Distribution -' -- _ e <_> _,XMEG NMSS REBrowning WMEG/JCV/WAPPA LETTER MJBell LHBarrett - 1 - TCJohnson Tdungling JVoglewede EAWick FEB1 8 l95 HJMiller JGreeves Mr. Jeff 0. Neff, Manager JOBunting MNataraja Salt Repository Project Office LBHigginbotham U.S. Department of Energy JLinehan 505 King Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43201 MTokar Dear Mr. Neff: CHPeterson KCChang By letter dated November 28, 1983 (Ref. 1), the Office of Nuclear Waste Isolation transmitted a copy of the computer code WAPPA (Ref. 2) to the NRC. This code has now been implemented on a number of different computer systems by the NRC staff and its contractors. A number of coding changes were required in order to run this code on NRC's in-house computer system, a Data General MV/8000. Because the computer system is similar to the VAX 11/780 used by the Office of Nuclear Waste Isolation, the modifications may be of interest to the code developer. The list of the changes is included as an attachment to this letter in a form similar to the DIFFERENCE runs supplied by ONWI. It should be noted that these modifications deal primarily with compiler compatibility and not with the technical merits of the code. Our review of the Salt Repository Draft Environmental Assessments (e.g., Ref. 3), have indicated that the version of WAPPA used in the waste package performance assessment is considerably different from that originally provided by ONWI. The new version appears to be able to limit corrosion according to brine availability and to compute the radiation field at intermediate overpack thicknesses. Please provide us with a copy of the revised code (and related - documentation) when it becomes available. Technical questions regarding this request, or our modifications to the current NRC version of WAPPA, may be addressed to John C. Voglewede, Engineering Branch, Division of Waste Management (FTS 427-4275). Si ncerely, WM Record File Wim Project Sce "'-2 $; _ Docket No. PDR D -R LPDR2_e John J. Linehan Distribuflon: Salt Project Section Leader Repository Projects Branch ________ Division of Waste Management 'o 'rN'vE E23 SS) __ ____ cc: Leslie A. Scott, ONWI 0 O 4 85Oi 9 ' PDR__ _ _ _ YFC :WMEG : WME M NAME :JVoglewede:gh: TC 'Noh f An :::: DATE------- ------ --- : 02 - ----------- DATE :02/1'/85 02/t\/5:02 5 . . .
30
Embed
Distribution NMSS TCJohnson JVoglewede EAWick FEB1 l95 · 2012-11-19 · Distribution-' --_ e _,XMEG NMSS REBrowning WMEG/JCV/WAPPA LETTER MJBell LHBarrett-1 -TCJohnson
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Distribution
-' --_ e <_> _,XMEGNMSSREBrowning
WMEG/JCV/WAPPA LETTER MJBellLHBarrett
- 1 - TCJohnson TdunglingJVoglewede EAWick
FEB1 8 l95 HJMiller JGreevesMr. Jeff 0. Neff, Manager JOBunting MNatarajaSalt Repository Project Office LBHigginbothamU.S. Department of Energy JLinehan505 King Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43201 MTokar
Dear Mr. Neff: CHPetersonKCChang
By letter dated November 28, 1983 (Ref. 1), the Office of Nuclear WasteIsolation transmitted a copy of the computer code WAPPA (Ref. 2) to the NRC.This code has now been implemented on a number of different computer systems bythe NRC staff and its contractors.
A number of coding changes were required in order to run this code on NRC'sin-house computer system, a Data General MV/8000. Because the computer systemis similar to the VAX 11/780 used by the Office of Nuclear Waste Isolation, themodifications may be of interest to the code developer. The list of thechanges is included as an attachment to this letter in a form similar to theDIFFERENCE runs supplied by ONWI. It should be noted that these modificationsdeal primarily with compiler compatibility and not with the technical merits ofthe code.
Our review of the Salt Repository Draft Environmental Assessments (e.g.,Ref. 3), have indicated that the version of WAPPA used in the waste packageperformance assessment is considerably different from that originally providedby ONWI. The new version appears to be able to limit corrosion according tobrine availability and to compute the radiation field at intermediate overpackthicknesses. Please provide us with a copy of the revised code (and related
- documentation) when it becomes available. Technical questions regarding thisrequest, or our modifications to the current NRC version of WAPPA, may beaddressed to John C. Voglewede, Engineering Branch, Division of WasteManagement (FTS 427-4275).
Si ncerely,WM Record File Wim Project Sce
"'-2 $; _ Docket No.PDR D -R
LPDR2_e John J. LinehanDistribuflon: Salt Project Section Leader
Repository Projects Branch________ Division of Waste Management
'o 'rN'vE E23 SS) __ ____
cc: Leslie A. Scott, ONWI 0 O 4 85Oi 9
' PDR__ _ _ _
YFC :WMEG : WME M
NAME :JVoglewede:gh: TC 'Noh f An ::::DATE------- ------ --- : 02 - -----------
DATE :02/1'/85 02/t\/5:02 5 . . .
K)j
WMEG/JCV/WAPPA LETTER- 2 -
REFERENCES
1. George Jansen, Jr. (ONWI) letter to John T. Buckley (NRC) on "Transmittalof WAPPA Code to NRC" dated November 28, 1983.
2. WAPPA: A Waste Package Performance Assessment Code, ONWI-452, Office of NuclearWaste Isolation, Battelle Memorial Institute, Columbus, OH, April 1983.
3. Nuclear Waste Policy Act (Section 112), Draft Environmental Assessment,Deaf Smith County Site, Texas, U.S. Department of Energy ReportDOE/RW-0014, December 1984.
OFC :WMEG : WMEG :WMRP
NAME :JVoglewede:gh: TCJohnson :JLinehan :
DATE :02/ /85 : 02/ /85 :02/ /85
Code Transfer Form
* To: 7T .4' K~ŽJ•eY
md'i 6,7 / 1 X
K.O~ate:de O f
From: ONWIBattelle Project Management Division505 King AvenueColumbus, Ohio 43201Attention: I -e5 // . S deo z-- 614) 424-4326/7806
Subject:' Computer Modeling Technology Transfer* Model Namle . I /p o. QA NumberReference: Request for Transfer a- c r1 ,Intended Application
- --- 4 -0 Ael
Enclosed are the items as described below. Please.report to us your acceptanceof the materials, any problem encountered during your installation of the model andexecution of the benchmark test problem on your computer, and any problems you mayencounter or modifications you made which either correct problems or might be ofgeneral utility.
Model Tape File Index 1Documentation -; Title -_.
Model Tape Listing (Optional) Sj-
-Magnetic Tape
Unlabeled a1600 bpi a-;
(9-Track) [
Other ElOther n
EBCDIC CB; Other ElFiles 19 /, Blocksize / 3 d;. Record Length
Files / -4 /' , Blocksize I 1r _ .
Model Tape generated and files verified by _Transmittal Package reviewed and'approved by -
Transfer approved by I' b7y, : ' ' "
Record Length / 3f e
..7
,V6-P '~jjze S26a A".
(CC)(MG.R)
For Use by Recipient: (Please complete and return this orginal copy to ONWI) .
Above items accepted El1: Acceptance contingent El upon receipt of the following:
Comments:
Signed:
Date:
FILES CHARACTERS/RECORD CHARACTER'SiLOCK,
1-15 90 ~~~~~~~~136016-18 136 16
19 s0 13.u0
FILE NAME FILE UNIT FILE DE~SCRIPTION
UF'INDX I 42.0--20OC-02:SEOU'ENCE OF lJ'AS[E PACKACE WUAPPAi FILES CH TAPEhCODES 2) (7)-(LQCAT2'.)-SvSTEM-CCuPREHENSIVE LI STI OF DATABASE M:"TE.-:A'S
H 1.2 (5)- iF:F')LAC- AOFL :,~ "VSTNTP 1~ (?-~O'~ LEACH- NCL.HE TPNFC44--FRF TI!SI 14 I 1.)-!?UT F-DR S A-iFE --SI"F-LI F IED) F-R9LE r;WAF'PA IK 420--20C-0-21.: S-INGLE FILE ~FF'iA :uPP4.-;AOSI 16 OUTPUT FOR, SAMPLE !:ElFLIF iSlE,:EVAPPIA 1.7 DIFFEFRINCE FILE CDC 'SEP-.'A,VAF'PA 'IS DIFFEREqC-E FILE OLDt' I6TE '- EIOR.A~ NELI Tl, iT; JAZ
CDC jCL 19 JO? ETFREEAM :-F' TFE LC . TER
v)
I
FPHILT270;CM30ooo0.,AC=A32-B7-2002kJ KATTACH, T-AF:E1 WCHLI4.W IyI'=MOHL.ATTACHTAPE7,LOCAT2, I.E'~iiDHIL.'ATTACHPTAPE10FRPRP02vIff=NOHL.ATTACH,TAPES2,YWSOLUT3, IE'=MOHL#ATTACHTAFE21 ,REF'OST2tIE'=KOHL.ATT4CH, TAP~30qFP'FGF2'IV=M0HL.ATTACH, TAFE12,ITPROP3, ID=MOHL.i'YTTA(.HrAFE42,CORENC2, IE'MOHL.Ar rA':J*{,TAF'E~l ,WEPR0P2, ID=iil3HL.*;rTTA CHyT PsFE 1,F:At'IFAT3? Iri=MOHL .AT TAC Hi TAFPE AO 7 CTEMFS 2 ,Ili=KHL.Ar TA,,TAE1-TFF3 r=OLATT AC H,-TAPE2OlWFF'rolP. -It, =MOHL.PTT1 d>4itJA'EXE , I D= MCHL..EfPUEST.TAPE7I PPF.
A PE if~ E.i;(GILCI T A PE?71 , RE ST R T Iit' M OP.L F-=9 99 .
i
. X
K)j
BATTELLE PROJECT MANAGEMENT DIVISION
.PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT DEPARTMENT
COMPUTER MODEL REVISION NOTICE
Model Title WAPPA - A Waste Package Performance Assessment Code
ONWI Model Control Number, Revision Number fl
Supplier QA Identification Number Revision Number_ _
L,_Addition'of.Part of Model Addition to Data Set(s) of Model.ID.Partial Change to Model L Partical Change to Data Set(s) of ModelIDPartlal Chance to Document
Purpose of Revision:
Correct fatal logic errors in barrier failure sequence and revise some words inoutput format. See details.in attached list (memo by Phil Mohl-er). The need forthese changes and a list of them was transmitted to ONWI by INTERA just after thedocument ONWI-452 was finalized. The changes have been necessary in order to run.the code to packages failure with multiple.barriers that fail in different time steps.increase the dimensions of number of time steps from 30 to 400 so that more accurateintegrations of time varying quantities can be made. Convert the reference version ofthe WAPPA code from the CYBER 74 to the.VAX/WMS'l-80 computer.
Document Affected:
ONWI-452 WAPPA - A Waste Package Performance Assessment Code (1983)
Assessment of possible impact on results of analyses as compared to results obtained fromthe previous version of the model
No change in verification results, code also will now a o run for typicalmodeling input data.
CC THESE OPEU STATEMENTS AOE NEUEDcD TO RIJN ON THE VAX COMPUTERCC OPEN(tNIJ[T-1,FILEcpILt12,STATUS=-OLn'IC OPFNIlJNITT7,FILE-'FILE2',STATUs.t'aLD')
(* C tUPEfJ(WUIT=1'JFILE='FTLE3' 5TATJS-'OLDo'C I)PEN(IIjN!T-11FILE-'FILE4 ,STATtS-'OLD IC OPEN(UNIT=12,FILE='FILE5V,StATIJS-IOLDOI.C (IPEN(IUNIT=2IFILE-FILE6iStATUS-'nLI)D'
* C OPFN(UrJIT-30.FILE-'FILE7'iStATOSe'lLO 'IC )PENUtJIT-4ei,FILf-'FILE8'iStATIIS:'1LO'IC. C OPENIUNIT-41,FILE-=FILE4',STATUS-'OLD'I C
1 - C OPEN(tj)JIT= ,ZFLE=-'FLE1'm ST&TUS='OLI) I; C OPFN(UNIT=2CFTLE=IF!LEiiSTATUS=OnLn#
C OIPEN(UI4IT=51,FILE-'FILF12',STATUS-'.'0L0C OPENIUNIT=52,FILE=FILE13',STATUS-flnLn'IC OPEN(UNIT-.69,FILE-=FILE14,$TATt3S-UIJNKNOWNI
C C OPEN(UNIT-70,FILE-'FILE15' ,FORl-=UNFORMATTEO' STATUS=UNKNOWUNIC l)PENIUNIT-7LFILE-'FiLE1h!,FORM.'UNFflRMATTEBoSTATUS-'UNKNOWN'IC OPEN(U!JIT-79,FILE-'FILE17,STATUiS-NFW'
IIF(IFD.IAG.GT.Q)lWRITE(ir iG,7G2O37012 FikMAT(/tMOnEL COMMON SLUCK 'FIMATLRS)
o f IfIFDIAG.GT.91WRITE(IFOG,7i0(23 (1,1-1,61
i <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>C><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>.<><><>o FILE WAPPA.SnURCE 0/2395 TO 0/9397*i <><><><><><><><><><><><><><>C><><><><CC><><>><>C><><><><><><><><><<><><>
IF(fIF)IAG.GT.0)WRITErf IFOG,7203)7203 FORMAT(/'MODEL COMMON nLnCK 'FISTRS'"1
' IF(lFOIAG.GT.O)WRITE(IFnG,70(3) (1,1-1,6)
! (j FILE WAPPA.F77S9W, /92 T1 9/404; C ><><><><><><><><><)><><>)<><>>C><
IF(IFI)IAG.GT.O)WRITE(IFOG,720317205 FORMAT(/MOOEL COMMON RLOCK 'FISTLSW'I'
- l~~F(IFDIAG.GT.n}WRITE([FnG97OD3l (1,1-1,6)
< ><>c><><><><><><><><><><><>c<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><FILE WAPPA.S(]l7CF* 9 /9411 TO 0/0 413
C - SFE G. JANSEN LETTER TO J. BUCKLEY DATED I/ /28/ 83-C CC I.. VAX IL/7tihj REVISIONS WIT(4 CUIE PrEVISONiviC I I 2TER AWAP.FOR;4 FEB 25, 192 :00 I'M
C 2 LAHELFI) COMIMON IRADIOL' RENAMED 'RADIOM' III ALL)C LOCATIONS TO AVOID mAmE CONrLICT WITHi SUBROUTINEC 'RADIOL'.C
c c * '. LADkY I:I) CJNN't ITn LABEIN COMMOnjrN 'SOUTC'OF MAINRE TN
C AJR XtlFCr ATIENT TOII WAPPAN istI APPAENL NO'445)E T I
C 1.T~t11/7R ROUIEVS) ARE IITI CROVl)EFEI). Nd
C 4. - A 'LAHELNI) ClM N WEOLFL COMMOND RSAUlCN OF MANLL TN
C IS GIVEN ATTRIBUTE ChARACTEp'*Z (LINE 04W441 TO E CONSISTENTC WITh USAGE IN OTHER ROUITINES.
C 4. ARlAY 'ISNUMll' IN LABELED COMIttl lSlUTC' OF SUBROUTINECC 'SYSONP' IS GilVEN ATTRIBUTE ClIARACTER42 (LINE 3296) TO BE
1 c.~ C CONjS I S TENT IT II IISAGF IPt 1H 0 rI V UTIrS N Ail D IT I ON,- C LABELED) FORllAT SIATM--NT 211', HAS 11PFN CHAt;FI) FROM
IG I ' TO ' I0Al' Trl ACCIl s0;;ATI. tlE CIIARACTCP ATTRIIlWTE.
C o. ARRAY I SNUMJM IN LAtBELEI' CI)I:4)N SOUrC' tlF SU9 R9UTI IEC 'QSkTk.' IS GIVFN ATTRbIItIE CI4APACTEV*2 (LINE 6124) rO BEC CONS ISI1PIT WITH USAGE I OlTHER RrJHTINJES.
* CC 7. ARRAY 'ISNUNM' IN LABELID Co.Pim'N 'sfitiC' DF SuDROUTiNE
|C C $RSTRTz' IS GIVEN ATTRtIBUTE CIIAP.ACTER*2 ILINE 6447) TO IIEC CONSISTrNT WITH USAGE lJ uii-rU POUTIHlES.
i C-C d. LINE 131169 IN SUHROUTINL f TTFMP' HAS SEEN C!IANGED lACK TOC COC VCkSION (IF COOF TO AVO)ID SY!ITAX ERROPS.C (E.G. IIL = (SHTW,' / I)Phl *-1111) I
C. CC 9. FOP!IAT STATEMliNTS 7017, 72.'3 AND W0 5 1%I SUBROUTINE fMUODFLC HAVE ADDITIONAL WIJTATIUNI MARKS Tt) TRAN45MITQOUCITATOIIN MARKS.
ry CC lu. FORMAT STATEMENt 2091 ItN SIUROUTINE FELMTL IhaS ADDITIONALC QunTATION 1ARKS TO TRAtJSMIT OUCTATION MARKS.
*I..* C C.C I1. THE FOLLOWING SUBROUTINE CALLS HAVE BEEN MODIFIED TO FORCEC CALL lHY VALuE (RATHFR THANJ CALL BY NAME I OF DO-LOOlP INDICIES:C 0ATRED (LINE 19ll1) CUREAD (LINE 0937), SWPMAT (LINE 2467),C SWP`IAT (LINe 27241, SYSCtlK (LINFS 391'), 3942, 39749 4007,C ','39 AND 4071), FFRACM (LIN. 94491) FELMTrI (LINIES 9675 AND
; (* C 982el FELMTG (LINE 06761, FELMrL (LINES 9677 AND 96791,: C FEL.ITI (LINFS 9678 AND 98i5)
CC 12. CALLS TO 'TIME. AND 'DATE' II SUBROUTINE IHEADNG 11AVE BEENC CHANGED TO AGREE WITH LOCAL USAGE.CC 13. OPEW STATEMENTS NOW INCLUDE MAXIMUM RECORD LENGTHI AND PADC ATTRItIUTES.C(EhND OF FILE)