GRAND CHAMBER CASE OF M.S.S. v. BELGIUM AND GREECE (Application no. 30696/09) JUDGMENT STRASBOURG 21 January 2011 This judg ment is f inal but may be subject to editorial revision. http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/viewhbkm.asp?sessionId=65524330&... 1 sur 71 25/01/2011 10:22
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 1/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 2/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 3/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 4/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 5/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 6/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 7/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 8/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 9/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 10/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 11/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 12/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 13/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 14/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 15/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 16/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 17/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 18/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 19/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 20/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 21/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 22/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 23/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 24/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 25/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 26/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 27/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 28/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 29/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 30/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 31/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 32/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 33/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 34/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 35/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 36/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 37/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 38/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 39/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 40/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 41/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 42/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 43/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 44/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 45/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 46/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 47/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 48/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 49/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 50/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 51/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 52/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 53/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 54/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 55/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 56/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 57/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 58/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 59/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 60/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 61/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 62/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 63/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 64/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 65/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 66/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 67/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 68/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 69/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 70/71
8/7/2019 ECtHR 30696/09 21jan11 - MSS v Belgiumm & Greece: EU DublinII Regulation, Art. 3 & 13 ECHR
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ecthr-3069609-21jan11-mss-v-belgiumm-greece-eu-dublinii-regulation-art 71/71
Related Documents
