Page 1
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 1
AFFORDABILITY VS. FINANCIAL AID: CRAFTING A NEW STUDENT RECRUITMENT MESSAGE
©ROBERT E. JOHNSON, PH.D. 2014
Robert E. Johnson, Ph.D.President, Bob Johnson Consulting
ACT Enrollment Planners Conference, Chicago, IL
July 24, 2014
Page 2
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC ... @HighEdMarketing 2
Who is Bob Johnson?
• Website reviews from a marketing perspective• “Top Task” research partner w/Gerry McGovern at Customer Carewords, Ltd, Dublin, Ireland
• 75 higher education clients since 2006• “Your Higher Education Marketing Newsletter”… 3,700 subscribers
• @highedmarketing… 6,600+ Twitter followers• “Higher Education Marketing” blog• Symposium for the Marketing of Higher Education… chair, 1994 to 2003
Page 3
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 3
AN NEW AFFORDABILITY ENVIRONMENTRequires serious “affordability” content.
Page 4
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 4
Chronicle of Higher Education…http://bit.ly/1l3n516
Page 5
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 5
From the Department of Education…http://collegecost.ed.gov/catc/
Page 6
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 6
Responses from 5 diverse schools…
• American University• Strayer University• Wellesley College• University of Findlay• Southern New Hampshire University• And 3 Appendices:
• Comparing competitive costs… 12 schools• Affordability to boost leads… 2 schools• “Affordability” without substance… 5 schools
Page 7
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 7
AFFORDABILITY: SERIOUS NEW CONTENT
Page 8
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 8
AMERICAN UNIVERSITYReducing tuition increases and merit aid.
Page 9
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 9
American U. gets serious…http://www.american.edu/initiatives/collegeaffordability/
Page 10
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 10
Reducing merit-based aid…http://www.american.edu/initiatives/collegeaffordability/how-financial-aid-stacks-up.cfm
Page 11
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 11
Lower loan default rate…http://www.american.edu/initiatives/collegeaffordability/taking-charge-of-your-college-costs.cfm
Page 12
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 12
Decreasing cost increase levels…http://www.american.edu/initiatives/collegeaffordability/how-AU-is-addressing-college-costs.cfm
Page 13
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 13
STRAYER UNIVERSITYMany ways to reduce cost of a degree.
Page 14
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 14
Starting on the home page…http://www.strayer.edu/
Page 15
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 15
Add unusual benefits…http://www.strayer.edu/strayer-university-tuition-reduction
Page 16
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 16
“Two ways to save money”…
For transfer credits… For Strayer courses…
Page 17
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 17
Reduce credits for a degree…http://www.strayer.edu/admissions/get-credit-your-life
Page 18
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 18
Unusual start to Financial Aid page…http://www.strayer.edu/tuition
Page 19
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 19
WELLESLEY COLLEGE“Basic financial question” to a FAFSA-free EFC estimate.
Page 20
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 20
Before the NPC, a “quick” first step…http://www.wellesley.edu/admission/affordable/myintuition
Page 21
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 21
#1… Demographics
Page 22
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 22
#2… Total family income
Page 23
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 23
#3… Savings & checking accounts
Page 24
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 24
#4… Home equity
Page 25
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 25
#5… IRAs, 401Ks and such (optional)
Page 26
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 26
#6… Value of investments
Page 27
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 27
#7… Other children in college
Page 28
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 28
Your expected family contribution…
Page 29
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 29
UNIVERSITY OF FINDLAY5 affordability myths.
Page 30
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 30
Myth #1… Public vs. private costhttp://www.findlay.edu/offices/student/financialaid/Affordability-Myths
Page 31
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 31
Myth #2… Family income
Page 32
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 32
Myth #3… Completion times & rates
Page 33
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 33
Myth #4: Debt level
Page 34
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 34
Myth #5… Default rates
Page 35
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 35
SOUTHERN NEW HAMPSHIRE UNIVERSITYCollecting 10 cost-related press releases.
Page 36
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 36
Scroll for cost-control press releases…http://www.snhu.edu/admission-costs.asp
Page 37
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 37
Pick the ones that interest you…
Page 38
THANKS FOR BEING HERE IN CHICAGO!
Bob Johnson, Ph.D. (248.766.6425)
[email protected]
www.bobjohnsonconsulting.com
@highedmarketing on Twitter
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC... @highedmarketing 38
Page 39
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 39
APPENDIX 1:COMPARING TUITION COST“A small tuition is the best tuition”
Eastern Washington University
Page 40
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 40
University of Wisconsin-Superior…http://www.uwsuper.edu/admissions/cost/compare-tuition-and-cost.cfm
Page 41
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 41
Strayer University…http://www.strayer.edu/strayer-university-tuition-reduction
Page 42
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 42
Eastern Washington University…http://www.ewu.edu/undergrad/afford
Page 43
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 43
University of Texas at Austin…http://www.utexas.edu/tuition/national.html
For state residents… For out-of-state students…
Page 44
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 44
State College of Florida…http://www.scf.edu/StudentServices/Tuition/TuitionandFeesComparison.asp
Page 45
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 45
Elgin Community College…http://elgin.edu/students.aspx?id=148
Page 46
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 46
Guilford Technical Community College…http://www.gtcc.edu/about-gtcc/public-disclosures/tuition-comparison.aspx
Page 47
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 47
Eastern New Mexico University…https://www.enmu.edu/future-students/tuition/compare.shtml
Page 48
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 48
Austin Community College…http://www.austincc.edu/tuition-and-financial-aid/compare-costs
Page 49
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 49
Texas Women’s University…http://www.twu.edu/bursar/cost-comparison.asp
Page 50
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 50
Linfield College…http://www.linfield.edu/dce/tuition-comparison.html
Page 51
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 51
Nicolet College…http://www.nicoletcollege.edu/future-student/high-school/value/comparing-costs/index.html
Page 52
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 52
Western International University…http://west.edu/affordability/tuition-comparison-guide
Page 53
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 53
http://www4.lehigh.edu/admissions/undergrad/tuition
Page 54
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 54
APPENDIX 2:AFFORDABILITY TO BOOST LEADS…
Page 55
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 55
UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND UNIVERSITY COLLEGE
Page 56
Using a tease to get a lead at UMUC… http://bit.ly/18IBXxn
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 56
Page 57
Forcing me to a PDF…http://www.umuc.edu/students/admissions/transfer/upload/10-great-ways-to-pay-for-your-education-brochure.pdf
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 57
Page 58
The good… and the not so good
• Prominent placement of monthly no interest tuition payment
• But what is the “low nonrefundable enrollment fee”?
• And the link here makes me link again to another page. Link direct.
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 58
Page 59
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 59
UNION INSTITUTE & UNIVERSITY“Affordable” as a teasing benefit.
Page 60
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 60
An online ad from March 18…
Page 61
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 61
Program benefits include “Affordable”…http://bit.ly/1qRLGqE
Page 62
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 62
Auto response: no links to benefits
Page 63
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 63
Academics: “affordable” still missing…http://www.myunion.edu/Academics.aspx#prettyPhoto
Page 64
APPENDIX 3:AFFORDABILITY: WORDS W/O SUBSTANCE
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 64
Page 65
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 65
Lost on a traditional financial aid page…http://www4.lehigh.edu/admissions/undergrad/apply
Start here… End here…
Page 66
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 66
“Cost & Affordability” = Financial aid infohttp://www.bradley.edu/admissions/freshman/cost/
Page 67
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 67
“Affordable” commitment w/o details…https://www.utsystem.edu/affordability/
Page 68
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 68
“Most affordable” claim, no specifics…https://www.lewisu.edu/affordability/outstandingvalue.htm
Page 69
Bob Johnson Consulting, LLC 69
The mission statement, PR approach…http://rwu.edu/about/partnerships-initiatives/affordable-excellence/our-approach