidakstabilan cerun telah dikenalpasti kerana ia akan mempengaruhi

pembentukan persamaan untuk daya-daya menegak dan daya-daya mendatar. Faktor-faktor

tersebut adalah geometri cerun, sifat-sifat tanah, keadaan air bawah tanah dan konfigurasi

tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

di dalam pengiraan yang direka, iaitu input data, penjanaan data, analisi data dan keputusan.

Dengan ujian percubaan dan kesilapan, faktor keselamatan cerun akan didapati apabila

keseimbangan daya-daya mendatar untuk keseluruhan baji cerun tercapai. Kerja pengesahan

pengiraan yang direka telah dilakukan dengan perisian Plaxis versi 8.2 untuk menguji

kebolehpercayaan pengiraan tersebut. Enam cerun telah direka untuk kerja pengesahan.

Deviasi-deviasi daripada perbandingan faktor keselamatan yang didapati daripada Plaxis dan

pengiraan Excel merangkumi 0.6 % hingga 3.27 % untuk keenam-enam cerun ini. Deviasi

tersebut dianggap rendah, maka ini membuktikan Kaedah Hirisan Mendatar dapat memberi

keputusan yang mendekati keputusan daripada perisian yang sedia ada. Keputusan daripada

Page 7: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

v

pengiraan Excel mempunyai corak yang sama dengan Plaxis. Ini membuktikan pengiraan

tersebut telah direka dengan tepat.

Page 8: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

vi

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT .......................................................................................................... i

ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................................. iii

ABSTRAK ................................................................................................................................ iv

LIST OF TABLES .................................................................................................................. viii

LIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................................... ix

1 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 1

1.1 PROBLEM STATEMENT ........................................................................... 1

1.2 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES .......................................................................... 2

1.3 SCOPE OF RESEARCH .............................................................................. 3

1.4 THESIS OUTLINE ....................................................................................... 3

2 LITERATURE REVIEW ............................................................................................ 5

2.1 SLOPE STABILITY ANALYSIS ................................................................ 5

2.1.1 Factor of Safety ................................................................................... 5

2.1.2 Limit Equilibrium Method .................................................................. 6

2.1.3 Finite Element Method ........................................................................ 7

2.2 VERTICAL SLICE METHOD AND ITS LIMITATION ........................... 8

2.3 HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD............................................................. 12

2.3.1 Horizontal Slice Method and the Basic Assumptions ....................... 12

2.3.2 Formulation of Horizontal Slice Method .......................................... 14

2.4 APPLICATION OF HSM IN THE PAST RESEARCHES ....................... 18

2.4.1 Application of Horizontal Slice Method on Soil Nailed Slopes ........ 18

2.4.2 Development of Horizontal Slice Method for Seismic Stability

Analysis of Reinforced Slopes and Walls ................................................... 21

2.5 GEOTEXTILE AS REINFORCING MATERIAL .................................... 23

2.5.1 Advantages of using Geotextile......................................................... 23

2.5.2 Characteristic of Geotextile ............................................................... 25

2.5.3 High Strength Geosynthetics and Soil Compatibility ....................... 26

2.6 PLAXIS VERSION 8.2 .............................................................................. 27

3 METHODOLOGY ..................................................................................................... 28

3.1 INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................... 28

3.2 SLOPE GEOMETRY ................................................................................. 30

Page 9: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

vii

3.3 SOIL PROPERTIES ................................................................................... 32

3.4 GROUNDWATER CONDITION .............................................................. 33

3.5 CONFIGURATION OF REINFORCEMENT ........................................... 34

3.6 COMPUTATION OF NORMAL FORCE AND SHEAR FORCE UPON

BASE OF SLICE ...................................................................................................... 36

3.7 EQUILIBRIUM OF HORIZONTAL FORCES FOR WHOLE WEDGE . 37

3.8 DEVELOPMENT OF SPREADSHEET .................................................... 38

3.9 VALIDATION WORK .............................................................................. 39

3.9.1 Data for validation ............................................................................. 39

3.9.2 Analysis through Plaxis Version 8.2 ................................................. 40

4 RESULTS AND CONCLUIONS .............................................................................. 43

4.1 GENERAL .................................................................................................. 43

4.2 VALIDATION RESULTS ......................................................................... 43

4.2.1 Comparison between Factor of Safety from Plaxis and Factor of

Safety from Spreadsheet for Slopes with Height of 5 m ............................ 43

4.2.2 Comparison between Factor of Safety from Plaxis and Factor of

Safety from Spreadsheet for Slopes with Inclination Angle of 60˚ ........... 45

4.3 SPREADSHEET FOR HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ....................... 46

4.3.1 Introduction to Spreadsheet ............................................................... 46

4.3.2 Guideline for Using Spreadsheet ....................................................... 52

5 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ....................................................... 53

5.1 GENERAL REMARKS.............................................................................. 53

5.2 CONCLUSIONS......................................................................................... 53

5.3 RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................................ 54

REFERENCES ......................................................................................................................... 56

APPENDIX .............................................................................................................................. 58

Appendix A: Results from Plaxis Version 8 ............................................................................ 58

Appendix B: Results from Spreadsheet ................................................................................... 64

Appendix C: Results for Comparison ...................................................................................... 85

Page 10: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

viii

LIST OF TABLES

Table 2.1: Method of limit equilibrium. 6

Table 2.2: Notation for Figure 2.1 9

Table 2.3: Notation for Figure 2.2 9

Table 2.4: Equations and unknowns of Vertical Slice Method of Analysis.

(Shahgholi et al., 2001)

10

Table 2.5: Notation for Figure 2.3 11

Table 2.6: Notation for Figure 2.5 14

Table 2.7: Equations and Unknowns of Complete Formulation of HSM of

Analysis. (Shahgholi et al., 2001)

14

Table 2.8: List of Equations and Unknowns in Two Simple Formulations.

(Shahgholi et al., 2001; Fakher et al., 2002)

17

Table 2.9a: Notation for Figure 2.7 19

Table 2.10: List of Equations and Unknowns in the First and Second 3N

Formulation. (Nouri et al., 2006)

22

Table 2.11: List of Unknowns and Equations in Rigorous 5N – 1 Formulation.

(Nouri et al., 2006)

22

Table 2.12: Summary of Types of High Strength Geosynthetics and Soil

Compatibility. (Tencate Geosynthetics Asia Sdn. Bhd.)

26

Table 3.1: Slope Conditions for Validation Work 37

Page 11: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

ix

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 2.1: Traditional Method of Slice 8

Figure 2.2: Forces Acting at A Typical Vertical Slice 9

Figure 2.3: Forces Developed on A Single Vertical Slice Containing

Reinforcement

11

Figure 2.4: Horizontal Slice Method 13

Figure 2.5: Forces Acting on A Single Horizontal Slice Containing

Reinforcement

13

Figure 2.6: (a) The Geometry of Log-spiral Failure Mechanism and Horizontal

Slice Method and (b) The Geometry of Acting Forces of Each Slice

16

Figure 2.7: Configuration of HSM Slicing for Soil Nailed Slope with Inclined

Reinforcement.

18

Figure 2.8: Distribution of Forces and Dimensions of Horizontal Slice (Taib &

Craig, 2007)

19

Figure 2.9 (a) Conventional Structure and (b) Reinforced Soil Structure

(Tencate Geosynthetics Asia Sdn. Bhd.)

24

Figure 2.10 (a) Conventional Slope and (b) Reinforced Soil Slope (Tencate

Geosynthetics Asia Sdn. Bhd.)

24

Figure 3.1: Analysis Procedure 29

Figure 3.2: Log-spiral Failure Surface 31

Figure 3.3: Geometry and Acting Forces for Each Slice 32

Figure 3.4: Distribution of Pore Pressure Forces of Each Slice 33

Figure 3.5: Dimensions for Reinforcing Force 34

Figure 3.6: Distribution of Normal Force and Shear Force upon Base of Slice 36

Figure 3.7: Flow of Spreadsheet 38

Figure 3.8: Input of Soil Parameters 40

Figure 3.9: Input of Material 40

Figure 3.10: Output of Factor of Safety 41

Figure 3.11: Output of Reinforcing Forces 41

Figure 3.12: Output of Total Displacement 42

Figure 4.1: Comparison between FOS from Plaxis and FOS from Spreadsheet

for Slopes with Height of 5 m

42

Page 12: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

x

Figure 4.2: Comparison between FOS from Plaxis and FOS from Spreadsheet

for Slopes with Inclination Angle of 60˚

45

Figure 4.3: Input of Geometry and Geotechnical Characteristics 47

Figure 4.4: Input of Slope Geometry 47

Figure 4.5: Input of Location of Reinforcing Material 48

Figure 4.6: Chart for Failure Surface 48

Figure 4.7: Dimensions and Angles 49

Figure 4.8: Computation of Forces 50

Figure 4.9: Computation of Reinforcing Forces 50

Figure 4.10: Data Analysis 51

Figure 4.11: Result 51

Page 13: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

1

CHAPTER 1

1 INTRODUCTION

1.1 PROBLEM STATEMENT

There are numerous methods used to analyse the stability of a slope. Limit equilibrium

methods adopting the vertical slice method are conventionally used to determine the factor of

safety of a soil wedge against sliding. In this method the soil wedge is usually divided into a

number of vertical slices during the analysis. In the reinforced slope, the orientation of the

reinforcement has a direct influence on the inter-slice forces, the force mobilised in the

reinforcement will intersect the vertical slices and additional unknown horizontal tension forces

from the reinforcement will appear in the vertical slice method of analysis. Thus, the solution

becomes complicated and time consuming. As a result, vertical slice method has the limitation

in analysing the reinforced soil slope.

A new limit equilibrium method known as Horizontal Slice Method (HSM) has been

identified and used to resolve the problem (Shahgholi, 2001). In this method, the sliding soil

wedge is divided into a number of horizontal slices, which do not intersect the reinforcements,

thus the reinforcement has no direct influence on the inter-slice force.

The factor of safety from HSM analysis is compared with values produced from program

slope, which utilises Janbu’s Simplified Method had shown reasonably close values (Taib &

Craig, 2007).Other than this, the HSM analysis was compared with the published procedures

Page 14: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

2

for verification of its reliability. Result has shown that the HSM analysis using the rigorous

formulation (5N-1) are similar to the procedure based on pseudo-static limit stability analysis

by Ling et al. (1997) in which the internal and external stability analyses are conducted to

determine the required strength and length of the reinforcement considering different modes of

failure (Nouri et al., 2006). Therefore reinforced slope analysis using Horizontal Slice Method

can be used.

1.2 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES

The aim of this project is to apply the Horizontal Slice Method for stability analysis on

reinforced slope with geotextile.

The specific objectives of this study are:

1. to apply Horizontal Slice Method to formulate mathematical equations for finding the factor

of safety (FOS) on reinforced slope with geotextile,

2. to design spreadsheet for stability analysis on reinforced slope with geotextile and

3. to validate the safety factor (output) produced from the designed spreadsheet with existing

software Plaxis version 8.2.

Page 15: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

3

1.3 SCOPE OF RESEARCH

Simple formulation of the Horizontal Slice Method comprises (2N+1) unknowns and

(2N+1) equations by Shahgholi et al. (2001) are used in slope stability analysis. The simple

formulation only considered the vertical equilibrium for individual slices together with overall

horizontal equilibrium for the whole wedge, no account being taken for moment equilibrium.

The scenario such as pore pressure will be considered in the formulation. Type of reinforcing

material for slope will be focused on geotextile. Microsoft Excel 2007 will be used to design

the spreadsheet for stability analysis on reinforced slope with geotextile. Validation work using

Plaxis version 8 is carried out to test the reliability of the spreadsheet.

1.4 THESIS OUTLINE

Chapter 1 covered problem statement, aim and objectives and scope of work. This chapter

explained the problem encountered in the calculation of reinforced slope through the

conventional Vertical Slice Method. A new method known as Horizontal Slice Method has

been identified to resolve this problem.

Chapter 2 covered the literature review done for the Vertical Slice Method and its

limitation in reinforced slope analysis, Horizontal Slice Method and the simplified formulation,

application of HSM in reinforced slope in the past research and detail of geotextile material.

Chapter 3 covered the procedure undertaken to achieve the objectives of the study. A flow

chart showed the overall process to conduct the study. Formulation of mathematical equation

for stability analysis on reinforced slope with geotextile by applying Horizontal Slice Method

Page 16: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

4

was carried out in this chapter. Reinforcement force was analysed and calculated. Explanation

on the development of the spreadsheet was done.

Chapter 4 covered the analysis of the validation work and explanation of the designed

spreadsheet.

Chapter 5 covered the conclusion of the overall study that had been made.

Page 17: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

5

CHAPTER 2

2 LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 SLOPE STABILITY ANALYSIS

2.1.1 Factor of Safety

Factor of safety for a slope is defined as shear strength of soil divided by the shear stress

developed along the potential failure of surface. If the shear stress of the soil along the potential

failure surface is more than the shear strength of soil, the slope will fail. This happens when the

factor of safety is less than 1. Meanwhile, factor of safety of 1 indicates the slope is in critical

condition. For a stable and safe slope, the factor of safety is more than 1.

FOS =shear strength of soil, Tf

shear stress developed along the potential failure surface,Td (Equation 2.1)

There are two methods used to analyse the factor of safety for a slope. The first method

is called limit equilibrium method and the second is called finite element method.

Page 18: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

6

2.1.2 Limit Equilibrium Method

Limit equilibrium method can be divided into two major classes. The first class

considers the equilibrium of the whole failing mass above the surface of sliding. This method

is merely suitable to analyse the slope which is formed by homogeneous soil. In the second

class, the soil above the surface of sliding is divided into a number of vertical parallel slices.

The stability of each slice is calculated separately. This is a method in which the non-

homogeneity of soil and pore water pressure can be taken into consideration. It also takes

account for the variation of the normal stress along the potential failure surface.

Limit equilibrium method consists of several methods of analysis as summarised in

Table 2.1. These methods search for the most critical slip surface that gives the minimum factor

of safety. The differences between these methods are each method need to make an assumption

for the shape of the sliding wedge whether circular, plane, etc. and satisfy the equilibrium

equation either for force, moment and both.

Table 2.1: Method of Limit Equilibrium

Limit Equilibrium Method Developer Description

Ordinary method of slices Fellenius, 1936 The simplest method where the resultant

of inter-slice forces is parallel to the

average inclination of the slice.

Bishop Method Bishop, 1955 The resultant of inter-slice forces is

assumed to be equal and opposite.

Morgenstern-Price Method Morgenstern-Price,

1965

The inclination of inter-slice resultant

forces is assumed to be varied based on

selected part.

Janbu Method Janbu, 1968 Resultant of inter-slice shear forces is

assumed where the correction factor is

taken into account.

Spencer Method Spencer, 1967

& 1968

The resultant inter-slice forces are

assumed to be constant.

Page 19: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

7

2.1.3 Finite Element Method

Finite element method is an effective method which is an alternative to the limit

equilibrium method. This method is widely used nowadays. The advantage of this method is

that no assumption needs to be made in advance about the shape or location of the failure surface,

slice side forces and their directions. This method can be applied to complex slope

configurations and soil deposits in two or three dimensions to model virtually all types of

mechanisms. The equilibrium stresses, strains and the associated shear strengths in the soil mass

can be computed very accurately. This method can be extended to account for seepage induced

failure.

Generally, finite element method consists of two approaches. One approach is to

increase the gravity load until the slope fails. In this approach, the ratio of the gravitational

acceleration in failure time and actual gravitational acceleration is used to determine the safety

factor of the slope. Another approach is to reduce the strength characteristics of the soil mass

until slope fails. The safety factor is determined when the actual strength parameters divided

with the critical strength parameters.

Page 20: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

8

2.2 VERTICAL SLICE METHOD AND ITS LIMITATION

Vertical slice method is one of the limit equilibrium method used in slope stability

analysis. This vertical slice method has been traditionally used to analyze the stability of slopes

with or without reinforcements. The method can be used to analyze both circular and general

slip surface. It can satisfy both force and moment equilibrium.

In this method, a sliding soil wedge is divided into a number of vertical slices, and the

equilibrium of the individual slice is considered during the analysis. Figure 2.1 shows a sliding

soil wedge of an embankment without any reinforcement and the notations for the figure are

shown in Table 2.2. A typical slice with the forces that act on it are shown in Figure 2.2 and the

notations for the figure are shown in Table 2.3.

Figure 2.1: Traditional Method of Slice

r sin α

r

l

h

b

α

O

Page 21: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

9

Table 2.2: Notations for Figure 2.1

Symbol Definition

Α Angle of base of slice

B Length of base of slice

H Vertical distance between any point in soil mass and external

border of soil mass

L Length of vertical slice

R Radius

O Centre of rotation

Figure2.2: Forces Acting at A Typical Vertical Slice

Table 2.3: Notations for Figure 2.2

Symbol Definition

HA, HB Horizontal inter-slice forces

N Normal force upon base of slice

S Shear force upon base of slice

VA, VB Vertical inter-slice forces

W Weight of slice

N α

W

HB

S

α

HA VB

VA

Page 22: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

10

Table 2.4 shows a list of governing equations and unknown parameters in the vertical

slice method of analysis. From Table 2.4, it can be concluded that the number of unknown

parameters (6N-2) is greater than the number of equations (4N + 3). Thus, further simplified

assumptions need to be made to reduce the number of unknowns.

Table 2.4: Equations and Unknowns of Vertical Slice Method of Analysis

(Shahgholi et al., 2001)

Equations Number Unknowns Number

∑Fx = 0 (each slice) N Horizontal inter-slice forces N -1

∑Fy = 0 (each slice) N Vertical inter-slice forces N -1

∑M = 0 (each slice) N Normal forces upon base of each

slice.

N

Trequired =Tfailure

FS (each

slice)

N Shear forces upon base of each slice. N

Equilibrium equations for

whole mass

3 Location of horizontal inter-slice

forces

N-1

Location of shear and normal forces

upon base of each slice.

N-1

Factor of safety 1

Sum 4N + 3 Sum 6N - 2

In the analysis of the reinforced soil slope, the tension force (Tj) from the reinforcing

material needs to be considered. These forces are usually acted horizontally due to its method

of construction and its usual orientation of the reinforcement. In Figure 2.3, it can be observed

that the orientation has a direct influence on the inter-slice forces, therefore the tension forces

of the reinforcement are additional unknowns in the vertical slice method of analysis. As a

Page 23: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

11

result the vertical slice method is not particularly suited to the analysis of reinforced soil slopes

(Shahgholi et al., 2001). Table 2.5 shows the notations for Figure 2.3.

Figure 2.3: Forces Developed on A Single Vertical Slice Containing Reinforcement

Table 2.5: Notations for Figure 2.3

Symbol Definition

Hj, Hj+1 Horizontal inter-slice force

Vj, Vj+1 Vertical inter-slice force

Nj Normal force upon base of slice

Sj Shear force upon base of slice

Tj, Tj+1, Tj+2 Tensile force of reinforcement

ΔTj+1 Change in tensile force of reinforcement

Tj+2–ΔTj+2

Tj+1–ΔTj+1

Tj–ΔTj

Tj+2

Tj+1

Tj

Hj+1

Vj+1 Vj

Sj

Nj

Hj

Page 24: Faculty of Engineering - Universiti Malaysia Sarawak OF HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD ON... · tetulang. Pengiraan telah direka menggunakan Microsoft Excel 2007. Terdapat empat seksyen

12

2.3 HORIZONTAL SLICE METHOD

2.3.1 Horizontal Slice Method and the Basic Assumptions

Shahgholi et al. (2001) had introduced the horizontal slice method in the reinforced

slope analysis to solve the limitation of vertical slice method. The idea of using horizontal slices

was also proposed by Lo & Xu (1992) (Nouri et al., 2006). In this method, the sliding soil

wedge is divided into a number of horizontal slices and the orientation of the reinforcing

elements still maintain as horizontal as shown in Figure 2.4. A single horizontal slice containing

reinforcement as shown in Figure 2.5 is extracted from the sliding soil wedge as shown in

Figure 2.4 and Table 2.6 shows the notations for Figure 2.5. It can be observed that no inter-

slice forces are generated by the reinforcing element for this method. The advantages of this

approach include simplification of the analytical procedures and less numerical effort.

In the horizontal slice method, Shahgholi et al. (2001) had made the following

assumptions during the stability analysis:

(i) The vertical stress on an element in the soil mass is equal to the overburden

pressure.

(ii) The factor of safety (FOS) is equal to the ratio of the available shear resistance

to the required shear resistance along the failure surface.

(iii) The factor of safety for all slices is equal.

(iv) The failure surface can have any arbitrary shape, but it does not pass below the

toe of the slope and wall.