, tkJ/ - Moritz College of Lawmoritzlaw.osu.edu/electionlaw/litigation/documents/Veasey73016.pdf · se€ooooo-xt EEZZ'VLV'Zr.E 'cNI 'gJrAEgS eNf,luodgu r.cgNND{9Z vz ez zz IZ 0z

t€8ooooo-xt-

etz?,'vL?'zls .JNI ,gCIAESS ONI,IEOdEU I,GSNND{

lroz/92/T ?T TTrE g,tvNgs 8o Nolr\rEscrsNoJ

92,

vz

EZ

27,

IZ

oz

OL

8T

LI

9I

ST

VI

ET

ZT

TT

OT

6

I

L

7

T

Y

I

8LV

TTIr't e/yr oS 'eqT-rcsa.rd .d11En1ce TTTm ecTlfo s r e?e1s lod:e1a:ceg aq1 l€r{+ .slueuraJrlrrba: cI oloqd /reu er{1 fnoqe

uoTleu[rofuT er{1 ,r,rou>1 no.,{. ,1sod ,{ar{+ 1€q1 sT ?uauta.rTnba:

sTr{1 os pue 'alTsqejv\ € a^€q saT?unoc 1eq1 saunsa;d

ITTq ar{1 1€q1 {uTr{1 I :}wHEgochl .stl

4aplaord loutrec se.Tlrrrroc

asoq? lT euoc 01 6u;o6 .{.euour 1eq1 sT aJer{rv\ ,uT euoc 1eq1

sar{caeur {Elapaf .&ue pue a.raq paqT-rcse-:d aaeq {pee:1e

nod uolTlTru Z, ai{1 ueql f,eqlo aruo-r; euoc o1 6u1o6

-{.euour f,or{tro eea sr araqn 'l.auour ae+ aAEr{ 1 r uop dar{+

lT eqa sT a.aeq/{ -ro ;.r{.euour aq1 a^er{ 01 6u1o6 tr"ql erE

'ueau I 'uei{? r{1T'!t :ar{1a6o1 le6 ol 6u;o6 a.r,nod leqa

'rrou>1 no.{.'TITq eql uT s.d.es 1T 1€r{rr aas I pqe &ou{

nod 'oS 'rr\ou 1q6Tr >1eads a/yl .se ffo 6ugde1 a-re.f.aql pue

. 'Tleluoqs E a^eq deql pue 'g:;o .de1 otr 6u11:ets dpea-z1e

sr ,{.1uno3 sr-r-reH pue ',{.1rrno3 srrreH ,l,1trnoc 1sa6-ze1

eql fuasarda: -rool] sTr{1 uo ereq sJar{lo pue I i/vl.ou>i

no.{, '.{,1unoc qc€a uo luaquncuT eq o? 6u;o6 sT r{cnut rvtor{ s-F

dn 1T trq6no-rq lseg roleues {uTi{? I 'nouq nod, Te^eT

.{.1unoc ar{t 1e sT 'sT e-raql urecuoc dur ,ytoN

'e6ueqc sTr{a ,Aq peql-rcsa:d

se slueuatlnba; g1 eqt J:o eoTlou aplno:d TIEr{s

tT surefuT€ut ler{f .{,3unoc qcee lo :e-rlsT6a.a .raao^ er{1

pue eoTll:o -rnod pue no.[. araq sdes tT ]noqe dn 1T

lq6no:q lsaM roaeues 'uoTlEcTlTluepl reloA , ZT0

- IE -repun

_,_tkJ/

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 1 of 8

se€ooooo-xt

EEZZ'VLV'Zr.E'cNI 'gJrAEgS eNf,luodgu r.cgNND{

9Z

vz

ez

zz

IZ

0z

5T

8T

L1

vl

:L

?T

EI

ZT

TT

01

o

E

L

9

I

€

7

I

6L?

uoT?ecnpe aql alpueq 01 aldoad a^eq

.r''l 6rrro5'a:,r{er{1 pue elTsqe& € aAeq oa 6uTo6 a:''{aq1 v+

3eq1 salunsa.rd rt;q sTq? lEr{l 6u1,tes lsnF tu'I a^€q 01

6u1o6 a:,dar{l 1pqtr AUnSA.rd nod uec floq uaql 'afe e/vt aITT

11e3:1.roqs la6pnq e q6no-l{a 6uToE ''(pea;1e a;e saTlunoo

asoqf IT puE ,dlunoc I{cEa uT :e:r1s16eJ qcEe q3T!1

puEq-uT-puEq {.ro/v\ 01 6u1o6 a-z,no'A' sl'es 1eq1 araq uoTlcas

sTqr 1€r.If au sulecuoc lsnF 1T ',ueaur 1 'oS

uolsnoH fo ,{1TJ el{l

uT6ulq6noliinfosTee:,.{aqlpug'lcE}€sr?EQlJac€l;e srler{,1 'uoTldurnsa-=d e lou srlEQ& 'Jv\ou 1q6Tf dltmoc

sT.rjreg uT lfo 6u1,{e1 a'r,'A'aq1 1eq1,llou)i I -- 6ulurnserd

lou lu, I r'rou 1r{61': no'd TTe1 uec I lnq '6u1q1d'ue

uo 1sn[ 'u,ou>i no.d 's6u1qa ]o 1oT'E armsa:d pTnoc I

pue ,s6uTr{1 l:o loT € Ar:rnsa:d uEc a/tl 'uEeul I 'lcadse: enp

TIe r.{1T/{ 'nou>i nod 'TIaM :SOOSTWO 'l[gs

'1nc 01 e^eq

ol 6uTo6 e-re {eq1 A-rAr{/vl ,mou>1 nor{ 'fo se1-Fsqar lTar{l

uAop a{e1 o] e^€q 01 6u1o6 a're ,{ar{a ]T , sacuelsunc.ITc

TECSTI: , saTlunoc aq? se f,€J SE 'r'rou>1 nod 'uoTl€Ulrol:uT

palTelap .,{.:ar'. auos 146 "{'1qeqo'rd 11 ' ar'r

e op 01 sn pe{sE s€tt lseM 'ro1€uas pue sacuElSUJnC'rTC

IEcs-Fl ar{? lio fr{6T1 uT ',noN

alTsqam rTeI{1 uo 1T lsod

of aAEr{ TT , r{ar{a uer{l pue 'sallunoc aQa 01 1no 1eq1 puas

,/-S /

TTOZ/SZ/T ?I TTIA g.IVNgS,{o Nor,lvu[crsNoJ

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 2 of 8

9€800000-xt

EEZZ'nLV'ZrS .oNI ,EcIAugS oNIJuodEu .l'qENNg)T

pue saTpoq eql lnocfe lEq& lng . Aer{f, q1T/,r uer{1 aplao_:d

01 6u1o6 e.: , nod ' TTaM : SOe gT.111g . NgS

'elTsqar{ rreql uo dn 1nd plnoi,r .{,eq1 ?€r{? a6en6ue1 er{a

.'6u1p:or'r aql uar{3 ap-pao-zd .plno/vt aA lEqa spru leq1 peer

I .{.ern eq1 Aou ur r I aqX,e6 : Nqgg[ect\i . SN

eTTTq 6uo'rr'l

aql 6u1pea;r I ut€ .ro : SOegTTVg - trds

.saI :t$fHEgect{ .stt

6u1pea: ur,1 leq/i\ 1eq1 sI ..re:1s1$a-r

.6.1rrnoc eql r{lT/v\ uoTlcrm[uoc u1 >i-rorv\ 11pvr nod 1ET{l

seqTlDsaxd TTTq ar{A lng :SOCSTTVE .NUS

_ elTsqervt e e4Er{

01 6uro6 trou a.r,daql lT os 'elTsqeA e a^Er{ saTfunoc

leqa sT uolldurnsse aql XuTr{? I TTTq aql ,pTes I a}iTT

'asnecaq treql uo uorlsanb -rno.,( otr J3/4SUe eQl /v10u{ trruap

I os '-{.1unoc ael 01 uorleT.rdo:ddE ue e>[eu l,useop.,TTITS eSeuas ',nou>1 no.r{ ',TIeM :NVHgEecN ..Shl

aruo-r; euoc o1 6u1o6 deuou lEr{1 sT a.req/v\ ,VT

TT-Fg aleuas repun paqt:cse-rd sT 1eq& aplno-rd o1 spunli

eqa 'trlsnotaqo ,el€r{ ?,uop {",{a lI 4dauour E.r1xe eqtr sT

oJaq/q 'a1e1s sTr{1 ug dlunoc .req1o due .ro l,lunoJ sT.rr€HTTT rrrddrcrr -r rrb^ nbrrn -i --??- d? E.--*,^- q L us\.lL sLt a 1 U€C 1eq1 IT lef{1 ST 6Ut>iSe tu, 1 1€q/,,t pUV . Aut

qTTTa-llfa\-\ lE?r? .rra-rArl uu4evsvu lei{,1 -uoTf,Gurnsa.rd e lou srlEI{1 ,pTES I e}iTT

'1ce; € srl€r{l pue ,4eads eA s€ Aou 1r{6Tf, Jfo 6utde1

e:,X,aq1 lT 6u1q3.due eurnse:d lruec no;.

9Z

vz

EZ

27,

r7,

07,

6I

8I

LT

9I

9T

VT

EI

ZT

TI

OI

6

a

L

s

E

z

T

OB?

./ / -/ Lh --t t

rr0z/92/T vr rrra g$vNss ,{o NorJ,vuECrsNoJ

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 3 of 8

.CNI

. zesooooo-xt

e€.zz'vLv'7'I9 ,gSIAUSS ENIJ,EOdgU IGSNNDT

9Z

vz

EZ

77

1Z

07,

6T

8T

LIqT

?T

trT

7,7

TT

OT

6

x

L

s

E

7

I

T87

8 h-s/

aq1 ro1 .6.cue6e lno roJ e)iTI 'nou>1 no'& lue6e eldl rof

d11ec1g:-gcads s, 1r 's€A acedurT a1E1s aql ?eqn a1€trs o?

se/v\ lsanbar alou TEcs-Fl E 01 $ulpuodsal uT luau:arlnba:

rno poolsJapun al\ r alv\ 'd'er'r aql 1nq '6uo;rn uraql 6u1Op

ueeq eArer\ aq^d.eu pue notr. 11aa uEc r ?ng 'rarrofldtuoJ

aqf .ro 88T s r 1eql lT 'leT'{1 seop ggr uTr{1Tl'/\ oldrvl

e-rns .{,11'exa lou ru,I pufd '1i:aruu:eno6 1eco1 o? ST 1oedu1

eq? f€t+{ lTcTIos lruoP ar'r d11e'reua6 og 'sT lcedtul al€1s

aql 3EI{r,r r,lou{ oa ?uel'\ trtqe 'ggT o1 alou TEcsTl: E 1-Fulqns

01 pe{s€ eIlel!\ ueT{l'\ ,IIoM :lwHEgecI^I .SI^I

aa.le ellr eITI sTTellfol{s

qa6pnq Eulrreq e-re saTlunoc :eqlo lT a;eq 6u1t'toqs

a.r,no..{. a€q& u€q1 alou] lsoc 01 6u1o6 srlT lel{l ,a.rar{1

lnos.Ielo^aI{SolEulpealsTlulTSTfoalouTecsT]an.T1e sTt{1 sT ,nor{ 6u1>1se tu.1 ?EI{j\[ .d11ear uar{1 ,.ralnduoc e

seq ?eq1 .dpoqr1:eae 'sexa;, lro a1€1s eq? uT alTsqa/i! d:rerra

uos,ler{?puedq6ulo6e'rra/{1Et{1'noulno,{'a1ouI€csTIe papr^o-rd no-{' lT prrv :soeETTVO 'Ngs

'pue1s:3pun I 'oN :IWHEgocN 'shl

a-reqA aes nor{ puv

;.a.rar{ 6uTo6 ur'I

'{erio : SOegT.1]fe 'NES

'se.tr. :l{VfiEgecl^l'Shl

'/v\ou 1l{bTf,

seTpoq eql e^er{ lruoP tr"t{a

s r 1e{1 uoTlecnpa :aqlo dueserpoq llo 6u1.{'e1 a:, '{'eq1

lr eT{Tq sTt{? '{q paqT:csa':d

Tro z /sz/t vITAIS ETVNSS gO NOITVU8CIISNOJ

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 4 of 8

g€Sooooo-xJ"

EEZZ'VLV 'ZIE' DNr' gcrnugs cNr,tuodgu r.cgr{NitrJ

ttoz/gz/T tr rrrg glvNgs Eo Nor,tvugcrsNoJ

9Z

vz

ez

zz

I?,

47,

8I

tT

9I

SI

VT

LL

ZT

TT

OT

x

L

9

I

v

L

7

T

z8v

rv\oq '1uauu:azro6 TecoT uo lcedurl sulacuoc 1eq1 alou

IPcsTl: ai{a 3:o uoll.rod eI{1 jv\or{ 01 4eeds d11ea:1ruec I'acTl:Jo srelels lo {:ela.rcas aq1 uo lcedurg ar{a 6u1r'roqs

,.{.11e4.r sT elou TecsTJ ar{J, :NvHEEOct\i 'SI^l

;anr 6u1IIa1 e:,nod 1eq& 1eq1 ,sI'a1ou T€csTJ popua-uedo ue ?sn[ sT alou TecsTf -rno.d u1

1E 6u1>1oo1 e.rrelv\ 1EI{rvI oS :SOOETTUO 'NES

I€csTf E

' l r uop I 'oN :NVHESect{ 'Sh[

aqcnul rvl,oq nou{ 1 l uop notr ' 1cedu1

aq .{,eu alaq;, :SO9ETTVO 'I{ES

, 'saTlunoc uo lceorur IEOSTJ: € aq

.{eu araql fEr{1 elecTpuT ssop aaou IEcSTJ ar{a 1Eq1 >iuTq1

I 1nq ';requrnu elTsuaqa.rduroc e 1ou sr?I 'roJ 6u1>ioo1

e:,no^ -requnu aqe s,lT >tuTi{1 lruoP I -- 1ou srf,T 'ivtou{

nod 'oS '.dlunoC -rexog -roJ pue .,{.1rmo3 truE.rJrEJ, f,oJ uT

s-raqurnu ouros lnd pTp traqa 'r'rou>i noa 's1soc .{.1unoc euos

eq d,eru a-rar{a ?eqtr elecTpuT saop and pTp ggT aer{1 otou

TecsTl: sTr{1 >iuTI{1 I 'ITaM :lStHgEecN 'SN

;eu 6u111aq a:,nor{, leqrvl trEr{tr sI 'a.raqa

s1 .,{.auour eql ?er{f edoq pue ecTp ettra TIof, 01 a^eq 1sn[

e/{ uaql '.d.1unoc qc€e uT .rer1s16e.r eql l{aTtq }t-ro/q of 6u1o6

a T nrr,( alttT-] ?Tr^rT1a\3q qTTT- s4 r rlvrL +sL.t-+ UOTICAS STI{1 lapun 1€i{tr pU€ elOU TECSTI: eQa

uT s r ?eel uoTIITru Z* ai{l J:o apTslno lEI{t sT eur 6u111a1

3.r I no^ lel{r!], os 'Ae>to : soeaTTvo 'Ngs

'ecTl:l:o s r e3E1S go .{.:elarceS

6kr/

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 5 of 8

6es0oooo-xl

tezz'nLv'219 .CNI,ECIAUES ONI.IUOdEU .6.CSIA{E'J

rroz/92/r vrTTIA g,lvNEs ,{o NorJrf,ugclSNOC

9Z

vz

ez

7,2

1Z

0z

BT

L1

9T

:L

,T

ET

z1

TT

OI

U

L

)

:

€

7

I

E8?

er{l a^eq l r.uop {".{f 1eq1 lno puTl: uaql pue op TITn d"'{l

leq1 .pTes TITq sTI{1 leq1 6ulqlauros 'd'ltnroc tr'ur oe e1€pueu

aqa a>iTI lruoP I 'nou>i noa :soogTTvo 'NES

'saTlunoc

aqllleuorl:e1ep1eql:reqle6pued:101^e^'rnsE

lno Eulpuas eq 01 6U1O6 ale ely\ puv '6u1-,{'es a-r ' nod' 1Et{tii

prre?sJaprrn I 'sad 'ITaM :twHggocl^l 'SN

e6uTdes ur,I 1€q$ ees

no.{, oG 'rvrou>[ no-d 'a:aq u1 aq o? 6u1o6 srlT 'TTe 1e JT

,pe1cedu1 aq 01 6u1o6 s; ,{1rmoc Xr:r 3:1 ?Er{1 I'\ou}t o? a{TT

plno/vr tr11ee: I 'sT 6u1-{.es ur, 1 leqA lng 'srequlnu esoql

ol I,t.Trd uaaq lou el€r{ I "(luno3 luEJ'reJ' pue '{'aunoJ

]€xagazre6no.{.leqls.IequnuaqlAou{lruoPI.]aqunuaq1 -raAaler{rt 'uoTIITul ea:q1 'uo1111ur onl 'UO1111u e JoJ

palcedurl eq 1ou plnoJ -1o pTnoc 1r ;6u1'{'es e: ' no''{ fET{A

leq1 sI ./v\oult 1,uop tr11ea: eA os '1eq1 o1 >{eads louuEc

no.{, ,nou>1 no.d, 'sallunoc eq1 r{1T/vl uoTlCun[Uoc u1 >['rol4 01

6u1o6 a.r,noX Eulrroqs sT lEi{1 a6en6ue1 aql puv 'pa+cedu1

aqol6u1o6sTelelsaql1er{/vl'sT6ulmoqsef,lno^

1€i{1 uoTIITul zs eqr os :soegTTue 'Nss

{=ttO :NVHggOcN 'Shl

uo1asanb dur ase':qda:

aur tal uer{'l '1t{6Tr ITV :soegTTuo 'Ngs

'IvlOUli

'sT ssacord JTeql leq$ 'l'tou4 no'{' 887 d11ea: 1'EoP I

c9-J/

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 6 of 8

ra3]e 1T seM

darr-rns sTqf,

' sa;. :l(ifHflEflctr^l'SI^l

auoTlcaTe 8002 aQa

apaloTdruoc ses, .{.ea:ns ?sel aea ,palaldruoc

ser\ uaqM : gtr,J,od ap lw^ 'NES

' sal : N\tHEEecN ' SN

6.,i.an-rng 6u1aon pue uoT?e.rlsTuTrxpv

ar{f uT a1edlclf-red sexaJ, saoq uoTlceIE

'.,{,anrns E o3 p:e6e.r

qlTA p-rocar ar{l oluT la6 o1 >isE 01 paau I ?ei{1 suoTlsanb

or'\f lsnF eirE e-reql puE 'sn .log: ssauST/v\ ec-TnosaJ

lr{aTTecxe uE ueaq azr,nod 'ueqeegc6 'sN

'uEulrTel{f, '-II^l

'no.,{. {uEqJ. : g1;Od ap IWA 'NES

'atrlnd ap ue^ .roleuasi

'so6a11eg

.ro tr€ue S 'nod {ueq[ : NVJN1C NV6ISIVHJ

LtrJ r lur

' .d.:err no.{. {ueq[ 'd=.]io : SOOETTV9 'NES

'' lCer"roc s r JeQ,L :lwHEEEchl 'sN

a?car-roc ler{1 sI '.{.lunoc r{cea lou 'saTlunocaTT.1 -lrtrr r31rr-1 c 3Tr-1 ar-r rlpdrrrr rrE Xrrrn cr "1az-r.r.nzrrl{ --r.+ -fve '+Els aql 01 1cedu1 ue dluo sT papTrto;rd aa,nod

1eql alou IEcsTli uoTIITru U $ sTr{1 lei{a 'euTluo ITTq

sTt{f 1€ 6u1>1oo1 a.:e leqt puE :aAndr:roc uo eleqep sTr{l

le 6ur>1oo1 ere 1ei{1 suexef,, 6u111a1 ,{,11ee-r u1 elepuEur

pepunlun uE s,1eq1 /eu 01 'l,rou>1 no; '1T op ol spun;

0r80oooo-xt

Eezz'vLv'zI9 .DNI ,gCIAESS ONI,IUOdEU ..\AENNE)T

9Z

vz

EZ

zz

1Z

n7

6T

8T

LT

qT

ET

VI

ET

7T

TT

NT

I

L

9

I

E

7

T

?B?

/5-5/

TT0Z|SZ|T ?r rrrs gJvNES ,{O NOTTVSSCrSNOJ

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 7 of 8

tt€ooooo-xr

EE7,Z'VLV'ZT9'DNr 'gJtAugs eNr'luodgu r'cgNN$

9Z

vz

e7,

7,2

TZ

07,

OL

8T

L1

9T

9T

?T

€T

zl

TI

OI

c

c

7

I

987

-aJ-J/

asoql roJ saler uo11ba[e: 1saq61q aq1 ]:o euos

e^er{ ary! '?sec are 1eq1 S?OTTeq TEuoTslao:d Jo 'requmu

ar{1 SEqf 'eneq an leqa uralstrs sTql rapun l{ou 1I{6Tjt

ua4a ,sp-rolr .req1o uT 'OS 'SAlE-r loTTEq IEUOTSTIO:Id

uoTlCA f e-r q61q .r{.ra.rr e^eq elv\ lEr{1 '1;eqc elels aq1 uT

3€r{1 6u1pue1s:eprrn .&rl sT 1I 'palunoc eJ€ ?Er{1 SSoTIEq

TEUOTSTzTo:d JO reqllnu ar{1 01 se sale1s aql 6uoure selEJ

-TaIvroT Aql l:O 3uo er\el{ e/Yr:l{UHEgOcN 'SI^l

'sel : gJlJ,nd ep NvA ']r8s

palunoc e;€ 1eql s?oTTEq Teuorslao:d Jo Jecgtunu

aqlseaelseSnq''sa?elsler{?oauosuTS€S€XAIrITaSoA TeuoTslrr.o:d e ?sEc aldoad Lueur se ?ou 1Eq1 Eulueaut

'selol TEuoTsTao:d 3:o 'requnu eq1 se 'reJ se 1ng 'pua

-re/v\ol 3I{1 uo ef I e/v\ '3s€C -Iaqunu TelO1 eq1 Se fEJ Se 1eq1

sT uoTlcaIToce.l 1e-zaua6 tr'61 :NVHgEecN 'Si^l

auoTaeTndod 6u11o.lt' ']no 01 prebe'r

r{1Tt{ pasn a.rE ?el{l SlOTIeq IeuoTsTAO'rd JO 'requlnu eql

uT {u€-r afy\ op /Ytot{ 'nou>1 no'{' se re] sv 'sExe.l l:o alels

oql uT sloTI€q leuoTsTao-rd ;:o .Iaqunu aql qlTlt 6u11eep

--uoTssTululocTe-rapal:aqlsTsTt{1pue--TTeo?'}iuTr{1

I , sao6 1€r{a ,{en:ns aq1 uo Elep aq1 01 seo6 a^ei{ I leq1

uollsanb aqJ, '/{e{o :gl.lnd ep NifA 'Ngs

' s a;. : twHgge cN ' sN

iaTqeITe^E

..{,arr:ns 1eq1 a/\Et{ a/{ os : gs&nd ap lwA 'Ngs

Ttoz/Ez/r vT TTrg 8,r,vN8SdO NOI'IVUECISNOC

Case 2:13-cv-00193 Document 672-15 Filed in TXSD on 11/11/14 Page 8 of 8