Top Banner
Intravenous Immunoglobulins CPG Adaptation Proposal Dr. Yasser S. Amer MBBCh, MS Ped, MS HCI, CPHQ, FISQua Coordinator, KSUMC - Wide CPG Steering Committee CPG Methodologist, CPGs Unit, Quality Management Dept. 6/30/2016 1 Capacity Building for CPG Adaptation at KSUMC Series June 2016/ Ramadan 1437
166

Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Jan 22, 2018

Download

Healthcare

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Intravenous Immunoglobulins

CPG Adaptation Proposal

Dr. Yasser S. AmerMBBCh, MS Ped, MS HCI, CPHQ, FISQua

Coordinator, KSUMC-Wide CPG Steering Committee

CPG Methodologist, CPGs Unit, Quality Management Dept.6/30/2016 1

Capacity Building for CPG Adaptation at KSUMC SeriesJune 2016/ Ramadan 1437

Page 2: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

مبســـــم هللا الرحمـــــن الرحـــــي

In the name of Allah. Most Gracious, Most Merciful

6/30/2016 2

Page 3: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Statement of disclosure

6/30/2016 3

Dr. Yasser S. AmerMBBCh, MPedia, MHCI, CPHQ, FISQua

I have no actual or potential, commercial or

academic conflict of interest to declare in relation to

this presentation/ project

Page 4: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

The EBM Triad

46/30/2016

Page 5: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Definition: (old)

“Systematically developed statements to assist

practitioner and patient decisions about appropriate

health care for specific clinical circumstances”

(IOM 1990)

Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs)

56/30/2016

Page 6: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPGs Definition (New)

“Statements that include Recommendations

intended to optimize patient care that are

informed by a Systematic Review of evidence

and an assessment of the benefits and harms of

alternative care options”

Committee on Standards for Developing Trustworthy

CPGs (IOM-AHRQ 2011)

6/30/2016 6

Page 7: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Evidence Pyramid (Study design)

SR

RCT

Cohort

Case control

Case series

Case report

Expert opinion

I

II

III

IV

A

B

C

Leve

ls o

f E

vid

en

ce

Gra

des o

f Reco

mm

en

datio

ns

MA

6/30/2016 7

Page 8: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

methods

6/30/2016 8

Benefits Risks/ Burden

QoE!

Page 9: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Level

Evidence

(LoE)

Grade

Recomm.

(GoR)

Strength

EVIDENCE PYRAMID6/30/2016 9

Page 10: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 10

What makes a trustworthy CPG?

Page 11: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Standards for high quality CPGsIOM 2011 – G-I-N 2012 – AGREE 2013

6/30/2016 11

Page 12: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Standards for trustworthy CPGsIOM 2011 G-I-N 2012

1- Establishing Transparency 1- Decision making process. 2- Methods

2- Management of COI 3- COI

3- (GDG) composition 4- GDG composition

4- (CPG – SR) intersection 5- Evidence reviews

5- Assign/ link to (LoE) & (GoR) 6- Rating of E & Rs

6- Articulation of (Rs) 7- CPG Rs (formulation/ wording)

7- External Review 8- Peer review & stakeholder consultation

8- Updating 9- Expiration & updating

10- Scope of CPG

11- Financial support/ sponsoring organization

6/30/2016 12

Page 13: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

How to assess of the quality of any CPG ?

6/30/2016 13

Page 14: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG development methodologies

6/30/2016 14

Page 15: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPGsWhat to do?

6/30/2016 15

Page 16: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Read

Adopt

AdaptDevelop

CPGs ?

6/30/2016 16

Page 17: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Different Options to deal with CPG

6/30/2016 17

Page 18: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPGsDEVELOPMENT

(de novo)

vs.

ADAPTATION6/30/2016 18

Page 19: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Types of CPGs

1.Evidence-Based CPGs (evidence-based methodology)

2.Consensus/ expert-based CPGs

6/30/2016 19

Which type do you think is better?

Page 20: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

The EBM Triad

206/30/2016

Page 21: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Process/ Methods

6/30/2016 21

Page 22: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 22

Page 23: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

236/30/2016

Page 24: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Adaptation of CPGsIs the systematic approach to the endorsement and/or

modification of a guideline(s) produced in one cultural and organizational setting for application in a different context. Adaptation may be used as an alternative to de novo guideline development, e.g., for customizing (an) existing guideline(s) to suit the local context.

http://www.adapte.org/

http://www.g-i-n.net/

6/30/2016 24

Page 25: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Hospital-Wide Policy & Procedure for

Hospital CPGs Adaptation-SEPT 2013- in process for update WITH “NEW TOOLS”

6/30/2016 25

Page 26: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Formulation of a CPG Adaptation Working Group

6/30/2016 26

In collaboration with:

• Departmental CPG Committee

• Departmental Quality Team

Page 27: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Selecting a CPG Topic

Prevalence of the condition (high volume)

Patient safety concern (high risk)

Under-, over-, misuse of intervention(s)

Burden due to the condition

Practice variation

Costs of different practice options

Likelihood of effectiveness of CPG

Potential for improving quality of care and/or outcomes

Existence of relevant good quality CPGs

6/30/2016 27

Page 28: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Topic (concerns?)

6/30/2016 28

• Disease/ condition (Clinical Diagnosis) versus Healthcare Technology? CPG vs. HTA http://www.inahta.org/hta-tools-resources/

• Another CPG Dept. Committee may work on another CPG that includes IV IG as one option for management (conflict?)

• Decision according to priority Dx vs. HT?

Page 29: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

HTA – IV IG in Sepsis (2012)

6/30/2016 29

Page 30: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

KSUMC Protocol for New CPG

6/30/2016 30

Page 31: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Health/ Clinical/ Key Questions

Patient (& disease characteristics)

Intervention(s)

Professionals (Target users)

Outcomes (purpose of the CPGs)

Healthcare settings (& context)

6/30/2016 31

CPG Scope: PIPOH Model

Page 32: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Health Question Tool (modif.)

6/30/2016 32

Page 33: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 33

Page 34: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 34

Page 35: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 35

Page 36: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 36

Page 37: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Inclusion / Exclusion CPGs Selection Criteria (6)1. Methods of Development: Evidence-Based CPGs: (Detailed

Methodology not Consensus-based CPGs (Expert opinion)

2. Author(s): Organization and Specialized Society not single authors.

3. Country: International not national CPGs.

4. Date of Publication: range of year of publications: last 5 years or less(e.g. 2010 – 2014) – except if none!

5. Language: English CPGs only

6. Status: only Original source CPG (de novo developed) rather thanadapted CPGs

6/30/2016 37

Page 38: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG selection criteria Tool (new)

6/30/2016 38

Page 39: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Search and Screen for Source CPGs

6/30/2016 39

Page 40: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Producers Finders

6/30/2016 40

Page 41: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPGs Finders

“Baseline Search List”

• National Guidelines Clearinghouse (NGC/ AHRQ)

• Guidelines International Network (G-I-N)

• EBSCO DynaMed

• PubMed/ MedLine

• Google Scholar

6/30/2016 41

Page 42: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

> 408 CPGs

6/30/2016 42

AHRQ-NGC National Guideline Clearinghousewww.guidelines.gov

Page 43: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Shaikh Bahamdan’s Research Chair for Evidence-Based Health Care & Knowledge Translation

Member of G-I-N since Oct. 2009Free access to International CPG Library of G-I-N

http://c.ksu.edu.sa/ebhc

6/30/2016 43

Page 44: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

http://c.ksu.edu.sa/ebhc/en

6/30/2016 44

Page 45: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 45

Page 46: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 46

Page 47: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 47

Page 48: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DynaMedhttps://dynamed.ebscohost.com/

Page 49: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Some CPGs are only retrievable by “Googling” them!

Page 50: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 50

Page 51: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Specialized Scientific (Specialty) Societies

6/30/2016 51

Page 52: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Assessment of retrieved source CPGs

6/30/2016 52

Page 53: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Instructor

Dr. Yasser Sami AmerMS Pediatrics, MS Healthcare Informatics, CPHQ

Supervisor, EBPU, QMD, KSUMCCPGs Advisor , KSUHs, AUHs

Member, G-I-N Adaptation & Implementation Working Groups

Page 54: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

The AGREE Research TeamPI: Melissa Brouwers, PhD

Head, HSR Oncology Dept., McMaster Univ.

https://youtu.be/z8nfqwvH4eM

Watch this video!

6/30/2016 54

Page 55: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Purpose

To guide on how to use and apply the AGREE II forassessing CPGS

Items

Domains

User’s Manual

Website

Page 56: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Outlines

• Overview of AGREE II including the items and domains.

• Present the scoring method of the CPG.

• How to use and apply the AGREE II for assessing CPG.

• Share the overall scoring.

• The AGREE Enterprise Website

Page 57: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

What is the AGREE II Tool ?

• Quality (Methodological rigor & transparency; confident in resulting

Recommendations)

57 Using the AGREE II Instrument

Assess

Guide •CPGs Development •CPGs Reporting

History

1st AGREE was published in 2003,then refined in 2009 AGREE II (New scoring “7 point scale” – Items modifications – New user’s manual) – 11 YEARS !

Can be applied to any CPG in any Disease area !

Page 58: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

• Healthcare providers/ clinicians

• CPG developers/ adapters

• Policy makers

• Educators

Who can use the AGREE II ?

Page 59: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Considerations before a CPG Assessment

• increase the reliability of the assessment

2 – 4 Appraisers

• in full and obtain all related information and needed documents before undertaking the AGREE II assessment ( to make a well informed assessment)

Read CPG first

Page 60: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Rating Scale• All AGREE II Items are rated on the following 7-point scale

Score Meaning

7 (Strongly Agree)

= If the quality of reporting is exceptional and full criteria and considerations in User’s manual are met.

1 (Strongly Disagree)

= No information relevant to AGREE II item OR the concept is very poorly reported

2 – 6 = when the reporting of the item does not meet the full criteria or considerations, depending on the completeness & quality of reporting .

Page 61: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

The AGREE II Includes….

•Core Items•(6 Domains)

23

•Overall Assessment Items

2

Page 62: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

23 Items in 6 DomainsUSER’S MANUAL page 7

DOMAINS No. of Items

1 Scope & Purpose 3

2 Stakeholder Involvement 3

3 Rigour of Development 8

4 Clarity & Presentation 4

5 Applicability 3

6 Editorial Independence 2

Page 63: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Items and Domains: A Closer Look

AGREE II:USER’S MANUAL

Per each Domain (guidance for rating the 23 items) Pages 11 – 41

User’s Manual Description:Where to Look:How to Rate:Item content includes the following CRITERIA:Additional CONSIDERATIONS:

Page 64: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Domain 1

Page 65: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DOMAIN 1. SCOPE AND PURPOSE

1. Objective(s):

Health impact & benefits of a CPG on target population

Introduction, scope, purpose, rationale, background & objectives

Page 66: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DOMAIN 1 - Q1 - Objective(s)

Page 67: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

2. Health Question(s):-Questions, Scope, Purpose, Rationale and

Background

3. Target population:-Pt. population, target population, relevant pt.s,

scope and purpose

DOMAIN 1. SCOPE AND PURPOSE

Page 68: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DOMAIN 1 – Q2 - Health Question(s)

6/30/2016 68

Page 69: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Health/ Clinical/ Key Questions

Patient (& disease characteristics)

Intervention(s)

Professionals (Target users)

Outcomes (purpose of the CPGs)

Healthcare settings (& context)

19th March 2013 EBCPGs: Dr. Yasser Sami Amer 69

CPG Scope: PIPOH Model

Page 70: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DOMAIN 1 – Q3 – Target population

6/30/2016 70

Page 71: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Domain 2

Page 72: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

4. Guideline groupMethods, guideline panel list, acknowledgements, & appendices

DOMAIN 2. STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT

Page 73: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

5. Patient preference Scope, methods, guideline panel list, external review &target

population perspectives

DOMAIN 2. STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT

Page 74: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6. Target usersTarget user & intended user

DOMAIN 2. STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT

Page 75: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Domain 3

Page 76: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E

9. Strengths & Limitations of E

10. Methods of Rs

11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)

13. External Review

14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)Methods, CPG Development process same sections+ Rs, Key Evidence+ acknowledgements+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 77: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Level

Evidence

(LoE)

Grade

Recomm.

(GoR)

Strength

EVIDENCE PYRAMID6/30/2016 77

Page 78: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Methodology of development

• In same CPG document (in brief or detailed)

• In a separate document or supplement (usu. Detailed)

• Not documented

Page 79: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Within CPG document (ENT IDSA ABRS CPG)

Page 80: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Mentioned but not documented

Page 81: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

KSUMC CPGs: Adaptation Process Methodology

Page 82: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Separate Methodology document (SIGN 50: A guideline developer’s handbook -2011)

Page 83: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

NICE: The guideline manual (2012)

Page 84: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E9. Strengths & Limitations of E

10. Methods of Rs

11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)

13. External Review

14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices

+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)Methods, CPG Development process same sections+ Rs, Key Evidence+ acknowledgements+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 85: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Selection Criteria of E

6/30/2016 85

Page 86: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E

9. Strengths & Limitations of E10. Methods of Rs

11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)

13. External Review

14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria

+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)Methods, CPG Development process same sections+ Rs, Key Evidence+ acknowledgements+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 87: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Strengths/ Limitations of E

6/30/2016 87

Page 88: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E

9. Strengths & Limitations of E

10. Methods of Rs 11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)

13. External Review

14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)

Methods, CPG Development process same sections+ Rs, Key Evidence+ acknowledgements+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 89: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Methods of Rs

6/30/2016 89

Page 90: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E

9. Strengths & Limitations of E

10. Methods of Rs

11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)

13. External Review

14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)Methods, CPG Development process

same sections+ Rs, Key Evidence+ acknowledgements+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 91: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Benefits, SE’s, Risks in Rs

6/30/2016 91

Page 92: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E

9. Strengths & Limitations of E

10. Methods of Rs

11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)13. External Review

14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)Methods, CPG Development process same sections

+ Rs, Key Evidence+ acknowledgements+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 93: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Evidence Links (Rs-LoE)

6/30/2016 93

Page 94: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E

9. Strengths & Limitations of E

10. Methods of Rs

11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)

13. External Review 14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)Methods, CPG Development process same sections+ Rs, Key Evidence

+ acknowledgements+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 95: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

External Review

6/30/2016 95

Page 96: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

7. Systematic methods for E search

8. Selection Criteria of E

9. Strengths & Limitations of E

10. Methods of Rs

11. Benefits , side effect and risks in Rs

12. Evidence Links (Gs of Rs – LoE)

13. External Review

14. Update Procedure

DOMAIN 3. RIGOUR OF DEVELOPMENT

Methods, literature search strategy & appendices+ inclusion/ exclusion criteria+ Evidence tables, clinical evidence, evidence description (results), evidence interpretation (discussion)Methods, CPG Development process same sections+ Rs, Key Evidence+ acknowledgements

+ CPG update, date of CPG

Page 97: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Update procedure

6/30/2016 97

Page 98: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Domain 4

Page 99: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DOMAIN 4. CLARITY OF PRESENTATION

15. Rs are specific Rs & executive summary

16. Options for management + discussion, Treatment (options/alternatives)

17. Recommendation identifiableKey Rs; separate (e.g. QRG)

Page 100: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Rs are specific

6/30/2016 100

Page 101: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Options for management ((? IV IG))

6/30/2016 101

Page 102: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Rs are identifiable

6/30/2016 102

Page 103: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Domain 5

Page 104: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DOMAIN 5. APPLICABILITY

18. Facilitators & barriers CPG dissemination/ implementation, barriers, CPG utilization &

Quality indicators

19. Tools+ tools, resources, appendices

20. Resource implicationsMethod, cost utility, cost effectiveness, acquisition costs &

implications for budgets

21. Monitoring /audit criteria Rs, Quality indicators & audit criteria

Page 105: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Facilitators & Barriers

6/30/2016 105

Page 106: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Implementation Tools

6/30/2016 106

Page 107: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Resource implications

6/30/2016 107

Page 108: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Monitoring/ audit criteria

6/30/2016 108

Page 109: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Domain 6

Page 110: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DOMAIN 6. EDITORIAL INDEPENDENCE

22. Funding bodyDisclaimer & funding source

23. Competing interestsMethods, Conflicts of interest (COI), CPG panel &

appendices

Page 111: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Funding body

6/30/2016 111

Page 112: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

DCOI

6/30/2016 112

Page 113: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Overall Assessment

Page 114: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

OVERALL CPG ASSESSMENT1. Rate the overall quality of this CPG

2. I would recommend this CPG for use

3. Notes

YES

Yes ,with modification

No

Page 115: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 115

Page 116: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group
Page 117: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Selected CPG DomainsOverall

Is CPG

Recommended for

use ?1 2 3 4 5 6

CPG 1

CPG 2

CPG 3

CPG 4

CPG 5

Finally AGREE II Domain Scores Color Coding (Prof. Lubna Al-Ansary)

< 40 % Red >41-70 Yellow >71 Green

Page 118: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

AGREE Domains Scores Table

CPG 1: SIGN CPG 2: EPR3 CPG 3: GINA CPG 4: ICSI CPG 5: Singapore MOH

Domain 1 60 % 74 % 45 % 61 % 42 %Domain 2 55 % 56 % 60 % 58 % 63 %

Domain 3 92 % 83 % 79 % 38 % 43 %

Domain 4 95 % 90 % 92 % 75 % 87 %Domain 5 70 % 82 % 80 % 33 % 58 %Domain 6 80 % 60 % 22 % 50 % 10 %Overall assessment 7 6 5 3 4Recommended for use Yes Yes (w M) Yes (w M) No No

Page 119: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Graphical Representation

Page 120: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

AGREE II DOMAINS

(ENT-ABRS CPG)

IDSA CPG 2012 Canadian CPG 2011

D1: Scope & Purpose 86 % 80 %D2: Stakeholder Involvement 86 % 69 %D3: Rigour of Development 90 % 85 %D4: Clarity & Presentation 92 % 90 %D5: Applicability 67 % 64 %D6: Editorial Independence 96 % 76 %Overall assessment 7 5Recommended for use Yes No

This table uses the AGREE II Domain Score Colour Coding proposed by Dr. Lubna Alansary

(< 40% red - > 41 – 70% yellow - > 71 % green)

Page 121: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

AGREE II DOMAINS CPG1 (Singapore) CPG2 (WFSBP) CPG3 (Canada)

D1: Scope & Purpose 90.7% 90.7% 96.3 %D2: Stakeholder Involvement 72.2% 65 % 81.5 %D3: Rigour of Development 39. 5% 84.5 % 90.3 %D4: Clarity & Presentation 98.1% 88.9 % 87.03 %D5: Applicability 34.7% 23.6% 40.3 %D6: Editorial Independence ZERO % 86.1% 55.6 %Overall assessment 4 5 6Recommended for use NO NO YES

This table uses the AGREE II Domain score colour coding proposed by Dr Lubna Al-Ansary

(< 40% Red - >41-70% Yellow - >71% Green)

Page 122: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

The paper tool (handout!)

Page 123: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Using the AGREE II Instrument 123

Page 124: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

AGREE II rater concordance calculator (EXCEL)

Page 125: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

AGREE II rater concordance calculator(McMaster University)

Page 126: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group
Page 127: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group
Page 128: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group
Page 129: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

AGREE Enterprise websitehttp://www.agreetrust.org/

Page 130: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

The online tool “My AGREE PLUS”

Page 131: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

My AGREE PLUS(OR Our AGREE!)

Page 132: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

My AGREE II Report PDF

Page 133: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group
Page 134: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

A tool for evaluation of clinical validity/ credibility of CPGs (in progress)

Page 135: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

AGREE-REX: Recommendation EXcellence:Innovations to enhance the capacity of practice guidelines to

improve health and health care systems

Develop a useful, reliable, and valid knowledge resource tocomplement the AGREE II, which will guide the development,reporting, and evaluation of the clinical credibility of CPGrecommendations.

Volunteers Needed for AGREE-REX Testing

April 2016

Page 136: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Other AGREE Resources

• AGREE Reporting Checklist (PDF, Word)Brouwers MC, Kerkvliet K, Spithoff K, on behalf of the AGREE Next Steps Consortium. The AGREE Reporting Checklist: a tool to improve reporting of clinical practice guidelines. BMJ 2016;352:i1152. doi: 10.1136/bmj.i1152.

A checklist based on the domains and items of the AGREE II intended to assist in the completeness of reporting in practice guidelines.

• AGREE II-GRS InstrumentA short item tool to evaluate the quality and reporting of practice guidelines. Get the AGREE II-GRS here.

6/30/2016 136

Page 137: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG Implementation

“The concrete activities and interventions undertaken to turn policies into desired results“

Guidelines for clinical practice: from development to use. IOM, 1992

CPGs Practice

6/30/2016 137

Page 138: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG Implementability

Set of characteristics that PREDICT the relative ease of implementation of CPG recommendations.

Implementability…….BEFORE implementation

6/30/2016 138

Page 139: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG implementation Strategies (SIGN)

Dissemination Process (print/ e-/website).

Local Clinical Champions.

Awareness raising/ training activities.

Regular M & E (Auditing) (The ‘living’ CPG concept!).

Networking and linking with existing projects (e.g. Dept. Clinical Rounds, CPD/CME activities, Accreditation, etc..).

Patients as champions for change.

1396/30/2016

Page 140: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG implementation Toolsavailable at the point of care (* MR)

Examples

1.Clinical Algorithm

2. Integrated Care/ Clinical Pathways

3.Protocol and/ or Policy & Procedure

4.Chart Documentation/ forms (e.g. Physician Order Sets: eSIHI

CPOE PowerPlans)

5.Quick Reference Guides/ Physician Guides & Pocket

Guide/Reference Cards (at-a-glance summary of key

recommendations 5 or 1-2 pages).

1406/30/2016

Page 141: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

1.Clinical audit criteria (tool)

2.Quality (outcome/performance) measures

3.Slide Presentation.

4.Wall Poster.

5.Patient Resources/ Information (health education guides).

6.Foreign language Translation (Non-English, Non-Arabic).

7.Implementation Tool Kits (collections of tools and/or strategies).

8.Staff Training/ Competency Material.

CPG implementation tools (cont’d)

6/30/2016 141

Page 142: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Mobile Apps

6/30/2016 142

Page 143: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Individual Positive attitude Learning through small

group interaction

Environmental• Professional

association/society support• Inter-organizational

collaboration networks

Facilitators

Organizational• Leadership support• Champions• Team work

collaboration

6/30/2016 143

Page 144: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG Implementation Failure….WHY?

Extrinsic to CPG:

provider & care system-related

Intrinsic to CPG:

ambiguity – inconsistency - incompleteness

6/30/2016 144

Page 145: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 145

Page 146: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 146

The concept of

the ‘LIVING’ CPG

Page 147: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

CPG Adaptation ProgramCurrent status 2016 - 1437

6/30/2016 147

Page 148: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) Adaptation

Program at King Saud University Medical City

KSUMC CPG Program Partners:-

KSUMC-Wide CPGs Steering Committee

Clinical Department(s); CPGs Dept. Committees)

Research Chair for Evidence-Based Health Care &Knowledge Translation

Quality Management Department; DQTs

Top Management of KSUMC; Medical Director(s), Dept. Chairperson(s), Unit Head(s)

IMPLEMENTQIP

ADAPTMethods

6/30/2016 148

Page 149: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Guidelines International Network (G-I-N)www.g-i-n.net

EBHC-KT Chair, King Saud University: Org. Member

since 2009

(1st Member from Gulf & 3rd Member from MENA

Countries)

Founded in Nov.

2002

6/30/2016 149

Page 150: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

23 KSUMC CPGs Subcommittees1. Department of Pediatrics

2. Department of Critical Care

3. Department of Psychiatry

4. Primary Care/ Family Medicine Clinics

5. Department of Pharmacy

6. Department of Emergency Medicine

7. Department of Medicine

8. Department of Orthopedic Surgery

9. Department of Otorhinolaryngology

10. Department of Ophthalmology

11. Department of Cardiac Sciences/ KFCC

12. Department of Surgery

13. Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology

14. Department of Dermatology

15. Department of Anesthesiology

16. Department of Laboratory Medicine &

Pathology

17. Department of Nursing

18. Department of Radiology

19. Health Education Center

20. Department of Rehabilitation Medicine

21. Department of Infection Control

22. Department of Occupational Health & Safety

23. Department of Clinical Nutrition

1506/30/2016

Page 151: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

How to access the KSUMC CPGs?

• PAPER1. CPG Binder (full document)

2. Forms (Implementation tools)

3. Algorithm Booklet

• ELECTRONICOnline:1. ICity website (KSU email)

2. G-I-N website (EBHCKT)

Offline: (intranet)Desktop Icon (IP Address?)

PARADIGMSHIFT: eSiHi

6/30/2016 151

Page 152: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

How to access CPGs on Intranet City (ICity)

6/30/2016 152

Page 153: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Desktop Icon

6/30/2016 153

Page 154: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 154

Page 155: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Type: MED

6/30/2016 155

Page 156: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 156

Currently, 18 out of the 29 adapted CPGs are already built on eSiHi as ‘CPOE with Order Sets’ (i.e. Cerner POWERPLANS). The rest are in progress!

Page 157: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

5 PowerPlans from Medicine CPGs

1. MED Diabetic Ketoacidosis CPG (adults)

2. MED Gout CPG

3. MED Hypertensive emergencies/urgencies CPG

4. MED oncology premedication

5. PULM Asthma CPG (adults)

6/30/2016 157

Page 158: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

1 from DEM/ ICU CPGsED septic shock (adults)

1 from Cardiology (KFCC) CPGsCARD Heart Failure CPG

6/30/2016 158

Page 159: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 159

29

KSUMC CPG PROGRAM IN NUMBERS

Page 160: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Who is the contact person for EBCPGs in each clinical department?

Chairperson, CPG Departmental Committee

Members, CPG Departmental Committee

Department Quality Team (former Accreditation teams)

Department Chairman & Units’ Heads

General Coordinator, CPG Steering Committee

Medical Secretary, CPG Steering Committee

6/30/2016 160

Page 161: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 161

Page 162: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Medicine (6 +5)

6/30/2016 162

1. Asthma (Adult)

2. Diabetic ketoacidosis (Adult)

3. Hypertensive emergencies & urgencies

4. Gout (acute gouty arthritis/ hyperuricemia)

5. Lung Cancer

6. Antiemetics for Chemotherapy-induces nausea & vomiting

7. Venous Thromboembolism Prophylaxis

8. Dyslipidemia

9. Vancomycin dosing and monitoring (Adult)

10. Surgical Antibiotic prophylaxis (Adult)

11. Heart Failure (Adult)

Page 163: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Pharmacy Services (3)

6/30/2016 163

• Vancomycin dosing and monitoring (Adult)

• Pediatric and neonatal parenteral nutrition (TPN)

• Antiemetics for Chemotherapy-induces nausea & vomiting

Page 164: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

How to read the KSUMC CPGs full documents?

Table of contents

• Preface by authors

• Acknowledgments

• Abbreviations

• Overview material

• Introduction

• Disclaimer/

Statement of intent

• Scope & Purpose (PIPOH)

• Recommendations (Key & details)

• External review & consensus

• Plan for scheduled review & update

• List of funding sources

• Adaptation process methodology

• Implementation considerations & Tools

• References

1646/30/2016

Page 165: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

Role as a Physician in CPGs

1) CPG implementers/users:

“Your continuous feedback!”

2) CPG developers/adapters.

3) Improvement research projects.

6/30/2016 165

Page 166: Capacity building for Adaptation of CPGs for the IV IG CPG Working Group

6/30/2016 166

Thank you!

Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

Ext. #: 91341, 91281