1 VP Conjunction, Relative Clauses Ling 406/802 Read Meaning and Grammar, Ch 7.3-7.4 2 Conjunction Reduction Analysis • In [TP1 and TP2], parts of TP2 that are identical with parallel parts of TP1 can be deleted. This deletion happens in phonology, so does not affect meaning. (1) a. Sam likes Gandalf and hates Gollum. b. Sam likes Gandalf and Sam hates Gollum. • But full and reduced [TP1 and TP2] do not always have the same meaning. (2) a. Every hobbit is short or fat. b. Every hobbit is short or every hobbit is fat. (3) a. An elf knows Gandalf and loves Aragorn. b. An elf knows Gandalf and an elf loves Aragorn.
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
VP Conjunction, Relative Clauses
Ling 406/802
Read Meaning and Grammar, Ch 7.3-7.4
2
Conjunction Reduction Analysis
• In [TP1 and TP2], parts of TP2 that are identical with parallel parts of
TP1 can be deleted. This deletion happens in phonology, so does not
affect meaning.
(1) a. Sam likes Gandalf and hates Gollum.
b. Sam likes Gandalf and Sam hates Gollum.
• But full and reduced [TP1 and TP2] do not always have the same
meaning.
(2) a. Every hobbit is short or fat.
b. Every hobbit is short or every hobbit is fat.
(3) a. An elf knows Gandalf and loves Aragorn.
b. An elf knows Gandalf and an elf loves Aragorn.
3
Syntax of VP Conjunction
• VP $ VP Conj VP
• Examples
4
Semantics of VP Conjunction
• Problem: So far, we have defined conjunctions to be sentential
operators, operating on formulas. But now, it looks like we need to
allow conjunctions to operate on predicates.
Can we keep conjunctions as sentential operators and yet allow
predicates to be conjoined?
• Solution: !-abstraction
For any 1-place predicates,
[Pred1 " Pred2] = !x[Pred1(x) " Pred2(x)]
[Pred1 # Pred2] = !x[Pred1(x) # Pred2(x)]
5
Translating Every hobbit is short or is fat
6
Translating Every hobbit is short or every hobbit is fat
7
Translating An elf knows Gandalf and loves Aragorn
8
Translating An elf knows Gandalf and an elf loves Aragorn