Writing, Submitting and Defending your Thesis

Writing, Submitting and Defending your Thesis

Writing your thesis

What does a thesis look like?

• Literature review (Chapter 1), empirical chapters (normally 4-ish), conclusions

• A PhD makes “a novel contribution to understanding”

• There are huge differences between areas of research (longitudinal, neuroimaging). No such thing as a ‘model’ thesis!– How to ‘package’ your experiments

How do I know if I have done enough?

• Your supervisor/TAP are the best guide• Look at other theses in your area• You can present all the steps that were

required – pilot testing, experiments that didn’t work and led to a change in method

• Small is beautiful! Please note: there is a word limit of 80,000 words excluding references for a PhD thesis in this department.

• Collections of theses are available electronically at:– White Rose depository:

http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/– British Library: http://ethos.bl.uk/– And there are older ones in the library

Planning your writing

• Work out what is needed (in detail)• Have a plan with timings attached• Discuss with your supervisor– Your plan must be realistic; revise it as you go– There will be a lot of rewriting and rethinking to

do – this can take a lot of time

Surviving

• Writing a thesis can be stressful• But tackling small chunks is enough to succeed– Keep going, day after day

• Find your best time of day; keep it clear of distractions

What coping mechanisms do you use?

Coping• Identify sources of support – practical and

emotional• Find a writing buddy• If you get stressed, take time out– But then come back to the task feeling refreshed;

don’t avoid difficult bits• Set yourself realistic targets and stop work

when you reach them• Bullet points fluent writing later editing

Know your examiners!

• You will choose an external examiner with your supervisor– Who would you like to know about your work? – Who will you feel comfortable with?– Do this in plenty of time: 6+ months before viva

• You’ll be asked about your preference for the internal examiner too

Know your examiners!

• Ensure you have referred to all relevant work by your examiners in your thesis

• Think about possible implications of your work for them and vice versa

Submitting your thesis

Submission

• Know your deadline – within 4 years for f/t students– Suspension of registration

• Notification of intention to submit (2 months before)

Submission

• Check University regulations carefully– https://www.york.ac.uk/students/studying/manag

e/research-students/theses-dissertations/– http://www.york.ac.uk/about/organisation/govern

ance/corporate-publications/ordinances-and-regulations/regulation-2/#2.7

• You can use a proof-reading service (Louise has a list)

Responsibilities

• You must get your supervisor’s approval before you submit

• The internal examiner will organise the viva: triggered by intention to submit form

• Viva might not be for several months after submission

Your viva

What is a viva like?

• Normally lasts 1½ - 2 hours • Often in internal examiner’s office• Examiners will have lots of notes and bookmarks

in your thesis – don’t be put off• You can bring notes too but you probably won’t

use them• Can be highly enjoyable• Examiners should not tell you the outcome during

the viva – they will ask you to wait

What is a viva for?

• Opportunity to demonstrate that you know a lot about the topic – Qs about literature

• Examiners need to be convinced that you have ownership of the thesis – Qs about detailed methods

• Think on your feet about interpretation– Don’t be defensive

What is the most important finding you obtained during your PhD work?

If you could change one thing, what would it be?

Outcome of viva

• Pass• Pass with minor corrections (2 months)• Thesis referred– Revise and resubmit

• Downgrade to MPhil• Fail

Referral

• Internal examiner will provide clear advice about what is required to bring thesis up to standard

• Supervisor will meet you and help to interpret• Resubmit 3-12 months post viva