Webcast Notes
• Type your questions in the “Submit Question” box, located below the slide window
• You can enlarge the slide window at any time by clicking on the “Enlarge Slides” button, located below the presentation window – the slides will advance automatically throughout the event
• If you are experiencing technical problems with viewing or hearing the event, please click on the “Help” button, located below the slide window
Speakers
John V HinshawGC Dept. DeanCHROMacademy
Tony TaylorTechnical DirectorCHROMacademy
Moderator
Dave WalshEditor In ChiefLCGC Magazine
An Introduction to Column Selection for Capillary GC
1. Important analyte / stationary phase interactions
2. GC stationary phase polymer types
3. Selecting an appropriate stationary phase
4. Stationary Phase Selectivity Effects –tuning the chemistry
5. Choosing column dimensions
6. Effects of column dimensions on selectivity, retention, efficiency and resolution
7. Bringing it all together from a practical standpoint
Aims & Objectives
Capillary GC column selection - what's important?
Stationary Phase
Length (m) x Internal Diameter (mm) x Film Thickness (mm)
L rc df
Efficiency (N) carrier gas / L / rc
Retention (k) oC / rc / df
Selectivity (a) oC / phase
5% Diphenyl dimethylpolysiloxane
30m x 0.25mm x 0.25mm
Stationary phase selection:Major analyte / stationary phase interactions
Major Analyte / Stationary Phase Interactions
Non-polar
Polar - Dipole
Electronegativity / Dipole Moments / Polarity
Stationary phase selection:Dispersive interactions
1. All substances contain small dipoles (small electronegativity differences)
2. Instantaneous dipoles fluctuate throughout the molecule (electron / nuclei vibration)
3. As two molecules approach – transient dipoles can induce the opposite dipole in the other molecule and a small attractive effect is seen
4. Often called a ‘dispersive interaction’ and occurs between compounds which are predominantly non-polar
5. Dispersive interactions occur with all substances, regardless if there is another overriding interaction
Van der Waals Forces
p8.flv
Stationary phase selection:Dipole interactions
1. Dipole interactions come in two sorts:
Dipole-Dipole / Dipole-Induced Dipole
1. Dipole interactions occur between substances whose permanent dipoles come into close contact with each other
2. Dipole-Induced dipole interactions occur when a polar substance meets a polarisable compound (typically containing pi-electrons)
3. The stronger dipole induces a more permanent dipole in the other substance and an intermolecular attraction occurs
Dipole – DipoleInteraction
p10.flv
p11.flv
Stationary phase selection:Hydrogen Bonding Interactions
1. A special case of a dipole-dipole interaction
2. Dipoles associated with the functional groups of two molecules come into close proximity
3. Hydrogen bonding interactions are very strong compared to dispersive interactions
4. In the extreme (e.g. the association of water with methanol) the dipole-dipole interaction energy can approach that of a chemical bond
5. Still an underlying weak dispersive interaction occurring simultaneously
Hydrogen BondingInteractions
Modern Stationary Phase Chemistry
‘Polysiloxane’ Phases
1. Immobilized Polymeric Liquids bonded to the inner surface of a silica capillary via silyl-ether linkages
2. Deactivation treatments applied before and/or after bonding
Higher percentage of functional monomer indicate higher degree of that interaction
50:50 phase shows stronger Induced Dipole Interactions with Aromatics
Typical Ratio of monomers (X:Y):5:9535:6550:50
Modern Stationary Phase Chemistry (III)
‘Polysiloxane’ Phases
Typical Ratio of monomers (X:Y):35:6550:50
Typical Ratio of monomers (X:Y):6:9414:8650:50
Modern Stationary Phase Chemistry (III)
‘Glycol / Wax’ Phases
Stationary Phase Interaction Summary
Lower polarity phases bleed less!
Stationary Phase Selection
1. Critical – Phase and Temperature directly effect selectivity
2. Principle of ‘like dissolves like’ holds well
3. Separate polar analytes using a more polar phase and vice versa
4. The skill is knowing the degree of polarity required to avoid overly long retention times whilst still obtaining a satisfactory separation
5. Separating compounds of intermediate polarity or mixed polarity & functionality requires knowledge of the retentivity and selectivity of each phase
6. May require ‘fine tuning’ of the phase chemistry using the monomeric ratios
Like Dissolves Like
Stationary Phase Selection:Test Probe Chemistry
Stationary Phase Selection:Dispersive Interactions
100% Methyl Polysiloxane
Boiling Point Column?
12
3
4
5
6
1. Toluene2. Hexanol3. Phenol4. Decane (C10)5. Naphthalene6. Dodecane (C12)
110oC156oC182oC174oC218oC216oC
Strong DispersionNo DipoleNo H Bonding
Stationary Phase Selection:Dipole (Induced Dipole) Phases5% Phenyl Phase
12
34
5,6
1. Toluene2. Hexanol3. Phenol4. Decane (C10)5. Naphthalene6. Dodecane (C12)
Strong DispersionNo DipoleNo H Bonding
Strong DispersionWeak (Induced) DipoleNo H Bonding
1 2 34
56
?
5% Phenyl
100%Methyl
Stationary Phase Selection:Dipole (Induced Dipole) Phases50% Phenyl Phase
1. Toluene2. Hexanol3. Phenol4. Decane (C10)5. Naphthalene6. Dodecane (C12)
Strong DispersionNo DipoleNo H Bonding
Strong DispersionWeak (Induced) DipoleNo H Bonding
50% Phenyl
100% Methyl
1 234
5
1 2 34
56
?
6
Stationary Phase Selection:Dipole & Hydrogen Bonding Phases14% Cyanopropylphenyl Phase
1. Toluene2. Hexanol3. Phenol4. Decane (C10)5. Naphthalene6. Dodecane (C12)
Strong DispersionNo DipoleNo H Bonding
Strong DispersionNone/Strong Dipole (Ph/CNPr)Weak/Moderate H Bonding (Ph/CNPr)
14% Cyano-propylphenyl
100% Methyl
1 23
4
5
12
34 5
6
?
6
Stationary Phase Selection:Dipole & Hydrogen Bonding Phases50% CyanopropylphenylPhase
1. Toluene2. Hexanol3. Phenol4. Decane (C10)5. Naphthalene6. Dodecane (C12)
Strong DispersionNo DipoleNo H Bonding
Strong DispersionStrong DipoleModerate H Bonding
50% Cyano-propylphenyl
100% Methyl
1 23
45
1 23
4 56
?
6
Stationary Phase Selection:Dipole & Hydrogen Bonding Phases35% Trifluoropropyl Phase
1. p-Xylene, 2. m-Xylene, 3. o-XyleneColumn: DB1 / DB200 (30m x 0.25mm, 0.25µm)Carrier: Helium @ 32 cm/sec.Oven: 45 – 115oC @ 5oC/min.
Strong DispersionModerate DipoleWeak H Bonding
35% Trifluoropropyl
100% PDMS
DB-1 DB-200
1
2
3
1,2
3
Stationary Phase Selection:Dipole (& H Bonding) Phases100% Polyethylene Glycol
1. Toluene2. Hexanol3. Phenol4. Decane (C10)5. Naphthalene6. Dodecane (C12)
Strong DispersionNo DipoleNo H Bonding
Strong DispersionStrong DipoleModerate H Bonding
100% PEG
100% Methyl
12
3
4
5
1 23
4 5
6
?
6
Stationary Phase Selection:PLOT columns
1. Porous Layer Open Tubular (PLOT)for Gas Solid Chromatographic (GSC) applications
2. PLOT columns are coated with small, solid porous particles using a binder. Particles are Alumina or Molecular sieve
3. Solutes are separated on differences in their adsorption properties, size and shape
4. PLOT columns used to separate highly volatile liquids and permanent gases without the need for cryogenic or subambient cooling of the GC oven
Stationary Phase Selection:PLOT columns
5. Alumina columns are wellsuited to the analysis of C1 – C10
hydrocarbons and small aromatics
6. KCl derivatised columnsproduce altered selectivity
7. The Q designated columnsshow better selectivity for C1-C3
hydrocarbons (not good for >C6)
8. Q columns are also able to separate sulphur gases and most light hydrocarbons.
9. Molecular sieve columns used for noble and permanent gas samples - also good for the separation of solvents.
50m, 0.53mm IDRt-Alumina™ PLOT
Practically Speaking!
1. If no information or ideas about which stationary phase to use is available, start with a DB-1 or DB-5
2. Low bleed ("ms") columns are usually more inert and have higher temperature limits
3. Use the least polar stationary phase that provides satisfactory resolution and analysis times. Non-polar stationary phases have superior lifetimes to polar phases
4. Use a stationary phase with a polarity similar to that of the solutes. This approach works more times than not; however, the best stationary phase is not always found using this technique
Practically Speaking!
5. If poorly separated solutes possess different dipoles or hydrogen bonding strengths, change to a stationary phase with a different amount (not necessarily more) of the dipole or hydrogen bonding interaction
6. If possible, avoid using a stationary phase that contains a functionality that generates a large response with a selective detector
7. 100% Methyl or 5% Phenyl, 50% Phenyl, 14% Cyanopropylphenyl and WAX (PEG) cover the widest range of selectivities with the smallest number of columns
8. Use PLOT columns for the analysis of gaseous samples at above ambient column temperatures
Column Dimensions - Column Length
Efficiency (N) carrier gas / L / rc
Retention (k) oC / rc / df
Selectivity (a) oC / Phase
1. Doubling column length doubles efficiency
2. Doubles analysis time (or by 1.5 – 1.75x for temperature gradient)
3. Increases column costs
4. Improves resolution by a factor of 1.4 x
p30.flv
Column Internal Diameter (or rc)
1. Affects efficiency, retention, carrier flow rate, capacity and pressure drop across the column
2. Inversely proportional to column efficiency – halve diameter, double efficiency, increase resolution by factor of 1.4
Efficiency (N) carrier gas / L / rc
Retention (k) oC / rc / df
Selectivity (a) oC / Phase
Column Internal Diameter (or rc) (II)
3. Inversely proportional to analyte retention for isothermalbut NOT GRADIENT
4. Consider gradient temperature programming in conjunctionwith pressure programming for constant flow
Efficiency (N) carrier gas / L / rc
Retention (k) oC / rc / df
Selectivity (a) oC / Phase
Column Internal Diameter (or rc) (III)
5. Column head pressure an inverse square function of column radius6. Column capacity increases with column internal diameter7. Capacity also depends on the stationary phase type, film thickness
and the nature of the analytes
Efficiency (N) carrier gas / L / rc
Retention (k) oC / rc / df
Selectivity (a) oC / Phase
p34.flv
Phase Film Thickness (df)Efficiency (N) carrier gas / L / rc
Retention (k) oC / rc / df
Selectivity (a) oC / Phase
1. Affects retention, inertness,
capacity, resolution and bleed
2. Film thickness is directlyproportional to retentiontime (1.5:1 for gradient)
3. Thick stationary phase filmsgive retention for highly volatile analytes
4. Increasing film thickness allows retention of volatile analytes at temperatures at or above ambient
5. Doubling df gives an increase of around 20oC in elution temperature
Phase Film Thickness (df) (II)
6. Retention of late eluting (high boiling point) analytes is reduced using thinner film columns
7. Early eluting analytes (k<2) are better resolved using thicker film columns
8. Resolution may DECREASE for analytes with k values between 5 with INCREASING film thickness
9. Thicker films bleed more - upper temperature limits of thick film columns will be lower
10. Thicker film columns are more inert as the film shields the analyte from active sites on the silica tubing
11. Thicker film columns have higher analyte capacity, and so may reduce peak fronting
Efficiency (N) carrier gas / L / rc
Retention (k) oC / rc / df
Selectivity (a) oC / Phase
p37.flv
Phase Ratio (b)
1. Stationary phase to mobile phase ratio
2. Increasing the phase ratio will result in decreased analyte retention (increasing the column radius or decreasing the film thickness)(reduction in capacity?)
Phase Ratio (b)
3. Use to keep retention time approximately constant whilst increasing efficiency (reducing the column internal diameter) and reducing film thickness to keep b constant
4. Net result is a more efficient separation within the same timescale as the original separation!
Phase Ratio (b) (II)
Practically Speaking!
1. Capillary GC columns are typically 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 50, 60,120 (m)
2. Extending the column length is the least favoured option for increasing resolution and should be avoided if possible
3. Cost and analysis time are proportional to column length
4. Use the shortest column that will give you the required resolution (begin with 25-30 m columns if the number/ nature of samples is unknown).
5. To increase resolution try changing the stationary phase or column internal diameter first
6. Narrow internal diameter columns are capable of separating multiple analytes in a single analysis
Practically Speaking!
7. Increase film thickness when volatile analytes are involved or reduce film thickness to decrease retention of highly adsorbed analytes
8. Use phase ratio to increase separation efficiency in the same timeframe as the original separation
9. Column head pressure and bleed increase with column length.
10. 10-15 m columns are well suited to samples containing well separated analytes or where the number of analytes is low
11. 50-60m columns should be used only where very large numbers of components need to be separated and as a last resort when reducing the column internal diameter and changing the stationary phase and temperature program have failed!
CHROMacademy & CHROMmunity
Today's Webcast was brought to you by CHROMacademy
http://www.CHROMacademy.com
Join CHROMacademy for $250 per year for a full subscription and to see all of the archived webcast content and much more
All questions will be answered within CHROMmunity
http://chrommunity.chromacademy.com
The webcast will be available for on-demand viewing
for 4 weeks from today
Question and Answer
Type your question in the
“Submit Question”
box below your slide window.
Thank You for Attending
We Need Your Feedback!
Please complete the post-webcast evaluation form that will immediately appear in your window.