Top Banner
XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria Sala Uni Barcelona Ronald Mennickent Uni Concepcion Super Soft X-ray Sources – New developments ESAC, May 18, 2009
20

XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Jan 21, 2016

Download

Documents

Silas Flynn
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83

Robert SchwarzAstrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam

Jochen Greiner

MPE Garching

Gloria Sala

Uni Barcelona

Ronald MennickentUni Concepcion

Super Soft X-ray Sources – New developments ESAC, May 18, 2009

Page 2: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Introducing CAL 83

• Canonical SSS source in the LMC

• 1-day orbital period

• Low amplitude orbital modulation in optical and X-rays

• Inclination < 30

• Tentative X-ray pulsations at 38 min

Page 3: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

High-resolution X-ray spectrum

• Good fit to the data with a NLTE model (Lanz et al. 2004)

• log g = 8.5, Teff = 500 kK

• Suggests a massive WD of 1.3 Msun

Page 4: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

X-ray off-states in CAL 83

MACHO light curve (Greiner & di Stefano 2002)

Page 5: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Anti-correlated brightness changes in SSSObservations of RXJ 0513-69• Short transition times• only high or low states • X-ray on state shorter than off

state

Page 6: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Anti-correlated brightness changes in SSS

Models• Expansion and cooling of the envelope• Limit cycle regulated by changing mass accretion rate

Hachisu & Kato 2003• Stripping of the companions

surface by a strong wind

• X-ray off: wind absorption optical high: expanded disk

Reinsch et al. 2000• Radius/temperature changes

of the WD

• Increased irradiation of the outer disk

Page 7: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Wind regulated accretion in RXJ 0513-69

Page 8: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Smarts/XMM monitoring of CAL 83

Page 9: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Comparison with MACHO observations

Similar pattern

Different timescale

Page 10: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Long term behaviour from OGLE

Recurrence time: 430 days Duty cycle: 50%

Page 11: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

X-ray/optical lightcurves

• Sharp drop (t < 1 d) to intermediate brightness level

• Immediate recovery (t ~ 20 d) • X-ray detection during optical

high state• Anti-correlation of optical and X-ray over a wide range

Page 12: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Low resolution X-ray spectroscopy

Blackbody fits

Correlation between Nh and kTbb

Page 13: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

High state RGS spectrum

Black: April 2000 (Lanz et al. 2004) Red: August 2008

Page 14: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Spectral variationFree fits: kTbb varies from 25 to 33 eV

fixing Nh to 8 x 1020 cm-2

kTbb varies from 23 to 37 eV

Luminosity increases and radius shrinks changes by factor of 2

Page 15: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Broadband spectral energy distribution

Changes of the X-ray spectra can not explain the UV variation..

Page 16: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

X-ray variation by strong absorption only?Fix temperature andluminosity to the value of the high state spectrum

Cold absorption fails

Ionized absorber

Nh = 4 1022 cm-2

Page 17: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Summary

New complex variability patterns 1. short repetition time 2. Long transitions to optical high state Long term variability

Ambiguous X-ray spectroscopy50% temperature changeor strong ionized absorber

Tight anti-correlation between optical and X-rays

Page 18: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

Ende…

Page 19: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

RGS Spectrum

Page 20: XMM monitoring of the state transition of the supersoft source CAL 83 Robert Schwarz Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam Jochen Greiner MPE Garching Gloria.

PN spectrum