Top Banner
Voice, agency and the medical arts Vicky Grant December 2016
15

Voice, agency and the medical arts

Apr 15, 2017

Download

Health & Medicine

missvagrant
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Voice, agency and the medical arts

Voice, agency and the medical arts

Vicky GrantDecember 2016

Page 2: Voice, agency and the medical arts

AShamed. Stitchcraft work by Kate Smyth at Bitchin’ Stitchin.

Page 3: Voice, agency and the medical arts

“Angry bowel syndrome” by Anne.

Page 4: Voice, agency and the medical arts

McCartney, M. (2012) The patient paradox: why sexed up medicine is bad for your health, London: Pinter & Martin.Image reproduced with the permission of Pinter & Martin publishers.

Page 5: Voice, agency and the medical arts

Shamed, by Angela

Page 6: Voice, agency and the medical arts

What the Royal College of Physicians think doctors should say to patients with IBS

“I have examined you thoroughly and cannot find anything wrong …”

“I am pleased to say that I do not think there is anything terrible going on here”

“This is good news …”

“You do not have a serious disorder such as cancer”

Collier, J. D. ed. (2004) Medical masterclass: Gastroenterology and hepatology, London: Royal College of Physicians of London.Keshav, S. ed. (2008) Medical masterclass: Gastroenterology and hepatology, 2nd ed., London: Royal College of Physicians.

Page 7: Voice, agency and the medical arts

“Just IBS” by Emily

Page 8: Voice, agency and the medical arts

ruining my life!By Niamh

Page 9: Voice, agency and the medical arts
Page 10: Voice, agency and the medical arts
Page 11: Voice, agency and the medical arts

“When I have IBS I am not well. Regardless of what your GP checklist says” Becki

Page 12: Voice, agency and the medical arts

By Becki and Polina

Page 13: Voice, agency and the medical arts
Page 14: Voice, agency and the medical arts
Page 15: Voice, agency and the medical arts

Does the hierarchy of clinical evidence silence patients?