Transcript
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
1/17
Niccolo Machiavelli
Thomas Hobbes
John Locke
Jean Jacques Rousseau
Karl Marx
7/23/2012 1Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
2/17
Niccolo Machiavelli
Niccolo Machiavelli is the father of modernPolitical Science and the classic of modernPolitical Realism.
He stood between Middle Age (Theocracy)and Modern Age (Secular/non-religious)thoughts and institutions.
He pioneered the break away from faith-based politics in the West.
Machiavelli separated politics from religionin his famous book,The Prince.
7/23/2012 2Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
3/17
Machiavellicontd.
In the Machiavellian doctrine, the endjustifies the means: no morality in politics.
The ruler is above the law, he is not bound
by moral principles and he could use anymeans to meet political expediency.
He may employ cruelty, murder or any other
negative means to achieve his political goals.Machiavelli divorced ethics from politics.
His political theory is amoral/immoral.
7/23/2012 3Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
4/17
Thomas Hobbes
Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau are calledSocial Contract theorists.
They all emphasise contract as the
foundation of governance.Hobbes believes government is not from
God but men.
Men hitherto lived in a state of nature(natural condition) that necessitated a warof each against all.
7/23/2012 4Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
5/17
Hobbescontd.
In the Hobbessian state, there was no arts; noletters; no society; and which is worst of all,continual fear, and danger of violent death; andthe life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutishand short.
The people entered into a social contract withthe Leviathan (a powerful ruler) for protectionfrom pervasive violence.
By the contract, the people surrendered alltheir rights and powers to the ruler in order toprotect them.
Thus, Hobbes argues that sovereignty lies inthe ruler and not the people.
7/23/2012 Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams 5
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
6/17
Hobbescontd. Hobbes asserts that the people cannot revoke the
contract since the Leviathan was not part of it.
The ruler could do whatever he likes and the
people cannot revolt against the ruler. Hobbes ideas created an absolute, omnipotent,
permanent, universal and inalienable sovereignpower for the ruler.
His ideas support totalitarian and autocraticregimes without constitutional checks andbalances.
7/23/2012 6Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
7/17
John Locke
In contrast to Hobbes, Locke argued that thepeople created the government through the
social contract and based on their consent.
Locke insists that the ruler must protect thelife, liberty and property of the people.
The people have the right to remove, or revolt
against a ruler if he falters in his political duties.Locke asserts that the ruler has no absolute
power. His powers are limited by popular will.
7/23/2012 7Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
8/17
Lockecontd.
He emphasizes popular (peoples) sovereigntyas the supreme authority.
For Locke, supreme authority resides in the
peoples representatives in the legislature andultimately in the people.
The legislature and the executive, however,
have supreme authorities in their limitedspheres.
Locke is considered as the Father of Liberal
Democracy due to his liberal principles.7/23/2012 8Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
9/17
Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Jean-Jacques Rousseau lived in the 18th
CenturyFrance.
He contributed to the philosophical foundation for theFrench Revolution of 1789.
In the beginning of his famous book, Social Contract,he asserts that Man is born free but everywhere is inchains.
Rousseau said life in the state of nature was good as
people lived as noble savages (like in haven) withneither artifice nor jealousy.
Men wanted more freedom; so they enter into socialcontract.
7/23/2012 Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams 9
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
10/17
RousseauContd
Rousseau favours the general will cravedby the whole community wants as againstparticular wills held be individuals and
groups.Those opposed to the ruler or the generalwill should be crushed.
Rousseau asserts that sovereignty residesin the General Will of the people.
7/23/2012 Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams 10
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
11/17
RousseauContd
The society make the people and not the otherway round; also bad people are made by thesociety.
He believes that a just society with voluntary
participation would make good people.
A good society would force men to be free.
He envisaged a perfect society of government by
the general will, which the ruler (dictator)claims to know.
Hes often criticized for promoting totalitarianism
but his theory is useful in developing democracy.7/23/2012 Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams 11
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
12/17
Karl MarxKarl Marxs ideas is generally referred to as
Marxism, which is opposite of liberaldemocracy.
His body of ideas based on history is called
Dialectical Materialism.Dialectical Materialism isthe Marxian concept
of reality in which material things are in the
constant process of change.This change is brought about by tension
between conflicting or interacting forces,elements, or ideas.
7/23/2012 12Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
13/17
Karl Marxcontd In the Marxist political ideology, Capitalism,
Socialism and Communism are successivestages of the development (changes) in the
human society.Marx says that the history of all hitherto
existing society is the history of classstruggles.
This class struggle will ultimately lead theProletariat (the working class) to overthrowthe bourgeoisie (the capitalist class).
7/23/2012 13Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
14/17
Karl Marxcontd
A classless society would emerge from theoverthrow.
Marx views the state as the instrument of
the dominant class.Eventually, when the class struggle is won by
the Proletariat, the state would wither
away.Many people confuse Communism with
Marxism and declare the latter dead after
the collapse of the USSR.7/23/2012 14Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
15/17
Karl Marxcontd Under Capitalism, there is private ownership of
property and the owners of the means ofproduction dominate the workers through thepower of the state.
It is the survival of the fittest: The rich dominatesthe poor.
But the poor workers would continue to struggleagainst the rich class and the state.
When the capitalist class is eventually overthrown,a classless society will emerge and there will be noprivate ownership of property.
7/23/2012 Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams 15
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
16/17
Karl Marxcontd
Under the new order called Socialism, each personwill get according to his needs.
Socialism is the economic system of stateownership of industry for the good of the wholesociety.
It is the opposite of capitalism or liberalism. Itemphasizes collective ownership of the means of
production. Under Socialism, the state will still exist but it will
no longer support any group interest because thesociety is now classless.
7/23/2012 Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams 16
7/31/2019 7. Modern Political Thinkers
17/17
Karl Marxcontd
Marx says Socialism will induce efficientproduction and distribution of goods/services.
When industrial production is high, the Socialistsociety will develop into Communisma perfect
society without money, private property, police oreven government.
Under Communism, no one will break the law orbe selfish to want to take property for themselves.
However, the above are just postulations (Utopia)and not true as Capitalism dominates till date
whereas Socialism failed in the Soviet Union.
7/23/2012 Intro. to Political Science. Isiaka A. Adams 17
top related