Top Banner
Most Massive Galaxies with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]
26

with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Aug 03, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Most Massive Galaxies with MUSE

[ Scary Monsters ]

Page 2: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Naab et al. (2014)A

ng

ula

r m

om

en

tum

In s

itu

Ste

llar

Mas

s

Various Mass

regimes

⇒ Most massive galaxies

In situ vs Ex situ

Page 3: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Na

ab, O

ser, E

E e

t al. (20

14)N

ot

just

on

e P

ath

!

An

gu

lar

mo

me

ntu

m

Page 4: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Lin et al. (2013)

Mass Growth @

the high Mass end Time evolu�on

⇒ Most massive galaxies

x 2-4 since z=1.5

Observa�ons

Model

Now

Page 5: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Or Or ?

Page 6: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Or Or ?

Why should we care ?

Orbital structure

Morphology, Dynamics, Mass

Constraints on Forma�on / Evolu�on

How are these formed / assembled ?

Naab, Oser, Emsellem et al. 2014

Emsellem, Cappellari, Krajnović et al. 2011

Merri( 2013

Things change at high mass

Angular momentum

Page 7: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

What's happening at Masses > 1011.5 M⊙

?

Page 8: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

[VLT/VIMOS]Jimmy, Brough et al. 2013

BCGs

[MASSIVE – Mitchell Spec + AO-NIFS]

Ma et al. 2014

Page 9: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

a MUSE GTO programme PI Eric Emsellem; Davor Krajnović

The Project

Goals:

Dynamical state, Dark ma-er content, Dynamical state, Dark ma-er content,

SFH, IMF SFH, IMF + Test predic1ons of numerical simula1ons

How:

Stellar content + dynamics

of the most massive galaxies

in densest environments

e.g. Ho3man et al. 2010, Bois et al. 2011,

Naab et al. 2014, Rö(gers et al. 2014,

Vogelsberger et al. 2014 (Illustris), Schaye

et al. 2015 (EAGLE), Hirschmann et al.

2015…

Page 10: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

More massive,

richer, clusters

→ 2 sub-samples (z~0.04)

Shapley Super Cluster

(brighter than -25.7 mag in K)

+

BCGs in rich clusters

The Project

Page 11: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Shapley Super Cluster

~200 Mpc [~1kpc / arcsec]

Mercurio et al. (2006)

Page 12: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Why MUSE?

Emsellem, Krajnović, Sarzi 2014

M 87

Page 13: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

MUSE (V-R-I)

“Snapshot”

Images

Page 14: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

PGC018236 and PGC019085

Rota1on around minor axis – counter rota1on

Rota1on around minor axis

Page 15: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

PGC003342 and PGC065588Rota1on around minor and major axis

Rota1on around major axis

Page 16: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

MUSE colour

PGC007300Velocity Dispersion

Age Metallicity

Page 17: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

PGC047202The most massive galaxy in Shapley

4 x 4h

101 merged data cubes...

374 544 spectra

2’

x 2

Page 18: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

PGC047202

• ds

Rota1on around minor axis

Page 19: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

PGC046832

• ds

A double A double

KDCKDC

Page 20: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

TYPE #

Prolate-like 8

Oblate-like 5

Including > 3 KDC

Non-rotators 1 (?)

First Results

> ½ show prolate-like rota�on ?

Page 21: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

The morphology of galaxies change with mass

Oblate Mildly Triaxial Prolate ?⇒ ⇒

First Results

Ques�ons

Dynamical models ?Dynamical models ?

Assembly history?Assembly history?

Geometry

Mass

Page 22: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Age [Fe/H]

Page 23: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Mass Assembly

Guérou et al. 2016

NGC 3115

Page 24: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Mass Assembly

Guérou et al. 2016

NGC 3115

Page 25: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

We have great tools !

Zeroth order : Mass, scale

First order : velocity moments, age, metallicity

BUT → are we just geIng V, s, … for any galaxy we observe… ?

aren't we doing this since… 1990?

WHAT IS MISSING ?WHAT IS MISSING ?

True coupling (dynamics/stellar pop) + new perspec1ve

Some (Tequila-weighted) ideas to be applied on M3G Galaxies

⇒ f[ (x,y,z), M, t, [Fe/H], Ang. Mom.](must be robust for comparisons with simula1ons)

How are we doing?

Page 26: with MUSE [ Scary Monsters ]...[ Scary Monsters ] Naab l.24) A n g u l a r m o m e n t u m I n s i t u – S t e l l a r M a s s Various Mass regimes ⇒ Most massive galaxies In situ

Something new?

● At VERY high mass Prolateness rules ! (?)⇒● Mass profle transi�on to the cluster HALO⇒● Probing the mass assembly via spectral fOng