Dreams Are What Le Cinema Is For: Five Desperate Women - 1971

FIVE DESPERATE WOMEN 1971lecinemadreams.blogspot.com/2013/10/five-desperate-women-1971.html

This camp-tastic treasure from my culturally misspent youth is high on retro '70s fashions, bitchy dialog, and TV-movie grade thrills.

Imagine, if you will, Mary McCarthy’s sorority sister soaper The Group, crossed with Friday the 13th, add a bit ofCharlie's Angels glamour (Aaron Spelling is also this film's producer), and toss a 1960s Ross Hunter "women inperil" melodrama into the mix, and you've got a pretty good idea of what’s in store for you with Five DesperateWomen (who can resist that title?). A minor entry in the beloved ABC Movie of the Week anthology series of made-for-TV movies that proliferated during the 1970s. The series produced a slew of amazingly durable motion picturesover the course of its seven years on the air, among them: Trilogy of Terror, Duel, Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark , SoAwful About Allan, Bad Ronald, and Reflections of Murder.These 90-minute movies, especially the thrillers, were ALWAYS the talk of my junior-high schoolyard the followingday, and I recall, at age 13, Five Desperate Women being a particular favorite – its high regard aided considerablyby our being too young and lacking in life experience to take much notice of the film’s timeworn clichés and obviousplotting.

1/10

Joan Hackett as Dorian

Julie Sommars as Mary Grace

Denise Nicholas as Joy

2/10

Stefanie Powers as Gloria

Anjanette Comer as Lucy

Five school chums, all graduates of Brindley, a tony private women’s college in the East, gather for a five yearreunion at a remote beach house on an island with no neighbors, no transportation and no phones. Armed only withtheir outsized hair, over-accessorized '70s fashions, and outré Samsonite® luggage (not a wheel or designer labelin sight), the friends are a virtual Who's Who of 70's television. There's sweet and mousy Julie Sommars (TheGovernor and J.J.) suffering a bad case of the guilts about leaving her controlling, mentally ill mother behind;incessantly gum-chewing wallflower Joan Hackett (a '70s TV movie staple, treading water a bit, having made her1966 film debut in The Group in a very similar role); self-reliant, black-power call girl Denise Nicholas (Room 222);big-haired, big city cynic, Stefanie Powers (The Girl from U.N.C.L.E.); and dipsomaniacal southern belle AnjanetteComer (who would work again with this film's director, Ted Post, in the 1973 cult oddity The Baby).

3/10

A weekend of rest, relaxation, and rehashing the past is on the agenda for the five diverse and high-strung women,whose only other companions on the island resort are the creepily geeky charter boat captain (Bradford Dillman),and the all-business, cloyingly sincere caretaker (Robert Conrad). Oh yes, and a homicidal maniac has recentlyescaped from a nearby mental institution—all secluded areas have nearby mental institutions—and is stalking thegrounds.

Thus, the mystery is set. Or at least one of them. The biggest one being how these five women ever became friendsin the first place. Once everybody starts airing their dirty laundry and copping to the fact that none of their lives hasturned out the way they had planned, the women waste little time in spending the bulk of their reunion time bitchilysniping at each other. A condition only exacerbated by frayed nerves and zero survival skills once the presence (notthe identity) of the killer becomes known and the women have to learn to rely upon one another.

"Special Guest Star" Robert Conrad as Michael Wylie

4/10

Bradford Dillman as Jim Meeker

The men don't behave much better. Short, stocky, Eveready Battery spokesman/Battle of the Network Starsbeefcake Robert Conrad, can't stop playing "Knock it off...I dare you!" with tall and lanky Bradford Dillman longenough to be of much help to anyone, let alone a house full of defenseless women burdened with anoverabundance of hair care products and a shortage of locks on the doors. The men don't trust one another, thewomen barely get along, and a killer is loose. How it all end?Viewed today, Five Desperate Women incites so many giggles at its own expense that it challenges one to imaginehow it was ever conceived as a serious thriller, but I must say, as an adolescent I found this movie to be VERYgripping and terrifically suspenseful. So much for the discerning tastes of youth.

The unintentional laughs start early with a scene in which put-upon rich girl Mary Grace is emotionally battered bythe passive-aggressive ventriloquist act engaged in by her silent mother and loudmouthed nurse. Hot on the heels ofthis comes the dockside reunion of the giggly sorority sisters wherein they sing a school song and southern-fried sotLucy, drops racist hints about affirmative-action charity case Joy, not really being “One of us….”

The Wild, Wild West 's Robert Conrad, who previously appearedwith co-star Stefanie Powers in the unforgettable Palm Springs

Weekend (1963), gets chummy with sweet-natured JulieSommars. Most people recall Sommars from the TV show,

Matlock, but she first caught my attention in the terrific comedy,The Pad and How to Use It (1966)

Once the women are ensconced on the island and the outbreaks of temperament erupt as regularly and abruptly asthe outbreaks of violence, Five Desperate Women - clocking in at a brisk 75 minutes - moves along so quickly one

5/10

scarcely minds the minimal drama and by-the-numbers thriller plotting. What does catch the attention is the risibledialog (“I buried the dog.” “[cheerily] Thank you!”); not-so-surprising personal revelations; and a screenplay (writtenby three men) which can’t think of a way to build tension without having five fully grown, college-educated womencarry on like sheltered adolescents at a summer camp.

Perpetually helpless, scared, and often absurdly overdressed (for her "escape" Denise Nicholas' character choosesan ensemble that features a cloche hat, midi vest jacket, hoop earrings big enough to throw a grapefruit through, andknee-high boots), these women quiver and quake while waiting to be victimized. They do traditional horror movie"girly" things like trip over brambles while running for their lives, demonstrating remarkably bad aim while throwingobjects to ward of an assailant, and wandering off to dark places alone. They all but run around in circles, shriekingand flapping their arms. Being terrified is one thing, but these women - surrounded by fireplace pokers and butcherknives – never once resort to grabbing some common household item for self-defense (OK, at one point one of themgrabs a shoe...but you see what I mean).

Posing for a fashion shoot? No, in this shot Denise Nicholas and Stefanie Powersare reacting to a grisly murder

6/10

Five Desperate Women moves at breakneck speed toward its not-wholly-unforeseen conclusion and the reveal ofthe killer's identity… a finale that finds one of the women being strangled while her friends have hysterics from thesidelines screaming at the manic to “Stop!” (that always works) for a good 30 seconds before it occurs to any ofthem that it might be a good idea to come to her aid.

If what I've written thus far has given the impression that Five Desperate Women is a film to be avoided, let mecorrect that error now. With apologies to TCM, Five Desperate Women is one of The Essentials: one of those rare,miraculous little films that exists simultaneously within the realm of good and bad. A film that pays countlessentertainment dividends whether taken seriously (for all it's faults, it's actually better than most of what is beingreleased in the horror/suspense genre these days) or viewed as retro camp.

WHAT I LOVE ABOUT THIS FILMAs stated before, Five Desperate Women is basically your average woman-in-peril suspense thriller - only taken tothe fifth power. There’s literally nothing here you haven’t seen a dozen times before in movies about a mad killer onthe loose in an isolated setting, the only difference: instead of one hysterical would-be victim, you have five. Onemight imagine this would lead to five times the suspense, but mostly it just translates to five times the screaminghysterics. Which is fine by me.

I'm not exactly feelin' it from Ms. Powers in this shot

PERFORMANCESThe late Joan Hackett as the forlorn Dorian is my absolute favorite in the film, but if, like me, you're already a fan ofher work, you'll note unfortunate echoes of similar roles she played in The Last of Shelia, The Group, Reflections ofMurder, and another college reunion TV movie, Class of '63. It's not that Hackett isn't excellent, no, she always is;it's just that she was horribly typecast throughout most of her career and directors rarely could see her as anythingbut the mousy, retiring victim. She was Oscar-nominated and won a Golden Globe for one of my least favorite of herperformances, the vainglorious socialite friend of Marsha Mason in Only When I Laugh (1981), but at least she wascast against type. Her rarely exploited gift for physical comedy can be seen to delightful effect in 1969's SupportYour Local Sheriff , a film for which I really think she deserved a nomination.

7/10

What really saves Five Desperate Women from complete TV-movie mediocrity is the masterstroke casting of two ofthe most splendidly idiosyncratic actresses of the '70s together in the same film. Joan Hackett is sensational, butAnjanette Comer (so great in The Loved One and The Appaloosa) almost steals the film as the skittish southernbelle Lucy.

THE STUFF OF FANTASYFive Desperate Women is a video catalog of all things '70s. You won't care a whit who the mad killer is becauseyour eyes will be popping out of your head from the fashion parade of mod MOD MOD fashions and positivelyenormous hairdos. You'll see minis, midis, maxis, hot pants, knickers, boots, huge studded belts, chokers, fringe,and halter tops. And lest we forget the boys, we have Robert Conrad traipsing about in his by-now-trademarkridiculously tight, bun-hugging pants and overstretched, pec-tacular T-shirts.

Smokin' & Drinkin' and Everything but Thinkin'One of the retro pleasures of this film is witnessing how much carefree smoking

and drinking goes on

8/10

THE STUFF OF DREAMSTwo favorite films from my youth that are infinitely better than Five Desperate Women but nevertheless alwaysremind me of this TV movie are: Five Gates to Hell (1959), a war film about of a group of army nurses having to fendoff a hoard of Indochinese guerrillas; and John Ford's last film Seven Women (1966), about the female residents ofa Chinese mission facing off Mongol bandits (featuring a kick-ass performance by Anne Bancroft). Although these"women banding together" movies never developed into an actual action film sub-genre, they are both notable andenjoyable for providing narratives in which women not only propel the plot, but play characters whose actions areinstrumental to their own survival.

Male-centric war movies and westerns always tend to bore me because of their reliance on archetypal machoposturing and one-note, stiff-jawed heroics. The need for male characters to always depict strength and assuranceso as to perpetuate society's narrow definition of masculinity has resulted in one woefully monotonous, action-oriented thriller after another. Conversely, female characters are allowed (sometimes to a fault, as this filmdemonstrates) the dimensionality of being able to display the gamut of human emotions, from weakness to bravery,in the carrying out of heroic acts...something I always find more engrossing than stoic fearlessness in the face of all. Five Desperate Women goes overboard in having the women characters evince too much in the way of unfetteredemotionalism (something I again must lay at the feet of the male screenwriters) , but at least it's a film in which thewomen eventually have to fend for themselves and are responsible for their own rescue. It looks awfully silly now,but back in 1971, the same year Helen Reddy's I Am Woman first came on the scene, Five Desperate Women (to a13-year-old who hadn't yet discovered the self-sufficient tough cookies of '40s film noir) looked very much like awomen's lib twist on the traditional suspense thriller.

9/10

Though we don't smoke and we don't drinkAnd though our hearts are pureThere's something about a rich man That's better than a poorRich fathers send your only sonsRich mothers send us your pearlsThough he may be your joyStill he's only a boy'Til he's been with a Brindley girl

Copyright © Ken Anderson

10/10