Vujacic, Veljko (2004) Perceptions of the State in Russia and Serbia

7/26/2019 Vujacic, Veljko (2004) Perceptions of the State in Russia and Serbia

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/vujacic-veljko-2004-perceptions-of-the-state-in-russia-and-serbia 1/31

!"#

!"#$%&"'()$ +,,-(.#! #$$%! $%! $! &&' ()%*(+%',-&./0123 4 #$$% 5. 6' 7' 809:3-9 ; <-9! =9>' ?@@ /0123: /A:A/BAC'

&'()'*+,-./ -1 +2' 3+4+'

,. 56//,4 4.7 3'(8,49:2' 5-;' -1 <7'4/ ,. +2'3-=,'+ 4.7 >6?-/;4= @-;;4*/'A';BC- A6B4),)!

? :->0-@-10:3 D2-:A E/AE -F AG&A/30:A 0: >-HHI90:H E9C 9E30-9E@0:H AGEH09A: 32A>EI:A: -F <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB C0::-@I30-9! D032 :&A>0E@ E33A930-9 3- &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@FE>3-/:' L2A D-/M -F <A/50E9 E9C NI::0E9 093A@@A>3IE@: 0: I:AC E: 32A 5E:0: F-/ AGEH0K9E30-9 -F 32A C0FFA/A93 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ E3303ICA: -F NI::0E9: E9C <A/5: 3-DE/C: 32A:3E3A! 20:3-/0>E@@. E9C CI/091 32A 3DA930A32K>A93I/. 5/AEMI&: -F 32A:A HI@309E30-9E@:3E3A:'

?9C .A3 32A <3E3A 03:A@F! 32-I12 E>>A&3AC 5. 32A &A-&@A E: E 9A>A:K:E/.! FE3E@ E9C I9EB-0CE5@A &/09>0&@A! DE: ABA/ /A1E/CAC E: :-HAK32091 F-/A019! E@H-:3 2-:30@A 3- 32A O2IHE9 :-I@'P 7A/A DA 2EBA3-I>2AC 32A 0@@-10>E@! E@H-:3 I9AG&@E09E5@A! &:.>2-@-10>E@ &E/EKC-G -F 32A NI::0E9 &A-&@A' Q-/ >A93I/0A: 2EC 32A NI::0E9 >E//0AC-9 20: :2-I@CA/: 32A >/I:2091 5I/CA9 -F 5I0@C091 E :3E3A! F-/>A93I/0A: 2EC 2A :3I55-/9@. ECBE9>AC 3-DE/C 03: &/ACA:309AC

9E30-9E@ 5-I9CE/0A:! :E>/0F0>091 D2-@A 1A9A/E30-9: E9C >/AE3091-9A -F 32A 1/AE3A:3 AH&0/A: 32A D-/@C 2E: ABA/ M9-D9R E9C .A3 2A2EC 9ABA/ /AE@@. FA@3 32E3 32A <3E3A DE: O20: -D9RP 2A 2EC E@DE.:@-91AC 3- AG>2E91A 03 F-/ :-HA <3E3AK@A::! &A/FA>3@. F/AA! ABA9E9E/>20>E@ F-/H -F >-HHI9E@ @0FA'

(?::->0E3A S/-FA::-/ -F <->0-@-1.! T5A/@09 ,-@@A1A' L2A F0/:3 BA/:0-9 -F 320: E/30>@A DE:&/A:A93AC 3- 32A &E9A@ U7-D =CAE: <3/I>3I/A S-@030>:V S-:3>-HHI90:3 WG&A/0A9>A:X E3 32AE99IE@ HAA3091: -F 32A ?HA/0>E9 ?::->0E30-9 F-/ 32A ?CBE9>AHA93 -F <@EB0> <3IC0A:!L-/-93-! Y-BAH5A/ #$*#Z! #$$Z' L2A EI32-/ D-I@C @0MA 3- 32E9M S/-FA::-/: 6A9A@09 [E9AB!6E@A/0A \I9>A! [email protected] S/0]A@! E9C! A:&A>0E@@.! S/-FA::-/ Ê/A9 _ED0:2E! F-/ 32A0/ I:AFI@ >-HKHA93: E9C :I11A:30-9:'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33MDE/CK9A:: E9C 5E/5E/03.' \I3 2-:30@A E3303ICA 3- 32A <3E3A DE: 9-3 5. E9.

HAE9: E :019 -F >I@3I/E@ 5E>MDE/C9A::R 03 DE: 3- 5A -5:A/BAC ABA9EH-91 32A !"#$% -F NI::0E9 >I@3I/AC :->0A3.' ` L2A &E::0BA E9E/K>20:H -F L-@:3-.! 20: 3AE>2091 -F O9-3 /A:0:3091 AB0@P DE: 9- H-/A32E9 E F09E@ @09M 09 E @-91 >2E09 -F E930K<3E3A :A930HA93 D20>2 DE:>I//A93 09 NI::0E9 :->0A3.'

?@AM:E9C/ Â/A9:M. a(+Z%! &&' Z$*Z(b

L2A <A/5: >/AE3AC 32A0/ :3E3A EF3A/ E @-91 E9C 5@--C. :3/I11@A

E1E09:3 F-/A019 &-DA/:' ,-9:AcIA93@.! EH-91 32AH! 32A :3E3A 0CAEDE: >-99A>3AC 3- 32A 9E30-9E@ 0CAE! E9C 5A>EHA E :.9-9.H F-/9E30-9E@ F/AAC-H' L2A/A E/A &A-&@A: EH-91 D2-H 32A :3E3A 0CAEDE: AcIE3AC D032 E C.9E:30> 3/EC030-9! -/ E &-@030>E@ 0CA-@-1.! -/ E:&A>0F0> :3E3AK@A1E@ -/CA/! -/ ABA9 D032 E >A/3E09 @ABA@ -F HE3A/0E@AG0:3A9>A' L2A:A &A-&@A! @0B091 09 2E&&0A/ >0/>IH:3E9>A: 32E9 32A<A/5:! C0C 9-3 2EBA 3- :AA 09 32A :3E3A 32A 2012A:3 1IE/E93-/ -F 32A0/9E30-9E@ F/AAC-H! F-/ 32A :EMA -F D20>2 -9A HI:3 5A /AEC. 3- 5AE/32A 1/AE3A:3 :E>/0F0>A: E3 E9. H-HA93'

<@-5-CE9 d-BE9-B0> ae(+)%f (++(! &' ghgb

2A B0/3IE@@. :0HI@3E9A-I: >-@@E&:A -F 32A 32/AA HI@309E30-9E@ >-HHIK90:3 :3E3A:i32A <-B0A3 j90-9! JI1-:@EB0E! E9C ,]A>2-:@-BEM0Ei2E:

E33/E>3AC >-9:0CA/E5@A :>2-@E/@. E33A930-9 CI/091 32A @E:3 CA>ECA' <ABA/E@AG>A@@A93 H-9-1/E&2: 2EBA 5AA9 CAB-3AC 3- 32A 5/AEMI& -F AE>2 -9A -F 32A 32/AA >-I93/0A: a,-2A9! (++Z! E9C 8--CDE/C! (++g! -9 JI1-:@EB0ER\A0::091A/! #$$#! E9C 8E@MA/! #$$Z! -9 32A <-B0A3 j90-9R =99A:! #$$#! -9

,]A>2-:@-BEM0E! 3- HA930-9 kI:3 :-HA -F 32A 5A:3 -9A:b' =9 ECC030-9! E9IH5A/ -F >-H&E/E30BA :3IC0A: 2EBA AG&@-/AC 32A >-93/E:3091 -I3>-HA: 09JI1-:@EB0E E9C ,]A>2-:@-BEM0E adE9-:! (++hb! 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 E9C JI1-K:@EB0E aS-:A9! (++ZR lIM0> E9C l.9>2! (++)R 6IkE>0> E9C mE:@EB:M.! (++(R6IkE>0>! (++)5R ?5/EH:! #$$#b! -/ E@@ 32/AA >E:A: 3EMA9 3-1A32A/ a\I9>A!(+++b' 82E3ABA/ 32A AGE>3 F->I: -F >-H&E/0:-9! 32A/A 0: 1A9A/E@ E1/AAHA9332E3 32A :3/0M091 >-93/E:3 5A3DAA9 32A /A@E30BA@. &AE>AFI@ C0:093A1/E30-9 -F 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 E9C ,]A>2-:@-BEM0EP: UBA@BA3 C0B-/>A!X -9 32A -9A 2E9C!E9C JI1-:@EB0EP: 5@--C. >-@@E&:A! -9 32A -32A/! 0: D2E3 9AAC: 3- 5A

AG&@E09AC' l0MAD0:A! 32A &/-&-:030-9 32E3 32A /AE>30-9 -F UC-H09E93X -/U>-/AX 9E30-9: aNI::0E9:! ,]A>2:! <A/5:b 3- 32A &/-:&A>3 -F :3E3A C0:093A1/EK30-9 DE: -9A -F 32A H-:3 0H&-/3E93 FE>3-/: 09 CA3A/H09091 32A C0FFA/A9>A 09-I3>-HA: :AAH: 5A.-9C C0:&I3A' 7A/A! -F >-I/:A! 32A H-:3 :3/0M091 >-93/E:30: 32A -9A 5A3DAA9 32A NI::0E9 CAH->/E30> A@03AP: E>>A&3E9>A -F 32A 5-/CA/: 5A3DAA9 <-B0A3 /A&I5@0>: E: 32A 5-/CA/: 5A3DAA9 093A/9E30-9E@@. /A>-1K90]AC :3E3A: E9C 32A <A/5:P D0@@0919A:: 3- >2E@@A91A E9E@-1-I: 5-/CA/: 09JI1-:@EB0E I9CA/ 32A EI:&0>A: -F E9 EI32-/03E/0E9 >-HHI90:3 >IH &-&IK@0:3K9E30-9E@0:3 @AECA/:20&'#

:



!"" ADNOPE AJOI@<@

L2A &/A:A93 EI32-/ DE: EH-91 32A F0/:3 3- AG&@-/A 32A >EI:A: -F <-B0A3E9C JI1-:@EB C0:093A1/E30-9 09 E >-@@E5-/E30BA AFF-/3 a6IkE>0> E9CmE:@EB:M.! (++(b E9C 3- -FFA/ E 32A-/A30>E@@. 09F-/HAC E9C 20:3-/0>E@@.

1/-I9CAC E/1IHA93 E5-I3 >/030>E@ C0FFA/A9>A: 09 NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E99E30-9E@0:H E9C 32A DE.: 09 D20>2 32A. >-93/05I3AC 3- C0FFA/A93 &-@030>E@-I3>-HA: a6IkE>0>! (++)5b' =9 32A @E33A/ E/30>@A! = 0CA930F0AC F-I/ >/030>E@C0FFA/A9>A: 09 32A 20:3-/0>E@ @A1E>0A: -F NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9 :3E3A E9C9E30-9K5I0@C091' L2A F0/:3 0: 32A NI::0E9:P 0H&A/0E@ 0CA9303.! D20>2 20:3-/0K>E@@. >-93/05I3AC 3- 32A 5@I//091 -F A3290> 5-I9CE/0A: 5A3DAA9 NI::0E9:E9C -32A/ A3290> 1/-I&: aA:&A>0E@@. jM/E090E9: E9C \A@-/I::0E9:! 5I3 E@:--32A/ NI::0E9K:&AEMA/:b! E9C 32A 20:3-/0>E@ E5:A9>A -F E NI::0E9 UC0E:&-/EXcIA:30-9' \. >-93/E:3! = E/1IAC! <A/50E9 9E30-9K5I0@C091 ->>I//AC 09 32A>-93AG3 -F -&&-:030-9 3- 0H&A/0E@ C-H09E30-9 E9C D032 32A 1-E@ -F 09>-/&-K/E3091 32A A3290> C0E:&-/E 093- 32A AHA/1091 9E30-9K:3E3A' L2A AG0:3A9>A -F E <A/50E9 9E30-9K:3E3A &/0-/ 3- JI1-:@EB I90F0>E30-9 HAE93 32E3 <A/5: >-I@C/A3E09 E :3/-91A/ :A9:A -F 9E30-9E@ &E/30>I@E/0:H 09 JI1-:@EB0E 32E9 NI:K:0E9: 09 32A NI::0E9 AH&0/A -/ 32A <-B0A3 j90-9'

<A>-9C! = ECC/A::AC 32A C0FFA/A9>A: 09 32A 093A/9E@ C.9EH0> -F :3E3AK:->0A3. /A@E30-9: 09 32A NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9 >E:A:' 7A/A! = E/1IAC 32E3 32A&E3/0H-90E@ FAE3I/A: -F NI::0E9 EI3->/E>.! D20>2 DA/A &E/30E@@. /AB0BAC 5.

<3E@09 09 32A >-93AG3 -F E 3-3E@03E/0E9 :3E3A! HECA F-/! E3 5A:3! E9 EH50BE@A93-/! E3 D-/:3! E U9A1E30BAX 0CA930F0>E30-9 -F NI::0E9: D032 32A :3E3A' \.>-93/E:3! <A/5: 0CA930F0AC D032 5-32 32A <A/50E9 E9C JI1-:@EB :3E3A: 09 EHE90FA:3@. &-:030BA HE99A/' ? &-:030BA 0CA930F0>E30-9 5A3DAA9 32A 9E30-9aD2A32A/ CAF09AC 09 U>0B0>X -/ UA3290>X 3A/H:b E9C :3E3A >2E/E>3A/0]A:9E30-9K:3E3A:' [A-1/E&20>E@@. >-9301I-I: AH&0/A: -F 32A NI::0E9 3.&AaT33-HE9! 7E5:5I/1b! 5. >-93/E:3! /A:3 -9 32A @-.E@3. -F HI@30KA3290> A@03A:3- U32/-9A E9C E@3E/!X E9C /AkA>3 &-&I@E/ :-BA/A0193. E: E HE33A/ -F &/09>0K&@A' ?: E /A:I@3! 32A 0CA930F0>E30-9 5A3DAA9 9E30-9E@ >I@3I/A E9C 32A :3E3A

32E3 >2E/E>3A/0]A: 9E30-9K:3E3A: FE0@AC 3- CABA@-& 09 32A NI::0E9 >E:A'L20/C! = AGEH09AC 32A C0FFA/A93 20:3-/0>E@ AG&A/0A9>A: E9C >-@@A>30BA

HAH-/0A: -F NI::0E9: E9C <A/5:' =9 320: /A:&A>3! 32A MA. C0FFA/A9>A 32E3 =2012@0123AC DE: 32A >-93/E:3 5A3DAA9 32A <A/5:P :2E/AC HAH-/0A: -F 20:K3-/0>E@ B0>30H0]E30-9 E3 32A 2E9C: -F AH&0/A: E9C &/-G0HE3A A3290> 1/-I&:09 8-/@C 8E/ == E9C 32A NI::0E9:P :I5kA>30BA AG&A/0A9>A -F B0>30H0]E30-9 E332A 2E9C: -F 32A -BA/5AE/091 EI3->/E30> E9C <3E@090:3 :3E3A:'

L2A F-I/32 >/I>0E@ C0FFA/A9>A DE: 32A 09:303I30-9E@ E//E91AHA93: -F

>-HHI90:3 FACA/E@0:H! D20>2 /AF@A>3AC 32A:A :3E3AK E9C 9E30-9K5I0@C091AG&A/0A9>A:' j9@0MA 32A NI::0E9:! D2- 09:303I30-9E@@. /AHE09AC E &$''$()*"+ 09 32A <-B0A3 j90-9! <A/5: DA/A 10BA9 32A0/ -D9 >I@3I/E@ E9C &-@030>E@09:303I30-9: 09 >-HHI90:3 JI1-:@EB0E' L2A @E>M -F -BA/@E& 5A3DAA9 <A/50E9E9C JI1-:@EB 09:303I30-9: DE: AG&@0>03@. CA:019AC 3- I9CA/:>-/A 32A FE>332E3 <A/5: D-I@C 9-3 5A E@@-DAC 3- 5A>-HA E NI::0E9K:3.@A UA@CA/ 5/-32A/'X

#L2A ,]A>2-K<@-BEM UBA@BA3 C0B-/>AX DE: HI>2 :0H&@A/ 5. >-H&E/0:-9! :09>A 03 C0C 9-309B-@BA &-3A930E@ 3A//03-/0E@ C0:&I3A: 5A3DAA9 32A >-9:303IA93 9E30-9:'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33-9:AcIA9>AV 03 HAE93 32E3 <A/50E99E30-9E@ &E/30>I@E/0:H DE: &@E>AC -9 E9 09:303I30-9E@ F-I9CE30-9' =9 &-@03K

0>E@ 3A/H:! 32A &/A:A9>A -F /A&I5@0>KD0CA 09:303I30-9:! F/-H 32A >-HHI90:3&E/3. -/1E90]E30-9 3- /A&I5@0>KD0CA HAC0E E9C >I@3I/E@ 09:303I30-9: a32A?>ECAH. -F <>0A9>A:! 32A j90-9 -F 8/03A/:! A3>'b DE: :0190F0>E93 5A>EI:A 03HAE93 32E3 @AECA/: @0MA n0@-:AB0> >-I@C HEMA I:A -F /AEC.KHECA 09:303IK30-9: F-/ 32A &I/&-:A -F 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9' \. >-93/E:3! 5-32 32ANI::0E9 >-I93A/&E/3: -F n0@-:AB0> aS-@-]M-B! m.I1E9-B! E9C -32A/: 1E32KA/AC 09 32A ,S N<Q<N EF3A/ (++$b E9C 32A NI::0E9 CAH->/E3: aJA@P3:09 E9C_AH->/E30> NI::0Eb 2EC 3- >/AE3A NI::0E9 09:303I30-9: F/-H :>/E3>2' ?: E/A:I@3! 5-32 0H&A/0E@ E9C E930K0H&A/0E@ BA/:0-9: -F NI::0E9 9E30-9E@0:H:3/I11@AC D032 32A cIA:30-9 -F NI::0EP: AHE9>0&E30-9 F/-H 32A U0H&A/0E@>A93A/X ABA9 0F 32A UAH&0/AK:EBA/:X I@30HE3A@. :0CAC D032 32A 0H&A/0E@>A93A/ 09 32A ?I1I:3 (++( >-I&' L2A 3A/H U0H&A/0E@ >A93A/!X -9 32A -32A/2E9C! 0: 09E&&@0>E5@A 3- JI1-:@EB0E! :09>A JI1-:@EB0E DE: 9-3 E U<A/50E9AH&0/AX 5. E9. :3/A3>2 -F 32A 0HE109E30-9' L20: DE: 32A >E:A ABA9 09 32A093A/DE/ JI1-:@EB M091C-H 09 D20>2 32A <A/5: DA/A &-@030>E@@. C-H09E93 5I3 D20>2 DE: >-9>A0BAC E: E 9E30-9K:3E3A -F 32/AA >-9:303IA93 &A-&@A: a32A^091C-H -F 32A <A/5:! ,/-E3:! E9C <@-BA9A:b E: U32/AA 3/05A: -F 32A -9AK

9EHAC JI1-:@EB 9E30-9X a8E>23A@! (++ob'=9 32A A@E5-/E30-9 -F H. E/1IHA93! = DA93 -9 3- :3E3A 32E3 32A:A 5/-ECC0FFA/A9>A: 09 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ E9C 09:303I30-9E@ @A1E>0A: DA/A 9A>A::E/.! 5I3 9-3 :IFF0>0A93 >-9C030-9: F-/ E FI@@ AG&@E9E30-9 -F 32A C0FFA/A9>A 09-I3>-HA:' ? FI@@ AG&@E9E30-9 /AcI0/AC! 09 ECC030-9! &E.091 E33A930-9 3- E9IH5A/ -F >-93AG3IE@ FE>3-/: 32E3 FEB-/AC U32A :A@A>30BA /AE>30BE30-9X -F A@AHA93: -F 32-:A @A1E>0A: 5. >I@3I/E@ E9C &-@030>E@ A@03A:' Q-/ 09:3E9>A! -9A:I>2 FE>3-/ 09 32A JI1-:@EB >E:A DE: 32A AG3/AHA >-9FACA/E@0]E30-9 -F 32AJI1-:@EB &-@03.! D20>2 -&A9AC I& 32A <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ cIA:30-9 09 E DE.

32E3 2EC 9- &E/E@@A@: 09 32A NI::0E9 >E:AR E9-32A/ :I>2 FE>3-/ DE: 32A^-:-B- >/0:0:! D20>2 3-I>2AC -9 32A BA/. >-/A -F 32A <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ H.32E9C &/-B0CAC <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:H D032 E >-9>/A3A 1/0ABE9>A 09 32A (+o$:'Q09E@@.! 32A :&A>0F0> DE.: 09 D20>2 @AECA/: @0MA n0@-:AB0> E9C JA@P3:09 HECAI:A -F 32A 09:303I30-9E@ >/0:A: -F 32A0/ /A:&A>30BA HI@309E30-9E@ :3E3A:! 5.>-H509091 E&&AE@: 3- 32A 9E30-9 D032 -32A/ >-9>A/9: aA>-9-H0> /AF-/H!:->0E@ kI:30>A! E9C E:&0/E30-9: F-/ &-@030>E@ &E/30>0&E30-9 -9 32A &E/3 -F >/030>E@ >-9:303IA9>0A:b! 09 &E/3 /AF@A>3AC C0FFA/A93 20:3-/0>E@ @A1E>0A: -F :3E3AKE9C 9E30-9K5I0@C091 09 NI::0E E9C <A/50E! E9C 09 &E/3 2A@&AC :2E&A HE::

&A/>A&30-9: 09 32A &A/0-C -F 32A 3A/H09E@ >/0:0: -F >-HHI90:H' =9 >-9>@IK:0-9! = E/1IAC 32E3 -9@. E HI@30KFE>3-/0E@ AG&@E9E30-9 32E3 3--M 093- E>>-I9332A 093A/E>30-9 5A3DAA9 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ E9C 09:303I30-9E@ @A1E>0A: E9C>-93AG3IE@ FE>3-/: a09>@IC091 @AECA/:20&b >-I@C -FFA/ E :E30:FE>3-/. :-@I30-93- 32A &I]]@A -F C0FFA/A93 -I3>-HA: 09 NI::0E E9C <A/50E'

L2A 1/-D091 :>2-@E/:20& -9 32A >-@@E&:A -F 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 E9CJI1-:@EB0E 2E: >-9B09>AC HA 32E3 32A >-H&E/E30BA E/1IHA93 :MA3>2ACE5-BA 0: 09 9AAC -F :-HA /AF09AHA93 5I3 9-3 FI9CEHA93E@ /AB0:0-9' =9D2E3 F-@@-D:! = D0@@ F0/:3 /AB0AD :-HA -F 32A AG&@E9E30-9: 09 32A AG0:3091



!"R ADNOPE AJOI@<@

,*-.'/'$#)% @03A/E3I/A -9 32A <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB 5/AEMI& 32E3 3EMA 093-E>>-I93 32A C0FFA/A9>A: 5A3DAA9 NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:H' =9 H.B0AD! E@@ 32A:A D-/M: >-93E09 BE@IE5@A 09:0123: 5I3 9-9A -F 32AH -FFA/: E

FI@@. :E30:FE>3-/. /A:&-9:A 3- 32A &I]]@A -F C0FFA/A93 -I3>-HA: 09 NI::0EE9C <A/50E! &/0HE/0@. -9 E>>-I93 -F 32A0/ AG&@E9E3-/. /ACI>30-90:H' n-:30H&-/3E93@.! H-:3 -F 32A:A AG&@E9E30-9: FE0@ 3- 3EMA 093- E>>-I93 >/030>E@ .*"#$#,'"0,1"$1/'" C0FFA/A9>A: 5A3DAA9 32A 3D- >E:A:! 3/AE3091 32AH! E3 5A:3!E: 5E>M1/-I9C -/ EIG0@0E/. FE>3-/:' 7-DABA/! E FI@@ AG&@E9E30-9 -F 32AC0FFA/A9>A 09 -I3>-HA: :2-I@C :E30:F. 32A 8A5A/0E9 >/03A/0-9 -F UECAcIE>.-9 32A @ABA@ -F HAE9091Xi0'A'! :2-I@C E>>-I93 F-/ 32A >I@3I/E@@. :&A>0F0>H-30BE30-9 -F &-@030>E@ E>30-9 09 32A 3D- >E:A:' L20: /AcI0/AHA93 :AAH:A:&A>0E@@. &A/309A93 5A>EI:A 32A :.H5-@0> C0HA9:0-9 -F :->0E@ E>30-9 0: -F :I>2 :3/0M091 0H&-/3E9>A 09 9E30-9E@0:3 H-BAHA93: E9C 5A>EI:A 32AE&&AE@: -F @AECA/: D2-! E: 03 DA/A! &A/:-90F0AC 32A C0FFA/A9>A 09 -I3>-HA:in0@-:AB0> E9C JA@P3:09iDA/A &A/HAE3AC D032 :.H5-@0> >-93A93' =9 3A/H:-F H. -D9 AG&@E9E30-9! 5/0AF@. :MA3>2AC E5-BA! 32A :A>-9C FE>3-/i32AC0FFA/A93 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ E3303ICA: -F NI::0E9: E9C <A/5: 3-DE/C: 32A:3E3AiD0@@ 5A :091@AC -I3 F-/ A@E5-/E30-9' =3 1-A: D032-I3 :E.091 32E3 32A&/A:A9>A E9C &A/309A9>A -F 32A:A &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ H-30F: 09 >-93AH&-/E/.NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9 20:3-/. >E9 -9@. 5A 0@@I:3/E3AC! 5I3 9-3 >-9>@I:0BA@.

CAH-9:3/E3AC! D03209 32A >-9F09A: -F E9 E/30>@A' Q09E@@.! = :2-I@C HEMA >@AE/32E3 E: FE/ E: 32A 1/-D091 H-9-1/E&20> @03A/E3I/A 0: >-9>A/9AC! = D0@@ 3EMA093- E>>-I93 -9@. E FAD :A@A>3 E/1IHA93: 32E3 2EBA 32A-/A30>E@ E9C AH&0/K0>E@ 0H&@0>E30-9: F-/ 5-32 >E:A:'

DS&NIFI:<EF3 EG :HD K<GGD5DF: EJ:@ETD3<F 5J33AC 09 32A >-H&E/E30BA @03A/E3I/A32E3 AGEH09A: 32A <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB 5/AEMI& F/-H 32A &-093 -F B0AD -F &AE>AFI@ BA/:I: B0-@A93 -I3>-HA: E9C 32A0/ /A@E30-9:20& 3- NI::0E9 E9C<A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:HV a(b E/1IHA93: 32E3 AH&2E:0]A 32A C0FFA/A93 AG3A/9E@:03IE30-9: -F 32A /A@ABE93 A3290> 1/-I&: E9C H0@03E/. E9C 2%'".*"#$#+ >-9K:3/E093: E9C -&&-/3I9030A:R a#b E/1IHA93: 32E3 AH&2E:0]A 32A DE.: 09 D20>209:303I30-9E@ E//E91AHA93: &/-B0CAC 09>A930BA: F-/ C0FFA/A93 M09C: -F &-@03K0>E@ >-93A:3 09 32A &A/0-C -F :3E3A CA>@09AR E9C F09E@@.! aZb E/1IHA93: 32E3>-9>A93/E3A -9 32A /-@A -F @AECA/:20& 09 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9'

L2A H-:3 >-9>0:A :3E3AHA93 -F 32A /%'"#($ E/1IHA93 CA/0BAC F/-H093A/9E30-9E@ /A@E30-9: 32A-/. 2E: 5AA9 -FFA/AC 5. \E//. S-:A9 a(++Zb' L2A/AE@0:3 E/1IHA93 AH&2E:0]A: 32A U:A>I/03. C0@AHHEX FE>091 &/-:&A>30BAH09-/030A: I9CA/ >-9C030-9: -F 09:303I30-9E@ >-@@E&:A E9C UAHA/1091 E9E/K>2.X 09 C0:093A1/E3091 AH&0/A: -/ HI@309E30-9E@ :3E3A:' ?>>-/C091 3- S-:A9!UAHA/1091 E9E/>2.X 0: H-/A @0MA@. 3- /A:I@3 09 E B0-@A93 -I3>-HA D2A9V a(b32A -FFA9:0BA E9C CAFA9:0BA >E&E50@030A: -F AHA/1091 :3E3A: E/A H-/A -/ @A:: 5E@E9>ACR a#b D2A9 -FFA9:0BA -&A/E30-9: E/A @0MA@. 3- /A:I@3 09 cI0>M 3A//0K3-/0E@ 1E09: F-/ 32A :-HAD2E3 :3/-91A/ &E/3. CI/091 E 5/0AF UD09C-D -F



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33E9 /AC/A:: 32A H0@03E/. 5E@KE9>AR aZb D2A9 32A/A 0: E 20:3-/. -F HI3IE@ E93E1-90:H 5A3DAA9 1/-I&: :-32E3 32A &E/30A: 2EBA 20:3-/0>E@@. 1/-I9CAC /AE:-9: 3- FAE/ AE>2 -32A/P:

>@E0H: -9 3A//03-/. E9C &-&I@E30-9R a%b D2A9 :I>2 20:3-/0>E@@. 1/-I9CACFAE/: E/A AG&@-03AC 5. &-@030>E@ A93/A&/A9AI/: E9C E/HAC 1/-I&: -F UFE9E3K0>:X D2- /E0:A 32A :3EMA: F-/ HAH5A/: -F 5-32 1/-I&: I9CA/ >-9C030-9: -F E9E/>2.R E9C agb D2A9 H09-/03. &-&I@E30-9: E/A :>E33A/AC 09 0:-@E3AC&->MA3: EH-91 E &-3A930E@ 2-:30@A HEk-/03. :- 32E3 32A -9@. DE. 09 D20>232A &/-:&A>30BA 9E30-9E@ 2-HA@E9C >E9 &/-3A>3 32AH 0: 3- A91E1A 09 &/AKBA930BA DE/' L2A H-:3 0H&-/3E93 >-I93A/BE0@091 FE>3-/ 3- B0-@A93 >-9F/-9K3E30-9 I9CA/ >-9C030-9: -F :3E3A >-@@E&:A! -9 32A -32A/ 2E9C! 0: 32AEBE0@E50@03. -F 9I>@AE/ DAE&-9:! D2-:A &/A:A9>A /E0:A: 32A :3EMA: -F 9E30-9E@ >-9F@0>3 3- E9 I9E>>A&3E5@A @ABA@'

S-:A9 32A9 &/->AAC: 3- CAH-9:3/E3A 32E3 32A:A FE>3-/: &/-B0CAC &-DKA/FI@ 09>A930BA: F-/ <A/50E 3- DE1A U&/ABA930BA DE/X E1E09:3 ,/-E30E 09 32A 5/0AF UD09C-D -F -&&-/3I903.X CI/091 D20>2 03 2EC 32A H0@03E/. ECBE93E1A'\. >-93/E:3! :ABA/E@ -F 32A:A FE>3-/: DA/A H0::091 09 32A NI::0E9KjM/E090E9>E:AV a(b 32A NI::0E9 H09-/03. 09 jM/E09A DE: >-H&E>3@. :A33@AC 09 E/AE: 5-/CA/091 32A NI::0E9 /A&I5@0>! D032 32A >-9:AcIA9>A 32E3 NI::0E >-I@C>-HA 3- 03: E0C 0F 9A>A::E/.R a#b 32A 3A//03-/0E@! CAH-1/E&20>! E9C H0@03E/.

0H5E@E9>A 5A3DAA9 NI::0E E9C jM/E09A DE: @E/1A! &/-B0C091 E C0:09>A930BAF-/ E >-9F/-93E30-9E@ :3/E3A1. -9 32A &E/3 -F jM/E09AR E9C aZb 32A 20:3-/0>E@>2E/E>3A/ -F NI::0E9KjM/E090E9 /A@E30-9: DE: C0FFA/A93 F/-H 03: <A/5K,/-E3>-I93A/&E/3 09:-FE/ E: 32A/A DE: 9- /A>-/C -F 32A :.:3AHE30> &A/:A>I30-9 -F NI::0E9: 09 jM/E09A 5. jM/E090E9: a09 >-93/E:3 3- &A/:A>I30-9 -F <A/5: 5.,/-E3: 09 ,/-E30Eb E9C 5A>EI:A 32A jM/E090E9 @AECA/:20& 5@EHAC 32A >E3EK:3/-&20> FEH09A B0:03AC I&-9 jM/E09A 5. n-:>-D -9 <3E@09! 9-3 -9 U32ANI::0E9:X aI9@0MA 32A ,/-E3 @AECA/:20&! D20>2 AB-MAC 32A :&A>3A/ -F U1/AE3A/ <A/50E9 2A1AH-9.X 3- /AFA/ 3- ,/-E3 20:3-/0>E@ 1/0ABE9>A:b' Q09E@@.!

32A &/A:A9>A -F 9I>@AE/ DAE&-9: 09 NI::0E E9C jM/E09A &/-B0CAC E &-DKA/FI@ CA3A//A93 3- B0-@A93 9E30-9E@ >-9F/-93E30-9'S-:A9P: /AE@0:3 E/1IHA93 CA:A/BA: -I/ E33A930-9 5-32 -9 E>>-I93 -F 03:

>@E/03. E9C 5A>EI:A -F 03: 0H&@0>03 E9C I9CABA@-&AC E::IH&30-9:' L- 3EMAI& 32A &/A:A9>A -F 9I>@AE/ DAE&-9: 09 NI::0E E9C jM/E09A F0/:3! 32A/A 0:@033@A C-I53 32E3 32A HI>2 1/AE3A/ /A:A/BA D032 D20>2 32A /A:&A>30BA A@03A:E&&/-E>2AC 32A AG&@-:0BA cIA:30-9 -F 32A @A1030HE>. -F /A&I5@0>E9 3A//03-K/0E@ 5-I9CE/0A: DE: /A@E3AC 3- 32A &-3A930E@ F-/ 9I>@AE/ >-9F/-93E30-9 cI03AE&E/3 F/-H 32A 3A>290>E@ cIA:30-9 -F D2A32A/ :I>2 DAE&-9: >-I@C 5A AE:0@.

/AC0/A>3AC F/-H 32A0/ &/0HE/. 3E/1A3: 09 32A 8A:3 3- F-/HA/ <-B0A3 3A//03-K/0A:' =9CAAC! D2A9 JA@P3:09P: &/A:: :A>/A3E/.! SEBA@ 6-:2>2E9-B! 5/0AF@./E0:AC 32A cIA:30-9 -F 32A @A1030HE>. -F jM/E09AP: 5-/CA/: 09 32A 0HHAC0E3AEF3A/HE32 -F 32A ?I1I:3 >-I&! 32A/A DE: E9 -I3>/. 09 5-32 jM/E09A E9CNI::0E! @E/1A@. -9 E>>-I93 -F 32A &-3A930E@@. CABE:3E3091 >-:3: -F >-9F/-9K3E30-9 a8E@MA/! #$$Z! &' (%#b' 820@A 320: C0C 9-3 &/ABA93 NI::0E9 9E30-9E@0:3:E9C >-HHI90:3: F/-H cIA:30-9091 32A @A1030HE>. -F jM/E09AP: 5-/CA/:09 32A EF3A/HE32 -F <-B0A3 C0::-@I30-9! 32A &/-:&A>3 -F >-:3@. H0@03E/.>-9F/-93E30-9 /A:3/E09AC ABA9 32A H-:3 AG3/AHA &/-&-9A93: -F U<@EB0>



!Q% ADNOPE AJOI@<@

/AI90F0>E30-9X E9Cp-/ 32A E99AGE30-9 -F U20:3-/0>E@@. NI::0E9 3A//03-/0A:X09 jM/E09A'

YABA/32A@A::! :ABA/E@ -5kA>30-9: >E9 5A /E0:AC D032 /A:&A>3 3- 32A /AE@0:3

E>>-I93' Q0/:3! 0F 32A &/A:A9>A -F 9I>@AE/ DAE&-9: DE: E &-DA/FI@ -5:3E>@A3- E H0@03E/0:3 A@03A :3/E3A1.! 03 :30@@ /AHE09: I9>@AE/ D2. 32A A@03A: -F 32ANI::0E9 /A&I5@0> 4#4 5*$ %)%5 $6#5+ *7 .*(#58 $6% 91%($#*5 -F 32A FE3A -F NI::0E9: 09 32A /A&I5@0>: I930@ 32A &/-:&A>3 -F <-B0A3 C0:093A1/E30-9 5A>EHAE 7'#$ ',,*-."#: Y-/ 0: 03 >@AE/ D2. NI::0E9 A@03A: >-I@C 9-3 2EBA &I/:IAC32A :EHA 1-E@: 5. &AE>AFI@ HAE9:! 0'A'! 5. &I:2091 F-/ /AFA/A9CE -9 32AU:A@FKCA3A/H09E30-9X -F A3290> NI::0E9: 09 jM/E09A E9C Ê]EM2:3E9 &/0-/3- CA>@E/E30-9: -F 09CA&A9CA9>A' =9CAAC! D2A9 32A ,/0HAE9 cIA:30-9 5/0AF@. F@E/AC I& 09 32A AE/@. (++$:! 32A 0CAE -F E /AFA/A9CIH -F 32A @->E@NI::0E9 &-&I@E30-9 DE: :I&&-/3AC 9-3 -9@. 5. AG3/AHA 9E30-9E@0:3: 5I3E@:- 5. H-CA/E3A: 09 32A NI::0E9 A@03A' \. 32E3 30HA! 2-DABA/! 32A HI3IE@/A>-19030-9 -F 32A 5-/CA/: 5A3DAA9 NI::0E E9C jM/E09A E: 32A 5-/CA/: 5A3DAA9 #5$%/5'$#*5'""; /%,*85#<%4 ($'$%( /A9CA/AC E9. E33AH&3 E3 E U3A//03-K/0E@ 1/E5X 0@@A1030HE3A 5. CAF09030-9' L2A &I]]@A! 32A/AF-/A! 0: D2. NI::0E9A@03A: :0CA:3A&&AC 32A cIA:30-9 -F &/-:&A>30BA NI::0E9 H09-/030A: 09 -/CA/3- E>20ABA D2E3 DE: 09 32A0/ A.A: E H-/A 0H&-/3E93 1-E@i32A CA:3/I>30-9-F 32A >-HHI90:3 /A10HAi%)%5 '$ $6% ,*($ *7 4#((*"1$#*5 *7 $6% ,*--*5 ($'$%=

D20>2 @AF3 #g H0@@0-9 A3290> NI::0E9: -I3:0CA -F 32A &/-:&A>30BA 9E30-9E@2-HA@E9C'WBA9 H-/A &I]]@091 0: 32A /A@E30BA &E::0B03. -F @->E@ NI::0E9 &-&I@EK

30-9: D2-! E: DE: E/1IAC E5-BA! DA/A 09 E 5A33A/ &-:030-9 3- >@E0H >-HK&E>3@. :A33@AC 3A//03-/0A: 32E9 32A0/ <A/50E9 >-I93A/&E/3: 09 ,/-E30E E9C 09\-:90E E9C 7A/]A1-B09E' S-:A9P: E/1IHA93 32E3 <A/5: 09 ,/-E30E E9C\-:90E DA/A &/-9A 3- H0@03E/0]E30-9 &/A>0:A@. 5A>EI:A 32A. F-I9C 32AHK:A@BA: 09 0:-@E3AC 3A//03-/0E@ &->MA3: D03209 &-3A930E@@. 2-:30@A A3290> 3A//0K3-/. 0: 9-3 E: >-9B09>091 E: 03 E&&AE/: E3 F0/:3 1@E9>A' S/A>0:A@. 32A -&&-:03A

>-I@C 5A E/1IAC D032 AcIE@ &@EI:[email protected] 9EHA@.! 32E3 32A >-H&E>3@. :A33@ACNI::0E9 &-&I@E30-9: 5-/CA/091 32A NI::0E9 /A&I5@0> >-I@C 2EBA -&3AC F-/:A@FKCA3A/H09E30-9 09 jM/E09A E9C Ê]EM2:3E9 FE0/@. AE:0@.! D20@A 32A /A@EK30BA 0:-@E30-9 -F <A/50E9 >-HHI9030A: 09 ,/-E30E E9C \-:90E >-I@C 2EBA&/-B0CAC E: :3/-91 E9 09>A930BA F-/ >-H&/-H0:A E: F-/ H0@03E/0]E30-9'n-/A-BA/! E: S-:A9 20H:A@F /AE@0]A:! 0F HE9. <A/5: 09 ,/-E30E E9C \-:90E09CAAC /AE>3AC 3- 32A &/-:&A>3 -F 5A091 :ABA/AC F/-H 32A0/ &/AFA//AC9E30-9E@ 2-HA@E9C aD2A32A/ U1/AE3A/ <A/50EX -/ JI1-:@EB0Eb C0FFA/[email protected] 32A0/ NI::0E9 >-I93A/&E/3: 09 jM/E09A E9C Ê]EM2:3E9! 320: DE:

5A>EI:A -F 32A0/ .%/,%.$#*5 32E3 32A &-3A930E@ A3290> 32/AE3 &-:AC 5. 09CAK&A9CA93 ,/-E30E9 E9C \-:90E9 :3E3A: -I3DA012AC 32A >-:3: -F H0@03E/0]EK30-9' WcIE@@. 0H&-/3E93! 32E3 &A/>A&30-9 DE: :2E/AC 5. A@03A: 09 32A0/&/-:&A>30BA 9E30-9E@ 2-HA@E9C! <A/50E! E: DA@@ E: 5. HE9. A3290> <A/5-FF0>A/: 09 32A JI1-:@EB SA-&@AP: ?/H. adY?b' L20: C0FFA/A9>A 09 &A/>A&30-9>E9 -9@. 5A AG&@E09AC 5. 32A C0FFA/A93 6#($*/#,'" "%8',#%( -F <A/5K,/-E3 E9C<A/5K\-:90E9 n-:@AH /A@E30-9: 09 >-H&E/0:-9 3- 32-:A 5A3DAA9 NI::0E9:E9C jM/E090E9: 09 jM/E09A! E9C NI::0E9: E9C Ê]EM2: 09 Ê]EM2:3E9'L2I:! 03 0: 32A &E:3 >-93A93 -F A3290> /A@E30-9:! 32A 093A/&/A3E30-9 -F 32-:A



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J333IE@ E9C &-@030>E@ A@03A: E3 >/030>E@ kI9>3I/A: 09 32A&-@030>E@ &/->A::! E9C 32A &/A:A9>A -/ E5:A9>A -F 093A9:A FAA@091: -F 9E30-9E@:-@0CE/03. 5A3DAA9 9E30-9E@: 09 32A 9E30-9E@ 2-HA@E9C E9C 32A0/ &/-:&A>K

30BA H09-/03. >-K9E30-9E@: 09 U9AD@. 9E30-9E@0]091 :3E3A:X 32E3 0: H-:3 099AAC -F AG&@E9E30-9'

<ABA/E@ ECC030-9E@ -5kA>30-9: >E9 5A /E0:AC D032 /A:&A>3 3- 32A /AE@0:3E/1IHA93' L2A /AE@0:3 E/1IHA93 C-A: 9-3 2A@& I: E:>A/3E09 32A 09CA&A9CA9309:303I30-9E@ AFFA>3: -F >-HHI90:3 9E30-9E@03. &-@0>. -9 32A &/->A:: -F <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB C0::-@I30-9 E9C C-A: 9-3 2A@& I: AG&@E09 D2. E9C 2-D/0BE@ 093A/&/A3E30-9: -F 32A >-HH-9 aE@32-I12 -FF0>0E@@. 2A1AH-90> E9C32A/AF-/A 2012@. 0CA-@-10>E@b 9E//E30BA -F 9E30-9E@ 20:3-/. AHA/1AC DA@@

5AF-/A 09:303I30-9E@ >-@@E&:A /A:I@3AC 09 UAHA/1091 E9E/>2.'X Y-/ C-A: 03AG&@E09 D2. HE9. NI::0E9: E9C <A/5: DA/A D0@@091 3- HEMA E C/EHE30>:20F3 F/-H :3E3AKD0CA a<-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EBb 0CA93030A:! D20>2 :I03AC 32A0/093A/A:3: E: 32A H-:3 3A//03-/0E@@. C0:&A/:AC 9E30-9:! 3- F-/H: -F 9E30-9E@0:3&E/30>I@E/0:H 32E3 >E//0AC 32A /0:M -F :3E3A C0:093A1/E30-9' <A>-9C@.! 32A/AE@0:3 &E/EC01H 3EMA: F-/ 1/E93AC @AECA/:20& H-30BE30-9:! C0:/A1E/C0912-D 32A. HE. 2EBA 5AA9 :2E&AC 5. 32A 3A/H09E@ @A1030HE>. >/0:0: -F >-HHI90:H! E9C &/ABA93: I: F/-H E::A::091 32A AFFA>3 -F C0FFA/A93 UlA909K0:3 @A1E>0A:X -9 >-9F/-93E30-9E@ -/ >--&A/E30BA &-@030>:!Z E9C 03 C0:>-I93:

0CA-@-10>E@ >-9:0CA/E30-9: E: I90H&-/3E93 F-/ AG&@E09091 -I3>-HA:iE9E::IH&30-9 C0FF0>I@3 3- :I:3E09 09 32A >E:A -F >-HHI90:3 /A10HA:' Q09E@@.!32A U:A>I/03. C0@AHHEX :>2--@ -F 32-I123 3/AE3: 9E30-9: a9-3 -9@. :3E3A:bE: 2-H-1A9-I: >-@@A>30BA E>3-/:! E9 I9DE//E93AC E::IH&30-9 9-3 -9@. 5A>EI:A 03 9A1@A>3: 32A :->0E@@. >-9:3/I>3AC >2E/E>3A/ -F 9E30-9E@ 0CA9303.E9C 09C0B0CIE@ >E@>I@E30-9: -F 32A HE3A/0E@ E9C :3E3I: /A3I/9: -F H09-/03.E::0H0@E30-9 BA/:I: AG03 -/ B-0>AiE: lE0309 a(++o! &&' Z#g*Z%)b 2E: &-093AC-I3i5I3 E@:- 5A>EI:A 03 @AEBA: 9- /--H F-/ >-H&A3091 093A/&/A3E30-9: -F 32A 9E30-9E@ &E:3! E: ECBE9>AC 5. C0FFA/A93 093A@@A>3IE@ E9C &-@030>E@ A@03A:'L20: &-@030>E@ :3/I11@A -BA/ @A1030HE3A 093A/&/A3E30-9: -F 32A 9E30-9E@ &E:309 NI::0E E9C <A/50E! 2-DABA/! DE: E9 093A1/E@ &E/3 -F 32A >-H&A3030-9-F A@03A: F-/ 32A U9E30-9E@ :-I@X 09 32A @E:3 .AE/: -F 32A :3E3AP: AG0:3A9>AE9C >E99-3 5A C0:>E/CAC E: 0//A@ABE93 F-/ AG&@E09091 9E30-9E@0:3H-50@0]E30-9'

? :A>-9C @09A -F E/1IHA93 09 AG0:3091 >-H&E/E30BA :>2-@E/:20& -9 32A>-@@E&:A -F 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 E9C JI1-:@EB0E AH&2E:0]A: 32A >/030>E@ 0H&-/K3E9>A -F 09:303I30-9E@ FE>3-/:' =3: H-:3 &/-H09A93 ECB->E3A 2E: 5AA9 6E@A/0A

Z L- 5A FE0/! S-:A9 0H&@0>03@. /A>-190]A: 32A 0H&-/3E9>A -F lA9090:3 @A1E>0A: D2A9 2A E/1IA:32E3 20:3-/0>E@ 093A/&/A3E30-9: -F 32A 9E30-9E@ &E:3 09 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 E9C JI1-:@EB0E 09AB0K3E5@. DA/A C0:3-/3AC! :09>A 5-32 >-I93/0A: U@E>MAC E9. :.:3AHE30> >-HH03HA93 3- 3/I32 0920:3-/0>E@ :>2-@E/:20&'X ?: E /A:I@3! 09F-/HE@ U-/E@ 20:3-/0A:X E>cI0/AC 1/AE3 :0190F0>E9>A' L-320: 03 >-I@C 5A ECCAC 32E3 09F-/HE@ UD/033A9X 20:3-/0A:! A:&A>0E@@. 09 @03A/E/. F-/H! DA/AAcIE@@. 0H&-/3E93 09 32A &-:3K<3E@090:3 E9C &-:3KL03-0:3 &A/0-C:' Q-/ 32A-/A30>E@ >-9>A&3IE@0]EK30-9 -F 32A lA9090:3 @A1E>.! :AA d-D033 a(++#! &&' #o%*Z$)b' L2A AH&2E:0: -9 "%8',#%( 0: HAE939-3 3- CA9. 32A >-HH-9E@030A: 5A3DAA9 <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB lA9090:H! 5I3 /E32A/ 3- I9CA/K:>-/A 32A 0H&-/3E9>A -F C0FFA/A9>A: D03209 32A >-HH-9 lA9090:3 F/EHAD-/M'



!Q$ ADNOPE AJOI@<@

\I9>A! D2-:A 09:0123: 093- 32A 09:303I30-9E@ >EI:A: -F 32A CAH0:A -F :->0E@K0:H 2EBA 32A ECC030-9E@ HA/03 -F &@E>091 32A >-@@E&:A -F HI@309E30-9E@>-HHI90:3 :3E3A: 09 32A >-93AG3 -F 32A 09:303I30-9E@ 20:3-/. -F >-HHI90:H

E: E C0:309>3 :->0E@ E9C &-@030>E@ :.:3AH a\I9>A! (+++b' ?>>-/C091 3- \I9>A!32A B0/3IE@@. :0HI@3E9A-I: C0:093A1/E30-9 -F 32/AA HI@309E30-9E@ >-HHIK90:3 :3E3A: a2A/ E9E@.:0: 09>@ICA: ,]A>2-:@-BEM0Eb >E9 5A AG&@E09AC 5. 32A>-9F@IA9>A -F 3D- -BA//0C091 FE>3-/:V 32A :.:3AH -F 9E30-9E@ FACA/E@0:H!D20>2 @E0C 32A 09:303I30-9E@ F-I9CE30-9: F-/ A@03AK@AC 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]EK30-9 E@-91 32A @09A: -F /A&I5@0>:! A:&A>0E@@. -9>A 32A \/A]29AB03A U:[email protected] >EC/A:X E@@-DAC F-/ A@03A >-9:-@0CE30-9 -9 32A @->E@ @ABA@! E9C 32AC/EHE30>E@@. E@3A/AC -&&-/3I903. :3/I>3I/A F-/ 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9-9>A A>-9-H0> CA>@09A! 32A @--:A9091 -F &E/3.K:3E3A >-93/-@:! E9C &/A::I/A:F-/ /AF-/H /A:I@3AC 09 32A U@AEME1A -F &-DA/ E9C A>-9-H0> /A:-I/>A:XF/-H 32A >A93A/ 3- 32A &A/0&2A/.! &/-B0C091 ECC030-9E@ 09>A930BA: F-/9E30-9E@0:3 &-@030>: a\I9>A! (+++! &&' hh*($#b' L2A 32/AA MA. FE>3-/: 32E32A@& AG&@E09 32A &AE>AFI@ C0:HAH5A/HA93 -F ,]A>2-:@-BEM0E E9C 32A<-B0A3 j90-9 BA/:I: 32A B0-@A93 C0:093A1/E30-9 -F JI1-:@EB0E @0MAD0:A DA/A09:303I30-9E@ 09 >2E/E>3A/V U32A CA1/AA -F CA>A93/E@0]E30-9 -F 32A FACA/E30-9R32A &-@030>E@ &-DA/ BA/:I: 32A 09:303I30-9E@ /A:-I/>A: -F 32A C-H09E93/A&I5@0>! E9C 32A /A@E30-9:20& 5A3DAA9 32A H0@03E/. E9C 32A &E/3.K:3E3AX

a\I9>A! (+++! &' ($Zb'8032 /A:&A>3 3- 32A F0/:3 FE>3-/! \I9>A E/1IA: 32E3 AE/@. CA>A93/E@0]E30-909 JI1-:@EB0E DAEMA9AC 32A FACA/E@ >A93A/ DA@@ 5AF-/A 32A 3A/H09E@ >/0:0:-F 32A &E/3.K:3E3A! /A:I@3091 09 E >-9:0CA/E5@A :20F3 09 &-DA/ 3- /A&I5@0>E9A@03A: D2- 5A1E9 E>3091 E: 32A @AECA/: -F 4% 7',$* 09CA&A9CA93 :3E3A:'n-/A-BA/! 32A @-10> -F 32A JI1-:@EB FACA/E@ :.:3AH C0FFA/AC F/-H 03: ,]A>2K-:@-BEM E9C <-B0A3 >-I93A/&E/3: 09 03: AG3A9:0-9 -F FACA/E@0:H 3- <A/50E!D20>2 /AF@A>3AC 32A &I/&-/3AC AcIE@03. 5A3DAA9 JI1-:@EB /A&I5@0>:' \.>-93/E:3! 09 ,]A>2-:@-BEM0E E9C 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 32A C-H09E93 9E30-9 DE:

3/AE3AC E: U32A /A&/A:A93E30BA -F 32A >A93A/ E9C :->0E@0:HX D032 9- :&A>0E@>I@3I/E@ E9C &-@030>E@ 9AAC: -F 03: -D9' n-/A 0H&-/3E93@. :30@@! 320: HAE9332E3 <A/50EP: A@03A: DA/A 09:303I30-9E@@. AcI0&&AC 3- &@E. 32A 9E30-9E@0:3 >E/CE9C AHA/1A E: FI@@KF@AC1AC >-93A:3E93: 09 32A U1EHA -F :3E3A C0:HAH5A/KHA93!X E /-@A 32E3 32A ,]A>2 E9C 32A NI::0E9 &E/3: -F 32A FACA/E30-9 >-I@C2EBA &@E.AC -9@. EF3A/ 32A. 2EC >-9:-@0CE3AC 32A0/ -D9 9E30-9E@ 09:303IK30-9:' ,-9:AcIA93@.! D20@A 32A &/0-/03. -F 32A ,]A>2 E9C NI::0E9 @AECA/:20&DE: 3- CABA@-& :I>2 09:303I30-9: E9C A9C 32A 0CA930F0>E30-9 5A3DAA9 32AC-H09E93 9E30-9 E9C 32A FACA/E@ >A93A/! <A/50EP: &/0-/03. DE: 3- /A>A93/E@0]A

32A JI1-:@EB FACA/E30-9 32E3 2EC &/-BA9 CA3/0HA93E@ 3- <A/50E9 9E30-9E@093A/A:3:' L- HEMA HE33A/: D-/:A! 32A 09:303I30-9E@ E//E91AHA93: -F JI1-K:@EB FACA/E@0:H DAEMA9AC <A/50E FI/32A/ 5. >/AE3091 3D- FI@@. EI3-9-H-I:&/-B09>A: D03209 32A /A&I5@0>! 32I: &/-B0C091 32A F-I9CE30-9 F-/ E @E:30919E30-9E@ 1/0ABE9>A' n-/A-BA/! ABA9 E: A3290> <A/5: /AHE09AC -BA//A&/AK:A93AC 09 >-A/>0BA :3E3A 09:303I30-9: :I>2 E: 32A E/H. E9C 32A :A>/A3 &-@0>A!32A. /AHE09AC &-@030>E@@. I9CA//A&/A:A93AC 09 >0B0@0E9 09:303I30-9: 5A>EI:A-F 32A >-9FACA/E@ 9E3I/A -F 32A JI1-:@EB &-@03.! D20>2 CAB-@BAC C0:&/-&-/K30-9E3A &-DA/ 3- 32A /A&I5@0>: E9C EI3-9-H-I: &/-B09>A: a\I9>A! (+++! &'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J333-/: /A:I@3AC 09 E &/-9-I9>AC C0:>/A&E9>. 5A3DAA9<A/50EP: &-3A930E@ E9C E>3IE@ &-DA/ E9C &/-B0CAC 03: @AECA/:20& D032 32A09>A930BA 3- /A>A93/E@0]A 32A JI1-:@EB &-@03. -/! :2-/3 -F 32E3! 3- H-50@0]A

<A/5: 09 ,/-E30E E9C \-:90E F-/ 32A >EI:A -F E9 A9@E/1AC <A/50E9 :3E3A'\I9>AP: F09E@ E/1IHA93 2E: 3- C- D032 32A /-@A -F 32A JI1-:@EB E/H.

09 32A 1EHA -F :3E3A C0:HAH5A/HA93' ?>>-/C091 3- \I9>A! 2A/A 32A >/030>E@FE>3-/ DE: 32E3 32A E/H. DE: E::->0E3AC D032 <A/50E H-/A 32E9 32A -32A//A&I5@0>:i&E/3@. -9 E>>-I93 -F <A/50EP: 20:3-/0> H0@03E/. 3/EC030-9:! &E/3@. 5A>EI:A A3290> <A/5: DA/A -BA//A&/A:A93AC 09 32A -FF0>A/ >-/&:! E9C &E/3@. 5A>EI:A 32A E/H. DE: 32A :-@A /AHE09091 1IE/E93-/ -F 32A L03-0:3 @A1E>.E9C :2E/AC D032 <A/50E E BA:3AC 093A/A:3 09 E :3/-91 >A93/E@0]AC :3E3A' ?3

32A :EHA 30HA! -9@. 09 JI1-:@EB0E DE: 32A/A E 3A//03-/0E@@. 5E:AC :.:3AH -F >0B0@ CAFA9:A 32E3 @AF3 >-9:0CA/E5@A >E>2A: -F DAE&-9: 09 32A 2E9C: -F /A&I5@0>E9 A@03A:! -/ E3 @AE:3 E@@-DAC :-HA -F 32AH 3- 5A U@AEMACX 3- 32A>0B0@0E9 &-&I@E30-9 &/0-/ 3- :3E3A C0:HAH5A/HA93' L2A >-H509E30-9 -F 32A:A FE>3-/: HECA F-/ E 2012 &-3A930E@ F-/ &/EA3-/0E9 &-@030>: 09 32A JI1-K:@EB >E:A a\I9>A! (+++! &' ((ob'

L2A <-B0A3KNI::0E9 >E:A! E/1IA: \I9>A! DE: E@H-:3 C0EHA3/0>E@@.-&&-:ACV 2A/A 32A @E>M -F 09:303I30-9E@ /A:-I/>A: DE: >-H509AC D032 E>3IE@&-@030>E@ &-DA/! :09>A 32A NI::0E9: @E>MAC 32A0/ -D9 9E30-9E@ 09:303I30-9:!

5I3 C-H09E3AC 32A FACA/E30-9' L2A HE09 >-9:AcIA9>A DE: 3- &/-CI>A 09NI::0E aE9C 32A ,]A>2 @E9C: E: DA@@b UE F-/H -F 9E30-9E@0:H 32E3 /AkA>3AC32A /A10HA E9C :->0E@0:H! 5I3 C0C 9-3 /AcI0/A 09 E9. DE. E /AAGEH09E30-9-F 32A 9E30-9E@ cIA:30-9R 32E3 DE: F/AA -F 32A >-9BA90A93 :I5:303I30-9 -F 9E30-9E@0:H F-/ >-HHI90:H 32E3 3--M &@E>A 09 HE9. -F 32A O@A::A/ /A&I5K@0>:P aA032A/ 32/-I12 32A /A50/32 -F ,-HHI90:3: E: 9E30-9E@0:3:! -/ 32/-I1232A /0:A F/-H 5A@-D -F 9E30-9E@0:3 E9C E930K,-HHI90:3 H-BAHA93bR E9C32E3 DE: E5@A! E: E >-9:AcIA9>A! 3- AH5/E>A 5-32 A>-9-H0> E9C &-@030>E@@05A/E@0]E30-9 E: BE@0C E9C E33/E>30BA :I5:303I3A: F-/ :->0E@0:HX a\I9>A! (+++!

&' ((gb' =F 320: DE: 09CAAC 32A >E:A! NI::0E9 aE9C ,]A>2b A@03A: >-I@C E>>A&3AG0:3091 /A&I5@0>E9 5-/CA/: E: 32A (#5% 91' 5*5 -F &-@030>E@ E9C A>-9-H0>@05A/E@0]E30-9' Q09E@@.! I9@0MA 03: JI1-:@EB >-I93A/&E/3! 32A <-B0A3 E/H. DE:CAF09AC U09 093A/9E30-9E@! 9-3 C-HA:30> 3A/H:!X 03: H0::0-9 5A091 3- &/AK:A/BA 32A <-B0A3 j90-9P: AG3A/9E@ :I&A/&-DA/ :3E3I:! 9-3 3- 093A/FA/A 09C-HA:30> &-@030>:' ?: E /A:I@3! U32A H0@03E/. DE: AG>@ICAC F/-H 32A 1EHA -F :3E3A C0:HAH5A/HA93X a\I9>A! (+++! &&' (#$*(##b'

?@32-I12 \I9>A >-9:0CA/: 32A:A 09:303I30-9E@ FE>3-/: 3- 5A >/030>E@! 2A/E9E@.:0: C-A: 9-3 A9C 2A/A' =9 &E/30>I@E/! \I9>A /A>-190]A: 32E3 0H&-/3E9320:3-/0>E@ FE>3-/: FEB-/AC .'/$#,1"'/ #5$%/./%$'$#*5( -F 09:303I30-9E@ /AE@030A:!E: D2A9 :2A :3E3A: 32E3 32A /A>A93/E@0]E30-9 -F 32A JI1-:@EB :3E3A DE: 9-3-9@. 09 U<A/50E9 A@03A E9C &I5@0> 093A/A:3:!X 5I3 DE: UE@:- E &-:030-9 32E3/A:-9E3AC D032 >A/3E09 32AHA: 09 <A/50E9 >I@3I/A E9C 20:3-/.' L2I:! &I5@0>-&090-9 :I/BA.: :2-D 32E3 <A/5: DA/A! 5. 32A :3E9CE/C: -F -32A/ 9E30-9:D03209 JI1-:@EB0E! I9I:IE@@. :I&&-/30BA -F E :3/-91 :3E3A' =9CAAC! 09 C0/A>3

% = HECA E :0H0@E/ 09:303I30-9E@ E/1IHA93 D032 /A:&A>3 3- <A/50E 09 6IkE>0> a(++)Eb'



!Q# ADNOPE AJOI@<@

>-93/E:3 3- ,/-E3:! <A/5: /E9MAC 320: >-9:0CA/E5@. E5-BA A>-9-H0> A9/0>2KHA93 09 32A 20A/E/>2. -F 32A0/ &A/:-9E@ 1-E@:X a\I9>A! (+++! &' +Zb' =9ECC030-9! \I9>A /A>-190]A: 32A 0H&-/3E9>A -F <A/50EP: 20:3-/0>E@ B0>30H0]EK

30-9 5. -I3:0CA 0H&A/0E@ &-DA/: E9C U09:0CA/:X 09 8-/@C 8E/ LD- a#:%:! 0932A =9CA&A9CA93 <3E3A -F ,/-E30Eb! E9C >-//A>3@. >-9>@ICA: 32E3 320: 20:3-/K0>E@ /A>-/C E>cI0/AC :&A>0E@ /A:-9E9>A CI/091 32A >/0:0: -F 32A (+o$:' l0MAKD0:A! 09 C0:>I::091 32A NI::0E9 >E:A! \I9>A /A>-190]A: 32E3 32A 20:3-/0>E@E5:A9>A -F E NI::0E9 9E30-9K:3E3A a09 >-93/E:3 3- <A/50EP: 3/EC030-9 -F 09CAK&A9CA93 :3E3A2--Cb DE: E9 0H&-/3E93 FE>3-/ 0920503091 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0K]E30-9 E@-91 &E/30>I@E/0:3 @09A: a\I9>A! (+++! &&' ((Z*((%b' Q09E@@.! \I9>AE@:- AH&2E:0]A: 32A 0H&-/3E9>A -F JA@P3:09P: E9C n0@-:AB0>P: @AECA/:20&! 5I3 0: :E30:F0AC 3- CA/0BA 32A0/ &/AFA/A9>A: F/-H 32A &E/30>I@E/ 09:303I30-9E@/AE@030A: 32E3 32A. >-9F/-93AC' =9:303I30-9E@ /AE@030A:! 32E3 0:! &/AF01I/ACJA@P3:09P: E@@0E9>A D032 &A/0&2A/E@ A@03A: E1E09:3 n0M2E0@ [-/5E>2AB E9C 32A<-B0A3 >A93A/! kI:3 E: 32A. C0C n0@-:AB0>P: E33AH&3 E3 /A>A93/E@0]E30-9 -/!E@3A/9E30BA@.! 32A >/AE30-9 -F E U1/AE3A/ <A/50E9X :3E3A'

j&-9 >@-:A/ 09:&A>30-9! 32A/AF-/A! \I9>AP: 32/AA 09:303I30-9E@ FE>3-/:E&&AE/ 09:IFF0>0A93 F-/ AG&@E09091 32A C0FFA/A9>A 09 -I3>-HA:' =F 320: 0:09CAAC 32A >E:A! 32A9 03 0: 9-3 A930/A@. >@AE/ D2. 32A. E/A E>>-/CAC :I>2-BA/D2A@H091 &/0-/03. 09 32A AG&@E9E30-9 E3 32A AG&A9:A -F &-@030>E@ >I@3I/A

E9Cp-/ @AECA/:20&' L- 5A :I/A! E: \I9>A -5:A/BA:! 20:3-/. 0: 5. 03:A@F E &--/1I0CA 3- &/A:A93 -I3>-HA:! :09>A 03 0: :I5kA>3 3- /A093A/&/A3E30-9 E9C &-@03K0>E@ >-93A:3! :- 32E3 32A cIA:30-9 5A>-HA: UD2. C- &-@030>0E9: I:A 32A &E:3E: 32A. C- E9C D2A9 32A. C-X E9C UD2. C- :-HA 20:3-/0>E@ :.H5-@: :AAH3- /A:-9E3A H-/A 32E9 -32A/: E9C E3 >A/3E09 30HA:qX a\I9>A! (+++! &&' ($%*($gb' L2A &@EI:05@A E9:DA/ 3- 32A:A @A1030HE3A cIA:30-9: 0: 9-3 -9@. 32E3 32A>/030>E@ C0FFA/A9>A @0A: 09 32A &/A:A9>A -/ E5:A9>A -F :-HA 09:303I30-9E@FE>3-/:i2-DABA/ 0H&-/3E93 32A:A H0123 2EBA 5AA9i5I3 32E3 E9 ECAcIE3AAG&@E9E30-9 D-I@C 2EBA 3- >-H509A 20:3-/0>E@! 09:303I30-9E@! E9C @AECA/:20&

FE>3-/:! 10B091 32AH 32A0/ E&&/-&/0E3A /A@E30BA DA0123 09 AE>2 >E:A 3EMA9:A&E/E3A@.! E: DA@@ E: 09 32A >-H&E/E30BA E9E@.:0: E: E D2-@A'=9 ECC030-9! :ABA/E@ -5kA>30-9: >E9 5A /E0:AC D032 /A:&A>3 3- \I9>AP:

E9E@.:0: -F 32A >/030>E@ 09:303I30-9E@ FE>3-/: 32AH:A@BA:' Q0/:3@.! 32A &/A:A9>A-F 09:303I30-9E@ F-I9CE30-9: F-/ 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9 09 32A <A/50E9 >E:ADE: >-H509AC D032 32A #5($#$1$#*5'" >%'+5%(( -F 32A /A&I5@0>! C0B0CAC E: 03DE: 093- 32/AA 4% 7',$* 09CA&A9CA93 A93030A: a<A/50E &/-&A/! 6-kB-C09E! E9C^-:-B-b' =9 -/CA/ 3- -BA/>-HA 32A >-9:303I30-9E@ CAEC@->M 32E3 2EC/A:I@3AC 09 <A/50EP: 09:303I30-9E@ 0H&-3A9>A a09E50@03. 3- FI@@. >-93/-@ U03:

-D9 3A//03-/.Xb! 32A <A/50E9 @AECA/:20& >-I@C 9-3 /A@. -9 03: /A@[email protected]/ 09:303I30-9E@ /A:-I/>A:! 5I3 2EC 3- /A:-/3 3- AG3/EK09:303I30-9E@ HE::H-50@0]E30-9' L2A :3/A9132 -F 320: HE:: H-50@0]E30-9 09 32A @E3A (+o$:! 093I/9! 0: 9-3 I9CA/:3E9CE5@A D032-I3 /AFA/A9>A 3- 32A 1/0ABE9>A: -F 32A^-:-B- <A/5: E9C 32A ^-:-B- H.32 E: 32A >-9:303I30BA H.32 -F H-CA/9<A/50E9 9E30-92--C'

?: FE/ E: 32A NI::0E9 >E:A 0: >-9>A/9AC! 03 0: 9-3 >@AE/ D2. NI::0E9 A@03A:>-I@C 9-3 2EBA /A@0AC -9 32A0/ &/A&-9CA/E9>A 09 FACA/E@ 09:303I30-9:! E9CA:&A>0E@@. 09 >-A/>0BA :3E3A :3/I>3I/A:! 3- :A>I/A E H-/A UFEB-/E5@AX F-/H -F



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33>-I93 32A 093A/A:3: -F &/-:&A>30BA NI::0E9 H09-/030A:' L2A NI::0E9 CAH->/E30> A@03AP: &/AFA/A9>AF-/ &-@030>E@ E9C A>-9-H0> @05A/E@0]E30-9 -BA/ 9E30-9E@0:H C-A: 9-3 EI3-K

HE30>E@@. F-@@-D F/-H 32A 09:303I30-9E@ DAEM9A:: -F 32A NI::0E9 /A&I5@0>!F-/ 32A :0H&@A /AE:-9 32E3 #5($#$1$#*5'" 7',$*/( ,'55*$ ?; $6%-(%")%( %@."'#5 .*"#$#,'" -*$#)'$#*5' Y-/ 0: 03 E>>I/E3A 3- :3E3A 32E3 32A/A DE: 9- :I5:303I30-9-F U>-HHI90:H 5. 9E30-9E@0:HX 09 32A NI::0E9 >E:A! -/ 32E3 32A/A DA/A 9-:0190F0>E93 9E30-9E@0:3 H-BAHA93: 09 NI::0E 03:A@F' T9 32A >-93/E/.! DA>-I@C &-093 3- 32A &/-H09A93 3/A9C 3-DE/C 32A 9E30-9E@0]E30-9 -F NI::0E9>-HHI90:H E: HE90FA:3AC 09 32A /0:A -F 32A 09CA&A9CA93 ,-HHI90:3 SE/3.-F 32A NI::0E9 QACA/E30-9! 32A AHA/1A9>A -F :3/-91 &/-K:3E3A F-/>A: 09 32AE/H. a32A &*;1< 1/-I& -F CA&I30A:b E9C &/-K<-B0A3 H-BAHA93: 09 32A&/-:&A>30BA NI::0E9 C0E:&-/E aA5$%/7/*5$( 09 32A \E@30> :3E3A: E9C n-@C-BEb!32A >-9:0CA/E5@A EH-I93 -F 9E30-9E@0:3 /E55@AK/-I:091 -9 32A &E/3 -F NI:K:0E9 D/03A/:! E9C 32A AG0:3A9>A -F E BE/0A3. -F 9E30B0:3 -/ &/-3-K0H&A/0E@F-/>A: aB'-;'$C! m20/09-B:M0.! E9C -32A/:b E: AB0CA9>A 32E3 E <-B0A3KNI::0E9:3E30:3K9E30-9E@0:3 >-E@030-9 DE: 09 32A HEM091' n-/A-BA/! 32A <-B0A3 E/H.C0C &@E. E /-@A 09 U32A 1EHA -F :3E3A C0:HAH5A/HA93!X 093A/BA9091 09 32A?/HA90EK?]A/5E0CkE9 >-9F@0>3! L50@0:0! E9C 60@90I:! E9C 32A FE0@AC ?I1I:3(++( >-I&' L2A /AE@ cIA:30-9 0: D2. 32A E&&AE@: -F 32A <-B0A3KNI::0E9

U:3E30:3 9E30-9E@0:3:X a 8*(14'/($)%55#+#b FA@@ -9 CAEF AE/:! E9C D2. E/H.093A/BA930-9 09 A3290> >-9F@0>3: >EHA 3- 5A :AA9 E: #""%8#$#-'$% 5. HE9.NI::0E9:! 9-3 -9@. 5. 32A HAH5A/: -F &A/0&2A/E@ 9E30-9E@030A:'

\AF-/A &/->AAC091 FI/32A/! DA :2-I@C 3EMA 9-3A -F 32A >-9B09>091/A:&-9:A 3- 32A @E:3 cIA:30-9 09 \A0::091A/P: a#$$#b HE10:3A/0E@ :3IC. -F 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9 E9C 32A >-@@E&:A -F 32A <-B0A3 j90-9' \A0::091A/E9E@.]A: 32A AHA/1A9>A -F NI::0E9 H-50@0]E30-9 E1E09:3 32A <-B0A3 >A93A/E: &E/3 -F E 5/-ECA/ >.>@A -F 9E30-9E@0:3 >-93A930-9 32E3 1/ECIE@@. I9CA/KH09AC 32A 09:303I30-9E@ >E&E>03. -F 32A <-B0A3 :3E3A 3- B0-@A93@. :I&&/A::

:A>A::0-90:3 H-BAHA93:' <0H&@0F.091 \A0::091A/P: 093/0>E3A E9E@.:0: -F 320:&/->A::! 32/AA 5/-EC FE>3-/: >E9 5A :091@AC -I3 E: >/030>E@V a(b 32A &A>I@0E/\/A]29AB03A /A10HA -F /A&/A::0-9! D032 03: 09:303I30-9E@0]AC /I@A: -F /A:3-/K091 -/CA/ D032-I3 32A I:A -F @E/1AK:>E@A B0-@A9>A E1E09:3 >0B0@0E9:i0'A'!D032-I3 HE:: 5@--C:2AC a09 :3E/M >-93/E:3 3- 32A ,209A:A >I@3I/A -F /A&/A:K:0-9 AGAH&@0F0AC 5. 32A L0E9E9HA9 :>A9E/0-bR a#b 32A /0:091 30CA -F 9E30-9KE@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9 -9 32A <-B0A3 &A/0&2A/. E9C 32A 09>/AE:091@. 2012 >-:3i 5-32 &2.:0>E@ E9C :.H5-@0>i-F :I&&/A::091 093A/9E@ -&&-:030-9 D032 32A2A@& -F 32A E/H.! A:&A>0E@@. 09 32A EF3A/HE32 -F 32A DE3A/:2AC L50@0:0 >E:A

a?&/0@ (+o+bR aZb 32A CA>@09091 @A1030HE>. -F :I>2 093A/BA930-9 09 NI::0E03:A@F! D2A/A NI::0E9 @05A/E@: :I>>A::FI@@. 3/E9:&-:AC 32A U:-BA/A0193. E9CE930K>-@-90E@ F/EHA: >2EH&0-9AC 5. 9-9KNI::0E9:X 3- NI::0E 03:A@F E9CF-/1AC E9 E@@0E9>A D032 U9-9KNI::0E9 :A&E/E30:3: E1E09:3 32A <-B0A3 /A10HAXa\A0::091A/! #$$#! &' Zo+b'

=9 E 5/-ECA/ :A9:A! \A0::091A/P: E9E@.:0: 32A-/A30>E@@. >-H509A: E20:3-/0>E@@. 1/-I9CAC 09:303I30-9E@ E9E@.:0: D032 E9 AH&2E:0: -9 32A /-@A-F MA. UC0:/I&30BAX -/ U>-93A930-I: ABA93:X 09 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9'2 ABA93:! D/03A: \A0::091A/! AH5-C. U32A >-9F@0>3 5A3DAA9 :A@F E9C -32A/



!Q" ADNOPE AJOI@<@

32E3 I9CA/@0A: E@@ 9E30-9E@0:H E9C H-BA: 32E3 >-9F@0>3 093- 32A D-/@C -F E>30-9X a\A0::091A/! #$$#! &' #(b' =9 ECC030-9! 32A &A>I@0E/ F-/H 32E3 >-93A9K30-I: ABA93: 3EMA aA@A>30-9:! CAH-9:3/E30-9:! &-1/-H:b! 32A0/ U:&A>3E>@A@0MA

[email protected] a32A U>/-DCX E: E U:0HI@E3AC 9E30-9Xb! 32A0/ -I3>-HA: aD20>2UAGAH&@0F. 32A E@3A/AC &-::050@030A: F-/ 0HE109091 -9AP: 0CA9303.X E9CCAF09A UAG&A>3E30-9: >-9>A/9091 32A &:.>2-@-10>E@ E9C HE3A/0E@ &A9E@30A:32E3 E>>/IA 3- AG3A/9E@0]091 E &E/30>I@E/ 0CA9303. &-:030-9Xb! E9C 32A DE. 09D20>2 32A. U:2E/&A9 32A >-9F/-93E30-9 5A3DAA9 OI:P E9C O32AHP!X E9C F-/>A&E/30>0&E93: E9C 9-9K&E/30>0&E93: E@0MA 3- HEMA 0CA9303. >2-0>A:iE/A E@@C0FFA/A93 H-CA: 09 D20>2 >-93A930-I: ABA93: :2E&A 9E30-9E@0:3 E>30-9a\A0::091A/! #$$#! &&' #(*#%b' Q09E@@.! >-93A930-I: ABA93: AGAH&@0F. 32AU/A>I/:0BA >E&E>03. -F 9E30-9E@0:HXi0'A'! U32A E50@03. -F 9E30-9E@0:3 E>30-93- 5A>-HA E9 A@AHA93 -F 03: -D9 >EI:E@ :3/I>3I/AX a\A0::091A/! #$$#! &' #hb'

\A0::091A/P: 32A-/A30>E@ F/EHAD-/M 093/-CI>A: 0H&-/3E93 099-BE30-9:09 32A :3IC. -F 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9 E9C /A&/A:A93: E DA@>-HA >-//A>K30-9 3- -BA/@. CA3A/H090:30> E>>-I93: -F 32A <-B0A3 >-@@E&:A' =9CAAC! 20:E33AH&3 3- AG&@E09 2-D 32A U:AAH091@. 0H&-::05@AX C0:093A1/E30-9 -F 32A<-B0A3 :3E3A >EHA 3- 5A :AA9 E: U09AB03E5@AX 5. A@03A: E9C HE::A: E@0MAECC/A::A: -I/ E33A930-9 3- 32A 09CA3A/H09E>. a0F 9-3 >-H&@A3A I9&/AC0>[email protected] -F 32A 20:3-/0>E@ &/->A:: E9C 2A@&: /AC/A:: 32A UFE@@E>. -F /A3/-:&A>K

30BA CA3A/H090:H!X D20>2 2EI93: HE9. D-/M: -F >-H&E/E30BA 20:3-/0>E@:->0-@-1.' n-/A-BA/! \A0::091A/P: F/EHAD-/M >-I@C AE:0@. 5A E&&@0AC 3- 32AJI1-:@EB >E:A! D2A/A E 9IH5A/ -F 0CA9303.K:2E&091 ABA93: a:I>2 E:n0@-:AB0>P: ?&/0@ (+oh E9C dI9A (+o+ ^-:-B- S-@kA :&AA>2A:R 32A HE::/E@@0A: 09 <A/50E -F :IHHA/*FE@@ (+ooR <@-BA90E9 HE:: &/-3A:3: E1E09:3 32A&/-:A>I30-9 -F E930KE/H. E>30B0:3: 09 :IHHA/ (+ooR <@-BA90E9 &/-3A:3:E1E09:3 <A/50EP: 0H&-:030-9 -F C0/A>3 >-93/-@ -BA/ ^-:-B- E9C 32A >-I93A/KH-50@0]E30-9 09 <A/50E 09 nE/>2*?&/0@ (+o+R E9C LICkHE9P: A@A>30-9 09,/-E30Eb 2A@&AC /ACAF09A 32A &E/EHA3A/: -F 32A &A/H0::05@A E9C @A1030HE3A!

C/ED091 32E3 :2E/& 5-I9CE/. 5A3DAA9 U:A@FX E9C U-32A/X 32E3 >2E/E>3A/K0]AC >.>@A: -F 9E30-9E@0:3 >-93A930-9 09 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 E: DA@@'[/E93091! 32A/AF-/A! 32E3 0CA9303.K:2E&091 >-93A930-I: ABA93: &@E.AC

E9 0H&-/3E93 /-@A 09 5-32 <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB C0:093A1/E30-9 &/->A::A:!E9C 32E3 32A DE. 09 D20>2 :I>2 ABA93: 2A@&AC :-@0C0F. -/ :2E&A 9E30-9E@0CA93030A: 9AAC: 3- 5A 3EMA9 093- E>>-I93 09 E9. HI@30KFE>3-/0E@ AG&@E9E30-9-F 32A <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB >-@@E&:A! DA E/A :30@@ @AF3 D032 32A &I]]@A -F AG&@E09091 D2. NI::0E9 A@03A: E9C HE::A: E@0MA E>>A&3AC 32A CAH0:A -F 32A<-B0A3 :3E3A D032 /A@E30BA AcIE90H03.' 7A/A! 03 :2-I@C 5A &-093AC -I3 32E3

:&A>0E@0:3 /A:AE/>2 093- 32A -/1E90]E30-9E@ >I@3I/A -F 32A <-B0A3 E/H. aLE.K@-/! #$$Zb 5/-EC@. >-//-5-/E3A: \A0::091A/P: aE9C \I9>AP:b &-093 32E3 32A<-B0A3 -FF0>A/ >-/&: AG20503AC 1/AE3 /A@I>3E9>A 3- E>30BA@. 093A/BA9A 09 093A/KA3290> >-9F@0>3: aA:&A>0E@@. EF3A/ L50@0:0b E9C E>>A&3AC 03: :I5-/C09E30-9 3->0B0@0E9 @AECA/:20& E9C [-/5E>2AB &A/:-9E@@.' YABA/32A@A::! E: LE.@-/a#$$Zb E@:- &-093: -I3! 32A -/1E90]E30-9E@ 9-/H -F :I5-/C09E30-9 3- >0B0@0E9/I@A DE: DAEMA9AC CI/091 32A [-/5E>2AB &A/0-C! D2A9 E :0190F0>E93H09-/03. -F <-B0A3 -FF0>A/: 5A>EHA E@0A9E3AC F/-H 32A /A10HAP: DAEM/A:&-9:A 3- 093A/9E@ C0:-/CA/ E9C CABA@-&AC E U&/EA3-/0E9 :I5>I@3I/AX 32E3



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33AFI@ C-HA:30> 093A/BA930-9' _A:&03A 320:! 32A 9-/H -F :I5K-/C09E30-9 3- >0B0@0E9 /I@A I@30HE3A@. >E//0AC 32A CE.! 5I3 -9@. EF3A/ ED2-@A :A/0A: -F E33AH&3AC 093A/BA930-9: >I@H09E3091 09 32A ?I1I:3 (++(

>-I& &/-BAC 5-32 I9:I>>A::FI@ E9C >-:3@.' =9 320: /A:&A>3! 32A 5A2EB0-/ -F JI1-:@EB E/H. -FF0>A/: DE: 9-3 E@3-1A32A/ C0FFA/A93! E3 @AE:3 5AF-/A 32ADE/P: -I35/AEM' ?@32-I12! E: \I9>A a(+++b &-093: -I3! 32A JI1-:@EB E/H.09CAAC :ED 03:A@F E: 32A HE09 1IE/E93-/ -F 32A L03-0:3 @A1E>.! E9C DE:20:3-/0>E@@. E::->0E3AC D032 <A/50E H-/A 32E9 D032 32A -32A/ /A&I5@0>:! 320: 5. 03:A@F C-A: 9-3 >-9:303I3A E HEk-/ C0FFA/A9>A F/-H 32A <-B0A3 >E:A aD2A/A<-B0A3 E/H. 3/EC030-9: DA/A! 0F E9.32091! HI>2 H-/A UNI::0E9X 32E9 SE/K30:E9 JI1-:@EB -9A: DA/A U<A/50E9!X E9C D2A/A 32A >-9309IAC AG0:3A9>A -F E UNACX E/H. DE: >@-:A@. 30AC 3- 32E3 -F 32A <-B0A3 -/CA/b' n-/A-BA/! CA:&03A32A &/-@-91AC &A/0-C -F E/H. 093A/BA930-9 09 ̂ -:-B- aEF3A/ (+o(b! JI1-:@EBE/H. -FF0>A/: DA/A 9-3 &E/30>I@E/@. U&/EA3-/0E9'X L2I:! 09 nE/>2 (++(i0'A'! E3 E 30HA D2A9 32A E/H. 09CAAC 5A>EHA E::->0E3AC D032 32A <A/50E9@AECA/:20&i32A E/H.P: >-HHE9C091 -FF0>A/! [A9A/E@ 6A@kM- ÊC0kAB0>!/AF/E09AC F/-H 0H&-:091 E :3E3A -F AHA/1A9>. 5A>EI:A -F 32A -&&-:030-9 -F 32A /A&/A:A93E30BA: -F F-I/ /A&I5@0>: 09 JI1-:@EB0EP: >0B0@0E9 >-@@A>30BA&/A:0CA9>. a<@-BA90E! ,/-E30E! \-:90E E9C 7A/]A1-B09E! E9C nE>AC-90Eb'Y-/ 0: 32A/A HI>2 AB0CA9>A 3- :I11A:3 32E3 JI1-:@EB E/H. -FF0>A/: -F

<A/50E9 -/0109 DA/A <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:3: 5. 0CA-@-10>E@ >-9B0>30-9' =9 FE>3!E: ÊC0kAB0>P: -D9 HAH-0/: 3A:30F. aÊC0kAB0>! (++Zb! F-/ :-HA MA. -FF0>A/:32A &/A:A/BE30-9 -F :->0E@0:H :AAHAC 3- 2EBA /E9MAC 2012A/ 32E9 ABA9 32A&/A:A/BE30-9 -F 32A JI1-:@EB :3E3A! @A3 E@-9A 32A >/AE30-9 -F E U1/AE3A/<A/50E'X 82E3 09CAAC >-9:303I3A: E HEk-/ C0FFA/A9>A! 2-DABA/! 0: 32E3JI1-:@EB E/H. -FF0>A/: -F <A/50E9 -/0109 >EHA 3- &A/>A0BA 32A &/-:&A>3 -F aA:&A>0E@@.b ,/-E30E9 09CA&A9CA9>A E: E 32/AE3 5-32 3- 32A0/ UL03-0:3 JI1-K:@EBX E9C U<A/50E9X 0CA9303. 09 E DE. 32E3 DE: 9-3 3/IA -F NI::0E9 -FF0>A/:09 jM/E09A E9C A@:AD2A/A' =9 320: /AE>30-9! E3 @AE:3! 32A. FE032FI@@. /AF@A>3AC

32A 9E30-9E@ AG&A/0A9>A -F <A/5: F/-H ,/-E30E! D2- 2EC 5AA9 :I5kA>3AC 3-1A9->0CA 09 32A =9CA&A9CA93 <3E3A -F ,/-E30E CI/091 8-/@C 8E/ LD- E9CF/-H D2-:A /E9M: E C0:&/-&-/30-9E3A 9IH5A/ -F SE/30:E9 -FF0>A/: DA/A/A>/I03AC'

? F09E@ &-093 D032 /A:&A>3 3- \A0::091A/P: AG>A@@A93 E9E@.:0: CA:A/BA:3- 5A /E0:AC' ?@32-I12 \A0::091A/ HA30>I@-I:@. C->IHA93: 32A &A>I@0E/>-9:3A@@E30-9 -F FE>3-/: E9C >-93A930-I: ABA93: 32E3 /A:I@3AC 09 32A AHA/K1A9>A -F NI::0EP: -D9 50C F-/ :-BA/A0193.! 2A C-A: 9-3 -FFA/ E FI@@. >-9B09>K091 E9:DA/ 3- 32A cIA:30-9 -F D2. NI::0E9 @05A/E@: >-I@C 3/E9:&-:A 32A

UE930K>-@-90E@X C0:>-I/:A E9C 0HE1A/. F/-H 32A &A/0&2A/. 3- NI::0E 03:A@F'?F3A/ E@@! 03 0: 2012@. I9>-HH-9 F-/ A@03A: -F UC-H09E93 9E30-9:X 09 HI@30K9E30-9E@ :3E3A: 3- :AA 32A0/ 9E30-9 E: 32A 20:3-/0>E@ B0>30H -F 03: U-D9X&-@030>E@ >A93A/ E9C 3- &A/>A0BA 32A :I&&/A::0-9 -F &A/0&2A/E@ 9E30-9E@0:3H-BAHA93: E: E &/A@ICA 3- C0>3E3-/:20& 09 32A >A93A/ 03:A@F' L2A FEH-I:n-:>-D /E@@. :@-1E9 EF3A/ 32A dE9IE/. (++( 60@90I: 093A/BA930-9iUL-CE.l032IE90EiL-H-//-D NI::0EX a\A0::091A/! #$$#! &' Zo$biD-I@C 2EBAHECA 9- :A9:A 9-3 -9@. 09 <A/50E! 5I3 09 E@H-:3 E9. -32A/ 9E30-9K:3E3A:3/I11@091 E1E09:3 32A >2E@@A91A -F &A/0&2A/E@ 9E30-9E@0:H! 09>@IC091 CAHK



!QR ADNOPE AJOI@<@

->/E30> -9A: aA'1'! \/03E09! <&E09! -/ ,E9ECEb' ?: = D0@@ E/1IA 09 32A >-9>@ICK091 :A>30-9 -F 320: E/30>@A! 32A &/A:A9>A -F :I>2 :3/-91 E930K:3E30:3 :A930HA93:09 NI::0E 03:A@F >E9 -9@. 5A AG&@E09AC 5. 32A 3/-I5@AC /A@E30-9 5A3DAA9 :3E3A

E9C 9E30-9 32E3 CABA@-&AC -BA/ 32A @-91 >-I/:A -F 0H&A/0E@ NI::0E9E9C <-B0A3 20:3-/. E9C E>cI0/AC /A9ADAC /A:-9E9>A CI/091 .%/%($/*;+''

? 320/C :A3 -F >-H&E/E30BA E/1IHA93: E5-I3 32A C0FFA/A93 -I3>-HA: 09NI::0E E9C <A/50E 2E: >-9>A93/E3AC -9 32A /-@A -F @AECA/:20&' ? >2E/E>3A/K0:30> F-/HI@E30-9 >E9 5A F-I9C 09 NA9A- lIM0> E9C ?@@E9 l.9>2P: >-H&E/KE30BA :3IC. -F <-B0A3 E9C JI1-:@EB C0:093A1/E30-9V U\A3DAA9 (+o+ E9C (++(!JA@3:09 :A0]AC -9 E :0HHA/091 DEBA -F NI::0E9 9E30-9E@ >-9:>0-I:9A:: E9C>2E99A@AC 03 &-@030>E@@. 093- E C0/A>30-9 32E3 DE: E3 32A :EHA 30HA E930K<-B0A3aE9C E930K[-/5E>2ABb! >-9:303I30-9E@0:3! E9C! D2E3 0: H-/A! 2012@. AFFA>30BA'NAHE/ME5@.! 09 32A @0123 -F NI::0E9 20:3-/.! JA@3:09 E9C 20: E::->0E3A:E/1IAC E3 32A 30HAi09 C0/A>3 >-93/E:3 3- <@-5-CE9 n0@-:AB0> E9C 32A<A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:3:i32E3 NI::0E9: >-I@C 9- @-91A/ EFF-/C AH&0/A! A032A/A>-9-H0>E@@. -/ &-@030>E@@.X alIM0> E9C l.9>2! (++)! &' %$b' ?: F-/n0@-rAB0>! U2A &-::A::AC E 9AE/ E5:-@I3A CA3A/H09E30-9 3- I:A F-/>A 3-&/A:A/BA 32A >-HHI90:3 FACA/E30-9 -/! FE0@091 32E3! 3- FE:20-9 E [/AE3A/<A/50E D03209 32A F-/HA/ JI1-:@EB0EX alIM0> E9C l.9>2! (++)! &' gb' lIM0>E9C l.9>2 >-//A>3@. 9-3A 32E3 32A C0FFA/A9>A 5A3DAA9 NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9

9E30-9E@0:H 2EC E @-3 3- C- D032 32A H-CA -F 32A :3E3AP: 5/AEMI& E9C -FFA/32A F-@@-D091 F-/HI@E30-9 E: E 2.&-32A:0:V USA/2E&:! 32A MA. 09 AG&@E0909132A C0BA/1A93 &E32: 3EMA9 5. NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:H E3 32E3 30HA@0A: 09 32A FE>3 32E3 D2A/AE: 32A <A/5:! >-H&/0:091 -9@. Z)s -F 32A &-&I@EK30-9 -F JI1-:@EB0E! >-I@C >-9B09>A 32AH:A@BA: 32E3 JI1-:@EB0E 2EC 5A>-HAE :D09C@A 5. 9-9K<A/5: 3- /ACI>A <A/50EP: &-DA/! 32A -5B0-I: C-H09E9>A-F NI::0E9: E9C NI::0F0AC <@EB: 32/-I12-I3 32A :3/I>3I/A: -F <-B0A3 &-DA/HECA 320: HI>2 H-/A C0FF0>I@3 3- C- 09 32A >E:A -F 32A <-B0A3 j90-9X alIM0>E9C l.9>2! (++)! &' (%Zb' lIM0> E9C l.9>2! 2-DABA/! 3A@@ I: @033@A E5-I3 D2.

U32A <A/5:X >EHA 3- 3209M -F JI1-:@EB0E E: UE :D09C@A 5. 9-9K<A/5:X 5. 32A(+o$:! 2EBA @033@A 3- :E. E5-I3 32A >-93A93 -F <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ 1/0ABE9>A:!E9C C- 9-3 -FFA/ E9. 32A-/A30>E@ AG&@E9E30-9 -F @AECA/:20& H-30BE30-9: E9CE&&AE@:' =9:3AEC! 32A. E/1IA 32E3 03 DE: 32A >-9F@IA9>A -F <A/50EP: UEI32-/K03E/0E9 &-@030>E@ >I@3I/AX E9C UE11/A::0BA @AECA/:20&X 32E3 AG&@E09: 32AB0-@A93 -I3>-HA 09 JI1-:@EB0E' =9 AFFA>3! 32A0/ E/1IHA93 EH-I93: 3- EBA/:0-9 -F E U<A/50E9 AG>A&30-9E@0:H 32A:0:X 09 D20>2 U1/AE3A/ <A/50E99E30-9E@0:HX F01I/A: E: 32A HE09 20:3-/0>E@ >I@&/03 F-/ JI1-:@EB0EP: 9E30-9E@&/-5@AH:! 5-32 09 32A &E:3 E9C 09 32A &/A:A93' 2 E/1IHA93:! E: = 2EBA

3/0AC 3- :2-D A@:AD2A/A a6IkE>0>! #$$#b! >E99-3 D032:3E9C >@-:A/ :>/I309.!-9 5-32 >-9>A&3IE@ E9C AH&0/0>E@ 1/-I9C:' ?: FE/ E: 32A NI::0E9 >E:A 0:>-9>A/9AC! -9 32A -32A/ 2E9C! lIM0> E9C l.9>2 C- 9-3 AG&@E09 D2. E9C2-D JA@P3:09 DE: E5@A 3- U:A0]A 32A DEBA -F :0HHA/091 NI::0E9 9E30-9E@K0:HX E9C /AC0/A>3 03 09 E9 E930K0H&A/0E@ C0/A>30-9! D2. :I>2 E930K0H&A/0E@K0:H E&&AE@AC 3- E :0190F0>E93 :A1HA93 -F 32A NI::0E9 093A@@01A93:0E! D2. 32AHE::A: DA93 E@-91 D032 03! E9C D2. <-B0A3 -FF0>0E@C-H >-I@C 9-3 2E@332A &/->A:: -F C0:093A1/E30-9! A:&A>0E@@. :09>A 32A UNI::0E9: E9C NI::0F0AC<@EB:X DA/A :- &/AC-H09E93 09 <-B0A3 &-DA/ :3/I>3I/A:' Q-/ E :->0E@K



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J330A930F0>E@@. 1/-I9CAC BA/:0-9 -F 32A @AECA/:20& E/1IHA93! 32A/AF-/A!DA 2EBA 3- @--M A@:AD2A/A! 9-3E5@. 3- 6A/9-9 [E19-9P: E9E@.:0: -F 32A<A/50E9 >E:A'

?>>-/C091 3- [E19-9! UB0-@A93 >-9F@0>3 E@-91 A3290> @09A: 0: &/-B-MAC 5. A@03A: 09 -/CA/ 3- >/AE3A E C-HA:30> &-@030>E@ >-93AG3 D2A/A A3290>03. 0:32A -9@. &-@030>E@@. /A@ABE93 0CA9303.X a[E19-9! (++h! &' (Z%b' L2A HE09H-30BE30-9 -F A@03A: F-/ &/-B-M091 >-9F@0>3 @0A: 09 32A0/ CA:0/A 3- &/-3A>3 32A0/C-HA:30> &-@030>E@ &-DA/ F/-H >2E@@A91A/ >-I93A/KA@03A:' T9A DE. -F C-091:- 09 E &-@030>E@ A9B0/-9HA93 32E3 &/A>@ICA: 32A I:A -F @E/1AK:>E@A F-/>AE1E09:3 C-HA:30> -&&-9A93: 0: U3- :20F3 32A F->I: -F &-@030>E@ CA5E3A EDE.F/-H 0::IA: D2A/A /I@091 A@03A: E/A H-:3 32/AE3A9ACiF-/ AGEH&@A! &/-K&-:AC >2E91A: 09 32A :3/I>3I/A -F C-HA:30> A>-9-H0> -/ &-@030>E@ &-DA/i3-DE/C -32A/ 0::IA:! CAF09AC 09 >I@3I/E@ -/ A3290> 3A/H:! 32E3 E&&AE@ 3- 32A093A/A:3 -F 32A HEk-/03. 09 9-9KA>-9-H0> 3A/H:'X 2 E&&AE@: 3- 32A9E30-9E@ 093A/A:3! 09 3I/9! CA&A9C -9 32A :A@A>30BA /AE>30BE30-9 -F U9E30-9E@3/EC030-9: E9C H.32-@-10A:X E9C 32A 09B->E30-9 -F &-DA/FI@ AG3A/9E@32/AE3: 32E3 >E9 /A:I@3 09 &@E>091 U32A 093A/A:3 -F 32A 1/-I& E5-BA 32A093A/A:3: -F 09C0B0CIE@:!X :- 32E3 A3290>03. 5A>-HA: UE@@ 32E3 >-I93:'X L20:>E9 5A 5A:3 E>20ABAC 32/-I12 32A H-9-&-@0]E30-9 -F &-@030>E@ C0:>-I/:A32/-I12 32A HE:: HAC0E D032 32A 1-E@ -F >/AE3091 U32A 0H&/A::0-9 -F

>-9309I03. 5A3DAA9 &E:3 >-9F@0>3: E9C >I//A93 -9A:X E9C 3I/9091 /I@091A@03A: 093- U>/AC05@A CAFA9CA/:X -F 9E30-9E@ 0CA9303. a[E19-9! (++h! &&' (Z)*(%#b' [E19-9 32A9 &/->AAC: 3- CAH-9:3/E3A 32E3 32A <A/50E9 A@03A @AC 5.n0@-:AB0> >-9:>0-I:@. &I/:IAC 32A :3/E3A1. -F 32A AG3A/9E@0]E30-9 -F >-9KF@0>3 09 E :I>>A::FI@ 50C 3- CAFAE3 5-32 32A 093/EK&E/3. E9C E930K/A10HA-&&-:030-9'

[E19-9P: E/1IHA93 2E: 32A CAH-9:3/E5@A ECBE93E1A -F /[email protected] -93A:3E5@A AH&0/0>E@ &/-&-:030-9: E5-I3 32A &/-G0HE3A >EI:A: -F >-93AH&-K/E/. >-9F@0>3:' n-/A-BA/! 320: E/1IHA93 FE0/@. E>>I/E3A@. >E&3I/A: 32A H-50K

@0]E30-9 :3/E3A1. -F 32A <A/50E9 A@03A 32E3 >-9:0:3AC -F AGE>A/5E3091 A3290>3A9:0-9: E3 32-:A >/030>E@ kI9>3I/A: D2A9 03 FA@3 H-:3 32/AE3A9AC 5. >-I93A/KA@03A >2E@@A91A/:' L2A B0>0-I: >.>@A -F A3290> H-50@0]E30-9: E9C >-I93A/KH-50@0]E30-9: 32E3 DE: 32I: 09EI1I/E3AC 1EBA :I5:AcIA93 A3290> >-9F@0>3:32A >2E/E>3A/ -F U:A@FKFI@F0@@091 &/-&2A>0A:X E9C A9E5@AC 32A <A/50E9 A@03A3- /A5I0@C @A1030HE>. E9C /A3E09 &-DA/ 09 E >2E@@A91091 C-HA:30> &-@030>E@>-93AG3' j9C-I53AC@.! 320: M09C -F E/1IHA93 >-I@C 5A AG3A9CAC 3- 32ANI::0E9 >E:A! 09 D20>2 32A FE0@I/A -F 32A <-B0A3KNI::0E9 A@03A 09 &I/:I091E9 E9E@-1-I: :3/E3A1. D-I@C 2EBA 3- 5A AG&@E09AC 5. >-93AG3IE@ FE>3-/:

:I>2 E:! F-/ 09:3E9>A! 32A &E/3. >-9:A/BE30BA:P @-:: -F >-93/-@ -BA/ 32A HAC0E09 (+oh*(+oo'

_A:&03A 03: CAH-9:3/E5@A :3/A9132:! 2-DABA/! [E19-9P: AG&@E9E30-9 -F 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9 HI:3 5A >-9:0CA/AC 09>-H&@A3A' n-:3 0H&-/3E93@.!320: AG&@E9E30-9 C-A: 9-3 10BA I: E >@AE/ :A9:A -F D2. 32A <A/50E9 cIA:30-9AHA/1AC 09 32A >-93AG3 -F E >-HHI90:3 JI1-:@EB0E 09 D20>2 <A/5: E@@[email protected]/A 32A C-H09E93 1/-I&! D2. A@03A E&&AE@: 3- <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:H DA/A>/AC05@A 3- 32A HE::A: aI9@A:: 03 0: E::IHAC 32E3 HE::A: E/A 092A/[email protected]@@05@Ab! E9C D2. E@3A/9E30BA F-/H: -F <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:H aI93E093AC D032



!R% ADNOPE AJOI@<@

>-HHI90:Hb FE0@AC 3- >E&3I/A 32A HE:: 0HE109E30-9' Y-/ >E9 32A U09:3/IKHA93E@0:3X :>2--@ -F 32-I123 :I>>A::FI@@. >E&3I/A 32A >-H&@AG03. -F n0@-:AB0>P: E&&AE@: 3- BE/0-I: :->0E@ >-9:303IA9>0A: 09 32A @E3A >-HHI90:3

&A/0-C! -/ 3- 32A 9-3 -9@. U<A/50E9X 5I3 E@:- UJI1-:@EBX :A930HA93: -F 20: F-@@-DA/:' Q09E@@.! 320: E&&/-E>2 /ACI>A: 9E30-9E@0:3 0CA-@-1. 3- E909:3/IHA93E@ HAE9: 09 32A 2E9C: -F A@03A:! D032 9- EI3-9-H-I: 09F@IA9>A-9 32A &-@030>E@ &/->A::'

&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D I3 I @IJ3IN GI@:E5

T9A FE>3-/ 32E3 E&&AE/: 3- 5A H0::091 aE3 @AE:3 AG&@0>[email protected] 09 E@@ 32A

EF-/AHA930-9AC AG&@E9E30-9: 0: &-@030>E@ >I@3I/A' ?: 32A EI32-/: -F :ABA/E@H-9-1/E&2: -9 NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:H 2EBA >-9B09>091@. CAHK-9:3/E3AC! 2-DABA/! 320: /A@A1E30-9 -F &-@030>E@ >I@3I/A 3- 32A :3E3I: -F E 5E>M1/-I9C FE>3-/ 0: I9DE//E93AC! F-/ 32A :0H&@A /AE:-9 32E3 D2E3 3/E9K:&0/AC 09 32A (+o$: >E99-3 5A AG&@E09AC D032-I3 /AFA/A9>A 3- 32A AB-@I30-9-F 9E30-9E@0:3 0CA-@-10A: CI/091 32A &/A>AC091 CA>ECA: a\/IC9.! (++oR7A@FE93 \ICC091! (++oR _/E1-B0>K<-:-! #$$#b' =9CAAC! E@H-:3 ABA/.3209132E3 3/E9:&0/AC 09 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 E9C JI1-:@EB0E 09 32A (+o$: 3-I>2AC -932A BA/. >-/A -F 9E30-9E@ 0CA9303. -F E@@ 32A A3290> 1/-I&: 09B-@BAC 09

C/EHE30> &-@030>E@ >-9F@0>3: -BA/ 32A FI3I/A -F 32A :3E3A! 5I3 320: DE: A:&AK>0E@@. :- F-/ NI::0E9: E9C <A/5:' NI::0E9: E9C <A/5: DA/A 5-I9C 3- AG&AK/0A9>A 32A &/-:&A>3 -F :3E3A C0::-@I30-9 E: E 1/AE3A/ >2E@@A91A 3- 32A0/9E30-9E@ 0CA9303. 32E9 32-:A 1/-I&: 32E3 :-I123 E 9AD &-@030>E@ 0CA9303. 09E :3E3A 09CA&A9CA93 F/-H 32A U-&&/A::0BA >A93A/'X 82E3 DE: E3 :3EMA!32A/AF-/A! DE: 9-3 -9@. 32A cIA:30-9 -F D2A32A/ 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 -/JI1-:@EB0E 2EC 5AA9 E H0:3EMA F/-H 32A &-093 -F B0AD -F NI::0E9 -/ <A/50E99E30-9E@ 093A/A:3:! 5I3 32A BA/. HAE9091 -F 32A H-CA/9 20:3-/0>E@ AG&A/0KA9>A: -F 32A:A 3D- 9E30-9:'

L20: 0: D2. AG&@E9E30-9: 32E3 /ACI>A 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9 3- 2%'"0 .*"#$#+ >-9:0CA/E30-9:! 09:303I30-9E@ >EI:A:! -/ 32A 09:3/IHA93E@ HE90&I@EK30-9 -F 9E30-9E@0:H 5. @AECA/: E/A 5-I9C 3- 3/AEC -9 32A :I/FE>A -F 32A HI>2H-/A >-H&@AG &2A9-HA9-9 -F 9E30-9E@ 0CA9303.' Y-3 32E3 32A:A FE>3-/: C0C9-3 HE33A/R E/1IE5@.! E@@ -F 32AH &@E.AC :-HA /-@A 09 AG&@E09091 &-@030>E@-I3>-HA:' \I3 2-D >E9 -9A -FFA/ E9 #5$%/./%$#)%"; '4%91'$% E>>-I93 -F D2E33--M &@E>A 09 NI::0E 09 32A .AE/: (+og*(++( D032-I3 /AFA//091 3- 32A <3E@090:3AG&A/0A9>A! C0/A>3@. -/ 09C0/A>3@. ECC/A::AC 09 ABA/. :&AA>2 5. >-9:A/BEK

30BA E9C @05A/E@ E@0MAq 82E3 3- HEMA -F 32A >-H&@A3A@. I9E930>0&E3AC E33E>M-F @05A/E@ NI::0E9 093A@@A>3IE@: -9 32A U0H&A/0E@ >A93A/XiE &2/E:A D2-:AHAE9091 0: 9-3 E: 3/E9:&E/A93 E: E >-9BA930-9E@ 1@E9>A H0123 :I11A:3q?9E@-1-I:@.! 09 32A <A/50E9 >E:A! 2-D 0: 03 &-::05@A 3- 154%/($'54 <A/50E99E30-9E@0:H 09 32A (+o$: D032-I3 E9 E9E@.:0: -F 32A 20:3-/0>E@ /A@E30-9:20& 5A3DAA9 <A/50E9 E9C JI1-:@EB 0CA93030A: -/ 32A 3/EIHE30> @A1E>0A: -F 3D-D-/@C DE/:q =F 2I9C/AC: -F 32-I:E9C: -F <A/5: >EHA 3- 32A F0A@C -F ̂ -:-B-3- >A@A5/E3A 32A )$$32 E990BA/:E/. -F E 5E33@A 32E3 @AC 3- 32A CAFAE3 -F 32A0/HAC0ABE@ M091C-H E3 32A 2E9C: -F 32A T33-HE9:! 0: 320: 9-3 &/--F A9-I12



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33E9>A -F 20:3-/0>E@ @A1E>0A: 099E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9q

=9 32A &/->A:: -F &-@030>E@ E9C 0CA-@-10>E@ >-93A930-9 E5-I3 32A HAE9K091 -F 32A 9E30-9E@ 2A/03E1A! :.H5-@: E9C D-/C: 5A>EHA E9 09A:>E&E5@AA@AHA93 -F &-@030>E@ H-50@0]E30-9 E9C :2-I@C 9-3 5A >-9:0CA/AC E HA/AE&&A9CE1A 3- 32A A@03AP: &-DA/ 093A/A:3:' T9 32A >-93/E/.! E3 >/030>E@ kI9>K3I/A:! E: CI/091 32A 2012@. :.H5-@0> >A@A5/E30-9 -F 32A )$$32 E990BA/:E/.-F 32A ̂ -:-B- 5E33@A 09 (+o+! D2A9 n0@-:AB0>P: &-&I@E/03. /AE>2AC 03: &AEM!-/ E3 32A 30HA -F 32A C/EHE30> ?I1I:3 (++( >-I& D2A9 -@C NI::0E9 F@E1:E9C 32A D-/C: 2*((#;'DE%"C$(#5D()*?*4' aNI::0EiJA@P3:09iF/AAC-HbDA/A HAE93 3- :I11A:3 32A 50/32 -F E 9AD NI::0E9 0CA9303.! :.H5-@: 5A>EHA

>-9:303I30BA -F &-@030>E@ /AE@03.! E9C 32A 09:3/IHA93E@ >-9:0CA/E30-9: -F @AECA/: DA/A 09AG3/0>E5@. 30AC 3- D2E3 09 32A kE/1-9 -F >@E::0>E@ :->[email protected]:AC 3- 5A >E@@AC $6% 4%7#5#$#*5 *7 ' (#$1'$#*5' L2A HE09 0H&@0>E30-9 -F 320: 0:32E3 DA 9AAC 3- 1/E:&! E: nEG 8A5A/ D-I@C 2EBA &I3 03! 32A HAE9091 -F ABA93:! 9-3 -9@. 3- AG&@E09 32AH >EI:E@@. 5. 09B-M091 HE>/-K:->0-@-10>E@FE>3-/:'

7-D >E9 DA 1/E:& 320: HAE9091 E9C E:>A/3E09 32A 09CA&A9CA93 /-@A -F 0CA-@-1. E9Cp-/ @-91K:3E9C091 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ &A/>A&30-9: 09 AG&@E0909132A /EC0>E@@. C0FFA/A93 &-@030>E@ -I3>-HA: 09 NI::0E E9C <A/50Eq 7-D >E9

DA :A&E/E3A ,/#$#,'" F/-H &A/0&2A/E@ A@AHA93: 09 &-@030>E@ >I@3I/A! E9C!H-/A-BA/! 2-D >E9 DA E:>A/3E09 32A0/ /-@A 09 32A >/0:0: -F 32A (+o$:q T9ADE. 0: 3- @--M F-/ /A>I//A93 H-30F: 32E3 /AE&&AE/ E3 H-HA93: -F :3E3A >/0:A:!D2A9 >I@3I/E@ A@03A: -F 32A >-/A 9E30-9 E/A F-/>AC 3- /AAGEH09A 32A0/ 2032A/3-3EMA9KF-/K1/E93AC >-HH03HA93 3- 32A @E/1A/ HI@309E30-9E@ :3E3A' ?9-32A/DE. 0: 3- @--M E3 32A C-H09E93 H-30F: 09 32A C0:>-I/:A -F 093A@@A>3IE@: E:32A >@E::0> >E//0A/: -F 9E30-9E@ >-9:>0-I:9A:: 09 320: &E/3 -F 32A D-/@C' ?:30@@ 320/C DE. 0: 3- E9E@.]A 32A :.H5-@0>! 9-3 :-@A@. 09:3/IHA93E@! A@AHA93:

09 @AECA/:20& E&&AE@: E3 >/030>E@ kI9>3I/A: 09 32A &-@030>E@ &/->A::'

g

? 1--C :3E/3091 &-093 F-/ C0:>I::091 :I>2 20:3-/0>E@@. 091/E09AC &A/K>A&30-9: E9C E3303ICA: 09 32A <A/50E9 >E:A 0: -FFA/AC 5. 32A <A/5K,/-E3E1/AAHA93 -F (+Z+' L20: DE: E 2012@. :0190F0>E93 ABA93 09 JI1-:@EB 20:3-/.

g ?3 320: &-093! = :2-I@C @0MA 3- C0/A>3 32A /AECA/P: E33A930-9 3- E :0H0@E/ E/1IHA93! HECA 5.?5/EH: a#$$#b' l0MA HA a6IkE>0>! (++)5b! ?5/EH: :3/A::A: 32A 0H&-/3E9>A -F 9E30-9E@0:3C0:>-I/:A! E/1IA: 32E3 32A 20:3-/0>E@ E5:A9>A -F E9 A3290> C0E:&-/E cIA:30-9 DAEMA9AC A3290>NI::0E9 9E30-9E@0:H! C->IHA93: 32A >-93A930-I: E9C EH50BE@A93 HAE9091: -F NI::0E9 0CA9K

303.! AH&2E:0]A: MA. C0FFA/A9>A: 09 NI::0E9KjM/E090E9 E9C <A/5K,/-E3 /A@E30-9:! E9C I9CA/K:>-/A: 32A 0H&-/3E9>A -F 32A 1-E@ -F 9E30-9E@ I90F0>E30-9 09 32A <A/50E9 >E:A' j9F-/3I9E3A@.!CA:&03A 32A:A DA@@K3EMA9 E/1IHA93:! ?5/EH:P: E&&/-E>2 :IFFA/: F/-H E 9IH5A/ -F AH&0/0>E@E9C >-9>A&3IE@ F@ED: 32E3 >E99-3 5A AGEH09AC 2A/A 09 CA3E0@' <IFF0>A 03 3- 9-3A 32E3 ?5/EH:FE0@: 3- C->IHA93 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ >-9309I03. -BA/ 30HA! E F@ED 32E3 0: A:&A>0E@@. B0:05@A 09 20:3/AE3HA93 -F 32A <A/50E9 >E:A' L2I:! ?5/EH: &-:03: E C0/A>3 >-9309I03. 09 <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:3C0:>-I/:A F/-H 32A 3I/9 -F 32A >A93I/. 3- 32A (+o$:! C0:>E/C091 32A DE. 09 D20>2 32A <A/5:P>-HH03HA93 3- JI1-:@EB0:H EFFA>3AC <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ 0CA9303.' =9 32A <-B0A3KNI::0E9 >E:A! -932A -32A/ 2E9C! ?5/EH: C-A: 9-3 3-I>2 -9 32A &/-5@AHE30> /A@E30-9:20& 5A3DAA9 NI::0E E9C32A <-B0A3 >A93A/ E3 E@@' ?: 32A F-@@-D091 C0:>I::0-9 CAH-9:3/E3A:! 2-DABA/! 32A:A FE>3-/: E/A>/030>E@ F-/ I9CA/:3E9C091 32A C0FFA/A9>A 09 -I3>-HA:'



!R$ ADNOPE AJOI@<@

5A>EI:A 32A >/AE30-9 -F E @E/1A! EI3-9-H-I: ,/-E3 I903 09 32A &/AB0-I:@.I903E/. JI1-:@EB :3E3A &I3 E9 A9C 3- 32A 1I0C091 E::IH&30-9 -F 093A/DE/JI1-:@EB0:Hi32A 0CAE 32E3 <A/5:! ,/-E3:! E9C <@-BA9A: DA/A U32/AA 3/05A:

-F 32A -9AK9EHAC JI1-:@EB &A-&@A a9E30-9b'X Q/-H 32A <A/50E9 &-093 -F B0AD! 32A E1/AAHA93 &/-BAC &/-5@AHE30> -9 32/AA >-I93:V a(b 32A 9AD ,/-E3I903 09>-/&-/E3AC E @E/1A 9IH5A/ -F A3290> <A/5: D2-:A >-@@A>30BA /0123:DA/A 9-3 1IE/E93AACR a#b 32A E1/AAHA93 09>-/&-/E3AC 093- 32A ,/-E3 I903 E:0190F0>E93 &E/3 -F \-:90E E9C 7A/]A1-B09E! 3/EC030-9E@@. >-BA3AC 5. <A/K 50E9 9E30-9E@0:3:R aZb 03 DE: I9>@AE/ D2A32A/ ,/-E3 @AECA/: I9CA/:3--C 32A9AD FACA/E@ I903 E: E &/-:&A>30BA ,/-E3 9E30-9E@ 2-HA@E9C -/ E: E9 093A1/E@&E/3 -F 32A JI1-:@EB :3E3A' =9 /A:&-9:A 3- 32A:A &/-5@AH:! <A/50E9 093A@@A>K

3IE@: E/30>I@E3AC 32A0/ 0CAE: E5-I3 32A /A@E30-9:20& 5A3DAA9 <A/50E9 E9CJI1-:@EB 0CA93030A:! <A/5K,/-E3 /A@E30-9:! E9C 32A <A/50E9 20:3-/0>E@ AG&AK/0A9>A H-/A AG&@0>03@. 32E9 E3 E9. -32A/ 30HA 09 32A 9E30-9P: 20:3-/.' )

Q/-H 32A :3E9C&-093 -F 20:3-/0>E@ @A1E>0A:! 32/AA 32AHA: B-0>AC 5. 32A:A093A@@A>3IE@: :3E9C -I3 09 &E/30>I@E/V a(b >-9>A/9 D032 <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ I903.!E9C 32A 5-I9CE/0A: -F 32A &/-:&A>30BA <A/50E9 FACA/E@ I903R a#b 32A :A@FK>-9>A&30-9 -F <A/5: E: E :3E3AK5I0@C091 &A-&@AR aZb <A/50E9 :E>/0F0>A: F-/ 32A>-HH-9 JI1-:@EB :3E3A E9C 32A <A/5:P :&A>0E@ 20:3-/0>E@ H0::0-9 09 03:>/AE30-9 E9C &/A:A/BE30-9'

? /A&/A:A93E30BA :EH&@A -9 32A F0/:3 32AHA 0: -FFA/AC 5. 6@EC0H0/,-/-B0>P: AG&-:030-9 -F 32A 09>-9:0:3A9>0A: -F 32A ?1/AAHA93' ?>>-/C091 3-,-/-B0>! D20@A 32A ,/-E3 :0CA >@E0HAC :-HA C0:3/0>3: -9 32A 5E:0: -F 32A0/,E32-@0> a0'A'! H-:3@. ,/-E3b HEk-/030A:! 03 >@E0HAC -32A/: -9 32A 5E:0: -F ,/-E3 U20:3-/0> /0123X -/ E/1IHA93: E5-I3 1A-1/E&20> >-9301I03.' =9 -32A/09:3E9>A:! 32A ,/-E3 :0CA CA@05A/E3A@. C0:/A1E/CAC 32A AG0:3A9>A -F T/32-KC-G a0'A'! <A/50E9b HEk-/030A: 09 C0:3/0>3: E33E>2AC 3- 32A ,/-E3 I903 a^909!NEB90 M-3E/0! 6/109 n-:3b! D20@A >@E0H091 -32A/ E/AE: a09 32A YA/A3BE

BE@@A.b -9 A3290> 1/-I9C:' 2 09>-9:0:3A9>0A: >-I@C 5A F-/10BA9! E/1IAC,-/-B0>! 0F 32A cIA:30-9 DE: -9A -F C/ED091 UECH090:3/E30BA 5-I9CE/0A:X09 E >-HH-9 JI1-:@EB :3E3A' 7-DABA/! U03 0: >@AE/ E9C -5B0-I: 32E3 320: 0:9-3 kI:3 E9 ECH090:3/E30BA C0B0:0-9! 5I3 E &I/A 3/05E@ eA3290>f C0B0:0-9' T932A ,/-E3 :0CA! 09 E9. >E:A! 03 DE: 9ABA/ C-I53AC 32E3 320: DE: 32A 5-I9CE/.-F E 9E30-9E@ 3A//03-/. E9C E 9E30-9E@ :3E3A' YE3I/E@@.! 09 :I>2 E C0B0:0-9<A/5: >E99-3 /AHE09 09C0FFA/A93 3- 32A -I3>-HA'X <09>A 32A H0GAC >2E/E>3A/-F HE9. C0:3/0>3: &/ABA93AC E >@AE/ A3290> CAHE/>E30-9! >-9309IAC ,-/-B0>!32A &/09>0&@A -F kI:30>A CAHE9CAC 32E3 32A 9IH5A/ -F >-K9E30-9E@: @AF3 -I3

) L2A:A 0CAE: DA/A /A>-/CAC 09 32A k-I/9E@ &/.(+# 8"'( aL2A <A/50E9 6-0>Ab! 32A -/1E9 -F 32A<A/50E9 ,I@3I/E@ ,@I5! 32A 9AD@. F-/HAC 9-9K&E/3. -/1E90]E30-9 -F <A/50E9 093A@@A>3IE@:' =3CA:A/BA: 3- 5A &-093AC -I3 32E3 E 9IH5A/ -F 32A:A 093A@@A>3IE@: &E/30>0&E3AC 09 H-BAHA93: F-/<A/50E9 E9C JI1-:@EB I90F0>E30-9! E9C D/-3A 0H&-/3E93 20:3-/0A: -F \-:90E! <A/50E! E9CJI1-:@EB0E' L20: DE: 3/IA -F 20:3-/0E9: 6@EC0H0/ ,-/-B0>! <@-5-CE9 d-BE9-B0>! _/E1-:@EB<3/E9kEM-B0>! E9C 6E:- ,I5/0@-B0>' =9 -32A/ D-/C:! 32A -&090-9: -F 320: >I@3I/E@ A@03A >E9 5A>-9:0CA/AC /A&/A:A93E30BA -F <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ 32-I123' Q-/ 32A F-/HE30-9 -F 32A <A/50E9,I@3I/E@ ,@I5 :AA _0H0> a(++)! B-@' =! &&' g$)*g((b' ?@@ :I5:AcIA93 /AFA/A9>A: 3- E/30>@A: F/-H&/.(+# 8"'( E/A F/-H 32A d-B0>0> a(++(b >-@@A>30-9'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J3330BA I903: 5A AcIE@ -9 32A <A/50E9 E9C ,/-E3 :0CA:' ?: 03 DE:!2-DABA/! 32A 9IH5A/ -F <A/5: 09 32A 9AD ,/-E3 I903 DE: 3D0>A 32A 9IH5A/-F ,E32-@0>: a9-3 E@@ -F 32AH ,/-E3:b 09 32A /A:3 -F JI1-:@EB0E' ? F09E@ /AE:-9

F-/ >-9>A/9! >-9>@ICAC ,-/-B0>! DE: 32A -&A9@. AG&/A::AC B0AD -F ,/-E3@AECA/: 32E3 32A E1/AAHA93 HE/MAC kI:3 UE &2E:AX 09 32A 9E30-9E@ :3/I11@A'<09>A 32A HAE9091 -F 320: U&2E:AX DE: 2E/C@. I9>@AE/! <A/5: >-I@C 9-3 5A/A&/-E>2AC F-/ CAHE9C091 H-/A I903. U09 <A/50E9 /E9M:X a,-/-B0>eY-BAH5A/ #Z! (+Z+f! d-B0>0>! (++(! &&' (o*(+b' nE9. >-93/05I3-/: 3- &/.(+# 8"'( :A>-9CAC ,-/-B0>P: E/1IHA93:! A032A/ 5. &-093091 3- 32A @E/1A 9IH5A/-F <A/5: 09:0CA 32A ,/-E3 I903 -/ 5. CAHE9C091 32E3 HEk-/03. <A/50E9C0:3/0>3: 09 ,/-E30E! <@EB-90E! \-:90E! E9C _E@HE30E 5A 10BA9 32A /0123 3-CA>0CA F/AA@. 3- D20>2 FACA/E@ I903 32A. :2-I@C 5A E33E>2AC a:AA d-B0>0>!(++(! &&' #$*##! #o*#+! %$*%#! ($Z*($)b' 82E3ABA/ 32A AGE>3 5-I9CE/0A: -F 32A U<A/50E9 I903X C/ED9 5. 32A BE/0-I: >-93/05I3-/:! 32A >@AE/ 0H&@0>E30-9DE: 32E3 <A/5: 2EC 32A /0123 3- :A@FKCA3A/H09E30-9 09 E@@ C0:3/0>3: 09 D20>232A. >-9:303I3AC HEk-/030A:! /A1E/C@A:: -F U20:3-/0>X -/ >I//A93 ECH090:3/EK30BA 5-/CA/:! A:&A>0E@@. 09 >E:A -F JI1-:@EB0EP: C0::-@I30-9'

L2A -32A/ 3D- &/-H09A93 32AHA: 32E3 F01I/AC &/-H09A93@. -9 32A&E1A: -F &/.(+# 8"'( >-9>A/9AC 32A -BA/E@@ :0190F0>E9>A -F 32A 9E30-9E@ :3E3A09 <A/50E9 20:3-/. E9C 32A <A/5:P 2A/-0> /-@A 09 32A >/AE30-9 -F 32A >-HH-9

JI1-:@EB :3E3A' L2I:! <@-5-CE9 _/E:M-B0> E/1IAC 32E3 3- 9A1@A>3 32A 093A/KA:3: -F 32A JI1-:@EB :3E3A D-I@C >-9:303I3A E 5A3/E.E@ -F 32A <A/50E9 :3E3AK 5I0@C091 3/EC030-9V UL2A 5A:3 <A/50E9 3/EC030-9 0:V 32A :3E3A E5-BA E@@' <0H&@. 5A>EI:A D032-I3 -9AP: -D9 9E30-9E@ :3E3A 32A/A 0: 9- F/AAC-H! 9- >I@3I/A!9- &/-1/A::! 9- @0FA' ` Q-/ <A/5: @0FA 0: D-/32 @0B091 -9@. 09 -I/ -D9 F/AA9E30-9E@ :3E3A! 09 D20>2 DA -I/:A@BA: E/A HE:3A/: -F -I/ FE3A' ` L2A D2-@A20:3-/. -F 32A <A/5: >E9 5A I9CA/:3--C -9@. 0F 320: 0: MA&3 09 H09C'Xa_/E:M-B0> eQA5/IE/. #+! (+%$f! 09 d-B0>0>! (++(! &&' (#%*(#ob' <0H0@E/@.!_/E1-:@EB <3/E9kEM-B0> AH&2E:0]AC 32A >-@-::E@ &/0>A 32E3 <A/5: 2EC &E0C

F-/ 32A0/ 3D- 09CA&A9CA93 :3E3A:i<A/50E E9C n-93A9A1/-' L2A:A :E>/0F0>A:DA/A 32A HE09 /AE:-9 D2. <A/5: UE@DE.: :A&E/E3AC 32A /A10HA F/-H 32A:3E3A' L2A /A10HA D0@@ >-HA E9C 1-! 5I3 32A :3E3A HI:3 5A &/A:A/BACXa<3/E9kEM-B0> e_A>AH5A/ #o! (+Z+f! 09 d-B0>0>! (++(! &&' +$*+%b' T32A/ >-9K3/05I3-/: ECBE9>AC 32A E/1IHA93 32E3 <A/5: 2EC :E>/0F0>AC 32A H-:3 F-/ 32A>-HH-9 JI1-:@EB :3E3A E: DA@@' ?: -9A AC03-/0E@ &I3 03V

03 0: E9 09C0:&I3E5@A FE>3 32E3 32A <A/5: 5-/A 32A 1/AE3A:3 :E>/0F0>A:!E9C 2EC 10BA9 H-:3 F-/ 03 eJI1-:@EB0Ef' 82E3 HEMA: 32AH e<A/5:f

C0FFA/A93 F/-H -32A/: 0: 32A CAB-3AC &E/30>0&E30-9 -F E@@ &-&I@E/:3/E3E 09 32A >-9:3/I>30-9 -F 32A 9AD :3E3A! D2A/AE: 09 32A >E:A -F -32A/: -9@. E :A@A>3 :3/E3IH -F &E3/0-30> :-9: 3--M &E/3 09 320: 3E:M'L20: 0: D2. 09 32A :-I@ -F ABA/. <A/5! D2A32A/ &AE:E93 -/ >030]A9!EHE3AI/ -/ 093A@@A>3IE@! JI1-:@EB0E 0: E HE33A/ -F 32A CAA&A:3FAA@091:! 32A :I&/AHA @ED -F 20: E>30B03.' ` YABA/ H09C 2-DC0FFA/A93 03 H0123 E&&AE/ F/-H 30HA 3- 30HA! JI1-:@EB0E 0: H-/ACAE/ 3- 32A <A/5: 32E9 ABA9 32A0/ 9E//-DA/ 9E30-9E@ FAA@091:' ?@@20: :E>/0F0>A: DA/A HECA F-/ JI1-:@EB0E! E9C 2A D0@@ 9-3 /AF/E09



!R# ADNOPE AJOI@<@

F/-H 32AH 3-CE. 0F 32A 093A/A:3: -F JI1-:@EB0E :- CAHE9C' L2A -9@.>-9>A::0-9 2A E:M: F-/ 0: 32A 1IE/E93AA 32E3 32A:A :E>/0F0>A: D0@@3/I@. :A/BA 32A >EI:A -F :3/A9132A9091 03 ad-B0>0>! (++(! &&' ((%*(()b'

Q-/ 320: /AE:-9! >-9>@ICAC 32A AC03-/0E@! D2-ABA/ :09: E1E09:3 <A/5C-H>-I@C 5A F-/10BA9! 5I3 32A -9A D2- U:09: E1E09:3 32A :3E3A 0: -I/ H-/3E@A9AH. D032 D2-H DA A91E1A 09 -&A9 >-H5E3'X

W9-I12 2E: 5AA9 :E0C 3- 0@@I:3/E3A 32A /A@ABE9>A -F 32A:A E/1IHA93: F-/32A >-93AH&-/E/. &A/0-C' L2A 0CAE 32E3 32A JI1-:@EB :3E3A DE: 32A 5A:31IE/E93-/ -F <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ I903. E9C 32E3 :2-/3 -F 32E3! <A/5: D-I@C 2EBA32A /0123 3- >-@@A>30BA :A@FKCA3A/H09E30-9 09 E@@ C0:3/0>3: 09 D20>2 32A.

>-9:303I3AC HEk-/030A:! /A1E/C@A:: -F 32A AG0:3091 ECH090:3/E30BA 5-/CA/:!HECA E C/EHE30> /AE&&AE/E9>A 09 32A @E3A (+o$:' ?3 32E3 30HA! 32A /0123 3-:A@FKCA3A/H09E30-9 -F <A/5: 09 ,/-E30E E9C \-:90E DE: :AA9 E: -BA//0C091>-9:303I30-9E@ 093A/&/A3E30-9: 32E3 B0ADAC JI1-:@EB /A&I5@0>: E: 32A HE09@->0 -F :A@FKCA3A/H09E30-9 a7E.CA9! (++#b' L2A >-93AH&-/E/. /A@ABE9>A -F 32A -32A/ 3D- 32AHA:i32A <A/5:P :A@FK>-9>A&30-9 E: E U2A/-0>X &A-&@A E9C32A :&A>0E@ &@E>A ->>I&0AC 5. 32A :3E3A 09 <A/50E9 20:3-/.i0: H-/A C0FF0>I@33- CAH-9:3/E3A' YABA/32A@A::! :ABA/E@ -5:A/BE30-9: >E9 5A HECA 3- 0@@I:K3/E3A 0H&-/3E93 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ >-9309I030A:'

Q0/:3@.! 03 0: DA@@ 3- /AHAH5A/ 32E3! I9@0MA 32A0/ NI::0E9 \-@:2AB0M>-I93A/&E/3:! JI1-:@EB >-HHI90:3: DE1AC 32A0/ /AB-@I30-9 09 32A >-93AG3-F YE]0 E9C =3E@0E9 FE:>0:3 ->>I&E30-9'h Y-3D032:3E9C091 32A >-9309IAC>-HHI90:3 H-50@0]E30-9 >EH&E019 EH-91 H09-/030A: E9C E1E09:3 U1/AE3A/<A/50E9 2A1AH-9.!X L03-P: SE/30:E9: C0:&/-&-/30-9E3A@. /A@0AC -9 A3290><A/5: E9C n-93A9A1/09: CI/091 32A F0/:3 3D- .AE/: -F 32A DE/! E: 0@@I:3/E3AC 5. 32A FE>3 32E3! E: @E3A E: (+%Z! (g -F #h SE/30:E9 C0B0:0-9: DA/A /A>/I03ACF/-H 32A:A 3D- 1/-I&: a\I/M:! (+)(! &' (##b' L2A/A 0: @033@A C-I53 32E3 320::I>>A::FI@ H-50@0]E30-9 2EC HI>2 3- C- D032 32A @-91K:3E9C091 <A/50E9E9C n-93A9A1/09 3/EC030-9 -F /A:0:3E9>A 3- F-/A019 /I@A' 7A/-0> /A:0:3E9>AE1E09:3 -BA/D2A@H091 -CC: DE:! 09 E9. >E:A! E9 093A1/E@ &E/3 32A ^-:-B-H.32 E: 32A CAF09091 9E30-9E@ H.32 -F 32A <A/5: aWHHA/3! (++$R 6I>090>2E9C WHHA/3! (++(b' \. E&&/-&/0E3091 320: H.32 -F 2A/-0> /A:0:3E9>A F-/ 32A0/&I/&-:A:! 32A >-HHI90:3: A:3E5@0:2AC E @E3A93 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ a9-3 09:30K3I30-9E@b @09M 5A3DAA9 <A/50E9 20:3-/. E9C 32A SE/30:E9 H-BAHA93 E9CHECA 32A &-:3DE/ JI1-:@EB >-HHI90:3 :3E3A E @A1030HE3A -5kA>3 -F <A/50E90CA930F0>E30-9' L2A :I&A/0H&-:030-9 -F 32A SE/30:E9 AG&A/0A9>A I&-9 3/EC0K

30-9E@ <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ 0CA9303. DE: >-9F0/HAC 09 E @-9103IC09E@ :3IC. 5.3D- 8A:3A/9 E932/-&-@-10:3: a7E@&A/9 E9C 7E@&A/9! (+o%! &' (#Zb E9C 32A/A0: HI>2 C0/A>3 E9C 09C0/A>3 AB0CA9>A F-/ 03 09 32A DE/30HA HAH-0/: -F MA.SE/30:E9 F01I/A: -F <A/50E9 E9C n-93A9A1/09 -/0109 a_AC0kA/! (++$! B-@' =!&&' #h*Z(! &&' hh*ho! &&' %#Z*%#gR _k0@E:! (+hh! &&' (%Z! Z#(b E: DA@@ E: 09@03A/E3I/A aÎ@A9-B0>! (+)#R T@kE>E! (+)hb'

h =9 320: /A:&A>3! E: d-29:-9 a(+)#b -5:A/BAC @-91 E1-! 32A JI1-:@EB /AB-@I30-9 DE: H-/A @0MA32A ,209A:A /AB-@I30-9 32E9 32A NI::0E9 &/-3-3.&A'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33E@@. /--3AC &A/>A&30-9: E9C D2E33/E9:&0/AC 09 32A (+o$:q LD- 5/0AF &-093: >E9 :A/BA 3- 0@@I:3/E3A 32E3 E @09MAG0:3:' L2A F0/:3 -9A 0: 09 32A F-/H -F E cI-3A F/-H 32A (+o) UnAH-/E9CIH

-F 32A <A/50E9 ?>ECAH. -F <>0A9>A:!X 32A MA. C->IHA93 -F E /AAHA/1091<A/50E9 &E/30>I@E/0:H 09 32A (+o$:V

=3 0: F0/:3 E9C F-/AH-:3 E cIA:30-9 -F 32A <A/50E9 &A-&@A E9C #$( ($'$%'L2A 9E30-9 D20>2 2EC E>20ABAC :3E3A2--C EF3A/ E &/-@-91AC E9C 5@--C. :3/I11@A! 2EC >/AE3AC E &E/@0EHA93E/. CAH->/E>. -9 03:-D9! E9C D20>2 09 32A @E:3 3D- DE/: @-:3 #'g H0@@0-9 >-H&E3/0-3:!0: 32A -9@. -9A D20>2 2E: 5AA9 4%./#)%4 *7 #$( *>5 ($'$% 5. E &E/3.

E&&E/E3 >-HH033AA EF3A/ F-I/ CA>ECA: 09 32A 9AD JI1-:@EB0E' ?D-/:A 20:3-/0>E@ CAFAE3 09 &AE>A30HA >E9 2E/C@. 5A 0HE109ACaUnAH-/E9CIH!X (++g! &&' ++*(%+R 03E@0>: H09Ab'

,@AE/@.! 32A/A 0: &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ >-9309I03. 09 32A &A/>A&30-9 32E3 32A>/AE30-9 -F E9 09CA&A9CA93 9E30-9E@ :3E3A DE: 32A <A/5:P H-:3 0H&-/3E9320:3-/0> E>20ABAHA93! E9C -9A -F D20>2 32A. DA/A CA&/0BAC 5. E/503/E/.09:303I30-9E@ CA>0:0-9: a32A C/ED091 -F 5-I9CE/0A: 5A3DAA9 /A&I5@0>: E9CE@:- EI3-9-H-I: &/-B09>A: 09 <A/50E! D20>2 C0B0CAC 32A <A/50E9 9E30-9b

5. 32A >-HHI90:3 /A10HA' L2A/A 0: -9A MA. C0FFA/A9>A! 2-DABA/! 5A3DAA932A &A/>A&30-9: -F @AEC091 <A/50E9 093A@@A>3IE@: 09 (+Z+ E9C 09 (+o)' j9@0MA(+Z+! D2A9 32-:A D2- E/1IAC F-/ 32A >/AE30-9 -F :A&E/E3A <A/50E9 FACA/E@I903 ECB->E3AC 32A &/A:A/BE30-9 -F 32A JI1-:@EB :3E3A E: E9 E@H-:3 :E>/AC0CAE@! 5. 32A @E3A (+o$: :I>2 D0@@0919A:: 3- CAFA9C 32A JI1-:@EB :3E3A DE:DAEMA9AC' 7-DABA/! 03 D-I@C 5A &/-F-I9C@. D/-91 3- 3209M 32E3 03 DE:E5:A93' ?9 AG>A@@A93 AGEH&@A -F 32A &/A:A9>A -F :3/-91 JI1-:@EB H-30F:aE9C! E3 32A :EHA 30HA! E /AFI3E30-9 -F 32A &-093 32E3 <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:HDE: AG>@I:0BA@. UA3290>Xb 0: -FFA/AC 5. 32A F-@@-D091 :3E3AHA93 -F n0/-:@EB<-@AB0>! 32A 1/E::/--3: -/1E90]A/ -F 32A ^-:-B- <A/5: E9C 32A HE09 @AECA/-F HE:: /E@@0A: 32E3 :2--M <A/50E! 6-kB-C09E! E9C n-93A9A1/- 09 (+oo E9C(+o+V

82. 0: <A/50E 32A H-:3 093A/A:3AC 09 JI1-:@EB0Eq \A>EI:A <A/5: @0BA-9 32A D2-@A 3A//03-/. -F JI1-:@EB0E' ?9C 0F .-I D0:2 E@@ <A/5: 3-@0BA 09 -9A >-I93/.! 320: >E9 5A -9@. 09 JI1-:@EB0E' F%""= 5*>= >%,*1"4 ?%,*-% ' ($'$% >#$6 7'(,#($ $/'#$( '54 ,/%'$% %$65#,'""; ,"%'5 ($'$%(=

?1$ $6#( #( 5*$ *1/ .%/(.%,$#)%: ` L2A C0FF0>I@3. 0: 32E3 -I/ /A&I5@0>:E/A F0/:3 E9C F-/AH-:3 9E30-9E@' ` \I3 03 0: -9A 32091 3- &/A:A/BA-9AP: 9E30-9E@ 0CA9303. E9C :.H5-@:! E9C E9-32A/ 3- C- :-HA32091A@:A -9 32E3 &/A3AG3' ` WBA/.32091 32E3 0: 9-3 -9 32A @09A -F JI1-K:@EB0:H HI:3 1-' JI1-:@EB0:H 2E: 3- 5A /AE@0]AC! 5I3 9-3 09 32AF-/H -F I903E/0:H! :- 32E3 <A/5:! ,/-E3:! E9C <@-BA9A: @-:A 32A0/9E30-9E@ >2E/E>3A/0:30>:! 5I3 E: 32A F0/:3 32091 09 320: :3E3A' 8A F0/:32EBA 3- 5A JI1-:@EB:' ?9C! EF3A/ 32E3! .-I >E9 5A E ,/-E3 -/ E <A/5!E9C :30@@ EF3A/ 32E3 .-I >E9 @0BA 09 320: -/ 32E3 /A10-9! >-HHI9A!



!R" ADNOPE AJOI@<@

:3/AA3! E9C FEH0@.' ` L2E3 0: 0F DA DE93 3- 2EBA E :3E3At a<-@AB0>!(+o+! &' +$R AH&2E:0: H09Ab'

=3 0: >-HH-9@. :3E3AC 32E3 n0@-:AB0> &-:030-9AC 20H:A@F E: E <A/50E99E30-9E@0:3 E9C 32E3 2A &@E.AC 32A 9E30-9E@0:3 >E/C 09 -/CA/ 3- /A:3-/A 32A@-:3 @A1030HE>. -F 32A &-@030>E@ /A10HA' L2E3 HI>2 :AAH: 09C0:&I3E5@A'7-DABA/! D2E3 0: -F3A9 -BA/@--MAC 0: 32E3 2A E@:- E&&AE@AC 3- 32A :30@@:3/-91 /A:0CIE@ &/-KJI1-:@EB :A930HA93: -F <A/5: E9C n-93A9A1/09:' T9A:3/0M091 AGEH&@A 0: 20: FEH-I: ?&/0@ (+oh ̂ -:-B- S-@kA :&AA>2 09 D20>2 2AE&&AE@AC 3- 32A 2A/-0> &E:3 -F <A/5: E9C n-93A9A1/09:! ECH-90:2091 32AH3- :3E. 09 32A &/-B09>A a0'A'! 9-3 AH01/E3Ab' 7-DABA/! 09 ECC030-9 3- HEM091I:A -F 32A @E91IE1A -F 9E30-9E@0:H 09 E >-H&@A3A@. 9-BA@ FE:20-9 F-/ E>-HHI90:3! n0@-:AB0> A9CAC 32E3 :&AA>2 5. HEM091 >@AE/ 3- 32A ^-:-B-<A/5: 32E3 UE@@ -F JI1-:@EB0E 0: D032 .-I' =3 0: 9-3 E cIA:30-9 -F ̂ -:-B- 5A091E &/-5@AH -F JI1-:@EB0E! 5I3 32E3 JI1-:@EB0E 0: E@:- ^-:-B-' JI1-:@EB0EC-A: 9-3 AG0:3 D032-I3 ^-:-B-t JI1-:@EB0E C0:093A1/E3A: D032-I3 ^-:-B-tJI1-:@EB0E E9C <A/50E D0@@ 9-3 10BA I& ^-:-B-tX an0@-:AB0>! (+o+! &&' (%$*(%hb' L2A 3A/H UJI1-:@EB0EX 0: 2A/A! E: 09 n0@-:AB0>P: -32A/ :&AA>2A:! E>-CAD-/C F-/ $6% ($'$%' j9@0MA &E/30>I@E/0:3 <A/50E9 9E30-9E@0:3: @0MA 6IM_/E:M-B0>! n0@-:AB0> /AFI:AC 3- :.H5-@0>E@@. AH5/E>A 32A G6%$5#+ 2A/03E1A

aCA:&03A 20: &-@030>E@ E@@0E9>A: D032 <A:A@kP: NEC0>E@ &E/3.b! I9CA/:3E9C09132E3 2A 2EC 3- >-BA/ :0HI@3E9A-I:@. 3D- >-9:303IA9>0A:V 32A <A/50E9 9E30-9KE@0:3 -9A! -/ E3 @AE:3 32E3 &E/3 -F 03 32E3 DE: 9-3 :3EI9>2@. E930K>-HHI90:3RE9C 093/EK&E/3. E9C E/H. >-9:303IA9>0A: D2-:A &-@030>E@ 0CA9303. DE:/--3AC 09 32A SE/30:E9 AG&A/0A9>A E9C L03-0:3 JI1-:@EB0:H! 0CAE@: 32E3 DA/A:30@@ :2E/AC 5. E :0190F0>E93 :A1HA93 -F U32A HE::A:X E: DA@@'o =9 320: FE:20-9!n0@-:AB0> >-I@C E&&AE@ 3- BE/0-I: A@03A E9C HE:: >-9:303IA9>0A:! D20@A:0HI@3E9A-I:@. &-:091 E: E CAFA9CA/ -F JI1-:@EB0EP: :3E3A 093A1/03. E9CL03-0:3 :->0E@0:H! -9 32A -9A 2E9C! E9C -F <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ 093A/A:3:! -9

32A -32A/'82E3 E5-I3 NI::0Eq 7A/A! 03 >E9 5A &-093AC -I3 32E3 E :0190F0>E93

>I//A93 -F NI::0E9 &I5@0> -&090-9 >EHA 3- B0AD 32A <-B0A3 :3E3A 09 E FE:20-932E3 DE: E@H-:3 C0EHA3/0>E@@. -&&-:AC 3- <A/50E9 &A/>A&30-9: -F JI1-:@EKB0E' L2A 0CAE 32E3 32A :3E3A 0: E9 -&&/A::0BA F-/>A E@0A9 3- 32A U:&0/03 -F 32ANI::0E9 &A-&@AX 0:! -F >-I/:A! BA/. CAA&@. /--3AC 09 0H&A/0E@ NI::0E920:3-/.! 1-091 E@@ 32A DE. 5E>M 3- 32A :ABA93AA932K>A93I/. :>20:H E9C SA3A/32A [/AE3 a7-:M091! (++hb' =9 32A H0CK909A3AA932 >A93I/.! D2A9 A3290>

NI::0E9 9E30-9E@0:H HECA 03: E&&AE/E9>A! 320: 0HE1A -F 32A EI3->/E30>SA3/09A :3E3A DE: >/.:3E@@0]AC 09 <@EB-&20@A 0CA-@-1.! 9-3E5@. 09 ^-9:3E9309?M:EM-BP: FEH-I: HAH-/E9CIH 3- ?@AGE9CA/ == a(oggb 09 D20>2 2A C/ADE :2E/& >-93/E:3 5A3DAA9 U32A :3E3AX E9C U32A @E9C'X ?>>-/C091 3- ?M:EM-B!03 DE: SA3A/ 32A [/AE3 D2- U3-/A E:I9CA/X 32A UE9>0A93 I90-9 -F 32A @E9CE9C 32A :3E3AX E9C /A&@E>AC 03 U5. E 4*-#5'$#*5 -F 32A :3E3A -BA/ 32A @E9C!

o 82E3 n0@-:AB0> E>3IE@@. C0C E9C 2-D 2A 5A3/E.AC 32-:A L03-0:3 0CAE@: E/A :A>-9CE/.R 2A/ADA E/A C0:>I::091 20: /2A3-/0> E9C E&&AE@:'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33EHA! E: 03 DA/A! >-9cIA/AC 3A//03-/. E9C 32A:3E3A 03: >-9cIA/-/' L2E3 0: 2-D 32A NI::0E9 H-9E/>2 DE: 3/E9:F-/HAC 093-E CA:&-3! E9C 20: D0@@091 :I5kA>3: 093- :@EBA: 2A@C >E&30BA 09 32A0/ -D9

>-I93/.X a?M:EM-B! (+))! &' #Z#b' ?M:EM-B E9C 7A/]A9! E: 0: DA@@ M9-D9!&E::AC -9 320: &A/>A&30-9 -F 32A :3E3A 3- 32A NI::0E9 &-&I@0:H! D2-:A093A@@A>3IE@ >E//0A/: AG20503AC E9 E@H-:3 &E32-@-10>E@ 2E3/AC F-/ 32A EI3->K/E>.' L- 5A :I/A! 09 32A :A>-9C 2E@F -F 32A 909A3AA932 >A93I/.! NI::0ED039A::AC 32A AHA/1A9>A -F &-@030>E@ F-/>A: 32E3 DA/A D0@@091 3- /A>-9>0@AD032 32A :3E3A! 9-3E5@. @05A/E@0:H aE: AGAH&@0F0AC 5. 32A <%-($)* H-BAHA93!\-/0: ,20>2A/09! 32A :3E3A :>2--@ -F NI::0E9 20:3-/0-1/E&2.! SA3A/ <3/IBA!A3>'b' L2A EI3->/E>.P: &A/:0:3A93 /AFI:E@ 3- &@E>A 03:A@F -9 32A F-I9CE30-9 -F 9E30-9E@ >I@3I/A! 2-DABA/! HAE93 32E3 32A 1I@F 32E3 :A&E/E3AC 32A :3E3A F/-HACI>E3AC :->0A3. a*?(6,6%($)*b E9C 32A @E33A/ F/-H U32A &A-&@AX a5'/*4b DE:9ABA/ -BA/>-HA aN-11A/! (+)#b' \. 32A AE/@. 3DA930A32 >A93I/.! E: ̂ A/A9:M.-5:A/BAC a:AA 093/-CI>3-/. cI-3Ab! 320: E@0A9E30-9 -F 32A &A-&@A H5'/*4b E9CACI>E3AC :->0A3. F/-H 32A :3E3A 2EC 3I/9AC 093- -I3/0123 2-:30@03.' ?: 32A1/AE3 NI::0E9 20:3-/0E9 SEI@ n0@0IM-B &I3 03 3- E9 ?HA/0>E9 EIC0A9>A 0932A EF3A/HE32 -F 32A NI::-KdE&E9A:A DE/ a(+$%*(+$gbV

L2A :.H&E320A: -F E F-/A019 &I5@0> HE.! 09CAAC! 2EBA 5AA9 >20@@AC

5. D2E3 DE: >-9:0CA/AC E >-9:&0>I-I: @E>M -F &E3/0-30:H 09 H.>-I93/.HA9R F-/ AGEH&@A! 5. E >A/3E09! :AAH091@. I33A/@. I9&E3/0K-30>! @A33A/ -F L-@:3-.P: -9 32A DE/' \I3! 09 kI:30>A 3- I:! 03 HI:3 5A 5-/9A 09 H09C 32E3 -F 9A>A::03. -I/ @-BA -F >-I93/. :-HA30HA:E::IHA: I9AG&A>3AC F-/H:! E9C 32E3 03: E&&E/A93 E5:A9>A 09 /AE@03./A&/A:A93: D032 I: 32A BA/. 2012A:3 AG&/A::0-9 -F 3/I@. &E3/0-30>FAA@091' 8A HE. 5A 32-I123 E cIAA/ :-/3 -F &A-&@A! 5I3 DA >@AEBA3- -I/ -D9 0CAE: -F &E3/0-30:HR E9C DA 2EBA 9- 2A:03E9>. 09CA>0C091 D20>2 -F 32A 3D- 0: 32A 3/E03-/ E9C D20>2 32A &E3/0-3!

S@A2BA -/ L-@:3-.! 0F DA E/A -5@01AC 3- >2--:A 5A3DAA9 32AH' 8AC- 9-3 >E@@ 03 &E3/0-30:H 3- &E/E@.]A 32A @0B091 F-/>A: -F 32A 9E30-9 5. E &-@0>A /A10HA ` an0@0IM-B! (+)#! &' (hb'

L2A NI::0E9 /AB-@I30-9 2A@C 32A &/-H0:A -F A9C091 320: :3E3A -F EFFE0/:F-/ 1--C 5. A@0H09E3091 32A EI3->/E>. E9C 32A 8A:3A/90]AC @E9C@-/C! E9C>/AE3091 E <-B0A3 NI::0E -F E9C F-/ 32A 5'/*4! E NI::0E -F UD-/MA/: E9C&AE:E93:!X E: 32A YWS F-/HI@E 2EC 03' L2A 2-&A 32E3 ABA9 E <-B0A3 NI::0E>-I@C 5A>-HA E NI::0E9 9E30-9E@ :3E3A DE: 5. 9- HAE9: @0H03AC 3- 32A

F/091A: -F YE30-9E@ \-@:2AB0:H! 5I3 E90HE3AC E :0190F0>E93 &E/3 -F 32ANI::0E9 093A@@01A93:0E DA@@ 093- 32A (+#$:' <3E@09P: F-/>05@A >-@@A>30B0]E30-9C/0BA E1E09:3 32A &AE:E93/. E: 32A HE09 :.H5-@ -F 32A NI::0E9 5'/*4!2-DABA/! :2E33A/AC 32A:A 2-&A:' =9 32A D-/C: -F N-5A/3 LI>MA/! U32A -I3K:3E9C091 :091@A HE90FA:3E30-9 -F 320: 3-3E@03E/0E90]091 &/->A:: DE: 32A3A//-/0:30> >-@@A>30B0]E30-9 -F 32A &AE:E93/. E9C 32A /A0H&-:030-9 -F :A/FC-HD03209 32A F/EHAD-/M -F 32A +*"+6*<' 7A/A 32A :3E3A E>3AC cI03A @03A/E@@. 0932A /-@A -F 32A >-9cIA/-/ -F /I/E@ NI::0E'X ?9C! E>>-/C091 3- LI>MA/! 32AHE09 >-9:AcIA9>A -F 320: &/->A:: DE: 32A /AB0BE@ -F 32A -@C U0HE1A -F CIE@



!RR ADNOPE AJOI@<@

NI::0EXi0'A'! 32A >-93/E:3 5A3DAA9 32A E@@KH0123. :3E3A E9C 32A 099->A93NI::0E -F 32A B0>30H0]AC &A-&@A -9 32A @ABA@ -F :->0E@ &A/>A&30-9 aLI>MA/!(+h(! &&' (#(*(%#b'

L2A BE@0C03. -F 320: B0AD 2E: 5AA9 5-/9A -I3 5. :I5:AcIA93 20:3-/0>E@/A:AE/>2' ?H-91 32A &AE:E93/.! 32A -9:A3 -F >-@@A>30B0]E30-9 cI0>M@. @AC 3-E9 -@CK:3.@A 9E30B0:3 /AE>30-9 32E3 0CA930F0AC 32A UE@0A9 :3E3AX E: 32A HE09B0>30H0]A/ -F 32A &A-&@A' T9>A H-/A 32A :3E3A DE: :AA9 E: 32A E930K,2/0:3! EB0AD A:&A>0E@@. D0CA:&/AEC EH-91 32A /AHE09091 T@C \A@0ABA/:! HE9. -F D2-H /AFI:AC 3- /A>-190]A 32A <-B0A3 :3E3A -/ ABA9 >E//. -FF0>0E@ C->IHA93:a60-@E! (++)! &' ($! g#b' L2A :0H0@E/03. 5A3DAA9 32A -5@01E3-/. H090HIH -F @E5-/ CE.: D20>2 32A >-@@A>30BA FE/H D-/MA/: :&A93 3-0@091 F-/ 32A <-B0A3:3E3A E9C 32A -@C @E5-/ -5@01E30-9: -F 3:E/0:3 30HA: a?'/(6,6#5'b >AHA93AC 32AE::->0E30-9 5A3DAA9 3:E/0:3 E9C :->0E@0:3 :A/FC-H aLI>MA/! (++#! &&' (+g*#$$b' L20: 9AD :A/FC-H DE: :AA9 E: E@@ 32A H-/A -9A/-I: 09 B0AD -F 32AU1/AE3 /A&E/3030-9X 32E3 2EC :&-93E9A-I:@. ->>I//AC EF3A/ (+(h E9C 32A/A@E30BA F/AAC-H A9k-.AC 5. 32A &AE:E93/. I9CA/ YWS' Y-3 D032-I3 kI:30KF0>E30-9! 03 DE: :AA9 E@:- E: U32A I@30HE3A ,-HHI90:3 5A3/E.E@ -F /AB-@IK30-9E/. 0CAE@:!X 9EHA@. -F 32A \-@:2AB0M:P :@-1E9 U@E9C 3- 32A &AE:E93:Xa60-@E! (++)! &' ($b' \. 32A H0CK(+Z$:! 320: 0HE1A -F UCIE@ NI::0EX DE: 9-@-91A/ @0H03AC 3- 32A &AE:E93/.! 5I3 5A>EHA 1A9A/E@0]AC 09 &-&I@E/ C0:K

>-I/:A' =9 320: C0>2-3-H-I: B0:0-9 -F E :->0A3. C0B0CAC 093- UI: E9C 32AH!X1( :3--C F-/ UO32A D-/MA/:!P O32A &A-&@A!P O32A 5#<;P e32-:A -9 5-33-Hf! O32A&AE:E93:!P O32A NI::0E9:!P 32A OHE::A:!PX E9C $6%- F-/ UO32A )%/+6#P e32-:A -93-&f! O/A:&-9:05@A D-/MA/:!P O&E/3. HAH5A/:!P O32A :3E3A!P O32A /I@A/:!P O32A9AD 5-I/1A-0:0A!P O32A 9AD >E&03E@0:3:!P OA9109AA/: E9C 3A>290>E@ D-/MA/:Pa=LNb! OdAD:!P E9C! @A:: >-HH-9@.! O/-33A9 093A@@01A93:0E!P OE>ECAH0>:!P E9C$('/C+# e@033@A 3:E/:fX a_EB0A:! #$$$! &&' %o*%+b' =9F-/HE@@.! HE9. EH-91 32A5'/*4 HECA 9- H-/E@ C0:309>30-9 5A3DAA9 32A 3:E/0:3 E9C <-B0A3 :3E3A:!:AA091 32A /I@A/: -F 5-32 E: AcIE@@. C0:091A9I-I: E9C CA>A&30BA a_EB0A:!

#$$$! &' +b'L2A >/030>E@ &A/0-C 09 <-B0A3 20:3-/. D2A9 320: 0HE1A >EHA 3- F/I030-9!2-DABA/! DE: ^2/I:2>2ABP: L2ED' 7A/A 32A AB0CA9>A 0: 3/I@. -BA/D2A@HK091! A:&A>0E@@. 09 NI::0E9 @03A/E3I/A' L2A 32/AA :091@A H-:3 09F@IA930E@ D-/M:CA3E0@091 320: &A/>A&30-9! SE:3A/9EMP: I*,$*/ J6#)'8*! <-@]2A903:.9P: K1"'8 L/,6#.%"'8*! E9C [/-::HE9P: M#7% '54 N'$%! DA/A A032A/ >-H&@A3AC -/ 5A1I9CI/091 32A L2ED' ?@@ 32/AA DA/A &I5@0:2AC 09 NI::0E -9@. CI/091 .%/%0($/*;+'! 5I3 D20@A I*,$*/ J6#)'8* E9C O6% K1"'8 DA/A D0CA@. /AEC 09093A@@01A93:0E >0/>@A:! 32A &I5@0>E30-9 -F [/-::HE9P: M#7% '54 N'$% 09 (+oo

>EI:AC E :A9:E30-9' L20: DE: 9-3 -9@. 5A>EI:A -F [/-::HE9P: /AF@A>30-9: -9NI::0E9 E930K<AH030:H -/ 20: 3/I@. :2E33A/091 AG&-:I/A -F <-B0A3 0CA-@-10>[email protected]:! -/! F09E@@.! 20: CA:>/0&30-9 -F 32A FEH09A 09 jM/E09A! 32A H-:3CABE:3E3091 CA&0>30-9 -F 32A 3/E1AC. -F >-@@A>30B0]E30-9 09 NI::0E9 @03A/E3I/Aa09 P)%/;$6#58 N"*>(b' WBA9 H-/A 0H&-/3E93 DE: [/-::HE9P: CAH-@030-9 -F 32A H.32 -F 32A [/AE3 SE3/0-30> 8E/! &A/2E&: 32A :-@A 20:3-/0> E>20ABAHA9332E3 E U<-B0A3KNI::0E9 >030]A9X DE: kI:30F0E5@. &/-IC -F' L2A HE09 &-093 0:32E3 32A :3/I11@A E1E09:3 32A [A/HE9: 0: E :A>-9CE/. 32AHA 09 M#7% '54 N'$%!D20@A 03: HE09 @A03H-30F 0: 32A :3/I11@A -F -/C09E/. NI::0E9: E: #54#)#41'"(



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J332 >@E0H: $6%#/ B0>3-/. F-/ 03:A@F'=9 320: U/AH-/:A@A:: >I99091 -F 20:3-/.X [/-::HE9 :AA: 32A 3/IA HAE9091-F <3E@091/ECV UQ/AAC-H A91A9CA/AC 32A NI::0E9 B0>3-/.' Q/AAC-H DE: 32A

E&&E/A93 E0H -F 32A DE/' \I3 32A :@. F091A/: -F 70:3-/. >2E91AC 320:VF/AAC-H 5A>EHA :0H&@. E DE. F-/ DE1091 32A DE/! E HAE9: 3- E9 A9CXa[/-::HE9! (+og! &' %ooR [E//E/C! (++(b'

L2A >2E/E>3A/ 09 32A 9-BA@ D2- C0:>-BA/: 320: 0/-90> 3/I32 F-/ 20H:A@F 0: 32A &2.:0>0:3 60M3-/ <23/IH! D2-:A /AHE/ME5@A :>0A930F0> C0:>-BA/. @AEC:3- 20: &/-H-30-9 E9C /A3I/9 3- E n-:>-D :>0A930F0> 09:303I3A' ?: -FF0>0E@ E930K<AH030:H 5A>-HA: 32A -/CA/ -F 32A CE.! <23/IHP: dAD0:2 @E5-/E3-/. E::-K>0E3A: E/A &/ABA93AC F/-H k-09091 20H 09 n-:>-D! D20@A 2A 20H:A@F 0: FE>AC

D032 32A -&&-:030-9 -F &-DA/FI@ 0CA-@-10>E@ 2E>M: 09 32A :>0A930F0> A:3E5K@0:2HA93 E9C 32A 09>/AE:091 09F-/HE@ 5-.>-33 -F 20: >-@@AE1IA:! D2- DE9320H 3- /A9-I9>A :>0A930F0> 32A-/0A: 32E3 B0-@E3A 32A U&E/3. :&0/03 09 :>0A9>A'X<23/IH 0: 3A//0F0AC -F 32A -H90&-3A93 :3E3A! E9C 03: 0HE1A 2EI93: 20H @0MAE9 AB0@ 12-:3V U60M3-/ FA@3 E :20BA/ -F FAE/! 32A FAE/ 32E3 DE: E@DE.: @I/M09109 20: 2AE/3iFAE/ -F 32A <3E3AP: E91A/! FAE/ -F 5A091 E B0>30H -F 320: E91A/32E3 >-I@C >/I:2 E HE9 E9C 1/09C 20H 3- CI:3X a[/-::HE9! (+og! &' go+b'<23/IH 0: 09 EDA -F 32A &-DA/ -F E :3E3A 32E3 U/E0:A: E HE9 I&! 32A9 32/-D:20H AFF-/3@A::@. 093- 32A E5.::X a[/-::HE9! (+og! &' gogb' ?3 E :30@@ @E3A/

&-093 09 32A 9-BA@! U2A >-I@C FAA@ 3E9105@. 32A C0FFA/A9>A 09 DA0123 5A3DAA932A F/E10@A 2IHE9 5-C. E9C 32A >-@-::I: -F 32A <3E3A' 7A >-I@C FAA@ 32A<3E3AP: 5/0123 A.A: 1E]091 093- 20: FE>AR E9. H-HA93 9-D 32A <3E3A D-I@C>/E:2 C-D9 -9 20HR 32A/A D-I@C 5A E >/E>M! E :cIAE@iE9C 2A D-I@C 5A1-9AX a[/-::HE9! (+og! &' ))ob' ?@32-I12 9-3 5A.-9C -&&-/3I90:H! 9-/!-5B0-I:@.! >-9>A/9 D032 20: -D9 :I/B0BE@ -/ 32A FE3A -F 20: FEH0@.! <23/IH/AFI:A: 3- /A&A93' WBA9 E3 320: H-HA93! 2-DABA/! 20: &/0HE/. H-30BE30-90: 9-3 :I&A/2IHE9 >-I/E1A 5I3 32A /AE@0]E30-9 -F 20: -D9 0H&-3A9>AV U7ADE: -F 9- I:A 3- E9.-9A' 82A32A/ 2A /A&A93AC -/ 9-3! 2A DE: -F AcIE@@.@033@A :0190F0>E9>A 3- 32A FI/0-I: <3E3AX a[/-::HE9! (+og! &' h)(b' =/-90>E@@.!60M3-/ 0: :EBAC F/-H 320: 3A//05@A FE3A 5. E &2-9A >E@@ F/-H <3E@09! D2-/AE@0]A: 32E3 20: :>0A930F0> M9-D@AC1A 0: 09C0:&A9:E5@A 3- 32A :3E3A' 60M3-/P:E>>A&3E9>A -F 20: -D9 /A2E50@03E30-9! 2-DABA/! >-HA: E3 32A &/0>A -F 32A @-::-F H-/E@ EI3-9-H.! HEM091 20: B0>3-/. E @E/1A@. 0@@I:-/. -9A aW@@0:! (++%!&&' (oo*(o+b'

[/-::HE9P: M#7% '54 N'$%! 32A/AF-/A! @03A/E@@. 5/-I123 32A &-093 -I3V 32A<-B0A3 :3E3A DE: 9-3 -9@. E 3-3E@03E/0E9 :3E3A! 5I3 E@:- E :3E3A 32E3 2EC

5A3/E.AC 32A NI::0E9 &A-&@A 5. A91E1091 09 &:AIC-K9E30-9E@0:3 E&&AE@:aE930K<AH030:HR [/AE3 NI::0ER <3E@09 32A QE32A/ E9C 09FE@@05@A @AECA/! A3>'b!E9C :3AE@091 32A B0>3-/. F/-H 09C0B0CIE@: D2- 2EC F-I123 F-/ F/AAC-H 5I31-3 C0>3E3-/:20& 09:3AEC' =3 D-I@C 9-3 5A 3-- C0FF0>I@3 3- CAH-9:3/E3A 32E3320: B0AD -F 32A DE/ 0: 9-3 @0H03AC 3- 32A U8A:3A/90]A/X [/-::HE9! 5I3 E@:->2E/E>3A/0]A: EI32A930> 9A-K<@EB-&20@A: @0MA <-@]2A903:.9! 5I3 320: D0@@ 9-3 5A E33AH&3AC 2A/A a:AA! 2-DABA/! <-@]2A903:.9! (+hZ! &&' #Zh*#hhb' ,E9 03 5A :2-D9 32E3 320: 0HE1A -F 32A <-B0A3 :3E3A DE: 09CAAC :2E/AC 5. E:0190F0>E93 >I//A93 -F NI::0E9 &I5@0> -&090-9 -/ 32A 093A@@01A93:0E 09 32A



!U% ADNOPE AJOI@<@

(+o$:q L20: 0:! -F >-I/:A! 32A >/IG -F 32A HE33A/! E9C = >E99-3 ABA9 5A109 3-&/-B0CA AB0CA9>A 2A/A'

YABA/32A@A::! 03 >E9 5A 5/0AF@. :2-D9 32E3 32A H-30F -F 32A -&&/A::0BA:3E3A &/-H09A93@. F01I/A: 09 32A :&AA>2A: E9C /AF@A>30-9: -F 9-9A -32A/ 32E9\-/0: JA@P3:09iE: 03 DA/A! 32A &A/:-9E@ AH5-C0HA93 -F NI::0EP: E:&0/E30-9:3- 09CA&A9CA9>A F/-H 32A <-B0A3 >A93A/' L2I:! -9 32A 2012@. :.H5-@0>->>E:0-9 -F 20: 09EI1I/E30-9 E: 32A F0/:3 F/AA@. A@A>3AC S/A:0CA93 -F NI::0EadI9A (++(b! JA@P3:09 FA@3 >-H&A@@AC 3- :E.V

8-/C: >E99-3 >-9BA. 32A FAA@091: = EH AG&A/0A9>091 E3 320: H09I3A'Q-/ 32A F0/:3 30HA 09 32A 32-I:E9CK.AE/ 20:3-/. -F NI::0E! E S/A:0CA93

0: 5A091 :-@AH9@. :D-/9 5AF-/A 20: FA@@-D >030]A9:' `N*/ ,%5$1/#%( #5 *1/ ,*15$/; .*>%/ '54 .%*."% 6')% ?%%5 '$ *..*(#$% .*"%(: Q N*/ ,%5$1/#%( $6% #5$%/%($( *7 $6% ($'$% 6')%= '( ' /1"%= ?%%5 .1$'?*)% $6*(% *7 $6% #54#)#41'"= 6#( 5%%4( '54 '(.#/'$#*5(: 8A 2EBA!/A1/A33E5@.! >-HA @E3A/ 32E9 -32A/ >0B0@0]AC &A-&@A: 3- 32A /AE@0]EK30-9 32E3 32A :3E3AP: :3/A9132 @0A: 09 32A DA@@K5A091 -F 03: >030]A9:'YA1E30-9 -F 320: :E>/AC &/09>0&@A @E0C 3- /I09 32A 1/AE3A:3 AH&0/A:-F 32A &E:3' ̀ 8A 2EBA 2EC 3- &E. E >-@-::E@! I9&/A>ACA93AC &/0>AF-/ -I/ AG&A/0A9>A' `

N*/ $6% 7#/($ $#-% ' 5%> )*"15$'/; #5$%/4%.%54%5,% #( ?*/5 ?%$>%%5$6% '1$6*/#$#%( '54 $6% .%*."%: <3E3A EI32-/03. 5A>-HA: E9:DA/E5@A 3-32A &A-&@A D2- A@A>3AC 03! E9C 32A &A-&@A 5A>-HA E9:DA/E5@A 3-32A :3E3A! D20>2 32A. 2EBA &@E>AC E5-BA 32AH:A@BA:' `

? D-/32. @0FA C-A: 9-3 >-HA E: E 10F3 F/-H E5-BA' ` T9A C-A:9-3 E33E09 03 5. :3E9C091 09 @09A E9C 5@09C@. -5A.091 -/CA/: F/-HE5-BA' ` L2A /AB0BE@ -F -I/ :3E3A 0: 3- 5A F-I9CAC -9 32A :&0/03IE@AHE9>0&E30-9 -F HE9! 3/IA F/AAC-H -F >-9:>0A9>A E9C 3-3E@ /AkA>K

30-9 -F 0CA-@-10>E@ C0M3E3' ` =H&A/0E@ EH5030-9: E/A CAA&@. E@0A93- 32A >-I/:A D20>2 32A &A-&@A 2EBA >2-:A9 aJA@P3:09 09 ?/-9! #$$$!&&' %Z%*%ZgR AH&2E:0: H09Ab'

=3 0: 3/IA 32E3 JA@P3:09P: &-@030>E@ H-30BE30-9: >E99-3 5A /ACI>AC 3- 320::.H5-@0> A@AHA93 E9C 32E3 20: >-9F@0>3 D032 [-/5E>2AB DE: /--3AC 09 5-32C0FFA/A93 093A/A:3: E9C 09 32A0/ C0FFA/A93 @AECA/:20& :3.@A: a\/A:@EIA/! #$$#b'l0MAD0:A! 03 0: 3/IA 32E3 JA@P3:09 DE: /A@I>3E93 3- C0:HE93@A 32A <-B0A3 :3E3AI930@ 32A BA/. A9C a8E@MA/! #$$Z! &&' (Zh*(h+b' 7-DABA/! 03 0: 3A@@091 32E3 09

20: -D9 HAH-0/: 32A C0:>I::0-9 -F 32A FE0@AC ?I1I:3 >-I& 0: F-@@-DAC 5.32A :3-/. -F 20: FE32A/ P: F-/>05@A UCAMI@EM0]E30-9X aJA@3:09! (++%! &&' +%*+ob!D20@A 32A CA>0:0-9 3- C0:HE93@A 32A <-B0A3 j90-9 09 _A>AH5A/ (++( 0:E>>-H&E90AC 5. 32A :3E3AHA93 32E3 U09 :019091 320: E1/AAHA93! NI::0E DE:>2--:091 E C0FFA/A93 &E32! E &E32 -F 093A/9E@ CABA@-&HA93 /E32A/ 32E9 E90H&A/0E@ -9AX aJA@3:09! (++%! &' ((Zb' JA@P3:09P: 2-&A! 32A/AF-/A! DE: 32E3 32AA9C -F AH&0/A D-I@C 5A>-HA 32A 5A1099091 -F 32A A:3E5@0:2HA93 -F 32ANI::0E9 9E30-9K:3E3A! -9A 5E:AC -9 U32A B-@I93E/. 093A/CA&A9CA9>AX -F 32A&A-&@A E9C 32A :3E3A'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33I::0-9 2E: 0@@I:3/E3AC a9-3 CAH-9:3/E3ACb E MA.

&-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ C0FFA/A9>A 5A3DAA9 NI::0E9 E9C <A/50E9 &A/>A&30-9: -F 32A JI1-:@EB E9C NI::0E9 a<-B0A3b :3E3A:! E C0FFA/A9>A 32E3! E: = 3/0AC 3- :2-D!2E: CAA& 20:3-/0>E@ /--3:' ?@32-I12 E9 093A1/E@ &E/3 -F 32A &-@030>E@ >I@3I/A:-F 32A 3D- 9E30-9: DA@@ 5AF-/A 32A >-HHI90:3 &A/0-C! 32A:A &A/>A&30-9:DA/A /A09F-/>AC 5. 32A C0FFA/A93 20:3-/0>E@ AG&A/0A9>A: -F NI::0E9: E9C<A/5: I9CA/ >-HHI90:H' n-:3 0H&-/3E93@.! 32A 3/EIHE30> @A1E>. -F <3E@09K0:H 09 32A <-B0A3 >E:A /AB0BAC! E: N-5A/3 LI>MA/ A@-cIA93@. E/1IAC! 32AU0HE1A -F CIE@ NI::0E'X <A/5:! 5. >-93/E:3! /AK0CA930F0AC D032 32A /A9ADACJI1-:@EB :3E3A 09 E HE90FA:3@. &-:030BA FE:20-9! E9C 03 DE: -9@. 32A 5033A/

C0:E&&-093HA93 D032 32A FE0@I/A -F JI1-:@EB0:H 32E3 &I:2AC HE9. -F 32AH09 32A C0/A>30-9 -F A3290> 9E30-9E@0:H' L- 5A :I/A! 32A I:A -F >-@@A>30BA 9-I9::I>2 E: UNI::0E9:X E9C U<A/5:X -5:>I/A: E HI>2 H-/A >-H&@AG /AE@03. -F 093A/9E@ C0B0:0-9:i&-@030>E@! 0CA-@-10>E@! :->0E@! E9C ABA9 U9E30-9E@'X \I332A &/A:A9>A -F /A>I//A93 H-30F: 32E3 E/A 09B-MAC 5. 093A@@A>3IE@: E9C@AECA/: E3 >/030>E@ H-HA93: 09 E 9E30-9P: 20:3-/. E@:- /AF@A>3: E >A/3E09 CA1/AA-F >-9:A9:I: E5-I3 32A CAF09091 20:3-/0>E@ AG&A/0A9>A: -F 32A 9E30-9' L- 320:03 :2-I@C 5A ECCAC 32E3 C0FFA/A93 >-@@A>30BA HAH-/0A: -F B0>30H0]E30-9 E/AE9 0H&-/3E93 E9C /A@E3AC &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ A@AHA93 09 320: &0>3I/A 32E3>-I@C 9-3 5A FI@@. AG&@-/AC 2A/A' SA/2E&: 3D- :3/0M091@. C0FFA/A93 0HE1A:E/A 32A 5A:3 DE. 3- >-9BA. 03 09 E >-9>@I:0-9V D20@A <A/5: DA/A >E//.091 32A 5-9A: -F L:E/ lE]E/ -F 32A ̂ -:-B- 5E33@A E9C -&A9091 32A &03: 09 D20>2 32A0//A@E30BA: 2EC 5AA9 32/-D9 5. 32A ,/-E3 R($'(6% E9C 32A0/ \-:90E9 n-:@AHF-@@-DA/: 09 8-/@C 8E/ LD-! NI::0E9: DA/A :3E/091 E3 32A 9AD@. -&A9ACHE:: 1/EBA: -F <3E@09P: B0>30H: E9C 3/.091 3- >-HHAH-/E3A E9C /A2E50@03E3A32AH' L- 5@EHA 32A CAE32 -F E@@ 32A:A H0@@0-9: -9 U32A dAD:!X E: AG3/AHANI::0E9 9E30-9E@0:3: E33AH&3AC 3- C-! kI:3 C0C 9-3 :AAH >-9B09>091 3-

H-:3 NI::0E9:'=9 >-9>@IC091! @A3 HA /A03A/E3A 32E3 32A FI9CEHA93E@@. C0FFA/A93 E3303ICA3-DE/C 32A :3E3A E9C >-//A:&-9C091 :A9:A: -F B0>30H0]E30-9 09 NI::0E E9C<A/50E >-9:303I3AC kI:3 -9A EH-91 E D2-@A :A3 -F 0CA-@-10>E@! 09:303I30-9E@!E9C >-93AG3IE@ FE>3-/: 32E3 09F@IA9>AC &-@030>E@ -I3>-HA: 09 32A @E3A ,-HKHI90:3 &A/0-C' 7-DABA/! 03 0: &/A>0:A@. 320: &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ A@AHA93 32E3/A9CA/: 32A E&&AE@: E9C E>30-9: -F @AECA/:! 093A@@A>3IE@ A@03A:! E9C 32A0/F-@@-DA/: 09 NI::0E E9C <A/50E 154%/($'54'?"% *5 $6% "%)%" *7 -%'5#58 a)%/($%06%5b! F-/H091 E 9A>A::E/. 5E>M1/-I9C E1E09:3 D20>2 -32A/ >EI:E@ FE>3-/:

&@E.AC 32AH:A@BA: -I3' =9 32A E5:A9>A -F E9 093A/&/A30BA AFF-/3 32E3 :AAM: 3->-H&/A2A9C 32A /--3: -F 32A:A C0FFA/A93 &-@030>E@K>I@3I/E@ &A/>A&30-9:! E9.>EI:E@ AG&@E9E30-9 -F &-@030>E@ -I3>-HA: 09 NI::0E E9C <A/50E D0@@ 5A F-/>ACA032A/ 3- /AHE09 -9 32A @ABA@ -F HE>/-K:3/I>3I/E@ -/ 09:303I30-9E@ E9E@.:0: 09C0:/A1E/C -F 32A H-30BA: -F E>3-/: -/ 3- :0H&@0F. 32A H-30BA: -F @AECA/: E9CF-@@-DA/: 09 E HE99A/ 32E3 -5:>I/A: -/ E@3-1A32A/ 019-/A: 32A >I@3I/E@HAE9091 -F 32A0/ E>30-9:' L2A /A:I@3! 09 5-32 09:3E9>A:! D0@@ 5A :[email protected]@A1E93 5I3! E3 32A0/ /--3! 093A/&/A30BA@. 09ECAcIE3A E9C -BA/@. :0H&@0F0AC>EI:E@ AG&@E9E30-9: -F &-@030>E@ -I3>-HA:'



!U$ ADNOPE AJOI@<@

5DGD5DF@D3

I8(4W/X F',;X UYE30-9E@0:3 n-50@0]E30-9 E9C =H&A/0E@ ,-@@E&:AV <A/50E9 E9C NI::0E9

YE30-9E@0:H ,-H&E/AC! (+oh*(++(!X L? A-.%/#*! $V%o+*gZ(! #$$#'IC/4C-=X P-./+4.+,. 3'(?''=,)2X UT9 32A 093A/9E@ :3E3A -F NI::0E!X 09 nE/> NEAFF! AC'!

21((#'5 A5$%""%,$1'" S#($*/;' YAD J-/M! YJV 7E/>-I/3 \/E>A! (+))'

I(-.X N'-.X E%"$(#5T L 2%)*"1$#*5'/; M#7%: YAD J-/M! YJV <3' nE/309P:! #$$$'

L',//,.?'(X T4()X U'$#*5'"#($ V*?#"#<'$#*5 '54 $6% G*""'.(% *7 $6% &*)#%$ R5#*5' ,EH5/0C1A!j^V ,EH5/0C1A j90BA/:03. S/A::! #$$#'

L('/;46'(X Y'-(?' Z[X K*/?',6%) '54 E%"$(#5 '( M%'4%/(' ,EH5/0C1A! j^V ,EH5/0C1Aj90BA/:03. S/A::! #$$#'

L(67.\X >,+]24CX 2%#5)%5$#58 21((#'T 21((#'5 U'$#*5'"#(- '54 $6% &*)#%$ &$'$%= WXYZ[WXXW'

,EH5/0C1A! n?V 7E/BE/C j90BA/:03. S/A::! (++o'L6.)'X A4;'(,'X &1?)%/(#)% A5($#$1$#*5(T O6% I%(#85 '54 I%($/1,$#*5 *7 &*,#'"#(- '54 $6%&$'$%' ,EH5/0C1A! j^V ,EH5/0C1A j90BA/:03. S/A::! (+++'

L6(C/X 5[ A[X O6% I;5'-#,( *7 G*--15#(- #5 P'($%/5 P1/*.%' S/09>A3-9! YdV S/09>A3-9j90BA/:03. S/A::! (+)('

@-2'.X N'.4(7 O[X \/*+%5 \*54(T O6% I#(#5$%8/'$#*5 *7 E18*("')#'' \-I@CA/! ,TV 8A:3B0ADS/A::! (++Z'

@-(-=,)X A;47,W,(X US03E9kA C/]EB9-1 &/AI/ACkA9kE aL2A cIA:30-9 -F :3E3A /A-/1E90]EK30-9b!X 09 n0-C/E1 d-B0>0>! AC'! ]'+* (/.($)*0^'+' ]18*("')#^': A<?*/ ,"'5'+' #< _&/.(+*8

8"'('` */8'5' &/.(+*8 +1"$1/5*8 +"1?'= WXZX[WXab: \A@1/ECAV YEI>9E M9k01E! (++('K4=,'/X 34(42X UOj: ?1E09:3 L2AHPV <->0E@ =CA9303. 09 <-B0A3 NI::0E! (+Z%*(+%(!X 09<2A0@E Q03]&E3/0>M! AC'! &$'"#5#(-T U%> I#/%,$#*5(' l-9C-9! j^ E9C YAD J-/M! YJVN-I3@AC1A! #$$$'

K'7,B'( / A;47,W,(X O6% F'/ I#'/#%( *7 c"'4#-#/ I%4#^%/' ?99 ?/5-/! n=V j90BA/:03. -F n0>201E9 S/A::! (++$'

K,W,)X NB68-7(4?X d1"$1/5' .*"#$#+' 1 d/'"^%)#5# ]18*("')#^# WXWe*WXaW a,I@3I/E@ &-@030>:09 32A ^091C-H -F JI1-:@EB0Eb! Z B-@IHA:' \A@1/ECAV <3I5-B0 MI@3I/A! (++)*(++h'

KB,;4/X T,;-=4.X F'/$#-%' YAD J-/M! YJV 7E/>-I/3 \/E>A! (+hh'

K(4?-=,)^3-/-X O4/.4X &')#*1/( *7 $6% U'$#*5fT &%/?#'C( A5$%""%,$1'" g..*(#$#*5 '54 $6%2%)#)'" *7 U'$#*5'"#(-' l-9C-9! j^V 7I/:3! #$$#'

K(4/C-=,)X 3;-8-74.X U_E9Er9k0 &-@-]Ek 0 ]ECE>0 </5E aL2A >I//A93 &-:030-9 E9C 3E:M:-F 32A <A/5:b!X 09 n0-C/E1 d-B0>0>! AC'! ]'+* (/.($)*0^'+' ]18*("')#^': A<?*/ ,"'5'+' #<_&/.(+*8 8"'('` */8'5' &/.(+*8 +1"$1/5*8 +"1?'= WXZX*WXab: \A@1/ECAV YEI>9E M9k01E!(++('

D;;,/X G(4.CX c'(#"#; K/*((-'5T O6% K%5%(#( '54 P)*"1$#*5 *7 ' 21((#'5 S%/%$#,' TGF-/C! jÊ9C S/-B0CA9>A! N=V \A/1! (++%'

DWW'(+X :2-W4/ I[X &%/?#'5 K*"8*$6'T d*(*)*! WZeX' YAD J-/M! YJV ,-@IH50E j90BA/K:03. S/A::! (++$'

Y4?.-.X A'(.-.X UW3290> YE30-9E@0:H E9C =93A/9E30-9E@ ,-9F@0>3V L2A ,E:A -F <A/50E!X09 n0>2EA@ W' \/-D9! TDA9 N' ,-3u! d/'! <AE9 n' l.99Kd-9A:! E9C <3ABA9 n0@@A/! AC:'!U'$#*5'"#(- '54 P$65#, G*57"#,$' ,EH5/0C1A! n? E9C l-9C-9! j^V n=L S/A::! (++h'

Y4((4(7X O-2.X U? ,-9F@0>3 -F 60:0-9:V 6E:0@00 [/-::HE9 E9C 32A NI::0E9 =CAE!X 09 WDEn' L2-H&:-9! AC'! O6% &%'/,6 7*/ &%"70I%7#5#$#*5 #5 21((#'5 M#$%/'$1/%' 7-I:3-9! LvVN0>A j90BA/:03. S/A::! (++('

Y(-//W4.X A4/,;\X M#7% '54 N'$%T L U*)%"' YAD J-/M! YJV 7E/&A/ ; N-D! (+og'

H4;*'(.X O-'; T[ 4.7 L4(84(4 P'('_/C\ H4;*'(.X L &%/?#'5 c#""'8% #5 S#($*/#,'" B%/(.%,0$#)%' YAD J-/M! YJV =/B0913-9 SI5@0:2A/:! (+o%'



&D5@D&:<EF3 EG :HD 3:I:D <F 5J33:!X&"')#, 2%)#%>! M!X %V)g%*)h%! 8093A/ (++#'

H';14.+ L677,.?X I67('\X U<A/5 =93A@@A>3IE@: E9C 32A YE30-9E@ wIA:30-9! (+)(*(++(!X

I9&I5@0:2AC C->3-/E@ C0::A/3E30-9! 7E/BE/C j90BA/:03.! (++o'H-/C,.?X Y'-11('\X UL2A NI::0E9 YE30-9E@ n.32 NA&IC0E3AC!X 09 [A-FF/A. 7-:M091

E9C [A-/1A <2x&F@09! AC:'! V;$6( '54 U'$#*56**4' l-9C-9! j^V N-I3@AC1A! (++h'<..'/X I88\X G<%,6*("*)'+#'T O6% &6*/$ K**4?;%' YAD 7EBA9! ,L E9C l-9C-9! j^V JE@A

j90BA/:03. S/A::! #$$#' O4.-/X I.7('_ @[X U,]A>2-:@-BEM0E E9C JI1-:@EB0EV W3290> ,-9F@0>3 E9C 32A _0::-@I30-9

-F nI@309E30-9E@ <3E3A:!X P@."*/'$*/; P((';( U1-?%/ Z! =93A/9E30-9E@ E9C ?/AE <3IC0A:!j90BA/:03. -F ,E@0F-/90E! \A/MA@A.! (++h'

O-2./-.X @24;W'(/X B%'('5$ U'$#*5'"#(- '54 G*--15#($ B*>%/T O6% P-%/8%5,% *7 2%)*"10

$#*5'/; G6#5'= WXZh*WXaY' <3E9F-/C! ,?V <3E9F-/C j90BA/:03. S/A::! (+)#' O-=4.-=,)X 3;-8-74.X UdACE9 &/0@-1 ]E &/-I>EBE9kA :/&:M-1 9E>0-9E@9-1 ME/EM3A/E a?

>-93/05I30-9 3- 32A :3IC. -F 32A <A/50E9 9E30-9E@ >2E/E>3A/b!X a(+)%b! 09 NEC-BE9<EHE/C]0> E9C m0B-/EC <3-kM-B0>! AC:'! &'?/'5' 4%"' &"*?*4'5' ]*)'5*)#,'= B-@' (#:\A@1/ECAV \=[m! dI1-:@EB0kE&I5@0M 0 </&:ME M9k0]AB9E ]EC/I1E! (++('

O-=,),)X T,-7(4?X '7[X ]'+* (/.($)*0^'+' ]18*("')#^': A<?*/ ,"'5'+' #< _&/.(+*8 8"'('` */8'5'&/.(+*8 +1"$1/5*8 +"1?'= WXZX*WXab a<3/-91 <A/5C-Hi:3/-91 JI1-:@EB0E' <A@A>30-9-F E/30>@A: F/-H UL2A <A/50E9 6-0>A!X 32A k-I/9E@ -F 32A <A/50E9 ,I@3I/E@ ,@I5b'\A@1/ECAV YEI>9E M9k01E! (++('

O-_,++X P'.X U%> F*/"4 I#(*/4%/T O6% M%5#5#($ P@$#5,$#*5' \A/MA@A.! ,?V j90BA/:03. -F ,E@0F-/90E S/A::! (++#'P47,B'=,)X A';BC-X V*^% )#4^%5^% /'(.'4' an. B0AD -F 32A C0::-@I30-9b' \A@1/ECAV S-@030ME!

(++Z'P'('./C\X I;'C/4.7( G\-7-(-=,)2X O6% G/1,#7#@#*5 *7 M#?%/$;: YAD J-/M! YJV d-29 _E.

,-H&E9.! (+Z%'P6;'.-=,)X 3C'.7'(X &$*^'5+' -'^+': d5%<*.*"^+' # 4/18% .%(-% a<3-kE9ME! 32A H-32A/ -F

^9A]AB- Q0A@C E9C -32A/ &-AH:b' \A@1/ECAV S/-:BA3E! (+)#'N4,+,.X K4=,7X A4%5$#$; #5 N*/-'$#*5T O6% 21((#'50&.%'+#58 B*.1"'$#*5( #5 $6% U%'/ L?/*'4'

=32E>E! YJ E9C l-9C-9! j^V ,-/9A@@ j90BA/:03. S/A::! (++o'N6C,)X 5'.'- 4.7 I;;4. N\.)2X P1/*.% 7/*- $6% \'"+'5( $* $6% R/'"(T O6% I#(#5$%8/'$#*5 *7

E18*("')#' '54 $6% &*)#%$ R5#*5' TGF-/C! j^ E9C YAD J-/M! YJV TGF-/C j90BA/:03.S/A::! (++)'

UnAH-/E9CIH <?Yj anAH-/E9CIH -F 32A <A/50E9 ?>ECAH. -F <>0A9>A:b!X 09 ^-:3En02E0@-B0> E9C 6E:0@0kA ^/A:30>! AC:'! V%-*/'541- &LUR ' g48*)*/# 5' +/#$#+%' \A@K1/ECAV <?Yj! (++g'

T,;-/'=,)X 3;-8-74.X K*4#5% /'(."%$' aj93.091 32A M9-3i' \A@1/ECAV \=[m! (+o+'T,;,6C-=X &46;X 21((#' '54 A$( G/#(#(' YAD J-/M! YJV ,-@@0A/ \--M:! (+)#'

E;B4)4X T;47'.X d*<'/': \A@1/ECAV S/-:BA3E! (+)h'&-/'.X L4((\X UL2A <A>I/03. _0@AHHE E9C W3290> ,-9F@0>3!X &1/)#)'" X VMX (V#h*%h! <&/091

(++Z'5-??'(X H4./X UYE30-9E@0:H E9C 32A <3E3AV ? NI::0E9 _0@AHHE!X G*-.'/'$#)% &$14#%( #5

&*,#%$; '54 S#($*/;! #X ZV#gZ*#)%! (+)#'3-;'=,)X T,(-/;4=X 093A/B0ADAC 5. _E/M- 7ICA@0:3! &$'/$! nE/>2 (o! (+o+'3-;]2'.,+/\.X I;'`4.7'(X O6% K1"'8 L/,6#.%"'8*T L5 P@.%/#-%5$ #5 M#$%/'/; A5)%($#8'$#*5!

WXWe*WXYj= B-@IHA: =*==: YAD J-/M! YJV 7E/&A/ ; N-D! (+hZ'3+(4.B4C-=,)X K(4?-/;4=X U7/BE30 0 :&-/E]IH -C #) EB1I:3E aL2A ,/-E3: E9C 32A

E1/AAHA93 -F ?I1I:3 #)b!X 09 n0-C/E1 d-B0>0>! AC'! ]'+* (/.($)*0^'+' ]18*("')#^': A<?*/

http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/external-references?article=0037-6779(1992)51:4L.654%5Baid=4053514%5D







!U# ADNOPE AJOI@<@

,"'5'+' #< _&/.(+*8 8"'(=` */8'5' &/.(+*8 +1"$1/5*8 +"1?'= WXZX*WXab: \A@1/ECAV YEI>9EM9k01E! (++('

:4\;-(X L(,4.X UL2A <-B0A3 n0@03E/. E9C 32A _0:093A1/E30-9 -F 32A j<<N!X ]*1/5'" *7 G*"4

F'/ &$14#%(! MX (V(h*))! 8093A/ #$$Z':6)C'(X 5-8'(+X O6% &*)#%$ B*"#$#,'" V#54' YAD J-/M! YJV 8' 8' Y-/3-9! (+h(':6)C'(X 5-8'(+X &$'"#5 #5 B*>%/: YAD J-/M! YJV 8' 8' Y-/3-9! (++#'A,-;4X N\..X B%'('5$ 2%?%"( 154%/ &$'"#5T G*""%,$#)#<'$#*5 '54 $6% G1"$1/% *7 B%'('5$ 2%(#(0

$'5,%' TGF-/C! j^V TGF-/C j90BA/:03. S/A::! (++)'A6),.,)2X Z4\.' 3[ 4.7 :2-W4/ I[ DWW'(+X '7/[X d*(*)*T M%8',; *7 ' V%4#%)'" \'$$"%'

n099AE&-@0:! nYV j90BA/:03. -F n099A:-3E S/A::! (++('A6B4),)X A';BC-X U=9:303I30-9E@ T/0109: -F ,-93AH&-/E/. <A/50E9 YE30-9E@0:H!X P'($

P1/*.%'5 G*5($#$1$#*5'" 2%)#%>= M! %Vg(*)(! QE@@ (++)E'

A6B4),)X A';BC-X U70:3-/0>E@ @A1E>0A:! 9E30-9E@0:3 H-50@0]E30-9! E9C &-@030>E@ -I3>-HA:09 NI::0E E9C <A/50EV ? 8A5A/0E9 B0AD!X O6%*/; '54 &*,#%$;! $MVh)Z*o$(! (++)5'A6B4),)X A';BC-X aNAAGEH09091 32A <A/50E9 WG>A&30-9E@0:H L2A:0:!X N#"*<*7#^' # 4/1k$)*!

SS<V#$g*#%h! #$$#'A6B4),)X A';BC- 4.7 b4/;4=/C\X A,)+-(X UL2A ,EI:A: -F _0:093A1/E30-9 09 32A <-B0A3

j90-9 E9C JI1-:@EB0E!X O%"*(! RRV(#$*(%$! <IHHA/ (++('Z4)2+';X I.7('_X V'+#58 ' U'$#*5= \/%'+#58 ' U'$#*5T M#$%/'$1/% '54 G1"$1/'" B*"#$#,( #5

E18*("')#'' <3E9F-/C! ,?V <3E9F-/C j90BA/:03. S/A::! (++o'Z4;C'(X D7_4(7 Z[X I#((*"1$#*5T &*)%/%#85$; '54 $6% \/%'+1. *7 $6% &*)#%$ R5#*5: lE92EH!

n_V N-DHE9 ; l033@AF0A@C! #$$Z'Z--7_4(7X 36/4. N[X \'"+'5 O/'8%4;T G6'*( '54 I#((*"1$#*5 L7$%/ $6% G*"4 F'/' 8E:2091K

3-9! _,V \/--M091: =9:303I30-9 S/A::! (++g'>';+/,.X L-(,/X O6% &$/188"% 7*/ 21((#': YAD J-/M! YJV NE9C-H 7-I:A! (++%'






http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/external-references?article=0304-2421()25L.763%5Baid=6088886%5D

Vujacic, Veljko (2004) Perceptions of the State in Russia and Serbia

Documents