[email protected]Improving Internal Communications at the City of Morgantown Susan Sullivan IMC 637 Week 9 Final Assignment Your final project for this course is to write an 810 page paper (i.e. case study) auditing the internal branding and communication efforts of a company or other organization of your choice. The organization should be one that you feel either needs to seriously revamp its internal branding and communication efforts or has recently faced a major external crisis and needs to develop a new internal communications program as a result. This could be a large, wellknown company or a lesser known, smaller one.For example, the company could have recently acquired another organization or fended off an acquisition. They may have recently faced or be about to face a major labor dispute. They may be dealing with new government regulation or facing major challenges because of the volatile economy. Perhaps they’ve had a recent change in senior management or just faced an acute crisis situation such as those described in Lesson 6. Spring 14
45
Embed
WVU IMC 637: Internal Communications Plan for the City of Morgantown, WV
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
S s u l l i v 5 @ m i x . w v u . e d u
Improving Internal Communications at the City of Morgantown Susan Sullivan -‐ IMC 637 -‐ Week 9 Final Assignment Your final project for this course is to write an 8-‐10 page paper (i.e. case study) auditing the internal branding and communication efforts of a company or other organization of your choice. The organization should be one that you feel either needs to seriously revamp its internal branding and communication efforts or has recently faced a major external crisis and needs to develop a new internal communications program as a result. This could be a large, well-‐known company or a lesser known, smaller one.For example, the company could have recently acquired another organization or fended off an acquisition. They may have recently faced or be about to face a major labor dispute. They may be dealing with new government regulation or facing major challenges because of the volatile economy. Perhaps they’ve had a recent change in senior management or just faced an acute crisis situation such as those described in Lesson 6.
Spring 14
08 Fall
Contents Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 3 The Industry ................................................................................................................................................................................. 3 History ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 4 Its Mission ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Strengths ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 6 Challenges ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 6 Services ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 7
Departments ................................................................................................................................................................................ 9 City Manager ................................................................................................................................................................................ 9 City Council ................................................................................................................................................................................. 10 City Clerk ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 11 Legal .............................................................................................................................................................................................. 12 Finance ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 13 Human Resources .................................................................................................................................................................... 13 Development Services Department .................................................................................................................................. 14 Public Works/Streets ............................................................................................................................................................. 16 Engineering ................................................................................................................................................................................ 16 Urban Landscapes ................................................................................................................................................................... 17 Public Communications ........................................................................................................................................................ 17 Other Agencies .......................................................................................................................................................................... 19 Current/Past Internal Communications ....................................................................................................................... 24
Downloadable Assessment Tool ...................................................................................................................................... 31 Point 1: Lack of Intranet/One place for all employee information ................................................................... 33 Solution ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 33
Point 2: No correlation between internal messaging and external messaging and branding creates two different pictures of the City: the view for Employees, and the view for citizens ............................. 34 Solution ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 34
Point 3: Employees lack assurance they are being fully informed .................................................................... 35 Solution ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 35
The Team .................................................................................................................................................................................... 37 Measurement ............................................................................................................................................................................ 38 Timeline ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 39 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................ 40 Works Cited .......................................................................................................................................... 42
Introduction The City of Morgantown’s Public
Communications Department (Office 16), an extension
of the City Manager’s Department, exists to efficiently
inform the public of news, events, and programs available for citizens. However, the City’s
in-‐house organization lacks any kind of internal communication, and could be improved
with slight changes that would make everyone more productive.
Leadership will need to improve online presence, coordinate internal and external
messaging, and reassure employees that they will know everything to come in order to
create this improved system. Forward is a look into the City, how each department
communicates, research into possible avenues, and assessment on what points are found
that need to be addressed most.
No plan is complete without a timeline for implementation, which is also included in
order to provide a path to success.
The Industry The Municipal Government industry must be highly reactive in order to keep up
with the demands of today’s society and community, but often decreased budgets and a
higher demand for citizen satisfaction can slow progress. Morgantown is not unlike any
other municipal government – striving to stay ahead of citizens needs with an increasingly
smaller revenue stream. Here are how each Department aims to work for its residents,
visitors, and businesses, and how it interacts with others internally.
History Morgantown was built around the great Monongalia River, whose name means,
“falling banks” in the native tongue of the Indians who lived in this area. The river brought
flatboats, and with them, men looking for a place to make whiskey.
Col. Zackquill Morgan, the area’s first white settler, founded Morgan’s Town in 1785.
There is currently fundraising going on to erect a bronze statue of Col. Morgantown in front
of the Public Safety Building. (Some outlets report that it will be placed at the Hazel Ruby
McQuain Waterfront Park, but that’s since changed.)
The University was founded in 1867 under the Morril Land-‐Grant Colleges Act as the
Agricultural College of West Virginia. It played a big part in Morgantown not being taken
by the Confederates during the Civil War.
Its Mission CITY
Mission: To provide outstanding municipal services and support to the citizens,
residents, businesses, and institutions of the City of Morgantown based upon the
priorities of the City Manager and City Council.
Vision: To develop a City Staff capable of continuous improvement through
performance measures (metrics) driven data and visionary proactive leadership. To
provide a well-‐trained and professional staff thoroughly capable of meeting the needs
of the citizens, businesses, and higher learning institutions of Morgantown; based upon
the priorities established by the City Manager and City Council.
CORE VALUES
Public service is our purpose – It is why we are here. We commit to provide
competent, dependable, and efficient services to all by knowing our job duties,
responsibilities, and our City.
Mutual Respect – We will give professional and courteous service to our citizens,
visitors, and customers. We will act professionally toward our co-‐workers,
subordinates, and superiors and maintain respect and courtesy in all our operations
and dealings.
We will act ethically (we will not lie, cheat, or steal) or tolerate this behavior. – We
deal ethically in all situations and bring inconsistency to the attention of leadership
wherever it exists. We must also demand high quality products and services from
suppliers and contractors as they represent the City of Morgantown.
We will strive to analyze business practices for accuracy and thoroughness and
work to make them as fair and simple as possible.
We value and expect tactful, useful, informative and honest communication among
ourselves and with our community. Listening to the needs of our citizens is critical
to the communication and problem solving process.
PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS OFFICE
Mission: To inform the public of news, information, events, and programs available
to them from the City Government. To help the City’s departments and facilities
identify what information and messages need to be conveyed to Morgantown’s
diverse audiences in the most effective manner possible. To promote what makes
Morgantown the great community that it is and to celebrate the successes of City
government, our residents, businesses, visitors, and institutions. To act as a liaison
and spokesperson for the City, reaching a hand to anyone who works closely with
the City and those looking to make connections with us.
Vision: To raise the level of knowledge and awareness of City news, information,
events, and programs so that each citizens is armed with the knowledge they need
to be a productive and informed resident, business, or institution. To foster a sense
of community between the City government and its residents, visitors, and
businesses. To increase the activity that strengthens bonds between Morgantown
and WVU. To adequately measure performance using metrics.
Strengths
Low Employee Turnover – Many of those working at City Hall and the Public Safety
Building in an administrative capacity have been employees of the City for some time. This
established base helps to strengthen the work done at the city because departments aren’t
constantly retraining new employees.
Challenges
Finances -‐ When the last City Manager left, Administrators discovered that money
through to be in a Contingency Account was not actually allocated – and we had much less
in our coffers than so thought. He kind of left us in a tough place to discover this after he
left so quickly. In response, Interim (and now acting) City Manager Jeff Mikorski did not
take a pay raise with his new position; City employees were not given a quality-‐of-‐life
adjustment at the beginning of the 2013-‐2014 Fiscal Year (July); we are currently in a
hiring freeze, except to replace those who leave us; and a Assistant City Manager of
Operations was hired who has a strong history of fiscal responsibility and also experience
turning tight budgets around. In February, the 2013-‐2014 FY Budget was presented. In the
transmittal letter, written by Mikorski, these financial considerations are presented, which
all reflect the need to stabilize the City’s budget:
• No levels of service are expected to be reduced for the 2013-‐2014 budget year. • The Hiring Freeze remains in effect. • The City will take on the cost of one Police Officer to the personnel costs due to
grant expiration. • A smaller-‐than-‐expected carryover from fiscal year 2012-‐2013 should be expected
since revenues in December 2012 were not as high as projected in the first six months of the 2012-‐2013 Budget.
• A payment of $153,000 of a million-‐dollar capital lease will need to be paid in 2013-‐2014.
• The City can’t accurately estimate what Mon County Property Tax assessments will be.
• Non-‐civil service employee pension contributions will not change this year. • Employee Health Insurance Contributions will go up by 4%. • Contributions to the Police & Fire Pension program will increase by 7%. • The City will experience a reduction of $276,000 in Wine & Liquor Tax collections
due to appeals last year. • City cannot afford to provide cost-‐of-‐living adjustments (COLA) for employees this
year. • A ten-‐percent increase (approx. $200,000) in Fire Service Fees is suggested to
increase funding for the Fire Department.
Services The City provides these services, detailed in the aforewritten pages, to its residents:
• Trash & Recycling • Housing Assistance • Downtown Business District Organization & Promotion • Public Works • Code Enforcement • Public Safety (Police & Fire Services)] • Municipal Court proceedings • Bicycle efforts • Green efforts • Urban landscape beautification • Information services • Trash & Recycling Services • Parking Services
o 2,022 Spaces o Permits o Garages
• Parks & Recreation Venues • Library
o Book/eBook rental • Air Transportation • Business Services
o Licensing o Fire Fees o Business & Occupation Taxes
• Streets & Signals Service & Maintenance • Development Services
o Plan approval o Variance approval
6/5/14
Trash & Recycling • Housing Assistance • Downtown Business District
Organization & Promotion • Public Works • Code Enforcement • Public Safety (Police & Fire
Services)] • Municipal Court proceedings • Bicycle efforts • Green efforts • Urban landscape beautification • Information services • Trash & Recycling Services • Parking Services
o 2,022 Spaces
o Permits o Garages
• Parks & Recreation Venues • Library
o Book/eBook rental • Air Transportation • Business Services
o Licensing o Fire Fees o Business & Occupation Taxes
• Streets & Signals Service & Maintenance
• Development Services o Plan approval o Variance approval
Departments
City Manager The City Manager’s office houses the City Manager, Assistant City Manager of
Operations, and an Administrative Secretary. It is where all calls to City Hall ring.
Typically, if a resident wanders in with a question, it would be their destination.
• The City Manager, if not in a meeting, is always available to all residents, media,
business owners, etc. He manages the day-‐to-‐day operations of the departments
and how they work with outside agencies and influences, including WVU, Utilities,
Transportations, and State and County government.
• The Assistant City Manager of Operations was hired in March 2013 and serves to
make the City more efficient internally.
• Executive Team – The Executive Team convenes each Monday morning at 10 a.m.
These meetings serve as the trendsetter for the week, and have come increasing
more important as the City looks to balance its budget in the 2013-‐2014 Fiscal Year.
10
The City Manager’s office houses the City Manager, Assistant City Manager of
Operations, and an Administrative Secretary. It is where all calls to City Hall ring.
Typically, if a resident wanders in with a question, it would be their destination.
City Council City Council is the governing and legislative body for the municipal government of
the City of Morgantown. It is comprised of seven representatives from seven wards
(Sypolt, 2014). It meets in a regular capacity on the first and third Tuesdays of the month,
at 7 p.m. in Council Chambers.
Council Member Phone Ron Bane -‐ First Ward ([email protected]) 304-‐376-‐5518
release and all pertinent information is shared on our website, through social media,
and Channel 15, if applicable.
• eNewsletters: The City sends two main eNewsletters: one monthly that is addressed
to Neighborhood Associations and like-‐minded residents who want news
specifically for their part of town, and a Morgantown News newsletter, sent the
Friday before a City Council Meeting, that updates recipients on action being taken
by Council by supplying them with an update from the last meeting and a look at
what’s coming up next.
19
• NIXLE: This email/text alert system is currently being used to advertise MUB work,
road closures, and will be used in the event of a large-‐scale disaster to reach all
residents. Signup is easy: text MORGANTOWN to 888777. The system was updated
with all employees mobile numbers at its inception, but requires updating. It is
possible to send mass text messages to all employees this way.
• COMCAST Channel 15: This Government Access Network is used to publicize
municipal programs and airs public meeting videos.
• Granicus – Live Streaming meeting video straight from Council Chambers.
• Social Media – the City of Morgantown can be found on Facebook, Twitter,
Instagram, YouTube, FourSquare, and more.
Additional information about the scope of work by the Public Communications
Manager can be found in the Fall 2013 City of Morgantown Media Guide, created for new
reporters as a comprehensive resource for information.
Stories, news, and projects are collected in Campaigns. View sample campaign
template. Campaigns can just be a news item or event, or can span and entire year, like the
Urban Deer Archery Hunt.
The Public Communications Office does not currently manage any internal
communications.
Other Agencies The remainders of those City that may come to mind operate individually from City Hall.
20
Police
The Police Department is made up of 65 sworn officers and an 11-‐civilian support
staff. It oversees 11 square miles of jurisdiction and works with the Sheriff’s Department
and WVU Police on a myriad of cases and projects.
• Police Civil Service Commission – This governing body oversees the hiring of Police
Officers.
• Special Services Division – This small group of trained officers helps to organize and
plan for municipal events, those applied for by the public, as well as managing
parade plans and working with film crews while they are filming within City Limits.
Police Chief Ed Preston has been pushing for an intranet for the Police Department
for some time now. The Police Department does use an internal software system and the
county’s emergency software to manage tasks. Email is also a large part of this.
The Police Department, just as the Fire Department, are housed in the Public Safety
Building and will not be included in an in-‐house communications plan, as it already has its
own to make up for a lack of intranet.
Fire
The Morgantown Fire Department is made up of 48 paid fire fighters and 2 civilian
administrative assistants. This department houses a Fire Marshal, the Chief, and three
firehouses strategically located throughout Morgantown.
• Fire Marshal – The Fire Marshal Division investigates fires to find their origin.
21
• Training – This arm is in charge of ensuring that all of Morgantown’s paid fire
fighters are up to snuff.
• Operations – This division manages operations on a daily basis to ensure complete
coverage at all times.
• Fire Civil Service Commission – This governing body oversees the hiring of firemen.
The Fire Department does use an internal software system and the county’s emergency
software to manage tasks. Email is also a large part of this.
The Fire Department, just as the Police Department, are housed in the Public Safety
Building and will not be included in an in-‐house communications plan, as it already has its
own to make up for a lack of intranet.
Morgantown Utility Board
The Morgantown Utility Board manages water and sewer services for the City of
Morgantown (MUB.org, 2014). Its Weekly Work Lists and Daily Road Closures are
publicized daily by the Morgantown Public Communications Office. Meetings are held and
aired live in Council Chambers on the second Tuesday of the month, at 6:30 p.m.
MUB’s Communications Manager, Chris Dale, uses social media and email alerts sent
through the City’s NIXLE Alert System (Nixle.com, 2014) to notify residents of alerts near
their home or place of employment.
Board of Parks & Recreation Commissioners (BOPARC)
BOPARC is dedicated to providing indoor and outdoor recreation to the citizens of
Morgantown, both through maintenance of parks and venues, as well as organization of
programming that encourages activity in all parts of town (BOPARC.org, 2014).
22
• Metropolitan Theatre Commission – One of the big venues that BOPARC manages is
the Metropolitan Theatre. Having recently undergone a renovation, the Met
provides all residents with a variety of shows year-‐round (MorgantownMet.com,
2014).
• Dorsey’s Knob – This Park is popular for not only the highest point in Morgantown
(and a great place to get sunset pictures), but also Dorsey’s Lodge, which is a fantast
weekend getaway, or just the right size for a small team retreat or conference.
• Hazel Ruby McQuain Amphitheatre – This Amphitheatre is the cornerstone of the
HRMcQ Park in the Wharf District. Events happen year-‐round, including the
Celebration of America on July 4, and the International Festival in September.
• Morgantown Ice Arena – Open March 7, 2014 for the season, the Morgantown Ice
Arena offers open skating, rehearsal slots and lessons, as well as houses the WVU
Hockey Team and other adult and youth teams, too.
• Marilla Park – Marilla Park is near Sabraton and has a baseball field, skate park,
tennis courts, lots of outdoor picnic areas, and Marilla Pool which features slides
and the annual Dog Splash on the last day of the season.
• Krepps Park – Krepps Park is on the other side of town in the Suncrest Area and has
picnic areas, lots of wooded acreage, Krepps Pool, and one of the two dog parks that
BOPARC also manages.
23
Solid Waste
The City contracts its waste services to Republic Services. It is currently using a
Clean Community Concept, whose enforcement called for two major changes, which you
can read about under Growth.
• Recycling: The City overhauled its services in 2013 to provide each resident with a
recycling toter (MorgantownWV.gov, 2013).
• Trash: Reorganization of billing responsibilities is helping to lower management
costs. If a rental building has 2+ occupants (and therefore two separate toters), then
responsibility for the bill is moved to the landlord, and he is then responsible for
sharing the costs of the bill within the rent costs instead of that individual tenant
having their own account and bill. This cuts back on the number of toters in front of
residences in student housing parts of town.
Morgantown Parking Authority (MPA)
The Morgantown Parking Authority manages 2,022 spaces in the downtown area
(Spencer, 2013). Its comprehensive website helps residents find somewhere to park, has
downloadable applications for permits, as well as offers billing services to pay your parking
ticket online (ParkMPA.com, 2014). It meets on the third Wednesday at 3 p.m. in the Public
Safety Building Conference Room.
Fairmont Morgantown Housing Authority (FMHA)
The FMHA helps to assist low-‐income families find and budget for housing. It also
offers Grant assistance to help improve the lives of those who have already found a place to
24
live, but can’t afford to make basic home improvements or make their home more
accessible (FMHousing.com, 2014).
Morgantown Public Library
The Morgantown Public Library provides a variety of services to the citizens of
Morgantown. It offers book and ebook rentals, Internet and printing access, book clubs,
Curiosity Quest Summer Programs, and hosts Green Nights at the Library in conjunction
with the Green Team. It has five branches across Mon County (Morgantown Public Library,
2014).
Morgantown Municipal Airport (MGW)
United Airlines provides flight services in Morgantown through the Morgantown
Municipal Airport. The airport offers 5 flights a day to Washington Dulles Airport in D.C.,
and from there, travelers can reach nearly anywhere in the world
(MorgantownAirport.com, 2014).
The Airport offers office space to a few entities, including the Morgantown
Monongalia Metropolitan Planning Organization and the National Guard Band, as well as
hangars for many private renters.
Current/Past Internal Communications
1.) Traditional, tangible hard copies of documents with attached Memos – This is the
most “official” and “most loved” way of sharing documents. There have been efforts
to “greenify” the document system, and much leeway has been made in the realm of
the vast amount of trees killed in the process of printing Council Meeting Packets for
7 Councilors, 2 City Managers, 1 City Clerk and 1 Attorney three times a
25
month. Now, only those Councilors who request hard copies are provided with
those – the majority of Council has a laptop or tablet that they use to access those
documents during a meeting.
2.) Scanned .pdfs emailed between officials/departments – This is probably the
furthest that City Hall has evolved in document sharing. Council Packets are a prime
example of these two avenues being used.
3.) “Intranet” Server – This “City Server,” or M:\ (“M Drive”), is the most the City of
Morgantown has in the way of an Intranet.
Figure 2: Screenshot of Current Intranet Server, City of Morgantown, 2014.
City Manager Jeff Mikorski reports that at one time, there actually was an internal
Internet page, but it was only up for a few months before it crashed, and the server
26
was simply created as a place to save files. It’s used to save documents for one-‐time
projects, for the most part.
27
Discussion To fully investigate the current internal communications atmosphere at the City of
Morgantown (more specifically, City Hall), one must begin with a look into each
department, provided prior to this discussion.
In addition to researching current communications in each department, I also
looked into possibilities for replacement. I signed up for, or participated in webinars
explaining, Yammer!, ActiveData, and Google Calendar.
I chose to also use an analysis tool that provided its own assessment of our current
internal communications based upon a survey completed.
Possibilities for Internal Communications Several approaches were researched and tested, including intranet, social media,
and subscription services.
Intranet For the most part, many of the City’s employees have only had experience with the
Intranet system that was briefly in place. It was managed by the Mr. Mikorski and the IT
Director, and had no input from Human Relations. It was the first and only chance at digital
internal communications that City Hall has had.
The costs associated with the Intranet trial were such that subsequent consideration
for Intranets was turned down due to the amount lost on the crashed system. Being a
government entity, the City of Morgantown attempts to operate exactly at budget, and does
well with the money that they do receive. However, internal communications is not a
priority in this regard, and money has not been allotted for this type of feature for our
employees.
28
Yammer! The City Manager and the Public Information Officer explored yammer. When gauging
employee reactions, two audiences were identified:
1. The few younger, social-‐media savvy employees immediately signed up and added
their coworkers’ emails, which in turn, invited more and more employees. It did
take off fast for a test run.
2. The older, seasoned employees responded thusly: What is this Yammer thing, and
do I have to do it?
It is clear that the majority of employees are not interested in putting time into an
entirely new service, while some of them are completely turned off by the idea of social
media. We did have ample excitement for any sort of mass communications tool for in-‐
house communications, however.
ActiveData One singular voice the City Manager’s and Public Communications office is able to
hear regularly is the use of calendars for internal communications. When a meeting is set
up in our Zimbra Email Client calendar, one can attach documents and notes. This is an
easy way for employees to share agendas for in-‐house private meetings. They contain
employees’ appointments, Public Meetings, Code Enforcement assignments, and more. It is
a system already implemented at City Hall.
Externally, Calendars are used to share events. However, we have four calendars for
the public, in addition to the 200+ we have operating inside City Hall for employees.
ActiveData gives us both public and private calendars, allowing us to consolidate all four of
29
our calendars into an interactive interface that can be used by employees and residents
alike.
Features include:
a. A Marketing Calendar with a wide variety of sharing options and third party
integration
b. Event/Volunteer Registration and Ticket Payment Options
c. Private Calendar for employees
d. Room Scheduler
e. Community Publishing Capabilities (residents can add events)
f. Calendar Sharing, iCal capabilities
Below is an excerpt from a memo to the City Manager regarding the suggestion to
use ActiveData versus other services. The entire ActiveData Memo to City Manager Jeff
Mikorski can be viewed here.
Internal Benefits - Transparency for open communications organization-‐wide - Event Conflict Avoidance - Everything found easily - Event Awareness through social media - Tip: ActiveData can auto publish to social media when added to a calendar - Increase Event Exposure when everyone goes to same calendar for everything - Reduce Administrative time associated with data entry
Calendar Toolbox: - Quickly create code and URLs – make the web team more efficient - Persistently send and receive info from 3rd party apps - Easy-‐to-‐use form to put in information for internal & external (Sullivan,
2014).
30
While this obviously isn’t an Intranet, or social media, this does seem to be a much
better fit for employees. The general feeling from the majority of employees is that they
don’t want to have to “sign in and check stuff all the time.” They have operated so long
without having to check anything but email and personal calendars (which could be in
Zimbra, Google, our physical desktop calendars, our phones, etc. etc.) that employees just
aren’t willing to do it anymore. The only person with access to the room-‐scheduling
calendar is the City Manager’s secretary, inaccessible to other employees.
WebEvent is the current for our City Calendar, and it utilizes html, and can only
show one calendar at a time. ActiveData is different. Visitors, outsiders, community
members, administrators and employees don’t want to have to check these three calendars
separately – a concise, easy-‐to-‐use calendar with alert notifications, event submission, and
personalization. It has a private calendar on which employees can post blood drives, City
birthdays, internal meetings like the Monday Morning Executive Team meetings, and you
can set up alerts for any meetings that use a specific word in the title, so you never miss a
planning meeting, even if you didn’t sign up to get alerts for that particular meeting on that
specific day.
ActiveData is definitely not social media – it certainly doesn’t carry the “social media
intimidation factor” that Yammer has on our older employees – but it is an integration of
the traditional shared calendar system and shared access to avenues that already exist, like
being able to simply add an event to the public calendar, then it automatically
(“persistently” [Sullivan, pp. 2]) sends updated information to everyone who has the
calendar shared with their iPhone calendar, Tweets, and posts to a calendar feed on our
website. Citizens can add the agenda for everyone inside and outside of City Hall, and that
31
ensures that both audiences are talking about the same things and are all on the same page
when it comes to municipal activity. In addition, this will appeal to both categories of
employees: the younger, social-‐savvy crowd, who no doubt tries new apps and services on
a regular basis, will eagerly learn the ins and outs quickly, while the opposite crowd doesn’t
have to sign up for social media, and doesn’t have to ADD a responsibility – simply replace
the calendar method they use, and the Public Communications Manager can take care of the
sharing to everyone inside and out.
NIXLE A communications tool that is used for external communications would also make a
great internal communications tool. NIXLE, our text and email alert system (see Public
Communications), is used to send text alerts to any citizen who sends a keyword to a
dedicated six-‐digit number. Employees and department heads are already programmed
into the system for emergency notifications.
Newsletters Another external communications tool that the Public Communications Manager
uses is the newsletter. Two are currently sent: one as a news-‐based, City Council-‐centric
semi-‐weekly enewsletter, and another, a neighborhood-‐association focused monthly
enewsletter (See Public Communications).
Downloadable Assessment Tool
This Internal Communications Assessment Tool, a Microsoft Excel template
downloaded from the website of McLean & Company (2014), provided me with these
results, after filling out a roughly 75 question survey, including questions about Human
32
Relations, Business Communications, Change Communications, Culture & Events,
Knowledge Sharing, and Crisis Communications (McLean & Company, 2014).
Results are as follows:
Figure 3: Current Internal Communications Assessment, McLean & Co, 2014.
While City employees have been relatively satisfied with the current methods, the complete
lack of an internal communications plan brings up three strong points that need to be
addressed:
• Each employee uses their own method of communication/No one place for
information for employees
• Internal Messaging does not reflect external messaging or branding
• Employees are notified once, at the same time, about upcoming changes.
33
All three of these cause an inconsistency in internal communications that cannot be
corrected without a cohesive approach.
Point 1: Lack of Intranet/One place for all employee information The City Manager manages his calendars on his Samsung G4, and saves documents
from HR on his personal server. The City Manager’s secretary manages the City Manager’s
meeting schedule, as well as the City Hall Council Chambers Room Reservation calendar in
our Zimbra email client. We all have remote calendars for our desktops, which can be
shared. The Public Communications Manager keeps her schedule on her desk calendar in
paper and ink, and saves her employee information in hard copies at her desk. These are
only a few examples of how each employee uses their own methods to keep their day
organized.
The problem with this is that there isn’t a single location that all employees can
access information. For our current Zimbra email/calendar system, calendar sharing
requires approval, and not everyone is willing to share his or her calendars. Also, there is
no “home page” to which employee documents, news, social media, or discussions can take
place, so each employee must receive the document individually, creating 50+ copies of the
same file on our servers when it goes out to employees and they all save it in a different
place. Having the document in one central location on our server, and then emailing to
notify about its presence, would be a much more efficient use of email to distribute
information without fatiguing our infrastructure.
Solution For this, a combination of internal server and Active Data might be sought. Linking
meetings with details on where they can find further files in-‐house on the City Server (The
34
M:/ Drive”) is possible, as well as a more through utilization of the server by all
departments.
Having all events in one place will help to reduce errors, as each employee won’t
have to put it in their own calendar, which is compatible with smartphone calendar
systems.
Point 2: No correlation between internal messaging and external messaging and branding creates two different pictures of the City: the view for Employees, and the view for citizens
The Public Communications Office came about in 2011, long after internal
messaging had time to develop. Although there isn’t much, what can be said is that it has
not changed since the Public Communications office came to be, and it has developed
external messaging and a standardized brand identity since then. However, there is not
much to be applied to.
Solution ActiveData can also make sure that all citizens and employees are viewing the same
special events, public meeting, inclusive community, and neighborhood association
calendars, and that creates a transparent cohesiveness – the feeling that everyone in the
City, inside and out, is on the same page.
Newsletters are used to communicate recent website news to the public, but unless
employees are going there on a regular basis, they do not get direct exposure to the
information that we send externally. To change this, an enewsletter can be created that can
help to send the same messages internally as externally. It can also include content such as
employee anniversaries, birthdays, and celebrations.
35
Point 3: Employees lack assurance they are being fully informed The Public Communications Manager recently took her paycheck downstairs to
Finance to report a miscalculation on her paycheck. It appeared as though her wages were
incorrectly calculated. However, she was flabbergasted to discover that she had gotten a
raise.
“Remember, that bump was supposed to go into effect for us this paycheck,” said the
payroll manager.
“What bump?”
“The raise we’re getting to replace our loss of COLA [cost of living allowances] from
last year. Don’t you remember the email?”
In fact, she didn’t – she didn’t know a raise was even on the way. This office
operates so closely with the City Manager’s office that sometimes it is assumed to know
things that are to be announced.
This is just one situation in which communications could be improved. How do you
build confidence back that you are going to be aware that a change is coming?
Solution Creating a communications tree and following it – instead of depending on Department
Heads to inform all other employees, including those who are not in a department, of the
changes to come.
Preparing employees for future implementation of this ActiveData program is crucial to
making sure it is well received.
1.) Initially inform well, and keep employees informed along the way. Surprising
employees the day of implementation is not a method that is going to be
36
successful. “Both upper management and end user employees must understand the
need for and advantages of the new system,” says Sarah White, who fully believes in
planning from the beginning and keeping everyone informed. Technology cannot
function without the end user (White, 2011), so its important that everyone knows how
to use the system, understands their role in its execution, and follows through with
interacting on a regular basis. In addition, giving the employees a way to help plan and
implement the system can also encourage them to “accept and adapt“ to the changes
(White, 2011).
2.) Implement game changers aggressively. John Mehrmann suggests that a company
should take an aggressive approach to implementing a system that will give the
company a competitive edge, much like a bank putting an ATM outside to allow
customers to self-‐serve (2014). This ActiveData system will work exactly like this ATM,
giving employees all the ability to enter their own meetings into a calendar everyone
can see, sharing a private event with department heads, or allowing employees to share
an upcoming community event to their personal Facebook page to share with friends
and family: that’s right, giving the City a competitive edge.
3.) Make Major changes slowly, and minor changes quickly (Merhmann, 2014). If we
are simply upgrading our web page, this can be done quickly, as it affects only a few
employees who manage their pages. However, changing a calendar system so that
everyone can benefit is going to be approached slowly, preparing employees, then
executed quickly, and then be prepared to troubleshoot or answer questions for a
period afterwards. Time cannot be wasted after you make the initial announcement;
losing momentum due to delays can do more harm than good (Mehrmann, 2014).
37
4.) Get support of Leadership to help drive employees’ feelings. In City Hall,
Department Heads trust the City Manager. They have all been working together for a
long time, years and years before Mr. Mikorski moved from Grant Writer/Assistant City
Manager to City Manager in 2013. They also share similar values, political views, and
recreation. Getting Mr. Mikorski’s support for the project and having his “face” on the
efforts will definitely ensure that I can gain support for the communications change
(White, 2011).
While these new measures incorporate a calendar system that is relatively intuitive, it is
still possible that not all employees are satisfied with the changes. Rob Bernshteyn, CEO
for Coupa, which provides cloud management solutions for companies like Amazon & Rent-‐
A-‐Center, offers these tips for increasing the viability of new technology in the workplace
(2011):
• Select intuitive products. • Follow the 80/20 rule. • Deploy to “friends” first. • Sell it hard. • Keep reiterating.
NIXLE can be used to send reminders and alerts, links to additional information, and
more to increase the flow of information to employees.
Who is going to do this?
The Team While hiring a dedicated internal communications manager may not be plausible,
given the City’s current financial situation, it may be possible to achieve this with the help
of a few employees on a team. This would include:
-‐ Human Resources Director -‐ City Manager’s Secretary
38
-‐ City Clerk -‐ Public Communications Manager -‐ Deputy Finance Director -‐ Code Enforcement presence -‐ Overseen by the Assistant City Manager
By implementing a plan with each of them in charge of a specific task, even if it is
just gathering content, little effort can be given by a dedicated few brand advocates to
provide all employees with a way to stay engaged with all branches of our government.
Measurement In the Internal Communications Team’s Plan, it will map certain numbers to show that it is successfully implementing systems that improve internal communications. To Track Point 1: Intranet/Server
Measure usage of City Server: Quarterly survey question during first year of Active Data implementation
Provided all Department Heads with FAQ for implementation, pre-‐implementation/First Quarter
Get response back from each department about preferred way to add to calendar (self-‐addition versus submitting event to team for submission), Second Quarter
Track submissions per category, Monthly Successfully have ActiveData Fully Implemented, Fourth Quarter
Point 2: Correlation between Internal and External Communications Successfully transfer calendar data to new ActiveData Calendar, pre-‐implementation/First Quarter
Measure consistency between external and internal newsletters (include news in both, not just external), monthly
Measure ease of use with Quarterly survey question
Point 3: Assurance of Knowledge Create Communications Tree so all can be informed, First Quarter Measure internal brand confidence with Quarterly survey question Keep track of number of internal communications sent and measure against how many employees believe they were informed of, Quarterly survey question Measure effectiveness of NIXLE alerts with reports on clicks, reads, reach.
39
Timeline
40
Conclusion While there is no dialogue in an online sense, employees are relatively open with
each other, and will address issues in a hallway meeting or by “walk-‐in appointment.” Due
to the nature of proximity to each other, as well as a long tenure of working together, the
administration largely knows how to communicate business issues. However, there is no
sense of community between the department heads and those who exist below them –
clerks, tellers, street workers, and janitor. There are many conversations and ideas that
would be useful to other departments if they were aware of them. Canceling duplication of
efforts could save time. The City’s departments might work better together if all employees
could see programs and projects from other departments in action.
This is one reason Yammer would have been such a visual solution. Different
“communities” could be made to address different issues and projects and responsibilities
and teams. However, ActiveData also does this, as Planning is able to see meetings that also
apply to the Neighborhood Association and the Pedestrian Safety Board, as well as the next
event to happen in that part of town (oh, during construction – let’s move it) without the
social media intimidation factor. Those employees who do enjoy social media can share a
story that they would not have seen if they weren’t looking directly at the news feed going
out to the public.
In addition, notifications can be sent from NIXLE, the City’s text and email alert
system. With it already existing and capable, this would be a great way to quickly send
employees communications – enewsletter urls, fun facts, and event notifications.
However, none of this will be possible with a plan – and this plan means nothing
without commitment (Smith, 2012, p. 25). “…They give people a sense of ownership of the
41
goals and the strategies to get there – even if those goals and plans weren’t their idea in the
first place” (Smith, p. 25). People are more likely to enjoy their own ideas, ideas created by
their department or office, rather than those fed to them by someone to whom they do not
relate. In the end, they are more committed to the idea of City Hall as a community, built
upon the foundation of our missions and goals.
42
Works Cited Bernshteyn, Rob. (14 Jul 2011). How To Get Employees To (Really) Use New Technology.