Top Banner
With STEM in Mind: How the New Science of the Brain is Changing STEM Education M. G. Saldivar, Ph.D. Learning Systems Institute Florida State University
42

With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Jul 07, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

With STEM in Mind:How the New Science of the Brain

is Changing STEM Education

M. G. Saldivar, Ph.D.Learning Systems InstituteFlorida State University

Page 2: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

An Activity

Page 3: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are
Page 4: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are
Page 5: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are
Page 6: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are
Page 7: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

What happened?

The task changed from perception to computation

Page 8: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

This is an example of number sense

(Subitizing, to be exact)

Page 9: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are
Page 10: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

What’s the point?

Typically developed brains share many cognitive characteristics. They tend to work in very similar ways.

Page 11: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Brain science posits that understanding the fundamental ways in which our brains work can help us become better learners and better educators.

Page 12: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

NeurosciencePsychology

Education

Page 13: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Neuroscience

Psychology

Education Individual learning

Cognition and behavior

Neural substrates of cognition

Page 14: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

My goal today is to offer advice for STEM educators grounded in findings from brain science research.

Page 15: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Due to time constraints, I will gloss over sources and methods.

Neuroscience research in particular requires careful study.

Page 16: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

To download these slides and a list of references and further reading:

mgsaldivar.com

Page 17: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

What will we discuss?

• Common myths about the brain

• Findings from STEM-related brain research

• Pedagogical implications

Page 18: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Common myths about the brain

Page 19: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

“Some students will never learn ____ because of race (or gender) (or linguistic background) (or

____).”

Page 20: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

“If you don’t learn ____ by age ___ then you will never learn it.”

Page 21: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

“We only use ___% of our brains.”

Page 22: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

“_____ is very difficult to learn if you are (left-brained) (right-brained).”

Page 23: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Findings from STEM Education

Page 24: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Conceptual understanding of math involves both language and mathematical cognition

Example:

3 vs three vs III vs

Different parts of the brain process these different representations of three

Source: Stanislas Dehaene

Page 25: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes.

Multiplication and division are computational processes.

Page 26: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Algebra and higher math involve abstraction.

DISCUSS: ‘Three-ness’

JanuaryFebruaryMarch

GPA = 4.0GPA = 3.0GPA = 2.0

Page 27: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Mathematical problem-solving seems to involve one of two strategies:

Source: Daniel Ansari

Memory retrieval Procedural

“The answer popped into my head.”

“I broke the problem down into ___ steps.”

Page 28: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Memory retrieval involves working memory.

Page 29: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

StimulusShort-term

memory

Functional outcome

Long-term memory

Working memory

A simplified model of memory

Page 30: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Recalling an existing memory is more efficient than embarking on a new round of abstract thinking (such as computation).

Our brains default to algorithmic processes called heuristics.

Page 31: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

A heuristic is a mental shortcut comprising a set of instructions or steps, like a computer program.

Heuristics are typically procedural in nature.

Page 32: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

There is a close relationship between our knowledge of the natural world and our ability to evaluate scientific (and mathematical) concepts.

Source: Duschl et. al.

Page 33: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Example 1: Shape of the earth

True or false? Our everyday experience clearly points to the fact that the earth is round.

Agree or disagree? Students’ daily experience has no bearing on teaching that the world is round.

Page 34: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Example 1I: Motion of objects

Research suggests that when asked to draw the trajectories of objects released from (for example) continuous rotations or curved enclosures...

Page 35: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

...Most individuals did not know that objects move in straight lines absent some external force.

Agree or disagree? Student misconceptions play a large role in science learning.

Page 36: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Pedagogical Implications

Page 37: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Brains connect new information to old

Learning depends on ‘points of reference’ bridging new ideas with old ideas.

Page 38: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Brains are highly plastic

Our brains can ‘rewire’ themselves in response to trauma or disease or disability

Example: Dyslexia interventions

Page 39: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Multiple representations of concepts seems to be the key to developing deep understanding

Example: Three-ness

Page 40: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Conclusions

Certain patterns of thought are common among human beings.

Understanding the ways in which our brains work in common can give us insights into pedagogical challenges.

Page 41: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Sources and Further Reading

Book: Tracey Tokuhama-Espinosa, Mind, Brain, and Education Science (2011)

Book: John D. Bransford, Ann L. Brown & Rodney R. Cocking, How People Learn (2000)

Book: Richard A. Duschl, Heidi A. Schweingruber & Andrew W. Shouse, Taking Science to School (2007)

Article: Stanislas Dehaene, Serge Bossini & Pascal Giraux, The mental representation of parity and number magnitude (1993)

Article: Daniel Ansair & Annette Karmiloff-Smith, Atypical trajectories of number development (2002)

Page 42: With STEM in Mind · 2016-10-25 · brained) (right-brained). ... Source: Stanislas Dehaene. Basic addition and subtraction are perceptual processes. Multiplication and division are

Download this presenation:

mgsaldivar.com