What is Biomedical Informatics? - Leadership & Discovery ... · PDF fileWhat is Biomedical Informatics? William Hersh, MD, FACP, FACMI Professor and Chair ... Patient care outside

WhatisBiomedicalInformatics?

WilliamHersh,MD,FACP,FACMIProfessorandChair

DepartmentofMedicalInformatics&ClinicalEpidemiologyOregonHealth&ScienceUniversity

Portland,OR,USAEmail:[email protected]:www.billhersh.info

Blog:http://informaticsprofessor.blogspot.comTwitter:@williamhersh

ReferencesAbdelhak,M,Grostick,S,etal.(2015).HealthInformation:ManagementofaStrategicResource,5thEdition.Philadelphia,PA,Saunders.Adams,JandKlein,J(2011).BusinessIntelligenceandAnalyticsinHealthCare-APrimer.Washington,DC,TheAdvisoryBoardCompany.http://www.advisory.com/Research/IT-Strategy-Council/Research-Notes/2011/Business-Intelligence-and-Analytics-in-Health-CareAmmenwerth,EandSpötl,HP(2009).Thetimeneededforclinicaldocumentationversusdirectpatientcare.Awork-samplinganalysisofphysicians'activities.MethodsofInformationinMedicine.48:84-91.Anderson,C(2007).TheEndofTheory:TheDataDelugeMakestheScientificMethodObsolete.Wired,June23,2008.http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/magazine/16-07/pb_theoryAnonymous(2005).FactSheet:ImprovingCareandSavingLivesThroughHealthIT.Washington,DC,WhiteHouse.http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/01/20050127-2.htmlAnonymous(2005).PresidentDiscussesHealthCareInformationTechnologyBenefits.Washington,DC,WhiteHouse.http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/01/20050127-7.htmlAnonymous(2008).InformationBehaviouroftheResearcheroftheFuture.London,England,CentreforInformationBehaviourandtheEvaluationofResearch.http://www.jisc.ac.uk/media/documents/programmes/reppres/ggworkpackageii.pdfAnonymous(2011).DismantlingtheNHSNationalProgrammeforIT.London,England,DepartmentofHealth.http://mediacentre.dh.gov.uk/2011/09/22/dismantling-the-nhs-national-programme-for-it/Anonymous(2011).TowardPrecisionMedicine:BuildingaKnowledgeNetworkforBiomedicalResearchandaNewTaxonomyofDisease.Washington,DC,NationalAcademiesPress.Anonymous(2012).DemandPersistsforExperiencedHealthITStaff.AnnArbor,MI,CollegeofHealthcareInformationManagementExecutives.http://www.cio-chime.org/chime/press/surveys/pdf/CHIME_Workforce_survey_report.pdfAnonymous(2012).HealthITandPatientSafety:BuildingSaferSystemsforBetterCare.Washington,DC,NationalAcademiesPress.Anonymous(2012).Singapore’sJourneytoBuildaNationalElectronicHealthRecordSystem.Chicago,IL,Accenture.http://www.accenture.com/us-en/Pages/insight-singapore-journey-build-national-electronic-health-record-system-summary.aspxAnonymous(2014).2014HIMSSWorkforceSurvey.Chicago,IL,HIMSSAnalytics.http://www.himssanalytics.org/research/AssetDetail.aspx?pubid=82173Anonymous(2014).2014NursingInformaticsWorkforceSurvey.Chicago,IL,HealthcareInformationManagementSystemsSociety.http://www.himss.org/ni-workforce-survey

Anonymous(2015).2015AnnualCMIOSurvey,SSiSearch.http://www.ssi-search.com/images//pdfs/SSi-SEARCH-CMIO-Survey-publ-2015.pdfAnonymous(2015).FederalHealthITStrategicPlan2015-2020.Washington,DC,DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.https://www.healthit.gov/sites/default/files/9-5-federalhealthitstratplanfinal_0.pdfAnonymous(2015).TheHealthITTalentShortage-WhatJobSeekersNeedToKnow,HealthITJobs.com.https://www.healthitjobs.com/healthcare-it-careers-resources/healthcare-it-talent-shortage-whitepaper.aspxAnonymous(2015).HealthcareAnalytics/MedicalAnalyticsMarketbyApplication(Clinical,PHM,Financial(RCM,Claim&Fraud),SupplyChain&HR),Type(Predictive),Deliverymodel(On-premise,Cloud),End-user(Payer,Hospital,Ambulatory,ACO)-GlobalForecastto2020.Vancouver,WA,MarketsandMarkets.http://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/healthcare-data-analytics-market-905.htmlAnonymous(2015).HealthcareMobilitySolutionsMarketbyProducts&Services(MobileDevices,MobileApps,EnterprisePlatforms),Application(PatientCare,Operations,WorkforceManagement),EndUser(Payers,Providers,Patients)-GlobalForecastto2020.Vancouver,WA,MarketsandMarkets.http://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/healthcare-mobility-solutions-market-1295547.htmlAnonymous(2015).MedicalRecordsandHealthInformationTechnicians.Washington,DC,BureauofLaborStatistics.http://www.bls.gov/ooh/healthcare/medical-records-and-health-information-technicians.htmAnonymous(2016).Request/RecommendationforNewHealthInformaticsPractitionerStandardOccupationalClassification(SOC)https://www.amia.org/sites/default/files/Healthcar-Coalition-Response-2018-SOC.pdfBenson,TandGrieve,G(2016).PrinciplesofHealthInteroperability-SNOMEDCT,HL7andFHIR,ThirdEdition.London,England,Springer.Berkowitz,LandMcCarthy,C(2012).InnovationwithInformationTechnologiesinHealthcare.NewYork,NY,Springer.Berner,E,Ed.(2014).InformaticsEducationinHealthcare:LessonsLearned.London,England,Springer.Bernstam,EV,Hersh,WR,etal.(2009).Synergiesanddistinctionsbetweencomputationaldisciplinesinbiomedicalresearch:perspectivefromtheClinicalandTranslationalScienceAwardprograms.AcademicMedicine.84:964-970.Bernstam,EV,Smith,JW,etal.(2010).Whatisbiomedicalinformatics?JournalofBiomedicalInformatics.43:104-110.Block,L,Habicht,R,etal.(2013).Inthewakeofthe2003and2011dutyhoursregulations,howdointernalmedicineinternsspendtheirtime?JournalofGeneralInternalMedicine.28:1042-1047.Blum,BI(1984).InformationSystemsforPatientCare.NewYork,Springer-Verlag.Blumenthal,D(2011).Implementationofthefederalhealthinformationtechnologyinitiative.NewEnglandJournalofMedicine.365:2426-2431.Blumenthal,D(2011).Wiringthehealthsystem--originsandprovisionsofanewfederalprogram.NewEnglandJournalofMedicine.365:2323-2329.Boyd,DandCrawford,K(2011).SixProvocationsforBigData.Cambridge,MA,MicrosoftResearch.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1926431Brailer,DJ(2004).TheDecadeofHealthInformationTechnology:DeliveringConsumer-centricandInformation-RichHealthCare.Washington,DC,DepartmentofHealth&HumanServices.http://www.hhs.gov/healthit/documents/hitframework.pdfBrennan,S(2007).Thebiggestcomputerprogrammeintheworldever!How'sitgoing?JournalofInformationTechnology.22:202-211.Bui,AATandTaira,RK,Eds.(2010).MedicalImagingInformatics.NewYork,NY,Springer.

Butler,M(2014).Adaptordisappear:AHIMA’sreality2016hasanewmissiontotransformtheHIMworkforcethrougheducation—orelse.JournalofAHIMA.85(5):24-29.Calhoun,M,Rudman,B,etal.(2012).Vision2016toReality2016:buildingaprofession.JournalofAHIMA.83(8):18-23.Carayon,PandKarsh,BT(2010).IncorporatingHealthInformationTechnologyIntoWorkflowRedesign.Rockville,MD,AgencyforHealthcareResearchandQuality.http://www.innovations.ahrq.gov/content.aspx?id=3048Chen,MA,Hollenberg,JP,etal.(2010).Patientcareoutsideofofficevisits:aprimarycarephysiciantimestudy.JournalofGeneralInternalMedicine.26:58-63.Chisholm,CD,Weaver,CS,etal.(2011).Ataskanalysisofemergencyphysicianactivitiesinacademicandcommunitysettings.AnnalsofEmergencyMedicine.18:117-122.Coiera,E(2007).Puttingthetechnicalbackintosocio-technicalsystemsresearch.InternationalJournalofMedicalInformatics.76(Supp1):98-103.Collen,MF(1994).Theoriginsofinformatics.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.1:91-107.Collen,MF(1995).AHistoryofMedicalInformaticsintheUnitedStates1950-1990.Bethesda,MD,AmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.Collen,MFandBall,MJ,Eds.(2015).TheHistoryofMedicalInformaticsintheUnitedStates.NewYork,NY,Springer.Collins,FS(2010).OpportunitiesforresearchandNIH.Science.327:36-37.Collins,FSandVarmus,H(2015).Anewinitiativeonprecisionmedicine.NewEnglandJournalofMedicine.372:793-795.Davenport,THandPatil,DJ(2012).DataScientist:TheSexiestJobofthe21stCentury.HarvardBusinessReview,October,2012.http://hbr.org/2012/10/data-scientist-the-sexiest-job-of-the-21st-century/delaCalle,G,García-Remesal,M,etal.(2012).e-MIR2:apubliconlineinventoryofmedicalinformaticsresources.BMCMedicalInformatics&DecisionMaking.12:82.http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6947/12/82Detmer,DEandShortliffe,EH(2014).Clinicalinformatics:prospectsforanewmedicalsubspecialty.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation.311:2067-2068.Dixon,B(2016).HealthInformationExchange-NavigatingandManagingaNetworkofHealthInformationSystems.Amsterdam,Netherlands,Elsevier.Donoho,D(2015).50yearsofDataScience.PrincetonNJ,TukeyCentennialWorkshop.https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/23421017/50YearsDataScience.pdfFarber,J,Siu,A,etal.(2007).Howmuchtimedophysiciansspendprovidingcareoutsideofofficevisits?AnnalsofInternalMedicine.147:693-698.Fenton,SH,Joost,E,etal.(2012).HealthinformationtechnologyknowledgeandskillsneededbyHITemployers.AppliedClinicalInformatics.3:448-461.Ferguson,T(2007).e-Patients:HowTheyCanHelpUsHealHealthCare.Boston,MA,e-PatientScholarsWorkingGroup.http://e-patients.net/e-Patients_White_Paper.pdfFourman,M(2002).Informatics.InternationalEncyclopediaofInformationandLibraryScience,2ndEdition.J.FeatherandP.Sturges.London,England,Routledge:237-244.Friedman,CP(2009).A'fundamentaltheorem'ofbiomedicalinformatics.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.16:169-170.Friedman,CP(2012).Whatinformaticsisandisn't.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.20:224-226.Friedman,CP,Wong,AK,etal.(2010).Achievinganationwidelearninghealthsystem.ScienceTranslationalMedicine.2(57):57cm29.http://stm.sciencemag.org/content/2/57/57cm29.fullGadd,CS,Williamson,JJ,etal.(2016).Eligibilityrequirementsforadvancedhealthinformaticscertification.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.23:851-854.

Gadd,CS,Williamson,JJ,etal.(2016).Creatingadvancedhealthinformaticscertification.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.23:848-850.Gardner,RM,Overhage,JM,etal.(2009).Corecontentforthesubspecialtyofclinicalinformatics.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.16:153-157.Geissbuhler,A,Kimura,M,etal.(2011).Confluenceofdisciplinesinhealthinformatics:aninternationalperspective.MethodsofInformationinMedicine.50:545-555.Giannangelo,K,Ed.(2015).HealthcareCodeSets,ClinicalTerminologies,andClassificationSystems,ThirdEdition.Chicago,IL,AHIMAPress.Gilchrist,V,McCord,G,etal.(2005).Physicianactivitiesduringtimeoutoftheexaminationroom.AnnalsofFamilyMedicine.3:494-499.Glaser,J(2012).FromtheTransaction-BasedEHRtotheIntelligence-BasedEHR.Hospital&HealthNetworks,August14,2012.http://www.hhnmag.com/hhnmag/HHNDaily/HHNDailyDisplay.dhtml?id=6510004866Gottschalk,AandFlocke,SA(2005).Timespentinface-to-facepatientcareandworkoutsidetheexaminationroom.AnnalsofFamilyMedicine.3:488-493.Greenes,RAandShortliffe,EH(1990).Medicalinformatics-anemergingacademicdisciplineandinstitutionalpriority.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation.263:1114-1120.Greiner,ACandKnebel,E,Eds.(2003).HealthProfessionsEducation:ABridgetoQuality.Washington,DC,NationalAcademiesPress.Hasman,A,Ammenwerth,E,etal.(2011).Biomedicalinformatics--aconfluenceofdisciplines?MethodsofInformationinMedicine.50:508-524.Haux,R(2010).Medicalinformatics:past,present,future.InternationalJournalofMedicalInformatics.79:599-610.Hayes,GandBarnett,D(2008).UKHealthComputing:RecollectionsandReflections.Swindon,UK,BritishComputerSociety.Henry,J,Pylypchuk,Y,etal.(2016).AdoptionofElectronicHealthRecordSystemsamongU.S.Non-FederalAcuteCareHospitals:2008-2015.Washington,DC,DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.http://dashboard.healthit.gov/evaluations/data-briefs/non-federal-acute-care-hospital-ehr-adoption-2008-2015.phpHersh,W(2004).Healthcareinformationtechnology:progressandbarriers.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation.292:2273-2274.Hersh,W(2008).HealthandBiomedicalInformatics:OpportunitiesandChallengesforaTwenty-FirstCenturyProfessionanditsEducation.IMIAYearbookofMedicalInformatics2008.A.GeissbuhlerandC.Kulikowski.Stuttgart,Germany,Schattauer:138-145.Hersh,W(2009).Astimulustodefineinformaticsandhealthinformationtechnology.BMCMedicalInformatics&DecisionMaking.9:24.http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6947/9/24/Hersh,W(2010).Thehealthinformationtechnologyworkforce:estimationsofdemandsandaframeworkforrequirements.AppliedClinicalInformatics.1:197-212.Hersh,W(2012).FromImplementationtoAnalytics:TheFutureWorkofInformatics.InformaticsProfessor,April1,2012.http://informaticsprofessor.blogspot.com/2012/04/from-implementation-to-analytics-future.htmlHersh,W(2013).DoPhysiciansSpendTooMuchTimeWithComputers?InformaticsProfessor,August30,2013.http://informaticsprofessor.blogspot.com/2013/08/do-physicians-spend-too-much-time-with.htmlHersh,WandEhrenfeld,J(2017).ClinicalInformatics.HealthSystemsScience.S.Skochelak,R.Hawkins,L.Lawsonetal.NewYork,NY,Elsevier:105-116.Hersh,WR(2002).Medicalinformatics-improvinghealthcarethroughinformation.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation.288:1955-1958.Hersh,WR(2006).Whoaretheinformaticians?Whatweknowandshouldknow.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.13:166-170.

Hersh,WR(2009).InformationRetrieval:AHealthandBiomedicalPerspective(3rdEdition).NewYork,NY,Springer.Hersh,WR(2014).HealthcareDataAnalytics.HealthInformatics:PracticalGuideforHealthcareandInformationTechnologyProfessionals,SixthEdition.R.HoytandA.Yoshihashi.Pensacola,FL,Lulu.com:62-75.Hersh,WR,Gorman,PN,etal.(2014).BeyondinformationretrievalandEHRuse:competenciesinclinicalinformaticsformedicaleducation.AdvancesinMedicalEducationandPractice.5:205-212.http://www.dovepress.com/beyond-information-retrieval-and-electronic-health-record-use-competen-peer-reviewed-article-AMEPHersh,WR,Weiner,MG,etal.(2013).Caveatsfortheuseofoperationalelectronichealthrecorddataincomparativeeffectivenessresearch.MedicalCare.51(Suppl3):S30-S37.Hey,T,Tansley,S,etal.,Eds.(2009).TheFourthParadigm:Data-IntensiveScientificDiscovery.Redmond,WA,MicrosoftResearch.Hoyt,REandYoshihashi,A,Eds.(2014).HealthInformatics:PracticalGuideforHealthcareandInformationTechnologyProfessionals,SixthEdition.Pensacola,FL,Lulu.com.Kann,MandLewitter,F,Eds.(2013).TranslationalBioinformatics.SanFrancisco,CA,PublicLibraryofScience.Kim,CS,Lovejoy,W,etal.(2010).Hospitalisttimeusageandcyclicality:opportunitiestoimproveefficiency.JournalofHospitalMedicine.5:329-334.Kleinke,JD(2005).Dot-gov:marketfailureandthecreationofanationalhealthinformationtechnologysystem.HealthAffairs.24:1246-1262.Kloss,LL(2012).HealthInformationManagementin2016.Wayne,PA,Precyse.http://www.precyse.com/resources/HIMin2016WhitePaper_042412.pdfKrist,AHandWoolf,SH(2011).Avisionforpatient-centeredhealthinformationsystems.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation.305:300-301.Kulikowski,CA,Shortliffe,EH,etal.(2012).AMIABoardwhitepaper:definitionofbiomedicalinformaticsandspecificationofcorecompetenciesforgraduateeducationinthediscipline.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.19:931-938.LaTour,KMandEichenwald-Maki,S,Eds.(2013).HealthInformationManagement:Concepts,Principles,andPractice(4thEdition).Chicago,IL,AmericanHealthInformationManagementAssociation.Leshner,AI,Terry,SF,etal.,Eds.(2013).TheCTSAProgramatNIH:OpportunitiesforAdvancingClinicalandTranslationalResearch.Washington,DC,InstituteofMedicine.Lesk,A(2014).IntroductiontoBioinformatics,4thEdition.Oxford,England,OxfordUniversityPress.Lowry,SZ,Quinn,MT,etal.(2012).TechnicalEvaluation,Testing,andValidationoftheUsabilityofElectronicHealthRecords.Gaithersburg,MD,NationalInstituteforStandardsandTechnology.http://www.nist.gov/healthcare/usability/upload/EUP_WERB_Version_2_23_12-Final-2.pdfMagnuson,JAandFu,PC,Eds.(2014).PublicHealthInformaticsandInformationSystems.NewYork,NY,Springer.Mamykina,L,Vawdrey,DK,etal.(2016).Howdoresidentsspendtheirshifttime?Atimeandmotionstudywithaparticularfocusontheuseofcomputers.AcademicMedicine.91:827-832.Mandl,KDandKohane,IS(2012).EscapingtheEHRtrap--thefutureofhealthIT.NewEnglandJournalofMedicine.366:2240-2242.Manos,D(2012).CNIOroleontherise.HealthcareITNews,March12,2012.http://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/cnio-role-riseMartin,SAandSinsky,CA(2016).Themapisnottheterritory:medicalrecordsand21stcenturypractice.Lancet.388(2053-2056)Maxson,E,Jain,S,etal.(2010).Theregionalextensioncenterprogram:helpingphysiciansmeaningfullyusehealthinformationtechnology.AnnalsofInternalMedicine.153:666-670.

Maxson,ER,Jain,SH,etal.(2010).Beaconcommunitiesaimtousehealthinformationtechnologytotransformthedeliveryofcare.HealthAffairs.29:1671-1677.McDonald,CJ,Callaghan,RM,etal.(2014).Useofinternist'sfreetimebyambulatorycareelectronicmedicalrecordsystems.JAMAInternalMedicine:Epubaheadofprint.McKethan,A,Brammer,C,etal.(2011).AnearlystatusreportontheBeaconCommunities'plansfortransformationviahealthinformationtechnology.HealthAffairs.30:782-788.Moehr,J(2004).TheQuestforIdentityofMedicalInformatics,andforGuidancetoEducationinit:theGermanConferenceattheReisensburgof1973revisited.YearbookofMedicalInformatics2004.R.Haux,A.McCrayandC.Kullikowski.Stuttgart,Germany,Schattauer:200-209.O'Reilly,T,Loukides,M,etal.(2012).HowDataScienceIsTransformingHealthCare-SolvingtheWanamakerDilemma.Sebastopol,CA,O'ReillyMedia.Osborn,R,Moulds,D,etal.(2015).Primarycarephysiciansintencountriesreportchallengescaringforpatientswithcomplexhealthneeds.HealthAffairs.34:2104-2112.Payne,TH,Detmer,DE,etal.(2011).National-scaleclinicalinformationexchangeintheUnitedKingdom:lessonsfortheUnitedStates.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.18:91-98.Protti,DandJohansen,I(2010).WidespreadAdoptionofInformationTechnologyinPrimaryCarePhysicianOfficesinDenmark:ACaseStudy.NewYork,NY,CommonwealthFund.http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/Files/Publications/IssueBrief/2010/Mar/1379_Protti_widespread_adoption_IT_primary_care_Denmark_intl_ib.pdfQuiros,FGB,Luna,D,etal.(2009).ExperienceintheDevelopmentofanIn-houseHealthInformationSystemandtheTrainingNeedsoftheHumanResourcesattheHospitalItalianodeBuenosAires.IMIAYearbookofMedicalInformatics2009.A.GeissbuhlerandC.Kulikowski.Stuttgart,Germany,Schattauer:147-152.Reddy,CKandAgarwal,CC,Eds.(2015).HealthcareDataAnalytics.BocaRaton,FL,Chapman&Hall.Richesson,RLandAndrews,JE,Eds.(2012).ClinicalResearchInformatics.NewYork,NY,Springer.Rosenbaum,L(2015).Transitionalchaosorenduringharm?TheEHRandthedisruptionofmedicine.NewEnglandJournalofMedicine.373:1585-1588.Rowley,J(2007).Thewisdomhierarchy:representationsoftheDIKWhierarchy.JournalofInformationScience.33:163-180.Safran,CandDetmer,DE(2005).Computerizedphysicianorderentrysystemsandmedicationerrors.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation.294:179.Safran,C,Shabot,MM,etal.(2009).ACGMEprogramrequirementsforfellowshipeducationinthesubspecialtyofclinicalinformatics.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation.16:158-166.Sarkar,IN,Ed.(2014).MethodsinBiomedicalInformatics:APragmaticApproach.London,England,AcademicPress.Sayles,NBandTrawick,KC(2014).IntroductiontoComputerSystemsforHealthInformationTechnology,2ndEdition.Chicago,IL,AmericanHealthInformationManagementAssociation.Schleidgen,S,Klingler,C,etal.(2013).Whatispersonalizedmedicine:sharpeningavaguetermbasedonasystematicliteraturereview.BMCMedicalEthics.14:55.http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6939/14/55Sengstack,PandBoicey,C(2015).MasteringInformatics:AHealthcareHandbookforSuccess.Indianapolis,IN,SigmaThertaTauInternational.Shaffer,VandGibson,R(2016).12thAnnualAMDIS-GartnerSurveyofCMIOsPreliminaryFindings.Stamford,CT,Gartner.http://amdis.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/amdisGartnerCMIOSurvey.pdfShortliffe,EHandCimino,JJ,Eds.(2006).BiomedicalInformatics:ComputerApplicationsinHealthCareandBiomedicine.NewYork,NY,Springer.

Shortliffe,EHandCimino,JJ,Eds.(2014).BiomedicalInformatics:ComputerApplicationsinHealthCareandBiomedicine(FourthEdition).London,England,Springer.Sinsky,C,Colligan,L,etal.(2016).Allocationofphysiciantimeinambulatorypractice:atimeandmotionstudyin4specialties.AnnalsofInternalMedicine.165:753-760.Skochelak,SE,Hawkins,RE,etal.,Eds.(2017).HealthSystemsScience.NewYork,NY,Elsevier.Smith,M,Saunders,R,etal.(2012).BestCareatLowerCost:ThePathtoContinuouslyLearningHealthCareinAmerica.Washington,DC,NationalAcademiesPress.Stark,P(2010).CongressionalintentfortheHITECHAct.AmericanJournalofManagedCare.16:SP24-SP28.Stead,WW,Searle,JR,etal.(2011).Biomedicalinformatics:changingwhatphysiciansneedtoknowandhowtheylearn.AcademicMedicine.86:429-434.Tipping,MD,Forth,VE,etal.(2010).Systematicreviewoftimestudiesevaluatingphysiciansinthehospitalsetting.JournalofHospitalMedicine.5:353-359.Tipping,MD,Forth,VE,etal.(2010).Wheredidthedaygo?--atime-motionstudyofhospitalists.JournalofHospitalMedicine.5:323-328.Victores,AJ,Coggins,K,etal.(2015).Electronichealthrecordsandresidentworkflow:Atime-motionstudyofotolaryngologyresidents.Laryngoscope.125:594-598.Wachter,R(2016).MakingITwork:harnessingthepowerofhealthinformationtechnologytoimprovecareinEngland.London,England,NationalAdvisoryGrouponHealthInformationTechnologyinEngland.https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/using-information-technology-to-improve-the-nhsWangsness,L(2009).Electronichealthrecordsraisedoubt-Googleservice'sinaccuraciesmayholdwidelesson.Boston,MA.BostonGlobe.April13,2009.http://www.boston.com/news/nation/washington/articles/2009/04/13/electronic_health_records_raise_doubt/Weaver,CA,Delaney,CW,etal.,Eds.(2010).NursingandInformaticsforthe21stCentury-AnInternationalLookatPractice,Education,andEHRTrends,SecondEdition.Chicago,IL,HealthcareInformationManagementSystemsSociety.Wilson,PandMcEvoy,S(2012).HealthITJumpStart-YourBestFirstStepTowardaCareerinHealthIT.Hoboken,NJ,JohnWiley&Sons.Woolf,SH(2008).Themeaningoftranslationalresearchandwhyitmatters.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation.299:211-213.Yousefi,V(2011).HowCanadianhospitalistsspendtheirtime-awork-samplingstudywithinahospitalmedicineprograminOntario.JournalofClinicalOutcomesManagement.18:159-164.Zikopoulos,P,Eaton,C,etal.(2011).UnderstandingBigData:AnalyticsforEnterpriseClassHadoopandStreamingData.NewYork,NY,McGraw-Hill.

1

WhatisBiomedicalInformatics?

WilliamHersh,MD,FACP,FACMIProfessorandChair

DepartmentofMedicalInformatics&ClinicalEpidemiologyOregonHealth&ScienceUniversity

Portland,OR,USAEmail:[email protected]:www.billhersh.info

Blog:http://informaticsprofessor.blogspot.comTwitter:@williamhersh

1

Outline

• Termsanddefinitions• Recentgrowthandchange– HITECHandmeaningfuluse

• People• Resources• Educationandtraining

2

2

Whatisbiomedicalandhealthinformatics?

• IgetaskedthissooftenthatIkeepaWebsite– http://www.billhersh.info/whatis/

• Andablog– http://informaticsprofessor.blogspot.com

• Ihavealsowrittenarticlesaboutit– Medicalinformatics:improvinghealthcarethroughinformation

(Hersh,2002)– Buttherearebarriers(Hersh,2004)– Characterizationofandchangesintheprofession(Hersh,2006)– Manycareeropportunitiesaswell(Hersh,2008)– Reconcilingdefinitionsofterms(Hersh,2009)– Theinformaticsprofessionalworkforce(Hersh,2010)– Clinicalinformaticsinthecontextofhealthsystemsscience(Hersh,

2017)

3

Otherviews• Earlydefinition:“storage,acquisition,anduseofinformation”(Greenes,1990)

• Other(US)perspectives– “Thescienceofinformationappliedtobiomedicine…dataplusmeaning.” (Bernstam,2010)

– Paradigmshiftinbiomedicinefrom“individualbrainstosystemsofbrains” (Stead,2011)

– AMIA:“Theinterdisciplinaryfieldthatstudiesandpursuestheeffectiveusesofbiomedicaldata,information,andknowledgeforscientificinquiry,problemsolving,decisionmaking,motivatedbyeffortstoimprovehumanhealth”(Kulikowski,2012)

• Europeanandglobalperspectives(Haux,2010;Hasman,2011;Geissbuhler,2011)

4

3

Letusstartbydefining“informatics”

• Thedisciplinefocusedontheacquisition,storage,anduseofinformationinaspecificsettingordomain(Hersh,2009)– Ismoreaboutinformationthan

technology• Sometimesdefinedasactivity

attheintersectionofpeople,information,andtechnology

• Thescienceof“sociotechnicalsystems” (Coiera,2007)

5

(SUNYBuffalo)

Whatinformatics“isandisn’t”(Friedman,2012)

• Is– Cross-trainingwherebasic

informationalsciencesmeetabiomedicalapplicationdomain

– Relentlesspursuitofassistingpeople

– Towerofachievement• Modelformulation• Systemdevelopment• Systemimplementation• Studyofeffects

• Isn’t– Scientistsorclinicians

tinkeringwithcomputers– Analysisoflargedatasets

perse– Circumscribedrolesrelated

todeploymentofelectronichealthrecords(*pointofdisagreement)

– Professionofhealthinformationmanagement

– Anythingdoneusingacomputer

6

4

Ithasa“fundamentaltheorem” anda“goldenrule”

7

FundamentalTheorem(Friedman,2009)– basedon“relentlesspursuitofassistingpeople”

Goalofinformaticsis

Goalisnot

GoldenRule(Kuperman,personalcommunication,2013):

“Neverimplementuntoothersthatwhichyouwouldnotimplementuntoyourself”

Mycurrentpreferredterminology• Biomedicalandhealthinformatics(BMHI)isthefieldconcernedwiththeoptimaluseofinformation,oftenaidedbytechnology,toimproveindividualhealth,healthcare,publichealth,andbiomedicalresearch– Informaticsappliedinamorefocuseddomainis{X}informatics,e.g.,nursing,dental,pathology,primarycare,etc.

– Canbeclassifiedby“level” ofdomainbutalsohassomeoverarchingareas,e.g.,imagingandresearch

• PractitionersofBMHIareusuallycalledinformaticians (sometimesinformaticists)

8

5

Informaticsalsohasan“adjectiveproblem”

(Hersh,2009;adaptedfromShortliffe,2006)

Informatics=People+Information+Technology

BiomedicalandHealthInformaticsLegalInformatics Chemoinformatics

Bioinformatics(cellularandmolecular)

Clinical(orMedical)Informatics

(person)

{Clinicalfield}Informatics

PublicHealthInformatics(population)

ConsumerHealthInformatics

ImagingInformatics ResearchInformatics

9

Informaticsnowviewedasacorecompetencyforhealthprofessionals

• AccordingtoInstituteofMedicinereport,themodernhealthcareprofessionalmusthavecompetencyininformaticsaspartoflargergoaltoprovidepatient-centeredcare(Greiner,2003)

• Informaticscompetencyisnotjustcomputerliteracy!– The“Googlegeneration” does

notnecessarilyhavegoodinformationskills(CIBER,2008)

• Informaticsisacorecomponentofthe“learninghealthsystem”(Friedman,2010;Smith,2012)

10

6

Somehistoricalperspectiveoninformatics

• OriginoftermattributedtoDreyfusin1962(Fourman,2002)

• AchievedwidespreaduseinFrance(informatique),Russia,andlaterrestofEuropein1960stodenotecomputingissuesrelatedtoinformationuse

• “Medicalinformatics” firstusedin1974(Collen,1994)– MoreEuropeanhistoryfromMoehr (2004)– HistoryoffielddocumentedbyCollen(1995,2015)

• Atpresent,mostsignificantuseisinbiomedicalarena,butitisusedbyotherdomains,suchaslaw,chemistry,socialsciences,etc.

11

Howisinformaticsdistinguishedfromrelatedterms?

• Informationtechnology(IT)– computerandrelatedtechnology

• ComputerscienceisacademicdisciplinethatunderliesIT(andothertechnologies)

• ManagementinformationsystemsisanotherfieldunderlyingIT(usuallyinbusinessschools)

• Healthinformationtechnology(HITorhealthIT)– health-relatedapplicationofIT

12

7

Otherrelatedterms

• Healthinformationmanagement(HIM)–disciplinehistoricallyfocusedonmanagementof(paper)medicalrecords(changingincurrentenvironment),withthreemainlevelsofpractice– RegisteredHealthInformationAdministrator(RHIA)–highestlevel,baccalaureatedegree

– RegisteredHealthInformationTechnologist(RHIT)–associatedegree

– CertifiedCodingSpecialist(CCS)– usuallylessthenassociatedegree

13

Otherrelatedterms

• Informationandcommunicationstechnology(ICT)– sameasITwithaddedemphasisontelecommunications

• eHealth – useofICTforhealth• Telemedicine – provisionofhealthcarewhenparticipantsseparatedbytimeand/ordistance

• Telehealth – pursuitofhealthwhenseparatedbytimeand/ordistance

• mHealth – useofmobiledevicesforhealth

14

8

Otherrelatedterms• Evidence-basedmedicine(EBM)– theapplicationofthe

bestscientificevidenceinthemedicaldecision-makingprocess

• Evidence-basedpractice(EBP)– theapplicationofEBMinclinicalpractice

• Comparativeeffectivenessresearch(CER)– researchthatcomparesoneormorediagnosticortreatmentoptionstoevaluateeffectiveness,safetyoroutcomes(alsocalledpatient-centeredoutcomesresearch)

• Informationretrieval(alsoknownassearch,partoflargerknowledgemanagement)– thefielddevotedtosearching(mostlytext,mostlyknowledge-basedinformation)

15

Termsrelatedtomedical/clinicalrecords

• Electronichealthrecord(EHR)– patient’shealthrecordindigitalform– Hasmostlysupplantedelectronicmedicalrecord(EMR)

• Meaningfuluse– programofincentivesforEHRadoptioninUSrequiringthattheybeusedinwaysthatachievehealthcaregoals

• Personalhealthrecord(PHR)– personallycontrolledhealthrecord

• Healthinformationexchange(HIE)– exchangeofhealthinformationacrosstraditionalbusinessandotherboundaries(averb)– OrganizationmanagingHIEusedtobecalledaRegionalHealth

InformationOrganization (RHIO),nowcalledanHIE(anoun)

16

9

KeyaspectsoftheEHR

• Therecordanditsdata• Standards andinteroperability• Meaningfulusethroughclinicaldecisionsupport(CDS)andcomputerizedphysician/providerorderentry(CPOE)

• Implementationandevaluation• Privacy,security,andconfidentiality• Re-use(orsecondaryuse),includinganalytics,ofdata

17

ManyareextollingthevirtuesofBMHIinhealthcareandrelatedareas

• Mostprominentdiscussionhasfocusedonimprovinghealthcarethroughimprovedquality,safety,andefficiency

• However,therearemanychallenges– MixingITwithclinicalworkflowhasbeendifficult– SomeHIThasbeendeleterious– FinancialbenefitsofITdonotalwaysaccruetothosewhopay

– Largerproblemsinhealthcareorganizationandfinancingmakeanytypeofchangedifficult

18

10

Informaticsisalsoessentialformodernbiomedicalresearch

• EmbodiedintheNationalInstitutesofHealth(NIH)Roadmaptoacceleratebiomedicalresearchdiscovery(http://commonfund.nih.gov)– Today’sbiomedicalresearcherroutinelygenerates…billionsofbytesof

data.…Whatresearchersneedarecomputerprogramsandothertoolstoevaluate,combine,andvisualizethesedata.Insomecases,thesetoolswillgreatlybenefitfromtheawesomestrengthofsupercomputersorthecombinedpowerofmanysmallermachinesinacoordinatedwaybut,inothercases,thesetoolswillbeusedonmodernpersonalcomputersandworkstations.

• AlsopermeatesprioritiesofNIHDirector(Collins,2010)– High-throughputtechnologies– Translationalresearch– Supportinghealthcarereform– Globalhealth– Empoweringtheresearchcommunity

19

Informaticstermsforbiomedicalresearch

• Translationalresearch– classically,thetranslationofbasicresearchintoclinicalapplicability(“benchtobedside”),butalsofromcontrolledsettingstocommunityandpopulation(Woolf,2008)– Increasingrecognitionthatresearchfindingsmust“translate” intoclinicalcare

morequicklyandefficiently,leadingtoUSgovernmentinvestmentinclinicalandtranslationalresearchthroughtheNIHClinical&TranslationalScienceAward(CTSA)program(Leshner,2013)

– Translationalbioinformatics– bioinformaticsappliedtohealth-relatedproblems(Kann,2013)

• Precisionmedicine (IOM,2011;Collins,2015)– clinicalcaretailoredtoanindividual’scharacteristics,includingtheirgenome– Sometimescalledpersonalizedmedicine(Schleidgen,2013)

• Clinicalresearchinformatics(CRI)isareaofinformaticsappliedtoclinicalresearch(Richesson,2012)– Differencebetweeninformationtechnology(IT)andinformaticsvery

evidentinthisdomain(Bernstam,2009)

20

11

Wecannotignoretheessentialroleoftheconsumer/patient/citizen

• OriginalStrategicFrameworkoftheOfficeoftheNationalCoordinatorforHealthIT(ONC)calledforITtofacilitate“consumer-centric,information-rich” healthcare(Brailer,2004)

• SomeadvocatethatthePHRbeatthecenterofthediscussionconcerninghealthrecords(Krist,2011)– Manyissuesrelatedtoflowofinformationandresponsibilityfor

it• e-Patients – Internet-enabledpatients

– Originatedwithself-helpleader,Dr.TomFerguson(2007)– Bestknownise-PatientDave,whofoundagreatdealof

incorrectinformationinhismedicalrecordinBostonteachinghospitalandpublicizeditwidely(Wangsness,2009)

21

Afinalperspectiveofinformatics• Dataè Informationè Knowledge

– UsedinmanyfieldsbutintroducedininformaticsbyBlum(1984)

• Dataaretherawmaterialcollectedandstored• Informationgivesmeaningandorganizationtothedata

• Knowledgeprovidesunderstandingandapplicabilitytonewsituations

• Someaddwisdom,asknowinghowtoapplyknowledge(Rowley,2007)

22

12

Informaticsisincreasinglybecominga“datascience”

• EHR(andprobablyallinformatics)workchangingfrom“implementation”to“analytics”(Hersh,2012)

• Datascienceisthe“sexiestjobofthe21stcentury?”(Davenport,2012)

• Growingimportanceofroleforanalytics inhealthcare(Adams,2011;O’Reilly,2012;Hersh,2014)– Butwemustusecautiontomakesurethatclinicaldataiscomplete,correct,andotherwisesound(theroleofinformatics?)(Hersh,2013)

23

Wehaveenteredtheeraof“BigData”

• Four“V’s”ofBigData:volume,velocity,variety,andveracity(Zikopoulos,2011)

• Leadingtoanewparadigmofscience(Hey,2009)?– Makingthescientificmethodobsolete,i.e.,noneedfor

experimentationanymore?(Anderson,2007)– Notreally;manycaveatsforresearchuseofclinicaldata(Hersh,

2013)• OtherconcernsaboutdatascienceandBigData

– “Provocations”tostudyingdata(Boyd,2011)• Biggerisnotnecessarilybetter• Westudywhatwecananswer• Notalldataisavailableoraccessible

– Haven’tmanyfieldsbeendoingthisalready,e.g.,statistics(Donoho,2015)?

24

13

Ismedicine/healthreallyaninformationscience?

• Timestudiesofhospital(Ammenwerth,2009;Tipping,2010;Kim,2010;Tipping,2010;Yousefi,2011;Victores,2014)andemergency(Chisholm,2011)physiciansshowphysiciansspendabout– 15-38%oftheirtimeindirectpatientcare– 50-67%oftheirtimeinindirectpatientcare,dividedbetween

reviewingresults,performingdocumentation,andengagingincommunication

• Studiesofoutpatientphysiciansfind– 14-39%ofworktakesplaceoutsidetheexamroom(Gilchrist,

2005;Gottschalk,2005)– Workrelatedtopatientwhenhe/shenotpresentconsumes15-

23%ofphysicianworkday(Gottschalk,2005;Farber,2007;Chen,2010)

25

Evenmoreworkwithdataandinformationmorerecently

• StudiesineraofwidespreadEHRadoption– Internsinlightofdutyhoursrestrictionsfoundtospendlesstimein

directpatientcareandmoreintalkingwithotherphysiciansanddocumenting,withabout40%oftimespentinteractingwithcomputers(Block,2013)

– About60%ofinternistsreported“loss”ofaround48minutesperdayduetoEHRusage(McDonald,2014)

– Residentsinanacademicteachinghospitalfoundtospend50%oftimewithcomputersvs.10%timedirectlywithpatients(Mamykina,2016)

– PhysiciansfoundtospendtwohoursoftimedoingEHRanddesktimeforeveryhourofdirectpatienttime,plusanadditional1-2hourspernight(Sinsky,2016)

• Thesestudiesdon’tanswerwhatistherightamountoftime(Hersh,2013)

26

14

Pause

• Turntoyourneighboranddiscussoneofthefollowing– Describeactivityinyourworkthat

• Isinformatics• Isnotinformatics

– Doeshealthcaresystemnowspendtoomuchtimewithcomputers?

• Iwillaskforafewtovolunteeranswerstooneofthetwoquestions

27

Informaticshasgonefrom“dot-com”to“dot-gov”(Kleinke,2007)

• BushAdministration– Recognizedvalueofhealthinformationtechnology(HIT)– Actions:OfficeoftheNationalCoordinatorforHealthIT(ONC),AmericanHealthInformationCommunity(AHIC),etc.

• ObamaAdministration– TheAmericanRecovery&ReinvestmentAct(ARRA)of2009providedincentivesfor“meaningfuluse”ofelectronichealthrecords(EHRs)andtheinfrastructuretoachieveitthroughprovisionsoftheHealthInformationTechnologyforEconomicandClinicalHealth(HITECH)Act(Blumenthal,2011;Blumenthal,2011)

28

15

TheBushAdministrationstartedpromotionofthefield

• PresidentBushStateoftheUnion– mentionedeveryyearfrom2004to2008– January,2004– “Computerizinghealthrecords[can]reducecosts,improvecare,andlowertheriskofmedicalmistakes.”

– January,2007– “Weneedtoreducecostsandmedicalerrorswithbetterinformationtechnology.”

• Bushalsosetgoalofelectronichealthrecords(EHRs)forhalfofallAmericansby2014(WhiteHouse,2005)

29

TheObamaAdministrationuppedtheante

“Toimprovethequalityofourhealthcarewhileloweringitscost,wewillmaketheimmediateinvestmentsnecessarytoensurethatwithinfiveyears,allofAmerica’smedicalrecordsarecomputerized…Itjustwon’tsavebillionsofdollarsandthousandsofjobs– itwillsavelives.”

January,2009

16

OtherUSgovernmentagenciesandentitiesinvolvedinhealthIT

• NationalLibraryofMedicine(NLM,www.nlm.nih.gov)andotherinstitutesoftheNationalInstitutesofHealth(NIH)– NLMleaderinfundingresearchandtrainingininformatics– ReaffirmedwithappointmentofnewleaderandincorporationofNIHdata

scienceactivities(Brennan,2016;Brennan,2016)• AgencyforHealthcareResearch&Quality(AHRQ,www.ahrq.gov)

– Fundsresearchandpolicydevelopment,produceshealthITinformationresources

• CentersforMedicareandMedicaidServices(CMS,www.cms.hhs.gov)– Payor forMedicareandMedicaid,includingHITECHincentives

• NationalCommitteeforVital&HealthStatistics(NCVHS,www.ncvhs.hhs.gov)– Governmentadvisoryboard,includingissuesrelatedtohealthIT

31

TheObamaAdministrationledusintoanew“ARRA”ofhealthIT

• Viewedbysomeasa“downpayment”onhealthcarereform

– ARRAincludedtheHITECHAct– Incentivesfor“meaningfuluse”ofEHRsbyphysiciansandhospitalsstartingin2011(upto$27B)

– Directgrantsadministeredbyfederalagencies($2B)– AlsoHIT-relatedprovisionsinotherareasofARRA,e.g.,

• Comparativeeffectivenessresearch• NIHandotherresearchfunding• Broadbandandotherinfrastructurefunding

32

17

ONCenhancementsduringObamaAdministration

• AppointedDr.DavidBlumenthalasthirdNationalCoordinatorforHIT– Awell-knownHarvardhealth

policyleaderwithinformaticsresearchcredentials

– LedinitialimplementationofHITECHAct(Blumenthal,2011;Blumenthal,2011)

– Followedbysubsequentothers– Currentstrategicplan(2015)

• “PuttingtheI inHealthIT”–www.healthit.gov http://www.healthit.gov/policy-researchers-

implementers/health-it-strategic-planning

Whatis“meaningfuluse?”

• Conceptintroducedinthe2007-2008Congress,HR6898:Health-eInformationTechnologyActof2008butnotpassedatthattimebyStark(2011)

• ItisnotenoughtouseEHRsbutmustusetheminmeaningfulwaystoachievegoalsofhealthcaresystem• Achievingcriteriatiedtofivegoalsforhealthcare• EHRsmustbecertified,abletoexchangeinformation,andabletoreportonclinicalqualitymeasures

34

18

HITECHinfrastructure

• http://www.healthit.gov/policy-researchers-implementers/health-it-adoption-programs

• HITRegionalExtensionCenters(RECs)– $677milliontofund62RECsthatprovideguidance,mainlytosmallprimarycarepracticesandcriticalaccesshospitals,inachievingmeaningfuluse(Maxson,2010)

• State-basedhealthinformationexchange(HIE)– $547millioningrantstostatestodevelopHIEprograms

• Workforcedevelopment– $118millionfor– Communitycollegeconsortia($70M)– CurriculumDevelopmentCenters($10M)– Competencytesting($6M)– University-basedtraininggrants($32M)

35

HITECHinfrastructure(cont.)• StrategicHealthITAdvancedResearchProjects(SHARP)Program– stillaneedforresearch;$60Mforfourcollaborativeresearchcenters– SecurityandHealthInformationTechnology– Patient-CenteredCognitiveSupport– SecondaryUseofEHRInformation– HealthCareApplicationandNetworkDesign

• Mostperseveringofthese,hasledtotheSMARTframework(Mandl,2012)

• BeaconProgram– shiningthelightforwardwith$250Mfunding17advanceddemonstrationprojects(Maxson,2010;McKethan,2011)

36

19

Thereisstillplentyofroomforfree-marketeers

• HITindustryestimatedtoreach– $228Boverallgloballyby2020,with13.4%annualgrowthrate

(Markets&Markets,2015)– $84Bformobilesolutionsgloballyby2020,with28.4%annual

growthrate(Markets&Markets,2015)– $18.7Bfordataanalyticsgloballyby2020(Markets&Markets,

2015)• Manyinvestmentactivities,e.g.,

– RockHealth– http://rockhealth.com– NewYorkDigitalHealthAccelerator–

http://digitalhealthaccelerator.com– MassachusettsDigitalHealthInitiative–

http://massdigitalhealth.org– CambiaGrove– www.cambiagrove.com

37

HITisnotlimitedtotheUnitedStates

• England– NHSConnectingforHealth– Mostambitiousinworldbutultimatelyfailedafterspending$18billionfor

developingnationwideEHRsandHIE(Brennan,2007;Hayes,2008;Payne,2011;NHS,2011)

– Morerecentapproachesbasedonscaled-backgoals(Wachter,2016)• Denmark

– Near-universaladoptionofEHRsandothertechnologies(Protti,2010)• CanadaHealthInfoway

– http://www.infoway-inforoute.ca/• SingaporeNationalEHR(Accenture,2012)

– https://www.moh.gov.sg/content/moh_web/home/Publications/educational_resources/2015/national-electronic-health-record--nehr-.html

• Argentina(Quiros,2009)• AustraliaMyHealthRecord

– https://myhealthrecord.gov.au/internet/mhr/publishing.nsf/content/home

38

20

UShasbeenalaggardbutisnowcatchingup

39

(Osborn,2015)

(Henry,2016)

Informaticsalsorequiresustoaddressharmsandlimitations

• IOMHITsafetyreportdocumentedconcernsaboutdangers(2012)

• Keyissuestoaddressareworkflow(Carayon,2010)andusability(Lowry,2012)

• EHRmustmovefrombeingamonolithic,transaction-basedapplicationtoaplatform(Glaser,2012;Mandl,2012)

• HasEHRunderminedmedicineorarewein“transitionalchaos”(Rosenbaum,2015;Martin,2016)?

40

21

Pause

• Turntoadifferentneighboranddescribeactivitiesinyourworkthat– Showedthebenefitofinformatics– Showedsomeharmfrominformatics

• Iwillaskforafewtovolunteertheiranswers

41

Whodoesbiomedicalandhealthinformatics?

• Opportunitiesfortheinformaticsworkforce• Whatweknowaboutthehealthinformationtechnology(HIT)workforce

• Whatweknowaboutinformaticsleaders• Educationandcertification• HITsalaries• Informaticscompetenciesforinformaticiansandnon-informaticians

42

22

Opportunitiesfortheinformaticsworkforce

• Mostprevalentinclinicalinformatics,butplentyofotheropportunityinotherareasofinformatics– Bioinformatics– leadingandassisting

computationalanalysisofgenomicsandrelatedtechnologies

– Clinicalandtranslationalresearch– usinginformaticstoaidbiomedicalresearch

– Publichealth– usinginformationtoprotectthepublicandpromotehealth

– Consumerhealth– helpingthegeneralpopulationmaintainandimprovehealth

– Imaginginformatics– usingimagesforbiomedicalresearch,clinicalcare,etc.

43

WhyisitcriticaltohaveacompetentHITworkforce(Hersh,2010)?

• SeniorHITleaderspersistentlyliststaffingconcernsamongtheirmostimportant– Chiefinformationofficers(CIOs)state“clinicalsoftwareimplementationandsupport” astheirtopneed(CHIME,2012)

– Keybarrierinmeetingpriorities;topneedsincludeclinicalapplicationsupport,network/architecturesupport,andclinicalinformaticsprofessionals(HIMSS,2014)

• HIThasa“talentshortage”(HealthITJobs.com,2015)• Growingroleofphysicians(Shaffer,2016;SSiSearch,2015),includingnewclinicalinformaticssubspecialty(Detmer,2014);nurses(Manos,2012;HIMSS,2014);andothers,includingnon-clinicians(Fenton,2012)

44

23

Needsforworkforce(Fenton,2012)

• SurveyofTexasHITemployersfoundneedfor“diverseknowledgeandskillsrangingfrombasictoadvanced,whilecoveringinformationtechnology,privacyandsecurity,clinicalpractice,needsassessment,contractnegotiation,andmanyotherareas.”

• Consistentthemes– employeesmust– Beabletolearnonthejob– Possesstheabilitytothinkcriticallyandproblemsolve– Havetechnicalskills,yetalsoknowledgeandunderstandingofhealthcareoperations

• EmployersuncertainaboutcareerpathwaysandadvancementinHIT

45

WhatweknowabouttheHITworkforce(Hersh,2010)

• Limitedbylackofpresenceinfederallaborstatistics(StandardOccupationalClassification),whichmaybechanging(AMIA,2016)

• Traditionalgroupingsofprofessionalsinhealthcare– Informationtechnology(IT)– usuallywithcomputerscienceorinformationsystemsbackground

– Healthinformationmanagement(HIM)– historicalfocusonmedicalrecords

– Clinicalinformatics(CI)– oftenfromhealthcarebackgrounds,performinganalysis,training,etc.

– Others– librarians,managers,etc.• Whatdothedatashow?

46

24

HIMSS2014WorkforceSurvey• About79%reportedplanstohireinthefollowingyearin2013survey,

with84%reportingthattheydidactually• About82%reportedplanningtohirein2014,withabouthalfplanningto

hire1-5FTEandtheremainderplanningtohiremore(10%plantohiremorethan20FTE!)

• Tophiringneedsforproviderorganizations– ClinicalApplicationSupport- 64%– HelpDesk- 57%– ITManagement- 45%– ProjectManagement- 35%– ITSecurity- 34%

• Tophiringneedsforvendorsandconsultants– Sales/MarketingTeam- 78%– FieldSupportStaff- 75%– SupportStaff- 73%– ExecutiveTeam- 60%

47

DemandstrongforexperiencedHITstaff(CHIME,2012)

• Skillsmostoftenindemand– Clinicalsoftwareimplementationandsupportstaff(e.g.,EHR,CPOE)– 74%

– Infrastructurestaff– 47%– Businesssoftwareimplementationandsupportstaff– 45%

• 71%saidITstaffshortagescouldjeopardizeanenterpriseITproject,while58%saidtheywoulddefinitelyorpossiblyaffectmeetingmeaningfulusecriteriaforincentivefunding

• 85%alsoexpressedconcernsaboutbeingabletoretaincurrentstaff

48

25

HIM• HIMisafieldintransition,withleadershippromotingadvancedskills,degrees,andwork(Calhoun,2012;Kloss,2012)– Careermap– http://hicareers.com– Callto“adaptordisappear”(Butler,2014)

• HIMisonlyinformatics-relatedareaseeninUSBureauofLaborStatistics(BLS)data– Occupationalemploymentprojections2014-2024(BLS,2015)

• MedicalRecordsandHealthInformationTechnicians(RHITandCCS)– about188,600employedin2014,increasingby29,000by2024(15%growth)

– RHIAs andotherrolesnotcountedinthesenumbers

49

Clinicalinformatics• Individualswhobringskillsatintersectionofhealthcare

andIT(Hersh,2010)• BecominghardertodistinguishfromIT(HealthITJobs.com,

2015)– “TheprimaryskillgapinhealthcareIT-- specificallyClinicalSystems(EMR/EHR)-- isthatmostleadersarelookingforemployeeswithbothhands-onclinicalexperienceandtechnicalexpertise.Historically,thesehavebeentwoveryseparateskillsets.”

• Estimatesofneed– OnephysicianandnurseineachUShospital(~10,000)(Safran,

2005)– Probablymuchlarger– manyUShospitalsnowhaveclinical

informaticsdepartments,oftenreportingtoChiefMedicalInformaticsOfficer(CMIO)(Shaffer,2016)

50

26

Certificationofphysiciansandothers

• PhysiciansubspecialtycertificationapprovedbyAmericanBoardofMedicalSpecialtiesin2011(Detmer,2014),basedoncorecurriculum(Gardner,2009)andtrainingrequirements(Safran,2009)– Subspecialtyofallmedicalspecialties– “Grandfathering” oftrainingrequirementsinitially,tobefollowedby

formalfellowshipsafter2022(originally2017;extendedin2016)– CertificationfirstofferedinOctober,2013– nowover1300passed– http://www.amia.org/clinical-informatics-medical-subspecialty– http://www.theabpm.org/abpm_clinical_informatics.pdf

• Neededordesiredforothers?– AMIAHealthInformaticsCertification(AHIC)TaskForcehasdeveloped

plansforcertificationofotherhealthprofessionalsininformatics(Gadd,2016;Gadd,2016)

• https://www.amia.org/advanced-health-informatics-certification

51

Pause

• Turntoaneighboranddescribeaninstanceinyourworkwhereinformaticsexpertisecontributedtoimprovingsomeaspectofyourorganization’sactivities

• Iwillaskforafewtovolunteertheanswers

52

27

Resourcesforfield

• Organizations• Information• Education

53

Otherprofessionalorganizations• AmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation(AMIA)– www.amia.org

• HealthcareInformationandManagementSystemsSociety(HIMSS)–www.himss.org

• AmericanHealthInformationManagementAssociation(AHIMA)–www.ahima.org

• AssociationofMedicalDirectorsofInformationSystems(AMDIS)–www.amdis.org

• AllianceforNursingInformatics(ANI)– www.allianceni.org• PublicHealthInformaticsInstitute(PHII)– www.phii.org• InternationalSocietyforComputationalBiology(ISCB)– www.iscb.org• SocietyforImagingInformaticsinMedicine(SIIM)– www.siim.org• AssociationforComputingMachinery(ACM)– www.acm.org• MedicalLibraryAssociation(MLA)– www.mlanet.org

54

28

Importantroleforgovernmentagencies

• NationalLibraryofMedicine(NLM)hasbeenhistoricleaderinresearchandtraining– www.nlm.nih.gov– OtherinstitutesofNationalInstitutesofHealth(NIH)havesupported

informaticsinvariousways• AgencyforHealthcareResearch&Quality(AHRQ)hasfocusedonapplied

clinicalinformatics– www.ahrq.gov

• OfficeoftheNationalCoordinatorforHealthIT(ONC)hasledhealthITandstandardsadoption– www.healthit.gov

• CriticalroleofotherfederalagenciesinDept.ofHealthandHumanServices,e.g.,– CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention(CDC)– CentersforMedicareandMedicaidServices(CMS)– FoodandDrugAdministration(FDA)

55

Medicalandnursingspecialtysocieties(non-exhaustive)

• AmericanMedicalAssociation(AMA)– www.ama-assn.org

• AmericanNursesAssociation(ANA)–www.nursingworld.org

• AssociationofAmericanMedicalColleges(AAMC)–www.aamc.org

• AmericanCollegeofPhysicians(ACP)–www.acponline.org

• AmericanAcademyofFamilyPhysicians(AAFP)–www.aafp.org

56

29

Wheredoesonefindmoreinformation?Textbooks

• Shortliffe andCimino (eds.),BiomedicalInformatics:ComputerApplicationsinHealthCareandBiomedicine(4thEdition),Springer,2014

• HoytandYoshihashi (eds.),HealthInformatics:PracticalGuideforHealthcareandInformationTechnologyProfessionals(6th Edition),Lulu.com,2014

• Sengstack andBoicey,MasteringInformatics:AHealthcareHandbookforSuccess,SigmaThetaTauInternational,2015

• Abdelhak etal.,HealthInformation:ManagementofaStrategicResource (5th Edition),Saunders,2015

• LaTour andEichenwald,HealthInformationManagement–Concepts,Principles,andPractice(3rd Edition),AHIMA,2013

• SaylesandTrawick,IntroductiontoComputerSystemsforHealthInformationTechnology (2nd Edition),AHIMA,2014

• WilsonandMcEvoy,HealthITJumpStart- YourBestFirstStepTowardaCareerinHealthIT.Wiley,2012

57

Wheredoesonefindmoreinformation(cont.)?Textbooks

• Weaveretal.(eds.),NursingandInformaticsforthe21stCentury,HIMSS,2010• Richesson andAndrews(eds.),ClinicalResearchInformatics,Springer,2012• Kann andLewitter (eds).TranslationalBioinformatics,PLoS,2013• MagnusonandFu(eds.),PublicHealthInformaticsandInformationSystems (2nd Edition),Springer,

2014• BuiandTaira (eds.),MedicalImagingInformatics,Springer,2010• Hersh,InformationRetrieval:AHealthandBiomedicalPerspective (3rd Edition),Springer,2009• BerkowitzandMcCarthy,InnovationwithInformationTechnologiesinHealthcare,Springer,2012• Berner (ed.),InformaticsEducationinHealthcare:LessonsLearned,Springer,2014• Sarkar,(ed.),MethodsinBiomedicalInformatics:APragmaticApproach,AcademicPress,2014• Lesk,IntroductiontoBioinformatics (4th Edition),OxfordUniversityPress,2014• Giannangelo,K,(ed.),HealthcareCodeSets,ClinicalTerminologies,andClassificationSystems,Third

Edition.Chicago,IL,2015• ReddyandAgarwal(eds.),HealthcareDataAnalytics,Chapman&Hall,2015• BensonandGrieve,PrinciplesofHealthInteroperability- SNOMEDCT,HL7andFHIR,ThirdEdition.

Springer,2016• Dixon,B(ed.).HealthInformationExchange- NavigatingandManagingaNetworkofHealth

InformationSystems.Amsterdam,Netherlands,Elsevier,2016• Skochelak etal.(eds.).HealthSystemsScience.Elsevier,2017

58

30

Moreinformation(cont.),Journals

• JournalofAMIA (JAMIA,http://jamia.oxfordjournals.org)• JournalofMedicalInternetResearch(JMIR)• AppliedClinicalInformatics(ACI)• InternationalJournalofMedicalInformatics (IJMI)• JournalofBiomedicalInformatics (JBI)• MethodsofInformationinMedicine (MIM)• Bioinformatics• JournalofDigitalImaging (JDI)• BiomedCentral(BMC,www.biomedcentral.com)

– BMCMedicalInformaticsandDecisionMaking– BMCBioinformatics

59

Moreinformation(cont.),Meetings

• AMIA-relatedmeetings– AMIAAnnualSymposium– AMIASummitsonTranslationalSciences– AMIAiHealth– Medinfo (biennial)

• Otherclinicalinformaticsmeetings– HIMSS,nationalmeetingandlocalchapters– AMDISPhysician-ComputerConnection

• Bioinformaticsmeetings– PacificSymposiumonBiocomputing (PSB)– InternationalSocietyforComputationalBiology(ISCB)

60

31

Moreinformation(cont.),Websites

• USgovernment– NLM– www.nlm.nih.gov,includingwww.pubmed.gov– HHSONC– www.healthit.gov– AHRQNationalResourceCenterforHealthIT–

http://healthit.ahrq.gov– HRSAHealthITToolbox– partofAHRQNationalResource– USHealthInformationKnowledgebase– http://ushik.ahrq.gov

• Other– HITECHAnswers– www.hitechanswers.net– Clinfowiki – http://clinfowiki.org– ElectronicMedicalInformaticsRepositoryofResources(e-MIR2;

delaCalle,2012)– http://www.gib.fi.upm.es/eMIR2/

61

Moreinformation(cont.),emaillistsandblogs

• Emaillists– HISTalk – http://histalk2.com– HITStrategist–

http://www.modernhealthcare.com/section/HITSarchive/– FromorganizationssuchasAMIA,HIMSS,AMDIS,etc.

• Blogs– (many!)– GeekDoctor(JohnHalamka,MD)–

http://geekdoctor.blogspot.com– HealthcareStandards(KeithBoone)–

http://motorcycleguy.blogspot.com– HealthITBuzz(ONC)– http://www.healthit.gov/buzz-blog/– TheHealthcareBlog– http://thehealthcareblog.com– InformaticsProfessor(Hersh)–

http://informaticsprofessor.blogspot.com

62

32

Moreinformation(cont.),acronyms

• Alwaysasked,sohereisalist– HITECHAnswers–http://www.hitechanswers.net/ehr-adoption-2/key-acronyms/

– AMIA– https://www.amia.org/glossary– Shortliffe glossary,whichincludesacronyms(2014)–http://people.dbmi.columbia.edu/shortliffe/docs/Glossary%20-%204th%20ed.pdf

– Wikipedia–https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_abbreviations_used_in_health_informatics

63

Educationandtrainingininformatics

• Educationhashistoricallyfocusedonacademicsbuthasbeenexpandingtomeettheneedsandopportunitiesofpractitionersandusers

• Anever-growingnumberofprogramsatassociate,baccalaureate,andgraduatelevels– Alsoshorter,continuingeducationcourses,suchas10x10(“tenby

ten”)– https://dmice.ohsu.edu/hersh//10x10.html• Informaticsprogramscomeinmanyflavors:medical,clinical,

biomedical,health,bio-,nursing,etc.• MajorfunderofprogramsisNLM,whichfundsfellowshipstotrain

futureresearchersatdoctoralandpostdoctorallevels• NewAccreditationCouncilforGraduateMedicalEducation

(ACGME)-accreditedclinicalfellowshipprogramsemerging– ~20accreditedand~10launched

64

33

Academicprograms• ListofUSinformatics

programsonAMIAWebsite– http://www.amia.org/educati

on/programs-and-courses• Internationalcompendiumof

programsatHealthInformaticsWorldwide(HIWW)– www.hiww.org

• NLM-fundedprograms– http://www.nlm.nih.gov/ep/G

rantTrainInstitute.html

65

Inventoryofcompetenciesforvariousgroups(Hersh,2010)

• Competenciesdifferbygroup– Informaticians

• Developing,implementing,andevaluatingsystems

• Makingoptimaluseofinformation

• RecentelucidationofcorecompetenciesbyAMIA(Kulikowski,2012)

– Clinicians• Applyinginformaticsindelivery

ofcare• Competenciesformedical

education(Hersh,2014)– Patients

• Healthinformationliteracy

66

…

34

Clinicalinformaticseducationforclinicians

Startedwithmedicalstudents(Hersh,2014),butinrealityapplicabletoallclinicalstudentsandprofessionals

Partoflargerhealthsystemsscience(Skochelak,2017;Hersh,2017)

67

Careerpathwayshavediverseinputsandoutputs(Hersh,2009)

68

Healthcareprofessions,e.g.,medicine,nursing,etc.

Naturalandlifesciences,e.g.,biology,genetics,etc.

Computerscience(CS),IT,andundergradinformatics

Healthinformationmanagement(HIM)

Others,e.g.,business,libraryandinfo.science

Jobsin:• Healthcaresystems

• Clinicalleadership• ITleadership

• Biomedicalresearch• Industry• Academia

Biomedicalandhealthinformaticseducation(graduatelevel)

Thereisnosinglecareerpathway,ladder,etc.

Therearemanycareeropportunitiesinmanysettingsforalltracks

35

Example:OHSUinformaticshttp://www.ohsu.edu/informatics

69

International students from: Argentina, Singapore, Egypt, Israel, Saudi Arabia, Zimbabwe, Thailand, China, and other countries

Track Degree/Certificate PhD MS MBI GradCert

ClinicalInformatics On-campusOn-campus

On-line

On-campus

On-line

On-campus

On-line

Bioinformatics andComputationalBiology

On-campus On-campus

DegreesAwarded1998-2016(653people)Track CI BCB TotalCertificate 406 0 406MBI/MMI 190 8 198MS 72 16 88PhD 18 6 24Total 686 30 716

HowhaveOHSUstudentsandgraduatesdone?

• About25yearsofexperience…• Generalobservation:Whatpeopledowhentheygraduateispartiallydependentonwhattheydidwhentheyentered,e.g.,– Physicians,nurses,publichealth,etc.drawontheirclinical/professionalbackground

– Informationtechnologyprofessionalsdrawontheiruniquebackgroundandexperience

• Graduateshaveobtainedjobsinavarietyofsettings,e.g.,clinical,academic,andindustry

• Someobtainjobsbeforefinishingprogram

70

36

Conclusions

• Theseareexcitingtimesforbiomedicalandhealthinformatics,withmanyopportunitiesinawidevarietyofsettings

• Attentionmustalsobepaidtotheprofessionalpracticeandeducationofinformaticians

• Butthemainfocusofthefieldmustbehowtooptimallyuseinformationandtechnologyproperlytoadvancehumanhealthandimprovedeliveryofhealthcare

71