8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
1/13
Porcupine TreeShadows and lightby Anil PrasadCopyright 2004 Anil Prasad. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution, No Derivatives license.
Porcupine Tree founder Steven Wilson isnt content with the status quo that tells us to shelve thedarker sides of our personas in the wake of recent tragedies that continue to grip the world. His
approach is to embrace the melancholic as catharsis and use it to propel his artistry forward. That
thinking permeates In Absentia,the British acts latest studio album. Its songs explore the psyche of
societys fringe elements, situated within thunderous metal riffs, complex melodies, multi-part vocalharmonies and ambient atmospheres. Its the most direct and in-your-face record the group has
released to date.
Porcupine Tree began in 1987 as a home studio solo project for Wilson, a multi-instrumentalist,
composer, vocalist and producer. Over the course of the next 17 years, Wilson transformed it into a
renowned, full-fledged group that also features ex-Japan keyboardist Richard Barbieri, bassist Colin
Edwin and drummer Gavin Harrison. The band went on to release a plethora of albums, EPs and
singles that explore its psychedelic, experimental and progressive leanings both independently and
through smaller labels such as Snapper and Delerium. A worldwide cult following latched on to the
group, causing major labels to take notice. In 2001, the band signed a deal with Lava, a subsidiary
of Atlantic Records.
Since In Absentiasrelease through Lava in 2002, the bands fan base has grown exponentially.
Many high-profile musicians have also taken notice, including King Crimson guitarist and vocalist
Adrian Belew, a contributor to the forthcoming Porcupine Tree record.
Porcupine tree represents an interesting combination of several things that I like, said Belew. Its
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/3.0/deed.en_UShttp://localhost/var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_7/https://www.facebook.com/innerviewshttps://twitter.com/innerviewshttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/3.0/deed.en_UShttps://twitter.com/innerviewshttps://www.facebook.com/innerviewshttp://localhost/var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_7/8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
2/13
a little bit like King Crimson, Tool and Trent Reznor, English-style, but not the same as any of those
things. Steven has a real strong vision of what he wants to do and it has a certain kind of power
thats really great. His voice is also very fetching. Its unique and fits in very well with what hes
doing. Musically, what I really like about the band is they do a lot of odd time things that you dont
notice so muchtheyre just in there. They fit together so well that they slide right past your ears,
which is something some bands never attempt and when they do, its very obvious. Porcupine Tree
also has really good players and the songs are really cool. I like everything about it. Its just good
stuff, custom-made for me. Steven has given me free reign and just guided me here and there and
said things like Play something strangely beautiful in this 17/8 area. Its been a lot of fun.
In addition to Porcupine Tree, Wilson is well-known for No-Man, his ongoing collaboration with
singer-songwriter Tim Bowness. The duo explores the perimeters of the rock and pop world,
infusing them with far-flung influences including neo-classical, jazz, dub and techno. However, No-
Man's latest release, 2003s Together Were Stranger,is its most stripped-down yet. Its a quiet,
meditative record that occupies the other end of In Absentiassonic spectrum.
Wilson is also involved in a myriad of other collaborations. Blackfield, another duo Wilson formed
with Israeli musician Aviv Geffen, has just released its self-titled debut record. Its an album of
concise, elegant, melodic rock that should hold a lot of interest for Porcupine Tree fans. Other
projects Wilson has in the works include ongoing recording for Bass Communion, his ambient,
electronic solo persona, and IEM [Incredible Expanding Mindfuck], his Krautrock and cosmic jazz
endeavor. If all of this wasnt enough, Wilson continues to serve as a producer for the likes of AnjaGarbarek, Opeth and Theo Travis.
Innerviewsbegan its conversation with Wilson by exploring Porcupine Trees move to the major
label ranks.
Great things were anticipated for the U.S. release of In Absentia.Did it work out to your
satisfaction?
I dont think you can anticipate or predict anything in America. I dont know if I had any particular
expectations either. Im in my 30s now and have been in the music industry on and off for 13 years,
so Im kind of cynical, but in a healthy way. Some might call that being realistic. You take each thing
as it comes and expect nothing. Its with that attitude that we entered into the major label scenario
in America. I suspect if we had been 18-year-old kids we would have expected to have sold a
million copies and be on top of the world. However, because weve all been around the block a few
times, we expected things would improve, but didnt really know how. Things have definitely
stepped up. The record has sold in the region of three times what any previous record has. Its
done about 100,000 copies worldwide which is a lot more than weve done in the past. In terms of
North America, weve gone literally from selling 2,000 copies to 45,000, so thats a big step up. In
Europe, sales have improved as well, but less so, because its been our primary touring and sales
market previously. In terms of percentages, weve increased massively in America and significantly
elsewhere.
At the same time, theres a lot of resistance from certain parts of the industry that is stopping us
from getting to a much higher level. Im talking about radio and the media in America. Were justbeginning to make an impact on radio. Blackest Eyes got added to various major rock stations.
We dont really know how these things work. Its been a real learning experience. Its funny, in
Europe, if a record hasnt been a hit by the end of the first month of release, you can basically
move on. It seems in America, you can still be working a record almost a year later. So, things are
progressing and things are beginning to happen. With this record, its been a war of attrition for us.
A few years ago, you told me you had little interest in working with a major label. What
changed your mind?
Finding the right label. To put this in perspective, every time we demoed a new record, pretty much
from Signifyin 1995 and beyond, we would do the rounds of labelsmajors and independents
alike. There was always a flurry of interest, particularly around the time of Lightbulb Sun.The band
had a proven underground following and sales and we were being recognized as a strong live act.
So, there was interest, but there was always a sense that the labels didnt get it or werent
expecting much of the band. So, what we really felt was if there was ever a scenario in which the
band signs to a major label, it would have to be a grade one record deal in which they were really
putting their money where their mouth was and giving us the resources to make a record that was
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
3/13
expected to sell, with ambitions to
hit a million copies, otherwise,
there didnt seem to be any point.
There was no point in signing to a
label where we were the small fish
in the big pond. With Porcupine
Tree, every label weve worked
with has made us a priority act.
We couldnt envisage a situationin which wed be a major priority
for a major label until we met
Andy Karp [Senior Vice President
of A&R] at Lava Records. He not
only got the band and wanted to
sign us, but he was a fan, actively
buying our records since the
mid-90s. He totally got it and was
prepared to really give us the
finances and marketing resources that major labels are capable of giving. He was committed to
backing the band over a longer period of time. Thats really important. We have a long-term dealwith Lava. Theyre not going to drop us because In Absentiadidnt sell a million records. In other
words, they recognize that were an album band and not necessarily a singles band.
When you and I spoke last time, I arrived at the conclusion that there was no major label that was
suitable for Porcupine Tree and Im happy to have been proven wrong. I think the other thing is the
climate changed between 2000 and 2002. There was a significant change in the way major labels
think. I think the downloading thing made them reconsider the short-term philosophy theyd pursued
for the previous 20 years. In other words, you sign a band, have one big hit album and single and
move on. The success of bands like Radiohead and Tool having number one albums without
releasing singles has definitely shifted the spotlight slightly in the direction of a band like Porcupine
Tree. Lava wasnt the only label that wanted to sign us. There was competition going on in the
American major label scene which was extraordinary and surreal for me at the age of 34. To getthat kind of interest was very strange.
Your last experience with a major label was when Sony distributed No-Man in America. How
is working with Lava different?
Yes, we were signed to Sony through One Little Indian, even though One Little Indian was still very
much an independent label. At the time, they werent a company of the magnitude of the Time-
Warner organization. Their financial resources were very limited in that they had to justify every
penny spent. During the time No-Man was on One Little Indian, Tim [Bowness] and I traveled to
America to meet the people from Sony around the time they were issuing the Loveblows and
Lovecriesalbum. The difference couldnt be more dramatic. Its down to being a small fish in a big
pond as opposed to being a big fish in a big pond. I cant emphasize enough the difference in beinga priority act as opposed to just being one of a group of small acts that have been picked up in a
job lot from an independent U.K. label. We had a guy who was supposed to be our contact at Sony,
but we would never have got to meet the head of the label to discuss A&R, marketing or press
policy. Having a good relationship with the various parts of a major label makes a major difference
when you feel they are behind you. Lava are motivated and genuinely liked In Absentia.In contrast,
there was probably one guy at Sony who even heard the No-Man record when it was released and
that was very depressing. It was one of the reasons I got put off the major label thing for the next
10 years.
Are you surprised that in America, a large percentage of Porcupine Trees audience has
turned out to be metal fans?
We seem to be picking up a lot more fans from that area, yeah. I think the fact that I collaboratedwith Opeth made a difference in that respect. It doesnt surprise me because the band has, over
the past three or four records, moved closer to a harder and heavier sound. I feel every record is a
step forward and an evolution from the previous record in some respect. The major innovation on
In Absentiais the fact that theres some real metal and riffing aspects to it. So, it doesnt surprise
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
4/13
me that metal fans are interested in America, a place where rock music has never really gone
away. In England, rock music comes back for a time every 10 years and then disappears again.
The last time it was fashionable was the Nirvana era and its been wall-to-wall DJ culture since. In
America, like in Germany, there is always an appetite for good quality rock music.
I was at the San Francisco show last year which was full of death-metal fans in goth outfits
and make-up. I felt like an alien pod person amongst them.
I love a lot of the music they listen to. Ive always loved metal music, particularly extreme metal
music in the last few years, so I dont feel like an alien pod person amongst them. [laughs] There
are a lot more younger people, but the old fans are coming too. Maybe they arent as vocal in San
Francisco as the young kids. What I find is if you have an audience thats 20 percent metal kids and
80 percent music-loving, slightly older people, you can guarantee the 20 percent of metal kids will
make it seem like theyre the only people there. [laughs] They tend to come to the front and make
the most noise. We did shows on the last tour where we really felt like we were playing only to metal
kids, but then you get to the end of the show and meet some of the fans and it appears to be more
of a mixture. I think the older Porcupine Tree fans that come from the mid-90s tend to be quietly
sitting on the sides or in the balcony.
In Absentiadealt with subject matter that explored your curiosity with the criminal, fringe
elements of society. Perhaps that attracted the metal fans as well.
A lot of people ask me about the serial killer aspect of In Absentiaand its there. Ive admitted it, butI always stress that Im not so interested in what these people do. What they do and have done is
really the stock-in-trade of death metal, heavy metal and satanic bands. The one thing I felt had not
been explored was what creates these kinds of people. What happens in their youth or
adolescence that creates people unable to empathize and related to other people in the way the
rest of us do?
Futile, one of the tracks from
the forthcoming albums
sessions, recently appeared on
a promo sampler specifically
aimed at metal radio. Tell me
why you took that approach so
far ahead of the new albums
release.
What happened is we started
working on material for the next
record and one of the songs that
came out was a very heavy piece
called Futile. Its probably the
heaviest thing weve ever done. At
the same time, Lava wanted to
target metal radio. One of theproblems Lava has with Porcupine
Tree has nothing to do with the quality of the music or appeal of the music. Rather, its the
eclecticism of the music. How do you market a band that one minute is playing metal, the next
minute is playing trip-hop and the next minute is playing progressive rock? One of the solutions
weve come up with is to put together samplers that target different aspects of the bands sound to
different radio formats. In America, you have this ridiculous radio format thing in which only certain
kinds of music will be played on certain types of radio stations.
So, Lava have put together a sampler that focuses on the bands metal side for metal radio. I dont
have a problem with this because at the end of the day, if it makes someone go out and buy the
record, hopefully theyll sit down and listen and think maybe its not exactly what theyre expecting,
but get the whole picture of it and still like it. In terms of Futile, Andy Karp heard it and said theyreputting together this metal radio sampler and that it would be a great track to include on it,
especially since its exclusive and not commercially available. He thought it might get the radio
stations even more behind it. So, we finished it way ahead of the next albums other material, put it
on and it seemed to do pretty well. It was the number two rock song in New York at one point.
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
5/13
Whatever helps, you know?
I understand the upcoming album is based on a film script youve co-written.
Yeah, its going in a very different lyrical direction to In Absentia.I wrote the film script with myfriend in 2002. Hes a film director from America named Mike Bennion. Hes one of my best friends
and makes commercials and short films. One thing hed never done is make a full-length feature,
so in 2001, we set out to try and write something he would want to film. Thats just the first stage.
Next, you have to shop it around and try to find the financing to shoot it. I thought it was a good
experience for me, because its a different artistic discipline to sit down and write a film script and
try to create a narrative that works in that medium. We spent two years working on it. I would
describe it as a very surreal ghost story. So far, the people that have read it have been impressed. I
felt like if there was an album to go with it, there would be more of a chance of the movie getting
made. So, Ive started to base the new songs on it. I dont want to create a concept album to tell the
story of the film, but I felt there were certain episodes in the movie that lent themselves to being
worked into songs as well. The script is called Lullabye.The album may or may not be called that.
Musically speaking, how does the album compare to In Absentia?
The album is more cohesive I would say. The metal element has now become more a part of the
fabric of the music and the extremes of In Absentiawill be more united on the new record. I'm very
happy with the new music. I think it is again an improvement and advance on all our previous work.
There are also some much longer pieces this time, as well as some very strong shorter piecesperhaps its that Aviv Geffen influence rubbing off on me. This time we have way too much good
music for a single record and I think it's going to be tough to leave songs off.
You once said you find it easier to write negative songs than ones that deal with
happiness. Is that a bona fide dilemma or simply a preference?
Its just what comes naturally for me. People ask me all the time Your songs are so melancholic
and depressing. Is that what youre like as a person? The answer is no. Im not really like that at
all. Because the songs are cathartic, they get the negative aspects out of my personality. Ivealways felt drawn to more negative and melancholic music since I was a kid. Ive asked myself why
that should be. If you come back to the metal world, you find so much of that music is very black
and deals with the dark side of life, yet kids are so drawn to it. I think thats because melancholicmusic is very uplifting. Why? Because its a shared experience. In contrast, I find music that is
artificially happy or very joyful to be very depressing. [laughs] I cant relate to that music. Life, most
of the time, isnt a particularly joyful thing. Thats not to say its a very depressing thing either.
Ninety-five percent of life is simply existing. Its the rare moments of joy or negativity that throw
everything else into relief. Those are the things that almost make life worth living. So, Ive always
found melancholic and dark music to be the most moving and beautiful because it makes you
aware there are other people in the world who have shared experiences. I cant find any other
rational explanation for that. Most people are drawn to sad music. Ballads are the all time classics
for some people, whether its Stairway to Heaven or Im Not in Love. Its always the ballads that
last for decades and decades and stand the test of time.
The perception is, for all intents and purposes, Porcupine Tree remains a solo project foryou in that your vision and direction drive it.
Yes, but that doesnt necessarily mean its a solo project. I think theres this myth that in some
respects the band is just me and whoever I choose to work with. If you look at every major band in
history, you can say in almost every case that theres someone who filled my role, whether it was
Pete Townsend in The Who, Peter Hammil in Van Der Graaf Generator or Robert Fripp in King
Crimson. You wouldnt say those bands were their solo projects. Yes, I write most of the material for
the band and produce the records, so in that respect, I consider myself to be the captain of the
ship. Im making sure its steering in the direction I want it to steer in, but in all other respects, the
band is very much a democracy. We all make decisions about what goes on the record, how it
sounds and where and when we go on tour. I dont have that situation with any of my other
projects, except for No-Man, where Tim is my partner. For me, a true solo project is one in which
Im truly only answerable to myself and that only holds for Bass Communion and IEM. I have to tell
you, there are many things Porcupine Tree have done, recorded and released that I personally
would have done differently had it been my solo project. Thats what part of being in a band is
about. Sometimes you make compromises for the good of the band. You get outvoted on things
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
6/13
and sometimes you realize you were outvoted for a good reason and other times you feel that if
theyd taken your opinion, it would have been better.
So, you dont have ultimate
veto power?
If I did, theyd all leave. [laughs]
Its as simple as that. If I simply
said No, were not going to do it
that way. Were going to do it my
way and I dont care what you
say I dont think they would be in
the band. You have to accept
sometimes that you cant do what
you want all the time. There are
other opinions and sometimes
they are valid. So, I dont have
final veto, except perhaps when
were in the studio and producing
the record. If somebody comes up
with an idea or sound that I dont think works, I would ultimately reach some compromise. But if I
felt it really didnt work, I probably would have ultimate veto there. I tell you, Ive written songs thathave been voted off the records that I really felt were some of the best Ive written. There are a
couple of songs that I wrote for In Absentiawhich for whatever reason the band didnt like, so they
didnt get recorded. If it was a solo project, that would never have happened. I accept those things
because there are a lot of positive things about having a democratic process.
A DVD-Audio version of In Absentiawas just released. Describe the opportunity remixing
the album in 5.1 provided and your take on the emerging high-resolution audio realm.
I was less interested in the higher resolutionas it's really only a minority of people than can
actually hear the difference or have a system that is capable of revealing the differencethan I was
in the opportunity to mix into surround. It's a medium perfectly suited to Porcupine Tree's music,
which has many layers to the production that stereo really cannot do justice to. For example, beingable to position the multi-part harmony vocals and some of Richard Barbieri's electronic sounds and
textures all around the listener means that the music really does open out in a three-dimensional
way. Once you hear something in 5.1, it really does render the stereo mix rather flat and
uninspiring, especially with a band like Porcupine Tree. I'm happy to say that the 5.1 mix of In
Absentiadoes seem to be becoming a benchmark of sorts for surround DVD-Audio, as I hoped it
would. We put a tremendous amount of time and effort into getting it right, whereas most surround
mixes are done as an afterthought without even the artist being involved much of the time.
Youve compared the process of making Peter Gabriels Upto In Absentiaas being the
difference between an overlabored approach and production trickery versus sheer hard
work and determination. Was there anything you could identify with in terms of Gabriels
difficulty in birthing his record?
Not really, no. I cant relate to that way of working because Ive never taken more than a year to
make a record. You might be quite entitled to say Ive never made a record as good as Peter
Gabriel though. [laughs] I dont feel thats true. I think In Absentiais a superior record to Up.Im
usually very objective about these things in the sense that Im quite happy to admit that some of my
past records are not as good as they should have been and that there were lots of records out at
the same time that were much better. But Ive heard Upand I feel its an overworked, overwrought
record that doesnt have a center. It does not hang together. The songs have been swamped in
complexities of arrangement and there is no perspective. It just feels like he wrote the songs and
spent so long working on them that the songs, which are ultimately the most important thing, got
somehow lost, ignored and forgotten about. I think thats a problem when you spend 10 years
making a record or however long it took.
When you have a song, you have to create a sound world for it and give it the best possible
context. When it becomes the other way around, in which the song is secondary to the production
and the process of recording itself, I think you lose a lot of your artistry and I feel thats true with Up.
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
7/13
With In Absentia,we had the songs and we went in and recorded them very quickly and very well, I
think. We didnt lose perspective on what we were trying to do. We didnt lose the shape of the
album, the power of the hooks and the songs themselves.Upjust collapses under the weight of its
own overwroughted-ness.
Do you ever encounter moments of total blockage or indecision?
I have periods when I cant come up with any new material at all. Everyone does. I feel like Okay,
thats it, Ive written my last song. I cant find anything new. I cant write anything without repeating
whats gone before. I always encounter that sometime during every album cycle. Theres always a
period when I feel Ive got nothing left to say. Every time so far, touch wood, Ive proved myself
wrong. Ive been able to wait it out or tap into some new inspiration thats restarted the creative
process. Yes, Ive been in a situation where there are certain songs or recordings in the studio that
no matter what you do with them, they dont seem to sound right. You find yourself going in a
vicious circle of scrapping what youve done before and starting again with a completely different
approach. Then you start thinking Well, maybe we can use a bit of that arrangement, a bit of this
arrangement and a bit of another arrangement. Then you start working in patchwork form. When
that situation arises, it can be a trap. In my experience, you kind of say Its not working. None of
these things are quite right and you scrap it and move on.
Ive got friends that have been working on the same songs literally for 15 years. What happens is
they wrote these songs 15 years ago and have spent months and months trying to find the ultimatearrangement for them. By the time theyre done, the whole music scene has moved on and theres
some new fashion or sound, so their songs are out of date. They then try to recreate the songs in a
more contemporary context and theyre always behind. So, five years ago, theyd be trying to
recreate songs again in a trip-hop style. Again, the problem with that is theyre missing the point of
the songs themselves in trying to make them contemporary.
I think there is one time No-Man fell into this trap. It was during the Wild Operaera in which we
were enamored with the trip-hop scene. We started writing, for the first time in our career since
Loveblows and Lovecries,in a generic way. We started to be influenced by what was happening
around us and that may or may not be a good thing. For No-Man, its a bad thing. I think its better
we exist outside of fashion and whats happening in the music scene. Of course, by the time Wild
Operacame out, the whole scene had passed and played itself out. I think thats the problem withpeople like Peter Gabriel who spend 10 years making a record with so many different things in
there. It just doesnt work. Maybe its just me. I dont know.
Youve served as a producer for
several artists. How would you assess
your effectiveness in that role?
I dont imagine I would ever be a good
producer for somebody who came to me
and said We have this band and want
you to make a hit record for them. But if
someone comes to me and says I wantto make an album. I like what you do and
I want you to come and do what you do,
that always seems to work. Thats what
Opeth and Anja [Garbarek] did. They just
wanted me to be myself and do what I do
anyway, which is come along and
respond to the music in the way I would
respond to my own songs. Typically, if
you want to be a proper producer, you
have to be able to work with all sorts of
artists from different genres and adapt
yourself to their sound and theirexpectations, as well as those of the
record company. Ive never done a project where Ive had to do that. I just work with people who
want me to do what I do anyway. So, in that respect, Im not as versatile as a full-time producer. I
only do things I really love anyway. I couldnt sustain a career as a producer. There arent that
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
8/13
many bands I like. [laughs]
How do you look back at the making of Garbareks Smiling and Wavingrecord?
That was a very interesting experience for me. She was signed to BMG and at the time I wasintroduced to her, she had been working on the record for about 10 years with about 10 different
producers by that point. Shed been in the studio with some very big names, including Chris Hughes
and Mark Hollis from Talk Talk. It had never worked out. The reason is because no-one was letting
her be herself. No-one was letting her realize the material in the way she wanted. For me, being a
producer, thats exactly what you should be trying to do. You should let the artist bring out what
they want in the music and help them realize that in the purest form. BMG had been hooking her up
with all these producers, trying to turn her into a Bjork, or in the worst case, a Celine Dion, which is
absurd. She had a set of very quirky, very unique, semi-orchestral, semi-jazz pieces of pop music.
When I heard her demos, I said Look Anja, these are fantastic. What do you want me to do? She
said I just want someone to tell me that Im doing the right thing in the studio and to let me do it. In
a sense, all there was to do was help give her the confidence that shes going down the right road
and tell the people around her Let her do this. This is fantastic. In the process, she got away from
BMG and signed to Virgin, who were much more supportive. It became an easier process from then
on. Musically, I added various electronic treatments and some more strange things, but pretty
much, she had a very strong vision for that record. I think she felt part of the initial problem was she
was a girl and had all these guys around her telling her she should do this and that. To have herproducer say No, just fucking let her do what she wants to do is what she really needed. Im really
proud of that record. Its really unique and beautiful. I can take very little credit for it.
You were considering working with an orchestra a couple of years ago. What became of
that?
I got waylaid by my interest in metal. [laughs] I went in the opposite direction. I have cycles. I find
there are certain periods when Im interested in certain kinds of music. At this time, I am interested
in very aggressive music, notwithstanding the No-Man album, which is not very aggressive. If Im
left up to my own devices, Im leaning towards the more aggressive side of my musical personality.
I know there will come a time again when Im interested in textural music and working with quieter
musical forces.
Do you have the chops to direct an orchestra?
I dont have any musical training, so it would be a very intuitive thing. These days, its very easybecause of the technology available. Its possible to work out an orchestral arrangement in a purely
musical way by just picking out notes on a keyboard, playing them into a computer and then having
the computer print the music out for you. So, its not as if you have to know how to read or write
music or even be aware of how to score music for orchestras. I have friends who know how, so I
can go to them. In fact, on the last three albums, Ive worked with orchestral arrangers and Ive
been involved in that process as well. Theyve handled the scores and arrangements because they
know how to do that. I dont know how to do that and I dont really have any great interest to learn
either.
Are you entirely self-taught?
Pretty much. My parents sent me to piano lessons as a kid and I hated it. [laughs] I kind of forgot
about it all. I guess there was something left from that when I finally decided to be a musician. Ive
never been interested in being a musician. Ive been interested in making records. There is a verystrong distinction there. A musician is someone who will sit down and play their instrument out of
pleasure for hours at a time. I dont. I never, ever, ever pick up an instrument unless Im writing or
recording. I have no pleasure in playing the guitar or keyboards or anything. I have pleasure in
writing and recording music.
Can you read music?
No. I dont even know the names of the chords. My manager, who is a guitar player, constantly hasto tell me what chords Im playing. He finds it very amusing.
Tim once played me some very different versions of the No-Man tracks that ended up on
Together Were Stranger.I was surprised at how much more stripped down the final mixes
were.
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
9/13
It was a very gradual, organic process. I kept taking things away and it kept sounding better. It just
seemed right to keep removing things. Theres something about the simplicity of the arrangements
and the space in them. Everything we tried to add seemed to detract from it. In the end, the mixes
were very minimal and very beautiful. Theres a kind of spirituality in the music that comes from the
simplicity. Its very strange for me because Im used to working on records where theres incredible
complexity in the production and lots of overdubbing and things to work into the mix. This was the
complete opposite for me.
There were a lot of people that played on the record that were probably horrified when they heard
the final mix. [laughs] We actually only used tiny amounts of what theyve done. I remember readingan interview with Mark Hollis at the time Talk Talk had released Laughing Stock.He was talking
about how they employed a huge, whole string section and worked with them for about a week.
After the string section had left, at huge expense, they kept only one soundthe sound of the cello
player dropping his bow on the wooden floor of the studio. [laughs] I always found that quite
amusing. Part of the process of making a record is in a sense, disappearing up blind alleys and
coming back, realizing youve spent the last two weeks on something youre now quite happy to just
hit the button and erase. You realize it doesnt add anything.
In a way, all of this comes back to Peter Gabriels situation. Sometimes, you have to have the
perspective to work on something for a long time and realize what you did in the first minutes of
conceiving the song still sounds better than what youve got after two months of working on it. Tim
and I found that very often wed come up with something with just guitar, voice and keyboardtexture and it would be almost instantaneous. In 10 minutes, wed have something we could work
on. Wed have various people come in and play on it. Wed collaborate on rhythmic ideas, song
ideas and solos. Then wed look at each other after a month and say You know what? It was better
when we did it in that first 10 minutes. Wed then erase everything wed been working on for the
previous month. You have to have the ability to press a button and erase all of that work, blood,
sweat and tears. Sometimes, its heartbreaking to do, but sometimes you feel cleansed and purified
by removing these unnecessary or superfluous things.
Are you ever hesitant to tell the people
who contributed to the work that
youve erased them from the final mix?
People have got kind of upset, yeah. Ive
never fallen out with anyone over it, but
there have been a few awkward
moments. At the end of the day, you have
to be true to the record and yourself, and
make the record the best way you can.
The guy that did all the rhythm stuff on
the record was completely erased from
the record. Ultimately, he still loves the
record and feels its the right decision too,
but of course, he put a lot of work andeffort into it. This happens all the time.
What inspired you to pursue the
Blackfield collaboration with Aviv
Geffen?
First and foremost, we became friends
when Porcupine Tree played shows in
Israel in 2000. Although we are very
different as people, we nevertheless share a lot of the same influences and a strong belief that
music really was richer in the late 60s and early 70ssomething that is the foundation of the
Blackfield production and sound. Also, I became very impressed with Aviv's ability to come up with
music that had class and quality within the three minute pop song formatsomething I have alwaysfound very hard to do myself. I have great admiration for anyone who can write convincingly and
make the three minute song format their own. So, I wanted to bring Aviv's songwriting talent to
people outside of his relatively small Hebrew-speaking audience.
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
10/13
What is Avivs experience as a professional musician in Israel like given all of the political
mayhem afoot?
Aviv is certainly a very famous figure in Israel, loved by many, but also disliked by some as a
representative of Israeli counterculturewhatever that may be. His work is totally bound up with his
politics and criticism of the Israeli government and military. I have seen him abused and threatened
on the street a few times, but more often I have seen girls fainting in his presence and young
people wanting to thank him for his music and his inspiration. Aviv is considered to be one of the
most important and influential musicians in Israel.
You recently released a Web-only CD single featuring a cover of Alanis Morissettes Thank
You. What made you want to record that song?
I have this plan to release a series of cover versions in the style of good, old-fashioned seven-inch
singles where you basically cut two tracks very quickly in the studio and in a few weeks they are
available in a kind of generic, no-artwork, single-style, double-A-side package. I still love that whole
seven-inch single thing and the fact that you can cut two tracks and have it on the market so
quickly. With the cover version thing, each disc will have a cover version and the B-side, if you will,
will be one of my own compositions that somehow relates to the cover version. The cover versions I
want to do are all going to be songs that people would never, ever, ever imagine that Id want to do.
The reason I wanted to do that is that some bands do cover versions of songs you think are just so
obvious, that its pointlesslike Sepultura covering Black Sabbath or Oasis covering The Beatles.They do it so faithfully because they are so in awe of the originals.
As Ive proven with Tim and No-Man, we pick cover versions that we take to completely different
areas. Theres a group of songs I have in mind that people dont give enough attention to as great
songs. For whatever reason, the original artist recording them is not considered to be a great
songwriter. Alanis Morissette is one of those artists. She gets treated with disdain by the music
industry and a lot of music lovers, mainly because of the things shes said and done. She seems to
be slightly dismissed. I think the song Thank You is fantastic. I wanted to represent it in a
completely different context so people would reevaluate it. The whole series of cover version EPs
will feature songs that fall in that categorysongs people dismiss out of hand. The next one Ill
probably do will be ABBAs The Day Before You Came. Its one of their last songs ever and its
one of the saddest, most beautiful songs ever written. When I say ABBA, most people laugh, just asyoure doing now.
I dont dismiss ABBA. Im not about to buy an eight-CD ABBA boxed set, but I acknowledge
theyre responsible for some very culturally important music.
Thats more than most people will admit, I have to tell you. The other thing about the cover version
EPs is that I didnt even tell people what the song was. The record was just called Cover Version.
During the first few seconds of listening to it, I thought perhaps there had been a mix-up at
the pressing plant and that I was listening to another artist. I said to myself Oh dear, its
defective.
[laughs hysterically] I like that. You dont actually know what the song is until you get the CD. I knowif I had announced what that song was, there would be immediate prejudice against the song and
questions like Why the hell have you done this? Why have you covered Alanis Morissette? Why
doesnt he do something good? [laughs] I know I would have got that, not from everyone, but there
would be a core of the fans that would find something to complain about. Im pretty sure if I had told
people what it was, there would have been people who wouldnt have bothered buying it or would
have complained that I should be covering obscure artists, not these major, mainstream, multi-
platinum selling artists. They would have missed the point that its a great song I and I felt I could do
something with it that that would put a different slant on it, which I think I did. I hope Alanis
Morissette gets to hear it. I changed one line of the lyrics because I couldnt understand it. I hope
she wouldnt be offended by that.
Youre very well known for your penchant for releasing a flurry of severely limited editionreleases, to the sheer delight and frustration of your fans. Tell me about the philosophy
behind these releases.
In terms of the volume of material, thats really because of the range of musical interests I have. At
the same time I might be working on a Porcupine Tree record, I might be making some completely
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
11/13
ambient, textural music with Bass Communion. Its very important to me to have these different
musical personalities I can go to on any given day. Thats probably the reason there are so many
records. Porcupine Tree make a record every two years now, but between every Porcupine Tree
record, there will be things like singles, EPs, demos, outtakes and live recordings which get added
to the discography. Fans seem to want this stuff. I enjoy releasing these things if they merit release.
There are always occasions when you feel theres something that should come out but its not for
everyone. In those situations, youll decide to do it as a limited edition, so that once the hardcore
fans have picked it up, it wont go beyond that.
A good example is the Porcupine Tree XM LiveCD which was a live in-the-studio broadcast wemade at a Washington-based satellite radio station. We wanted to make it available because it is a
good quality recording, even though it doesnt have the atmosphere of a proper live recording. We
decided to make it available in a limited edition of 1,500 copies. What happens when you make a
limited edition is the hardcore fans find about it first, so theyre the ones that snap it up. Theres no
danger the casual buyer who browses in Tower Records will pick up XM Liveinstead of In Absentia.
Another reason I do this is Ive always loved the philosophy of limited editions and the more elusive,
indulgent releases. Im very much a music fan myself. Im a collector of music and a lot of the acts
Im drawn to are very obscure and underground. Some of their releases are very limited and you
almost get into this mentality like the art world, where if a painter creates a painting, it becomes a
very unique, original piece and only one person can own it. Theres an exclusive thing about that.
With some of my releases, Ive tried to go down that route of making something very limited.Theres something more precious to the collector about owning something so limited. I speak for
myself here as a music collector. I love picking up something thats a limited edition of 300 copies.
Ive got a Muslimgauze four-LP box set and its limited to 300 numbered copies. Its one of the most
precious things that I own. Its not like owning a CD you can pick up at a High Street store anytime
you need. So, I guess Ive tried to perpetuate that collector mentality within my own catalog. I love
doing those limited things. Same thing with vinyl. Im a big vinyl fan. And with vinyl, you have to
make things limited because there isnt a big enough market not to.
I find it curious that youre
remastering and remixing portions of
the Porcupine Tree back catalog much
in the same way major labels areapproaching records made 20 to 50
years ago.
I think everyone is doing it now. Its not
just what major labels are doing with old
catalogs. The process of remastering and
reevaluating is speeding up. For example,
theres an artist I like from the 90s called
Momus and his albums are about to be
reissued with bonus tracks. Also, as
recently as five or six years ago, I didntreally know what I was doing with
mastering. I didnt know how to make the
best possible transfer from the master
tapes to CD. When I listen to the remaster
of Signifyor Coma Divine,compared to
those from five or six years ago, the
difference is phenomenal. Maybe fans
dont care so much about that, but for me,
this has been a really good opportunity to
make the albums sound much better.
As for the bonus material, unfortunately, we live in a world where it is very difficult to get things intorecord stores. One of the only ways to get things into the stores and reactivate catalog a lot of the
time is to do whats called add extra value to the records. In other words, add extra tracks or
change the packaging. In a sense, I do feel embarrassed about having to do that, only five or six
years from the original album being released, but its the only way to get them to restock it. In my
own defense, when we do this, we try to give very good quality in terms of the extra value stuff.
8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
12/13
With Signify,theres a whole extra album of songs, most of which werent included on the final
album. They sound good. Its not like they are four track demos. Theyre not far off from finished
masters. So, Im sure people will be happy to have them.
I must admit, Im a terrible revisionist. I feel like my knowledge of recording and sound has come on
so much in the last 10 years that when I listen to things I did even five years ago, I really feel like
want to go back and remix and redo them. I do that a lot. I dont know if fans get pissed off at it, but
I cant help it. One of the first Porcupine Tree albums, Up the Downstair,which is about 10 years
old, has been deleted. Its going to be reissued and virtually re-recorded because I hate it. When I
listen to that record. I think These are good songs and performances, but God, I hate thosecheesy drum machines and samples! The reason I did that at the time was because I couldnt
afford to go to a real studio and have a real drummer. So, Id spend hours and hours programming
drum machines to emulate what a real drummer would do, but of course, it never sounds the same.
Now, I want to go back into the studio and remix and re-record parts of the album with a real
drummer. At the end of the day, you have to be true to yourself as an artist and I really want to do
this.
The Up the Downstairre-release really cant be categorized as a reissue then, can it?
No. Its a new recording. A lot of the elements will still be the same. It will have the same vocal
performances and guitar parts, but its a complete overhaul of that record. The original version is
being withdrawn permanently, so its almost replacing that record with a new version.I understand the No-Man back catalog will be revisited in the future as well.
I hope so, yeah. The first few No-Man records have been unavailable for many years. If you look on
eBay, youll see people bidding large amounts of money to get those records, so there is a need to
reissue that material. Of course, in the process of reissuing that material, there are opportunities for
us to remix, remaster and improve the sound and perhaps correct some of the decisions we felt
were wrong at the time. One Little Indian were very much pushing No-Man towards coming up with
radio friendly singles, as is always the record companys desire. So, we made some very bad
decisions at the time. We took tracks off the records that we felt were better than tracks we put on
them because we were forced to include more commercially viable material. We now have an
opportunity to reevaluate that whole era and extend the records with material that was just as good,
if not better, than the material released at the time. We can also put everything in context to try and
tell a story about where we were at that time in our lives. It was the first time we had a record deal,
so like a lot of musicians, we made decisions we regret, artistic and otherwise.
As you mentioned, some of the rarer CDs you've released are fetching astonishing amounts
of money in collector's circles. What do you make of the obsessive behavior your work is
inspiring?
On one hand I understand it because I myself am obsessive about collecting music. But on the
other hand, it is of course bizarre for anyone to become the object of such obsessive behavior, and
part of me is still astonished that even one person would want to pay money for one of my records.
I like to release a lot of limited editions in a variety of formats because it's fun for collectors. It's also
pissed a lot of people off, but I can't help thatI always see the way I choose to release my musicas just as much a part of my artistic personality as the music itself. One thing I have almost always
striven for is to have a totally unique personality as an artist which extends to every aspect of my
work. This is becoming increasingly rare these days. I think of people like Zappa, Bjork, Neil Young
and Aphex Twin, as these artists inspire obsessive collecting because there is no-one else who can
give their fans the same experience. How many generic nu-metal, old-metal, R&B, trip hop, hip-
hop, indie, progressive and techno artists can say the same thing? Fans of these kinds of artists
can move on to a thousand others with an almost identical sound and ideology in a second. So in
that sense, I'm proud that the work inspires such loyalty among collectors. It must mean Im doing
something right.
Websites:Porcupine Tree
Steven Wilson
http://www.swhq.co.uk/http://www.porcupinetree.com/8/10/2019 Www Innerviews Org Inner Ptree
13/13
Copyright 1994-2014 Anil Prasad. All content licensed under a Creative CommonsAttribution,
No Derivatives license.
Site design and development by COLOR:GRAY// Powered by ExpressionEngine
http://www.colorgray.net/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/3.0/deed.en_US