Women in Conflict Situations in Northeast India Introduction From the prehistoric period, women and children were the worst suffers of the armed conflicts both directly or indirectly. Their sufferings are attached to their counterparts who are taking account of everything in silence across the world. Moreover, the myth regarding the power of choice and having a liberating culture is the most reliable area of romanticism for an outsider about the women of Northeast India. The women of Northeast have a brilliant approach towards peace making in the region on account of which they have spearheaded a number of women‘s movements. A decade of activism, ranging from the massive protest by women in Manipur during British colonial rule and among the more recent protest is the Meira Paibis in Manipur against the Indian state. The Naga Mother‘s Association in Nagaland and most recent was the Mahila Shanti Sena in Assam. All these protest are actively working for resolving the disputes and the conflicts and negotiating for peace in different states of the region. 1 My aim in this chapter is look at how women through their participation in peace negotiation convey their feelings and representing the violent event as a source that can reveal how the state policy and government are acting as active agents in promoting these violence and the indigenous people has to go through a traumatic experience because of such state interventions. Representation of Memories of Violence Tilottoma Mishra (2010) wrote how memories play a vital role in expression of a traumatic event whether in literature or oral narrations. According to her the most important thing to be noted in such narrations is the difference between what gets presented and what is not. Thus, there is a vast difference in representation of memories. The distinction between what is ―truth‖ and what is ―fiction‖ in the whole discourse of representation of violence is much more complicated area to pen it down in a certain sense. Regarding violent memories or experiences, the dilemma 1 Baneerjee Monika; Conflicts and Constructive Work: Strengthening Civil Society in the Northeast; in Preeti Gill(Ed.) The Peripheral Centre Voices from India’s Northeast; 2010; Pp- 217-226
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Women in Conflict Situations in Northeast India
Introduction
From the prehistoric period, women and children were the worst suffers of the armed conflicts
both directly or indirectly. Their sufferings are attached to their counterparts who are taking
account of everything in silence across the world. Moreover, the myth regarding the power of
choice and having a liberating culture is the most reliable area of romanticism for an outsider
about the women of Northeast India. The women of Northeast have a brilliant approach towards
peace making in the region on account of which they have spearheaded a number of women‘s
movements. A decade of activism, ranging from the massive protest by women in Manipur
during British colonial rule and among the more recent protest is the Meira Paibis in Manipur
against the Indian state. The Naga Mother‘s Association in Nagaland and most recent was the
Mahila Shanti Sena in Assam. All these protest are actively working for resolving the disputes
and the conflicts and negotiating for peace in different states of the region. 1
My aim in this chapter is look at how women through their participation in peace negotiation
convey their feelings and representing the violent event as a source that can reveal how the state
policy and government are acting as active agents in promoting these violence and the
indigenous people has to go through a traumatic experience because of such state interventions.
Representation of Memories of Violence
Tilottoma Mishra (2010) wrote how memories play a vital role in expression of a traumatic event
whether in literature or oral narrations. According to her the most important thing to be noted in
such narrations is the difference between what gets presented and what is not. Thus, there is a
vast difference in representation of memories. The distinction between what is ―truth‖ and what
is ―fiction‖ in the whole discourse of representation of violence is much more complicated area
to pen it down in a certain sense. Regarding violent memories or experiences, the dilemma
1 Baneerjee Monika; Conflicts and Constructive Work: Strengthening Civil Society in the Northeast; in Preeti
Gill(Ed.) The Peripheral Centre Voices from India’s Northeast; 2010; Pp- 217-226
comes into being only when the memories that one is recounting through the experience may be
harmful for the victim. Thus, it becomes very difficult to study a traumatic experience after the
experience of the violence and moreover it will be a painful act of recalling the trauma that they
have faced and make it into literary discourse. Thus, this may be the reason why the intellectual
kept quiet when the government of Assam did not permit a social science research institute in
Guwahati to organize an academic lecture on Nellie massacre.2 People were so traumatized with
the incident that the sense of recalling was like a punishment for them. Moreover the process of
recalling generates some sets of questions in the mind of the investigator: what such intervention
will do the people who had recount the experience? Does the victim want to recall and narrate
the whole violent experience? Such type of questions emerges with the intervention of an
outsider. For women writers, literatures especially the poems and the shorts stories became the
medium of conveying their feeling and portraying the traumatic and violent situation that have to
face because of the state and the insurgency groups. Not only this there are women who merged
together and formed powerful organization and agencies to fight against the patriarchal system.
The Women’s Organizations and Agencies
There are many women organization and agencies that are working for the welfare of society
even after inhabiting in a violent environment. Some of the women organizations are actively
working for the peace and security of the region are3:
Meira Paibis: Meira Paibis is a women group that fought against the injustice and the brutality of
the military through stripping themselves in front of Assam Rifles Headquarters for allegedly
raping and killing of Manorama Devi. The event took place on July 15, 2004. It was the huge
revolt that took place in history where women challenged their culture, patriarchal ideologies and
the state policies that has given the AFSPA the right to take any step without any evidence in
2 Nellie Massacre is the large-scale violence that took place in the plains of Nellie, a central part of Assam on
February 18, 1983. Around two thousand Muslim peasants of East Bengal origin were killed while in the attack by the inhabitants of the area that includes the Assamese and the Tiwas. The event is recognized as the biggest collective acts of violence in postcolonial India. (Kimura,2013, 1) 3 As my dissertation is looking at three region of Northeast India; Assam, Manipur and Nagaland so I am taking up
only the women organizations that are operating in these region.
context of the suspects. This very act became a major site for debate but AFSPA is still there
operating in the same manner and being the threat for the region.4
The Naga Mother Association: Naga Mother‘s Association came into being in 1984 which stated
that Naga mothers felt the need for conscientising citizens towards more responsible living,
human development and the eradication of bloodshed and violence. They also pledged to be
negotiators and mediators of peace among the Nagas. The NMA has rendered valuable service
for the cause of peace. It mediated between the Government of Nagaland and Naga Students
Federation over age limit for job issues. Rallies and demonstrations for the withdrawal of the
Armed Forces Special Powers Act, seminars on drug trafficking and status of Naga women with
regard to inheritance rights, etc., have been initiated by the NMA. The NMA has not limited its
interest on gender issues alone. It expresses a lot of concern about issue of the ongoing cease-fire
between the Government of India and the armed Naga opposition. These women need to fight on
two fronts – (a) they have to fight against state violence, and (b) they have to fight against
patriarchal structures that discriminate against them. Thus, women groups have persisted in their
own way to express their desire for peace and to condemn violence. In a symbolic gesture of
condemnation and rejection of violence, the NMA has persisted in covering the body of every
victim of violence with a black shroud. This silent yet eloquent statement has gone unnoticed or
unheeded today. NMA is also playing a pivotal role in bring the NSCN and the other Naga
militants to the negotiating table (NEN Report). Similarly, the Mothers‘ Union of Tura has
managed to persuade some militant groups of Meghalaya to give up arms. Naga Women‘s Union
of Manipur together with the members of the NMA have also started the process of bringing
about reconciliation between different rival militant groups and put an end to ethnic and factional
killings. 5
4 Baruah Sanjib, Northeast India: Beyond Counterinsurgency and Developmentalism; Preeti Gill (Ed.), The
Peripheral Centre: Voices from India’s Northeast; New Delhi: Zubaan, 2010 (2013) Pp. -38 5 Anuradha, Dutta, ‘Women as Peacemakers: A study of Northeast India’ in Monirul Hussain (ed.), Coming out of
Violence: Essays on Ethnicity, Conflict Resolution and Peace Process in Northeast India New Delhi: Regency
Publications, 2005
Mahila Shanti Sena: Mahila Shanti Sena6 was formed with the help of Dr. Rama Shankar Singh,
who belonged to the Peace Centre of McMaster University of Canada in two parts of India: Bihar
and Northeast India. 7 The organization aims at empowering women in order to build peace, raise
mass awareness among women about their power and strength, focuses on the problems that
women are facing like poverty, negligence, illiteracy and unemployment.8 Today MSS has
trained 50,000 women who have working regarding the issues of village disputes to peace
resolution of insurgency groups.9 The organization also promotes women‘s writing. It held
workshops, seminars and conference in these regards.
Women Writing as a Response to Violence
Women writers used the literary discourse to portray the revolution and the effects on them that
was taking place in Northeast India due to continuity of violence and conflict in the region. Most
of the stories were written to show that how women survived such inhuman violence and came
up with an active protest against the state and society. One of the best example of this is Arupa
Patangia Kalita‘s Felanee (2011), whose life was surrounded by ethnic violence. The story not
only depicts with how ethnic violence affects a woman‘s life but it also deals with the theme like
intercaste marriage which was a taboo at that period. This story focuses upon women coming out
of the domestic space and fighting against the injustice that has destroyed her life and how she
succeeded in bring out the men folk from the police custody. This shows how women are stand
actively for protecting the patriarchal system.
A woman‘s life is always centered on her husband and children as they became her identity.
When this centered area gets destroyed women came up like fire to protect their close ones. The
urge to fight against injustice comes up when the question of identity emerges, who will be her
6 Mahila Shanti Sena was conceptualized by Late Acharya Ramamurti, a revered social activist and leader in
Ganhian tradition. It was created by rural women at the Buddhist City, Vaishali, in Vashali Sabha held in February 2002. It attracted about 10,000 women in Bihar to Vaishali Sabha. (http://www.hdf.org.in/MSSNewsletterMarch12) 7 http://seedsnet.org/seeds1/projects/MSS/MSS-2.htm
savior know, who will take the responsibility of her. In Bhadari10
a short story written by
Lakshminath Bezbaruah. This story is about a woman‘s life under patriarchal structure that goes
through domestic violence on daily basis but she lives a happy life with her husband in spite of
the ugly fights and beatings that she gets from him. Her final plea to rescue her husband from the
prison and forgiving her husband who tried to murdered her shows how women are socialized to
think that a men is everything for her. He is her identity, her proud, her savior (even though he
beat her or even tries to kill her) and her life. The process of socialization and the construction of
patriarchal ideas that revolves round the institution of marriage and family are problematic.
Bhadari‘s lie about the incident shows her devotion towards her husbands, how deeply it is
rooted in her that she can die but the idea of living a life with a husband who will remain in the
prison is a like a curse. Her effort and the feeling of anguish to fight for her husband portray how
forgiveness is inbuilt in woman throughout her life. She is taught to forgive her husband in every
situation of her life. Bhadari‘s story also throws light upon the identity crisis that she will face
when her husband will be in prison. She could not take this burden as it will be a threat to her
identity, her respect in the society. The story shows how woman identity is socially constructed,
dominated by patriarchal norms how she is mentally dependent upon the man that couldn‘t think
of surviving without him.
This perpetuation of violence on women in patriarchy does not end here but the state and
government is equally responsible for such violence. In The Figure of the Abducted Woman: the
Citizen as Sexed, Veena Das argues and raises questions on the abducted women in the
imaginary of the masculine nation. She deploys the notion of trauma attached to them and raises
questions like what kind of protocols for telling their story might have been imported into the
task of making visible (or audible) the suffering of women in the nationalist discourse?11
State in
protecting its dignity and in the notion of nation building it forget the major harm that it was
causing to a section of people. The Meira Paibis is good example of this where women came up
and stood actively against the injustice of the AFSPA and the policies of the state. They used
10
Bhadari is a short story written by Lakshminath Bezbaruah, that revolves around the domestic life of two protagonist Shishuram and his wife Bhadari who got engaged in a fight (as all other days) but this time it was a severe attempt of taking Bhadari’s life from her. The story is clear glimpse of a woman who has faced severe domestic violence but still want to live with her husband(even if he has tried to kill her). 11
Das Veena; The Figure of the Abducted Woman: The Citizen as Sexed; Life and Words : Violence and the Descent into the Ordinary; University of California press; Berkeley Los Angeles London; 2007; Pp – 20
their body (where the dignity and patriarchal norms were attached) as a weapon to protest against
the injustice and the violence that they have caused to the women of Manipur. This event
brought revolution in whole Northeast India. Women used their body as a language to protest
against the injustice of the state. Thus there is a shift from patriarchal supplication to protest.
Use of ‘Bodies’ as a Language of Protest
Paula Banerjee in his article Women in Assam and Nagaland argues women faces ―two sets of
belligerent institutionalized power, one composed of the state or majority community and the
other of the rebel, and being strangers to such power, their vulnerability is increased‖.12
Further
he argues that ―how women negotiate their own spaces within and between these two set
opposing patriarchal power, in what ways they influence conflict and whether a re- examination
of women‘s roles leads to a redefinition of the conflict itself‖13
. There are mainly two
predominant images of women in conflict: the victim and the amazon. There are movements
where women are victimized and as well as proved themselves to be fighter.14
One such
movement is the women‘s protest against the rape and killing of Manorama who was a suspect of
Maoist insurgent. She was brutally raped and killed by Indian Army in Manipur in July 2004.
With this brutal case a unique kind of non-violence resistance emerged in the state. A group of
women came out for naked protest named as ‗Mothers of Manorama‘in front of the Indian Army
headquarters, urging armies to come and rape them. In the article Reading Women’s Protest in
Manipur: A Different Voice?, Paromita Chakravarti argues that ―this protest was neither pacifist
nor passive, but through its quiet aggression exposed the naked predatoriness of the Indian state
against its own female citizens. The women ritualistically mirrored the state‘s repression through
mockery and subversion. By enacting the unnaturalness of violence on their ‗bare bodies‘ they
shocked the nation into realising the extraordinary conditions created in Manipur and elsewhere
through the deployment of the army and the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act 1958 (AFSPA),
12
Banerjee Paula; Women in Assam and Nagaland; Women, War and Peace in South Asia: Beyond Victimhood to Agency; Edited by Rita Manchanda; 2001; Pp-132 13
Banerjee Paula; Women in Assam and Nagaland; Women, War and Peace in South Asia: Beyond Victimhood to Agency; Edited by Rita Manchanda; 2001; Pp-132 14
Ibid Pp-132
which grants the army legal immunity‖. 15
Such kind of act brought into open all the nakedness
and all the routine rapes that are committed by the army. The protest was a clear picture of
women protesting the mode of the state and how gender became a focal point of in large social
movement peace building and development. The protest also showed that the Manipuri women
rejected the patriarchal construction of rape as dishonouring women and redefined the
boundaries of the public and private, the personal and the political.16
The women of Manipur used the language of naked protest, to have a disturbing impact upon the
Indian Army as well as the State. Not only this, it challenged the analytical frameworks of
understanding women‘s political demonstrations through a radical deployment of women‘s bare
bodies in the public sphere. Further, it is a bold redefinition of the discursive construction of rape
and of the realms of the public and the private. These bodies sought to deconstruct the politics of
objectification rather than representing itself as a site of male gaze or voyeurism or sexual
invitations.17
For this, Irom Sharmila is a good example, a bold woman who stood for the injustice of the
military, who fasted for her entire life creating a history over fighting against the repeal of the
draconian law AFSPA which treat its citizen unequally and inflict injustice by the State to the
common people of Northeast India. Irom Sharmila ―reclaims her body: as a means through
which to express her agency, ideas, emotions and values. Asserting her right to deploy her body
as she sees fit, she has inverted the norm—of eating.‖18
Daily meals are one of the basic needs of
human beings and thus refusal to have it is a challenge to whole system.19
Irom Sharmila says
that ―I am not a spirit. I have a body. It has a metabolism.‖ Any harm her body may incur is, in
her view, inconsequential. As she puts it, ―I have no other power. I do not have economic power,
or political power. I have only myself…. This is the only way I have to get my voice heard‖.20
Through this act she is restating the right to her own body and reclaiming through her self-
chosen action of fasting. Fasting is form of non-violence act. Hence, Irom Sharmila is fighting
15
Chakravarti Paromita; Reading Women’s Protest in Manipur: A Different Voice?; Journal of Peace building & Development; 02 Apr 2012; Pp-48 16
Ibid; Pp-48 17
Ibid; Pp-48 18
Mehrotra Deepti priya; Irom Sharmila’s Protest Fast: `Women’s Wars’, Gandhian Non-Violence And Anti-Militarisation Struggles; PEACE PRINTS; South Asian Journal of Peacebuliding; Pp- 9 19
Ibid; Pp-9 20
Irom Sharmila, Interview, New Delhi, December 2006
against violence through the means of non-violence which may bring a change in heart,
conversion in behavior and beliefs of the opponents.21
The sense of spirituality emerges from her
act. Through her act she has accepted the sufferings, pain and deprivation that are attached to it.
She has portrayed herself as an idol of justice, who is a rational being and who is representing
the universal truth through her act of fasting. 22
The Mother Figure
The idea of motherhood is a traditional construction. The idea of caring and nurturing evoke
initially to move on with peace process. Women are always imagined as potential mothers. Every
woman is women but every woman is not a mother. Both the Naga Mother‘s Association and
Meira Paibis are using the language of motherhood to intervene the conflict situation which
means reinforcing patriarchal ideology of caring and nurturing.
According to NMA, every person should be respected. They provided shawls for the dead body
whether they are the militant or the insurgents. They appealed both the parties to stop fighting
against each other. Further, they worked to bring peace in the society by fighting against the drug
abuse and alcoholism which was the integral part of their organization. They also joined hand
with Naga Women‘s Union of Manipur (NWUM), Naga Student Federation, Naga Tribal
Councils and the Naga Peoples Movement for Human Rights for the peace process.23
With the
claim of being mothers, NMA‘s activities got social acceptance and got reorganization in eyes of
the Nagas that women plays an important role in peace process. Further, this agency believes that
victimization will come to an end once they achieve victory in political struggle. All this,
whatever they have achieved is with the reclamation of idea of motherhood.24
As the position of
a mother brings with it the idea of respect, authority, caring and nurturing, this agency is using it
as a tool to bring peace in the society and to making effort to include the feminine voice to the
21
Mehrotra Deepti priya; Irom Sharmila’s Protest Fast: `Women’s Wars’, Gandhian Non-Violence And Anti-Militarisation Struggles; PEACE PRINTS; South Asian Journal of Peacebuliding; Pp- 9-11 22
Ibid; Pp- 11 23
Banerjee Paula; Women in Assam and Nagaland; Women, War and Peace in South Asia: Beyond Victimhood to Agency; Edited by Rita Manchanda; 2001; Pp-162 24
Manchanda Rita; Naga Women Making a Difference: Peace Building in Northeastern India; Women Waging Peace Policy Commision; Sanam Naraghi Anderlini, Series Editor, January, 2005
movements. But what is problematic here is that this will not end the idea of marginalization of
women in certain sense.25
The idea of motherhood that was evoked through these organizations is asexual. In the naked
protest women were seen as asexual being they portrayed themselves as mothers. As Soibam
Haripriya (2012) wrote ―Meitei society‘s discomfort in dealing with women‘s sexuality has
pushed women‘s movements and agitations into de-sexualized frame of motherhood. While the
emotive vocabulary of motherhood can be seen as an effective strategy in conflict-affected
societies, it can be also seen as an effective strategy in conflict –affected societies, it can also
substantially limit the space and scope of protests.‖26
The notion of a middle aged woman
stripping is acceptable but a young woman stripping is problematic because a young woman‘s
body is always seen as desirable, sexual. Thus featuring oneself as a mother means being asexual
being. This is not the end the idea of motherhood is also attached to the idea of nationalism. The
nation is our mother. Hence with the term ―mother‖ the notion of honour, dignity, patriotism and
nationalism is attached. Thus claiming oneself as the mother means the sense purity is attached
to it.
Conclusion
From the above discussion it is clear that in order to understand violence especially in Northeast
India, it is important to look at the role and intervention of women in this conflict and violence
situation. Though there is no positive response from both the sides- insurgent agencies and state.
The whole conflict situation is severely affecting the womenfolk. Whether a woman plays an
active role or passive she has work inside the periphery of patriarchal constructions. The naked
protest was the best example for this. It was a threat to the patriarchal ideology that a women‘s
body is site sexual invitation or voyeurism. This event also shows that women should fight for
themselves to protect their dignity as well as the men folk. The protest has raised questions about
Indian nation-state which is focusing on security of civilians but some way or the other giving
25
Banerjee Paula; Women in Assam and Nagaland; Women, War and Peace in South Asia: Beyond Victimhood to Agency; Edited by Rita Manchanda; 2001; Pp-163-174 26
Haripriya Soibam, Agitation Women, Disrobed Mothers; Eastern Quarterly; Vol. 8, Issues I and II, Spring and Monsoon 2012, Pp- 18
for rights and privilege to AFSPA to operate sexual violence and murders in the state. Rape,
abduction, kidnapping and brutal killing shows how the armed force that is there to protect the
nation is itself violating the norms and operating crimes under the set prominence. The law itself
is giving them the right to operate violence in the region which needs a critical analysis of the
working of sate and law in the construction of the nation. This raises a question of: is the law or
the nation state dominated by patriarchal ideologies which is creating gender biasness and
insecurity among the gendered category – women. Well if we look back in history it is clear that
the Indian nation state is dominated by patriarchal ideologies and norms which is why women as
a gendered category is facing so much trouble and a sense of insecurity and identity crisis is
always prevalent whenever it comes to women. This might be the reason why women adopted
the idea of motherhood to regain their dignity, honour and justice from the nation. The cultural
code and the process of socialization and the very space of being a citizen are dominated by
patriarchal ideologies then how we - ‗women’ can have a space of our own as an active and
powerful gendered category? And if this so then I guess we as women, being a gendered
category, have to break the barriers of this patriarchal ideologies and create a new mode of
women‘s resistance which redefined rape and rewrite the semiotics of nude, female body and a
new mode of resisting the cycle. The best example of this is Meira Paibis who refused to sue a
state which was antagonistic to its citizens, raised questions upon militarization of the state and
their urge for justice. But some way or the other by adopting the idea of motherhood these
agencies as promoting the patriarchal ideology which is problematic and calls for a critical
articulation. Thus, there is a contradiction regarding the women‘s role in conflict situation. On
one hand, they are working within the frame work of patriarchal ideology and on the other end
they are challenging the notion of patriarchy which is problematic.
References
Baneerjee Monika; Conflicts and Constructive Work: Strengthening Civil Society in the
Northeast; in Preeti Gill(Ed.) The Peripheral Centre Voices from India’s Northeast;
2010; Pp- 217-226
Misra Tilottoma; Women Writing in Times of Violence; in Preeti Gill(Ed.) The
Peripheral Centre Voices from India’s Northeast; 2010; Pp. 306-334
Bezbaruah Lakshminath; Bhadari; Comedy of a Spark and Stories; Translated by Manjeet
Baruah; 2003
Chakravarti Paromita; Reading Women‘s Protest in Manipur: A Different Voice?;
Journal of Peacebuilding & Development; 02 Apr 2012
Das Veena; The Figure of the Abducted Woman: The Citizen as Sexed; Life and Words :
Violence and the Descent into the Ordinary; University of California press; Berkeley
Los Angeles London; 2007; Pp – 18- 37
Banerjee Paula; Women in Assam and Nagaland; Women, War and Peace in South Asia:
Beyond Victimhood to Agency; Edited by Rita Manchanda; 2001
Anuradha, Dutta, ‗Women as Peacemakers: A study of Northeast India‘ in Monirul
Hussain (ed.), Coming out of Violence: Essays on Ethnicity, Conflict Resolution and
Peace Process in Northeast India New Delhi: Regency Publications, 2005