Annexture - 16 bAnnexure 16b].pdf · Calcutta. April 29: ... Metro Norm Bengal Northeast Jharkhanc Bihar Odisha ... The statement would mean thatother than Rs50 lakh, ...

~,t. "J

.--.-------_._-----~-------------------------_.H.IP gh'l~!->up 011 fUrlHill;:minurity ~lJ\'{ in Il('lhi':

':THE FINANCIAL EXPRESS

10 (b)

Wot:nesday. Di'c;:!moor 10.2014 Tocay's P•.•per I E.Pa;x;r I HorcsC(lpe I gallery

o

lO •• SASH'!' ElECTI~NS ,,0';4

~-',~.'.. ,

- ,~

IN THE NEWSMamata Banerjee's paintbrushfetched TMCRs 6.47 crore in twoyears

c- Indian resC"ufcher dt'n:lop~afforci<~bJ(.h't'H,ibJe cei';CC 71)lr~h.'k:-:t:ltus oi he-al'L

Comrr,ents

SUt/.~.ARY

Tl'ino.']1o,-;;' Cl1ilr-i'CSS has (C::';l('d n.:a:':y R,,,~, .;- ~--"oJ'("J;"(lm thr ,,::(lit C!t'.i1amatC!Ba/H'iy"ccqs })(.:i::ti;,g, ,fiC .<:<f,1ject ofG hitt,')' {':rd:cl1!lL' hCt!Ci:'C1! :~1(mwtaarnlXm'cn.-!n, )106.

,~1 Sin;:;lt> hlil0d te:,t to detect ma,lY'=~~ I t)"'Pl..'-::or" l..'<interllii

TODAY'S PAPER

Offices b;Z loo,,~..l;; 2-Sfirm~ se.:oK .s.c<,.rce ;;~I:tHWeod-es ses

r-:;;.~c!soff polic~ issues: UPtc oonks on cdr,c

"~Icmg

'-P.7N c!iHCrr,t worst in l:l::'i:l~ C,",RE stw-c'y

Related Articles

M<ltY..o:s~lcs"d :oday fl)~

Lok Sabh,; e!ectlo~s~'o:ing 1;1 1w',lJmbaj

In the' bst two y(';jrs, thC'Trin<!.:11Oo1CongrC'ss 1135('rimed nearly Rs 6.-t7Croft' irO:l1 tIlt' salt' of tliamata llanerje('qs pai:llings. the subject of a

bitter e"c1u:.nht' het\\(:'en Mamuta and ~arendra ~Jodi.

(;0091£(,5 Proj.:cl A:;.; Piece :02£th!H your~r'l::iroic

Sacked MancheslerUnited manager O;;.vidf/,cyes thwks ,l"lelFerguso:1. St2YS mum onplayers

Yes 60:* ~""ic$i\'e ab~llt'talks' ''Iit/'", l& T Fin,znc€

fo~st,;k~ sale

51,;o.rt: Infr:;tel Ltd Q::

pron surges 64% 10 R~472 crore

.'\ balanct' shed or lhl' p31'ly~tlblllilt('d to tlw EI('t'lion Commission ~hol\'s

her painLings ft.'lcht'd Rs 2.,j:l croro:' in 20]2-2013 and just under Rs 3.9-1

crore ~he pJ"{'\iolis year. ]n 2010-2011, \\'hich was befol'l:' h('r pany C;1Illt'

to po\\'cr. no Mamatt, p:J.iEting \I"ns sold, :o;how L'opic~ of the thrt'c balan~'e

sheets 3C'('l'Sso2"d byThe Indian Express.

(>1f the Elt't1ion Commission feels i( necessary, it ,\ill ask for a hl't'akllJl of

the lis!. As of no\\". tht:re has bl'l'1l no intimlltion ttl us.~ said Amit

BtJ:ltt<.charya. offkcr on spC'tia\ duty at thl' offit,C' of till' West llengnl chi"f

ek(1o:a! officer.

MOST POPU lAR

GALLERIES

S.t ~.~India's

'"~

Real ,""GOP '0H: :.:~:o~(O\t,1

Read

l'l~i,~,'"~< ~- • ,-

tllm

Gil'igh 1\ l'andc, l~hicf {.'ommis~iuner of income tax in Kolkata, s,lid the EC

wodd senu the ul'parnmm the dt'tails aiter the t'lediolls. (>Thc ECwill send liS thest> fin,Hl('iai

statements and R('('ounts and if \\'(' fbel ;\l~~1hing W{'nN'd 10 probe. \\'{' \\ill.~ he said.

:\Iocli questioned Sunday ho\\. ont: ~IamatCl painting l'Ould fl:h:h Rs 1.$0 ('rore. The stale leadership of

the BJP and the Congress. roO..h.I\"(,. a1Jt'gC'd chit fund cOlllpanies wt'l'e amung the buycrs of the

paintings.

ffThe buyel's arc owners of chir fund companit's and some unstl'UpUl0,lS indllstri;llists who p:dd he;I\;.'amount ..•to 1llC'chief ministf'r \dlO became such a ee\C'I.Ha!('(lpaintl'r overnight. "'(' di'tnand that the

list oi buyers be pul up on th<, public domain,(/> said Congress state prC'sidelll Adh:r Ranjan

Chowdhury.

India's GOP, BhartiInfratcl. HindustanUnilever, BSE SenSE:X,NSE Nifty, Gold price,m()(e on October 27,2014

Maharashtra, Haryana

Assembly elections: Bythe numoors

Got money to splurge?Here are 5 latest

flagship smanphonesyou can buy this Diwali

Haryana electionsresults: BJP celobratesas Nareodra Modijuggernaut rolls over

oppn

DlJ~. j' (~.P<;', g.d'l,! t.1.-'llniljl)ril~. in

:'1<111:I., hlra \..,~...1111':.\ el..'cli'ln..;'/

BJ I' St;ltC presidl'llt Ral1l11 Sinh:! .••aid tILis is 01rout(' tILt' Ci\l has taken to IC'S<lJisl' 01:1(';'mOJl('Y. ~Thb is

moo(')' enllc(.tcd from chit fund compani('s wIdell the (lmty iii SiUl\\111g .IS salt, or pailltillgS. We \\''101 to

know 11m\'the paintings were f'old. Through auction or at randolll?(,l-llc ~aid.

OPINION POLL TODA V'S QUIZ

epl(:.'!) h';lder :.1d Sl'Iillll':lid, .q:\lort' th;lll :lIlything,lhl'Y an' paintillf: hl<wk mOJ1eyinto \\'l1ite . .f) '(es

The statements, with l"O\'cring letters of the party gelll'l'nI5t'tTct<lry !Vlukul Roy aloll}; \\1th the

Clllditur~s [('port. shu\l' thnt in two years after the p<1rty C<lme into power, sale of it~annual maga'l.inl'

too shot IIp ~ from Rs 3,79.:.!80 ill ::010-11 to Rs 12:,64.319 and Rs J() ,':""0.2:30 in tht" ,;ubs,~qll('nt t\WI

No

Can't Say

years.

Pailltcr{fs P"occ(,us

MORE FINANCIAL EXPRESS

2(}10-11: ~o saleINT. REPORTS

"2011-12: Rs :~,93-90,()OO

••:.!OI2-J:~:R5 :.!.5:'i.OO.ooo

* Total: Rs 6,-16.90.000

(.-\$ P('J' h;:!lam" sheet submitted to Ee)

- .\r:,h~ld.-\li

TAGS;

FE Events

SU??lEMENT(S)

C .•. ,'):"', ;!; 1-,1;:;;<';-

I,';:;':'~ae~'Sa~".s

::-:'2-r:-:'::>'~.o "0 a 2'_ L

I~: ':l i:>./ 2t•.:;".

S.>uoik'it'a

MORE FROf'f, LOK SABHA ELECTIONS 2014

\'i('torioll~Xiift'ndra i\"lodi fi;;ht~tearS in fjr~1addre~:,- to Indiac,rariialll('ntr.J3r<Jn~ulMOdi C:ioked :;p and stopped hiS s;;t'ec~to or,r.k wat<Jr during nls in(!ug:;ral appearance 1:1

lhe round. colc!"Iial-era buildIng

S,:-rnc Gc:"d~~, Ru'1~[ Go?:!"'cj~ia\'e~se;o te::')""':lf,g

Loaf-de of O;O;'OSiiie-- .:-:•..ck Sat •.a

EDITOR'S PICK

If~•

Efforts 10 t,ring ~2ck blaci<:~1cney on right trae.\: prJ,Na~E'l"!dra Modi

HoI\' Google .•••.ams 10 rule::.e s':'jar:'p!lo~e rnarke:

ItsOHICiel rON' M~vutiSL:zuki set 10 launc~ r'€"X,Gener,"",ion lIjio K 10 on No\3

Reader's Comments 1Post Go Comment

The Telegraph

Fcliow Us:

EditionToday's IVIledr.esday, April 30,2014 I

Paintings sold, TMC 'forgot' to pay NGO

But the IICP, known as the Spastic Society of Easlern India till 1999, said it had receivedonly Rs 50,000 from sale of Mamata's paintings in 2004. Shortly before that. an IICPofficial said, it had received Rs 25,000 and a painting by Mamata but the official couldnot recollect the year.

SAII,.1StTSAHA

Calcutta. April 29: The Trinamul Congress forgot to hand OVE<[the proceeds from the saleot Mamata Banerjee's paintings to the Indian Institute of Cerebral Palsy (IICP) despitethe chief minister making a promise in public more than a year ago, a party officialloldThe Telegraph this evening.

The Trinamul official, who declined to be quoted by name. was responding to a series ofquestions from this newspaper after the JlCP said thaI it had not received any donationfrom the party since 2004.

Trinamul has been defending t.'1epair,ling sales thal fetched crores by saying that theproceeds were given to charity, including 10the ~Spastics Society', and used in electionwork.

.,Twc£,t i7

Front Page> StoryIN TODAY'S PAPER

Front PageNationCalcutta

Bengal

Foreign

Business

SportsHorse Racing

12Opinion

CITIES & REGIONS

Metro

Norm BengalNortheast

Jharkhanc

BiharOdisha

WEEKLY FEATURES

Knowhow V~n

Jobs Tui'

You Th~Howrah F.,

Salt Lake h7days 3,,~.Graphiti !;.•.'~

LEISURE

SudokuSudoku NewCrossword

JumbleGallery

ARCHIVES

Since 1 March. 1999

The Trinamul official said the painting and the Rs 25.000 were given in 2005,

Botti versions suggest that the proceeds from the painting sales immediately beforeMamata became chief minister and after she assumed power did not go to the IICP. Tr,ebulk of the sales-.J"as reported from events organised in April2011 -less than tv.:omonths before Mamata beC2.me chief minister-and in January 2013.

On February 7,2013. soon after CPrv'! leader Surjya Kanta Mlshra wondered aloud "whobought the paintings and at '".••hat price", Malilata had said at Wri,ers' Buildings: "From thefunds raised from the exhibition (at the To\"mhall annexe), I have dee,ded to donate Rs10 lakh to the governor's rel,ef fund and Rs 25 lakh to the chief minister's relief fund. I willgive Rs 51akh e2ch to our three candidates contesting the by-elections. The rest of themoney would go to .he Spastics Society,~

The statement would mean that other than Rs 50 lakh, the remainil1g amount from theexr.ibition proceeds should have gone to the IICP,

Subhra Chaaerjee, deputy director of lICP, said this evening after being contacted by t!lisnewspaper: "Mamata Banerjee has been nice to us. The painting (given earlier) is stillthere in my room. But the IICP has not received any donation. 6ither in cash or kind. fromher after sr.e became the C11efminister as being mentioned in some places:'

EXTRAS

Press Releases

Travel

THE TELEGRAPH

AbDUl Us

AdvertiseFeedback

Contact Us

She added: "If it (Spastics Society) means us, we received (donation) last in 2004 andnothing thereafter." Chatterjee could not readily confirm whe!her there was any otherorganisation bearing the name cf Spastic SOCiety in the city.

The Trinamul official also did not say that Ine chief minis,er meanl some otherorganisation,

Asked about the promise made by the chief minister more than a year ago, ,he Trinamulofficial said: "It slipped our mind. Tne IICP will definilely get It but after Ihe electionbecause we don't \\'ant to make it a poll issue right now, We want to flghl the election enthe plank of development:'

Trinamul ail-India general secretary Mukul Roy had said yesterday: ~Every lime, tr,eamount '-se received from such exhibitions has been given for a social cause. In 2004,the amount was given to Spastics Society."

Roy's version matches with that of the IICP as far as the year 200415 concerned. Multipleattempts to contact Roy tonight for a comment on the chief minister's promise wereunsuccessfJI.

ncP's Chatte~ee, who looks ater the communication and resource mobilisation part ofthe organisatjon, recalled lhallv1amata came to tr,eir office unannounced and spantUme

-with the-children once. - - - - - ~-

~She came and lied rakhL la:er after becoming eM. she also invited our children tosome governr.1ent programmes, notably Children's Film Festival," she said.

The Trinamul source indicated thai the IICP was likely to get Rs 20 lakh from Uleexhibijon at the Town Hall annexe.

However, going by the source's own "offhand" estimate that '.over Rs 2 crore'. was raised.the IICP should be given at leasl Rs 1.5 crore a(ter deducting the Rs 50 lakh ec.rlllarkedby the chief minister for other causes.

Documents submitted by Trinamul 10 tile EleeUon Commission do not sllow the hmdsraised through the sale of paintings 'Ii January 2013, according to SOllrces in Deihl.

The Trinarnul complainl against Narendra Modi for his alleged defamatory slatement onMamata included an income and expenditure slatemenl for 2011-20 12, Ihe sources said.

The sources said the statement mentioned an income of Rs 3.939 crare frem the "sale ofpaintings", out otthe party's total income of Rs 10.56 crore for that financial yea.

The proceeds from U1G Townhall annexe exhibition are expected to feature in the auditr3dreport of 2012-13. The figure Rs 3.939 CfOre could then possibly indicate the proceedsfrom the exhibition al Galerie 88 in April 2011.

ADDITIONAL REPORTING BY MEGHDEEP BHATTACHARYYA

5E, Tweet 17

Bhar"ti'.1o:tnmony - the gateway to happy marriages. Register Fl"ee'

More stories in Front Page

• I,/jool n.ms lor st',a"y K:rti• Deb as\.;s qJilstlOn~ about CIJ r~19ti\la;; fl:'1CScops at t10me• Dry '.'iinds spur heal ~ave alen• Ke:lp va~s.cty AAU ,ie-:.JP• ED t~ al1e ••'"! Saraoha proper:ias• P::J,r;,"';~$.;'. T';'C .f:,rg:);' I:' n;. T,•.••..•• SWdy rindS Sonllpur hub of trafflCiiing• Election .;Iv~r, ~uwer a.;t rages 111slat~• Palzmau 10probe primi1M~ tribe dea:!'.s• Spot the differences. i'l trea~menr arJd in (!",em€ssage

D:sclaimer I Privacy ~olICY I Conlact Us

~~ 8.,~1~'f(~jJ~~frni."'-1 1---1- -I--'---I-'--T---T-il--

You are here: 'i" 1'(, ~ lndl<l

RFL\TEIl I\El'WORDS: j rin('!:t;<:.,l I "::1'" -~,H;:r,~;',','

BJ;; a~ ••.S f',.1::v~::l:<, Baro,nf<€ t(; 'r,,:;;'!~:i fCCIO,,,:d~:rtJr;:u'e' c:::~nd Pf,j,'s "-;:'':;'1

Details of lvlamata Banerjee's paintillg sales are in publicdomain: Trinamool

Tnr;jr.'I0C~ S~lO".0: ~1:'er.g:1 iiG<Wl~r";:;ppCn)r'iS:"

C::-.SI ';(.<3'1"1. ED t:i ~~9.S:i:"'7 [1'::':: ;:"Sfo-:,l<iJ~06ri:"';; r!RE-

Op;".•.si:ion \....(0"1:" k\ar.':')M ::l::';':J';3~ I.,) ~:Q::-''cr.d!lr'9' .n ::;c?

PIL ;r, \'3~;'2~ higl".C.O,.1'~!i2:1~"':"~~:'OJ'':!:,l5el1"fJ: 7r:J~\~it:rd l:'C; ':::'";.-~-,~

KOLK\T ..\; Tilt" cm pr;:;),' into S;lr;Hibl b",;~~udi;':,: ''';'.'11'::~i:k,!.;{.d I'l;::in; 1/()I~:ll1al~~g~l1"'l:il.i.'\ p:,i,;tjr:.~.'i'l'r:; !:~';'i,>i.t:~1h:l..~ ,:1";\\":1 flak fo'l,lri Ti';llar:wnl. Pnrty n;HI;J'1.:: ..;p\;i.,-",~j',.':'';:.::1

Dt-,t"l, UB!io:n ft':lltt"Ll tilt" TOl novo;-, vL T"l':':.j~;~,.~:\i:j_~i:~'~,.':<.::Z'~;i, .2't'tilH of:h,,: ,,!II.: pr,)('C"c';!.o: uf :.1:1il,;\!;i',; ;~;,:nt;l):::_.';t21:::!l,~h (;~~l1jhj!it~:l.~,

';',"l' Tt'i;:~:~l,'oj ;{;;.iy;) ~';:.hlw )1 P ,,<!id t!";;j: ":r~f)ll~~',\',;...•!"\-'C:":l, ,.'d;1~'("::..:'q~!(:.;!:1d ali ;~;<,ll:"-'i~t"'-h,i\'C: h,\':; cui: ,';;'.; f:li;,h~\:lly,t'P,,?:';," i t;J ,i~<:' t :,:", ;, 11!hl)riti,;,.~ .! r :i:,,, ;'-:'IJ ••,:' i:',."d., '.':1 r";,,;~:-:\"i.lj

Ga\',~'r.m.;'1: C€-:~,~,i'1~I.:::€:2;::;:l'~iT,;it~:) CO;T;~I:$W'':lcte. '6f11S\'t", ~~:IO'l :::('9

~ar_0!5,~J"",hrif.~'Y ;,;:.;.;r",h-dl\:<;' ':.'6i ~,..."r;'''••I'. ;>('n",T;;rr.:j f..j:?i~

';9~~ !,lurn~;,' :)j;:lS:,s $": ~:"']:. Y,oj.~'h 5

E->.'2:t.h:.r

Ol;;.x:sl:ion C';iT~i' go',: C,'f:' .al.•~:;-.'): ",1,-: 2'(.",::;-,'.<;~sic"'l;~';';;F~

,\,r, t''of: j,;ti,.,c~ .:1';' "Pt'il t;J .:~n.'111~~~1t'i.:)' ~,;; ;n,in:~"::-;~,~innu-.::t:l\'t: ;;c ••l iK'ni:'~ti:H;';iil:- 1/ r;{;sir::.:.f\t:~d::. (nr ,I l'oHti.':d P<ii:~' ;,:;'",dfor j),)tii.i:::l ~ir,d ;:.()cj~d;:I'l;\;.":;1. T!;(":f \\.:::' ;<.:~c1i~t1(lthi:;~ ,'k,;:k-:1:lt~-da~~•.:r ;,h:H:t lh•..'~('tran •.•."1l.til111:>, Till' l'xhlbiltun,; ii<!\\'l;il,l':l pine\.' ~nfull pl,bEL' ',1",;\,a::d allthe inf;,n~liltlo" r~;.:,;;dill:}. the t:alt':- i,:-. in th<: puhlil' ll(lniain," ncr~k ~li(i, HC\':i'\"eL rhe Trina:nol,lki!G:"r dinn't t;-Ik"" tilt, l"(..,;,p0n::ihiiity (If ;:,Ii tho",,,,d:.') \""tlgLt thi' pninting:'" j'r"Jlj the punlie :,h\';w.

'j'(jl h •...<.1:'t"p(".r;~'l,!nl1 TI.:t.~d;:y that Cp'j ::' '"e-c'I.:':n::c:";-,:Iil",~':-l)ill th-e inC('!:k :,1:\ ,~::pilrtn~:"'::t 0::purcb;",,,, t'.{ ni'!v of :\l:lmal;:;'~ p<1j,ilill;::~b:- ;;';~;ri~;'ll:.5,,"]1. !'('pr,fcl'dl.\ kr J.:.~:.;::,'ro!'.:,

?n;.,-j'.l :::."; 'Ud:l\h' ItTthe .,.d~~of :-.jnm;.~k'.-i~;':il'j!'i:l,;~h :'.\(11 ,~ :'OWur~d",:' (:H! :i:";,'i. T!:~T;';,l,,:;h)(,).';i;.;l(':~:i.'n: ."2.;d: "c;'lic first ,;"i."i1 ~'..;i:db:ljC!; \",';5 !1c1d :1'. ":~;":l.P~.,inLin~s:\\\';-,' pri,.,'d ,1t Rs !O.UlIU-~f),:"JO. Till.' :-;(,~.{!!~,j(.~:!;ihitiO:l \\';:!,> h<:id ::-1:21)1r, P::,:"ltb,,;~ ',\\.'1"('p:'h:""d ~:l 1\lllg:1!Y R- H.H1.()i10.rr~,m t:~:;pm{:(;'e,j~ l!f ~h.~t:'.:I,d '.nb::<:'cp,;{""i e\h~hiti,lL1:S ,""dt--. ,f,:1trlh,:ti,111~ (Jr' R~ 1 ~ ['(Wi:" \'.",••rt;n;!dc to :1:\:.l:'h:\,f :)Iillj"'"trr'~Rdiri Fm,d '\nd R:e- i,~,,:i-:f, to ii,," GC1"c-r:;c,r':, I'kJid FlUId . .-\"sis", ,:-c\'.'l:'",!::--.' ;'["\'\ idt-c ii, :.he\k~im,; of pn!il'" ;,11.i CP-;,f hn: 1~1j:~'in :\ itnJi,'fr,:nl ::n? O~hl~l'pb('(;~.~

'm'"'p.'.'.Ib••••••••••""'.""'.'.' •• b•• ' O'.'''''ii.''''''"'''!?''''' ••• """".w••••••..,,,,,..... __

'0j< $;':"

_._.'.' IS __Mw:w!:'1 l){;nl'j:i(!(~ louks ur-her :;cinti;lf}, :chich silt: tfrc(c lIiI rhl.'. ,"[(~ye d,~l'illq the ini.HI~)unllPJ'l',']:'rWI ;JXorrh J;(,119(,lfr'stit:al (!t SiligH/'I"~ A'/!711:!IC1~hIll9a S't(uJiWI!, Oil JWll..!l1r£, I, 2(}IS. (TOlpi:<i!O h.<ll,:a::sUk Ri.!y)

Tht' third t':-;hibiti,m wac' held in :::011. it ~air1. ",\1t' ..,.O: h., "Pil:1. 127,nOlI :,idun: ;,)O:'1l';I1'ds andhl.llOn (,;11;tk'.~\lc::\\"I'ri~~olrl "t Grdl<:rie 3S in i\rJlk<lta. '[1,,' n;lin:i1Ij.':s \'.\~r(:Dri('~'ti b\' thl'

" ", :.....