ECE 415/515 ANALOG INTEGRATED CIRCUIT DESIGN...RESISTIVE CM-DETECTOR: COMPENSATION 1 • Miller compensation of the CMFB loop using C c,CM • Two ways to place the compensation cap

ECE 415/515 –ANALOG INTEGRATED CIRCUIT DESIGN

FULLY-DIFFERENTIAL OPAMP DESIGN AND SIMULATION

© Vishal Saxena

OPAMP DESIGN PROJECT

VCM

vin/2

-vin/2

R1

R1

R2

R2

CL

CL

VCMvout

VCM

vin

CL

RL

vout

(a) (b)

ECE415/EO ECE515

© Vishal Saxena 2017

FULLY-DIFFERENTIAL (FD) OPAMPS

• Differential output is 𝑣𝑜𝑢𝑡 = 𝑣𝑜𝑝 − 𝑣𝑜𝑚 for differential

input 𝑣𝑖𝑛 = 𝑣𝑖𝑛𝑝 − 𝑣𝑖𝑛𝑚

• Common-mode (CM) output is 𝑣𝑜𝑢𝑡,𝐶𝑀 =𝑣𝑜𝑝+𝑣𝑜𝑚

2

• Output CM-level must be held constant to a well-

defined value (VCM)

• Common-mode feedback (CMFB) loop to control the output CM-level

• Implemented using continuous-time (CT) or using switched-capacitor (SC) circuits

CMFB

VCM

VCMFB

CL

CLvinm

vinp

vop

vom

CMFB: BASIC IDEA

CMFB loop compensation CM equivalent circuit

CMFB

VCM

VCMFB

CL

CLvinm

vinp

vop

vom

VDD VDD

vinp vinm

vopvom

VCMVCMFB

VDD

vin,CMM1 M2

M3 M4

M5 M6

VbiasnVbiasn

Cc,CM

VCM

vo,CM=M1,2

M5,6

M3,4

1

2

(a) (b)

CM

Detector

Cc,CM

VCMFBvop+vom

2

vop+vom

2

CMFB

CMFB

CM

Detector

RESISTIVE CM-DETECTOR

• Resistance (RCM) averaging circuit senses 𝑣𝑜𝑢𝑡,𝐶𝑀 =

𝑣𝑜𝑝+𝑣𝑜𝑚

2

• A capacitive averaging network

(CCM) in parallel for high-frequency

averaging

• Mitigates bandwidth limitation due to RCMCin,p

• 𝑣𝑜,𝑐𝑚 =𝑣𝑜𝑝+𝑣𝑜𝑚

2

2𝐶CM

2𝐶CM+𝐶

1

• 𝑖𝑐1 =𝑔𝑚𝑐1

2𝑣𝑜,𝑐𝑚 − 𝑉𝐶𝑀 Resistive CM-detector

with error amplifier CM equivalent circuit

vo,CM

(b)

CCM

VCM

VCMFB

RCM CCM

vop

vom

RCM/2

2CCM

vo,CM

VCM

ACM ACM

RCM

(a)

VCMFB

VDD VDD

Mc1 Mc2

Mc4

VCMFB

Vbiasn

Mc3

Mc0

VCMvo,CM

RESISTIVE CM-DETECTOR: COMPENSATION 1

• Miller compensation of the CMFB loop using Cc,CM

• Two ways to place the compensation cap between nodes 1 and 2.

CMFB loop compensation CM equivalent circuitUnlabeled NMOS are 10/2.

Unlabeled PMOS are 22/2.

VDD VDD

vinp vinm

vopvom

VDD

vin,CMM1 M2

M3 M4

M5 M6

Vbiasn

Vbiasn

vo,CM

M1,2

M5,6

M3,4

1

2

(a) (b)

RCM CCM

VCM

VCMFB

RCM CCM

vop

VCMFB

vom

Cc,CM

RCM/2

2CCM

vo,CM

VCM

VCMFB

Cc,CM

ACM

ACM

RESISTIVE CM-DETECTOR: COMPENSATION 2

• Note that zero-nulling resistor is not shown in these slides, but is used in

designs

CMFB loop compensation CM equivalent circuitUnlabeled NMOS are 10/2.

Unlabeled PMOS are 22/2.

VDD VDD

vinp vinm

vopvom

VDD

vin,CMM1 M2

M3 M4

M5 M6

Vbiasn

Vbiasn

vo,CM

M1,2

M5,6

M3,4

1

2

(a) (b)

RCM CCM

VCM

VCMFB

RCM CCM

vop

VCMFB

vom

RCM/2

2CCM

vo,CM

VCM

VCMFB

Cc,CM

Cc,CM/2 Cc,CM/2

ACM

ACM

DUAL-DIFF-PAIR (DDP) CM-DETECTOR

▪ 𝑖𝑐1 =𝑔𝑚𝑐1

2(𝑣𝑜𝑝+𝑣𝑜𝑚

2) − 𝑉𝐶𝑀

▪ =𝑔𝑚𝑐1

2

𝑣𝑜𝑝

2−

𝑉𝐶𝑀

2+

𝑔𝑚𝑐1

2

𝑣𝑜𝑚

2−

𝑉𝐶𝑀

2

▪ =𝑔𝑚𝑐1

4𝑣𝑜𝑝 − 𝑉𝐶𝑀 +

𝑔𝑚𝑐1

4(𝑣𝑜𝑚 − 𝑉𝐶𝑀)

Diff-pair Diff-pair

Unlabeled NMOS are 10/2.Unlabeled PMOS are 22/2.

VDD VDD

VCMFB

VCM VCMvomvop

5

25

2

5

2

5

2

Vbiasn

VCMFBVCM

vop

vom

Symbol

(a) (b)

5

2 5

2

Mc11

2

Mc01

2

ACM

Quiz: Diff-How does the dual diff-pair (DDP) look in CM-equivalent circuit?

DUAL-DIFF-PAIR CMFB COMPENSATION

CMFB loop compensation

CM equivalent circuitUnlabeled NMOS are 10/2.

Unlabeled PMOS are 22/2.

VDD VDD

vinp vinm

vop

vom

Cc,CM/2

VCM

VCMFB

VDD

vin,CMM1 M2

M3 M4

M5 M6

Vbiasn

Vbiasn

Cc,CM

Cc,CM/2

VCM

vo,CM

M1,2

M5,6

M3,4

1

2

(a) (b)

ACM

ACM

ASIDE: TWO-STAGE LOOP STABILITY (1)

• Two-stage feedback loop should ensure overall negative feedback

• Only one gain-stage can be negative

• Two possible configurations by interchanging polarities

Cc

Gm2

Gm1

C1

C2

vd

vd

vin

vin

voutvout

ASIDE: TWO-STAGE LOOP STABILITY (2)

• From loop-analysis, the negative transconductance should have larger Gm for

stability (Important!)

Cc

Gm2

Gm1

C1

C2

vout

Cc

Gm2

Gm1

C1

C2

vout

+ve gain

-ve gain

-ve gain

+ve gain

Doesn’t work if

Gm2>Gm1

• Results in LHP poles if Gm2>Gm1 • Results in RHP pole(s) if Gm2>Gm1. Unstable!

CMFB LOOP STABILITY (1)

CM equivalent circuit

VDD

vin,CM

Vbiasn

Cc,CM

VCM

vo,CM

M1,2

M5,6

M3,4

1

2

(a)

ACMCc,CM

Gmc

Gm1

C1

C2

(b)

• We have 𝐺𝑚𝑐 < 𝐺𝑚1 by design

(Ic0=I0/n)

• Gm1 should have negative

polarity for stability!

• Gmc would have positive gain

across it

• Overall negative feedback in

the CMFB loop

Reduced circuit

Gm1>Gmc

CMFB LOOP STABILITY (2)

CM equivalent circuit

VDD

vin,CM

Vbiasn

Cc,CM

VCM

vo,CM

M1,2

M5,6

M3,4

1

2

(a)

ACMCc,CM

Gmc

Gm1

C1

C2

(b)

• CMFB unity-gain frequency

𝜔𝑢,𝐶𝑀𝐹𝐵 ≈𝐺𝑚𝑐𝐶𝐶,𝐶𝑀

• Note that here Gmc≡gm1 and

Gm1≡gm2 in the pole-splitting

equations, as we had gm2>gm1 in

the pole-splitting derivation

• The CMFB loop-gain

𝐴𝑣,𝐶𝑀 = 𝐺𝑚𝑐𝑅𝑐𝐺𝑚1𝑅1

• Should be large enough to ensure

small DC error

Reduced circuit

Gm1>Gmc

SIZING OF THE CMFB ERROR AMPLIFIER

• The error amplifier circuit should be

a replica of the gain stage

• Bias current Ic0 and widths are

scaled down to save power (Ic0=I0/n)

• Both the stages should have the

same current density

•𝐼0/2

𝑊3,4=

𝐼𝑐0/2

𝑊𝑐3,4

• Ensures that M3,4 and Mc3,4 will have

the same VSG values

• Otherwise, any mismatch in bias

voltages will lead to systematic offset

in the CMFB loop

VDD VDD

vip vim

vopvom

M1 M2

M3 M4

VCMFB

M0

Vbiasn

VDD VDD

VCMMc1 Mc2

Mc3 Mc4

Mc0

VbiasnI0 Ic0

RCM

CCM

RCM

CCM

vop

vom

vo,CM

SIZING OF THE DDP CM-DETECTOR

• Same ideas for the DDP

CM-detector

• Both stages should have

the same current density

•𝐼0/2

𝑊3,4=

𝐼𝑐0/2

𝑊𝑐3,4

• Ensures that M3,4 and

Mc3,4 will have the same

VSG values

• Otherwise, any mismatch

in bias voltages will lead

to systematic offset in the

CMFB loop

VDD VDD

vip vim

vopvom

M1 M2

M3 M4

VCMFB

M0

VbiasnI0

VDD VDD

VCM VCMvomvop

Vbiasn

Mc1

Mc0Ic0

1

2Ic0

1

21

2

1

2

Mc3

COMPARISONResistive CM Detector

• Unrestricted input range

• Rail-to-rail operation ☺

• RCM loads the differential gain stage

and reduces its gain

Dual-Diff-Pair CM Detector

• Limited by input CMR of the diff-pair

• Allows very limited voltage swing

• Only small capacitive load ☺

VDD VDD

VCMFB

VCM VCMvomvop

5

25

2

5

2

5

2

Vbiasn

(a)

5

2 5

2

Mc11

2

Mc01

2

CCM

VCM

VCMFB

RCM CCM

vop

vom

vo,CM

ACM

RCM

TWO-STAGE FULLY-DIFFERENTIAL

OPAMPS

TWO-STAGE FD OPAMP

• What is the best strategy to set the CM-level at the output of both gain stages?

Block Diagram

VDD VDD

vim vip

vom1

M1 M2

M3 M4

M0L M0R

Vbiasn

VDD

vop

M5

M6

vop1

VDD

vom

M7

M8

I0I0 I2I2

Cc,DMCc,DM

vop

vom

vp

vm

vom1

vop1

Cc,DM

Cc,DM

TWO-STAGE FD OPAMP CMFB (1)

• Employ individual CMFB loops for each of the gain stages (robust scheme)

• 1st stage (high-gain) mustn’t be loaded → Dual diff-pair CM-detector

• 2nd stage should allow large output swing → Resistive CM-detector

Block Diagram

vop

vom

vp

vm

vom1

vop1

Cc,DM

Cc,DM

CMFB1

VCM1

VCMFB1

CMFB2

VCM2

VCMFB2

TWO-STAGE FD OPAMP CMFB (2)

• What are the reasonable voltages for VCM1 and VCM2?

• VCM1 sets the bias for the second gain stage (=Vbiasp in our example)

• VCM2 is the output CM-level and is dictated by the overall application circuit

• VDD/2 is commonly used to allow maximum output swing

Block Diagram

vop

vom

vp

vm

vom1

vop1

Cc,DM

Cc,DM

CMFB1

VCM1

VCMFB1

CMFB2

VCM2

VCMFB2

TWO-STAGE FD OPAMP CMFB (3)

VDD VDD

vim vip

vom1

M1 M2

M3 M4

M0L M0R

Vbiasn

VDD

vop

M5

M6

vop1

VDD

vom

M7

M8

I0I0 I2I2

Cc,DMCc,DM

Cc,C

M1/2

VC

M1

Cc,C

M1/2

CCM

VCM2

VCMFB2

RCM

CCM

vo,CM

RCM

VCMFB1

vop

vom

vp

vm

vom1

vop1

Cc,DM

Cc,DM

CMFB1

VCM1

VCMFB1

CMFB2

VCM2

VCMFB2

Block Diagram

TWO-STAGE FD OPAMP: SINGLE-LOOP CMFB (1)

• What if we just have one CMFB loop wrapped around both the gain stages?

vop

vom

vp

vm

vom1

vop1

Cc,DM

Cc,DM

CMFB

VCM

VCMFB

Block Diagram

VDD VDD

vim vip

vom1

M1 M2

M3 M4

M0L M0R

Vbiasn

VDD

vop

M5

M6

vop1

VDD

vom

M7

M8

I0I0 I2I2

Cc,DMCc,DM

VCMFB

VCM

RCM

CCM

vomvop RCM

CCM

Vbiasn

TWO-STAGE FD OPAMP: SINGLE-LOOP CMFB (2)• 3 low-frequency poles in the CM-

equivalent circuit

• Need to compensate like a three-stage

Opamp (higher complexity)

• Solution: Get rid of one of the high-

impedance nodes to move the pole to

higher frequencies

VDD

vip M1,2

M3,4

M0

Vbiasn

VDD

M5,7

M6,8

Cc,DM

VCMFB

2

RCM/2

2CCM

VCM

ACM

1

3

Common-mode Equivalent Circuit

TWO-STAGE FD OPAMP: SINGLE-LOOP CMFB (3)• Use diode-connected load in the

error amp

• low gain, ACM~1

• Only two low-f poles ☺

• Loop provides large CMFB gain

• DM compensation caps compensate

the CMFB as well

• Only control knob is n: Ic0=I0/n

• See notes for detailed analysis

• Use same current density in the error

amp, as the two gain stages

• Not as robust against PVT variationsCommon-mode

Equivalent Circuit

VDD

vip M1,2

M3,4

M0

Vbiasn

VDD

M5,7

M6,8

2Cc

VCMFB

2

RCM/2

2CCM

1

VDD VDD

VCMMc1 Mc2

Mc3 Mc4

Mc0

VbiasnIc0

I0 I2

TWO-STAGE CLASS-AB FD OPAMPS (1)VDD VDD

vim vip

vom1

M1 M2

M3 M4

M0L M0R

Vbiasn

VDD

vop

M5

M9

vop1

Cc,DMVDD

M8

VDD

vom

M10

M14

Cc,DMVDD

M13

M7

M6

M12

M11

I2

I0Ix

vop

vom

vp

vm

vom1

vop1

Cc,DM

Cc,DM

Block Diagram

• Note the crisscross biasing for the pseudo Class-AB (push-pull) output stage

• Diode-connected M7,12 are added to decouple VGS9,14 from M6,11

• Ix is minimized to save power (but use same current density in all branches)

TWO-STAGE CLASS-AB FD OPAMPS (2)• 1st stage CM-level can be set

using the DDP CM-detector

• How to set the output CM-

level for the 2nd stage?

• Note that the previous CMFB

method was suitable only for

Class-A stage!

• Need creative ways of controlling the output CM-level

VDD VDD

vim vip

vom1

M1 M2

M3 M4

M0L M0R

Vbiasn

VDD

vop

M5

M9

vop1

Cc,DMVDD

M8

VDD

vom

M10

M14

Cc,DMVDD

M13

M7

M6

M12

M11

I2

I0Ix

Cc,C

M1/2

VCM1

Cc,C

M1/2

VCMFB1

CLASS-AB STAGE CMFB METHODS• Several methods have been developed and tried

• Passive feedback using resistors

• CMFB based on Current-injection

• Triode-device based CMFB

• You can come up with your own!

CLASS-AB CMFB: CURRENT INJECTION (1)

vop

vom

vp

vm

vom1

vop1

Cc,DM

Cc,DM

CMFB2

VCM2

CMFB1

VCM1

VCMFB1

VCMFB1

• Two-independent CMFB loops

• Inject or remove DC current from the output stage to set its out CM-level

• Elegant scheme

Block Diagram

CLASS-AB CMFB: CURRENT INJECTION (2)VDD VDD

vim vip

vom1

M1 M2

M3 M4

M0L M0R

Vbiasn

VDD

vop

M5

M9

vop1

Cc,DMVDD

M8

VDD

vom

M10

M14

Cc,DMVDD

M13

M7

M6

M12

M11

2I2

I0

VDD VDD

M16 M15

vopvom

CCM

RCM

CCM

RCM

Cc,CM/2Cc,CM/2

VCMFB1

VCMFB2

1.5I2

VCM2

0.5I2 0.5I2

2I2

1.5I2

I0

• A ¼ current branch injects/removes current into/from the output nodes to

control their CM-level

• 3:1 DC current split for I2 used to avoid potential instability (see paper)

CLASS-AB CMFB: TRIODE-DEVICE (1)

• TBD

FULLY-DIFFERENTIAL OPAMP

SIMULATION

CMDM PROBE

• Located in Spectre library: AnalogLib→cmdmprobe

• Variable CMDM needs to be set in he model

▪ -1 measures differential mode response

▪ +1 measures common mode response

• In IC615, diffstbprobe is available which handles unbalanced differential circuits

better than the cmdmprobe.

• More information on the differential probes and the STB analysis algorithm can be

found in [4].

FULLY DIFFERENTIAL CIRCUIT ANALYSIS• Use CMDM probe for differential analysis [1, 3]

• Placement of the CMDM probe should break the differential as well the common-mode loop(s).

Vcmfb

CMFB

vCM

vop

vom

R2

R2

R1

R1 CL

CL

“analogLib/cmdmprobe”

CMDM = -1 measures DM

CMDM = 1 measures CM

FD CIRCUIT ANALYSIS SETUP 1• For internal loops, isolate those loops

individually and perform STB analysis

▪ Ensure overall DC feedback for accurate biasing, and ensure that all loops are compensated

▪ CMDM1 measures only the first-stage CM response

▪ CMDM2 measures overall DM response and second-stage CM response

Vcmfb1

CMFB1

vCM

vop

vom

R2

R2

R1

R1 CL

CL

vop1

vom1

A1 A2

Vcmfb2

CMFB2

CMDM1 CMDM2

CC

CC

Two-stage Opamp STB Analysis

FD CIRCUIT ANALYSIS SETUP 2• cmdmprobes placed outside DM

loop, only in CMFB loops

▪ CMDM1 measures only the first-stage CM response

▪ CMDM2 measures only the second-stage CM response

▪ But need another CMDM3 probe to measure DM loop stability

▪ Results match with iprobe results very well.

Vcmfb1

CMFB1

vCM

vop

vom

R2

R2

R1

R1 CL

CL

vop1

vom1

A1 A2

Vcmfb2

CMFB2

CMDM1 CMDM2

CC

CC

Two-stage Opamp STB Analysis

CMDM3

Fully Differential Opamp Schematic

Two-stage fully differential opamp Class AB output stage for large voltage swing With individual CMFB. 1st stage CMFB compensated

37

STB Analysis Using Method 1

Be noted that the nulling resistors should be connected before the inputs of cmdmprobe in the 1st CMFB loop, or it will generate incorrect results.

© Vishal Saxena and Venkatesh Acharya

38

STB Analysis Using Method 2

Need one extra cmdmprobe to measure DM loop comparing to method 1.

DM LOOP BODE PLOTS M1&M2

Differential Mode loop gain and phase margin plots Same results obtained by using Method 1 and Method 2

Method 1

1st Stage CMFB Loop Bode Plots

Method 2

2ND STAGE CMFB LOOP BODE PLOTS

Method 1 Method 2

SIMULATION SETUP

Use previous oppt (operating point) in the stb analysis

BODE PLOT SETUP

Results → Direct Plot → Main Form

DM TRANSIENT

Unity- gain inverting amplifier transient response with a 200mV differential step

(rise/fall time=0.1ns, pulse with=100ns)

CM TRANSIENT

Unity- gain inverting amplifier transient response with a 100mV common mode step (rise/fall

time=0.1ns, pulse with=100ns)

FULLY-DIFFERENTIAL OPAMP CMFB

EXAMPLES

REFERENCES1. The Designer’s Guide to SPICE and Spectre: http://www.designers-

guide.org/books/dg-spice/

2. Spectre User Simulation Guide, pages 160-165: http://www.designers-

guide.org/Forum/YaBB.pl?num=1170321868

3. M. Tian, V. Viswanathan, J. Hangtan, K. Kundert, “Striving for Small-Signal

Stability: Loop-based and Device-based Algorithms for Stability Analysis of

Linear Analog Circuits in the Frequency Domain,” Circuits and Devices, Jan

2001. http://www.kenkundert.com/docs/cd2001-01.pdf

4. https://secure.engr.oregonstate.edu/wiki/ams/index.php/Spectre/STB