Top Banner
www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08
25

Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

Mar 27, 2015

Download

Documents

Sean Schwartz
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 1/19

PASCAL Challenge

PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team

Page 2: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 2/19

…tbc

Page 3: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 3/19

Contents of our Universe

70% Dark Energy

25% Dark Matter

5% Baryonic Matter

Page 4: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 4/19

Gravitational Lensing

Light from a distant galaxy is bent around a mass

Page 5: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 5/19

Gravitational Lensing

Galaxies seen through dark matter distribution analogous to

Streetlamps seen through your bathroom window

Page 6: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 6/19

Page 7: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 7/19

Cosmic Lensing

Real data:gi~0.03

gi~0.2

Page 8: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 8/19

Atmosphere and Telescope

Convolution with kernel

Real data: Kernel size ~ Galaxy size

Page 9: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 9/19

Pixelisation

Sum light in each square

Real data: Pixel size ~ Kernel size /2

Page 10: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 10/19

Noise

Mostly Poisson. Some Gaussian and bad pixels.Uncertainty on total light ~ 5 per cent

Page 11: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 11/19

Page 12: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 12/19

Typical starUsed for finding Convolution kernel

Typical galaxyused for cosmicshear analysis

Page 13: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 13/19

Page 14: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 14/19

GREAT08 Data

One galaxy per imageKernel is givenOne shear per setNoise is Poisson

~10 000 imagesdivided into ~10 sets

~100 000 000 images

Divided into ~1000 sets

Page 15: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 15/19

GREAT08 Results

You submit g1, g2 for each set of images

Page 16: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 16/19

GREAT09 and Beyond• Kernel is not given (just kernel images)• Galaxies with more complicated shapes• Kernel is more realistic• Many objects in each image• Correlated noise• Poisson + Gaussian noise + bad pixels• Shear is different for each galaxy• Kernel is not the same for every galaxy• Cosmic rays, satellite tracks, saturated stars• Multiple exposures• Pixels not exactly square or on a grid

Page 17: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 17/19

GREAT08 Timeline• ~8 Feb 2008 GREAT08 Handbook public• Feb 2008 Produce simulations• Mar 2008 Internal analysis of simulations• ~ May 2008 Release simulations

– Leaderboard starts containing best internal results

• ~ Nov 2008 Competition deadline• ~ Dec 2008 Workshop; Release final report

– Input shears public

www.great08challenge.info

Page 18: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 18/19

GREAT08 Summary

• 100 million images• 1 galaxy per image• De-noise, de-convolve, average → shear

• gi ~ 0.03 to accuracy 0.0003 → Q~1000 → Win!

Page 19: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 19/19

cosmocoffee.info

Page 20: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 20/19

GREAT08

Page 21: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 21/19

Understanding Cosmology

Page 22: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 22/19

GREAT08 Summary

• 100 million images• 1 galaxy per image• De-noise, de-convolve, average → shear

• gi ~0.03 to accuracy 0.0003 → Q~1000 → Win!

18/18

Page 23: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 23/19

Questions for you• Is there too much astronomy to learn?

– Yes– No

• Is timeline (~6 months) right?– Too short – Fine– Too long

• Is this potentially on your research agenda?– No– Maybe– Yes

Page 24: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 24/19

Page 25: Www.great08challenge.info 1/19 PASCAL Challenge PASCAL Workshop, Bled 28 Jan 2008 Sarah Bridle (UCL) on behalf of the GREAT08 Team.

www.great08challenge.info www.cosmocoffee.info 25/19