Psychology 305A: Lecture 7 Contemporary …ubc-emotionlab.ca/psyc305a/pdfs/Lecture-7-contemporary...Psychology 305A: Lecture 7 Contemporary Psychoanalytic Approaches Wrap up Motives

1

Psychology 305A: Lecture 7

Contemporary Psychoanalytic Approaches Wrap up

Motives

2

Metamorphosis of Narcissus

3

NARCISSISM

• DSM characteristics: grandiosity, dominance, entitlement, superiority

• In normal (non-clinical) populations, characterized by self-enhancement– i.e., excessively positive view of self and

negative view of others– bragging, egotism, superiority, derogation of

others, entitlement

4

Classic NarcissistArmand Hammer

• Wealthy tycoon• Bought Leonardo DaVinci’s book “Codex

Leicester” and renamed it “Codex Hammer”

• "My ideas are beyond the comprehension of ordinary mortals. The brilliance of my mind can only be described as dazzling. Even I am impressed by it...”

– After Hammer’s death, Bill Gates bought back “Codex Hammer” and renamed it “Codex Leicester”

5

• “Around the time of grammar school I had this incredible desire to be recognized… I didn’t care about the money, I thought about the fame, about just being the greatest. I was dreaming about being some dictator of a country or some savior like Jesus. Just to be recognized.”

- Arnold Schwarzenegger,1976

6

What Causes Narcissism?• Parents over-idealize child, set up

unrealistic standards• Simultaneously, they excessively criticize

child for failing to meet unrealistic standards

• “Narcissistic wound” – early humiliation experience

• Narcissists overcompensate for insecurities by self-aggrandizing

7

Measuring Narcissism

Circle the choice that most accurately describes you:

– A. I am much like everyone else– B. I am an extraordinary person

– A. I like to look at myself in the mirror– B. I am not particularly interested in looking

at myself in the mirror

8

Measuring Narcissism• Unrealistically positive beliefs about abilities

and achievements– “I can make anybody believe anything I want them

to.”– 37% agree

• Preoccupied with fantasies of unlimited success, power, brilliance, and beauty– “If I ruled the world it would be a much better place.” – 45% agree

• Strong sense of entitlement– “I will never be satisfied until I get all that I deserve.” – 26% agree

• Grandiose sense of self-importance– “I am an extraordinary person.” – 55% agree

9

Narcissism and Therapy• Narcissists typically go to therapy for

external life problems – Work

• Repeated failures• Not living up to their own career expectations

– Love• Idealization and devaluation of romantic partners• Always need to be center of attention

• Narcissistic Personality Disorder is very difficult to treat in therapy– Why?

10

Research Findings on Normal-Range Narcissism

• More first person pronoun usage – I, me

• Look in the mirror more frequently • Take credit for their accomplishments

but blame others for their failures

11

Research Study: How Deep-Seated Are Narcissistic Illusions?

• Do narcissists become less grandiose when they have the opportunity to see how others see them?

• Experiment: Manipulate visual perspective via video– Show narcissists how others see them

12

Method• 1) Self-Evaluation

– Rate self’s performance relative to other group members

• 2) Objective Evaluation– 12 psychologists– 5 other group members ("peers")– Objective task outcome (success vs. failure)

• DV: Self-Enhancement Bias = degree to which self-evaluation is more positive than objective evaluation

• IV: Manipulation of Self-Focused Attention– Control Condition:

• Evaluate performance immediately after group discussion

– Self-Focused Condition:• Evaluate performance after viewing videotape of self participating

in discussion

13

2.4

2.6

2.8

3.0

3.2

3.4

3.6

3.8 Control Self-Focused

Narcissists

Non-Narcissists

ObjectivePerformance

Experimental Condition

Self-

perc

eive

d pe

rfor

man

ce

How will people rate their performance in each condition?

14

Comments After Watching Self on Video

• Narcissistic Individual– "I came across more or less the way I would want

to: stern but compassionate, matter of fact, business like and effective. I liked watching myself very much. Not too many surprises."

• Non-Narcissistic Individual– "I don't think I performed as well as I thought I did.

The only impressions I got from watching myself on videotape were the bad ones. It was quite a sobering experience."

15

Narcissism as Pathology

• 2 types– Grandiose/Malignant Narcissist– Fragile narcissist

16

Grandiose/malignant narcissist• Has an exaggerated sense of self-importance• Appears to feel privileged and entitled• Has little empathy• Tends to blame own failures or shortcomings

on other people or circumstances• Tends to be critical of others• Tends to be controlling• Has little psychological insight into own

motives, behavior, etc.

17

Fragile narcissist• Tends to feel unhappy, depressed, or

despondent• Tends to be critical of others• Has an exaggerated sense of self-importance• Tends to feel anxious• Tends to feel envious• Is prone to painful feelings of emptiness• Appears to feel privileged and entitled• Tends to feel s/he is inadequate, inferior, or a

failure

18

A Real Clinical Case• 40 year-old, college educated single male• Socially isolated, impaired intimacy• “Empty” depression, anhedonia, self-criticality• Chronically suicidal• 3 hospitalizations in the last year:

ECT, Medication did not help• Pursuing Disability• Living w/ parents after most recent hospitalization

• Overt Presentation: Vulnerable, Low Self-Esteem

19

More information about this case• Can’t play guitar b/c no one pays to hear him play• Feels that daily responsibilities are a “hassle” and he

should not have to do them (e.g., groceries, finding a job, balancing his checkbook, filling out forms, paying taxes).

• Lived off a trust fund (recently depleted).• Resents parents for aging and having decreasing

resources.• Can’t hold a job because he resents lack of control over

his schedule and accommodation to others’ schedules.• Can’t tolerate listening to “other people’s crap.”• Everything becomes “flawed.”• Often withheld information in treatment

• Covert Presentation: Grandiose Narcissism?

20

21

5. Object Relations Theory

Modern research on influence of childhood on adulthood

relationships

22

Object Relations Theory

• Emphasis on social relations• Origins of adult relationships in

childhood• Internalized representations (i.e.,

unconscious) of parents become basis for relating to others

23

Early Childhood Attachment

• Early bond with parents influences child’s personality

• Harlow (1958)– Raised monkeys apart from mother

• Provided surrogate “wire” mom or surrogate “cloth mom”

• Surrogate wire mom provided food and water– Which surrogate did monkeys spend most

time with?

24

Early AttachmentEven when wire mom provided food, infant monkeysstayed close to cloth mom

Importance of physical contact between infantand caregiver.

25

Early Attachment• Infant monkeys deprived of real mothers

became anxious, insecure, abnormal sexually

• Bowlby (1969) noticed a similar pattern in humans

• But, there are individual differences in kids’ behaviors– Some become anxious until mom returns

(separation anxiety)– Some become depressed, and show anger and

detachment when mom returns

26

Early Attachment• Ainsworth: Strange Situation Procedure

– How does a child respond to being left with a friendly stranger for a few minutes?

• 3 Responses1. Continue exploration, play, happy to see mother

upon return2. Unfazed when mother left, and avoidant upon

return3. Very anxious throughout procedure, clingy and

angry upon return• 3 Attachment styles

– Secure, Avoidant, Anxious-Ambivalent

27

Early Attachment• Child’s behaviors in Strange Situation

predict– Mother’s behavior toward child

• How responsive to child’s needs? – “Internal working models” for later

relationships• Unconscious expectations for how people will

treat them– Adult attachment styles

28

Adult Attachment

• Hazan and Shaver (1987)• Found similar patterns of attachment

in adult relationships– Secure relationship style– Avoidant relationship style– Anxious-Ambivalent (Preoccupied)

relationship style

29

What is your attachment style?Read each of the three self-descriptions below and place a checkmark next to the single alternative that best describes how you feel in romantic relationships or is nearest to the way you feel.

______A. I am somewhat uncomfortable being close to others; I find it difficult to trust them completely, difficult to allow myself to depend on them. I am nervous when anyone gets too close, and often, others want me to be more intimate than I feel comfortable being.

______B. I find it relatively easy to get close to others and am comfortable depending on them and having them depend on me. I don't worry about being abandoned or about someone getting too close to me.

______C. I find that others are reluctant to get as close as I would like. I often worry that my partner doesn't really love me or won't want to stay with me. I want to get very close to my partner, and this sometimes scares people away.

30

Attachment Styles• Important part of personality• Related to relationship behaviors• Many research findings on differences in

relationship behaviors based on attachment style

• For example…– Preoccupied have most sex, Avoidant least

(except for Avoidant males)– Preoccupied feel greatest need for intimacy– Avoidants have worse memory for relationship-

related concepts

31

Stress Test Study

• Romantic couples brought into lab; told that male must participate in experiment involving the “machine”

• Experimenter leaves couple alone for 10 min. in waiting room– Secretly videotaped

• Male participant feels stressed• How does female respond?

32

Stress Test Study

• Avoidant females least likely to show support– If anything, show annoyance at partner’s

nervousness• Secure females most supportive

33

Motives

34

Motives

• Internal states that direct behavior• Based on needs, or tension• Can be unconscious

35

Motives are part of personality• Individual differences in the strength of

various motives – achievement vs. affiliation

• Contribute to major life outcomes – career success, marriage, etc.

• Motives are stable over time• Motives tell us (part of) why people

behave the way they do

36

Motive Theories and Personality

1. Early Motive Theorists – Murray, McClelland, McAdams

2. The Humanistic (a.k.a. Phenomenological) Perspective – Maslow, Rogers– The Self

37

The Thematic Apperception Test (TAT)

What is going on here?

38

Henry Murray

• 1930s-1960s• First modern theory of motivation• Began as a medical doctor• Studied psychoanalysis with Jung

– Became a “reborn man”

39

Murray’s Theory

• Need– Psychological force that guides behavior– Compulsion to reduce state of tension

40

Needs According to Murray

• Achievement– Success seeking

• Exhibition– Getting attention

• Order• Dominance

– Control others• Aggression• Autonomy

– independence

• Affiliation/ Intimacy– Closeness to others

• Nurturance– Taking care of others

• Abasement– Lowering oneself

• Blame-Avoidance• Succor

– Desire to be taken care of

41

Murray’s Theory

• “Press”– Importance of environment– Needs are only activated in certain contexts

• “Apperception”– Process through which we perceive the

environment– Influenced by needs

42

David McClelland• Implicit vs. Self-attributed motives

– TAT reveals implicit (unconscious) motives– Implicit and explicit motives are not related – Implicit motives Long-term outcomes

• Career, marriage, health, stable beliefs– Explicit motives Shorter term

behaviors/attitudes• Performance on an experimental task

43

McClelland and the Big 3

• Big 3 Motives– Achievement

– Power

– Affiliation (and Intimacy)

44

Achievement

• Preference for moderate levels of challenge– Need to feel it’s tough, but still succeed

• Desire for performance feedback• Choose careers with some risk and

much personal responsibility

45

Next Class

• Finish Motives, Humanistic Approach• Begin Self