Top Banner
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS Slide # 31
62

DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

Feb 12, 2016

Download

Documents

season

DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS. Slide # 31. IV GANCICLOVIR. IV GCV is a first-line treatment for CMVR Approved in US in 1989 Current Indications treatment of CMVR in immunocompromised patients prevention of CMV disease in transplant patients at risk - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

Slide # 31

Page 2: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

IV GANCICLOVIR

IV GCV is a first-line treatment for CMVR Approved in US in 1989 Current Indications

– treatment of CMVR in immunocompromised patients

– prevention of CMV disease in transplant patients at risk

Well-described efficacy and safety profile

Slide # 32

Page 3: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

ORAL GANCICLOVIR

Oral GCV approved in US in 1994 Current Indications:

– maintenance treatment of CMVR in immunocompromised patients

– prevention of CMV disease in SOT patients & in HIV patients at risk

Limited by bioavailability (6%) and t.i.d. dosing regimen

Slide # 33

Page 4: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

Slide # 34

MECHANISM OF ACTION

ExtracellularIntracellular

GCV GCV-MP GCV-DP GCV-TP

CellularEnzymes

ViralProtein Kinase

(UL97)

Inhibits Viral DNA Polymerase (UL54)

Page 5: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

PRO-DRUG OF GANCICLOVIR

valganciclovir HCl ganciclovir

HN

N

O

H2N

N

NO

HO O

O

H2N

HCl HN

N

O

H2N

N

NO

HO OH

Slide # 35

Page 6: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

VALGANCICLOVIR KEY CHARACTERISTICS

GCV exposure (AUC) following 900 mg Val-GCV similar to IV GCV (5 mg/kg)

Bioavailability approx. 60% (10X higher than oral GCV)

< 2% of absorbed dose appears as valganciclovir in plasma (t1/2 1 hour)

450 mg film-coated tablet

Slide # 36

Page 7: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

COMPARATIVE GANCICLOVIR PK PROFILES

0.01

0.1

1

10

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Time (h)

Gan

cicl

ovir

Con

cent

ratio

n(ug

/mL)

GCV from VGCV(900mg) Oral GCV(1g t.i.d)i.v GCV(5mg/kg) Val-GCV from VGCV (900mg)

GANS2230

Slide # 37

Page 8: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

COMPARATIVE GANCICLOVIR PK PROFILES

0.01

0.1

1

10

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Time (h)

Gan

cicl

ovir

Con

cent

ratio

n(ug

/mL)

GCV from VGCV(900mg) Oral GCV(1g t.i.d)i.v GCV(5mg/kg) Val-GCV from VGCV (900mg)

GANS2230

Slide # 38

Page 9: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

COMPARATIVE GANCICLOVIR PK PROFILES

0.01

0.1

1

10

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Time (h)

Gan

cicl

ovir

Con

cent

ratio

n(ug

/mL)

GCV from VGCV(900mg) Oral GCV(1g t.i.d)i.v GCV(5mg/kg) Val-GCV from VGCV (900mg)

GANS2230 (IV & Oral GCV)WP15509 (GCV from Val-GCV)

Slide # 39

Page 10: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

COMPARATIVE PK: MEAN (%CV)

Dose AUC0-24(µg•h/mL)

Cmax(µg/mL)

Cmin(µg/mL)

Bioavail.

IV GCVGANS2230

n=16

5mg/kgq.d. 26.8 (23) 9.03 (16) 0.027*(181)

(n=15)NA

Oral GCVGANS2230

n=24

1gt.i.d. 13.0 (25) 0.975 (21) 0.2 (39) 6%

* Concentrations at 24h after single doseSlide # 40

Page 11: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

COMPARATIVE PK: MEAN (%CV)

Dose AUC0-24(µg•h/mL)

Cmax(µg/mL)

Cmin(µg/mL)

Bioavail.

IV GCVGANS2230

n=165mg/kg

q.d. 26.8 (23) 9.03 (16) 0.027*(181)(n=15)

NA

Oral GCVGANS2230

n=241g

t.i.d. 13.0 (25) 0.975 (21) 0.2 (39) 6%

Val-GCVWP15509

n=17

900mgq.d. 24.9 (18) 5.15 (22) 0.085*(56) 59%

* Concentrations at 24h after single doseSlide # 41

Page 12: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

PK/PD SUPPORTS GCV AUC AS CORRELATE OF EFFICACY

PK/PD explored in GANS2226- dose-ranging maintenance study- included IV and three oral GCV doses

Population PK approach (NONMEM)

AUC0-24 significantly correlated with efficacy (time to progression)

Slide # 42

Page 13: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

BASIS OF DOSE SELECTION

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

0 1000 2000 3000

Valganciclovir Dose (mg)

Gan

cicl

ovir

AU

C0-

24 (m

g.h/

mL)

900 mg Val-GCV achieves target AUC ( 26 mg•h/mL)

maintenance

induction

Slide # 43

Page 14: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

METABOLISM AND ELIMINATION

Rapid hydrolysis to GCV

Intestinal and hepatic esterases represent a high-capacity system

No other metabolites detected

GCV drug interactions applicable to Val-GCV

Renal impairment requires dose adjustment

Slide # 44

Page 15: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

DEVELOPMENT RATIONALE

Therapeutic alternative to IV GCV treatment of CMVR (induction and maintenance)

Avoidance of risks associated with IV access required for IV GCV therapy

Simple oral regimen that could improve patient adherence during maintenance treatment

The PK profile of GCV from Val-GCVprovided the potential for:

Slide # 45

Page 16: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

EARLY CHALLENGE

Pilot Study: potential efficacy in induction treatment– Enrollment initiated Jan,1997– Impact of HAART– 11/70 patients enrolled in 4 months

(17 sites)

Slide # 46

Page 17: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

From Kovacs JA and Masur H. N Engl J Med. 2000342: 1415-1429

IMPACT OF HAART

Slide # 47

Page 18: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMOverallN = 491

Therapeutic Studiesin AIDS Patients

N=372

Clinical PharmacologyStudiesN=119

Controlled StudyWV15376

N=160

Uncontrolled StudyWV15705

N=212

Multiple Dose StudyWP15347

N=39

Single-Dose andSpecial Population Studies

GANS2661, WP15509WP15511

N= 80

Transplant: PV16000 (n=121 as of Aug 31, 2000); WP15711 (n=28) Slide # 48

Page 19: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

BrazilAustralia

Mexico

Canada

FranceItaly

United States Germany

United Kingdom

Spain

PARTICIPATING COUNTRIES372 patients in 26 months (50 sites)

Slide # 49

Page 20: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Built on the proven efficacy of GCV Primary interest:

Comparison of Val-GCV and IV GCV efficacy & safety

Induction setting - highest efficacy hurdle for CMVR treatment

Slide # 50

Page 21: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

EFFICACY

Slide # 51

Page 22: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 STUDY DESIGN

900 mg bid 3 weeks900 mg qd 1 week

Week 4Baseline

5 mg/kg bid 3 weeks5 mg/kg qd 1 week

Randomize

IV Ganciclovir

Valganciclovir

RANDOMIZED PHASE EXTENSION

Valganciclovir

900 mg qdN = 160

Slide # 52

Page 23: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 PRIMARY ENDPOINT

Progression defined as movement 750 mm (along a 750 mm front ) or new retinitis lesion 750 mm diameter

Assessed by retinal photography

Proportion of Patients DemonstratingProgression of CMV Retinitis by Week 4

Slide # 53

Page 24: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

PHOTO ASSESSMENT METHODS

Full-field, bilateral photographs Central retinal photograph reading

center (independent) Scored by experienced grader

(masked) Scored: progression, distance of

border movement, border activity

Slide # 54

Page 25: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376: ANALYSIS CONSIDERATIONS

Non-inferiority is a standard statistical approach to address this

Non-inferiority test utilizes only the lower bound of confidence interval

Non-inferiority limit (d = -0.25) chosen to represent the limit of a clinically acceptable treatment group difference

Is efficacy of Val-GCV similar to (no worse than)

IV GCV for induction therapy?

Slide # 55

Page 26: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

ASSESSING NON-INFERIORITY

0Val-GCV No Worse than IV GCV

Treatment difference (Pg-Pv) - 0.25

d

Slide # 56

Page 27: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

ASSESSING NON-INFERIORITY (cont’d)

0

Treatment difference (Pg-Pv) - 0.25

d

(Hypothetical)

Slide # 57

Page 28: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

0Val-GCV No Worse than IV GCV

Treatment difference (Pg-Pv) - 0.25

d

ASSESSING NON-INFERIORITY (cont’d)

(Hypothetical)

Slide # 58

Page 29: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

ASSESSING NON-INFERIORITY (cont’d)

0Val-GCV No Worse than IV GCV

Treatment difference (Pg-Pv) - 0.25

d (WV15376 Results)

(Hypothetical)

Slide # 59

Page 30: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

BASELINE STATUS [1]

IV GCVn=80

Val-GCVn=80

Gender (M/F)

Age Median (yr)

73 / 7 72 / 8

37 39

EthnicityCaucasianHispanicBlackAsianOther

42 (53%)25 (30%) 9 (11%) 1 ( 1%) 3 ( 4%)

43 (54%)25 (30%) 9 (11%) 1 ( 1%) 2 ( 3%)

Slide # 60

Page 31: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

BASELINE STATUS [2]

IV GCVn=80

Val-GCVn=80

CD4 median (cells/mL)(range)

26(2-365)

20(2-390)

HIV Load, median (log) (range)

4.9(1.7-5.9)

4.8(1.7-5.9)

CMV Load, median (log) (range)

3.4(2.5-5.5)

3.6(2.6-4.8)

CMV-Positive Culture 65% (n = 46/71)

46% (n = 33/71)

CMV-Positive Plasma PCR 51% (n =39/76)

40% (n = 31/77)

Slide # 61

Page 32: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

BASELINE - HIV THERAPY

PI Use - ongoing/priorPI-Naïve 16 (20%) 16 (20%)

IV GCVn=80

Val-GCVn=80

No Anti-Retrovirals at entry 18 (23%) 17 (21%)

Anti-Retroviral-Naïve 7 ( 9%) 5 ( 6%)

Protease Inhibitors (PI) at entry 47 (59%) 53 (66%)

64 (80%) 64 (80%)

Slide # 62

Page 33: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

BASELINE RETINITIS

IV GCVn=80

Val-GCVn=80

19 (24%)Zone 1 19 (24%)Zone 2/3 55 (69%) 53 (66%)

Bilateral 20 (25%) 20 (25%)Unilateral 54 (68%) 52 (65%)

71 (89%) 68 (85%)Active Lesion Border

Slide # 63

Page 34: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

STUDY POPULATIONS

IV GCV Val-GCV

ITT - All Randomized 80 (100%) 80 (100%)

EFFICACY (STD) Population 73 ( 91%) 73 ( 91%)

- Subjects excluded 7 ( 9%) 7 ( 9%)

Slide # 64

Page 35: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

PRIMARY ENDPOINT(COMPARABLE EFFICACY AT WEEK 4)

IV GCVn=73

Val-GCVn=73

Photo Progression 7 7No Photo Progression 63 64Unevaluable 3 2

Proportion progressed 0.100 (10%) 0.099 (9.9%)

Difference 0.001 (0.1%)95% Confidence Interval (-0.097, 0.100)

Slide # 65

Page 36: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

PROGRESSION AT WEEK 4 BY CMVR ZONE AT BASELINE (PHOTO)

IV-GCV Val-GCV

Zone 1

Zone 2/3

Uneval.

Prog n=7

Non-Prog n=64

14 (88%)

48 (91%)

1

2 (13%)

5 ( 9%)

0

16 (89%)

45 (90%)

3

2 (11%)

5 (10%)

0

Prog n=7

Non-Prog n=63

Slide # 66

Page 37: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

VISUAL ACUITY & FUNCTIONAL VISION

25/79 (32%)24/77 (31%)Decreased Functional Vision By 1 Category

13/77 (17%)11/77 (14%)Decreased Acuity By 2 Categories

12/77 (16%)10/77 (13%)Decreased Acuity By 1 Category

Val-GCVIV GCV

(To Clinical Cut-Off)

Slide # 67

Page 38: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

K-M: TIME TO PROGRESSION (PHOTOGRAPHY)

72/74 65/62 39/49 33/34 25/32 21/26 18/22 17/18 15/16 14/14 *

Median Time To ProgressionIV GCV/Val-GCV 125 daysVal-GCV/Val-GCV 160 days

* IV GCV/Val-GCV Pts still at riskSlide # 68

Page 39: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

CMV CULTURES

% of patients withIV GCV Val-GCVCMV-positive culture

Baseline

Week 4

65% (46/71)

6% ( 4/64)

46% (33/71)

7% ( 4/58)

Slide # 69

Page 40: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

CMV PCR

% of patients withCMV viremia (plasma)

Baseline

Week 4

51% (39/76)

3% ( 2/70)

40% (31/77)

4% ( 3/71)

IV GCV Val-GCV

Slide # 70

Page 41: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

K-M : TIME TO WITHDRAWAL

* IV GCV/Val-GCV Pts still at risk

80/80 77/74 74/65 68/61 64/58 58/51 53/46 46/39 39/35 36/33 *

Median Time To WithdrawalIV GCV/Val-GCV 419 daysVal-GCV/Val-GCV 376 days

Slide # 71

Page 42: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WITHDRAWALS BETWEEN WEEKS 4 & 12

Adverse Events: IV GCV - Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia Val-GCV - hypoaesthesia & pain in limb; neutropenia; lymphoma; dehydration; pancytopenia

DeathAdverse EventRefused TreatmentFailed to ReturnInsufficient ResponseTotal

211004

1 5 2 2 414

IV GCV Val-GCV

Slide # 72

Page 43: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

K-M: TIME TO PROGRESSION OR WITHDRAWAL

* IV GCV/Val-GCV Pts still at risk

77/80 67/66 43/52 35/36 27/33 22/28 19/23 17/19 15/16 14/14 *

Median Time To Progression or WithdrawalIV GCV/Val-GCV 102 daysVal-GCV/Val-GCV 112 days

Slide # 73

Page 44: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 MEAN STEADY-STATE CONC. OF GCV AFTER IV GCV & VAL-GCV

0.01

0.1

1

10

0 5 10 15 20 25Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n ug

/mL

i.v GCV wk1 GCV from Val-GCV wk1

Week 1

Slide # 74

Page 45: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 MEAN STEADY-STATE CONC. OF GCV AFTER IV GCV & VAL-GCV

0.01

0.1

1

10

0 5 10 15 20 25Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n ug

/mL

i.v GCV wk4 GCV from Val-GCV wk4

Week 4

Slide # 75

Page 46: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 MEAN STEADY-STATE CONC. OF GCV & VAL-GCV AFTER IV GCV & VAL-GCV

0.01

0.1

1

10

0 5 10 15 20 25Time (h)

Con

cent

ratio

n ug

/mL

i.v GCV wk1 i.v GCV wk4GCV from Val-GCV wk1 GCV from Val-GCV wk4Val-GCV wk1 Val-GCV wk4

Weeks 1 & 4

Slide # 76

Page 47: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 MEAN GCV PK PARAMETERS

IV GCVn=18

Val-GCVn=25

IV GCVn=18

Val-GCVn=20

Dose

WEEK 1 WEEK 4

5 mg/kgb.i.d.

5 mg/kgq.d.

900 mgb.i.d.

900 mgq.d.

Slide # 77

Page 48: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 MEAN GCV PK PARAMETERS

IV GCVn=18

Val-GCVn=25

IV GCVn=18

Val-GCVn=20

12 hr AUC

(CV%)

24 hr AUC28.6

(31.6)

32.8

(30.7)

30.7

(25)

34.9

(38.1)

Dose

WEEK 1 WEEK 4

5 mg/kgb.i.d.

5 mg/kgq.d.

900 mgb.i.d.

900 mgq.d.

AUC: µg•h/mL Slide # 78

Page 49: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

WV15376 MEAN GCV PK PARAMETERS

IV GCVn=18

Val-GCVn=25

IV GCVn=18

Val-GCVn=20

12 hr AUC

(CV%)

24 hr AUC28.6

(31.6)

32.8

(30.7)

30.7

(25)

34.9

(38.1)

Cmax 10.4 6.71 9.86 5.87(n=21)

Dose

WEEK 1 WEEK 4

5 mg/kgb.i.d.

5 mg/kgq.d.

900 mgb.i.d.

900 mgq.d.

AUC: µg•h/mL; Cmax: µg/mL Slide # 79

Page 50: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

SAFETY

Slide # 80

Page 51: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

SAFETY-RELATED STUDY WITHDRAWALS RANDOMIZED PHASE

IV GCVn=80

Val-GCVn=80

Total Safety-Related Withdrawals

2 (3%) 1 (1%)

Adverse Event OrIntercurrent Illness

1 (1%) (ANC)

0

Death 1 (1%)(lymphoma)

1 (1%)(PCP)

Slide # 81

Page 52: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

SAFETY RANDOMIZED PHASE (10%)

IV GCVn=79

Val-GCVn=79

Diarrhea 8 (10%) 13 (16%)Pyrexia 9 (11%) 10 (13%)Neutropenia 10 (13%) 9 (11%)

11 (14%)Nausea 6 ( 8%)Oral Candidiasis 5 ( 6%) 9 (11%)

8 (10%) 6 ( 8%)VomitingCatheter-Related 9 (11%) 2 ( 3%)

Adverse Event

Slide # 82

Page 53: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

LABORATORY ABNORMALITIESRANDOMIZED PHASE

IV GCVn=79

Val-GCVn=79

5 ( 6%)10 (13%)

5 ( 6%)12 (15%)

< 500500 to < 750

ANC (cells/µL)

0 2 ( 3%)

04 ( 5%)

< 6.56.5 to < 8.0

Hemoglobin (g/dL)

0 0

01 ( 1%)

< 2500025000 to < 50000

Platelets (/µL)

Slide # 83

Page 54: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

POOLED SAFETYWV15376 & WV15705

Slide # 84

Page 55: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

STUDY WV15705 DESIGN (SAFETY & TOLERANCE)

Patients with CMV Retinitisn=212 Val-GCV

900 mg bid21 days

Val-GCV 900 mg qd

CMVR Progression

CMVR Progression

CMVR Stable CMVR Stable

Slide # 85

Page 56: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

VAL-GCV TREATMENT (DAYS)(To Clinical Cut off)

WV15376 WV15705IV GCV

n=79Val-GCV

n=79Val-GCV

n=212Mean 322 281 333

Median 287 248 372

Range 0-875 2-847 12-513

Slide # 86

Page 57: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

SAFETYMAINTENANCE TREATMENT PHASE

Adverse Event (%)Val-GCVN= 370

GCV 3gN= 536

IV GCVN=412

PLAN=119

Diarrhea 34 31 27 24Pyrexia 24 35 36 35

Neutropenia 21 23 26 12Nausea 22 25 19 22Fatigue 18 17 18 23

20Anemia 17 20 17Vomiting 17 13 12 13

Historical(To Clinical Cut-off)

Oral Candidiasis 17 9 6 13

Slide # 87

Page 58: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

LABORATORY ABNORMALITIESMAINTENANCE TREATMENT PHASE

< 500500 to < 750

ANC (cells/µL)

< 6.56.5 to < 8.0

Hemoglobin (g/dL)

< 2500025000 to < 50000

Platelets (/µL)

N = 370

55 (15%)54 (15%)

25 ( 7%)34 ( 9%)

10 ( 3%)17 ( 5%)

(To Clinical Cut-off)

Slide # 88

Page 59: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

VALGANCICLOVIR COMPARABLE SAFETY TO GCV

Safety profile comparable to GCV experience

No unexpected toxicities observed Most frequent severe or serious events:

neutropenia, anemia Frequency of pancytopenia similar to

IV GCV (1-2%)

Slide # 89

Page 60: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

CMVR progression rates were equal Clear and comparable anti-viral effect Significantly fewer IV catheter-related &

serious adverse events in Val-GCV group Other adverse event rates were similar

During Randomized Treatment (IV GCV or Val-GCV):

SUMMARY

Slide # 90

Page 61: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

SUMMARY

Val-GCV provides:

Systemic exposures comparable to IV GCV (induction and maintenance)

Similar long-term rates of CMVR progression and adverse events, regardless of randomized induction regimen (IV GCV or Val-GCV)

Slide # 91

Page 62: DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM & STUDY RESULTS

CONCLUSION

Valganciclovir, an oral prodrug of ganciclovir with high bioavailability, provides an effective and convenient treatment for CMV retinitis

Slide # 92