Xingchen Ye, A078 694 496 (BIA Nov. 8, 2013)

8/13/2019 Xingchen Ye, A078 694 496 (BIA Nov. 8, 2013)

1/18

Nightingale, Zachary, Esq.

US parm of Jsi

Executive Oce r Immigaion Review

Board of Immigration AppealsOce of h Crk

5107 Leburg Pike, Sute 2000Fals Churc, Vrgna 20530

Van Der Hout Brialiano & NihtinaleLLP

S/CE Oice of Chief Counse - SFRPO Box 26449San rancisco CA94126-6449

180 Sue Street Fih FoorSan Fancisco CA 94104029

Name: YE XINGCHEN A 078-694-496

ate oftis notice 11/8/2013

Enclosed is a copy of he Boad' ecisio a ore he above-rerenced cae.

cose

l Mb:Malphrus, Ga D.Man Anaane Hgh G.

Siceey,

D ctDonaCa

Cie Cerk

yungc

m:

ket

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Xingchen Ye, A078 694 496 (BIA Nov. 8, 2013)


2/18

US Depament of JusceExecuv Oce r Imiation Rvw

Deciso of the Board omiton Appels

FaJ Cuc, Vrgina 4

File A07 694 96 Fracico CA

I e: XGCEN YE

IN MOVAL PROCEDINS

APPAL AND MOTON

Dae

O BEHALF OF REONDENT Zchary Nghigle Eque

O BEHALF OF S ame B ildeaAia hief oe

APLAO ermo of oceedg; reman

NOV -8 2013

e eode h apeaed Immgrio dge decio of Aug 202 dgh e reode ha baoed hi w perme eie LR) u Whle heaeal w eig he repoe d moio o remd, whch he Deparme ofHomelan Secy DH) ha oed e record wil be ree o e mmigraio

udge

We reiew r ce eo e ding of c icdig he deeio of creilimade y e Imigraon ge. CFR. 1003.d)(3)(i) We reiew de oo l oher ecldig wee he rie he e e elean burde of proof ad iue o dicreon8 CF.R 1003.(d)(3i)

Were ere e reode h cooble cla of LR a he e i o eD o demorae by clear equoca and cocg edece ha e reodenanoed h au Khosahm v. Holder 655 3d 4 (9 i 201). oder o ify a reuig reie aie m be reig o reued w permeredence er empory ii abrod" See ingh v. Reno 3 3 152 51 (9 Cr.997). rip i a emorary ii abroad" if a) i i r a relaiey hor eriod xed byome eary een o b) e wi eiae o he occuece of ee ha areaob oibili of occing h a elaely ho eriod of ime. ee Chavez-Rmre

v IN, 92 F.2 932 937 i 196 f he alie rip aoa i o relaiey ho" a emory ii abroad" oly if e ae a a coiuou uieuped ieo o re ohe ied ae drg e eiey of er i" ee Khodaghon v Ahcro, 35 F3d 009 Cr. 203 For o b odrd eauaig epone ne o eu o ne Se il "h ie fiy ie ropery olig a be fio wie nie Se ad e lie fiy poey d ie ie in e reg coy."ngh v Reno upr 5-5

e epod w gd R a in 200 ad wa pce remoa procedigi Ar 2010 e Imigao dge d a e eoden ha abdoe hi ciig o he c a bewee 200 d 2010 e repode en a a ume of dayin e ed Se d e go ried a cden and ard own bie a.

Cite as: Xingchen Ye, A078 694 496 (BIA Nov. 8, 2013)


3/18

AQ78 694 96

The mmgraton Judge speccally noted the deh of documenty evdnc of thresodent's tes to the Unted States J at 1, th ac of afdavts om famy or ends(J at 12-13, he lack of proof tat he mantaned any renta unts or had any propryoneshp n the Unted Stats .J a 1, 12.

h hs moton, the respondent has submed evdence of hs nted tates busness tesMoton, Exhs. B C6), adavts om hs Untd States ctzen amly membrs (Moto,Exh. A 2, documntato of th ba accout h mantand n th ntd States (Exh A12,as w as vdence he says dcates that, durng h years n quston, he pad rnt to manta resence here Moton, Exh A2 ad ownd, rgstred and pd xes on h car whch hkpt n the Unted States (Moton, Exh. A, 5-8 The resondet hs aso submd medcaevdece regardng hs ther's nss and deah whch he sad caued hm to rman n Chna n2 as wl as evdence of hs on medcal probem hat h sad deayd hs r n 21(Moto, Exhs D d E

Athough the vdence proerd by the rspondnt was prevousy valabe, he assers acam of nectve sstce of counse aganst hs er aoey r fang to advs herespodnt to produc such evdence Moton, at 142 He also cams hat hs aoeyed to advse hm of the consequences o a rmoval order, namely t yar ba omretng to he Unted tates, ad dd not gve hm the oton of whdrang or renouncngs L staus (Moton, at 23 Tr at 1-8)

The respondent has comled th the requrments set rh n n Mate ofLoada 9 &NDec. 637 BA 1988, r nectve assstance of counse cams Moton, Exh , 25W w remand r the mmgraton Judge to evauate th neectve assstace cam ad todetern whether th respondent h estabshed the rqust prudce See Det v Holder

627 .3d 36, 373 Cr. 21 prjudce mens that the outcome of h proceedng mayhav ben aected by th alleged volaton). Accordngy, th owng ordrs shal beenterd

RDE e respondnts moton to rmd s granted

TE ORDE: Th record w be remandd to the mmgaton Judge r herrocdngs consstnt h te regong onon nd r th ntry of a new decson

R THE BAD1 Gv our dsosto o th moton, we need not adjudcate th respondnt's appa at

ts tme

2Cite as: Xingchen Ye, A078 694 496 (BIA Nov. 8, 2013)


4/18

NTED TAE DEPARTMET OF JUTIEEXETIVE OFIE OR IMMIGRTION REVIEW

NITED TTE IMMIGRTIO ORT

Fie: 849

In e Me f

XINGHE YE

REPODENT

FRAIO, ALIFORI

Ags , 212

I REMOVAL PROEEDIG

HRGE: ein 212) ) ) (i) I) f e Immiin ndNini A s mended s n Iin , he imepplin f dmissin, ws n in pssessin f vlidnexped Imin vis, e en pemi de ssng d, e vlid en dmen eied b e nd vlidnexpied pssp e sibe ve dmen dmens f ideni nd ninli s eied nde e

eins issed b e Ane Genel ne ein 2)f e A

APPLIATION Andnmen f esidene

O EHALF OF RE PONDENT: ROERT MMIG, EQUIRE, 2 ROADTREET, REDWOOD ITY, LIFORNIA 43

O EHALF OF H: JME GILDEA EIRE, 12 MOTGOMERY

TREET, ITE 2, N FRNIO, LIFORNIA 1

ORL DEON OF HE IMMIGTION JDGE

Respnden is ied me nive nd iien f

in Te Depen f Hmelnd ei insied


5/18

preedngs gns e Respnen e ssne f e

er ded r , py s ne s

ed n e rerd Ex .

A Mser endr erng ed n pr , 1,

Respnden ded egn ne, nd ree n e e

per dened egns r nd fve nd dened e

rge f revy. Respnden sg ge n nnen

resene erng Respnden ened desgne nry f rev s e dreed n

In ddn Respnden sg ppy fr

nen f rev prsn EOIR 42A. Ts ree s

vbe f permnen resdens exse r ve

res Hever Respnden, n s se s n egbe fr

s reef nr, r er, s e sed ny ype f

ppn Terere is rees e nsdered ved

Te r ed erng n Respndens n

Ags 1 A s erng Respnden sed sever

dmens nd esfed n sppr f s

EIDEE OF THE HEARIG

Te evidene e erng nssed f e

fng E 1 s e e Aper. Ex 2 s

den sed y e gvenen nng e rerd f

srn seen gven e Respnen n Apr 5 1, s e

s rerd f Respndens enres n r r e

Uned es Ex 3 nssed f ern fr e

8-44 Ags , 1


6/18

Responden, a saeen of ene and depaues a C and

su of he Resonden, o coes of cefcaes fo he

Respondens o Maes egees a lee ha pupos o be

fo nel Hoeve he Cou noes ha does no hae a

cefcae of anslaon a eued and 8 C R. ll e

l ed egh o hs docuen x H, 3H, as a lee

fo an nddual naed Ksen uha fo Bay ea Councl

Ms. uha as no ade aa lale. lee fo Ron Collea appeas o be a declaaon of an ndvdal naed ao

Boch s Boch and M Colln nyde en ee ade

avalale a declaaon fo Mneva Yang agan M Yang as

no ade avalable Responden also sued ax docuen

fo 2005 o 007 as ell a a copy of h olde passpos, and

ha ppo o e coes of Reponden olde paspos soe

docuen elang o h s pcase of a popey n 07 a

ell as a copy of Respondens laful peanen esden cad,

and a le fo a ca aed 08/04/2004. esponden, n xh

4 sued a deed fo popey puchae n 011 nd xhb

5 consed of a cefcae of le fo an auooble daed

2011 x 6 consed o a 14 lee fo an ndvdual

back a h unvesy nd xb 7 consed of he 2011

axes Responden alo esfed n suppo of h s applcaon

and hs eony can e befly suazed as follos.

Reponden s a nave and cen of Chna

Responden eneed he ned aes soee n 4.

078-6446 3 ugus 7 202


7/18

Respnen lie e enere ere g s He

epine e e e Unie es n n -1 is

s e Universi f llinis in Urn, llinis He

ine Msers' Degrees ne in Engis ierre n

Englis ngge n sen ne in nfrin iene fer

ese egrees, e en n r seer ers fr vris

pnies in e Unie es espnen epine

rn 24 is fer ee ill n e spen ppriel

ers in e Unie Ses s inse e se rern

e spen se ie i is fer He epline is

fer een sffering fr Prinsns s e rerne e

i i

n 25 is fer psse Respnen eer

eie rein in in ese ie e

ffer w nel in Cin Respnen epine is

e ver ineresing i n e g e w e g fi

ere s e reine i nel pn ni Oer 28

Respnen esifie n e er refles espnen wen p

e rpre ler i ne in in 28 He ws

respnsie fr new pr n e s se e-p is

spinff pn, nsf in in e epine e rennee n inerepenen n ne n e nines

ep is pn

Respnen esifie e riginl ine is

LP ss see in 23 se e never g e r

8-694496 4 gs 212


8/18

' I

unl Noveber of 2004 esponden dscussed e fc h

hle he s lvng n Cn nd orkng for nel he dd ve

nd s oncerned bou s sus n he ned es. He s

dvsed by ne oney, hrugh el e ould no lose

s sus n e ned es provded h he kep reurnng

nd pyng xes s resul esponden kep flng xes

fro 2004 o e presen He also nned r ere o

ls o ve nned hernd hs proded le o

effec esponden lso dsussed ho e ould rounely

rvel o e ned es bu ould ry o spend less hn 30

dys every onh o vod x conseuenes

esponden lso esfed bk n Cn e s

veed s n ern nd e as xed ore ealy nd e

pons o lee fo nel shong hs green crd nuber

esponden lso dsussed s personl lfe nd

exended fly He sed h e hs sser ho s

cen nd lves n ssacuses He hs severl ousns here

n e ned es one n sschuses nd one n

Clforn Bo e cens s for hs ede

fly esponden esfed he s rred o on o s

lful peanen resden nd ogeher ey hve o chldren ere born n Hong ong esponden dscussed ho s fe

s lful pernen resden nd h se ons soe popery

n Ne ork, ppenly soe so of condonu ey sold

nd ogeher ey ve purchsed propery here n Clforn

04-46 5 ugus , 2012


9/18

Responden dscussed ho boh s chlden ee bon n Hong

ong nd nehe of he hve saus He expned h hey

e ve young

Responden esfed h s hs nen nd hs

fes nen o eun o he ned es lve hee and

se he chden He explned he fees ecn and ha

hs s hs hoe and h he shes o spend he es of hs

lfe hee He explaned ha he oppounes hee e bee,

he educonl sse s bee, nd he ns hs chlden o

be sed hee n he ned es He and s fe nend o

eun nd se he chlden and educae he nd hey e

eely ng fo ppova fo he chdens cds,

pculy once he dughe ho s pcclly hee nd

hf o fou yes od ll s kndegen hey hope h

hey be ble o begn he educon hee

Wh espec o hs ohe a hch s pevousy

dscussed as hs s se nd hs fe Hs ohe connues o

ve n Chna

Responden esfed ha, alhough he fled xes he

hs no pad axes n hese ls fe es o hs knoledge

h he eed upon he advce o a fed pepng hs axesfo fng sngly nd he hs no ade ny effos o coec

hese epesenaons of flng hese xes

Responden cas ha he dd no nend o abndon

hs esdenc He acknoledged h beeen 2004 and 2010

08-694-46 6 ugus 202


10/18

I

he pen only appoxaely accodng o h Cou

calulaon, approxaely 6 day n e ned ae

Neerele he explaned ha he ould rae ofen and wa

no h nenon o aandon and he n fa, ade effor o

ae ure ha h au a eal hrough conang he nel

lawyer eponden alo explaned a nce arrn n he

ned ae n prl of 1 e has reurned a o Cna

eeral e and, n fac ony pen e la wo onh or o

n e ned ae depe nong a au a a

r. e explaned, f r of all, ha e head up a copany n

Chna and need o e ere, alo ha h hlren are ery

youn, and fnally e had oe o of edal condon ha

reured eergency eda reaen n Chna

eponden alo expaned ha h fe a unae o

oe hee oday een hough h wfe and chldren e n Chna

and he dd no hn o a oher people o oe efy

eponden heefore aed on hee douen and h

eony, eee ha he ha ealed a e ha no

abandoned h redency n e ned ae

MNT OF W

n order o qualfy a a reurnn reden alen,

alen u hae acqued lafu peranen reden au n

accordance w he law f he ned Sae and u hae

reaned ha au fro he e he aqured and u be

eurnng o an unrelnqhed laful peanen reden afe a

8-6944 7 uu 7 1


11/18

emporary vs abroa See Maer of Huan, 19 &N e. 49 a5 (BI 1988.

rp s a emporary vs abra f t is for a

reavey sort pero, fxe by some eary event or e rip

w ermnae pon e orene f an even a as a

reasonabe possiby of orrng wtin a reavey sor

pero of me. See Snh v. Reno, 113 F. 3 1512 at 1514 9Cir. 199, see CaveRamre v. NS, 92 F 2 932 (9 r.

198 6 .

rps abroa of eg or nne mons n onseve

raon are no reavey sor. ee Sinh v. Reno, spra a1514. an aiens tp abroa is no reavey sor, s

no a emporary vs abroa an ony f e aen as a

onnos nnerrpe nenon o rern o e ne

Saes rin e ime of s vs, e nen s no einen o rern e Une Saes imaey, b e nen

s o rern e ne Saes wn a reavey sor

per of me, Sngh a 114.Fars a e Cor ms onser in main

eermnaons on weer an aen arbore a onnos,

nnerrpe nenon o rern, nng aens famiy

es, prpery oings, bsness affaons wn e ne

Saes, an an aen's fmiy, propery, an bsiness es n

te foregn onry. See Khodaholan v. srof, 335 F. 313 a 1 (9 Cr. 23, an aen's ese o rean s

8694-496 8 s , 1


12/18

stats wthot oe s not en. See Matt r of Huan,sa.

RR NSIS N ININGS

Ive stene to te esonent ve evewe the

omentaton n ths atter an arefy obseve s emeano

n s testmony. to ths Cot notes that Responent

sbet to te provsons of te L I t, wee he mst

sbmt evene reaes of ebe testmony, th Cot

notes that te Cort have soe onerns rearn s

testmony atay wth reet to hs tax etns.

Resonent as a stoy of fn tax etns were he has mae

ams of ten the trt where, n at, these oments are

not tthf s oe rase e eston f Responent as

been trtf to ths Cot. Neverteess, even f esonent

tesfy eby, th ot s not esae tat he

as mantane a ontnos, nntepte ntenton to etn

to te nte States.

e Cort st aresses te tme that Responent as

emane n te nte States n th ase, te tme at sse

s from 2004 to p 4, 200. n ths ae, te Cort notes

esonent emaine n te nte States ony aoxmatey 1ays. hats aproxmatey 10 ays per yea or te sx yeas

e's a s aw emanen eene. n at, esonent

was no even ysay ee wen he was ven s awf

peranent reent ar. is hows the Cort tat e as

08694-496 9 gst , 202


13/18

smp nt inteeste in lng in the nite States an

bling a ife in te nte States f imsef, ater e was

smpl intereste n the fte hang te ablt t etn

t the nite tates wit is faml s fte eience f

this, sine cming an nwng in Apri f 2010 tat is stats

as at rsk, e et agai ece t etrn t Cna tgh

espnent ffers as eplanatns f y e cse t

tat te Crt fns it tbing tat he w kning is

stats was at risk n te Unite States, e netheess

retrn t Cina an spen ess than tw mnts n the nite

States n this case, te t rea has n iea w mc

tme Respnent as spent in the nite States in te ast t

eas since 010 ecept n t assme that ts prbab ess

than 30 as a ea agan seing frter eence tat

espnent s simp nt ntereste in makng a fe fr hmsef

in te nite States

n aitin wt respet t ties in te nite

States this Crt sees acta n tes hee t te nite

States. espnent as a nte States ctizen siste et

fae t pre er r sbmit a statement frm her

evence n fact that se s a nite States ctizen Hecaims t ae ppet tes in the nite States Te Ct

ntes, eer, that the n ppert tie he ha was a car frm

003. e has nt pre, caime r shwn me that he has

pa taxes n it an in igt f is ter faes wit taxes

A08694-496 0 Agst 7, 01


14/18

an estionabe taxes, this ort s not even sre that

esonent has one that Moreover, athoh esonent

recent rchase a roert, sch proert was rchase n

2011, ivin the ort the mpresson hes trin to create

evience or ties to the Unite States owi f we that hs

stats was at ris esonent aso caims his wife ha some

roet et he roves no eence, hatsoever, of his ifes

roert ties, nor even a statement from hs wfe exainin

that she ha sch ropert ties

As for fami tes, this ort notes esponents wife

was not here n the Unite States This Cort oes not even

have a co of esonents wifes awf ermanent resient

stats n aiton, both his chiren ere born overseas

The o not have stats in the Unite States. t is cear to

ths Cort that esponent has vra no ties to the Unite

States with resect to fami e aso caime to hae two

cosins Aain, no eience o a fami memers in the Unite

States excet his on sef-servin testimon

n fact, it s cear that esonent oes an wo

e to ive in the nite States, eventa brinin his

fami here owever, what is certan here is that intent to

eventa retrn to the nite States s sim not rons for

showin that he ha a contnos, nnterrpte intention to

retrn to the Unite States The on exanaton ths

esonent has iven here is the ness of his father his

A08-69-96 1 Ast , 201


15/18

,/

Crt is smpatetic t the Respnent Certain in an

spenin sme ast as f his faters ife is nerstanabe

n a Respnent ne that an retrne t the Unite tates

after te eat f is fater, ten the Crt ma re

ifferent ever,e nstea cse t remain in Cinarl

prsin is caree tere

Respnent sbmitte sme eience tat e rke fr

nte in the Unite tates bt nne f this ss that te

cnsiere im a empee an te fact tat e faie t

pa taxes r make an effrt t sh tat he cnsiere imsef

iin in the Unite tates an a ties t te Unite tates,

aain beies an caim eres n expanatin Respnent

as nabe t fin a jb here in te Unite tates t s is

interest in ivin a ife ere, rather, at as been

estabishe here is that Respnent acta , smetime in

te ftre, ike his chiren t cme t the Unite States an

t sch here eer, it is cear e ha n intentins,

in tese ast ears, t ie in the Unite States, n prpert

in te Unite tates, have is ciren brn, r marr ere in

the Unite tates, r create a ife fr imsef in te Unite

tates e i nt wn prpert e i nt have renta nits

e i nt even bther pin taxes, r een fiin prper

taxes, r makin effrts t shw e ha an interest in in s

e cims t hve friens an fami ere in te

Unite States he Crt ntes tat n ne ere came t testif

A07869496 2 st 7 2012


16/18


17/18

speaking abo he nie Saes abroa oes no reae an

uninerrue, oninuou ineres or oninuous eabimen

o ive in he nie ae A i o i a he in

igy of he nie Saes 's erainy no a faor i

Cour as oniere, or sown, or s eie o onsie for

i purpoe oringy, e Cor wi fin a Reonen

as abanone i nie ae awf permanen reiene, a

uh, e oes no ave any aus i e nie ae, an wi

orer im remove o China on e arge onane in e

Noie o ppear So orere is 7h ay of ugu 0

078694-496 4 gus , 0


18/18

CEFCAE PAGE

heeb etif hat the ataed poeedi befoe GE

LE GE E i te ae o:

GCE YE

A07899

A ACCO CALFOA

i an aate vebati taipt o te eodi a povide

b the Exetive Offie o iatio eview a ha i i

the oiial aip heeo fo te ile o te Exetive

Offie o iaio evie

a/eh

OMA DAFEL aibe)

Y EGHC ECE

CBE 1, 201

Coleto ae}

Xingchen Ye, A078 694 496 (BIA Nov. 8, 2013)

Documents