Top Banner
'• bb�fl1�fl11fl1� (KM Action Plan) n11�1b uA�B11�11�111u�flA1B bb11 . fl. @ n1u1fl�1 bu�flfl I @. U1 fll1mL 1 U (Labour Law) L ufll1�LL�1e1�1 �fl1 efl11"e 1�1LL�efl11e�fl1 11�11fl11�fh�11�1 �fl1 LL��efl11�fl�11�eU �e u u LL��e� L �e1fl1111 fl111iLL 11 fl11U1�flefl11 LL��fl11lih�111�1LL�fl1 u L11�� L 1�11��1� 1�m �vh1Ln�m1l�"fl11L� LL�m1l�fl LL1 � 1 � fl 1 fll LL� �1� L 1 � 1�� fl fll1 � LL 1 1 U 1� L 1 �1 i �1 U . . I Q 4 I Q Q 4 l�1�O eL " �1�111LL 11l� �.. ?®� �1�111�1mL 11LL��111 fi�LL11 �.. 1�111U�1h��fl .. 1�111U�L�LL .. l 1�11U� Alfl1�LL 1��1 �-. ?�® �1�111Dm1l�e� m1e1� LL�fn�Ln�el1 fl1111 �.. ??� ' �1�111�LL 11�1nl �.. ?� �1�11u�lfl1e��111�1 �.. ?? u LL��1�11�LL 111�L�.. ??� �fll1mL 11flO�fl�11l1�LL � fl1� 1�1e11=1�1 �41 �fll1 �1�e�1�� L0�1�e�n1L41U1� 1� 1�1e1�flfi�1�1�fle1�1 � 1 1mL��1�f 1n1�n�1l�e�1�m�1m11��fll1mL 1111 . 1fl�1ml,�,1�lflebb1 .fl. @ 1 �1�111D�lfl1e�LL11 l1m1 ? 1�fl11ll1�"mfh111�41 11 "��n�n41 u L111 b��1�fh411 LL��1�fl1111lfi ®) �1�flel1�111LL 1�41 u ) 1m�1�41L �flfl� 1l1 �fl1111 �a11m�1m1LL i�flfl� LL��1�f " lel1�1fl�11m�1fl11LL i�flfl�11fl11LL ��" u ' l111 ; "1m��u1�flenfl1,.ll1�1flfi�flfl�1�L u�1fi111m fl11U1�fle1fl�11 1��fl1111LU�1� 1fl1�11� �e1fl1fl11lf��e "e�U1�flefl11 LL��1�flfl�L U�flfll�LL�fl1111�e�e1fl11�1��1411LLfi�1 11�e1�n1l 1�e11�u1�fle nfl11LU1�41"efi�l111�fl�11, u � 1�411�1�111D��lfl1eLL 11 �111 LL Uee1�L UeU1�L 1�LL1�1 1 1 L uflfi�11l�1LL��1�1L uflfl� 1 "1 1" I . 1 ; 1 ;. . 1 . ; ; L u ;. ; flfi ; . 1 1 . l ; �; 1 L u1 1 � LLfl ®) flfl��n�f� n41L1111��1�1411 L 1m�1n�411�1Tvh1LU�n1 u u �1LL�1n1 1L�L�e 1®o,ooo 1 1mm�m�1�LU141"e1"11 ) �1�lel111fl11LL 141 L 1m m L41"e flfl11lel111�1� fl11 u u 1 1ua11�nm1�11 LL 1� 1fl1��1�11�n1"e fl�1�11L�e® ,ooo 1 efl1fl1�Lm�LU11LL�1 1��1�1�LU11"e1Yhan�1 . 1 �u ' 4 o - - u �l Lfln , fl1U1fn1LL11L n11tnn�! ------ ---- -------- 1
15

bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

Nov 28, 2021

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

'•

bb�'I.Jfl1'f��fl11fl'l1:U� (KM Action Plan) '1.1

n11�1b iluA�B1ru1�1:ucr.�1�11"11ururu�fl:uA1B.:J bb 1-!I-!11'1.J cr.�. fl. �£�ct'tr@ n1ruu1fl�1-!l b t!uil�'Uflfl� QJ QJ QI • 'II

@. U'V1'\J1 �� .J cv Cl.l�.ct <=�t, .o:::��t. II .J II II 4'

fl!JV!l.l1mL 1-:J .. :nU (Labour Law) L u'Ufl!JV!l.l1�'Vl'IJfYfYI'ltl'IG'I'VlliLL��V!'U1'Vl"tle.l'I'U1�';11'1 �fl-;)1'1 e.J'Iflfl11"tle.J'I

'U1�..ij1'1LL��e.J'Ifi'fl11"tle.J'I�fl..ij1'1 11lJ�'IlJ11'l1fl11�fhvt'U� 1l1'U1�..ij1'1 � fl..ij1'1 LL��e.J'Ifi'fl11�'1fl�11�e.J'IU i1'1J��e.J tl'U u u �

LL���e.J�\i �'I.Q' L �e.J 1l1fl11..ij1'1'11'U fl111 iLL 1'1'11'U fl11U1�fle.J'I.Jfl';Jfl11 LL��fl11lJ"'l.JoW'Uih�vt11'1'U1�..ij1'1LL���fl..ij1'1 � u

L'iJ'W1 'IJ1�� L vtlJ1�G'IlJ�1-:�1��'1J'IJ1� 1�"lft1��m Vi�-:� eJ'U-;]�iit:.J�vh1l1Ln�m1l.IG'I-:�'IJ�"tlfl11lJL';J�fY LL��m1l.l�'Ufl'l

LLrl'U1 �..ij 1'1 � fl..ij 1'1 "''I fll.J LL� �'IJ 1� L 'VI 1"1"111 � 1� � fl flvtl.J1 � LL 1 'I '11 'U"tl eJ 'IU 1� L 'VI 1"11 'VI ��1 i'IJ-:� �'IJ eJ �1 'U U ';1-;]tJ'U tT'U � � � .

... .G:II Q.l 4. I QJ Q..ooiQ. Cl.l CV 4' Cl.l Cl,AII::t.QJ Q.l Clt.-=:14. l.JV!�1 � O'IJ'IJ e.J1'Vl L "lf'U �1�11"11'1JfYfYI'lLL 1'1'11'UG'Il.J�'Uli �.Pl. �!Jet®� �1�11"11'1JfYfYI'l';l�l'l'IP11mL 1'1'11'ULL��'dli�';l11ru1

fi�LL1'1'11'U �.Pl. l!lcti!JI!J '1"11�11"11Ut1JtY�1.h�ti''UG1�fllJ '1"1.1"1. l!lctrnrn '1"11�11"11Ut1JtY�L�'U'Vl�LL'Vl'U '1"1.1'1. \!,ctrnl>'ll '1"11�11'1lUt1JrY�

Al.lfl1tJ�LL 1��1'U �-Pl. \!Jet�® �1�11"11Druru'im1l.l'IJ�e.J�.tl� m:fi1e.J'U1:W'� LL��G'Ifn�Ln��e.Jl.l 1 'Ufl11vl1'11'U �.Pl. l!letet� ' "' "'

�1�11"11'1Jruru�LL 1'1'11'U�\i1G'!Tvtn';J"'l.JoW''Ui5 �.Pl. l!let�Q1 �1�11"lfururu�fi'l.Jfl1e.J-:���'IJ'�1'U1 '1Jvi1�.U1'U �.Pl. l!letetQ1 .., Ll aU cu u .. 'U

LL���1�11"lftJruru�LL 1'1'11'U'Vl1'1'Vl�L� �.Pl. I!Jetet� "' "'

�'lfl!JV!l.l1 mL 1'1'11'U'YJflOtJ'IJ�fl�11l.l1tT'U�'d'ULL�ii'IJ'Vl fl1V!'U� 1 'Vl�'V11'1e.l1qj1611vt�'IJ'U1 �41'1 ��fl!JV!l.l1 �

'1Jryt[�1l1�e.J'I�'IJ�� 1�� L0�1� vt�e.J�'I!n-:�1'UL41vtU1� 1�� 1 'Vl�'Vl1'1e.l1fY1�'4flfi�';J� 1��'1JtT'U-;]�'IJ1�fle.J'IJ1 'IJ�1 �

1 'Vl'l�''il1fJmL�� 1 'Vl�'t.Jf'IJ vt1n1�'1Jn'IJ�I'l1l.Jvt�e.J�1�'Um�v11m11 'U�'��fl!Jvtl.l1mL 1'1'11'U'IJryry1i11

l!:J. 'LJ1fl�1.:Jml.l"W,.�,.1,n1ruru�fi'l.Jfl"ae.J.:Jbb "a.:J.:J1'LJ "W.fl. l!J<rt£@ 1 Ql Ql •

�1�11"11Druru�fi'l.lfl1e.J�LL1'�'�1'U"1 l.l1m1 et 1� l1fl11l.lvtl.l1�"tlmfh11'U1�41-:� 11 "��-:�l'ln�-:��'IJ�n41-:� cu u 'I 'U 'U

LoU1vl1'11'U b���1�fh41-:�1l1 LL��V!lJ1�fl11lJ11l.Jfi'l

®) ��'11�f'I.Jl.Je.J'IJV!l.J1� 1l1vl1'11'ULL 'Vl'U'U1�41'1 u

l!l) 1 'Umru�'U1�41-:�L tl'U'u�'IJ flfl� 1l1vtl.J1 �fl11lJ11lJCi-:� �iia1'U1';Jm�v11m1LL 'Vl'U'ii�'IJ flfl� LL����-:�1�f'IJ " 'U 'I 'U

l.le.J'IJV!l.l1�';11 fl�:iM1'U1';1 m�vl1fl11 LL 'Vl'U'ii�'I.Jflfl� 1l1v11fl11LL 'Vl'U�'d �" u '

l.J11'l11 (9)(9); C9) "1 'Umru��u1�fle.J'I.Jn';Jfl1,.l.Jtl'IJV!l.J1� 1l1'1Jflfi�V!�'I'I.Jflfl� 1� L u'U�'<il'�vt1fi'UlJ1vl1'11'UeJ'Um '1i \I 'I 'I 'U

fl11U1�fle.J'I.Jli1fl';J'<il'�vt1'11'U 1��fl11vl1'11'UtY'U L U'UG'i'd'UV!�'IG'i'd'U 1� 1 'Ufl1�'1J'd'Uf111t:.J� (;1Vf�e.Jli1fl';J 1 'U fl11l.lf'IJ��"lfe.J'IJ • •

"tle.J'I�U1� fle.J'IJ fl';Jfl11 LL�� 1� �'IJflfl�tT'U';J� L U'U�fl'd'I.Jfll.J� LL� fl11vl1'11'UV!�e.l�'IJ��"lfe.J'IJ 1 'Ufl11�1��141-:�1l1 LLrlfi'U�lJ1 'U 'I 'U 'I 'U

vl1'11'UtY'Uvt�e.J 1�nl'l1l.J 1l1�e.J11�u1�fle.J'IJ n';J fl11L U'U'U1 �41'1"tle.l'lfi'U�l.J1vl1'11'U�'Ifl�11, u

�'ltT'U 'U1�41'11'l1lJ�1�11"11DfYtY��l.Jfl1e.J'I LL 1'1'11'U., �'IG'I1lJ11tlLL U'le.Je.Jf11� L U'UG'Ie.J'IU1�L.f1'Vl 1�LLrl'U1�..ij1'1 .J .?1 .., .J .?1 """" 'VI L u'U'I.Jflfi�Li11l.l�1 LL��'U1 �';11-:I'Vl L u'U'UI'l'I.Jflfl�

• •

""' .., .J.?1 ".?1 .., 1"

I

"""'"fl..;..1 ru;;.;.;..;.;'U;...;. 1.;;;;..ti';J..;..1.;..'1;.;. 'Vl;.;. L u.;;;;..'U.;.;;. 'IJ� fl fi;..;. �;;.;.. Li;;...1;;....; 1..;.. l.J;.;..; �;...;. 1 � L u'U'U1 tl ';11'1 � LLfl

®) 'I.Jflfl��l'l n�-:�f'IJ� n41-:� L oU1vl1'11'U 1���1tl�141-:�1l1 L 'li'W 'U1m :U�11'l n�-:�41'1'U1 �"ti1Tvh-:�1'UL U'U� n..ij1-:� • u u

�1LLvt'l1-:��'11n-:�1'U'IJfY:tl 1l1L�'UL�e.J'U 1�� ®o,ooo 'IJ1'Vl 'U1m:Um�m.Jii�1'U�L U'U'U1t�41'1"tle.J'I'U1tl"tl11

I!J) ��1��'1Jl.Je.J'IJV!l.J1ti1l1v11fl11LL 'Vl'U'U1t141'1 L 'li'U 'U1m :fim L41"tle.J'I fl';Jfl11l.Je.l'IJV!l.J1 t�1l1'U1tl�1�'<il' � fl11 u u

vt1 1 uiia1'U1';J'<il'�n';Jm1�1'�1 LL 'Vl'U 1� vt1fl'U1��1�1'1'U1m�h iJ'U�'I!n-:�1'U6'i-:�"tJe.J-:� (;lfl�-:�1l1�1..ij1-:�L�e.J'U�� ®l!l ,ooo 'IJ1'Vl

'Ue.Jfl';J1fl'U1�L:fim';J�LU'U'U1ti..ij1'1LL�1 'U1��1�'1ii\i1'U�LU'U'U1ti..ij1'1"tle.J'I'U1t!Yhan�1ti ...

1 �u ' 4 � o -. .J -. u � 'l'l'l�"illltJ Lfl"itlnl'ltJ , fl1€li'iU1f.ln-!J'I1:U1EJLL "i'I'I11.JL 'l'ltln1"i'LJ"il11"i'Vl"i'l'ltnn"i:U'4�!.l

------ ---- --------

1

Page 2: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

m rih.n t�"hn U'l.l'U� 'U 1"11"1� � b Utiti1 r.��\:�1�\bfi .:...:..;..=..;;.;;..;..;:;...:....;..;.;..;;;..;�.;..,;;;.;..;.;..;..:..; 'U

C9l) il�'Ul"ll"l���'U�fr-h:tb-b'1vhnti 1�r.��1r.JfiT�1-:�1 � • 'U

l"lTJ1 "il�'Ul"ll"l�" (Juristic person) 'VIl.l1r.Ji'i-:�-v-:�l"lm'VI�Bl"ltu�'Ul"ll"l��nf1Vn.J1r.J fl1'VIti� 1 �b Uti'Ul"ll"l� " , � ,

?11l.ITH1Vl1-:J �Vl5 bb� �V1'l!1� ml.l� n!J'VIll1 r.� n1'VIti � 1� �-:J'VIl.l1 r.� 5-:�il � 'i 1"11"1� mllth�ll1 � n!J 'VIl.l1 r.� Lb �-:� bb� �'V'l1 ru'U � AA d u��ti�1.il"ll"l��1lln!)'VIl.l1r.JBti

il�'il"ll"l� mllth�ll1�n!J'VIll1 mL �-:� Lb��'V'l1ru'll r.�1�LLn ?lll1l"ll.J lJ�il5 �1-:J�tici1ti?11l1'ty"ii �Vl� b iJ t�ti �1-!l�tici'Jti"ih n� bb� �'\J�-Mvro.h n ��1�"ii�Vl � b iJ r.Jti bb�1

ci1tiil�'il"ll"l�ml.ln!)'VIll1r.J�ti "ii�bb ti-:�1 tl� 1l.l�n!)'VIl.l1r.J bbtol��utJ'U n1'VIti�1 �v-:�1"1 m1�ii:i1ti� b Uti il�'il"ll"l�ml.ln!J'VIl.l1mr1-:� b'llti 'V'l1�11'11D'Y��'\J�-MV1ll'VI1'1Jti"ihn� 'V'l.!31. I!:J<tQl<t n1'VIti� 1 �'\J�-MV1ll'VI1'1Jti"ihn� Ldv"ii�Vl� L iJ r.Jtibb�1 �Bllii�1ti�b Utiil�'il"ll"l� 'VI�B'V'l1�11'11Dty��1� b Ur.J'\J'\J�'VI1111'1lfl11bb�ti�ti 'V'l.!31. I!:J<tQl�

n1'VIti� 1 ��Twnti1r.Jn��l.lti�� m�Vl11-:J Vl'U1-:Jbb��ml.l ii�1ti�b Utiil�'Ul"ll"l� b Uti�ti � � .

1!:>) �iieJ1ti1"ii,.,1fl11 bb Vltiil�'Ul"ll"l� 'U •

il�'il"ll"l� �B 1�11b Utib Vi r.J-!11.il"ll"l��n!)'VIl.l1r.J�-:J�ti b �B 1 �ii�VJ5VI'l!1�ml.ln!J'VIl.l1 m vhtTti hliil'l1 �ti�1l.l l"l11l.lb Uti"ii�-!1 fl11bb?l�-:� b"ii�ti1"llv-:Jil�'Ul"ll"l��-:��v-:� bb?I�-:JBBn 1�r.��iirl1ti1"i1,.,1fl11bb Vltiil�'U l"ll"l�tTti., �-:�-db Uti 1 tl

, \.1 , I ... 1.1 ClJ' CL1 4 C1.1 Q.l ..:=t...:=t. I �1l.J"lJB'U-!Il"l'\J'VI1B�11?111"ii��-!lti�'Ul"ll"l� b 'Uti

- '\J�-Mwihn�bb��'\J�-MV1ll'V11'1Jti'ihn� 1�Lbn m1l.Jfl11�iirl1ti1"il,.,1fl11bb Vlti 'U

- �1-!l�tici1ti?l1l1'f11"iJ�Vl� b iJ r.Jtibb���1-!l�tici1ti"ihn� 1� bbn �tici'Jti��� m1 1 a� 1 1 \1

- ?ll.J1l"llJ 1�bbrl f111l.Jfl11?1l.J1l"ll.l - m�Vl11-:J Vl'U1-:J 1�Lbn ��l.lti�� ... - ml.l 1�Lbn v5'U� bUw;i'ti

Ql) en��'\Jl.JB'\JeJ1ti1"ii 1 �iirl1ti1"i1,.,1fl11bb Vltiil�'Ul"ll"l� 'U '

'Ul"ll"l��ii�1ti� b Utiti1 t��1-:� Vll.l1 r.�i'i-:� 'Ul"ll"l��1��'\Jl.JB'\J'VIl.l1r.J"i11nil �'\J l"ll"l�'VI�B�bb Vltiil�'U 1"11"1� 1 ,Xij "' "" , • '\1 ,

eJ1ti1"ii,.,1fl11bb Vlti b 'lfti mrun11l.Jfl11�ijeJ'1ti1"ii"lJB-!I'\J�-MVl iil.J1n "iJ1n� lJB'\JeJ1ti1"ii1 �ti1r.Jbb�-!l��� fl11'*11 tl 'U 'U

iieJ1ti1"ii 1 tifl1111�1-!l bb�� b� n�1-:1� n�1-!lbb Vlti'U�-MV11� 1 ti b�B-!1 b�r.J1 n'Ufl11�1-!l bb�� b�n�1-!l� n�1-:1 ti1r.Jbb�-:Jii�1ti�

.:I I II CII..IIClt.

'U 'U ...

Ql.Vlq��11�1ati�1.il"ll"l�

Q1.(9) Vl'l����B11il�'il"ll"l� b UtieJ1ti1"ii"llB-:J�tl nl"l1B-:J1 tiV11-!Ifl11biiv-:� C9l) Vl'l��fl1'VIti�bB1 b B-!12 (Fiction theory or fiction theorie) Vl'l��d1��B11il�'il"ll"l�

b Uti'Ul"ll"l�'VI�B nv-:�VJ�'V'l��ti�11l.lnti n f1'VIlJ1r.J 1��'\JTI�r.J?Illll�1 �b Uti'Ul"ll"l�B nl"lti'VI�-:�1'11-:�'V11n bii��ti 1� r.�ml'i'r.� 'I dJ \J , ,

eJ1ti1"il"lJB-!!n!)'VIl.l1r.J 'VI11�ij�Ji'1�ti'VI�Bl"l11l.JbUtiB�B�1-!IbbVl"ii�-!!1lJ n!)'VIl.l1r.JB1"ii"ii� 1 �?lm'V'lil�'il"ll"l� 'VI�mlvti?l.fl1'V'l ""A d 1 �1"' ti�'Ul"ll"l�bl.IB 1n �

?111��1�ru"llB-:JVJ n�fi-d'v5'U1 r.J?I.fl1'V'l"llB-:J'Ul"ll"l�11 b Uti�-:J?Il.Jll �11Jiil'l1�tiB � B �1-:1 bb Vi'"il�-:� � ul d.J "' '1. \J

il�'i l"ll"l��-!1 b Uti�-!!� n!)'VIl.J1 rJ 1�fi�'VI�B 1�n1'VIti�offtibB-!I'VI11�iil'l1�ti L�r.J bb Vl"ii�-:J11J 1!:>) Vl'l��l"l11l.l�tir.JBl.J (Concession theory) Vl'l��dbUtiVl'l���bn�offti'V'liBll1n'UVl'l��

n1'VIti�bmLB-:J Vl'l��d�v11 l"l11l.lb Utiil�'il"ll"l� Ln��tibdvn!J'VIll1r.J 1 �m1l.l�tit�Bl.l Lb��?l.fl1'V'll"l11ll b Utiil�'i 1"11"1�

2

Page 3: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

�a.:J � U'U 1 tl m�� n�vt�1mhvt'UV� 'Vl(]�� 1"111� �'U � a�-d'�m'f .n1¥�ti�� 1"11"1(;1 � 'li'U�� m n'U'Vl(]�� rhvt'UV� � m �a.:J ��� �'UEJ'U11-r�� vhtT'U� U'U��1'1Ja.:J?tm¥�'W�ul"ll"l(;l ?f.fl1¥�'UI"ll"l(;l'Vl1-:J nf1vt�1��-:Jvt�1 �t1-:J ?t.n1¥�'U l"ll"l��n f1V!�1 � 1 vt\"111�

dol , .. dJ .. d.J A 4 I Q.l I � del I I II A �'U�a����:::flm1im'Vl1'U'U'Vl�a�a�1-:J��wili.:J

... 'IJ

rn.l!l 'Vl(]����a11�n�ru:::'lJa.:Jti��l"ll"l(;l�tJ'U�.:Ji1vt�mmwsn (non-fiction theory)

C9l) 'Vl(j���l"l�nm¥�'1Ja.:JI"lru:::�l"ll"l�B'U��Vi'"'ii�.:J (The group personation , realist , organic theory ,

socialogical theory ,or theorie derrealen verband spersonlichkeit) 'Vl(]��d�a11mi?f�11"l��U'UoUaLVi"'il"'ii�.:J 1 'U�.:JI"l� ��ai1mi�a�-ru LV��n�vt�1� "'iJ:::n(;11��1 � U'U�.:J��� Vl"'ii�.:J'Vl1-:Jn�vt�1� ��(;l:::?f.n1¥��1"ll"l�'lla.:Jti��l"ll"l� � U'U ..: d 111 d: 4 1.1 d: A. Q.l I 1 .J d .cd CV 1 _.,j .... 1 d ?1-:J'Vl��?IV�.:J vt�vt'Ufi.:J'llaL'Vl"'il"'ili.:JV�.:Jnm1 'UPlmii"�'Vl (9)� �miflnLfi�.:Jn'U�1n 'U�i"a.:J?f.fl1¥�'1Ja.:J'UI'l'UI"ll"l(;l 'U'llru�'Vl

,

'Vl(]��rhvt'UV��m�a.:J"'il:::¥�m�1�,]1fiV�I"l11�?11�1ifl'lla.:Jti��l"ll"l� ���'Vl(]���l"l�n.n1¥�'lla.:JI"lru:::�l"ll"l(;lel'U��Vi'"'ii�.:J1� ¥�mm�11-:Ji"1n�1'U 1 'Un1i"�a�-ru?tm¥�ti��l"ll"l(;l'Vl1-:J n�vtm� a�1-:J n11-:J'll11-:J LV�t.�1fimi"'i!V�'Vl::: � u �'U

l!l) 'Vl(]��mivh1Vf�tl'U�I"ll"l(;l��a11'1�tli�?!.:JI4 (Zweckvermogen of theoie) 'Vl(j��.Q �a11�1"11"1� nii"� V\1 � vhtT'U� � U'U'U 1"11"1(;11'11� n f1 vt� 1 � 3 11'1fltli:::?t.:J 14� �� Vl"'il �.:J'lla.:J?t .n 1¥�ti �u 1"11"1� � U'U ��a.:J'Vl-r¥1 ��'U� �a , 6J 'I 'I

11'1fltli:::?t.:JI4 �u¥11� � "'il1:l::"'ii.:J ti�'U\"11"1{;11�1 'liul"ll"l�� �� Vl"'ii�.:J � ¥�i1:l::'U l"ll"l(;lliii�V�1 � vhtT'U�?f1�1ifli1�'Vl5��� �vt'I.J1�1� .. , , ,

'Vln�fi mivh 1 VI� U'U'U 1"11"1(;1 � � a11'1 t�tl i ::::?1-:J 14-d � U'U m i� a.:J11ti�u 1"11"1� � U'U na.:J'Vl-r¥1 ��'U�i1 .. 1 d.J 'I 'I 'I

11'1fltli:::?t.:JI4�o¥�1:::�"'il1:::"'ii.:J �.:J�U'U'Vln�fi�l.l.:Ja5'U1�ti�ul"ll"l(;l���.:J'U1-:Jtli:::�.n'Vl bVhtT'U �'li'U ��ti5 �U'U�'U 'I .. , 6.1 'I , 'U

rn) 'Vl (] � � � -r 'U tl i:::: 1 � '11 '11 (Geniesser theorie or Bracket theory or The Symbolist or

Collectivist theory)

'Vln�fid�a11 ?1�1�n'lla.:Jti�ul"ll"l(;l�U'U�i1�'Vl5��(;1:::vt'I.J1� n�11�a ?1�1�m1�n'U�.:Jti�ul"ll"l�:ff'U���1 .. , dJ , 'U ,

1 i�a11ti�'UI"ll"l(;lel'Uvttl.:J�� 'Vl'U'UI"ll"l(;lvr.:Jvt�V\ � �al"ld1�?f:::Vt1n 1 'U n1i"�1 � ti'Umi"� vhtT'U . ,

'Vln�fid� �'U11 ��a�'Vl5��(;1:::vt'I.J1�'1Ja.:Jti�ul"ll"l(;l� �� Vl"'ii�.:J �a� 1� �� nu l"ll"l(;lnii"�V�1 �'Vl5'1Ja.:Jti �'U\"11"1(;1 .. , dJ 'U , , ,

� tl'U-u'a �Vi"'il"'ii�.:Jm m 1nu?t�1�n�� tl'U'U"'il �"'iln'lJ'U 1 'U'Vl1-:Jtl5u�m"'il"'il:::1l.l?t:::mn�"'il::: 1 vt�'Vl5� vt�1d� U'U'lJa.:Ju"'il �"'iln'11'U ���(;1::::\"l'U (;).:JtT'U u"'il�"'iln'11'U��u'U?t�1�n�.:J(;l:::�'Vl5LT'UH ��(;l:::vh1Vfu"'il�"'iln'11'Ui1�u'Uvt'l.bm�mn'U

16mi�a.:J11ti�'UI"ll"l�i1 � �atl1::: 1�'11tJ'lla.:Ju"'il � "'il n'11'U� � U'U?f�1� m!u-J1� U'U16m1�a.:Jt1-:Jti �u 1"11"1(;11 'U ' 'IJ '

?tm¥��"'ii�.:J 1 'U�.:JI"l� h1�d��vttl.:J vr.:Jd��a.:J"'i11nmi�n�vt�1 � 1 vt�.:J�'U'Uan"'il1 n����i1�'Vl5��(;1�vt111�1P11lm�vt�1 � 1�LT'U � '.i1ml-lmi�"'il���vt�n�11 n�vt�1tJ 1�ut1Jt1J�:ff'ULT'U� �a����vt�a�l"ll"l(;ln'.ii�V�1 � vhtT'U 1�1 'li� �a�.:J�'U 1V�€in vt1n 1� ut1Jt[�1 Vf�.:J�'U�.:J 1l.l1 'll����?t1mifli1�'Vl5 ��(;1 :::vt111�1'11� n�vt�1 � 1� fiLV�� 1 vtl"l11�?t:::V�1 n ��n1�'Vl1-:J�1 � ti'U'lla.:J �'U�6,j''U�a.:J LV� �mPi'�vt� nl"l11�"'il �.:J�11 m1�1 � ti'U�11'l'U1-:Ja �1-:J'lla.:J�'U�6J'U �'U�61"l'U �� �1vh 1l-lG11 � �"'il�m

, ' ,

mPI t.ll"l11��1�i1a"'il1nvt(;11�., l"l'U �.:J"'i!::::v\'1 m11� ���mi"�1�a� 1 'Uvtl.il"lru:::d vt1n 1l.i?t1�11fli1�'Vl5��(;1:::vt111�1�a�1-:J I " "

�l"ll"l(;ln11�V�1���1 mi�1� ti'U.:J1'U'lla.:Jvt�l"lru�� �an"'il mitT'Um"'il 1l.l?t:::V�1 n n�11�a"'ii�'Vl1-:J�'Vl51V�1 v11�t1Jt1J11V�1 1 'U'U1�vtl-ll"lru:::1l.l1� "'ii:::Yla.:J�a.:J�aP11(;1�a.:J1l.i1� i(;l, (;).:J.Q' ��al"l11�?t�mm�nm'.i�1�ti'Um1'lJa.:Jvtl.il"lru:::a'Ui1

'IJ 'IJ

t:-J�'Vl1-:JBa�1 vttl'.i� 1�'1l'l1��n�l"ll"l���tl'.i:::nau � tl'Uvt�l"lru:::LT'U n�vt�1 ��.:J1�utyt[�1 Vfvt�l"l ru:::LT'Ui1?t.n1¥� � tl'U ti�'UI"ll"l�:ff'U vtl.il"lru:::�i1?tm¥�'UI"ll"l(;l(;).:Jn�11d �a vt1-:Jvt'U611'U�1�"'iiV�'Vl:::�u�'U���1 u��'Vl,)1fiV� ?1�11"1� �U'U�'U

, 'U 'I 'I

ct:) 'Vl(j��n1vt'UV��m�a.:J�I"l1 vtl.l (Modern Fiction theory) � U'U'Vl(]���irn1'111n1i'U1-:JVh'U1�¥��1m� tJ-rutl�.:J'Vl(]��n1vt'UV��a1�a.:J 1Vfi1vt�mnrusn�1n�.:J:ff'U4LV�m��nn��'Vl(]��d€ina�1-:Jvttl.:J11 organic theory

3 Hughes,supra note m

4 Martin wolf , "on the Nature of Legal Person"

3

----- ----- ------ ------- --------- --

Page 4: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

--------�---

17

lA.L.11.1t1.L.�m�lt1.L.J.2 L.ful..Bl!l1.!11.11. 1l..l!l�L.UBrt� f"' 11 11 n o 11:0' � 0 ,.., s

n.

UL1.1�11 "�t:IG�J!t-��!.[1, L�Ur.l�1��t-��t:IG�Jlt'��!.fbrLP.Ll'\�W�r.l�1 np.�tt-�Ul!l�rtLl!lfb l Ll'\�W!.LU��t�m1

�t.!IA.rtLl!lLIA.�W ��lA.�, t-�U l!l!.LUrt LIA.�W ��IA.�t.!M:U .. t.! rt!.LU t-IJ r.l Lrtltl.t-�rLrLLrLl!l � 1 r.l �1LIA.�W!. LU "rLrl.LIA.�W!.LU '="� 0 F' l. F=' 0 F' � I=F � � � 0 � 0

n. n.

t-Gfl.�t:lrL� 1t-�1 rtGrG�Itl.�t:I��Jlt'��!.fbL!'\�!.U J:rL,Vtr.l�1�rufl.n t��11 Ll'\�!.U�!.LUrL tU!}L�kr.l�1 Ll'\�!.U�11�l

Lrl.l!l�1r.l�1 Ll'\�W, L�H�iU,CL�tLmL�r.lLrtltl.UU�r..rt�!.[bt-yt 11 t-��t.!!.!.t �;:> L!.l!lLrtrtLl!l LrLl!l�1r.l�1 Ll'\�W � .

!}t-� Ll'\�W!.LU�t-����LfUL�t-LIA.��n.l-t-���t�t.!t.!n.L�rtLtt.!r.lLrtltl.t-!i! "LrLl!l�1

�ftl r.l �1 L!A�W�Ut11 �� n.l-t-��� t ��t-�11 r.l �ll-t�,QJiU,CLr.lLrtltl.UU�U'lW n. t�1m_¥ 1B�It1.1A.Lrt�!.[br.l�1 Ll'\�W �l �p1

�t:ln.!.t-�l!lltl., l!lmmn.r.lLrtltl.UUIA.ruWn, IA.Lrt�f.llr.l�1LIA.�W�, ��l!l11nr..1 Lrl.l!lMr.l�1LIA.�W�, �rt1�l!lULmLGt-LIA.n., �lb l'll'lf.._n I"D F'�'=" l, 1�:� o 11k 1 1'1 o l'lhf' 1� l,

��n.l-t-�����t.!t.!h., L,r..�IU£1 U!.11t.!!.!.t �;:> L!.l!lLrt LmL�r.lLrtltl.UU�trt�!.[brtLl!lL!'\�W!.LUt-�fl.�ru�u� •

�l rL���m�rL�rt!.!.QrtLl!l��t:lrLQ-1 t-��np.��rtLtt.IL!'\�W!.LU t-�fl.�t:l rL�U ,tllt1.�1A.1 n.l-t-���t.!t.!n.� t Ll'\�t Ll'\�W!.LU � • n.

t-�fl.�t:l U Lltl.LJ} ��11 LfU L�t-LIA.�� n.l-rtLtt.! �ftWrl.,tL�I.ll.ln.t�11rL,tL� t-�fl.Ll'\�W!.LU U L��!J1�U!\[A�!. U!.LU t-yt 11 �t;lLJ} ,lll11 " " ,. " " . . LfUL�t-LIA.��n.l-rtLtt.!�� n.,tt.�l.lt.!n.�t�t.!t.!n.t-�fl.Ll'\�!.U!.LUUL���1rL���1�Ll'\�!.U!.LUt-�fl.�t:IULit1.

"fl.l rL�t1 g�biA.U�Itl., rtLl!lLru!.L"��!.LUrLQ-1 ftl ��lt1.rL���1 ���t:l � rL,tLL!'\�W!.LU�ftt L���tL�U �t:1��11Ll'\�W!.LU r " "

t-L�Itl.�!.�n.�rtjfrtLtt.!t-�� 1 Lru!.L��t-� � ���� 1 L�� �rtLtt.!rl.Q-1 ��t-�n���1 �t:l �t-�����rtLtt.!n.t� (NOL.LV'SnV'))

�t:l � �11 Ll'\�W!.LU t-L�Itl.�!.� rL�rtjfrtLtt.!U �ltl.Lru!.L��t-� �rl.f;l-1 L£!-fttp-rL���1 t-��L£!-ftt �t:l���rtLtt.! t-�11�l �p1

�� 1 L���rtLtt.!rLQ-1 L��t ����11iU�L���p.t,rtt ftl ��ltl.L,I!lr.l�,\l�� 1��rLLt-U,CLM.L�mp.t-�11!.LU t-�fl.�t:l rLLt-U ,CLM.L�1B� n. n.

�� 1 rLQ-1 t-�11 �rtL tl.l��L�kt'� 11� rLLt-U,tLM.L�1�11�� 1rtLtt.!t-�11U'iWrl.flo 1 Ll'\�W!.LUt-�fl.�t:I!.LUt-����rtLlt.!ftQ-1U'l!.Ut-Ln.nt LIA.�!.U!.LUt-�fl.�t:I���LIA.�!.U!.LUt-Ltltl.�!.QrLM.rt�rtLtt.!Lru!.L�M.t-�l!l��LmL�t-LIA.�t:lrtLtt.!LIA.�!.U!.LUt-�fl. 0 0 I ,P f1ll l'b � II '="' 0

�ru�u� ···rtLlllllln.unrt, ···· Lr..r.., lllmmn.�r,�t�. .... rtLllll!ln.unrt, �r,�t�.n.MLM"".. Lr..r.., lllmmn.�� ®;1>::>181 ·ki·M. nLt-t-!. ,, 1"D" ���gl I, " 1111,� I"D Iii=' " �'t:t'JID, "'rP Jr:,J,a 11 Ill"'� fb

t-�!.t.!rt��,QJiU,CLll.L!.�!.M.rtLl!l�IA.1 �rLit1.L1JIA.n.UL��t l!lU1t'Jf��t-� LmL�t-LIA.�IA.1 n.l-t-����,,��n.l-rtLtt.!�t-����� rtLl!l�gfbftt ��ltl.r\.1:. L���t.!l.lfb L),A.�Wl\ t �n.lt1.L1Jr.l Lrtltl.UU�rtLl!l!.LU L),A.�Wftt ��ltl.rtL���n.�t L�!.LUrl.Q-1 �L),A.�W!.LU ��t

• •

��1rL,CLt-� t-!}ltl.t-Lr��tt-Lr�!.LUL),A.�W�t.!t.!n.�tn.�t-,(1�rLit1.L1J��It1.��11t-!}lt1.!.LU�t!.LUL),A.�W�t.!t.!n.�wrtL��rLit1.L1J I I( I I

. � "' ��tL�U �ru�U�t-���t��rtLtt.IL!'\�W!.LU�rLit1.L1J�t ®;!>;:>Gil .ki.M. rLLt-t-!.11t-�!.t.!rt��liJIU,Cbll.L!.�!.M.rtLl!l

rl.,Vt��mp. 1LmL�t-LIA.�IA.1 n.l-t-����rtLtt.!���11r.!Lrtlt1.UUrtLl!l�gfbftt rL,CL�t.!t.!h.L��t ��� L),A.�W� t

�f'Lit1.L1J r.lLrtltl.UU�rtLl!l!.LUL),A.�Wftt np.�t.�t.!h.UL1t1.��11 L),A.�W� t n.�t-,CLr.lLrtltl.UUU'l!.Un.� W�mp. 1LmL�t-LIA.�IA.1 n.l-• t'!. •

t-����rtLtt.!�np.�t.�l.ln.L��t ��� L),A.�W� t(!rtL�r.lLrtltl.vU�rtLlllrl.I:.L�!.LUL),A.�W �t �t.!t.!n.�pmp.t-�

H �tt-�Ul!l�rtLl!l

np.L!A�W� t �t-,(br.lLrtltl.UU�!.LUrL_¥ 1�t-��11 L),A.�W� t n.�t-,(1r.lLrtlt1.UU�!.LUrL_¥1�t-����tt-�Ul!l L),A.�W� t n.�t-,CI.r.lLrtltl.UU

�!.LUrL_¥ 1�t-������� rL_¥ 1�t-r.l�1 L),A.�W!.LU t-��1�LM.01�!.11�r1.f;l-1�rL�rtjfrtLtt.!UL���1�L,Q-It1. rLl!lt-�fl.� rL�� LIA.�W!.LUUL��U11A.IA.Lf'Lit1. (�, Urtrt, �!.ltl.Lmm�rt�L�) t-��LM�LM.m r.l�1n.!.rt�r.l!.LUUL��U11A.IA.LrLit1. r.lLrtltl.UUrtLl!l 0 't:t'f'f'l'l l'lk�Pihli=" ntp::r fb 't:t'f'f'l'l

�L,Q-Itl.rLQ-1�L�t-� �L,Q-Itl.L)tl.ftt rL_¥ 1�t-�11L),A.�Wt-���L,Q-It1.���np.�t:�rL,Vt-�Q.�� 1 L),A.�W t-�����!.LUrL_¥ 1 �t-!.LUrLt�

rLrL�, t-�U l!liA.rtLlflll, LIA.�W�rtt-�!.LU rt�, ��11�t.!IA.rtLl!lLIA.�W��IA.�, t-�Ulll!.LUrt LIA.�W ��IA.�t.!rtLtl.lrt!.LU �t.! � l, F' I D t., 0 p F='l'l "' 't:t' F' 0 F' ls. I'=' 0 F' "=" Jl=t' I'P

t-!.l!lr.l�1 Ll'\�W!.LU ( LmL�r.lLrtltl.UU�trt�!.[b r.lL�t.!!.!.t �;:> L!.l!lLrt) n.p.�t:�rL,Vt-�Q.�� 1L),A.�Wt-��U��!.LUrL_¥1�t-r.l�1 •

�t n.�t-!}ltl.rL� �1';1��1� t !.LU��11 t-!.l!lr.l �1 Ll'\�W!.LU��tL�U !.LU�!.[bt-� ��t L),A.�W �L��t.!t.!n.t-�fl.L),A.�W!.LUt-!}ltl.t-Lr�

�tt-Lr �!.LU Ll'\�W �t.!t.! h.� t n.� t-,Cbr.l Lrtltl.UU� �11 �tt-Lr �t-pltl.t-Lr �!.LU Ll'\�W � t.!t.! h.� t(!rtL��,QJ m ,(1� �� Lrtltl.UU

��r..L�U �ru�u� Gil rL�tLru!.L��r.��u.t��rtLtl.lL),A.�W!.LUt-�fl.�ru�U��rLit1.L1J��LmL�r.lLrtlt1.UU

sl..),A.::!.U!.L..U::ruftu�::�11l..fut...B�l..rtlt1.UU��rtl..t.t.!::ru�u� ·;»

\

Page 5: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

Lfl.lfli!.1��1LlA.:::WJ;.LUf1.n1N�lflt-l!. J,:o 1; liP

®;D::PCS) "lei· M. fl.Lt-t-J;. 11 t-13!;.61�Wfu,Q.R.LJ;.:::J;.M.rtLlfl��rtLt6IL.\A:::WJ;.LU f>l.lA.1k���rtLt61fl.Q-1�t ��rtLt61mttt-� ®;D;:pCS) "lei. M.

fl.Lt-t-J;. 11 t-13!;.61!1JtWfu,Q.R.LJ;.:::J;.M.rtL�lA.1 fl.,Cl.t'� rl.k fl.t'X\L� t-X\I3�111,1A.Lrl.f1.�11 t-13 � n.�1 ftt n.k fl,l3�111,!;bt-!}ltl,fl.� 1 ftt U � L� 13 � II II II I " 1'\ " 1\

��t-�n.�:::�11 IA.Lrl.fl.M-L�f1.�1 fttrl.k fl,J;.LU 13�� �L�fl.�� �rtLt6IL.\A:::W ��11 t-�:::l!.�f>l.IA.1 �� rtLt61 t-131l.Ln. 1 U _tl.lt1,rtL t61 1'\ " "',.

rtLlfl ��IlL t61 L.\A:::W � �11 t-�::: l!.�f>l.IA.1 � fl.ltl,L� J:lt n.f1 ®;D::PCS) "lei" M. fl.L t-t-J;. 11 t-13!;. 61 11):! �_QJrn ,Q.ll.LJ;.:::J;.M.rtLlfl

"n._v� tj;lt}LrtL�n.p. 1n.kfl.t'X\L�t'X\13�111, � � � II II n no

IA.Ln.fl.�ltl,t-pltl,n,�, rtt rl.kfl.l3�1tl,f1.13�1t-pltl,n.�1 rtt U61L�f>l.lA.1t-Lt:::J;.t-13�t-���rtLt6113�f>l.lA.11tl,���rtLt61" L�� U�.QJfli,Q.J:lt C8) O® LJ;.lflLrtLfuLI3 � Lrtltl,[jU � trt:::J;.f1,11Llflf>l.IA.1 k�� �rtLl61� �1f>l.IA.1 rl.kt-13 �ftlfl._tl.�f>l.IA.1 k�� � rtLl6IL.\A:::J;. UJ;.LU �

" I\ .. 1\ •

n.n.�n.,tt��l3�1tl,f>l.lA.11tl,���rtLt6IL.\A:::WrtL�WM.��Wfl.Q-1UL111,�11 ��rtLl61fl.Q-1�Lfl.lfll!.1�ftt��1 L.\A:::W�11f>l.IA.1111,� ��rtLt6IL.\A:::WJ;.LUn.p.t-� "fl.�t-L� 13fl.Q-m� 1� t�� fu,Q.rtLl61�:::i!.n.p.��fu,Q.lA.rl.rtLlfl�1m� 1 ��rtLt61fl.Q-1�Lfl.lfll!.1

�ftt ��1 L.\A:::W�11 t}�Lrtltl,[jU�lrt:::J;.f!,rtLlflf>l.lA.1 k���rtLt61 L.\A:::WJ;.LU, L�HWfu,Q.J:lt ;DO® LJ;.lflLrt LmLI3�Lftltl,[jU

�r_rt:::J;.f!,rtLlflt-� "Cn.lfll!.1�ftt��1 L!A:::WJ:�W11��n.kt-13�� t�,Eot-�11��u-t��fu,Q.�Lrtltl,[ju��wn. Llfl1m� 113�111,····,

L���fu,Q.� UJ;. 1161J;.J;.t �;:p LJ;.lflLrtrtLt61rtLlflfl, tfl.Q-1p.t-� 11Llfl�Lfl.lfll!.1��1 L.\A:::WJ:ltftt:::l!.�11��n.kt-13��t��fu,Q. �Lrtltl,[jU��1 f1.���1L.\A:::WJ;.LUt-131l.�f':l��L.\A:::WJ;.LUfl.Q-1�111A.Lrt:::J;.f1,��1 L.\A:::WJ;.LUP.Lrtt Lfl.lfll!-1 ��1 L.\A:::WJ;.LU

p. Lrt���rtLl61L!A:::WJ;.LUfl.Q-1��1 n._vn.p. 1Lfl.lfll!.1��1 L!A:::WJ;.LUt-131l.fl.� 1U�I3�n.�; 1 Lfl.lfl1!.1ftt��1 L!A:::WJ;.LU

®;D::PCS) "k!"M. fl.Lt-t-J;. 11

t-13J;.61rt��fufu,Q.ll.LJ;.:::J;.M.rtLlfl��rtLt61�ftt:::l!.�11 �Lrtltl,[jU�t,rt:::J;.f1,11Ll!lLfuLI3t-LlA.��n.krtLl61�:::1!.�L.\A:::J;.U� �LlflrtLl61

�11t-�13�111,1!.tlfl�I3�111,�LU�11 �LJ;.lflfl.�rl.kJ:!tt-L�U�� tl£111, 1n.Q-11A.Lrt:::J;.f1,��1 L.\A:::WJ;.LU:::LM.01��1 ��1 � �tLfuLI3t-LlA. n.

� (1rl.k t-13�f'tt::: I!.L.\A:::W� t�1m���1 IA.Lrt::: !;.fl.� �1 L.\A:::WJ;.LU�I3�1 L,lrtLl61�Lilltl,J:lt�,lfl11 IA.Lrt::: !;.fl.� �1 L.\A:::WJ:lt 13�1 ��n.kt-13��6161h.� t �t LJ;.lflLrtfl. tt-�11�,E-��1�fu,Q.IA.rl.�ftt ®;D::PCS) "k!"M. fl.Lt-t-J;. 11t-13!;.61rt��fu,Q.R.LJ;.:::J;.M.� �1

13M.t-�� 1 ftt�t-�:::J;.�,et:::J;.J;.LUfl.Q-1 �11 (,�11 t-�:::J;.�,et:::J;.rtLl61 ,e. t I!.LI3�tliJ;.LU �bM.:::�11 �»�rtL!fl�t-13�t-� t-�:::J;. �,et:::J;.rtL!'.-61 �Lil.� �1 L.\A:::WJ;.LUL.\A:::WJ;.LU t-131l.�f':lfl.� 1 t-�1 1113� 13�111,�f':ll3� Jlt'�:::J;. fl.� �1 Lfl.lfll!-1 p. tftt���rtL t61

L.\A:::WJ;.LU t-��Lrtltl,t-�IA.Lrt:::J;.f1,��1 Ll't:::WJ;.LU "ftt 13M.t-�� 1� 1j�t Llt1,�11 J:lt fl._tl.L�n.p. 1t-�:::J;.�,et:::J;.rtLt61,e. ti!.LI3 � n. '·

Ll't:::W �::: �11 tliJ;.LU �u M.:::�11 � »�rtLlfl �t-13 �U �n.,ttn.p. 1::: lLU'fl. t �611!1 n.t-�t-�:::J;.�,et:::J;.rtL tl!l U Ll!.k!L!;.fl,� �1 Ll't:::W �11

Lfl.lfll!-1 ��1P.tl!��rtLl61Ll't:::WJ;.LU�11J:lt IA.Lrt:::J;.���1 Ll't:::W, L�H��fu,Q. LfuLI3�Lrtltl,[jU�t,rt:::J;.f!,t-yt 11 �l!IJ;.J;.t, �;:p LJ;.lflLrtrtLlfl Lfl.lfll!-1 ��1LlA.:::Wt-13lfl:::l!.lA.LfuLI3t-LlA.�f':ln.J;.rtLll!lt-131l.fl.t 1U�I31l.n.n 1 IA.Lrt:::J;.n ��1LIA.:::W 0 II � "=' ,_ II II I,: I D 0

"J:lt n.���ml3� � n.

L�rtJ;.J;.grtLlfl��f':lfl.Q-1 t-13�n.p.Ll't:::WJ;.LUt-131l.�f':l fl.�U_tl.itl,f>l.IA.1 rl.kt-13�Li't:::W�� t Ll't�t ��rtLt61Ll't:::WJ;.LUt-131l.�f':lL�,

L�H�fu,Q.�LfuLI3�Lrtltl,[jU�trt:::J;.f!,t-yt11 we. LJ;.lflLrtrl.I3U:::J;.f1, t-13�l!IJ;.J;.t ;D;D® LJ;.lflLrtrtLlflfl.�ULrtrt� 1f>l.lA1 rl.k�tt-13�:::1!. n. n. •

���rtLl6IL.\A:::W�t-L��Lfl. l!.t lfl �13�111,�LU�11 �LJ;.lflfl.�rl.k�t 13�111,�LlflrtLll!l�11 t-�t-L�U �� t lflltl, 1n.Q-1fl._tl.L.\A:::WJ;.LUt-yt 11 �

�f':l:::�11 o;:p LJ;.lflLrt13�111, �;D '�;D 'fUl;D 'CS);D '�w ·�w' fUll�' LJ;.lflLrtrtLlfl�,Q.�fl.ftt13�111,fl.[tL�:::I!.�Lfl.lfli!.1��1Li't:::W

J;.LUfl.Q-1ULII1, �LlflrtLl61�11t-�13�111,1!.tlfl�13�111,�LU�11�LJ;.lflfl.�n.k�tt-L�U��J;.LU n.p.1 fl.�rt� 1�LfuLI3t-LlA.f>l.lA.1 rl.kt-13�

1!. LI3TUW t-L n.n.t::: �11 Lfu L 13 t-L IA.fl.t� f':lrtLtl!l rt::: I!.U fl. fl.� �1!161 h. �f':lf'\,111, 1 t-�11113 � 13!;.111,� f':ll3lfll!l t-� :::J;. n L fl.lfll!. W �1LIA.:::W::: 1!. � "=' � p ,..,1'1 p p I p I )I 1° 0

L�ftt�,Q.�fl,� t n.�t-,Q.�fl.ltl,L� ��fu,Q.lA.rl.rtLlfl���ftt�Wfl. t 13�111,� t �fl.ltl,L���fufu,Q.lA.rl.fl.[tL�L.\A:::W� ®;D;:pCS) "lei "M. " "'111 n.

fl. Lt-t-J;. 11 t-13!;.1!1 ll):!�_QJrn ,Q.ll.LJ;.:::J;.M.rtLlfl t-� �t[!fl._tl.Li't:::W J;. LU t-131l.�f':lfl.� 1 t-�1 1113� 13�111,�f':ll3� Jl t-�:::J;.fl.Ll't:::W � L�l3�::: 1!. ' � 1'\ 1'\ "'"'

��rtLl61t-131l.rl.I3U:::J;.f!,Jlt'13fl.Q-m�t-&1!.1!.� 113�kJ:ll[!L.\A:::W�L�, L�H!!(lJfli,Q.� rtL�61J;.J;.t, �;:p LJ;.lflLrtrtLlfl��rtLl61t-yt 11 n. n.

n.I3U:::J;.n 61t-13n.n ml3t-J;.I!.I!.IA.1131l.J;.�, LlA.:::Wf':llA.mwn.n 1t-13lflfl.t-IA.:::m1 "�f':lfl.ltl, 1t-�1 rti3���1Lfl.lfll!.1, LW�J;. 1 :::l!.t-Rt 1°)1 1,.; 1"'0'=" � 11�11ko 11f'F=' 1:3 11fr� p � I I II=" f" n. n. �

� �n.kt-13�:::1!-L.\A:::W � n.���1 Ll't:::WJ;.LU t-yt 11 �f':l�:::I!.L��t �f':lfl.� 1 t-�1LJJ;.LrtL��1m f':li3�J!t-�:::J;.f1.�tftt L.\A:::W� L�u-ULJ;.fl, �

Page 6: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

nTm1:::v111�w��Li'U mllth:::ll'J�n�vtll1tJ€11fY1ll1m1 cr� 11WIVl1tJ 1�uryf[�··h "m1m:::v111� vtll1 tJm 1ll11llG�m11 �di �e-�m)'t.tvt��a'U1��u 1�tJ��L 1'um1�� n��� m:::'Yl1L ��-u�� n'U e-��tT'U�h tJ" ��tT'U

fl11llvtll1 tJ"ll��m1m:::'Y11��L 1'Wm1�"il::: ��� m:::'Y11 L ��-u�� n'Ue-��tT'U �tTw1ilfl11ll-r'U ��'Vl1�B1t\J1���-r'U 1 'Vl�

1'11llf1�'Vtll1tl ..J QJ CU4 II 11c:J1 tl' o SJ' ..J .o:d II .J Cl.l II o

"'l�1'11ll'rl1:::11"t1'Uturu �'�fill fl1�� LL 1��1'\J 'rl. !31. l!:lctcs:::Cil e-J'Vl � m:::V11m1�� L'J'U f111'Vli'I'Ullvt'U1'Vl"il nl'l �� m:::'Vl1 "' .., " '\J

1'11ll� f1�'Vtll1 tJ tl1'Vt'U� 11 L ��{J�� tl'Ue-1� Llj��tT'U�� L i'U 11Jm:::vl1 f111��ilfl11ll-r'U� �'Vl1�B1ty1 1�tJ�� L i'U f111f11:::vl1

LL�:::���-r'U 1 'Vl�'Vl1�B1ty11�L 'li'Utl'U

QQ,I Q ..::�cl Q,l ,. 6

ct. 11�'U1f11'�· LL 'U1fi'J1llflfl LL��'VIq�� Lnt11f1'Uf11'a�·h 'VI'I!t

f111�� 1 'Vl� (Punishment) L tl'U1�'Uli11ll'Vl1�L'U�li11ll"ll��LL(;]�:::"t1'U"t11� ��"il:::il1fim1�Lbl'lf1(;]1�tl'U 1 'l.l ll.l d q Q..l ll .dl �

{;11ll'Jw..I'Uli11ll fi'J1ll L "t1� !311?l'U1 LL�� f1�1� L 'UtJ'U'Vl1�?l�flll'lJ��'U1'ULlltl�'U'U 1

f111�� 1 'Vl��� L U'U.rr'U I'I�'U?l �Vl1 tJ'lJ�� m:::'U'J'U f111tl �li11ll�U nu� (;]� �m:::vl1fi'J1ll� �1'11llfl1oW'rl1 f1�1 " " � '\J

'll��!311� B'ULtl'Uvt.U1�vtii"1n"llmmll11'UVi'rusn LL(;]m,.�� 1 'Vl�'U1���1� L'li'U 1 'Vl'l!t�1fln ��Ltl'Um'a�� 1 'Vl��ilii"1n�ru::: , L tl'U f111{;)��tl f1"il1f161�flll-&'Jfl111 L ���� 1 'Vl�LL�:::'IJ-r'UU1� LLm 'lJ�tT'U LLI'I L 'Vl��1fl f1B1"il(lf1'Vl� LL 'Vl'U�i"J tJ'V11�L��f1�'U 1�

'I \J , '\J

L'li'U f111flllfl11ll'll1:::�n� ��L tl'U'V11�t��n�"t1�'U�1tJf11lvtll1tJ LL 'Vl'Uf111�� 1 'Vl��1fln �n����L tl'U15m1LLm 'll�'U'I"l , VI dJ " '\.1

�m:::v11fl11ll ��1'11llvtii"1 mL 'U'J fl11llfi� L� mn'U m1�� 1 'Vl��'J tJ 'IJ

"" .d .., ,. 'VI'J'Ii!JLmJ1n'Um'a�o:� b 'VI'Ii

'Vl ��� �1'Uty 11'VltJ1 b � tJ'J tl'U f111�� 1 'Vl�ii cs:: 'Vl��� 1� bb fl 'Vl��� f111�� 1 'Vl�b ��'Vl � bb 'Vl 'Ufl11ll ��

(Retributive Theory) 'Vl��� f111�� 1 'Vl�Lb 'U'U�11(1U1::: 1tJ'UtJ (Utilitarian Theory) 'Vl��� f111�� 1 'Vl�L �tl LLm 'll�'U� � n1:::'Y11 � � (Rehabilitative Theory) Lb� :::'VI ��� f111�� 1 'Vl�b � � 'l.l n'll �� �ll fl1tl� 61 �fill (Social Protection

Theory)

Cil) 'Vl���f111�� 1 'Vl�L��'Vl�LL'Vl'Ufl11ll�� (Retributive Theory)

m1V1� bL 'Vl'UL u'W11'1(1U1:::?l�fl1 'Uf111�� 1 'Vl��Lf11 LLn�?l�� �1�'\11�� L vtl'le-�� 1 'U m1V1� bb 'Vl'UG'i'J'U 1 vtru�'U 'I , 'I ..,

, QJ 11!:! d 11 v vd 1111 1 1.1 v 1 .., o o

�tJf1'\.Jfl11ll1�f1'Vl"il:::unufi'U'lltl�e-J'Vl(lf1u1:::'Vl�11tJ fl11lll'l��f111'll��'Uflfl� 'U�'U"il:::n1:::'Vl1f111'Vl�U'Vl'UUf1 '\1 \1 '\J '\J • "

11..J 0 c:::t 111 I � :'1 IJ' 1 111 I I .J Cl.l 1.1 Q.J 11 ..J ') II o A d �� e-J'Vl'Vl1fn1ll L?l tJ'\111 tJ VI bbf11'l'U'U'U b u'U'll�� b "IJ1 "iJ ��1 tJ LLI'I f111'Vl?l�flll b 'lJ 1ll11'U'Vt'U 1'Vl �� b 'Vl�e-1 m:::'V11 e-1 � b �m u'U 'IJ 'IJ

f111'Vl�bb 'Vl'U.Q L ���ll1"il1m vtl'l1��� hlL U'U�bL 'tl'Utl'U LL(;] lJI1lll"l1e.J6'U1tJ���n'U 1�tJvi'1 1 'l.l n�� L ���"il1 n61�flll L �'U-h ,

?lll1'B n��� m11 �il f111'Vl� LL 'Vl'U LL�::: 61� flllm "iltJ1U� fl11ll��� m1�� mh'J'llm ?lll1'Bn1�� tJ61 �fill L -b'1� �v11 L� tJ L ��

��"il::: b U'U 1:::L iJ tJ'U b�tJ'U�tltJ�f111'1.l��tJ1 mll1'tln-<il'flf111LB1m� fi'J1llfl�?l'I1'U?l'4'U'Vl���'Vl�LL'Vl'Uiiill1Lbi'IL 'U11fl.lf11� LL�'J

LL(;]L��ll1ilm11�Lvtl'le-J� LL�:::11�vtii"1mmusn��1�?lll'U1ru1'W?llJtJ'll�� Kant LL�::: Heaal , 'IJ �

1�tJ Kane 1� �Lvtl'le-��11 LU'U�L�'U-ti��tJL'Ut;l111 m1��1 'Vl�LU'U'lle.J��n'Um1m:::'Y11�� L��fl11ll , 'IJ 'IJ

��li11ll LL�'J ��"il� hv11m1a'U11JL U'Un11ll"il:::����n��mry1 �� 1�61�6'11'\J'rl���� 1 'U?l.fl1'rl LL�::: m1llvt'IT n L 'U 1 n'U

fl11ll��"IJ��b'll1 t;)161�flllhl�� 1 'Vl�erm:::v11��n b vh n'U61�fllltJ�ll-r'U1��f111f11:::vl1"llm b 'll1 bt�:::�'J m vtl'ltT'Unile-�� 'IJ ,

L vtil�'U1161�flllbU'U�?l'IT'U?l'U'U 1 �m:::v'h�� Kant �e.Jvtii"1n.fle.J�1�L oUll�'J� 1�tJ hltJ�ll-r'Ub vtl'le-1���1��'\J 1 'Uf111�� 1 'Vl� 'IJ , ,

bL�::: 1�n�11 1 n 'Uvt'IT��� Philosophy of Law 11 ""iJ::: 1im1�� 1 'Vl�b U'Ub�tJ�bfl���ilm �t11 �Lii�'ll1::: 1tJ'UtJ��1��'U

6 1·-·f 1') , .,j • . rn-s�-:1 'V1�:��.€l€l'\J mJ .u 'VI�.:I'V1l.l1 : www.lawprachln.com/fileadmin/templates/data/LA 790/

7 Bl.ll.!TI�Lil� 1'11'\JYl (Immanuel Kant) \Jm.J1''1lqJ1'1l11Lt:Ja-sil''IJ �1fiLLrr)'Wtl1'?�L'lit:J 1�1'urn-st:Jn�a-:�1�t:Jvi'11tJ·h LtJ'W\Jn���ij �'V15��l.J1f1�G'l�'ll€l.:l� 1 -stJ LL�� L tJ'W\JntJ1''1lqJ11"l'UGhrlqjl"l'UG'l�'l-11 t:J'lleJ-:1� 1"1 LL?f-:1?111.:1 L 'll1?�i\:i�-mm::VItJ��1AqJ1 tJCi.:�\JntJ1''1lqJ1?11t:J 1 'SLLl.J'\J�f1U��?f1t:J�h•rilt:Jl.J

6

Page 7: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

1lJH1 hl-h'il� L �a 1 � Li'1�tJ1� 1tJ"IltJLLner"n�'l1 vt�La.:J vt�mLnli1-:Jfl1JL t1t�G11'U111Jnm1J m1�'11 vt�1 'Uvtnmrulil��a'l "" .

L �a.:Jll11i11m vt(;rl1 tmfl��" n�.:J1 vt� 1�m�vh��mn11 L vhtYt� �.:JilL 'Vl11� L tlt�m11lJ'I.T.:Jfl11�1il�tJ rhY�!'im.Jflfl�vttl.:J , , \1 gt 6.J "

L YitJ'l L �alii� L tl'ULfl�a'lna 1 �'I.T.:J Ln�e.J� LLnuflfl��'U vtflfl'Un�vtm 'U;j1'U��Ln�ll1L tl'Ull'U�m 'Uel'Uiil� 1lJ"ntJ nlliiL 'llt�J'U, 'I " ca " 'IJ �

Kant tJa1l1�ijoU'ewmi't1"il1flvt�n·h:��t1iJ1� 1!:> tJ1:::m1 �a tJ1:::m1LL1n m"ili1fl11�Elt1LU1Lvt'!j1���'Nvt1flU11fl!J11

fl11�'11 vt�a �1-:Jvt'l1 n1�tJ�1 L i'J'U m11vt� n.U1-:J�'Ua �1-:J Lfl� .:J fl��lil� L U'U n11m�vtu m� L Via'U fl111l�?i n"lla.:JtJ 1�"1l1"1l'U "

tJ1:::m1�{;1a.:J 1t�Lnam1tJ�lliimllvt�noU'1-:J�'Ua�1'1Lfl�'lfl��lii:::Ltl'Um1���1'U1'U'Vl�Lna.:J"lla'l���.:Jiii'ULn'Um1

1 'U"llru�� Hegal8 i1m111L�'U��vt�a'U�'l1 tJn'l1 Kant '\J1-:J 1�m�'U11 fl11�'11 'Vl�L Utlfl11��5111l ... t ..1 � ...... t � ... I I d � "'.I I fl ... ..1 ... "" t ...

L 'Vl11� e.J(lfl�'l � 'Vl�{;11Jfl11'Vl"il � ��1U � 'Vl�fllil1'la tJ LL(;)'Vf1flL1Ja �� u11fli111L u'U fl11tJ(;)5111J'VlliJ�(;)a.:J1Jfl11�'l � 'Vl�LL�1 1IJ 'U \1 d.J ,

Hegal EJ'l tJall1 �tJ1�'l�'U'Uafllil1flfl111l��"lla.:Jfl11fl1:::v11 LoU1111'Yllil11ru11 'U fl11rl1vt'U� 1 'Vl��1 tJ fl11�'11 'Vl��

"' .,.,f... ol 11 d

1 ol "'

.,f "1Jauu111J(;)11Jvt�fl"lla'lvtt)��tl(;la.:Ju1�flaumm.:Ja'U "1l rn u1:::fl11 �'l'U

C9l) fl11�'11 'Vl��a.:JL U'Ufl11'Vl�LL'Vl'Ufl111JL�tlvt1tl (vindication) vtll1tJi1'l fl111J(lfl�a.:J"lla'lfl11�'11 'Vl� "

lij��a.:Jm�vi'1�-:J1 tJ L �a L tJt1m1vt�LL vt'U vt�mLnLLFi't�1 �LLn� L�tJvt1tJiiJ1nm1��m�vi'1�� 1�v111 �Lfi�fl111JL�tJvt1tJ " 'IJ

�'Uri'l1 un11Jt1 lij��a.:JL tlt1m1v111 �er L�tJvt1tJ�?in'Vla 1�i� LL����11L t1t�m1m�v11�tl�o111J LL�1 vtn�nd�11 \1 \1 '\ ul '6J

d II!:! II � .J II V V I V 0 ... � fl � .J� I II 0

1 V II �

fl11�� L�tJL 1a'lfl111l1G1fl'lJa.:Je.JL&1tl'Vf1 tJ'Vl(;)a'Jfl11LLflLLfl'ULLfle.Jfl1:::'Vl1 e.J�tltiL utlb1'l'Vl �llt:lfl(;)a.:J L 'V'l11�"iJ:::'Vl1 'Vfe.J LG1tl'Vf1 tJ \1 \I '1.1 \1 \1

vt�mu1��'\Ja.:J"lla.:JL"ll1��m�allP!�vto1�i1!'ia�;j11 LlJB11ilL�tldtJ1fl111lL�tlvt1tJ1 �L"ll11� fl11�'11 vt�1�tJflTU.:Ji;1-:J ... " ....

fl111l'Vla 1"il"lla'lerL�tlvt1tJd lil�v111 �erL�tlvt1tJ tJa11�u11m1�'11 vt�1�tJ�;jL t1t�m11l"llauo111J LL��tJa1J�u11m1LLnLLffi.J " 'IJ ...

II 0 .,. �- � I II ..1 I flo 0 II ..1 V

e.Jfl1�'V11e.J� 1J.J � 'lJ'Vf'U1'Vl'lJa.:JLafl"ll'U LL(;]L u i..i'Vtti1'Vl'lJa.:J1;j " ....

1!:>) fl11�'11 'Vl��a'l m�vi'1 L �a 1 �Lfl�fl111l L U'U5111l (fairness) 'Vlt)��dlla'lvtoU1�"1la'l� flfl� 1 'U

�1'Ufl11 Lij a.:J LL���fi1fljf1!1U1:::'lJ1flll�L�tJfl-J1 fl111'i1-:J(;la'U LL 'Vl'U (reciprocity) i1vt�fl11fl111il� 1 �fl�'Vtll1tJi1e.J��llfl1a'l

tJ1� 1tJ"IltJ'l"ll LLriG11'U111l fl'UVJfll"l'Uiil��a.:J Lfl11'Vl LL"' �tJ�u'9i(;111Jfl�vtm tJ fl11��m�v11���1tl'U n� vtll1tl'tl1fl!1 LL��::: fl�'l

Lvhnu11 erm:::vh� � La1 L tJ�tJU'Ufl fl"'�'U� L �a�'l fli1'Vf1J1tl LL"':::.Ua 1� L U�tJUdliJ::: L �'U1�i� Llii'Uri'l�'U 1;)1 L U'U " • ':.1

m1m�v11��mru1��n'Ua�1-:JLL'Vl�vt�1tJ �.:J,r'U m1"'-:JL vt�erm:::v11���-:JL tlt1m1�v111 �erm:::vi'1�� LL��Uflfl��'U � \1 \1 1IJ ,

� L �a�'l fl�'Vfll1tl (;)';i�'Vt,j' n-J1 � flfl"'�"'::: LiJ� fl�'Vfll1 tllil :::� a'l� fl�1 L i'J'U fl� LL"' ��ffi� L tJ� tl'Uiil1 fl fl11�1tJ'U fl�'Vfll1 tJ

"il��a'lt:lfl"''l1 'Vl� �1tJLvt(;ld fl11"''11 'Vl�LLrl�fl1:::vl1�� �'lfl11i1fl11111ti LL 1-:JL VitJULVhnUfl11111�LU�tJU�erm�vl1 \1 , 'U , \1

1��Uiil1flfl11�1�1'Ufl�'Vtll1tJtY'U 1�tJ�a-J1�fl1�vl1�� 1��1tJvtdeJ'ULfl�lil1flfl11vl1 �� 1 �LLrlfl'UVJflfl'U� L �a�'l fl�'Vfll1 tJ ,d �� cto 'f ClJ � ,d r II � aJ .dl I V

1 .J !4 .c:51 .cd C11 1 _.d

'1!-:JL u'Ui;11J1'llfl � 1J{;1-:Jflll'U'U LL"'�L1JaliJ1tJLL"'1L "ll1flfl�Ufl'U{;1i;1-:J!"lll 'tJ;j11J�'VlL U'U'V'l"'Llla.:J� LL�:::1J;j1'U�L 'Vl1fl'Ua'U . \1 o:d oCJI

rn) fl11"''1L'Vl�lil��a'l1�&1�G11'Utl'Ufl111l�� (proportionality of punishment) 'Vlt)��dL�'U11�1'U1tl1vt�

��m�vi'1��fl111il� 1�-rulil��a.:J L vhnt�nu f\1111 L�tlvt1 tJ� L "ll11� m:::v11"'-:J"il1 nm1m:::vi'1��,r'U a �1-:J11n� mlili1

oUatJm l'Uiil1fl'Vt�fl�'lfl�11 1� 1!:> mru �a mru�fl11�'11 'Vl�{;1-:Jfl11fl111JL�tl'Vf1tl�erm�vl1rla�'UJ'Ui;111J1�(lfl1�vl1 " "

H1l t�mru"lla.:Jm1"'-:J1 vt��11"lfl(;l"'a��i(;]LLrierm�v11���L tl'UeJ'U(;111tJ�ali1-:Jflll L �au n-tla.:JG1-:Jflll1 �tJ"'a�.tltJri.:J�'U • 'IJ

1 'U'Vl1'1(;)1'l tl'UoU11l fl11"''1L 'Vl�a11i1�1 n11ii1�G11'ULLvt'lfl111l� � 1 'Umru�er m:::vi'1�� 1lJffi afl1!;1�1il�m�vi'1��J'U� n "

�.:JJ'U �m:::vi'1"i1:::1��um1"'� 1 'Vl'lj vt�mam1"''11 'Vl� LL"':::1 �a�mtJ1�L�a'U1"llfl11�1lU1:::Ylq� uryvt111"il:::�avt�n1�

111'Yllil11ru1111 vt��1'U1'UL vh 1��-:Jiil� 1�&1�G11'UtlUfl111l���erm�v111�ria 1 �Ln��'U 1 'UU1:::L�'Ud Immanuel Kant "

L �'U11 "1 'Vl��erm�v111��ulil:::�a.:J1�fi1�G11'U'V'la��'li;1i11'Vl LL"':::m111vt'l1m U1"1la'lfl111l��"lla.:JL"ll1" l;1i11'VlLL"'� "

8 �€14� iG"�L��ll V'J�I'l:S'!! L�LnG'l (Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel) tTm..J-s'!!qj1'!!11L tJ€J'SlJtJ 1tJ•!hn..lG"�1tJ�FlLL\oi�IJiiilqJqJ1 (En lighten ment) L�Lnm UtJlTm.J-r'!!qJ1FltJri1l'i' '1)'11€1� 1G"� f11J1�1tJI'l n �1tJL � tJtJ'VIG'\1 tJ�tJ'tl€1� L '111U�'Vlfi'VlG'l €1�1 � �� �m.H'!!qJ1 n�ll � 1� 1

m� tJ-s'!!qj1fl1Fl�tJ'V11tl (Continental Philosophy) tJ-s'!!qJ1iLF111�'1-1 (Analytical Philosophy) LLG'l��'Vlfim4n'l1 (Marxism)

---- --� �-- --

7

Page 8: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

fl11l.J'VIL1fl b 'IJ1'lla\lfl11l.Jc:i�d�"il1'HU1 Hi'"il1fl "fl11l.J�1 tlbb 'j\IV11\1��5'j'jl.J'lJa\lfl11l.Jc:i� bb���\i1'U bb� ��"iJ1'jUJ1"il1 fl m1l.Jtl1�1'VIil"il1flY'l'l� m'jru"tJa\lm'jm�vhc:J� 1 'Ubb�m: b�a\1 'Uan"il1nd EJ\I'j"Jl.Jti\lm1l.J�1mb 'j;��m�Y11 ria 1 �bii��'U B'Ubn�"il1flfl1'jfm::vh 1�m"ill'l'U1 th�l.l1V1 Lb�� 1 'U'IJ1\ImriUi'1tJ" IK\It!'U'VI�flfl1'j�"iJ1'jru11'UL�a\IG1�6'11'U'lla\11 Vl�"il� �a\l�"iJ1'jUJ1ti\161.fl1Y'l bb��fl11l.J'VIL1 fl b 'IJ1'lla\lfl11l.Jc:i��\lth� fla'IJ�1 tJ fl11l.J�1tl bb 'j\J'lJeJ\Ifld1l.J b�tl'VI1tl 1 'UV11\I

" fl1 'j fl 'j�Vh bb� � � � � aG1\Ifll.J eJ'U bn � "iJ 1 fl fl1'j fl 'j�vl1c:i �11'1..1

�) Vltj��fl1'j�\11 Vl�b �aiJa\ltl'U'VI�mll.l�EJ'\Jt\I'VI�a bb'IJ'\Ja'j'jf:l'\.J'j� 1tJ"IJ,J (Utilitarian Theory) bb 'U1fi�'lla\IV1tj��.a �a fl'Ub 'j1fl'j�vl1c:l� 1�m"ill'l'U1 bb��na'U"il��\lriam�v11t!'U n1��"iJ1'jUJ1

1fl�fl11qj ti\1 ����� b�tl bb�1�\l�\lllav11 b Y<J'j1�u�t!'U-s' ��\Jfld'jflf) fl fl�'VIl.J1 tJ n 1'VI'U�fl11l.Jc:i� bb�� 1 Vl�G'11VI-s''Ufl11l.J c:J�J'U 11l �'11 � b"il'U bb�� btl� L� tJ�ali1151'jUJ"IJ'U b �aiJa\1 ti''U fl11l.Jc:i�vl"il� Ln��'U 1�vfhw'lti\I'VI� flfl1'j"tJa\lm1l.lli1'll�'U"IJl.J�'U� '

bb�� fl11l.l b �'UtJ1 �VI n'li'Vl'jl.J1'Ul.J1tJ 'j� na'IJ fl1'j�"iJ1'jUJ1 b �am'IJ fll.JV'I n� fl'j'jl.J"tJa\ll.l'U�V�1 tJ bdaii� m�vh �� 'VI�a It " 111 1 " '\1

�1�'Ufl�'VIl.J1tln"il�� eJ\11�-s'u 1 V1�1'11l.J�fl�'VIl.J1 tl1Jqj��11 rr\ldfl1'j�\11 Vl�"il��a\lm�v11a�1\l'j"J � b �1 bb tl'Ua'U b!i1l.la.fl1fltl'U bb��'j'Ubb 'j\JI'J1l.lfl11l.lb 'VIl.l1�1i1l.l'lleJ\11 Vl��n1'VI'U� 11 fl1'j�\11 Vl�IK\Ifl�11�al.l"il�iitJ'j� 1tJ"IJ,J�aG1\Ifll.l '

1 'U�1'Ufl1'j��B1"1Jqj1fl'j'jl.J bb��6'1\lbli1�l.J 1 �fl'Uvi'11 tJbfl1'jV'I bb��tJ�mil'11l.Jfl�'VIl.J1tl bb 'U1fi�fl1'j�\11 V1�1'11l.JV1tj��m'jf:l'\.J'j� 1tJ"IJ,Jii'j1fl�1'Ul.l1bb�1 'IJ'j1UJ 1 'U�fl n�n Plato9 1� mh111

.J 1 1 "'1 1� 1" 0"' d o.J1"' 01•'"'"' "'1 '"' "fl1'jV1'\Jflfl� �t:lfl�\1 Vl�l.J "IJb1J'UbV'I'j1�b'll1 �m�V11�� b'UB\I"il1flfl1'jfl'j�V11V1 �fl'j�V11 ubb�1 l.JB1"il�'\Jm\l 'VI ' " 0 11/.c:i I .d � 1 d 1 I QJ I 1.1.d .d "' I 0 � 1'"' fl'j�V11 �an bbl'lVl'\.Jflfl�'U'Ut:lfl�\1 Vl� b V'l'j1�b V'la�� 'Ua'U1fll'lbbfll'ld b 'll1bB\Ibb�� bbfl�a'UVl b 'VI'U11fl1'jfl'j�V11'U'Ufld'j � ' " "

-s''Ufl1'jbbm 'll bb��� �BI'J'j1fl1'jm�v11c:i�vlert!'Una1 �bn��'U" �al.J111ntJ'j1"1Jru�a Thomas Hobbes10 n�1111 " u

"fl1'jbbtlbbA'U 'VI�a�\11 Vl�'\J�'��'�� 1lJfl"J'j"iJ��"iJ1'jru1ti\lfl11l.J�1mb 'j\leJ'Ubn�"il1nm1l.Jtl1�1'VIil'lla\ler,r'U 1 'Ua�I'J bb�fld'j ' " ... .,. .. .J .J 1 ., � 1 °1"' il .. .J � .., 0 ... V'l"iJ1'jUJ1t:l\I���Vlli1�Vlml.ll.l1"il1flfl1'j�\J Vl� �\I'U'U fl1'j�\l Vl�"il�m�V11 �bUV'I1�bbl'l 'UmtuVl"il�bbfl b'll�m�V11�� ' "

.dl Q.l 4 �1 Sl!l.d ,d I II 0 � 'VI'jai'Jflbi'Ja'Ul.J 'VI�a'UbB1btltJ\IatJ1\I�fl'j�V11��" " " "' 1 .. • I 1 .-1 ..,.. 01 d ,.. ."1 01 1 ,J .. bb'U1fl�'tla\lfl1'j�\l V1�1'11l.JV1tj��fl'j'jf:lu'j� tl"IJ'U �l.Jfl1'jV'Ioo.J'U1b 'jatJl.J1t:l\lu"il"ij'U'U fl1'j�\l Vl�V1�1'11l.J bb 'U1fi�-rl' �a\1'\.J'j� na'IJ�1 tJ'VI� n fl1'jiK\Id

<9>) fl1'j�\11 V1�erm�v11m1l.Jc:i� m�lJ\15\Im'j�\11 V1��\lc:i���,r'Um�v11l.J1bb�11 'Ua�l'lbb�btl'Um'j�\11 Vl� " ' " .d .. l.f CL1 .d II t C1 .d 1 Q.l 0 .o:::tt. � 1 I b V'!a1J a \I fl'U fl1'jVJ�'U'U 'VI'ja'\Jflfl�a'U 'Uii1\lfll.l"il� m�V11fl11l.l��'ll'Ul.l1 'VIl.l " '

) I .. 01 d 1 0 .J .::'1 "' .. V 1 V 0 .,j .::' 1 � fl�11afl'Utl'VI'U\I fl1'j�\l Vl�fl1'jfl'j�V11Vlbu'Ufl11l.J�� "il�l.Jfl11l.J"IJa'IJ5'j'jl.J m �fl'j�V11bV'IBbu'U fl1'jiJa\l n'U fl1'jm�v11c:i��"il � bn��'U 1 'Ua'U1fll'l

) ..... 1 ., .. ;�, .'1 ., .N .. 1 "" .. 1 .., "' 0 ... "'"" ., '11 15fl1'j�\J Vl�a'U"il�l.l�mu'Ufl1'j1Jfl\lfl'U'U fl'fl fl1'j�\l Vl�bV'IBLI'la'U 'VI�m�V11�� bb���a'UI'J'j�'VI'Ufl

" " "

5\1 �� fl1'j �1�'Un f1'VIl.J1 tJ IK\111'1..1 ertTruru�n f1'VIl.J1tJ�\I�a\lfl'Tw\15\l e.� �'lla\li�m'j�\11 Vl�er m�'Vl1c:i �11 "il��a\lli11l.J1'jf:l dJ 'U .., ..., dJ cu

iJa\1 n'Ufl1'jm�v11 c:l�eJ''Uii� n�ru�vi'11 tJ�1 tJ m 'libb� b oWt!\Jfl1'jvlEi''U t'�� m�'Vl1 c:l� b vht!'U "

) 1 .IJ' 0 .o:::t. J,l 0 4 4 a I 1 6' .J 111Q.I Q.l I .c:i CV .d

CS::: fl1'j�\l Vl��m�V11e-l�"il�I'Ja\lfl1'U\It:l\l u'j� tl"IJ'U�\I��Vlb 'tl1fld'j"iJ� �'j'IJ"iJ1fl'j�b "IJ'Ub� tl1 fl'\J'4flfl�fl'U 'l IK\It!'U erm�v11c:i�"il��a\11�-s''I.Jm'jb�CJ1 m-s'n�1 m'jvl b 'll1iim'jm�v11a'Ub tl'Ufl1'j�a�1'UG1\Ifll.ltllil"ilD'U b �a 1 �b 'll1 " '

li11l.J1'jf:lii;gil'la�1\l b tl'U�'ll 1�n'\J fl'U6'11'U 1 'VIqJ'lla\IG1\Ifll.J

8

Page 9: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

6

lbLI!I�l.lA.11i-t!.!:.LU � OOt!l!ll!lfl.!i-�n.��&lA.NilM. 1 BM.Ii-J:. 1mtrtLtl!JLJ:.I!\Bib�l!.J:.tl!Jib.!:.J:.QI!\�lA.FI.lA., li-t!.!:.LU�t!11 Mf1.UWI§l1n.Q. 1 l§ll':llbLtl!l p � re f"' P=' ,..,r=r "=" F" 1 � ro r=r 1 ._

. �

L,\A.�W� t�n.� t!l!ll!lrl.f1.,\;lli-B(:�l!.J:.tl!lf!l11 l§l�lbLtl!J�Q. 1 l§JQ.B�Ifl. l§l�lbLtl!JL,\A.�W �f1.Lib.!:.lA..!:.LUf1.Q-1 �1!-.!:.tl!lrtt FLIA.11i-t!J:.LU

li-Bfl.Lf1.1!11!-1L�HtL�U�t��1Ll!ll!lP,1 LP,�fl.Q-1 (epe::>::>ag aJeSa)) ��1Ll!ll!lP,1 }Lf/s��li-�Ugk!Lt!l!lU,tl.L�Ii-!f1.11L�lA.�

Lfull.LBU,tl.li-Bfl.l§l�lbLtl!ltf1.111bLI!I �® �FLJ:.J:.tl!llelf1. tn.���l!-li-� 1 f1.,1;11i-B(:B�If1.1i-g rl.,.lil.!:.LUf1.Q-1B� 1FLIA.11i-t!l:.LU (UO!+U<3A<3Jd

JO +U!eJ+Sal:J JO a::>uaJa+ao e se +UaWLjS!Und) f1.,\;lli-B(:B�If1.1i-gn.,.lil.!:.LUf1.Q-1B�1FLlA.11i-t!J:.LU G91 �lb�U •

f1.�1i-�ULib�l!.�!}FLlA.11i-t!J:.LU!i-Bfl.�li-k!�J:.fb(ji!\X,. f1.Q.ruJ:.LQLk!L,Ci-lt1.Bf!lL,\A.�W ... ' " . � .

�tFLlA.11i-t!J:.LU L,\;'1 li-� li-L� B�LM.01 � 1§)1 f1.Lib.!:.lA.9-U lA.IbLtl!l � t,lfl§l � lbLtl!l,So t l§JQ.Ii-B�� 1!-l§l �lbLtl!J L,\A.�W �!}�li-k!�J:.fb(j I!IX,.IbLI!\

f1.\!l11U11.!:.LUf1.[} 1B� 1FLlA.11i-t!J:.LUrl.U � BM.U11LU1lA.t!l':l�lf1. mn 1U l§ll':llbLtl!l�Q.11§JQ.B.!:.If1.f1.lA. 11l§llA.J:.LU�n 1BM. 1FLIA.11i-t!J:.LU ,. ,. ,. F' ,.. , , F' I,J,_.,. "" I,J F'

(+UaWaUO+'If JO UO!+e!dX3 e se +U<3WLjS!Und) l§l�lbLtl!J�Q.1l§JQ.B�If1.f1.lA.11l§llA..!:.LUf1.Q-1B�1FLlA.11i-t!J:.LU (Gl �

�Bf!lH L,\A.�W��Ib.!:.Wt!l':ln.� 1� t f1.,Ci-1B� 1 _P'� f1.,1;11bLI!Ifb t UI!I�LI!I� tFLlA.1 rl.k,lft�&.!:.tl!llbk!�Ln.l!l&1 � l§l1 � � �

� Ll!\f1.��Lr&�� n.p. 1 n.�L,\A.�W,lf�l§l�lbLtl!ln.,\;lrtk!Lk!li-L�BFLlA.11i-t!l:.LU � t,lfrl.BI!\�1 J:.LUrl.k�t �&J:.tl!llbk!l§l� lbLtl!JL,\A.�W�

L,tii-p.lfl.ii-L�BU��t tL,t!Uii-� f1.,\ei11,\)11.!:.LUf1.Q-1 B� 1FLIA.11i-t!.!:.LU!i-Bfl.ii-p.lf1.ii-L�Bt�n.r;: 1� f1.MoBf!lT1.Mo LI!IB,I!ILI!\rl.n.11FLIA.11i-t!J:.LU .. • n. ..

n.n.�J:. n. n.&& n_ n., ii-lA.�W lb11 l§l k!lA. � L t!lfl.J:.M, 11 � t!11 ru LJ:. n.1� lbk!l!\11 LlblblA.l§ll':llbL tl!l LlA.�W I':IFLIA.11i-t!Q., lA.l!lli-k!�J:. n (j 1!1 t /'1:11 h"' l, � II F' I ,.., I F="f"' "=" 0 1'1 1'1 l,F', I 0 I'll

n.r;: 1L�n.,tt (a8uaAaJ Jo uoqene+aJ 'UO!+nqp+al:J e se +uaw4S!Und) f1._!t11,Y11J:.Lun.r;: 1B� 1FLIA.11i-t!J:.LU (® •

n,n 1UBBU�11 l§ll':llbLtl!J�Q. 11§JQ.BJ:.If1.f1.lA. 11l§llA.f1.\!l11U11BM. 1FLIA.11i-t!J:.LU ® lA.Ibt!U I,J "' "" " " F' F' ' n.n. .. "

l§ll':llbLtl!JLlA.�WI':I�A f1.�A fl., U11�t!111i-J:.n n.J:.n BM. 1�t!111bl!lli-k!li-B.!:.l!llbl!JJ:.LUf1.n 1BM. 1 f1.U!i-BrlBJ:.If1.1i-�rl.�.!:.LU '=" 0 1'1 ,... � hoi I 0 l'b I 1;1 p I'll 1'1 I; F' l'b h" IP � ,. • •

n.r;: 1B� 1 l§l�lbLtl!JL,\A.�W.!:.LUf1._!t11,\)11J:.LUf1.Q-1B� 1 B� lb�U � n.r;: 1,lft tL�Ul!.LBFLlA.11i-t!J:.LUf1.1.Jlli-k!�J:.fb(ji!IX,. •

RlA.lt-t!_g,LU�N�::_g,fb(jl!\� " . �

� t�f1.,\;llbt�LruJ:.L&�J:.LUn.BU�.!:.fbL!bLP,B� 1 lb.!:.WLflill.LB!i-Bfl.!li.!:.LUf1.L(jk!�t!11 t!l!ll!lrl.� L.!:.f1.Q-1 l§l�L,\A.�W�

li-Bfl.lb.!:.W�bM.LFLU�Ii-B��&n.Q-1L� ,lft W�11i-L�Bii-�� 1�Liblf1.UUU�If1._e.t&LB!bt l§l�L,\A.�W�FLIA.11i-t!.!:.Lll "Gl . � "

t!l!ll!l n.� L.!:.f1.Q-1 l§l�lbLtl!JL,\A.�W�FLlA.1ii-t!J:.LUL�Llll Llblb.!:.W Lflill.LB . . �

Ll L&lbl!lli-� li-BW lb_!tli-!1� 1§)1 n.n.�J:.f1.Q-1 li-L � Bl§l � lbLtl!l L,\A.�W� rl.,I;I.!:.L Uf1.!} 1 L�£�1i-Bib.!:.Lll �� &.!:. tl!l "®

B�fu�L��.!:.Lllll �lfl.�� l§l11bl!lli-�li-Btl!llb�li-B(:LlfbB� 1FLlA.11i-t!.!:.LllgFLblA.ii-Bfl.f1.L�f1.�l§l�tn. 11n.f; 1 Ln.��,lft

_p.tL�Llli-�.!:.Lllll �lfl.li-� lb.!:.WLfull.LBf1.,1;11i-B(:B� 1 �t!11n.��lbl!lli-�� t L,\A.B� 1 lbB1'-l§lt 11 li-�rt�n.tl!l.!:.Lll�t!11 LfuLB�Liblfl.UU n. .. ,. ,. ..

l§l�L,\A.�W�Ii-Bfl.M.Ll.fll�l!ln. B� fli�L�Ii-�n.t&tn.k!rtLtl!l�trtl!lli-�f1.,1;11i-B(:U,tl.L�Ii-Bfl.L�lA.�LfliQ.LBLl,tl.f1.,Clot!.t!.Q.

(N0<3Ljj_ UO!P<3+0Jd lePOS) lbl!lli-�li-B.!:.l!llb�li-B(:LlfbB�1FLlA.11i-t!.!:.LUgFI.blA. (�

fl. fl. I§) ,.. ...

�bM.�.!:.fbf1.l!l� t L,\A.�l!.Lf1.!1tFLlA.11i-t!.!:.Lll� t�Ll Lrl.L�LlL�IbLtl!Jn.k�'!» t L,\A..!:.LU�LJ:.M. 1 fl. lA. 11 (+uaw+eaJ+) �,Cb�fb.!:.LUL�L�

_e.tttl!lf!l11 (+U<3WLjS!Und) FLIA.11i-t!.!:.LUL�L�_e.tttl!lrtt L�n.� 1�� � t,lfn.�n.p.1�;-gn.,lil�l!.�(jJ:.LibLk!lbLtl!ll§lkt1n.��� tL.\A. �

li-B�� l!.li-,.lil t1'-11 Ll �L_g.l§l � L,\A.�W !bt �;-g rl.,.lil � !!-�� li-k!�t fblbLtl!Jl§lkt1 t1'-11 Llbl§l� L,\A.�W ,lft��� t li-L lA.Lifl.lbL� L� M.�&LlL &Ll B n.

B�_P'gFLblA.rtLI!I.!:.Lll£� li-.!:.1!1 � 1§)1 f1.�t!l!ll!lfl.li-12t!l':l�� t �!!-� Llblfl.li-�,lft!bt Ll �L_g.l§l� L,\A.�WL!brl.�Ll t1'-11Libl§l � L,\A.�W ,lft�

t!l!ll!lfl.� 1,.rttf1.,\;lli-B(:�&Ii-�� 1�Liblf1.1i-�lbLtl!l�_p.gFLblA. n.��lfl. 1 Lk!�ll. U111 B�lfl.LFI.Uk �L�l§l�f1.BI!If1.��t!11 �lfl. 1Lk!%i�L.!:.l!l1� " . �

li-Bk!�f1.BI!If1.� Llf1.fliQ.Ii-Bfl.l!llf1. 1Lk!Lif1.rl.Bk!&t.!:.l!l Ll.!:. 11n.BI!\f1.� B� f1.BI!If1.��Lt!lf1.f1.BI!\f1.��1i-B� �f1.l!lf1.Q-1� t l§l�L,\A.�W�

fl., U11.!:.Lll fil tn �n,n. 1 l§li':ILIA.�W �Bl!ll§li':ILIA.�W��.tn,�A fl., Ll11BM. 1FLlA.11i-t!.!:.LllUFI.blA.ii-Bil.f1.L�n.M.l§ll!Jtn. 11 Wi I, 0 1'1 1,; "=" 0 1'1 IP '=" 0 1'1 lUI s: \.Yi p F:=' lf' '="

(N0<3Ljj_ <3A!+e+!l!qeLj<3l:J) l§l�L,\A.�W��f1.�1l.1,V11B� 1FLlA.11i-t!J:.LllgFLblA. (W . "'

lb.!:.J:.Q�FI.f1.1blblbLtl!lli-Bfl.f1.L�f1.M.f1.n. .. lf'

rB�.!:.Lll£�f1.Q-1 f!l11 1!\�Bn. tn.p. 11i-�li-t 1mt�FLlA.11i-t!J:.LllP.t�li-�FLlA.11i-t!tLU n.n.�tli-Bil.lbJ:.J:.Qrl.BQ.IbLtl!l (�

Page 10: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

-J�(loJ�:!G'f-:!rld n b �ml:!Vh 1 ��fl1:!Vhl"l11l.l�� b ��VIm'U bb�:! bfl1-:!fl�1':J'U 1lJml1 fl1:!vl1 1"111l.J � �B n�a 1 oJ BnLh:!n1�VI�-:! ' '\1

Rb �m tl'Um�L�a'Uil1 �fl'U�'U., vi'1ml.la�1-:��m:!vl1fl11l.l��b��1:!':J�(ln�-:� t 'VI�b'li'Ub�tnn'U I "' "'

n"l.l� m m��-:!L'VI�b�mtl'Um�l"i'l.lfl�a-:��-:�fll.J (Punishment as a Protection of Society or an ' '

Incapacitation) m��-:� t 'VI�b �m tl'Um�ila-:�n'UG1-:�fll.lb�l.l:ff'UL�anm�111Lm15m��-:� t 'VI�"il1fl m.n1-ff LL�ria'UV1ti1d '

m��-:� t 'VI�b �m U'Un1�bbtlbbl"i''UL �m tl'Um�'VI� bb'VI'U bb��m�e!u�-:�ntoffa �b U'UeJ'Ul.l1n L'li'U 1 'Un1�fh�'�Pl'�� '\1 '\1

'V11-:!n1�blJa-:! �lJeJ1'U1'iJoJflfl �a-:1 b 'U�b 'VII"ltJfl L 'VI�n1�Llja-:� Vl�am-;;� fl1���1 v1fim�oJ��VI1��1�VI�a-rr-:� 1 'U�a-:1 1��'U '\1

n"l.l� � m��-:�1'VI�L�mtl'Um�oJ1'uoJ�-:� Vl�mbm"l!�'UYI (Punishment as a means of Reformation ' ' '\1

or Rehabilitation)

n1��-:! L 'VI�b �a b tl'Un1�oJ1'uoJ1-:!�n1�vl1fl11lJ�� L� tln1�1 olfi 'VI�"il1flfllJ�l.J1':J1fl'VI{j��n1��-:! L 'VI�"lla-:1 '11nm"IH1J11'VImci'1'11nflmG'f�n L Vl�r:.J�iia�-:hm��-:� t 'VI�lJbb 'U1 t Ul.l�'iJ�oJ1'uoJ�-:�� m�vi'1fl11l.J��Lb��m-;;�-;;��tJ1'uoJ�-:� .., 'I 'U , 'U ,

LLm"ll 1�ci'1L �-;;� t�vm�ria1 �Lii�fl11l.ln�111-;;��nm��-:� t 'VI�15n t�vm�na 1 ��n�fl11l.Jci'Tun11m"llry1m�l.l1 � oJ�� 1v"ll'U1ll�l.Jn'IJ t 'VI�VI�a t�vm�vi'1�1v'W�v�1-:1 1 �m"llry1m 1�G1�1-:�:ff'U t�mu�1�a�1-:��-:�t1'1 t 'VI�b tl'Um�"il1fln

V 0 "" � 1 la'f "" � I � I 'f .,j !"1 !:"1 � ool a .J ��t)�fn1 r:.Jn)�'VJ1fl11l.Jr:.J�fl'iJ� l.Jl.J baf11G'fbbG'f�-:I'U!i1tJb Vfm'U'U G'f1'Ufl1��-:) b 'VJ�b �flb u'Ufl1�bbfl b"lJy,'U Y, lJ'VIl.J1'iJ1fl '\1 '\1

'VIfl�n m�oJ n'\J��atr m�vi'1m11Je:J�"Ua-:�'11 nm"lltm1'VI mci'1'11n t ���YI L 'li'Un u15m�LLm "ll�'UYitr m�vi'1m11J e:J� L tl'U 1111 1 6..1 d.J '\l cu 'U \1 .. I I �1V1iflfl�VI�m1vn�l.J bb uum-:� 1

b. m��1LU'Ufl�mru1mru'U1EJ�1-:!�Ltl'Uil�'Uflfll6i "' '

����1"1l'!Jryry'1i�l.Jma-:�Lb �-:�-:�1'Ui l.l1��1 @let� '1Jry�H-.i1 "1 'Umru��m�vi'1fl11l.Je:JI'lbU'U'W�1iflfl� t1'1m�m�vi'1fl11l.l��"lla-:�'W�uflfl�,r'Ubn�-;;�1nm�i-:� m� Vl�am�m�vi'1'lla-:�uflfl� 1� Vl�a 1lli-:� m� Vl�a 1llm�vi'1

, '

n1�eJ'U b tl'UVIU1��� a-:� fl1�vl1'lla-:! fl1�l.l m��� � m� Vl�a'IJ flfl� 1� �-:! 1'u � �"/la'U 1 'Un1��1 b 'W'U-:!1'U'lla-:!'W�'IJ fl fl�,f'U '\1 ' '

�,f'U�a-:!1''\.J L 'VI��1l.J�Df!,Jf!,J'1i11ci'1VI1''1Jm1l.Je:J�,f'U 1 �1CJ" II .o=�.J�I �� 11'�! iJ .J 111�! .Q.Q, ..Jfl.l 11 II o .cr 'U1tl'iJ1-:!fl1t\J'VIb u'U'U�'\Jflfl� 1:-Jb u'U'U1CJ'iJ1-:! G11lJ1�(l'VI'iJ�bbtl n �b u'U 'U�'\Jflflt=l'VI�'IJ�fl'iJ1-:!b 'll1'VI1-:!1'U b�tl

, 'U lj 'U

�1CJI"h41-:� 1 � �lJeJ1'U1'iJvl1 n1�bb 'VI'U'W�'Uflfl� bb��m�1''Ul.la'UeJ1'U1'iJ 1 �lJeJ1'U1'iJVhm�bb 'VI'U'W�'Uflflt=l �-:! Ll'lVLl n� 'U , 'U 'I

m��1 b 'W'Ufl�B1UJ1'U1 CJ41-:� 1 'U mril� b U'U'W�'Uflfl�,r'U G11l.J1�(l�'iJ� LLCJnm�1''U �l'l'V11-:1mru1 a an 1� b tl'U �-:�d � ' �

®) 'W�'Uflfl��bU'U'U1CJ41-:� 'W�'I.Jflfl��a1�11iiG'f.n1�'lla-:�m�Ltl'U'Uflflt=�ml.JnnVfl.J1V �-:�m�m�vi'1'lla-:� 'I 'U , , 6J

'W�uflfl� LL�� m� LLG'fl'l-:!L -;;��'U1'll a-:�'W�'I.Jflfl�'iJ� �1 L 'W'U m� t�CJtr Lb 'VI'U�1l.l n flVIlJ1 CJ'lla-:�'W�u flfl� L 'li'U �'U�1'U�� �m� , , 'U 6J " , \1

'iJ � b U 'U� bb 'VI'U �1l.Jfl flVIlJ1 CJ'lla-:!�1-:!�'U�1'U"iJ1n 1'1 Vl�a m�l.l n1 ���� fl1�'iJ� b tJ'U� bb 'VI'Uml.l fl flVIlJ1 tl'll a-:1'\.J �,;''VI"iJ1 tl � 'U 6J , 'U 'U dJ

L tl'U�'U �-:�iT'U'W�u flfl��-:�iifl11l.l1'u � �'V11-:�mru1 b Vlria'U b 'li'Wmru'U1CJ41-:�� L U'U'IJ flflt=�n��l.ll'\1 . � .

�!:>) �neJ1'U1'iJvl1n1�bb 'VI'U'W�uflfl� bb��en�-rul.Ja'\JeJ1'U1'iJ 1 �neJ'1'U1'iJvl1fl1�bb 'VI'U'W�uflfl� t�CJ'\Jflfl� \1 'I 'U " "

�-:!G'fa-:�tJ��b.fl'VI�'iJ��a 1�rJ1b tl'U��1l.Jfl1�vl1fl11l.Je:JI'\ nu'W�'Uflfl� ,f'U �1lJVI�flflflVIl.J1tlB1UJ1fl1VI'UI'l1111'1Jflfl�� 'U 'I 6.1 .., ,

� a-:��u t 'VI�'VI1-:�mry1,1'U-;;� �� a-:��-;;�1�ru1ml.l Lfl�-:�G1�1-:�fl11l.J1'ue:ii'J'VI1-:! a1ry1 t�mu�1�a �1-:� �-:� m�� Lfl�1��i1-:� b'iJ�'U1"lla-:!� n1�vl1fl11l.le:i�b tl'Uci'1�fY mJVI1n0��U�1fl{] ml.l'WCJ1l.J "'U1V41-:�" bL�il1�iJ�1'Ub�tnoffa-:� bb��ijl�ij b'iJ �'U11 'U m �m :!vl1 fl11l.l e:il'l u flfl� b Vl"1dbb�'iJ�a �1 'U �1'U�'U 1 CJ41-:� il a1-;;� 1ll �a-:�1'u e:l �'V11-:I a1ru1 �1l.loJ ��l.J1 �

'I 'U cQ u

n !] Vll.l 1 t1 a 1 ry 1l.l 1 � � 1 cr � oJ � � n a 'IJ VI � n fl 1 1l.l � l.l � 'Uth � VlrJ1 -:1 n 1 � n � � vi' 1 bb � � 1:-J � (CAUSATION)

LL��VI�n'VItJ��L�a'U1'll �-:�1'Umrud ci'1'11n-:�1'Uflru�m�l.lm�ntJ��m 1�nm��auoU'aVI1�a"Ua-:�ml.lG11'G1�m�LL�� '-' .,j � .,J 1 .,. .,j o ... a IV QJ <V<> fll.Jfl�a-:!bb �-:1-:11'\.J �1l.Jb �a-:!bG'f�'iJ'VI mo®/l!:Jcfcrb 'Ufl1�VI1�Bb �a-:1 fl1�mb 'U'Ufll'lB1fY1'U1tl'iJ1-:!�1l.J����1"/l'UfYfY�

10

Page 11: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

Fl11:w'l.J"a�.n CJ m�hm.J1lJCJ bb"�?l.n1Yl bL1��a:w1 'Ufl1'jvhnu Yl .1"1. �<r<r<S::" t:i-:J1 'U?i1'UF111:W�u��Vl1'1B1tyT".h

"iJ �� B'l�"iJ1'jUJ11� CJ bFl� 'IF!�� \011:WVI"' f1 f1�VI:W1 CJ B1qj1 mh1 �B"ii � � B'l�"ii 1 'jUJ11FJ'j 'I ?1�1'1 Fl11:W�'U � �Vl1'1 B1 t\]1

1� CJ b0Yl1� B �1'1 �'I� B'l� bFl 'j1 �'Vit:i'l b "iJ \Ol'U1"ll'EJ'I � m�vl1Fl11:W ���1 CJ �'ILT'U b�B �'\J'j�f1B'U n"iJ f11 'j(011:W�'\J'j1 f1 f1 B CJ "l 'U 'U 'U dJ 'U

UV1UCJ1:W "'U1CJ-.5'1'1" i11�ii?f1'Ub�CJ1oUB'Ibb"�i}1�ijb"ii\Ol'U11 'Uf11'jf11�vl1Fl11:W�� UFlFl" b 'V!ci1\lbb�"ii�B�1 'U�1'U� . " "'

'U1 CJ -.5' 1'1 nhJ B1"ii�B'I �'U ��Vl1'1 B1 ty1\011:W'V'l'j�'j1"1l'U ty��.Q '\J 'j� n B'U nu Fh1 i1 "ii o CJ 1"11" ��511:W� ty� �/l!J<r<rb

i.mu"iioCJ 1 'U'\J'j�b�'U�'Inci11 1111 b�au�'UF1F1"'1f1nci11'V1111m�vi'1m1:w�� b"iJVJn�nci11VI1"ii��a'�nm'j�"'"ii'U1 � , 'U 'U 'U

�"�1" b '!:1'U 1� CJ'l.J'j11"l"ii 1m 'VI\OleJ'U m1?1'161CJ11 m'jm�vi'1m1:w � �LT'Ubn�:ff'U"ii1 n m'ji-:J fl1'j 'VI�a fl1'jhJi'� fl1'j Vl�a •

f11'jfii�vl1f11'j'VI�B L�m�v\'1 f11'j"1J'EJ'I m'j:Wf11'j��� f11'j 'VI�e:J'UF1F1" 1��-:J�'U��"llB'U 1 'Uf11'j�1 b U'U f11'j"1Je:J'IU�'UF1F1" J'U " . .

�'l"'n�ru�q'jfi"iJm'jfl1\011:W�n�'VI:W11:lfl1VI'U� 11 ?11:W1'jmb u-:J'\J'j�b.!lVl 1.� �'�d

C9l.) �1'1�'U?f1'U?I1l!ru �'I'VI:W1 CJf:i'I�'U?fTU'l.J'j� b.!lVl�� b thJ�'U?f'J'U'VI:W �Vlf1Fl'U�B'I�'U���1:Wtl'U 1 'U'VIil"lJB'I , "' , 'U 'I 'I

�1'1�'U?i1'U 1�CJ1��1n� (LJ.Yl.Yt :W1\0l'j1 C9lo�ct) 1�CJ�1'1�'U?i1'U?11l!ty bU'U�1'1�i11�"ii�Vl::buCJ'UbU'Uil��F11"1" �'�1�ii�1'U::

bU'U'UFll"l"\011:wnf1'VI:w1CJ �'�i.�m"iibtl'U�m1:w 1 'UF1�1� • -:..1 "

�.) �1'��'U?i1'U?11l!ruil�uFJI"l" �'I'VI:W1CJt:i'I�1'��'U?i1'U?�1l!nl�"iJ�Vl� btl CJ'U �'�ii�1'U� btl'Uil�uAA" ii�VJ5 , 1111 • 'I g� Q •

'VI,_J1� bb":: m 1:W�'U � � bbi:J f1 �1'1VI1 f1"ii1 f1 � b'iJ'U�'U?f'J'U 1� CJ�1 'I�'U?f'J'U ?11lJ UJU �'UF!Fl" B 1"iioWB'I Fl �'VI�B t1 f1oWB'I Fl �� 'U'U1:W "

"1JB'I�1'1�'U?f1'U,j''U •

'U 'I , .., 'I 'U

m.) �1'1�'U?i1'U�1 n � 'VI:W1 CJt:i'I�1'1�'U?i1'U'\J'j� b.!lVl'VI�'I� 'I'UF!Fl"�'� bb�?IB'IFJ'U:fi'U 1 U\Olf1"'1 b oU1tl'Ub �B m�vl1 ' . .

n"iim'j�'J:wn'U�'JCJ'l.J'j�"''�ri'"ii::bb u-:Ju'Un1 heJ''U"iJ�-w'�1� bb�n"iJm'j�v11J'U ('\J. Yl.Yl. lJ1(01'j1 (9)0(9)�) 1�CJ�1'1�'U?i1'U�1n� '

ii�bU'U�'U?i1'UB�?IB'I�1Yl1f1 �B "U • "U

- �'U?f1'U�1 tl�Fl11:W�'U�� �B�'U?f1'U��1 tl�Fl11:W�'U �� b oWCJ'I l� bn'U�1'U1'U b�'U�\Ol'U�'U"'I�'U ' ' '

- �'U?f1'Ul��1tl�Fl11:W�'U�� �e:J�'U?f1'U��B'I�'U���1:Wtl'U 1 'U'U1'j�1'VIil"1JB'I�1'1�'U?f1'U 1�CJ l��1tl�

�1'U1'U ' ' '

<S::".) 'U�,;Vl�1 tl� �'I'VI:W1 CJt:i'l 'U�,;Vlog'l�'l:fi'U�1Clfl11bb U'IVl'Ub U'U�'U:W"�1 b vl1'1fl'U 1�CJ��B�'U�1'1�'U�� • , 'll I 'U ,

�1ti'�b�CJ'IL�bn'U�1'U1'Ub�'U�\Ol'U�'�?i'�H1�mu:w"�1"1Jm�'U�\Ol'U�a (LJ.Yl.Yl. :w1m1 C9lo�b) "U '

<r.) 'U � ,;Vl -oJ' 1 n � (:WV11"1l'U) 611 'IVI:W1 CJ {i 'I u �,;Vlog'l �'I :fi''U m :WYl 'j � 'j1 "llU ty ��u�,;VJ:w V11"1l 'U -oJ' 1 n �

Yl.l"l. �<rm<r �1CJ1'\0lt1'\J'j�?i'lrl�"ii�b?I'UB"1J1CJ�'U�B'\J'j�"1J1"1l'U 1�CJ�iiB�'UiiF111:W�'U��-..hn�L�bn'U-oJ'1'U1'Ub�'Url1�'U 'I 'I 'U • 'I

��B'I"li1'j� bb"�'U�,;Vl �'I nci11 l�'j�� Fl11:W'\J'j��'l rl b 'li'U,j'U l 11. 'UVI,j''I�B'U �FlUJ'Vi?I'Ufi

�'�,j'U 1 'Uf11'j�1 b il'UFJ�B1ty1mru'U1 CJ-.5'1'�� b tl'Uil��FlFJ"'\J'j� b.nVJ�1'�1 J'U �'1?11:W1'jt1��"i)1'jru11�

C9l) fiitW"lJB'I�1'1�'U?i1'U?I1lJqj b�B�1'1�'U?i'J'U?I1lJqj �B 1�11bU'U�1'1�i11�"ii�Vl:lb tJCJ'Ub U'Uil��FlFl"

�'�1�ii�1'U�b tl'U�F1F1"\011:w n�'VI:W1CJ �'�1�m"ii bU'U�F111:w1 'UF1�1� �'�J'U 1 'Uf11'j�1 b U'UF1�mty1tl'U'U1CJ�1'� ,j'U iii'I�B'�

�1 b U'UFJ� mru1 bb� bO'V'l1�� b U'U�'U?i1'U"ll e:J'I�1'1�'U?i1'U?11l! ru b vi1,r'U 1� CJ"ii��m�1 b U'UFJ�B1 ru1 nu � b U'U�'U?i1'U"1JB'I u 'U , 'I Ill .., 'U 'I

�1'1Vlf1Fl'U 1 'U"' n�ru� b '1i'Ub�CJ1tl'U fl1'j�1 b U'UFJ�'EJ1fli1'U1 CJ-.5'1-:Jmru�b U'UUF1Fl"5'j'j:W�1 . ·� '

�1B�1'1b'li'U 'U11:Jbb�'lbb"�'U11:Jb'VI�B'I �1:Wtl'U'\J'j:maun"iifl1'j��b�Ub�B�1 1�CJ..ij'��'lbU'U�1'1�'U?f1'U •

?11lJUJ bb�'l b VI�B'I bb�in�"ii�Vl� b {j CJ'Ub U'UU�UF!Fl" mrub 'li'Ud fl1'j�1 b U'UFl�B1 UJ1'U1CJ-.5'1'1 "iJ �?11:W1'jt1�1 b U'U Fl � "' . "'

B1tu1l�bb� b0Yl1�'U1CJ bb�'lbb"�'U1CJ b VI�B'I bb�l�?11:W1'jt1�1b U'UFl�B1UJ1�1'1�'U?i1'U?I1lJUJ bb�'l b VI�B'I 1,� b y.j'j1� i,�ij "' QJ 'I Q.l

11

Page 12: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

h) �1-l�iJ�1iJ�1l1uru�hJI"ll"l� Li1a�1-l�iJ�1iJ�1l1'ru�liJ�Vl�buCJiJ n�1iJ�b uiJ-a�ul"ll"l� �-lt1iJ 1 iJn11 • tl • , IIIJ .... "

lii1b\liJF1�mru1nUiJ1CJ�1-lt1iJ lil��a-llii1L\liJF1�mru1nu ®. �1-l�iJ�1iJlW�1iJ��bUiJ\l�hJF11"1� bb�� \!:>. �\tliJ�iJ�1iJ .., cu • .... " \1 •

Vlfll"liJ 1 '1.1�1'\J� b tl'U�!ii1 b \liJ m111l.JniJ 1 iJ�1-l�iJ�1iJ , "" \1 ,

lii'1a�1-l L"liiJ iJ1EHb�-l bb��iJ1tlb Vl�a-l 111ltliJ'lh�naufililfl111ii'�b�Ub�a�11�CJ..ij'��-l bb��lil�Vl� b UCJiJ

bUiJ�1-l�iJ�1iJ�13Jru\l�UI"ll"l�bb�-lbVI�a-l mrub-ciiJd n111ii1L\liJI"l�B1ru1iJ1tJ�1-l lil��a-llii1b\liJI"l�B1ru1 ®. �1-l�'\.1�1'1.1 'I u , u QJ "

�1l!ru\l�ul"ll"l� Lb�-lb Vl�a-l 1 iJ�1iJ�\l�ul"ll"l� \!:>. iJ1mL�-lbL��iJ1 m Vl�a-l � L UiJ�iJ�1iJ 1 '1.1�1'1.1� L UiJ�\ii1 L\liJm1111ltliJ u , "" " 'U 'I ca \1

1 iJ�1-l�iJ�1iJ

Ql.) �1-l�iJ�1iJ�1n� lil��a-llii1L\liJI"l�mfll1nu C9l. �1-l�iJ�1iJ�1n�1'W�1iJ��LtliJ\l�ul"ll"l� l!:>. �'1.1�1'1.1 , g� • 61 , "

�..ij � m1�'\J 11 nn�a � 1l.JVI't1-lti au �1"1 ru��iJ61� tJ��iJ�1iJ�..ij' � fl11�t1iJiil� l'i'm L UiJ� i-l n11 Vl�au �VI11-.ij � n11 \1 6.1 'I \1 'U 'U

�L�CJ1-rra-lnumi�1�liJVI�a 1l.Ju!]u11�1l.l�1�11"11Ut1Jty1i�l.ll"11a-lLL 1-l-l1iJ �.Pl. l!:>��C9) 1 '1.1�1'1.1� L UiJ�iiehiJ11ilvi1m1

LLVliJ\l�UI"ll"l� '

lii'1a�1-l L "liiJ iJ1£JbL�-l Lb��iJ1m Vl�a-l 11l.lniJ'\Ji�naufililfl1ilii'� L�UL�a �1 1�CJ..ij'��-l LL��Iil�Vl� L uCJiJ

L uiJ�1-l�iJ�1iJ�1 n�LL�-lb Vl�a-l iliJ1mL�-l L uiJ�iJ�1iJ�..ij'�miu�VI1inliln11L �tJ-ll"liJ L�CJ1 mrub ,;iJd m11ii1L UiJ ' ' "

1"1�81ill1iJ1CJ�1-l lil��a-llii1L\liJI"l�eJ1fll1 ®. �1-l�iJ�1iJ�1tl�LL�-lbVI�a-l1iJ�1iJ�\l�UI"ll"l� bb�� \!:>. iJ1tlbb�-l �'1.1�1'\J "' gt • cd , ,

���n11 1 iJ�1iJ��ijeJ'1iJ11il'V\'1n11bL VliJ\l�UI"ll"l� 'U 61 'U •

�.) u�,;'Vl�1n� lil��a-llii1L\liJI"l�mqJ1nu C9l. u�,;'wihn� 1'W�1iJ��LtliJ\1�'41"11"1� \!:>. m1l.Jfl1i�'\J11nn

�a�1l.JVI'tJ-ltiau�l"lru��iJG LL�� Ql. ml'i'�Ul.JaUeJ1iJ11il 1 �iieJ1iJ11il'Y11fl1ibb VliJ\l�UI"ll"l� b� CJ� fl1il.Jfl11VI�a m��U " ' "

l.JaUeJ1iJ11il 1 �iieJ1iJ11ilvi1 n11 bb VliJ\1 �UI"ll"l� �,riJiil�l'i'm b UiJ�i-l n11 Vl�au�VI11-.ij�mi� b� morra-l nu fl11 �1 �iJVI�a ' ... ...

1l.Ju!]llii�11l�1�11"llutyt"[��l.JF1ia-lbb 1-l-l1iJ �.Pl. l!:>��C9) 1 iJ�1iJ�LtliJ�iiel'1iJ11il'Yl1miLL VliJ\1�'41"11"1�

lii'1a�1-lb"liiJ u�,;''Vl mi11tJ �1ti'� 'lh:maufililmilii'�L�Ub�eJ�1 i1'1.11mb�-l '1.11tJLVI�a-l LL��'W1m�tJ1 bUiJ��el'l·l'W ... '

1�CJi1iJ1 mL�-l Lb��'\.11 m Vl�a-l b UiJ fl1il.lfl1 1�-.ij� fl11u�,;''Vl iiel'1iJ11il U�V111-.ij'�fl1i'Vl n�1iJ 1 iJu�,;'Vl Sli-l'\.11 mL�-l bb�� " .

'1.11 m Vl�a-l l.JaUeJ1iJ11il 1 �iJ1tJYh �..ij�m1vY11 '\Jiiel'1iJ11il U�V111-.ij�fl1 1Vlfl�1iJb "liiJb� tJ1tlUiJ1 tlbb�-l bb��iJ1CJ b Vl�€1-l b -ciiJd ... .

fl1ilii1L\l'WI"l�fl1t1J1'1.11tJ�1-l "'il��a-l�1L\liJI"l�a1qJ1 C9). u�,;''Vl mi11tJ �1ti'� 1'1.1�1'1.1�\1�'41"11"1� \!:>. iJ1tlbL�-lbL��iJ1mVI�a-l

fl1il.Jfl11�-.ij�fl11U�,;'Vl1iJ�1iJ��ije)1iJ11il'Y11fl1ibbV1iJ\l�ul"ll"l� bb�� Q1 • iJ1tJYh 1 iJ�1iJ�m��Ul.JaUeJ1iJ11il1�iieJ'1iJ11il \1 "" 'U 'I .... \I

'Y11fl11LL'ViiJ\l�ul"ll"l� •

�.) u�,;'Vl �1tl� (l.JVI1"lliJ) lil�l))a-llii1L\liJI"l�eJ1nl1tlU ®. u�,;'Vl �1n� (l.JVI1"lliJ) 1iJ�1iJ��LUiJ\l�UI"ll"l� ·� ... '

\!:>. fl1il.Jfl1i�U11fln�aml.JVI't1-l�au�l"lru��iJG Lb�� Ql. m��ul.JaUeJ1iJ11il1 �iieJ1iJ11il'Y11fl11LLV1iJ\l�ul"ll"l� b�CJ� � ... '

m11J n11VI�am��ul.Jauel'1iJ11il 1 �iiehiJ11il'Yl1 n11 LL VliJ\l�ul"ll"l� �,riJ"'il� l'i'a-l L U'W�i-l n11 Vl�au�VI11-.ij � n11 'U " 'U \1

� L�m-rra-l nu fl11�1tliJVI�a 1l.Ju!]u11�1l.J�i�i1"11UtyqJ1i �l.JI"lia-l bb i-l-l1iJ � 0 Pl. l!:>��C9) 1 '1.1�1'\J�b UiJ�iieJ1iJ11ilvi1fl11

bbVliJ\l�UI"ll"l� '

®. u�,;''Vl Laii �1tl� (lJVI1'll'U) 1iJ�1iJ�\l�UI"ll"l� \!:>. iJ1tlbabb��iJ1tJU fl1ilJfl11�-.ij�fl11U�,;'Vl1iJ�1iJ��ije)1iJ11il'Y11fl11 ... • 'U .... \1

bb'VliJ\l�UI"ll"l� bb�� Ql. iJ1CJ61i 1iJ�1iJ�m��Ul.JaUeJ1iJ11il 1 �iieJ1iJ11il'Yl1fl1ibb'ViiJ\l�UI"ll"l� 'I dl 'U ..

--�-- ---

12

Page 13: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

m�. m,-�h L ihJfl�mru1mnhJ1tl�1·:l'il�h.Jflfl� L tl'Un\ilm1�13Jfl1 � .

n\lrn1�13Jfl1 uo1 NT vENTuRE) L u'Un\1 rn1·t.h�Lil'VI'V1�-:���1 L tl'Urn1�1lJfl''U1 'U'VI1-:Jfl1'VI�a'VI1 n111 I � QJ .Q. Q.J QJ SJ' II I .c::t..Q. II IJ' 1 .Q..c::t. CV SJ' II I .c:::t.-=:11. .o:::!ll I .o=o. CLI

1�'V111-:JU 1�'VI U 1�'VI f1U'VI1-:J 'VI'U ?11'\J'U l'lU rl rl" 'VI1-:I'V!'U?l1 'U'U 1'1 U rl rl" f1U 'VI1 -:J'VI'U ?11'\J 'U l'lU rl rl" Vl1 €11 �'VI11 -:JU 1�'VI , '\ , , , ,

LL" � /'V!�a�1-:J�'U?f1'Utl � U rlrl" tlUU rl rl" 5113.1 (;11 rtru�U rlrl"�ffi "litl �U rtf!" �1-:J�'U?f1'U ?11�UJ'V!�aij �U rl rl" �'U , , " " Iii , " ,

�,:) n\1 f111�1:U #h� f1\l � L U'U f111�1:U tl'U'Yh 1rt1,:) f111'1J'U 1 (;11 VI ru� � a-:�1 i L�'U'VI'U "il1'U1'U:U 1 f1 LL" � "' '

1-ffL'VIrt1'U1"�1��U?l-:J L"li'U f111?1�1-:J?l�Yl1'U'll'U1(;11'V!ru L1'U'U?l1ti1'V!ru a1:U-:Jfl1L11vJvh1��'U 1(;ltln\lf111�1:Ufl1 '\1 4.1 u ,

1 'U LL�'lla-:Jtb�3J1" f1� VI3J1 tl LL �-:! LL"�Yl1ru'lJ6 hJ�a'J1 L tJ'Umruiiu �,;''VI1 'V!lJ Lfi(;l�'U LLI))1 'ULL�'1Ja-:11.h�l.J1"-r��1 fl1

�a-J1iiu�,;''VI1VIlJLfi{;l�'\J L\"l11�1.h�l.J1"-r��1f11 l.J11'111 rnri 1� �U'VI1Lrt11��Ylvlrh'J1 "u�,;''Vl'V!�a�1-:J�'U?f1'U

tl�urtrt"" V!l.l1tlrl11l.l11:U(i-:� n\lfl11�13Jfl1'V!�a Joint Venture �1tl LL"�Yl1�11'lJDturu�rn1'1Jru:U Yl.�. l!J<t�rn , u cu u

�a11 n\lfl11�1l.Jfl1J'U L U'Uu�,;''VI Lbtlfli))1,:J'V11fl\11flU �,;'V1�3J1�1:Ufl1J'U �-:�J'U 1 'U'U\l�D'Ud1.h� L 'VI�1 'VI ti�-:Jiifl�'VI:U1tl

1!l o'IJu ��a11ii\lfl11�1l.lfl1�-:J 1lJ1�\l(;l'VI� L .U ti'UL U'Utl�ur�r�" L U'UU �,;''VI1 'V!lJ '

1(;1 t11 'ULd'lJa-:Jtb�3J1" fl�'VI:U1tl LL �-:JLL"�Yl1ru'lJ6 n\lfl11�1:Ufl11lJ�a11L U'Uu�,;''VI o�J'U 1 'Ufl11�1L tl'U

mqJ1mrun\l rn1�1:wf11 �-:� 1lJ?t1:U11L1m�vi'11� 'U'U1l.Jn\l rn1�1:wf11 �-:�'VI1 n\1��1 L tl'Ur��mt!J1J'U \l��a-:��1 L tl'Ur��

81t!J1tlUn\l fl111))1-:J'"] �:U1�1Li1'Ufl11�1l.Jtl'U 1 'U'VI1-:Jfl1'V!�a'VI1rl111L tl'U11tlb\d\"l1�n\l fl111 'IJ

�-:�J'U m1�1 L tl'Ur��mt!J1'lla-:�'U1tl�1-:�1 'Umrun\1 m1�1l.Jf11 J'U �-:��a-:��1 L tl'Ur��mt!J1 nu'U1tl�1-:�

L 'V!i!a'U�-:1 mru�1L tl'Urt�81UJ1f11ru'U1ti�1-:J�L U'Utl�Urlrt" 1(;ltJ1 'U?i1'U'lla-:J�iie11'U1\l'Yhfl11LL 'VI'Utl�Urlrl" LL"�m� u " '\J 'I '\J

-ru3JaUB1'U1\11 �iiB1'U 1\l'Yh fl11 LL 'VI'Utl �Urtrt"\1�� a-:J�\111nJ1�1 t111 fl11 fl1�'1'11rt11l.J e:i{;l'lJa-:J�ij-J1'U1\l'Vi'1 fl11 LL 'VI'U ' "

tl�u rtrt"J'U Lfi(;l�'U \11 mfi(;l�'U\11 f1 n11i-:1 fl11 'VI�a fl111lJi-:� fl11 'VI�a fl11f11�'Vi'1 fl11'VI�a 1lJm�'Vi'1 fl11 L tJ'Ua-:J fl '

'IJ1�flaUV!�-:!�1tl

o ..:::::.. ..:::::1 .:::::1 II C..A II

c:;;. n11fi1L'U'Ufl(;la1ru1n1ru'U1tllii1�'UI'1Uflfl��l.l���1tl � .

Yl1�11'lJ'IJn,ru��:u"�"1tJ Yl.�. l!l��rn :w11'111 ri 1�n1'V!'U(;l'Vf�mnrusnm1'1Ja1�"rmd�:u"�"1t111 •jj "' "

!L1 ,J/ .. � � VII 1"'� I ,d

L\11'VI'U\l�l"la-:J" f1'VI'U � 'VI"l.l"�mtl (;lf11'1m:wa "

(<9l) "n'VIdii'VId�'U�'U�1 "

(l!l) "n'VId�� L tl'Uurtrt"u11:U(;l1 L U'U'VI;j'L�1'VI;j'� L U'U hnv'irt'U L�ti1'V!�a'V!mtlrt'UL U'U"i!1'U1'U 1lJL!atJ n-J1 " ' "

wd-:��1'UU1'VI 'VI�a" n'VId�-:� L tl'Utl�u r�r�" L U'U'VIdL �1V1d� L U'U h'VInrt'U L� tJ1VI�aVI"1 t1 rt'U L tl'U"il1'U1'U 1lJ.U a t1 n-J1 . 'U , '\1

?18-:J�1'UU1'VI LL"�

� f11'11l.J

(rn) 'V!;j'J'Um\1 rl1'Vf'U{;l"ii1'U1'U 1�(;ltiLL tJ'Ua'U 1lJ11'VI;j'J'U\l �(i� n1'V!'IJ{;l'1111� 1(;lt1Yl�'U'V!�a 1 'Ua'U1rtl'1

.,J � II ..:.d 0 I 1 1.1 Jt V

11 11/.::;::,j 0 ri.J C. QJ t Q.l t d !II �

"'f� L:Ua L \11'V!'U ti'U rt1'lJ a 1'1 a� 1" VI" f1VI'U�:Ul;'l�m tl bbl;'l � �1 l;'ll;'l:U" � m tl (;l:IJ rt1 ?1�\"l'VI f1�'VI1Yl tiL(;] �'ll1 (;] Lbl;'l1'\J'U "

'U1ti�1-:J 1 'U�1'U�" f1'VI;j'\l� 1lJ?t1l.J11L1 m�'Vi'1f1111(;1 'l b� tl1 tlU'VI-rYl6�'U 'V!�an\1 fl11'1Ja�l'l'U L i''Ubbl))\1 � 1� m�'Vi'11'11l.J ""' "

rhi-:�V1�am1:u L �'U'lJau'lJm�1" YlL1'n-:J1'U��n,;'VI-rYl6 ��(;lfl11'VI-rYl6 'VI�a�'IJ1�'lJ:uL�1'VId m:u�'IJ n1ru�111. 'U '\J '\ D� U

Yl1�11'lJ'IJruru�d 1(;lm�a�1"iirhi-:���n,;'VI�Yl6"n'VIdLL�1 Yl1�11'lJ'IJruru��l.J"�"1tli l.J11'111 l!ll!l n1'Vf'IJ{;l1� CI.J u '\J Ql "

L�1YlUf1�1'U��f1,_;'VI-rYl6LLI))�L�tldiiB1'U1\l �-:��a1'1Jd "

< <9l) � (;] m1 LL"�1il1V1tl1 t�'VI-rYl6�'U'lJa�" n'VId 'VI�a m�'V11 rn1�"il1 L tl'U L �a 1 �n\1 n11"1Ja�" n'V!d�f11-:�a v " " "

(l!J) LrlU11U11:U LL!;'l�-ru L�'U 'V!�a'VI-rYl6�'U��\1�1'1 n1� LLn" f1'VI;j' 'V!�a�-:Jl;'lf1'V!;j'ij�'VIB\l� 1�-rU\11f1��'U " " "

(rn) 'IJ1�U'IJ1�'Ua:UtJa:U rl11l.J 'VI�a.Wa-:��a� 'VI�a� a� rtm(;l 'l L� tl1 nu'VI-rYl6�'U'lJa-:J" n'VId " "

13

--- -�--- --- -�-- ----

Page 14: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

1� £J fl �ru fl1 � � 1 L th.Jf1 �1) 1 UJ1 fl � ru'U1 £J �1� L U'Utl� 1J f1 f1 !;1 � mt �!;11 £J L� eJ 1"11 !;1 � rh i� 'W '11 fl�Vl �� �

L��'111�LL�1 J'U �1lJ1�tl�lil�LL£Jfl'Wlil1�ru11\il ���eJhJ-d' '

- 'U 1 £!�\:�� L'iJ'UiJ&\ Ul"ll"l � er:Ua1'U1\l '\Ill tl1 � LL Vl'UiJ &\ U 1"11"1� Lb�� rn��'Ul.J'fl'U el1'U 1\11 �:ijel1'U 1\l'Vll fl1� 'I '\J 'I 'U

bb Vl'Uil&iu 1"11"1� LdBil&iUI"ll"l� 1:W�1lJl�t;1�1 b il'U m�1�., b�CJ1 tl'UVl�"tl��'U"UB\IIPI'UbB\11\il vt1fl b U'U mru�'U1CJ41\I ' ' I

i1m�m�vh r11111t:i �IPI111fl!)vt111CJ LL �\I\11'Uvt�\llil1fl!3!1��11���1 c.�i1rhi\I�Vlfl,;Vl�TI� L��"1!1� L -d'UL�n41\l� n41\IL�CJ

1:W�1CJ�1'1l�b"!1CJ IPI111Yl���1'1JUqJqJ1i�111"l�B\Ibb�\I\11'U Yl.!3!. �<tCS::C9l 1111P1�1 C9lC9l� Lb���fl41'1lu�'Ufl1�B\I�B"tltifl\11'U

m1"il LL �\I\11'U �\!TIL! fl\11'UIPI�1"il LL �\I\11'U 1��€1U�1'UoUm Vilil"il�\1 LL�1:U rhi�Tiii' f1\11'Um1lil LL ��\11'U1 '\X'U1 CJ�1\IL� CJ

er:na1'U1"ilm�v11m�Lb Vl'U'U1CJ�1\I �1CJ�1'1Jiilb"!JCJ mc.� 1 'U rna -r'U ti'Ubb�'!'U�V1�1'Uvt�€1�€1,.h 1�V1�1'Ufl'1i\l 1 '\XLLn�n41\l � �

�\ITiilfl\11'Um1"il LL �\I\11'U 11il�'lfl'1i\11 '\X'U1 CJ41\I LL�� L�1Tiilfl\11'U�Vi'n,;Vl�TI� �'UV1�1'Ufl1i\IL�CJ'U�€1mL�1 LL�Ld€1mu

tl1'Vt'U�IPI111fl1i\l u�,;Vl., LlilCJb�1Ylii'fl\11'U�Vlfl,;Vl�"tl� �\l:i1eJ1'U1"il-.ij�fl1�Vl�"tl ��'U"1JB\I'U��V1"1 m�t.h b�'U111�1CJ 1 �

bbtl�fl41\lbb�� 1:!1'1111"1�1 llG1!3!1�bb �\I\11'U � �

fl1��1b iJ'U l"l�€11f:v1 tl'UiJ&i'U!"ll"l� 1:!J(;'f1111�t;1�"iJ�fl1�vl11\il b �B\I"il1fl1:!Jm"il�Bl1iJ&i'U!"ll"l�:ijb "iJIPI'U1�1�J'U u ' '

vt�B 1:Wll�u&i m11rhi'ITiiln\11'Um1"il LL �\I\11'U L �€1\l"il1 nvt�\l"il1nm��11� ��1c.� 1�i1fl'1i\I�Vi'n,;Vl�TI � L��"1l11il

il&i'UI"ll"l� bb�� er:na1'U1"il v11m�LL Vl'Uil&i'U 1"11"1� vt11\ila1'U1"il�"il �'111 b�'U"il1 n nB\IVl�"tl ��'U"U€1\Iil &i'U l"ll"l�m�1 c.�1 '\X bbn , '\J 'I ,

� n41\l b �B\1 "il1 fl b 41Tiii' fl\11'U 'WVI fl,;Vl�"tl � bL� b Vi CJ\Ier b� CJ1i1eJ1'U1"il IPI111 fl flvt111 CJ�"il �-.ij � fl1�'Vt�B m�vl1 fl1�� "i\'1 b U'U � � �

L �B 1 '\Xn"iJ fl1�"1JB\IiJ&i'U!"ll"l��!")1\IB�b��"il�'U1 ll vl11 '\XiJ&i'U!"ll"l� 1:!J�1111�t;1�1L iJ'Ufl1� 1�., L�CJ1tl'UV1�"tl��'U"1JB\IIPI'U 1� , '\J , I

n1� n ��vl1"1JB\Iil &i'U!"l r1� �'11:!1 m'U€1\1 rill�� fl€1'\.J r11 111 �u t:i lilV11\I €11 ru 1 Tiii' fl\11'U L 41vt,J1�� '11:!1 (;'{1111 �t;) � 1 L il'W ' u

r1�mru1 n'Uil&i'UI"l\"1� Lb��er:na1'U1"ilv11m�LL Vl'Uil&i'U!"l r1� 1 'U;i1'U�?i1'U 1'11 1� tl.l , 'U 'I ell

- L�1Ylilfl\11'U�Vl fl,;Vl �"tl � fl1��1 b il'UI"l�€11qj1 flU b�1"tlti fl\11'U�Vlfl,;Vl �"tl m:!J(;'f1111�t;1�"iJ � m�vl11�

L �B\I"il1flvti1L�'U�1'1J� b 'IJCJ L U'U11� bb vi-:�vtd� bn��'U'Vt�\l"il1 n-!'U� !311� �11���1 CJi1fl'1i\I�Vl fl,;Vl�"tl � L�lil"1J1� �111�\lvtd �

�\lmh1 1:!11 "!lvtd�Lnlil;ff'U b � B\l"il1n m��L 41TI'!! fl\11'U�Vi' n,;Vl �"tl � b .U11 ll b u'Uer -.ij� n"il n1 �Vl�"tl ��'U Lb Vl'Uil &1 'U r1 r1� � '

�\lfl1�fl1�vl1"1J€1\IiJ&\'U 1"11"1� 'U1 CJ�1\11:!J1� m�vl11Pl111fl1i\lvt�Br11111 L �'U'll€1'\J"UB\1!3!1� L 41Tiii'fl\11'U�Vl fl,;Vl�"tl � vt�B '

�ll��'1J11 L � 1vtd LL�€1 �1\11� fl'1i \1"1! B\l"tlti fl\11'U \PI �1"il LL � \I\11'U � '11:!J e-1 fl�'U L 41Titi fl\11'U�Vl fl,;Vl�"tl � LL� � fl €1\!Vl �"tl ��'U ' �

'11€1\liJ&\U\"11"1� 1 'Url��11��m CJ �fl�\11:!Jll�1fl floU €1 L Vi"il"il�\ll1fl1� 1:!1�1 CJ L�'UIPI111fl1 i'ITii! fl\11'UIPI�1\l LL ��\11'ULLn �fl�1\l ' ':..! �

Ln\il"il1fl fl1��L 41Titi fl\11'U�Vl fl,;Vl�"tl �:ijL\IIPI'U11:!J(;'f"iJ �IPI'Vt�€1\)e.JI:l� B �1\11 � fl1�fl1�vl1�\11:!Jmu €1\1 rill ��flB'U '

rld111�U t:i�V11\I €11ill1 Tii! fl\11'U L 41vttJ1�� '11:!J(;'f1lJ1�t;1 �1 L iJ'U 1"1 �€11 ru 1 L 41Titi fl\11'U�Vl fl,;Vl�"tl CJ1� ( -iJ€1vt1�B L�B\1 u u

0 .c.t. .c::!l 1.1 q II oll:li 0 V .o::tt. Q.J' � Q.J 4' � Q.l � .Q.A d fl1 � � 1 L 'U 'U 1"1 � €11 qJ 1 'U 1 CJ \11\1 fl � UJ !311 � � lJ � � � 1 CJ lJ 1"11 � \1 "tl V1 fl �Vl � "tl CJ L � � "1J 1 � IPI111 VI 'U \1 (;'{ €1 fl B \1 'U \PI fl1 � V1

Q.J' d Q.J' (

) �\I a <toed oornCS::rn �\11'UV1 C9lQ1 fl11.fl1"tl'Uli �<t<t� '

�- f11j�1Lil'Ur1�€11ru1mW'U1E.l:ij1\lil&iuflflt'I�'UorlthlnTl � • v

m"�'U1'U fl1��'U'VJ n"il fl1�"1JB\I � nvtdi1-J�P�t;1ll ��(;'f\lri L � €1"ll1 CJ 1 '\XLi�n"il"UB\1� nvtd�ll��(;'ft.J'Utuvt1V11\1�1'U 'U 'U 'I 'I 'U Cl.l

fl1�L�'U (a financially distressed enterprise) fl\ll"l\1�1lJ1�t;1�1 L il'U�B 1 ll11'11 'U"Uru��:nm�ll �'U Ll"l� \1(;'{�1\lvtd

"UB\1� nvt-d'L �€11 '\X� nvtdn�U111 L U'Uvtt.h CJV11\Ili�n"ilvt'l.ld CJ'Vt�\11 'U��'U'U L!3l��;jn"iJ�:i1 rld111�1111�t;11 'U fl1�e-J�IPI LL�� '\J '\J 'I 0.!1

LL "ll\1-tl'U 1� 1�c.�m�'U1'Ufl1��'UvJn"ilm�"il� b�11�'U�er�€1\1'11B 1:W11"il�L U'U'U��V1"il1n� 'U��V111vt1'1l'U ("i\'1n�) vt�B � �

.,..,. .,j .J 0

1 !:"1 "" 0 !V I .,j � ••'"" !V '] ... 0 V

'UIP!l.Jrlrl61B'UIPI111Vlfl1'Vt'U� 1 b 'Ufl!Jfl1�V1�1\I CJ'Url1�€1\1"1J€JIPIB!311� L "tl€1"1Je.Jy�'U YJfl"il fl1�"tl�B11LLe-J'U blilCJ'Vt1fl!3!161111"11(;'f\l

1 ��'U'VJn"ilfn�LL��CJ€111�'\.J LLe-J'U,r'U !3!16l"il�i\l�\lervl1bLe-J'U L �B 1 �erv\'1 LLe-J'U-.ij'lilll��'1J11L 41vtdL �B�"il1� UJ1 LLe-J'U 'Vt1 fl '\J '\J 'U ,

�ll��'1l11 L�1vtdi111&\ CJ€111�'\.J LLe-l'U \l�b(;'f'U€1 LLe-J'U,r'U�B!3!161 'Vt1 fl!3!1� L �'U'1JB'U�1 CJ LLe-J'U er'U �'Vt1�LLe-J'U/er'U�'Vt1�LLe-J'U ' � �

i11"1�11 \)��1L il'Ufl1�1Pl111 LLe-J'U,r'U bL�'Vt1fl1 'U mru�er�€1\I"UB �'Urll�€1\I"UB�Bm� L�CJm� L�'U€1bLe-l'U111"tl�€111 tl'U'Vt�B �

14

Page 15: bb 'I.Jfl1'f fl11fl'l1:U n11 1b iluA B1ru1 1:ucr. 1 ...

�tl 1�'1111 l � 1,-d' �� 19 1'Utr vh llv.J'U f311� Iii d1 f11i � 1 ,X l � Tvru fN1'UY1VI n,;'Vl-r'lfl � l�f.J ntl1�'1l11 l �1,-d' ll� � � � tr'U �,1 1 " 'U , 'U

-B-1 m11 (mlillil� l U'Ul �1,-d' fl'U 1�fl'U,� �,�a,m f.Jfl'U,�atr'U �,11'lla� � n,-d'1� f.J a� fl1 f.l 1� fl1 1n1 n'U � ll�'ll a� '\J 'U 'U 'U

l 'ii' 1 '!flu n � 1 'U Y1 VI m;'Vl-r'lfl f)) l �a 1 ,X P11 � i � � � tr v\' 1 llv.J'U 1 � CJ, � � lil1 mf'U tr 'U �, 11 llv.J 'U/tr 'U �,1 1 llv.J 'U -&1 fl 111 '\) '\) '\)

lil��1 b ii'Ufl11\Jl111lbv.J'U,f'U Ll��,1 fl6i1L �lil\Jl111Lbv.J'U f311�1ild1fhi�f.Jf\L� flfl11�'U'I"lfllilfl11 bb�,1fl1:!J6'11l �lil\Jl111 Lbv.J'U '\)

f311�1il dM1i� CJ n l�h fl11�'U'I"lfililfl11l �aiif11i�Y1VIn,;'Vl-r'lfl� l��'ll1��a 1 tl '\)

;�,��lil1fl bd aP11�iif11i�-r'U 1"11 �a�'ll a�'U'V'l filii fl11'lla�� n,d ll�1 � n,-d'lil� 1�i'-r'Um 1A11fl1a� 1Jl111'1f11�11'1l '\J 'U 'lJ 'I

Ut1JtY��11G'l�mf.J 'lfi.Pl. l!Jc(W:m 111\Jl11 �o/®1!> VJ'UVi1�f.Jfl�,111f.J 1111 C9lC9l ia ;�ijv.��vh1,X�n,.Q'G111111��1Lii'U

filii fl11'lla�\Jl'U�a 1 t11� LL�� 1�-r'U fl11Al.lfl1a� m tl1�m1 Fla (®) A1lfl1a� 1 ,X'U�,;'vmn,-d'iiG1m'lfl L tl'Wii�'Uflfl��a 1 tl " , 'U ,

(1!>) Al.l fl 1a� L �a 1 ,x'Vl-r'lfl ��'U'll a�� m-1-d'�� fl� a�� a 1 tl LL� � (m) ri'11 fl 1a� L �a 1 ,X� n,-d'G111111��1 L ii'Uu1filil �a 1 tl 'I 'U 'U " \} ..

�1'Uia,X1111 'U�n�ru�..J1n��'V15'lla��nwd',f'U n1,'U� 111 'U111m1 �o/ ®1!> ia � ;� n1,'Uwh ,X111il1 ,X�nwd' '\) '\)

..J1wt.hf.J �1f.J 1a'U 1,XL'Ih '1111�,-Q na,.Q' ,�am�Vllf\111�1 �na1,XLfi�fi11�1'U'Vl-r'lfi��'U'Uafllil1fllil�LU'U

f\11 m�vh�..J1 L U'U L �a 1 ,Xm1�1 L ii'U fl11A1tl n �'1Ja�� n,-d'G111111� �1 L ii'U �a 1 t11� L 1'ULL� f311��-r'U f11�a�'llalil �iif11 '\)

i�LU'Ua�1��'U

��,f'Uf\11�1 L U'Ufl�mru1mru'U1 CJ�1� L tl'Uu�'Uflfl��'Wi"'fililm1 ,f'U G111111��1il� LLCJnY11ilTHl.n1� ���a 1 tid " ' "

- mru,.,dm1l'lfi'S�'S1'1JUruru�ri'11ma� LL 'H�1'U 'lfl.f'l. l!J<tc(® Lfi� na'Wi''W� f'11G'liiFhi�1 ,X�'Ui"' fllil fl1'S cu v , 'll

LL�fJ� 1:JJ LL���� trv\'1 LLV-l'U�'U'\"l fllil fl1'S 'Uflfl�;��a�-r'U��'Vl1�eJ1tU1 1�LLn ii�'Uflfl� triiB1'U11ilvl1fl1'SLL 'Vl'UU�'Ufl fl� 'U 'U , u , 'U "

crt� -r'U 11 a 'U e) 1'U 11il1 ,Xij B1 'U 11il vl1 f\1 1 LL 'V1 'U ij � 'U fl fl � LL� � er 'U�,1 1-B-1 fl 111;� ,1 fl m ru er 'U�, 1 1-B-1 fl 111 'U " 'U 'U

L U'UL�1'1f1U n�1'UY1VI n,;'Vl-r'lfl �Iii� 1:!.1 �a� -r'U � �m ty1 L � a�lil1 n L �1'lflti n�1'UY1VI n,;'Vl-r'lfl � L i1111 � lL�'U�,11� � n11

LL'Vl'U'U1 CJ�1�\Jl111B1'U11ilWW1�'1Ja�'lfl1�11'lJUruru��11���1 CJ 'lfi.Pl. l!Jc(W:m (ia,1�a l�a� n11�1 L i1'Ufl�mru1 "' "' "'

'U1f.J�1� \Jl111,,r��ana�ii�fl11 � 1� o<toc(/ool!J®b ��l'U� ®1!> fl11fi1�'U5 l!J<t<tW:) '

- mru,-d'm11'1f11�11'11Uruni'�f111fl1a�LL 'S��1'U '!fl. Pl. l!J<tc(® Lfl�,��l'U�f311�iif11i�1 ,X�'U'I"lfllilfl11LL�� ..,ot , 'U

��trvl1LLv.J'U�'U'V'J fllil f\11 'Uflfl�;��a�-r'U ��'V11�mru1 1� LLn ii�'Uflfl� LL�� trv\'1 LLv.J'U L �a�lil1 f\�a'J1trv\'1 LLv.J'U 'U 'U 'I Cll , 'U 'U

iiB1'U11il,U1�1 'Ufl11��fllilfl11'lJa�'U1f.J�1�\Jl111'1f11�'S1'1lUtytY��11���1f.J 'lfi.Pl. l!Jc(W:m 111\Jl11 �o/l!J<t ��L U'U

�ij B1'U11ilvl1 fl11LL 'Vl'U'U1 CJ�1� ��ii�1'U� L U'U'U1 CJ�1� \Jl111'1f11�11'1lutyt[� �11fl1a� LL 1��1'U i 111\Jl11 <t �a��111-r'U� �

tl'U'U1 CJ�1�1 'U fl �mty1 LL�1:W� a �-r'U � � L U'U�1'U(;)1 (f11Y1'1f11 n�1� f\1� l!l<tl!l/l!J<tc(g)j LL� �f11Y1'1f11 n�1� f\1�

gJjgJjW:b/l!J<t<tb) .o=l J{ Q.l QJ�V ..:::., QJ Q.J d .oc:I O � � II'

- f\1ru,_.,'U\Jl111'1f11�11'1l'Uqjqj\Jl�11fl1a� LL 1��1'U '!fl. Pl. l!J<t�C9l Lfl�,��1'U'Vlf311�11fl1G1�L ,_.,'U'Ila'Um f.JLLv.J'U

'U flfl�;�� a�-r'U ��'V11�mru1 1� LLn U�'Ufl fl� tr'U�,11 LLv.J'U/tr'U�,11LLv.J'Ui1fl111 ;�,1fl mrutr'U�,11LLV-�'Ui1 m11 , CLI II 'U 'U \J

L U'UL �1'1f1U n�1'UY1VI n,;'Vl-r'lfl �Iii� 1:!.1 � a�-r'U � �m ty1 L � a�lil1 n L �1'1f111 n�1'UY1VI n,;'Vl-r'lfl f1 L i1111 � LL�'U�,11�� f\11 1.1 0 1.1 d CLI QJQ.t,l

LL 'Vl'U'U1f.Jiil1�m11m'U11il,'U1'Vl'lla�'lfl1�11'1l'U tyty\Jl�11��m f.J '!fl. Pl. l!Jc(W:m

-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-

15