Top Banner
DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS
34

DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

Dec 31, 2015

Download

Documents

Egbert Anthony
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS

Page 2: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

STREAMBANK INVENTORY AND EVALUATION FORM

County ______________________T.________ R________Sec. ___________Stream Name ______________________________________UTM Coord. _______________________, ______________________________Landowner ____________________________

Drainage Area _______________sq. mi. Bankfull dimensions from Regional Curve: Width _______ft. Depth _______ft.

Valley slope from Topographic Map ______________ ft/mi. _______________ft/ft

Estimated 2 yr. Discharge from “Water Resources 87-4207” _______________ cfsEstimated sinuosity ___________ (stream length / valley length)

Field Data

Field determined Bankfull Width _________ft. Maximum Depth_____________ft. Mean Depth ________________ft.Width / Depth Ratio ___________(bankfull width / mean bankfull depth)

Estimated D 90 particle size ___________in.Estimated D 50 particle size ___________in.Manning’s “n” _____________Channel slope ______________Velocity ----- Manning’s equation ______________ v=(1.49/n) (R2/3) (S1/2) V= Q/A _______________________ Required to move D 90 ____________

Entrenchment ratio ___________ (width @ 2 x max. bankfull depth / width @ bankfulldepth)

Channel Evolution Stage (1 thru 5) __________ Stream Type (Rosgen) ____________

Radius of Curvature (Rc) _____________ Rc / Bankfull width ______________

NOTES:_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Page 3: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

STREAMBANK STABILIZATION GUIDELINES FOR PRACTICE SELECTION

YES ROCK RIFFLE GRADE CONTROL

NO

------------------- YES STOP ---TREAT SEEPS AND/OR SPRINGS

NO

YES STONE TOE PROTECTION

NO

YES BENDWAY WEIRS OR STREAM BARBS

NO

YES BENDWAY WEIRS & STONE TOE PROTECTION OR STREAM BARBS

NO

--- CALL FOR ASSISTANCE

AVERAGE SURVEYED GRADIENT > VALLEY SLOPE FROM TOPOG ORBED IN RIFFLE LOCATION IS SILT OR CLAY ORWIDTH/DEPTH RATIO < 10 & ENTRENCHMENT RATIO <1.4

SEEPS OR SPRINGS PRESENT AT PROJECT SITE

BANKFULL WIDTH @ SITE < 130% WIDTH AT RIFFLE

UNVEGETATED POINT BAR < 30% WIDTH AT RIFFLE

RADIUS/WIDTH RATIO > 1.8

RADIUS/WIDTH RATIO > 4.0

UNVEGETATED POINT BAR < 50% BANKFUL DEPTH

UNVEGETATED POINT BAR MATERIAL < 1 INCH DIA.

RADIUS/WIDTH RATIO < 4

UNVEGETATED POINT BAR < 50% BANKFULL DEPTH

UNVEGETATED POINT BAR MATERIAL < 1 INCH DIA.

STREAM BARBS ORTRADITIONAL BANK TREATMENT

Page 4: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE?

• LOOK AT I&E DATA

• ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10

• ----CEM STAGE IV OR V

• ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar @ < 50% bankfull depth

• ----Radius Curvature/Bankfull Width >6

• ----Rc/Bankfull Width >4<6

Page 5: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

ARE BENDWAYS RIGHT?

• CAN POINT BAR MATERIAL BE MOVED BY FLOW?

• IS SOME SCALLOPING BETWEEN WEIRS ACCEPTABLE?

• IS CHANNEL BED AT LEAST 20 FT WIDE?

• ARE ENTRANCE AND EXIT CHANNELS RELATIVELY STABLE?

Page 6: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 7: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 8: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 9: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

START THE LAYOUT

• PLACE FIRST WEIR AT VERY START OF ERODING BANK

• ANGLE UPSTREAM SO THAT FLOW IS DIRECTED TOWARD POINT BAR AND INSIDE EDGE OF BEND

• ANGLE SHOULD BE 10 TO 20 DEGREES UPSTREAM OF PERPENDICULAR

Page 10: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 11: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 12: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

RECORD DATA

• LEFT OR RIGHT BANK

• STATION

• LENGTH

• ANGLE

• AZIMUTH (COMPASS READING)

Page 13: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 14: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

LAYING OUT WEIR 2

• STAND IN STREAM AT KEY OF WEIR NO. 1

• TURN 90 DEGREE ANGLE DOWNSTREAM FROM WEIR

• PLACE FLAG AT INTERSECTION OF SIGHTLINE WITH TOE OF BANK

• MEASURE DISTANCE TO FLAG

Page 15: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

LAYING OUT WEIR 2

• IF DISTANCE TO INTERSECT IS LESS THAN 4 TIMES THE LENGTH OF WEIR 1 ---PUT WEIR #2 JUST ABOVE TH EINTERSECT POINT.

• IF DISTANCE IS MORE THAN 4 TIMES LENGTH OF WEIR 1 ---MOVE UPSTREAM TO POINT WHERE SPACING IS 4 TIMES LENGTH OF W-1

Page 16: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 17: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

REPEAT PROCESS UNTIL

• LAST WEIR IS LESS THAN 4 WEIR LENGTHS FROM STABLE POINT ON BANK

• THEN SET ANGLE ON LAST WEIR TO DIRECT FLOW AT 90 DEGREES INTO THE CENTER OF THE EXIT CHANNEL

• (COULD BE 0 DEGREES OR EVEN ANGLED DOWNSTREAM)

Page 18: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

ADJUST WEIR LENGTHS

• GO BACK AND ADJUST LENGTHS TO MAKE ENDS OF WEIR FORM A SMOOTH ALIGNMENT THRU WEIR TIPS.

Page 19: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

RE-CHECK ANGLES

• GO BACK THRU THE LAYOUT AGAIN TO CHECK WHERE EACH WEIR IS DIRECTING FLOW.

• PERDENDICULAR FROM MIDPOINT SHOULD NORMALLY DIRECT FLOW NEAR THE TIP OF THE NEXT WEIR DOWNSTREAM.

Page 20: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

WEIR HEIGHT

• GO DOWNSTREAM TO RIFFLE LOCATION• SHOOT ELEVATION OF RIFFLE AND

MEASURE AVERAGE FLOW DEPTH.• ADD 1.5 FT. TO RIFFLE ELEVATION AND

THAT SHOULD BE YOUR “CREST ELEVATION” FOR ALL WEIRS IN THIS SET.

Page 21: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 22: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 23: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 24: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 25: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

QUANTITIES

• USE WATER SURFACE AS LEVEL AND MEASURE WATER DEPTH ALONG WEIR EVERY 10 FT. AND COMPUTE AVERAGE DEPTH.

• SUBTRACT AVERAGE DEPTH OF WATER AT RIFFLE FROM 1.5 FT. AND ADD TO AVERAGE WATER DEPTH TO GET RIFFLE HEIGHT.

Page 26: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

QUANTITIES

• (ALL WEIRS IN A SET SHOULD BE SAME HEIGHT ABOVE WATER LINE)

• FIND END AREA FOR DESIGN HEIGHT ON CHART AND MULTIPLY BY WEIR LENGTH TO GET VOLUME

• MULTIPLY VOLUME (CU. FT.) BY 105 LBS.

• DIVIDE BY 2000 LBS TO GET TONS.

Page 27: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 28: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

QUANTITIES

• “KEYS” ARE A MINIMUM OF 5 FT. DEEP AND 4 FT. WIDE.

• HEIGHT OF KEY SHOULD BE APPROX. HEIGHT OF “LOW BANK” OR 2 TIMES MAX. BANKFULL DEPTH.

• COMPUTE REQUIRED STONE FOR “KEYS” AND ADD TOTAL

Page 29: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 30: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.

DETERMINING STONE SIZE

• USE VELOCITY CALCULATED DURING I&E

• MULTIPLY VELOCITY BY 2 TO APPROX. MAX. VELOCITY (PROVIDES A SMALL MARGIN OF SAFETY)

• SELECT D100 STONE SIZE FROM CHART OF VELOCITY REQUIRED TO MOVE STONE ( I&E SECTION)

Page 31: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 32: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 33: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.
Page 34: DESIGNING BENDWAY WEIRS. ARE BENDWAYS THE RIGHT CHOICE? LOOK AT I&E DATA ----WIDTH/DEPTH RATIO > 10 ----CEM STAGE IV OR V ----Unvegetated Pt. Bar.