Top Banner
Op#mising Management For Children In Our Region Dr. Craig McDonald Consultant Paediatrician Bucks Healthcare NHS Trust
21

AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Nov 28, 2021

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Op#mising  Management    For  Children  In  Our  Region  

Dr.  Craig  McDonald  Consultant  Paediatrician  

Bucks  Healthcare  NHS  Trust    

Page 2: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Equity  In  Delivery  of  Healthcare  •  Varia<on  in  healthcare  is  ubiquitous  •  Varia<on  in  immunisa<on  rates  between  GP  prac<ces  

•  Varia<on  in  pa<ent  outcomes  for  surgical  procedures  

•  Variability  in  access  to  research  across  different  hospitals  

•  Varia<on  in  inpa<ent  management  of  common  condi<ons  

Page 3: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Introduc#on  •  The  NHS  Ins<tute  for  Innova<on  and  Improvement  •  “if  all  NHS  organisa<ons  improved  their  performance  to  match  the  top-­‐performing  25%,  the  NHS  could  save  about  £3.6  billion”  

•  Don  Berwick  •  “Varia<on  is  a  thief.  It  robs  from  processes,  products  and  services  the  quali<es  that  they  are  intended  to  have.  ...  Unintended  varia<on  is  stealing  healthcare  blind  today.”  

Page 4: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Causes  Of  Varia#on  

VARIATION  

NICE  

RCPCH  

Resources  

Policy  

Private  Provision  

Service  Configura<on  

Clinical  Decisions  

“How  It’s  Done”  

Guidelines  

In  pa<ent  Beds  

Wai<ng  Lists  

Specialists  

Cost  vs  Tariff  

Pa<ent  Choice  

Morbidity  

Commissioning  Priori<es  

Popula<on  Lifestyles  

Determinants  of  Illness  

GP  Decisions  

AZtude  to  Risk  

Socio-­‐economic  deprivaton  

Demographics  

Age  Gender   Ethnicity  

Bad  Data  

Random  Varia<on  

BTS  

Source:  NHS  Atlas  of  Varia3on  

Page 5: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Types  of  Varia#on  •  Systemic  vs  unintended  •  Systemic  varia3on  •  Varia3on  outwith  the  control  of  clinicians  and  comissioners  •  Varia3on  in  popula3on  /  demographics  etc  

•  Unintended  •  “Varia3on  in  the  u3liza3on  of  health  care  services  that  cannot  be  explained  in  pa3ent  illness  or  pa3ent  preferences.”    •  Different  thresholds  among  clinicians  for  admission  /  treatments  /  interven3ons  

Page 6: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Reducing  Varia#on  •  1st  step  to  reducing  unintended  varia<on  is  the  gathering  and  publica<on  of  pa<ent  outcomes    

•  Varia<on  in  admission  rates  for  common  reasons  for  paediatric  admissions  •  Pneumonia    •  Bronchioli<s  •  Sepsis  /  Fever  •  Gastroenteri<s  •  Asthma  

•  Varia<ons  in  management  of  Pneumonia  •  BTS  audit  

Page 7: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Admission  Rates  •  Admission  Rates  •  Hospital  Episode  Sta<s<cs  •  Primary  or  secondary  diagnosis  •  Grouped  by  CCG  

•  Popula<on  •  Popula<on  for  0-­‐4  years  and  5-­‐17  years  for  each  CCG  

•  Length  of  Stay  •  %ge  of  admissions  discharged  in  <24  hours  •  Average  LOS  for  the  remainder  

Page 8: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

The  Thames  Valley  

Page 9: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Results  -­‐  Maps  

Page 10: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Results  II  –  Funnel  Plots  

1,141

564

1,123

1,861

557

781 833

1,907

843

1,117

916

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1800

2000

0

5000

1000

0

1500

0

2000

0

2500

0

3000

0

3500

0

4000

0

4500

0

DSR

per

100

,000

Sta

ndar

d Po

pula

tion

per Y

ear

Population

Gastroenteritis (0-4yrs)

England Average

2SD limits

3SD limits

Page 11: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Results  -­‐  Dashboard  

Page 12: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Length  of  Stay  •  Day  Case  Rates  

•  Length  of  Stay  (for  admissions  >24  hours)  

Page 13: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

BTS  Pneumonia  Audit  •  BI-­‐Annual  Audit  of  prac<ce  in  UK  against  current  recommenda<ons  

•  Data  from  2012/13  compared  between  ins<tu<ons  

Hospital) Number)of)patients)

Horton&Hospital& 21&

Milton&Keynes&General&Hospital& 29&

Royal&Berkshire&Hospital& 20&

Stoke&Mandeville&Hospital& 51&

The&John&Radcliffe& 24&

Total) 145)!

Page 14: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

BTS  Pneumonia  •  Significant  differences  in  pa<ents  at  admission  across  hospitals  •  No  Requiring  O2    •  10%  at  HGH  vs  72%  SMH  

•  Presence  of  Wheeze    •  <20%  JR  /  HGH  vs  40—50%  in  other  hospitals  

Page 15: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

BTS  Pneumonia  

Horton  Hospital  

Milton  Keynes  General  Hospital  

Royal  Berkshire  Hospital  

Stoke  Mandeville  Hospital  

The  John  Radcliffe  

Na<onal  Data  

No   10   3   10   21   14   1753  No  Data  /  Not  Recorded   3   59  Yes   11   23   10   30   10   1875  

0%  10%  20%  30%  40%  50%  60%  70%  80%  90%  100%  

Blood  Cultures  Taken?  

Page 16: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

BTS  Pneumonia  

Horton  Hospital  

Milton  Keynes  General  Hospital  

Royal  Berkshire  Hospital  

Stoke  Mandeville  Hospital  

The  John  Radcliffe  

Na<onal  Data  

No   5   1   3   1   7   425  Yes   16   28   17   50   17   3276  

0%  10%  20%  30%  40%  50%  60%  70%  80%  90%  

100%  

Percentage  of  children  receiving  chest  x-­‐ray  

Page 17: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Management  of  Pneumonia  •  1st  line  an<bio<c  •  Significant  varia<on  in  PO  amoxicillin  as  1st  line    •  from  2%  at  Milton  Keynes  to  62%  at  the  Horton  •  Majority  treated  with  either  amoxicillin  or  co-­‐amoxiclav  +/-­‐  a  macrolide.    

•  Use  of  Intravenous  an<bio<cs  •  Significant  varia<on  in  pa<ents  receiving  IV  An<bio<cs    •  45%  at  RBH  to  79%  John  Radcliffe  (?more  complicated)  

Page 18: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

Summary  •  Across  the  Thames  Valley  there  is  significant  varia<on  in    •  Admission  rates  •  Length  of  stay  •  Management  of  pneumonia  

•  So  What?  

Page 19: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

5  Stages  of  “Data  Grief”  

The  Data  is  wrong  

It  does  not  apply  to  me  

I  will  find  the  correct  data  

There’s  nothing  I  can  do  

Acceptance  and  Ac<on  

DENIAL  

ANGER  

BARGAINING  

DEPRESSION  

RESOLUTION  

(With  Apologies  to  Elisabeth  Kubler  Ross)  

Page 20: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

What  Next?  •  Report  circulated    •  Comissioners  •  Providers  

•  Mee<ng  with  Guideline  leads  across  region  •  Star<ng  to  work  towards  syncrony  •  Central  loca<on  for  guideline  lists  •  Training  –  Pneumonia  e-­‐Learning  package      •  Due  Sept  2015    •  Audits  planned  for  winter  2015  •  Bronchioli<s  &  Gastroenteri<s  

Page 21: AHSN Partnership Board 17th June 15 CMCD1

 Varia#on  in  an#bio#c  prescribing    •  Abx  guidelines  from  each  hospital  •  Benchmarking  exercise    •  Local  resistance  paserns  explored  •  Move  to  harmonise  prescribing  guidelines