Page 1
What the search engines know about us
Online Information, London, 2011Karen Blakeman
[email protected] http://twitter.com/karenblakeman
http://www.rba.co.uk/ Slides available at http://www.rba.co.uk/as/ and
on authorSTREAM and Slideshare
This presentation is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License
Page 2
Personalization is commonplace
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 2
\
\ \ \ \ \ \
AmazonOnline shopping (Ocado)
Targeted advertising
Page 3
Search engines personalize too
“Dear Bing, We Have 10,000 Ranking Signals To Your 1,000. Love, Google” – http://searchengineland.com/bing-10000-ranking-signals-google-5
5473
– over 200 hundred “signals”, many have over 50 variations
“Bing Adds Adaptive Search, Customized by Your Search History” – http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2109647/Bing-Adds-Adaptiv
e-Search-Customized-by-Your-Search-History
Emphasis on Google in this presentation because Google is the most open about what it does!!
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk3
Page 4
Your browser, device, operating system...
Panopticlick https://panopticlick.eff.org/
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 4
Page 5
Where are you?
• IP address location on desktop or laptop
• Mobile devices
• Present you with what they think is the relevant country information
– “local” content is given priority and more emphasis
– access to some sites and information blocked to those outside of local “region/area”
• Actual location is not always correct – some hotel broadband networks give the wrong country for user’s physical location
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 5
Page 6
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 6
Page 7
Search engines remember what you’ve done
Results change depending on
activity
So do ads
– for your “ad preferences”
in Google go to
http://www.google.com/ads/preferences/
– gives you a clue as to what
Google (and other search
engines) thinks you like to
see
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 7
Page 8
Facebook remembers you...
....even when you think you’ve deleted stuff– europe-v-facebook.org http://europe-v-facebook.org/
– europe-v-facebook.org - Data Pool http://europe-v-facebook.org/EN/Data_Pool/data_pool.html
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 8
Page 9
Google knows us so well
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 9
Google personalizes and tailors
your results depending on your
location, computer, browser, past
searches, what you have looked
at in the past, your +1s, your
blocked sites, your Google+
account, your other social
networks, what you had for
breakfast...and anything else it
can find by rummaging around
in your Google dashboard
They all do it
Page 10
Google personalization
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 10
Page 11
Your social networks
Logged in to a Google account? Your social media connections may be given priority
Used +1 to “approve” a page or posting?
Blocked sites from your searches?
Google says it may use all of these as “signals” for everyone, not just you
Check the dashboard on your Google account http://www.google.com/dashboard
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 11
Page 12
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 12
An identical search run at the same time by several people with differing social network connections and on different devices will come up with different results.
Presents problems for those of us who help and advise others on effective search strategies. We can no longer say that a particular search strategy is the best approach for dealing with a specific type of search.
You see what you want to see
Page 13
Google can seriously damage your news
Experiment by Mary Ellen Bates
Is Google really filtering my news? - Librarian of Fortune
http://www.librarianoffortune.com/librarian_of_fortune/2011/09/is-
google-really-filtering-my-news.html
Highlights
More than 25% of stories showed up in only one searcher’s
results
Almost one in five searchers saw a story that no one else saw
Only 12% of searchers saw the same 3 stories in the same order
And it’s about to get worse – “Google News Launches "Standout" Tag
for Featured Content” http://searchengineland.com/google-news-
launches-standout-tag-for-featured-content-9425611/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 13
Page 14
Do you know what you’re sharing and with whom?
Facebook news apps
“Read" in Facebook - It's Not a Button, So Be Careful What You Click!
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/read_in_facebook_social_news_apps.php
Google profiles can no longer be private
Google+ circles
Android Google+ by default uploads photos to your album (thankfully doesn’t automatically share – at the moment)
Google+ taking over share functions e.g. Google Reader
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 14
Page 15
Do you know what you’re sharing and with whom?
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 15
• Logging in to sites with email address, user name and password disappearing
• Log in with Facebook or Google+ account
• Log in with Facebook and you automatically "like" the page or site, with Google+ you +1 it
Page 16
De-cluttering your Google dashboard maynot be possible
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 16
Page 17
More dashboard clutter....
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 17
Note: Secondary connections are included in determining relevant search results
Page 18
Do you have any control over personalization?
• Not entirely but damage limitation sometimes possible
• Decide whether or not having a web history is going to be a help or a hindrance
• If you have a Google or Bing account:– log out of it when you don’t need it
– regularly check your dashboard and privacy settings
– delete “stuff” and clear histories if you don’t need them
• Use Google Verbatim when necessary
• Check your ad preferences in Google and also consider using Network Advertising Initiative http://www.networkadvertising.org/managing/opt_out.asp
• Cookie management (but remember if you delete all cookies you will lose opt-out cookies as well)
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 18
Page 19
Reject all cookies?
• You won’t get very far on the internet without cookies
• New European legislation “Cookie laws” http://www.out-law.com/page-5486
• Active management of cookies? Can be time consuming and may lose opt-out cookies
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 19
Page 20
11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 20
“Normal” search Verbatim (identical to &pws=0) Chrome Incognito
Google searches
Page 21
Go undercover?
• Anonymous proxy servers?• Browser tools
– Firefox – Tools, Start private browsing – Chrome has an incognito mode - still has localisation– Internet Explorer – In Private Browsing
• Scroogle.org – anonymised interface to Google– no cookies, no search-term records, access log deleted within 48
hrs– web search only and no verbatim search
• DuckDuckGo.com – does not keep your web history or personalize
• Blekko.com – http://help.blekko.com/index.php/what-do-the-privacy-options-in-
prefs-do/
Personalization is not always bad!11/04/23 www.rba.co.uk 21