4-How share wants to practically apply the mca methodology

04/12/23

How SHARE wants to practically How SHARE wants to practically apply the MCA methodologyapply the MCA methodology

• SHARE aims to apply the SHARE aims to apply the MCA methodology MCA methodology to the HP plants’ decision to the HP plants’ decision processes.processes.

• This approach is led using an This approach is led using an existing informatic tool existing informatic tool customized during the customized during the project to project to facilitatefacilitate the the comprehension of the procedure comprehension of the procedure by all stakeholders: by all stakeholders: SESAMO software.SESAMO software.

SESAMO is the tool for the SESAMO is the tool for the MCA implementation in SHAREMCA implementation in SHARE It works with It works with PROJECTSPROJECTS containing data and structures of the decision containing data and structures of the decision

processprocess The The structurestructure of the project of the project reflectsreflects the the logical steps logical steps of the methodologyof the methodology

The software for MCA The software for MCA application in SHAREapplication in SHARE

The software for MCA The software for MCA application in SHAREapplication in SHARE

• In the SESAMO software, each MCA phase is represented by a In the SESAMO software, each MCA phase is represented by a specific panel specific panel where it is possible to implement and elaborate data.where it is possible to implement and elaborate data.

The software for MCA The software for MCA application in SHAREapplication in SHARE• On the first SESAMO panel, on the left side, it is possible to create the On the first SESAMO panel, on the left side, it is possible to create the decision decision

treetree, and on the right side it possible to insert the , and on the right side it possible to insert the alternativesalternatives..

The software for MCA The software for MCA application in SHAREapplication in SHARE• The The resultresult of the implementation of all the SESAMO panels is of the implementation of all the SESAMO panels is visiblevisible in the in the

Alternative Ranking panelAlternative Ranking panel. .

The software for MCA The software for MCA application in SHAREapplication in SHARE• The last SESAMO panel is the The last SESAMO panel is the Sensitivity AnalysisSensitivity Analysis..• In this section it is possible to evaluate the effects of the weight allocation In this section it is possible to evaluate the effects of the weight allocation

through through 4 different sub-panels4 different sub-panels. .

• In the In the Analysis of Changes sub-panel Analysis of Changes sub-panel it is possible to vary one or more indicator it is possible to vary one or more indicator weights and/or fix others in order to evaluate if and how the alternative weights and/or fix others in order to evaluate if and how the alternative ranking changes (as the sum of the weights allocated must be 1). ranking changes (as the sum of the weights allocated must be 1).

• As we can see the As we can see the bars highlighted in green bars highlighted in green correspond to varying indicator correspond to varying indicator weights, the weights, the blue ones blue ones change accordingly and the change accordingly and the red one red one is a fixed indicator is a fixed indicator weight.weight.

SHARE project testingSHARE project testing

► The MCA methodology and the related software will be applied in The MCA methodology and the related software will be applied in 11 Pilot 11 Pilot Case Studies Case Studies on various mountain basins in on various mountain basins in 5 Alpine Space countries5 Alpine Space countries. .

► All the 11 Pilot Case Studies are alpine basins but they represent All the 11 Pilot Case Studies are alpine basins but they represent different different typologiestypologies, geomorphologies, biotic and abiotic conditions, anthropic , geomorphologies, biotic and abiotic conditions, anthropic pressures, kind of touristic activities, etc.pressures, kind of touristic activities, etc.

““Dora Baltea & Chalamy basins (I)”Dora Baltea & Chalamy basins (I)”

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

““Chisone basin (I)”Chisone basin (I)”

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

““Astico and Cordevole basins (I)”Astico and Cordevole basins (I)”

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

““Durance basin (F)”Durance basin (F)”

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

““Arc – Isère basins (F)”Arc – Isère basins (F)”

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

““Mur basin (AT)”Mur basin (AT)”

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

““Lech basin (D)”Lech basin (D)”

Pilot case studiesPilot case studies

““Kokra basin (SI)”Kokra basin (SI)”