Cyber Emotions Research Institute WCU Webometrics Ins titute Webometrics Analaysis of Local Media in South Korea : Focused on University students Presented by Jiyoung Park & Kim Se Jung Park P h . D . S tu d e n t, G e o rg ia S tate U n ive rs ity, U S A Han Woo Park D ire c to r, C yb e r E m o tio n s R e s e arc h C e n te r Associate Professor, Yeungnam University, South Korea Cyber Emotions Research Institute WCU Webometrics Ins titute Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Webometrics Analaysis of Local Media in South Korea : Focused on University
students
Pres ented by J iyoung Park & Kim
S e J ung ParkPh .D . S tu d e nt, Ge o rg ia S tate U n ive rs ity, U S A
Han Woo ParkD ire c to r, C yb e r Em o tio ns Re s e arch C e nte r
As s o c iate Pro fe s s o r, Ye ungnam U n ive rs ity, S o uth Ko re a
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Introduc tion
• In th e s m art s o c ie ty, m e d ia e nviro nm e nt
has c hange d and m e d ia c o m p an ie s
have u tilize d th e Inte rne t as an
alte rnative c hanne l.
• H o w d o lo c al m e d ia b e ing p e rc e ive d
am o ng re s id e nts and d o p e o p le s atis fy
th e ir s e rvic e s ?
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
D ae gu
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Res earc h objec tives• Id e ntifying aud ie nc e p re fe re nc e , s atis fac tio n o f
re g io nal m e d ia c o m p an ie s in D ae gu and
Gye o ngb uk are a
• Me as uring in d ire c t p e rc e p tio n o f u s e rs u s ing s o c ial
ne two rk analys is b y d is c o ve ring th e h id d e n ne two rk
• To p ro vid e a c o m p re he ns ive d e s c rip tio n o f
c irc um s tanc e s and o nline p re s e nc e s o f lo c al m e d ia
in S o u th Ko re a fro m aud ie nc e - o rie nte d ap p ro ac h
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Literature Review- S tud ie s on loc al me d ia in S outh Kore a
•H an(2003) In s p ite o f th e im p o rtanc e o f re g io nal jo urnalis m , th e re is little ac ad e m ic in te re s t and s tu d ie s o n lo c al m e d ia, s o it is d iffic u lt to figure o u t its s o c ial c o ns e q ue nc e s .
•Kim & Kim (1 990) Exis te d s tu d ie s e xam in ing re g io nal jo urnalis m have fo c us e d o n ge ne ral re m arks . The re s e arc h to p ic , m e tho d s are to o narro w to fu lly und e rs tand lo c al m e d ia its e lf.
•S e o l(2003) Mo s t e xis te d s tu d ie s have m ainly analize d m ajo r b ro ad c as ting c o m p an ie s in s te ad o f lo c al m e d ia in d ive rs e re g io ns .
•Ahn, e t al.(2006) To re fle c t the ne e d s o f c o m m un itie s and s tre ngthe n the c o m p e titive ne s s o f lo c al m e d ia, th e s tu d y fro m an aud ie nc e ap p ro ac h is ne c e s s ary,
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Res earc h Q ues tions
- To what e xte nt d o s tu d e nts p re fe r e ac h
m e d ia (newsp ap ers, b road castings & cab le televisio ns) in D ae gu and Gye o ngb uk are a?
- Is th e re c o rre latio n b e twe e n o ffline and
o nline p re fe re nc e ?
- To what e xte nt d o s tu d e nts s atis fy th e
we b s ite s o f th e e ac h Me d ia?
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Method
• Online s urvey
• S oc ial Network Analys is( Webometric s & Hyperlink Analys is )
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Online s urvey- Data c o lle c tion•O nline s urve ry
(Stud ent click the web site in terms o f p reference and satisfaction on online )
- 1 74 U n ive rs ity s tu d e nts in D ae gu & Gye o ngb uk are a u s ing c o nve n ie nc e s am p ling
e g)S tud e nt p artic ip atio n d uring c las s
- Ave rage age o f re s p o nd e nts : 26 ye ar o ld .
•Me as ure me nt - Pre fe re nc e :Rank fro m m o s t to le as t
- We b s ite s atis fac tio n :1 1 like rt s cale
•S tatis tic s- Pe ars o n c o rre latio n
- O ne - way ANO VA
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
A lis t of media c ompaniesPresented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
• 6 ne ws p ap e rs
• 7 b ro ad c as ting s tatio ns
(3TVs /4rad io s )
• 8 c ab le te le vis io ns
Us e population not S ample: C overing a ll the loc al Media in Daegu & G yungbuk
area
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
S oc ial Network Anlays is
Webometic Network Analys is Webometic Network Analys is WebWeb oo metric smetric s = = World Wide Web World Wide Web ++ Metric sMetric s
- Co- link analys is
•To re ve al hidden network s truc ture fro m an aggre gatio n le ve l•C o lle c ting c o - link d ata fro m Le xiU RL s o ftware
A B
C
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
Hiden network
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Res ultsRes ults
1. online s urvey 1. online s urvey
2. Webometric Network Analys is2. Webometric Network Analys is
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
Res ults : news paper 1.
- Pre fe re nc e s fo r ne ws p ap e rs
Daegu Daegu Daily
Maeil Yeongnam Daily
Weekly L ife Palgong
8.9% 3.8% 54.8% 30.6% 0.0% 1 .9%
- Pre fe re nc e s fo r we b s ite s o f ne ws p ap e rs
Daegu Daegu Daily
Maeil Yeongnam Daily
Weekly Life Palgong
1 0.8% 3.6% 49.6% 27.3% 5.8% 2.9%
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
- Pe ars o n c o rre latio n analys is
O ffline p re fe re nc e
O nline p re fe re nc e .721 * *
N= 852, * * p < .01
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
Res ults : news paper 2.
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
- We b s ite s atis fac tio ns o f ne ws p ap e rs
D ae gu D ae gu
D aily
Mae il Ye o ngnam
D aily
We e kly Life Palgo ng
5.9
(N= 1 27)
5.8
(N= 1 29)
6.7
(N= 1 27)
6.7
(N= 1 28)
6.0
(N= 1 29)
5.3
(N= 1 27)
- Re s u lts o f ANO VA
S um o f S q uare s d f Me an S q uare F S ig .
Be twe e n Gro up s 1 85.709 5 37.1 42 1 0.633* * .000
With in Gro up s 2658.205 761 3.493
To tal 2843.91 4 766
* * p < .01
N= 1 57
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
Res ults : news paper 3.
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
- Pre fe re nc e s fo r b ro ad c as ting s tatio n
- Pre fe re nc e s fo r we b s ite s o f b ro ad c as ting s tatio ns
N= 1 1 8.
MBC KBS TBC C BS BBS PBC TBN
56.0% 1 1 .3% 24.7% 2.7% 0.7% 0.7% 4.0%
N= 1 50
MBC KBS TBC C BS BBS PBC TBN
55.9% 1 3.6% 20.3% 5.9% 1 .7% 0.8% 1 .7%
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
Res ults : broadc as ting s tation 1.
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
- Pears on c orrelation analys is
N= 854, * * p < .01
O ffline and o nline c hanne ls are p o s itive ly c o rre late d
O fflin e p re fe re nc e
O nline p re fe re nc e .754* *
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
Res ults : broadc as ting s tation 2.
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute
- We b s ite s atis fac tio ns o f b ro ad c as ting s tatio ns
MBC TBC KBS TBN C BS BBS PBC
7.2
(N= 1 1 4)
6.9
(N= 1 1 4)
6.9
(N= 1 1 4)
6.3
(N= 1 1 5)
6.1
(N= 1 1 2)
5.5
(N= 1 1 4)
5.4
(N= 1 1 3)
- Re s u lts o f ANO VA
S um o f S q uare s d f Me an S q uare F S ig .
Be twe e n Gro up s 354.21 8 6 59.036 1 7.321 * * .000
With in Gro up s 2699.399 792 3.408
To tal 3053.61 7 798
* * p < .01
Presented at 2011 SICSS, Shanghai, 18 Aug 2011
Res ults : broadc as ting s tation 3.
C yber E motions Res earc h Ins titute WC U Webometric s Ins titute