CMMI Impact on Higher Education I propose, that like our geographer, CMMI (in education) can provide a map for future exploration
Richard TurnerDepartment of EngineeringManagement and Systems
EngineeringThe George Washington
University
CMMI Technical ConferenceDenver, November 2002
CMMIImpact on
HigherEducationHow Academic
Introduction CanImprove Competencies
And Speed Transition
I propose, thatlike our
geographer,CMMI
(in education)can provide amap for future
exploration
Slide 2
Today’sOfferings(e.g. theoutline)
• The needs of education• The needs of industry• Educating with CMMI• The GW experience
Slide 3
HigherEducationEnvironment
• Rapidly changing technology• Higher degree of specialization• More diverse student
backgrounds– Cultural– Academic
• More adult students withsignificant life/work experience
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 4
SystemsEngineering • Systems Engineering is a broad
discipline– Fundamental principles– Techniques– Specialty engineering– Domains…
• Systems Engineering is abroadly applicable discipline– Product systems
• Hardware• Software
– Management systems• Project management• Organizations
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 5
EducationalNeeds
• Widely-applicable frameworks• Flexible courseware• Bodies of Knowledge• Integrated approaches
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 6
IndustryEnvironment • Rapidly changing technology
• Higher degree of specialization• Global corporations• Multiple standards• Complex systems of systems
– Software is ubiquitous– Everything is a software-intensive
system– Everything needs to talk to
everything
• Integrated teams andprocesses
• “Fluid” business environment
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 7
Attributes ofEngineeringManagers • Rapid decision making
• Maintain broad understandingof numerous disciplines
• Technical, organizational, andfinancial savvy
• Ability to build and manageprocess-informed organizations
• Act as leaders/coaches• Perform in an integrated project
environment
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 8
IndustryNeeds
• Well-educated, well-roundedstaff
• Experience in a process-basedenvironment
• Managers and engineers who– Understand process concepts– Understand systems engineering
principles– Understand software principals– Work across discipline
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 9
CMMI As Partof Curricula
• Systems Engineering• Software Engineering• Technical Management• Organizational Development
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 10
CMMI inEducationSupportsEducators
• Provides broad, tailorableengineering framework– No specific methodology– Applicable to many engineering
domains– A Knowledge Infrastructure (per
Steve Cross)
• Provides real-world insight intotechnical managementactivities in context
• Informative material providesexamples and work products
• Generic practices are atechnical manager’s checklist
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 11
CMMI inEducationSupportsIndustry
• Provides process-awaregraduates
• Provides real-world insight intotechnical managementactivities in context
• Supports adoption throughfamiliarity
• Encourages research inintegrated processes and PI
• Ideas introduced in class areoften influential at work (ifallowed) and so supporttransition
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 12
Some Barriers
• Industry needs to enableprocess-competent grads
• Academia must educate, notindoctrinate
• Academia is much slower tochange than industry– Publish or perish (refereed
journals)– Tenured (ancient?) faculty
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 13
GeorgeWashingtonUniversity
• Serves the Washington, DCmetro area
• Students from all level ofengineering and developmentfirms
• Cohort programs in companiesand government organizations
• Wants to meet industry andgovernment needs
• Two relevant departmentscurrently looking at CMMI– Engineering Management and
Systems Engineering– Management Sciences
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 14
EngineeringManagement • School of Applied Science and
Engineering• Students from all engineering
disciplines– Civil– Mechanical– Electrical
• Two-course series in SystemsEngineering– First course (required) covers SE
Principles– Second course is a project-based
course
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 15
EMSE-283SystemsEngineering I
• Currently using two texts byHoward Eisner
• Couples systems engineeringwith project management
• Based on MIL-STD-499 andHoward’s 30 key elements
• Briefly addresses SW-CMM andSE-CMM
• Recently taught using EIA-731as an outline
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 16
ManagementScience
• School of Business and PublicManagement
• Management courses– Technical management– Organizational development– Information systems– CIO certification
• Process improvement– SW-CMM mentioned– ISO standards mentioned
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 17
ProposedExperimentsat GWU • EMSE-283 Systems Engineering I
– Pilot based on CMMI– CMMI Distilled supplemental text– Chris Miller (SPC)– Richard Turner, Howard Eisner
(GW)– Possible textbook based on course
• MGT-280 Information SystemsDevelopment and Applications– Pilot based on CMMI– Under consideration
The needs of educationThe needs of industryEducating with CMMIThe GW experience
Slide 18
Conclusions• CMMI in education can benefit
both industry and academia• CMMI is an effective map for
knowledge transfer inacademia
• Process-informed managementis a critical success factor for PI
• Process-informed graduateworkforce eases adoption andperformance of processimprovement