Bi Scorecard Blank

The BI Scorecard provides a consistent, side-by-side comparison of products from leading BI vendors. The information is copyrighted and restricted for use to subscribers.

To use this spreadsheet:

1. Understand the criteria by reviewing the related documents that explain the benefits and meaning of each of the criteria.

2. Business users and IT should work together to prioritize the criteria. Assign a weighting or importance in column A. For features that you do not need, assign a 0. For criteria that are considered show-stoppers or essential, assign an importance of 3 or higher.

3. As you investigate each vendor's functionality, you may want to change the scores that BIScorecard has assigned to each vendor/feature. Review the individual vendor evaluations and comments here to understand these scores. If you want to change a score, change the value in the color coded columns so that the calculated weighted rating is preserved. You also can insert new columns for additional vendors or products not covered by BIScorecard.

4.Review the weighted scores for each functional area to create a short-list of vendors/products that meet your needs.

5.Evaluate these scores against strategic considerations.

Additional Notes:- As of Q1 2008, blanks are accounted for in the subtotals so that vendors are not penalized for incomplete information.- Summary totals only include essential and important features, not features ranked with a 1.- In calculating % fulfillment of requirements, possible requirements are factored by 2 (so 2 means it adequately fulfills the capability). If a vendor scores a 3 on capabilities, the % fulfillment will be greater than 100%. - As of Q1 2009, we are sharing preliminary scores for new or soon-to-be-released versions for which hands on testing is not fully completed. Subtotal formulas for these versions are only added when hands-on testing is completed.

Copyright 2009, ASK LLCThis publication may not be reproduced in any form without prior written permission. All rights reserved.

www.biscorecard.comPage 2 of 129

Importance Item Feature

Information Delivery & BI Reach2 82 Time-based schedules2 83 System event-based schedules2 84 Report bursting2 85 Output formats (PDF, Excel)2 86 Output destinations (printer, FTP)

2 87

2 88 E-mail push delivery / Subscriptions2 89 Business Alerts2 90 Dedicated BI Portal3 91 Integration with 3rd party Portals3 92 My Portal2 93 Disconnected access2 94 Mobile Device Support

3 952 96 BI Search2 97 Guided Analysis

1 981 99 Gadgets or Widgets

Report Consumer Interactivity2 100 Outline view/Table of Contents2 101 Integrated drill3 102 Filter3 103 Sort1 104 Find2 105 Freeze Panes1 106 Hide Column

2

2 107

51

Versioning/archiving report refreshes

Display of business meta data to users

Collaboration Capabilities (report ranking, comments)

Stream first page for fast viewing of long reports

Web 2.0 Rich Reportlets (Flash/AJAX)

Information Delivery & BI Reach Important/Essential

SAP BusinessObjects XI IBM Cognos Hyperion System 9

BOE XI R2 XI 3.1 8.4

BI Scorecard subscribers have access to completed, detailed scorecards.





2 87





2

2 107

51







Information Builders Web Focus MicroStrategy Microsoft Oracle Enterprise BI (Siebel)

ReportCaster NarrowcastDistribution

Services v9.0

O23

Cindi Howson: Note: MSTRAT has good interactivity with OLAP services but not Report Services. See the full vendor evaluation for more information.





2 87





2

2 107

51







Oracle Enterprise BI (Siebel) SAS BI QlikView 8.2

9.1.3 v 9.2




Importance Item Business Query and Reporting3 1 Business view of the data1 3 User-defined server-side objects1 4 Readable SQL3 5 Busine

Prompting1 6 Column prompts2 7 Filter prompts2 8 Hierarchical prompts1 9 Pick list customization2 10 Cascading prompts1 11 Find within picklist2 12 Save prompt values2 13 Optional prompts1 14 Prompt interface2 15 Fixed Filters

Multiple Data Sources

2 162 17 Multiple data sources in report

3 18 Multiple Schemas/ Multipass SQL

2 193 20 Business question complexity2 21 Calculated conditions3 22 RDBMS Analytic Functions2 23 Subquery

2 24

2 253 26 HAVING or filter on measures3 27 Minimal requery of database

Document Layout2 28 Multiple objects in a document2 29 Crosstabs, Master/Detail1 30 Multiple report tabs

Charting2 31 Chart types2 32 Handling of dual Y-axes1 33 Master/detail charts1 34 Chart controls2 35 User defined Formulas

Formatting2 36 Conditional Formatting1 37 Display in 1000s2 38 Templates1 39 Contextual formatting2 40 WYSIWYG1 41 Structure Mode

2 422 43 Undo3 44 Overall Ease of Use & Appeal

70

Multiple data sources in business view

Types of Data Sources (Multiple Native Relational, OLAP, XML, Web Services)

SET Operators (Intersect, Union, Minus)

Comparative filters between columns or objects (ship date > request date)

Printed reports (fit to page, headers, quality)

Business Query Important/Essential


SAP Business Objects IBM Cognos Hyperion System 9

Score Comments Score Comments











2 24






70








Information Builders Web Focus MicroStrategy Microsoft Oracle Enterprise BI (Siebel)

U20

Cindi Howson: but its one query on a page/worksheet










2 24






70








Oracle Enterprise BI (Siebel)

EG










2 24






70








SAS BI QlikView 8.2

EG




Importance Item Production Reporting2 45 Business view of the data2 Business view optional2 46 Modifiable SQL1 47 User-defined server-side objects2 48 Readable SQL1 49 Web-based authoring

Prompting1 50 Column prompts2 51 Filter prompts2 52 Hierarchical prompts1 53 Pick list customization2 54 Cascading prompts2 55 Save prompt values2 56 Optional prompts1 57 Prompt interface2 58 Fixed Filters within a report query


2 592 60 Types of Data Sources3 61 Minimal requery of database

Document Layout2 62 Multiple objects in a document2 63 Crosstab/ Master Detail1 64 Multiple report tabs2 65 Absolute object placement2 66 Relative positioning2 67 Cell level control2 68 Ease of modifying

Charting2 69 Chart types2 70 Handling of Dual Y-axes1 71 Master/detail charts2 72 Chart controls2 73 Report Linking/Hyperlinks

2 74 Developer Formulas and FunctionsFormatting

2 75 Conditional Formatting2 76 Templates2 77 WYSIWYG2 78 Structure Mode

2 792 80 Undo2 81 Rulers & Design Tools

63

Multiple data sources in report & separate queries

Printed reports (fit to page, headers, suppress blanks)

Production Reporting Important/Essential

applet

SAP BusinessObjects XI Cognos 8.3

applet













63




applet

Information Builders Web Focus MicroStrategy













63




applet

Microsoft Oracle Enterprise BI (Siebel)

EG




OLAP125 Architecture

2 126 Single cube capacity

2 127

23 128 Multidimensional Calculations2 129 Handle Semi-Additive Measures2 130 Ratios Recalculated with Drill2 131 Nonstandard consolidations (-,*)2 132 Incremental load

2 1333 134 Time Period Analysis2 135 Attribute analysis

1 1362 137 Drill through to detail presentation3 138 Drill through to detail maintenance3 139 Reporting & OLAP integration1 140 3rd party OLAP

OLAP Viewer2 141 Drill/Pivot intuitiveness2 Charting capabilities2 142 Drillable Charts1 143 Write back and/or what-if analysis3 144 Rank2 145 User-defined hierarchies1 146 User-defined calculations2 User-defined set selections2 147 Missing cell suppression

32

15 OLAP Viewer Important/Essential

Sources to populate cubes (relational, flat file, star or snow flake)

Flexible control over MOLAP storage

Partitioning and aggregate awareness

Procedural calculations and/or scripts

OLAP Platform Important/Essential


SAP BusinessObjects XI IBM Cognos







2 127





32








Hyperion System 9 Information Builders Web Focus MicroStrategy






2 127





32














2 127





32








SAS BI Server 9.1.3 QlikView 8.2

©ASK LLC, 2009 Page 16 of 129

Importance Category Requirement

3 Dashboard Layout Multiple objects on a page/display (table, chart)2 Dashboard Layout Ability to resize portal objects independently

2 Dashboard Layout

3 Dashboard Layout

Dashboard Layout2 Dashboard Design Formatting templates for consistent look 1 Dashboard Design WYSIWYG design mode1 Dashboard Design Structure mode for faster design without all data1 Dashboard Design Record limit in design mode2 Dashboard Design Undo

3 Dashboard Design

3 Dashboard Design2 Dashboard Design Elements re-usable in multiple dashboards2 Dashboard Design Web-based design environment3 Dashboard Design Ease of design and maintenance aspects

Dashboard Design

User defined dashboard layout, in addition to centrally built by IT

Multiple data sources within dashboard presentation

Java development environment or Visual Studio or SDK for embedding

Developer-defined calcs for data not in data warehouse

Cognos 8Capability



3 Presentation3 Presentation Charts Overall1 Presentation Hi/Lo Chart2 Presentation Gauge Chart1 Presentation Bullet Graphs2 Presentation Spark Lines1 Presentation Maps1 Presentation Ability to create own visualizations

Presentation

3 Alerting Alerts - Visual display of exception values or text3 Alerting Alerts - Email notification

1 Alerting Alerts - user defined in addition to centrally defined

1 Alerting

Alerting

2 Analysis Trending - time based analysis

3 Analysis This Year/Last Year analysis3 Analysis Top 10 ranking

1 Analysis2 Analysis Predictive analysis / what if

Analysis

3 KPIs / metrics Web-based screen for users to enter target for KPI1 KPIs / metrics Multiple targets per metrics (stretch goals)2 KPIs / metrics User-defined KPIs3 KPIs / metrics IT-developed KPIs as part of dashboard

KPIs / metrics

Conditional formatting - traffic lights, trend arrows, highlighting of exceptions and variances within tabular display

Alert as RSS feed or textual display within dashboard

Assymetrical reporting (expand Q4, collapse Q1-Q3)

Cognos 8Capability



3 Dashboard Interactivity Global filter for all gadgets in dashboard

2 Dashboard Interactivity Re-sort data in a table within an existing dashboard

3 Dashboard Interactivity Drill-down3 Dashboard Interactivity Pivot / drill by other dimensions

2 Dashboard Interactivity2 Dashboard Interactivity Sliders/ Lassos to select content2 Dashboard Interactivity Flash animation3 Dashboard Interactivity Overall usability and navigation

Dashboard Interactivity3 Delivery Print whole dashboard2 Delivery Export to PDF3 Delivery Export to Excel2 Delivery PowerPoint1 Delivery Print one widget2 Delivery Disconnected access1 Delivery Live Excel connectivity

Delivery2 Architecture Caching - consistently fast response time2 Architecture Auto refresh/requery of dashboard objects2 Architecture In-memory3 Architecture Web-based dashboard delivery0 Architecture Use of Applet/activex controls

Architecture Support for Linux/Unix2 Architecture Support for 64-bit

3 Architecture

3 Architecture

Architecture1 Other Guided analysis / workflow / link reports

Drill from one dashboard to another with context passed

Broad and Flexible data access (OLAP, relational, Web-Services)

Dashboard integration with other tools in the BI Suite

Cognos 8Capability

0 0



1 Other Annotations /Collaboration

Cognos 8Capability

0 0

B86

Cindi Howson: Greater weight within scorecards




2 Dashboard Layout

3 Dashboard Layout


3 Dashboard Design


Dashboard Design





Microsoft Performance Point 2007SAS BI

Dashboard 3.1




Presentation



1 Alerting

Alerting




Analysis


KPIs / metrics





Dashboard 3.1










3 Architecture

3 Architecture






Dashboard 3.1





Dashboard 3.1

2

B86





2 Dashboard Layout

3 Dashboard Layout


3 Dashboard Design


Dashboard Design





Microsoft Performance Point 2007




Presentation



1 Alerting

Alerting




Analysis


KPIs / metrics














3 Architecture

3 Architecture










Comments can be added to cells within Scorecard

B86





2 Dashboard Layout

3 Dashboard Layout


3 Dashboard Design


Dashboard Design





Oracel BI EE QlikView




Presentation



1 Alerting

Alerting




Analysis


KPIs / metrics














3 Architecture

3 Architecture










B86





2 Dashboard Layout

3 Dashboard Layout


3 Dashboard Design


Dashboard Design





QlikView




Presentation



1 Alerting

Alerting




Analysis


KPIs / metrics




QlikView










3 Architecture

3 Architecture





QlikView




QlikView

B86





2 Dashboard Layout

3 Dashboard Layout


3 Dashboard Design


Dashboard Design





Business Objects





Presentation



1 Alerting

Alerting




Analysis


KPIs / metrics




Business Objects










3 Architecture

3 Architecture





Business Objects




Business Objects

B86


Evaluation of Advanced Visualization and Discovery Tools

Copyright 2009, BI Scorecard Page 40 of 129

Advanced Visualization ToolsImportance Item Feature TIBCO Spotfire

Feature Explanation or Purpose Score

Delivery and Exploration2 Visual appeal

23 Consumer interactivity1 Consumer drill down and pivot2 Printing2 Ease of use for consumer1 Annotations9 Subtotal Delivery and Exploration

Design and Analysis

2 Single step query, visualize, exploreAdvanced visualizations

2 Spark lines

2 Small multiples and Trellis Charts1 Bullet graphs2 Scatter plot2 Heat map or tree map

Box plotGeospatial analysisNetwork chart

22 Formatting and layout

Web-deployment of dashboards/visualizations

Application of best practices in visual design



1 Customization of shapes2 Dashboard layout options

2 Multiple data sources presented2 Multiple data sources joined2 Tabular Manipulations2 Local calculations2 Aggregations2 Time series analysis2 Statistical analysis

Monte Carlo simulationTool positioning for author

3 Ease of use for author33 Subtotal Design and Analysis

Architecture and AdministrationData Sources

1 OLAP OLAP sources supported2 Relational Relational sources supported3 Other Other sources

2

3 Integration with BI platform for data

Desktop or web authoring environment

Integration within existing BI environment

If tool is to be deployed along with enterprise BI, how does it integrate with platform

Integration with BI platform for security

If the tool is integrated with the BI platform, consider data sources, meta data, security re-use.

Can existing cubes, reports, and data sources be accessed easily or must data be replicated into a separate analytic environment



Stand-alone deployment

3 External authentication

3 Row, column, subject security

2 Data load and modeling features How is data loaded into the tool and accessed

2

1 Access to ERP, CRM, HR systems

2 Support for 64-bit OS

2 In-memory

1 Support for Unix/Linux

24 Total Architecture and Administration

For departmental, stand-alone deployment, consider rapid deployment and ability to maintain separate from enterprise BI platform

Can user IDs and passwords be used from Windows AD, LDAP, or BI platform

If separate security, degree of granular security

Ability to load data from multiple data sources into the cube or in-memory environment

Understanding of physical schemas in source systems

64-bit operating systems allow for greater data and user scalability. The product should be compiled for native 64-bit

In-memory products load the data into memory for speed of thought analysis. Some products will only load a subset of data into memory and leverage the OLAP server and other data sources to avoid replicated data and latency issues

Are platforms and OS beyond Windows supported



Additional InformationPricing

LEGEND

Product Scores

3 Exceptional capabilities2 Good capabilities1 Limited capability,difficult to do0 Minimal to no capability or requires coding

blank Not fully evaluated

Importance / Weighting

3 Essential, a "show stopper" or feature that significantly affects deployability and/or cost of ownership2 Important1 Nice to Have0 Not necessary



Advanced Visualization ToolsTIBCO Spotfire Tableau Corda CenterView SAS JMP

Comments Score Comments (version 5.0) Score Comments Score







Advanced Visualization Tools Data Exploration ToolsSAS JMP QlikTech QlikView SAP BusinessObjects Explorer

Comments Score Comments Score Comments








Spreadsheet IntegrationAdd-In

2 108

3 109

3 1101 119 Save To Repository2 118 64K row limit handled

Relational Data Sources3 111 New Queries (relational)2 183 Filter values can come from cell

2 1841 113 Formatting retained2 114 Tabular data sets & Pivot Tables2 115 Report formulas translated1 117 Charting imported from report

OLAP Data Sources3 112 OLAP Drill & Pivot2 116 New formulas preserved in drill

Spreadsheet Export from Report2 120 Scheduled spreadsheet2 121 Export tabular data set1 122 Export Chart2 123 Export Formulas

2 1851 124 Export Formatting

34 Spreadsheet Important/Essential

Additional Office Support (PPT, Word)

Breadth of data sources (relational, OLAP, planning)

Suite integration, reusability, consistency, workflow

Worksheet can contain multiple queries

Export page breaks or master/detail as separate worksheets


SAP BusinessObjects IBM Cognos Hyperion System 9 Information Builders Web Focus






2 108

3 109














Information Builders Web Focus MicroStrategy Microsoft





2 108

3 109














Oracle Enterprise BI (Siebel) SAS BI Server 9.1.3 QlikView 8.2





2 108

3 109














QlikView 8.2




Administration3 148 3rd party authentication2 182 Single Sign On2 149 Use of NT or LDAP groups

1 150

2 1511 152 Column level security2 153 Row level security2 154 Profiles for software functionality

2 1563 157 Usage monitoring3 158 Manage current sessions

2 1592 160 Regression testing tools

1 1612 162 Dev/Test/Production Migration2 163 Re-usable objects/components

29

ArchitectureSuite integration

2 164

2 1653 166 Suite-wide Security3 167 Common Metadata1 168 Consistent User Interface

1 169

2 170

2 171 Support for 64-bit OS in 64-bit mode2 172 Load Balancing

173 Broad Application Server Support2 174 Open BI Repository3 175 Caching3 176 Query Governers

177 Multi lingual meta data translation178 Multi lingual interface179 Extensibility/Embedability

24

2 180 Documentation Quality

1 181 Bookmarks to save report versions

Optional internal (proprietary) authentication

Leverage source system security (userid pass through)

Meta data exchange with ETL or modeling

Impact analysis / change management

Locking / check out for multiple developers

Administration Important/Essential

Breadth of Integration (query, reporting, dashboards, performance management)

Consistent Server Infrastructure with central control for core BI

Seamless navigation between modules

Support for Linux, Unix (in addition to Windows)

Architecture Importantant/Essential


SAP BusinessObjects IBM Cognos Hyperion System 9






1 150





29


2 164


1 169

2 170




24















Information Builders Web Focus MicroStrategy





1 150





29


2 164


1 169

2 170




24















Microsoft Oracle Enterprise BI (Siebel) SAS BI Server 9.1.3





1 150





29


2 164


1 169

2 170




24















QlikView 8.2

Revised: January 2009Copyright 2009, ASK LLC

This publication may not be reproduced in any form without prior written permission. All rights reserved. www.biscorecard.com

Page 58 of 129


Importance Item Business Query and Reporting

3 1 Business view of the data1 3 User-defined server-side objects

1 4 Readable SQL3 5 Web-based authoring

Prompting

1 6 Column prompts

2 7 Filter prompts2 8 Hierarchical prompts

1 9 Pick list customization

2 10 Cascading prompts1 11 Find within picklist

2 12 Save prompt values2 13 Optional prompts

1 14 Prompt interface

2 15 Fixed FiltersMultiple Data Sources

2 16Multiple data sources in business view

applet

SAP BusinessObjects XI

WebIntelligence XI R2 XI 3.1 Comments

3 30 0

2 23 3

0 0

2 20 0

3 3

2 22 2

0 00 2 New in XI R3

1 1 No check boxes. Basic.

2 2

0 1

Note there are 5 authoring interfaces: Java, Interactive, HTML, 508 compliant, WebI rich client

Keeps the last value selected but just for that session

Can create filter objects in universe but no picklist

Data Federator option supports this

applet



Page 59 of 129


2 17 Multiple data sources in report


2 19

3 20 Business question complexity

2 21 Calculated conditions

3 22 RDBMS Analytic Functions

2 23 Subquery

2 24

2 253 26 HAVING or filter on measures

3 27 Minimal requery of databaseDocument Layout

2 28 Multiple objects in a document

2 29 Crosstabs, Master/Detail

1 30 Multiple report tabs

Charting

2 31 Chart types2 32 Handling of dual Y-axes1 33 Master/detail charts





3 3

2 2

2 2

2 2

0 0

2 2

2 2

2 2

22 2

2 2

3 3

2 2

2 2

2 2 Line, Pie, Area, Bar, Scatter. 1 1 Mixed bar line2 2

Personal data providers now possible in WebI rich client. These can be viewed but not refreshed from InfoView portal. DeskI allows for stored procedures, freeform SQL.

Note that it is universe specific for that database

Filters in a query can be based on a comparison of universe objects. To have based on query results, need to use DeskI.



Page 60 of 129


1 34 Chart controls

2 35 User defined FormulasFormatting

2 36 Conditional Formatting1 37 Display in 1000s

2 38 Templates1 39 Contextual formatting2 40 WYSIWYG1 41 Structure Mode

2 42

2 43 Undo

3 44 Overall Ease of Use & Appeal

70

Importance Item Production Reporting2 45 Business view of the data2 Business view optional

2 46 Modifiable SQL

1 47 User-defined server-side objects

2 48 Readable SQL

1 49 Web-based authoringPrompting



applet


2 2

2 2

2 21 1

0 02 22 22 2 In Java Report Panel

1 2

2 2

2 2

86.8% 92.9%

Crystal Reports 10 Crystal Reports 2008 Comments1 1 Universe or Business View2 2

1 1

2 2

2 2

1 0

No hover over but can control legends, items graphed, scale, color

Printing is via PDF from most viewers; Java Report Panel supports direct print. There is not a fit to page. Users can control margins, page breaks. Image or logo can appear in header.

There is Undo in interactive viewer and now also in Java Report Panel viewer

Can't modify if generated via Data Expert wizard

Web-based authoring no longer available, was limited in the past

applet



Page 61 of 129


1 50 Column prompts

2 51 Filter prompts

2 52 Hierarchical prompts


2 54 Cascading prompts2 55 Save prompt values

2 56 Optional prompts1 57 Prompt interface

2 58 Fixed Filters within a report queryMultiple Data Sources

2 59

2 60 Types of Data Sources

3 61 Minimal requery of database

Document Layout2 62 Multiple objects in a document2 63 Crosstab/ Master Detail

1 64 Multiple report tabs2 65 Absolute object placement2 66 Relative positioning2 67 Cell level control

2 68 Ease of modifyingCharting

2 69 Chart types2 70 Handling of Dual Y-axes1 71 Master/detail charts2 72 Chart controls



0 1

1 2

0 0

1 2

0 22 0

0 21 1

2 2

0 2

3 3

3 3

2 22 2

1 12 21 12 2

1 1

2 22 21 12 2

Work around is to create as parameters

Score improved as filter list is now dynamic

Not tested against an OLAP database

Multiple subreports can be embedded in a main report

Column headings and cells now stick together, but not easy to convert report elements such as crosstab to chart



Page 62 of 129


2 73 Report Linking/Hyperlinks




63

Information Delivery & BI Reach

2 82 Time-based schedules2 83 System event-based schedules

2 84 Report bursting

2 85 Output formats (PDF, Excel)

2 86 Output destinations (printer, FTP)

2 87

2 88 E-mail push delivery / Subscriptions

2 89 Business Alerts





2 2

3 3

2 22 22 22 2

2 22 22 2

84.9% 92.9%

BOE XI R2 XI 3.0

2 22 2

1 2

2 2

2 2

2 2

2 3

2 1

Report bursting now for WebI in addition to Crystal format

Save As PDF, XL, CSV from WebI. Crystal has more export options. Each output format in scheduler is new job.

Send to can include dynamic email lists from database such as invoice to

Rules are now in different SAP module.



Page 63 of 129


2 90 Dedicated BI Portal

3 91 Integration with 3rd party Portals3 92 My Portal2 93 Disconnected access

2 94 Mobile Device Support



Report Consumer Interactivity

2 100 Outline view/Table of Contents2 101 Integrated drill

3 102 Filter

3 103 Sort1 104 Find

2 105 Freeze Panes1 106 Hide Column

2





2 2

2 22 21 2 New WEBI rich client in R3

2 2

3 32 22

1 1 Report annotations2 2 BI Widgets

2 22 2

2 3

2 32 2

0 01 1

2

This has gotten more cumbersome though. InfoView

Includes greater data lineage in XI 3.1 but only displayed in Interactive viewer

Newly available for both Crystal and WebI reports, using cached report data



Page 64 of 129


2 107

51

Spreadsheet Integration

Add-In

2 108

3 109


Relational Data Sources

3 111 New Queries (relational)

2 183 Filter values can come from cell

2 1841 113 Formatting retained

2 114 Tabular data sets & Pivot Tables2 115 Report formulas translated

1 117 Charting imported from report








0 2

90.8% 105.1%

Live Office XI R2 (PP)

2 2

1 1

2 22 2

2 2

1 1

21 1

2 20 0

1 1

Direct OLAP no longer supported

Filter values can come from a cell but only for new queries, not for existing WebI or CR reports. Process to "bind" is cumbersome.

imported as picture not as Excel chart



Page 65 of 129


OLAP Data Sources

3 112 OLAP Drill & Pivot

2 116 New formulas preserved in drill

Spreadsheet Export from Report2 120 Scheduled spreadsheet

2 121 Export tabular data set1 122 Export Chart2 123 Export Formulas





2 127

2

3 128 Multidimensional Calculations2 129 Handle Semi-Additive Measures

2 130 Ratios Recalculated with Drill2 131 Nonstandard consolidations (-,*)2 132 Incremental load

2 133






0 0

0 0

2 2

2 22 20 0

2 2

58.9% 61.7%

Web Intelligence Web Intelligence VoyagerDynamic OLAP Dynamic OLAP

1 1

2 2

1 10

010

1 1

Smart objects added in 3.0 but push to database doesn't work well

WebI can handle aggregate awareness but not partitions



Page 66 of 129


3 134 Time Period Analysis2 135 Attribute analysis

1 1362 137 Drill through to detail presentation3 138 Drill through to detail maintenance

3 139 Reporting & OLAP integration

1 140 3rd party OLAP

OLAP Viewer

2 141 Drill/Pivot intuitiveness

2 Charting capabilities

2 142 Drillable Charts1 143 Write back and/or what-if analysis

3 144 Rank2 145 User-defined hierarchies

1 146 User-defined calculations2 User-defined set selections2 147 Missing cell suppression

32


Administration




1 12 2

0 02 22 2

2 2

2 2

WebI Voygager

2 2 2

2 1

2 2 20 0 0

3 3 20 0 0

2 2 20

0 0 2

69.2%

77.3% 80.8% 66.7%

BOE XI R2

Universes can be based on SAP BW, MSAS

Drill and Focus or just drill. Right click to drill up and down.

Can create charts but not adjust scaling, display of values, difficult to stack

Voyager and WebI both support Rank. In WebI, can do server rank or report rank. Server rank is only available in Java Report Panel.

Voyager limited to column a vs column b type calculations



Page 67 of 129


3 148 3rd party authentication2 182 Single Sign On2 149 Use of NT or LDAP groups

1 150

2 151

1 152 Column level security

2 153 Row level security

2 154 Profiles for software functionality

2 156

3 157 Usage monitoring

3 158 Manage current sessions

2 159

2 160 Regression testing tools

1 161






ETL to report


2 22

2 2

2 2

2 2 Database credentials

2 2

2 2

2 2

2 2

2 2

1 1

2 1

0 0

2 2

Row restrictions are set within the universe.

Access levels can be created and defined for groups of users such as authors vs consumers and down to the individual menu features.

An Activity universe and prebuilt reports are provided.

Administrator can see the session but cannot interrupt them. Administrators cannot kill queries.

If a field is renamed, this is adjusted in the dependent report. However, there is no longer a way to find that dependent report.

The report validation is a new feature but one intended for the query user.

ETL to report



Page 68 of 129


2 162 Dev/Test/Production Migration

2 163 Re-usable objects/components

29


2 164


1 169

2 170

2 171 Support for 64-bit OS in 64-bit mode

2 172 Load Balancing

173 Broad Application Server Support2 174 Open BI Repository

3 175 Caching3 176 Query Governers

177 Multi lingual meta data translation178 Multi lingual interface







2 2

2 1

87.0% 81.0%

BOE XI R2

3 2

3 32 22 21 1

2 2

2 2

0 1 HP UX

2

2 2

2 22 2 Crystal lacks governers

2 2

Life Cycle Manager new in 3.1, improved over Import Wizard. Some dependency checking

Universe Linking continues to be problematic, buggy in 3.0 resolved in 3.1

Not as well integrated now with SAP Performance Modules

meta data, lovs, and query results cached



Page 69 of 129


179 Extensibility/Embedability

24





2 2

100.0% 100.0%

2

0 Favorites



Page 70 of 129





Prompting

1 6 Column prompts








applet

Cognos 8.3 Hyperion System 9

8.3 Query Studio Comments Interactive Reporting Comments

2 12 2

1 23 1

0 0

2 21 0

1

0 11 0

0 20 2

1 0

2 1

3 0

It's not plain SQL but can see some degree of query information

Does not save, not even for session. User can set option in run parameters, which may or may not be specific to an individual user

Calendars but no check boxes in run. Can't customize prompt message

You can create fixed filters in the Framework Manager model but there is no picklist. Picklist is provided in RS



Page 71 of 129




2 19




2 23 Subquery

2 24






Charting






0 2

2 0

3 2

1 1

2 2

2 2

0 2

0 2

02 2

0 2

1 2

2 2

0 2

2 12 21 2

Data is never saved with the report and each different output format reruns query

no charting in Express authoring mode



Page 72 of 129


1 34 Chart controls




2 42

2 43 Undo


70


2 46 Modifiable SQL


2 48 Readable SQL




applet


2 2

1 2

2 22 1

3 02 02 10 1

2 1

2 0

2

75.7% 68.5%

8.3 Report Studio20

2

2

2

3

Express authoring does not have rank/if then else, very limited. QS is percentage, arithmetic but no advanced

User can specify a Query Calculation that is pused to SQL or Layout Calculation



Page 73 of 129


1 50 Column prompts

2 51 Filter prompts






2 59









0

2

2

2

22

22

2

1

2

1

22

2102

1

2212

Can set test option to run query with minimal data during development. Also, can set option to use local cache but it only works with HTML output

They are multiple pages, then need to build a TOC



Page 74 of 129






63






2 87







2

2

2302

220

81.7%

2 12 0

2 2

2 0

2 0

2 2

2 0

3 0

Workflow for event studio much better to define alerts. Changing them and seeing what they are still needs improvement



Page 75 of 129









3 102 Filter



2





2 3 Workspace

22 20 2

2

1 Only to authors not to consumers 02 2

Find More / Search 0

2

1 22 2

0 1

0 21 1

1 00 2

2

WebSphere, SAP, SharePoint, Plumtree

BlackBerry, Symbian, Windows, new in 8.4 support for prompted reports, scheduled and bursted

can build but not generated from Master/Detail



Page 76 of 129


2 107

51


Add-In

2 108

3 109















0

74.5% 56.0%

Smart View 9

2 2

2 3

2 12 21 generates an error message

0 2

2

2 22 0

1 20 0

1 It's an image, not Excel chart 0

Go! Office & CAFÉ (8.3tested)

As of July 08, SmartView works with OBI EE but still requires separate server install.

Go! Supports Word, PPT, Excel. CAFÉ only Excel

Planning is different add-in for inputting numbers,but for analysis, can use CAFÉ if Framework Manager model built on top of Planning cube

Essbase, Planning, OBI EE as of July 08

Can go into edit mode from Excel, launching either QS, RS, AS

Hyperion Foundation Services separate from BI Server platform

changed in July 08 release to integrate with OBI EE

Treats as tabular data set but does not create crosstab as Excel pivot table

Existing report content from OBI EE is not imported, but some content from Hyperion products can be



Page 77 of 129


OLAP Data Sources









2 127

2



2 133






2 No visual drill indicators 3

2 2

2 0

2 22 10 0

02 0

67.6% 83.9%

ROLAP/ PowerCube MOLAP MOLAP/HOLAP2 3

3 3

1 2

2 3

1 22 2

2 3

CAFÉ accesses any OLAP cube and dimensionally modeled relational

in CAFÉ and includes formula language

Below scores relate only to Hyperion products

PowerCubes & Analysis Studio

Hyperion Essbase (Analytic Services)

Primarily MOLAP but can specify degree of aggregation

Rquires additional license - ASO/BSO



Page 78 of 129






OLAP Viewer






32


Administration




2 21 Treat as dimensions 2

0 22 22 2

2 1

2 2

Web Analysis

2 2

2 20 TM1 2

2 20

22 But no apparent way to subtotal2 2

92.9% 110.7%

84.6% 100.0%

Limited formatting options within Analysis Studio but you can go to Report Studio, but then lose AS capabilities

Swap icon, drill with click or popup menu



Page 79 of 129



1 150

2 151




2 156



2 159


1 161






ETL to report


2 22

1 2

2 2

2

2 2

2 Not that granular to menu level

3

2 1

1 0

1 1

1

2 0

Cognos Namespace and Series 7 security

Object level security set in Framework Manager

Data Security set in Framework Manager

Although no documentation so not sure what is prepackaged vs built for the demo

Can kill individual queries but not sessions. To view sessions, need

to install an optional report (SMM) - it comes from the audit db so not

realtime

Find report dependencies now also searches private folders, but renaming elements breaks reports. Vendor released a downloadable tool (DRU) to address

Upgrade Manager supports testing and analysis of going from 1 version to the next of Cognos, but not testing for internal development purposes



Page 80 of 129




29


2 164


1 169

2 170












1 0

2 1

87.0% 55.3%

Cognos 8 Hyperion System 9

2 3

3 33 33 02 1

1 1

2 2

0 2

2

2

1 22

22

Can create a zip archive file but no dependency checking or much granularity on selections

TM1 supports but C8 only Content Manager will in 8.4

Application Tier components can be distributed for load balancing. For fail over, multiple Content Manager stores can be on multiple machines.

Apache Tomcat, IBM WebSphere, SAP NetWeaver, BEA WebLogic, Oracle Application Server 10G

PowerCubes provide MOLAP caching. Very limited query caching



Page 81 of 129



24





2

102.1% 102.9%



Page 82 of 129





Prompting

1 6 Column prompts








applet

Information Builders Web Focus

InfoAssist 7.6.7 Comments

1 1 Master files2

1 0 Can view code but not SQL1 2

3 0 Create in Developer Studio

2 20 0

2 1

1 20 0

1 22 2 Referred to as "no selection"

2 1

2 1 No way to nest filters

2 2

Power Painter & Assistants

Can enter data values or read from data source but cannot change columns

displayed

Users can save their prompt values and run a standard report with the saved

prompt values. (This was not available in tested version).

No calendar for dates. Prompts are displayed in separate window. There is a ultiple values option for prompts but no checkboxes; ctrl click only. The prompt

message can be customized.



Page 83 of 129




2 19




2 23 Subquery

2 24






Charting






2 1

0 0

3 3 SAP BW, MSAS, Essbase supported

2 0

2 2

0 0

1 0

0 0

02 2

2 0

2 1

1 2

0 2

2 1 Bar, Pie, Line, Area, Scatter. 2 00 2 Multi graph option

Can join a local file but not two master files in one report

More complex reports are better created in DeveloperStudio.

Can compute a new field and use that field as a filter value

Specifying output to Excel or PDF requires rerun. Each rerun requeries the

database.

If user wants a chart and table, need to create two separate windows

Can use breaks and table of contents to create master detail

It's a toggle but each report is one type of output.



Page 84 of 129


1 34 Chart controls




2 42

2 43 Undo


70


2 46 Modifiable SQL


2 48 Readable SQL




applet


2 1

2

1 11 0

2 00

2 Interactive view displays data2 Query design mode shows fields only

1

0

1 1

69.2% 51.4%

Developer Studio12

2

2

1

0

Can format legend, but can't control scale, bar colors. Series menu allows

data values to be added.

Traffic lighting feature did not show format while defining and then had

unusual results.

Print report uses PDF, which sends away from report and back to main

screen. Users can only print a single window at a time.

Introduces ribbons but not well organized or intuitive.



Page 85 of 129


1 50 Column prompts

2 51 Filter prompts






2 59









3

2

0

2

11

22

2

2

3

2

22

2021

1

2202



Page 86 of 129






63






2 87







2

3

1202

122

81.0%

ReportCaster

2

2

2

2



Page 87 of 129









3 102 Filter



2





2

02 Active Reports

2

02

21

2

21

0 12

There is an Annotate in InfoAssist but not easy to place annotation.

Freeze in InfoAssist. Specify freeze and then rerun. It freezes columns but not

rows.

O120

Cindi Howson: Note: MSTRAT has good interactivity with OLAP services but not Report Services. See the full vendor evaluation for more information.



Page 88 of 129


2 107

51


Add-In

2 108

3 109















2

75.0%

Quick Data Plug In

0

2

200

2

2

Active Reports AJAX has the most robust capabilities. SWF output version

currently lacks charting.



Page 89 of 129


OLAP Data Sources









2 127

2



2 133






0

0

2

312

22

71.4%



Page 90 of 129






OLAP Viewer






32


Administration




1

0

25.0%



Page 91 of 129



1 150

2 151




2 156



2 159


1 161






ETL to report




Page 92 of 129




29


2 164


1 169

2 170












2

222

1

3

2 Since 2004

22



Page 93 of 129



24





2

107.1%

0



Page 94 of 129





Prompting

1 6 Column prompts








applet

MicroStrategy

MicroStrategy 8 MicroStrategy 9 Comments

31

12

2

33

2

22

22

2

2

1 2

Save prompt selections change in 9 - Load Answers

One object can also point to multiple data sources, so aggregate one db

and detail another



Page 95 of 129




2 19




2 23 Subquery

2 24






Charting





MicroStrategy

1

2

2

3

2

2

3

1

2

2

2

2

0

122

Better in 9 for filter on report can come from other data sources, but report services still has constraints

Users can save a list of prompt answers and load as filter.

Nice visual cues of charts in 9, but still only graphs measures that are there.



Page 96 of 129


1 34 Chart controls




2 42

2 43 Undo


70


2 46 Modifiable SQL


2 48 Readable SQL




applet

MicroStrategy

1 2 Better in 9 in Web

1

1 21

111 22

2

1

2

95.4%

Report Services22 via FreeForm SQL

1

1

1

2

Color bands make it easier to apply, without having to create formulas



Page 97 of 129


1 50 Column prompts

2 51 Filter prompts






2 59








MicroStrategy

2

3

3

2

22

22

2

1

2

2

22

0212

1

1221



Page 98 of 129






63






2 87






MicroStrategy

1

1

1 2112

2 3 Auto table of contents, pagination12

82.5%

Narrowcast

1 22

2 1

2

2

2

2

1 2

Now in Web product, not just Desktop. Nice sliders and default

ranges

Distribution Services

Distribution Services more integrated in v9. There is a migration tool.

Each query is rerun for each recipient in v9, whereas Narrowcast was run

once then parse

Users can subscribe themselves or others by entering email address

Narrowcast allowed for system admin to define alerts, but in 9, users can

define their own alerts



Page 99 of 129









3 102 Filter



2




MicroStrategy

2

202 Via Flash

2

10

22

1

21

22

Before portal integration was optional fee, now included

MSTRAT has good interactivity with OLAP services but not Report Services. See the full vendor evaluation for more information. Table of contents is auto created in PDF.



Page 100 of 129


2 107

51


Add-In

2 108

3 109














MicroStrategy

2

77.3%

Office 8

2

1

302

0

2

20

2

In 9, extreme AJAX pushes UI processing to local java VM so less

server round trips



Page 101 of 129


OLAP Data Sources









2 127

2



2 133





MicroStrategy

0

1

210

2

57.7%

ROLAP3

2

2

22

2



Page 102 of 129






OLAP Viewer






32


Administration



MicroStrategy

22

122

3

1

1

2 31

30

22 Multi select user defined groupings

109.6%

83.3%

In 8, charts were drill down; in 9, it's also drill by



Page 103 of 129



1 150

2 151




2 156



2 159


1 161






ETL to report

MicroStrategy

2

2 Security in 9 can now be decentralized

2

2

2

2

1

2

3 Enterprise Manager

3

2 2 Integrity Manager introduced in v8

2 Multiple development teams improved

Improved in 9 but it is updated in batch



Page 104 of 129




29


2 164


1 169

2 170











MicroStrategy

2 Object manager

3

110.0%

2

2233

3

3

2

2

32

2New in 9. In v8, had to have multiple

projects for each language



Page 105 of 129



24




MicroStrategy

2

118.2%

1

2

Integrated with Eclipse IDE for Web presentation and Flex.



Page 106 of 129





Prompting

1 6 Column prompts








applet


Report Builder Answers (Original teComments

2 32 2

0 21 6 MB Client Plug In 2

0 0

0 10 0

0 0

0 00 2

00 can enter as not specified 2

2 1

2 1

0 3

Can't do prompts in Report Builder, only in Report Designer

Work flow nonsensical, buggy, and resource intensive

You can only filter data that is also an output column. In theory, a way to define in meta data layer, but not documented and could not be validated



Page 107 of 129




2 19




2 23 Subquery

2 24






Charting






0 1 Would use dashboards for this

2 2

1 Oracle added in SP2 3

3

2

0 2

0 2

2

02 2

1 2

0 2 Compound layout

1 no master detail 1

0 1

2 20 1 Overlay chart, mixed bar and line0 1

Users can define an advanced filter that may allow this by coding their own SQL in the filter line. However, testing this generated an error (OpenQuarter=CloseQuarter)

Master/detail only available for pivots. Sections don't start on new page and display extraneous data.

Chart types are adequate and build process improved in 10.1.3.3

EG

W20

Cindi Howson: but its one query on a page/worksheet



Page 108 of 129


1 34 Chart controls




2 42

2 43 Undo


70


2 46 Modifiable SQL


2 48 Readable SQL




applet


2 2

2 2

0 20

2

0 02 2

1 1

2 0

1 1

41.5% 81.6%

Reporting Services XML Publisher2 2 OBI EE can be a data source to a query2 2

2 2

2 1

2 0

0 1 Query yes, presentation no

Can specify bar colors, scale. Process is not very intuitive.

No headers/footers, no fit to page, can break on groups, Active X print control

Dashboards easier to use but usability issues in Answers portion

Query Builder available for new queries or write SQL

Code in SQL but not through menus or toolbars

What actually gets submitted with parameters is not shown



Page 109 of 129


1 50 Column prompts

2 51 Filter prompts






2 59









0 0

2 2

0 0

1

2 1

0 All option but it submits a null value in query2 1

2 1 Need to code in SQL, no picklist provided

2 Multiple data sets 2

2 OLAP and relational 1

1 2

Word or Adobe are design environments2 22 2

0 1 Appears as template drop down in browser2 20 02 2

1 0Leverages BI Beans

21

A drop down menu appears while viewing the report

Can display description but not sort order

List of values are query specific and you choose the column

Can link the values but it doesn't appear to be genuine cascade

There is a Null and Blank but no optional

Data model can contain multiple data sources

SQL Query, Web Service, XML Feed. No OLAP

Option to use cached result set. Data and presentation layers are separate. But this may only be for the report session and not shared across users.

Separation of query and templates poses problems

EG



Page 110 of 129






63






2 87







2

2 0

2 What if logic21 Customize XML files 0 Design the RTF template with no data2 2

2 2

2 2 Whatever is in Word or Adobe

80.9% 68.1%

2 22 0

2 1

3 2

1

2 0

2 2

2

Define within Web-based Report Manager

This would be the biggest weakness, but problems in testing this. Needs verification.

includes XML output, Web Archive, PDF, Excel, CSV

Publisher: PDF, XML, Excel, RTF. One output per schedule. 10.1.3.3.2 does not include XL.

Publisher: email, printer, fax, web server, but Answers uses different scheduler



Page 111 of 129









3 102 Filter



2





2 2

21 20 2 Briefing books and disconnected option

1

0 10 0

2

1 can insert comments in MSAS

0 01 2

0 2

2 12 1

2 00 0

Yes, via MOSS but not clear on BI-specific content

iPhone support, limited capabilities for particular KPI app

Viewing capabilities vary in Dashboard and Publisher

Depends if parameter implemented and cache settings, which requires specific DB credential settings

Must be explicitly enabled in Answers, not in Publisher unless Flash output



Page 112 of 129


2 107

51


Add-In

2 108

3 109















0 0

62.2% 60.9%

Office Add-In

1 Word with Soft Artisans 0

2 2

1 22 0

0

1 2

1

2 10

1 0

Only Publisher currently has Flash output as option, but not documented, and can't save disconnected. Charts within dashboards may be Flash output but it's not leveraged

(Refer to SmartView scores that works with OBI EE as of July 08); Below scores refer only to the Office Add-In

Query New tables but not business view

not drillable, not leveraging server data



Page 113 of 129


OLAP Data Sources









2 127

2



2 133






3 0

2 1

2 2

1 21 00 0

2 1

77.1% 53.6%

Analysis ServicesMOLAP mainly ROLAP

3 3

3 2

3 ROLAP, HOLAP, MOLAP

2 12

20

2 2

2 2

XML Publisher Analyzer has particular export to pivot capabilities.

Sections of the cube are stored as separate partions



Page 114 of 129






OLAP Viewer






32


Administration




2 22 2

2 122

1 1

0 2

2 0

2 hover over mouse tip 20 no write back in web part 2

2 10 0

0 not in WebPart Analytic 222 0

106.0% 84.6%

84.6% 31.8%

Calculated item can include case statement and be scripted

RS can access MSAS but 2 meta data layers

Performance Point 2007 with ProClarity

Drill in web part but no pivot, drill is expand, not drill and filter; no sorting within analytic grid

No drill up, just back button. No preview of tree navigation. No pivot.

Somewhat hidden but possible via filter



Page 115 of 129



1 150

2 151




2 156



2 159


1 161






ETL to report


2

2 2

2

0 2

2

2

2 2

2

1 2

1 2

0 0

0

This could be easier, though, more manual steps and variables than in other tools



Page 116 of 129




29


2 164


1 169

2 170












0

0

50.0% 73.9%

2 1

1 12 11 22 1

1 1

0 2

22

1 21 limit time but not rows 2 Publisher lacks governers

Publisher supports multiple locales

Publisher, OBI EE, Hyperion product lines all have separate servers and administration.

Open report with Report Builder, get an error, different views with ProClarity can't be modified

if certain credentials stored with report

Publisher caching limited to session, not multi user



Page 117 of 129



24





2

58.3% 82.5%

2



Page 118 of 129





Prompting

1 6 Column prompts








applet


WRS 3.1 Comments QlikView 8Comments

2 01

13 0 authoring is in desktop

0 0

20 2 When OLAP data source

1 1 Option to specify case insensitive good

0 2 20 2 2

20 2

0 1 1

1

2

Web Report Studio 4.2

There is not a business view. Expressions are defined within each sheet

Associative memory shows related data values automatically

Calendars new but no checkboxes, radio, even the cascade display could be improved

No radio buttons, check boxes just ctrl click



Page 119 of 129




2 19




2 23 Subquery

2 24






Charting






2 2

0 1 0

2 2

2

0

2

0

0

1

1 2

3 2

2 1

2 2

1 2 Heat map, mixed bar/line 22 22 0

Concept of composite infromation map introduced

Wrong results are stated for many-to-many relationships

Caching improved in 9.2 but need to clarify how

Note that Enterprise Guide does much betterE

G



Page 120 of 129


1 34 Chart controls




2 42

2 43 Undo


70


2 46 Modifiable SQL


2 48 Readable SQL




applet


1 2 2

1 1 2

3 20

100 0 02 2 1

2 0

0 1

1

65.4% 60.5%

More extensive in 9.2, but not clear if you can you add logo on header.

Some work flows improved, but visual appeal needs improving



Page 121 of 129


1 50 Column prompts

2 51 Filter prompts






2 59









EG



Page 122 of 129






63






2 87







2 20

2 Burst to PDF or HTML but not to Excel 2

1 2 Schedule to Excel added in 9.2 2

1

2

2 2

2 2

Plublisher module not provided for testing

Business alerts were previously only part of SAS portal and now introduced in BI Dashboard in 9.2



Page 123 of 129









3 102 Filter



2





2 2

2 2 020 0 2 Via exe file

1 00 0

0

2 Report comments0

2 01 2

2 2

2 21

22

Sharepoint WebParts for BI Dashboard and stored process, but not for WRS. Others supported through JSR 168



Page 124 of 129


2 107

51


Add-In

2 108

3 109















1 Available in BI Dashboard 1

75.6% 63.9%

2

2

223 Can preview data chunks on server

2

2

20

3

Parts of a chart can be animated, but no ajax or mht file.

Can access Information Map or tables directly

AMO has additional charting capabilities than Excel only



Page 125 of 129


OLAP Data Sources









2 127

2



2 133






2

0 2 New scheduler in 9.2

210

2

80.8%

MOLAP / HOLAP In-memory OLAP3 2 Greater scale with 64-bit

1 1 2

NA

2 10

20 00 2 2

0 0

The OLAP drill uses enhanced Excel pivot capabilities

Single star schema only. With Composite Information Maps this may work better in 9.2 but it's a workaround

Extensive function library in expressions and could do such calculations by nesting IF statements but not as straightforward as other OLAP tools or MDX.

The expressions are processed on the fly so correctly recalculated



Page 126 of 129






OLAP Viewer






32


Administration




2 12 2

1 11 02 0

2 NA

1 0

2 1

2 20 2 Not write back but can do what-if

2 1 Formula0 2

2 22

2 2

73.1% 48.1%

81.8% 80.8%

Need to create calculations, no understanding of YTD, period to date

Can extract from but not access live



Page 127 of 129



1 150

2 151




2 156



2 159


1 161






ETL to report


22

Yes for roles

2

2

2 Via Publisher

1

1

0 2

2 0

0

Server module not provided for testing

Information is captured to log files but no prebuilt reports or Information Maps to leverage

Can kill queries from central management console



Page 128 of 129




29


2 164


1 169

2 170












2 0

0

75.0%

2

2322

1

2 0

2 2

2 WebDAV

0 20 NA



Page 129 of 129



24





79.5% 71.4%

1

Bi Scorecard Blank

Documents

3rd party

prior written

kpi multiple

bi reach time

oracel bi

bi reach importantessential

drill nonstandard

detail presentation