Vicky Nanousi, Arhonto Terzi Technological Educational Institute of W. Greece, Patras Workshop on Advances in the Sciences of Language Disorders University of Cyprus, June 19-20, 2015. Passive Sentences in agrammatism: The case of Greek
Jan 17, 2016
Vicky Nanousi, Arhonto Terzi Technological Educational Institute of W. Greece, Patras
Workshop on Advances in the Sciences of Language Disorders
University of Cyprus, June 19-20, 2015.
Passive Sentences in agrammatism:The case of Greek
1. Background
Individuals with agrammatic aphasia are known to suffer from a deficit regarding sentences with non-canonical word order. Reversible verbal passives constitute a much studied subset of them.
A prominent account of the deficit is known as the Trace Deletion Hypothesis (TDH), proposed by Grodzinsky (1990, 1995, 2000).
TDHIn passives, the trace of the moved element is
deleted. As a result, the two cannot relate and the moved DP cannot be interpreted as a patient. It is interpreted as an agent via a non-grammar strategy.
2
The boy was pushed <the boy> by the girl. #
But:Passives are not impaired in all languages in agrammatism.Impaired: English, Spanish, HebrewNot impaired: German, Dutch.Directionality of th-assignment (Grodzinsky 2006).
3
4
Directionality of th-assignmentEnglish, Spanish, Hebrew: to the right (VO languages)German, Dutch: to the left (OV languages)
The boy was pushed <the boy> by the girl. √ German, Dutch
* English, Spanish, Hebrew
Greek: a VO languagePassives understudied in agrammatismPassives develop late in children's grammar (Terzi et al. 2014, a.o.)
Relative sentences
The same rationale for aphasic performance on relative clauses.
Trace of moved DP is deleted, affecting object relatives, (1), but not subject relatives (2). The latter are interpreted successfully via a non-grammatical mechanism.
(1) The boy that the girl pushed <the boy>.(2) The boy that <the boy> pushed the girl Recently the above facts are explained via
Relativized Minimality (Grillo 2005, 2009 via Rizzi, 1990 et seq.).
5
In (1) the moved element, the boy, has no Q features in agrammatism, and crosses another element of the same type, the girl.
In (2) nothing intervenes between the moved element and its trace.
(1) The boy that the girl pushed <the boy>.(2) The boy that <the boy> pushed the girl
Sameness of intervening features is claimed to cause trouble in children too (Belletti et al. 2012).
Gender is such a feature (in languages that it is responsible for movement).
6
2. The current study
The languageGreek is a VO language.
Passives are formed via the use of verbal inflection rather than the an auxiliary.
(1) I Maria sproxnete.the Mary push-nonact-3s‘Mary is pushed.’
(2) Ta pedia timorunde.the children punish-nonact-3p‘The children are punished.’
7
Same morphology for middle and reflexive verbs.
MiddleAfto to vivlio diavazete efkola.this the book read-nonact-3s easily'This book reads easily.'
ReflexiveO Kostas ksirizetethe Kostas shave-nonact-3s 'Kostas shaves himself.'
8
The participants a. Broca’s aphasics
b. 10 healthy controls. 2 per each aphasic, matched on age, education, gender.
9
Age
Educ.
Gender
MLU Noun-verbRatio
P1 48 12 M 1,6 1,5
P3 56 12 M -- --
P5 51 10 M 1,8 1,5
P4 65 12 M 1,9 1,25
P5 71 9 M 1,6 1,4
The tasks
1. A Past Tense (Reference) elicitation task A Sentence completion task 51 sentences/verbs. 18 sentences contained real regular verbs (Varlokosta & Koutsoubari 2006, w. minor modifications)
2. A clitics production task A picture task 10 sentences/clitics (and corresponding pictures) 4 masculine, 3 feminine, 3 neuter (Chondrogianni et al. 2010)
10
Results (1) Accuracy scores
Also: Tense Reference: a few Agreement errors Clitic Production: a few Gender errors11
Tense Reference
Clitic Production
P1 100% 80%
P3 78% 50%
P5 87,5% 60%
P4 65% 30%
P5 83,5% 50%
12
The Passive tasksPassive Task 1: Short Passives
A picture-matching task consisting of 36 sentences. Tested passive and reflexive verbs, along with
Binding of pronouns and anaphors. 6 sentences with short passives, i.e., passive
sentences without the by-phrase. An example:
(3) O Giorgos sproxnete the George is-pushed ‘George is pushed.’
The same protocol was employed by Terzi et al. (2014) in an acquisition study. Typical 6:06 year-old children gave 75% correct responses on passive sentences.
Results (2) Short Passives
All participants performed at ceiling.Participants from both groups commented that
the test was easy.Reminder: Typically developing 6;06 children
performed 75% correctly on passives.
14
Passive Task 2: Long Passives
A picture-matching task consisting of 96 sentences.Tested actives and long passives, i.e., passives with
the by-phrase. It also tested subject relatives and object relatives. There were 24 sentences in each condition., i.e., 24
long passives, An example:
(4) Edo o gabros fotografizete apo tin giagia. here the groom is-photographed by the grandmother ‘Here the groom is photographed by the grandmother.’15
3. Results
Long Passives Task
Active sentencesBoth groups, aphasics and healthy controls
performed at ceiling.
17
Results (cont.) - Long Passives
Accuracy scores
18
Agrammatics
Correct Controls Correct
P1 21/24 C1 (2) 47/48
P3 22/24 C2 (2) 48/48
P5 21/24 C3 (2) 48/48
P4 23/24 C4 (2) 46/48
P5 21/24 C5 (2) 46/48
Total 108/120(90%)
Total 235/240(98%)
Results (cont.)Previous findings
Fyndanis (2012)1 agrammatic: 94% correct performance on both
actives and passives
Fyndanis et al. (2013)2 agrammatics: 39% and 50% correct performance
on passives but: 56% and 70% correct performance
on actives
19
4. Conclusions - Discussion
It most probably follows that passive sentences do not constitute a selective deficit for Greek-speaking individuals with Broca’s aphasia.
Although the performance of Broca's aphasics on passives is not as good as on the corresponding actives, it is by no means impaired.
20
What cannot account for this behavior?
Dirctionality of th-role assignment (Grodzinsky 2006)
No, because Greek is a VO language
Lower parts of the tree are not impaired (only higher are)
(Friedmann 2005)
No, because the Infl area, i.e., the T projection is not good.
The manner in which Greek forms passives?21
Appendix - Relatives clauses
22
Subject RelativesSame gender
Subject RelativesDiffer. gender
ObjectRelativesSame gender
Object RelativesDiffer. Gender
P1 2 0 9 1
P2 1 0 5 2
P3 0 0 5 4
P4 4 1 7 4
P5 4 1 7 7
Total 11 2 33 18
13 51
Selected References
Caramazza, A. et al. 2005. Patterns of comprehension performance in agrammatic Broca's aphasia: A test of the Trace Deletion Hypothesis. Brain and Language 94: 43-53.
Friedmann, N. 2005. Degrees of severity and recovery in aphasia: climbing up the tree. Brain and Language 19: 1037-1051.
Grodzinsky, Y. 1990. Theoretical perspectives on language deficits. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Grodzinsky, Y. 2006. A blueprint for a brain map of syntax. In Y. Grodzinsky & K. Amunts (eds.), Broca’s Region, Oxford University Press.
Fyndanis, V. 2012. Comprehension in Greek-speaking agrammatism: a case study. In Z. Gavriilidou et al. (eds.), Proceedings of ICGL10, 265-274.
Fyndanis, V. et al. 2013. Morphosyntactic comprehension in agrammatic aphasia: Evidence from Greek. Aphasiology 27: 398-419.
Terzi, A. et al. 2014. Grammatical Abilities of Greek-Speaking Children with Autism. Language Acquisition, 21: 4-44.
23
Acknowledgements
This research has been co-financed by the European Union (European Social Fund - ESF) and Greek national funds through the Operational Program "Education and Lifelong Learning" of the National Strategic Reference Framework (NSRF) - Research Funding Program: ARCHIMEDES III. Investing in knowledge society through the European Social Fund.
Project Title: The structure of (a)typical language:
linguistic theory and intervention
PI: Arhonto Terzi
24