Top Banner
INNOVATION APPLICATION FORMATION CARACTERISATION 8, allée Geoffroy Saint Hilaire CS30021 F-33615 PESSAC Cedex Tél : (33) 05 47 74 69 00 Fax : (33) 05 47 74 80 13 Mél : [email protected] http://www.rescoll.fr Agréments formation 72330571433 DRTEFP Aquitaine EWF – Certificat n° 27 pour EAB-EWF 515 EAS-EWF 516 SIRET 437 950 173 00041 – NAF 7490B – VAT FR 81437950173 Accréditation n°3-1004 Portée disponible sur www.cofrac.fr Verification report n°180098d Cancels and replaces the previous version from July the 24 th , 2018 Pessac, 27/07/2018 Author : Approved by : ORIGINAL SIGNED ORIGINAL SIGNED Claire MICHAUD Claire MICHAUD Inspector ETV technical manager If Rescoll do not receive any comment from you within 15 days after sending it, Rescoll will consider that the verification report is accepted by the two sides. The verification report should not be copied or used without prior agreement of RESCOLL EU Environmental Technology Verification pilot programme
34

Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

Mar 25, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

INNOVATION

APPLICATION

FORMATION

CARACTERISATION

8, allée Geoffroy Saint Hilaire

CS30021

F-33615 PESSAC Cedex

Tél : (33) 05 47 74 69 00

Fax : (33) 05 47 74 80 13

Mél : [email protected]

http://www.rescoll.fr

Agréments formation

72330571433 DRTEFP Aquitaine

EWF – Certificat n° 27 pour

EAB-EWF 515

EAS-EWF 516

SIRET 437 950 173 00041 – NAF 7490B – VAT FR 81437950173

Accréditation n°3-1004 Portée disponible sur www.cofrac.fr

Verification report n°180098d

Cancels and replaces the previous version from July the 24th, 2018

Pessac, 27/07/2018

Author : Approved by :

ORIGINAL SIGNED

ORIGINAL SIGNED

Claire MICHAUD Claire MICHAUD Inspector ETV technical manager

If Rescoll do not receive any comment from you within 15 days after sending it, Rescoll will consider that the

verification report is accepted by the two sides.

The verification report should not be copied or used without prior agreement of RESCOLL

EU Environmental Technology

Verification pilot programme

Page 2: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

2/ 34

I. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................... 4

Name of technology ........................................................................................................................................... 4

Name and contact of proposer .......................................................................................................................... 4

Name of verification body and responsible of verification ................................................................................ 5

Organisation of verification including experts, and verification process ........................................................... 5

Deviations from the verification protocol .......................................................................................................... 6

II. DESCRIPTION OF THE TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATION ............................. 7

Summary description of the technology ........................................................................................................... 7

Intended application (matrix, purpose, technologies, technical conditions) .................................................. 14

Intended application .............................................................................................................................. 14

Matrix ..................................................................................................................................................... 14

Purpose ................................................................................................................................................... 14

Technical conditions ............................................................................................................................... 14

Verification parameters definition .................................................................................................................. 16

III. ACCEPTED EXISTING DATA ....................................................................... 17

IV. EVALUATION ............................................................................................ 18

Calculation of verification parameters including determination of uncertainty ........................................... 18

Evaluation of test quality ............................................................................................................................... 19

Control data .......................................................................................................................................... 19

Audits .................................................................................................................................................... 19

Deviations .............................................................................................................................................. 20

Verification results (verified performance claim) .......................................................................................... 22

Description of statistical methods used ................................................................................................ 22

Verification parameters ........................................................................................................................ 22

Additional parameters, with comments or caveats where appropriate ............................................... 31

Recommendations for the statement of verification .................................................................................... 31

Page 3: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

3/ 34

V. QUALITY ASSURANCE ................................................................................ 33

VI. REFERENCES ............................................................................................. 33

VII. APPENDIX 1 : QUICK SCAN – VERIFICATION PROPOSAL ........................... 34

VIII. APPENDIX 2 : SPECIFIC VERIFICATION PROTOCOL .................................. 34

IX. APPENDIX 3 : AMENDMENT AND DEVIATION REPORT FOR VERIFICATION

..................................................................................................................... 34

X. APPENDIX 4 : TEST PLAN ........................................................................... 34

XI. APPENDIX 5 : TEST REPORT ..................................................................... 34

XII. APPENDIX 6 : TEST SYSTEM ASSESSMENT REPORT .................................. 34

Page 4: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

4/ 34

Environmental Technology Verification (ETV) is an independent (third-part) assessment of the performance of a

technology or a product for a specified application under defined conditions and quality assurance.

RESCOLL is an accredited Verification Body (ISO 17020, type A) for the three following technology areas :

1. Water treatment and monitoring

2. Materials, waste and resources

3. Energy technologies

Verification report compiles and summarises all information relevant for the verification.

Name of technology

The technology studied in this verification is Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S with addition of floculant.

Name and contact of proposer

Veolia water technologies AB - Hydrotech

Contact : Carles Pellicer-Nachèr

Téléphone : +46 722 34 70 55

Courriel : [email protected]

I. Introduction

Page 5: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

5/ 34

Name of verification body and responsible of verification

RESCOLL, 8 allée Geoffroy Saint Hilaire CS30021, 33615 PESSAC, FRANCE

ETV Technical Manager : Claire Michaud

Phone : 00 33 (0)5 47 74 69 00,

Email : [email protected]

ETV inspector : Claire Michaud

Phone : +33 (0)5 47 74 69 00,

Email : [email protected]

Organisation of verification including experts, and

verification process

The verification process was leaded by RESCOLL.

RESCOLL was in charge of :

- writing the specific verification protocol with the contribution of technical experts,

- writing the verification report,

- writing the verification statement,

- exchanges with European Commission.

The technical expert was :

- Mr SAMUELSSON Oscar, IVL, [email protected]

Test management has been performed by Hydrotech on a pilot line of Sjölunda water treatment plant in Sweden.

Analytical tests have been performed by Veolia Water Technologies AB, located in Lund, Sweden.

Page 6: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

6/ 34

Relationships between organizations are described on the following scheme.

1.

2.

Deviations from the verification protocol

Deviations from specific verification protocol are described in paragraph IV.2.3.

Figure 1 : Organisation of the verification

Verification Body

Rescoll

European commission

Technical expert

Oscar Samuelsson, IVL Proposer

Hydrotech - Veolia

Test Body

Hydrotech - Veolia

Analytical laboratories

Veolia Water Technologies AB,

Lund

Page 7: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

7/ 34

Summary description of the technology

The technology studied is Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S implemented with addition of flocculant.

Drawing of the technology is available in appendix 2 of specific verification protocol.

The size of the cloth installed in Sjölunda pilot line is 100 microns.

ETV verification has been performed on a pilot line of Sjölunda Waste Water Treatment Plant, Sweden. A

description of Sjôlunda waste water treatment plant was put in appendix 1 of specific verification protocol.

The drumfilter is implemented after screening, fat and grit removal steps as it is described in the following

scheme.

Figure 2 : Scheme of water pilot line

Bellow are described the equipment implemented in the pilot line.

II. Description of the technology and application

Page 8: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

8/ 34

1. Influent pump

The centrifugal pump (Flygt NS 3102.160 SH-256, Figure 3) is used to deliver flows from 5 to 30 m3/h by

controlling the rotation speed of the pump rotor with a frequency controller (Parker AC30). Flows can be set to

a certain value or can be set to simulate a user-defined flow pattern. Water is pumped from the end of the

aerated sand grit, before chemicals are dosed prior to the primary clarifier.

Figure 3 : Centrifugal pump used at the pilot

2. Drumfilter HDF2001-1S

A drumfilter (HDF2001-1S, Hydrotech) with a cloth of 100 µm pores features level control, and an backwashing

system in order to prevent blockage of the cloth. Technical water (max 0,5 L/s) is used for backwashing the filter.

Drawing of the technology is available in appendix 2 of specific verification protocol.

Page 9: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

9/ 34

3. Coagulation tank

CONFIDENTIAL

Page 10: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

10/ 34

4. Flocculation tank

CONFIDENTIAL

Page 11: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

11/ 34

5. Polymer preparation unit

Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering

of polymer solutions, either powdered or liquid chemicals. PolyRex uses a step-by-step mixing system to

effectively hydrate and mix the polymer to a homogenous and fully activated polymer solution. Powder polymer

is dosed into a tank with tap water by a multiscrew feeder in order to achieve a concentration of 0.1% active

polymer. This solution is maturated with a mixer for one hour and later discharged in a storage tank, where it is

pumped into the main treatment line with a diaphragm dosing pump.

Figure 4 : Tomal polymer preparation unit

The polymer used is H6358: a cationic medium charge high molecular weight powder flocculant supplied by

Hydrex.

6. Polymer dosing

DME 940-4 AR-PP/V/G-S-32A2A2F is a diaphragm dosing pump supplied by Grundfos able to deliver up to 940

L/h at 4 bar (Figure 5). Pressure loading valve is installed in the dosing line to even the dosed flow. The drive

technology and microprocessor control make sure that liquids are dosed precisely and with low pulsation, even

when the pump is operating with high viscosity or degassing liquids. The capacity of the DME is regulated by

automatic adjustment of the motor speed during the discharge stroke, and by fixed suction stroke speed.

Polymer prepared in the polymer preparation unit is dosed directly in the overflow funnel of the coagulation

tank in order to achieve proper dispersion and a concentration of active polymer in the range 2-6 mg/L.

The concentrations of active metal or active polymer can be set by the user at a fixed value or adjusted by the

programmed controller, based on the signal from the turbidity probes.

Page 12: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

12/ 34

Figure 5 : Polymer dosing pump

7. Turbidity meters

Solitax SC ts-line immersion probes (LXV423.99.00100, Figure 6) are installed in the pumping point, flocculation

tank, and filtrate tanks in order to monitor the removal efficiencies of particulate matter. The integrated

automatic wiper allows the probe to remain clean.

Figure 6 : Turbidity probe installed in the flocculation tank

Page 13: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

13/ 34

8. Flow meters

Promag W 400, 5W4C80 flow meters (DN80, Figure 7) supplied by Endress and Hauser are installed in the inflow

of the Drumfilter and effluent from the Discfilter in order to monitor the water losses in the installation, if any.

The influent flow is used in order to control the rotation speed of the influent pump and the dosing rate of the

flocculant dosing pumps.

Figure 7 : Flow meter installed upstream the drumfilter

9. Measure of SS to control dosage

It is a Solitax turbidity probe (Hach Lange). Infrared Duo scattered light technique for color-independent turbidity

measurement Turbidity in accordance with DIN EN ISO 7027.

10. Backwash water treatment

Backwash water is pumped back to a sludge tank, and later digested in the plant for biogas production.

The Drumfilter is backwashed when required with technical water at max 0.5 L/s. The filter is backwashed

seldomly, so the actual consumption is below 0.5 L/s. Daily consumptions can be monitored. Tapwater is also

used for preparation of the polymer stock solution.

Page 14: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

14/ 34

Intended application (matrix, purpose, technologies,

technical conditions)

Intended application

Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S is used as primary treatment stage for raw municipal wastewater (after

mechanical treatment, i.e. removal of sand, grit and grease) to enable removal of particulate matter.

The high level of carbon extraction of the technology induces high level of biogas production coming from sludge

digestion, so, a good overall environmental footprint.

Matrix

The technology is intended to treat wastewater.

The verification will be performed on a pilot line of Sjölunda Waste Water Treatment Plant. The full address is:

Sjölunda avloppsreningsverk

Spillepengsgatan 15-17

211 24 Malmö

Sweden

The water is received from the greater part of Malmö, together with Burlöv and parts of the municipalities of

Lomma, Staffanstorp and Svedala.

Purpose

The purpose of the technology is to perform a first treatment of suspended solids, BOD, P and COD of the

wastewater with a good overall environmental footprint.

The technology is implemented after sand, grit and grease removal.

Technical conditions

Performance parameters will depend on several technical conditions.

The most important one are described as operational parameters in the paragraph Verification parameters

definitionII.3.

Two scenarios were tested with varying flow conditions varying flow between 6-30m3/h (average is 15m3/h).

For technical reasons it was not possible to use the real inlet flow, so, the flow pattern was fixed by Hydrotech.

The flow pattern is presented in the Figure 8.

Page 15: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

15/ 34

Figure 8 : Flow pattern for varying flow scenarios

Page 16: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

16/ 34

Verification parameters definition

Here is the table summarizing the parameter table defined in the specific verification protocol.

Parameter Unit Test or measurement

method(s) Frequency

PERFORMANCE PARAMETERS

Concentration of total suspended

solids after Hydrotech drumfilter

HDF2001-1S

mg/L or g/m3 Direct analyses

Sensor and registration Continuous

OPERATIONAL PARAMETERS

Concentration of total suspended

solids before Hydrotech drumfilter

HDF2001-1S

mg/L or g/m3 Direct analyses

Sensor and registration Continuous

Quantity of coagulant before

Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S

Unit of quantity

and unit of

volume

Calculation from dosed

volume Continuous

Quantity of coagulant after Hydrotech

drumfilter HDF2001-1S

Unit of

concentration Sampling and lab analysis Once a week

Quantity of flocculant before

Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S

L/h or unit of

online

measurement

Sampling and lab analysis Once a week

Flow before hydrotech drumfilter

HDF2001-1S L/unit of time Flowmeter Continuous

Water temperature °C Temperature sensor and

registration

Continuous

measurement

Concentration of BOD before

Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S mg/L or g/m3

Sampling and lab analysis

Samples should be freezed

before sending to external

lab

Once a week

Concentration of BOD after Hydrotech

drumfilter HDF2001-1S mg/L or g/m3

Sampling and lab analysis

Samples should be freezed

before sending to external

lab

Once a week

Concentration of TOC before

Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S mg/L or g/m3

Sampling and lab analysis

Samples should be freezed Once a week

Concentration of TOC after Hydrotech

drumfilter HDF2001-1S mg/L or g/m3 Samples should be freezed Once a week

Concentration of pH before Hydrotech

drumfilter HDF2001-1S / Sampling and lab analysis Once a week

Concentration of pH after Hydrotech

drumfilter HDF2001-1S / Sampling and lab analysis Once a week

Concentration of alkalinity before

Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S mg/L or g/m3

Direct analysis

Sampling and lab analysis Once a week

Concentration of alkalinity after

Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-1S mg/L or g/m3

Direct analysis

Sampling and lab analysis Once a week

Concentration of total phosphorus

before Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-

1S

mg/L or g/m3 Sampling and lab analysis

Samples should be freezed Once a week

Page 17: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

17/ 34

Parameter Unit Test or measurement

method(s) Frequency

Concentration of total phosphorus

after Hydrotech drumfilter HDF2001-

1S

mg/L or g/m3 Sampling and lab analysis

Samples should be freezed Once a week

ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS

Energy consumption

MJ or kWh per

unit of water

treated or per

unit of time

Energy measurement

performed by Hydrotech Continuous

Consumption of backwash water

L per unit of

water treated or

per unit of time

Flowmeter Continuous

Consumption of cleaning materials L or g

Weighting and registration

of nature, quantity of

cleaning materials and date

At each cleaning

step

All the tests have been implemented in the frame of verification and no existing data were accepted.

III. Accepted existing data

Page 18: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

18/ 34

Calculation of verification parameters including

determination of uncertainty

Initially, it was planed to use online continuous measurement of TSS.

The online sensors that have been used during the test for turbidity measurement is a Hach Solitax SC

TS-line (for more information see test plan in Appendix 4 : Test plan). The value from the Solitax SC-

probes has been used to estimate the total suspended solids in the water (TSS). To do this a conversion

factor between TSS and turbidity has been calculated from grab samples collected on a weekly basis

during the test period. The conversion factor was then used to estimate the TSS-concentration in the

water from the online-sensors.

We can see in the Figure 9 the curves used for the calculation of TSS performance parameter.

Figure 9 : Correlation between NTU and TSS used for calculation of performance parameter

The on-line values were used to assess the real-time performance of SS-control. The lab samples were used to evaluate the overall weekly SS-reduction. Measurement technical difficulties with the SS-sensor made it infeasible to use the on-line data for evaluating the exact SS-reduction although the time trends were accepted to be valid.

y = 1,9967xR² = 0,9146

y = 1,4579xR² = 0,9239

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

TSS

(mg/

l)

Turbidity (NTU)

Influent

Effluent

IV. Evaluation

Page 19: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

19/ 34

Evaluation of test quality

Control data

Rescoll verified the accreditation scope of the laboratory Veolia Water Technologies AB. He is accredited for the

following tests :

- BOD

- TOC

- Tot P

- TSS

- pH

Veolia Water technologies is not accredited for alkalinity tests but results were accepted without quality system

assessment.

A test plan has been performed by Veolia before start of the tests. He is described in Appendix 4 : Test plan.

Audits

One test system audit was performed by Mr Oscar Samuelsson before the beginning of the tests on December

7th, 2017.

The test system assessment report is in Appendix 6 : Test system assessment report.

Page 20: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

20/ 34

Deviations

The following table shows deviations between tests implementation and specific verification protocol.

Paragraph of the specific verification

protocol

Description of the deviation Criticality Conclusion

II.1 Summary description of the technology Initially, hydrotech planed to use floculant and

coagulant but there was no use of coagulant.

Not critical The modification was accepted.

V.1 Test design

3 scenarios of tests were initially planed.

Each of these scenarios should have been

tested four three types of inflow.

During the timeframe of the program, it was only

possible to perform 2 scenarios with 2 types of

flow.

The scenario “Maintain the effluent at a

continuous 25 NTU concentration despite daily

variations using chemicals” has not been studied.

Not critical The modification was accepted because the low flow

were the most beneficial to the proposer. So, if results

are good for other types of inflow, results should be good

also for low flow.

Deletion of a scenario of test was possible because

results for other scenarios are good. And, it does not

affect the environmental added value of the technology.

V.5.2 Test report All results have been summarized and sent to

Rescoll in excel sheets but no test report has been

written.

Not critical The modification was accepted because the test plan was

very complete and all results were sent in excel sheets.

V.1 Test design

Time period of each test should be 3 weeks

The test period of the scenario « 50 NTU with a

varying flow » was of 1.5 week.

Not critical The deviation was judged as not critical because during

the period of test, there was one period of high flow

which was well controlled by the Hydrotech drumfilter

HDF2001-1S.

V.1 Test design

Continuous measurement

It was planed to use continuous sensors

measurement for TSS performance claim.

Not critical There were continuous measurements of NTU

performed with sensor Hach Solitax SC TS-line of

turbidity.

Page 21: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

21/ 34

We checked correlation between NTU and TSS and finally

used the lab measures for the performance parameter

because they were more reliable.

V.1 Test design

Continuous measurement

Calculation of final parameters should have been

based on the whole time period of tests but we

excluded period of time with technical issue

(power failure, …)

Not critical This situation are not due to the technology itself but to

the pilot line scale.

Table 1 : List of deviations between test realisation and specific verification protocol

Page 22: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

22/ 34

Verification results (verified performance claim)

Description of statistical methods used

Mean has been calculated with this formula :

𝑥 = ∑ 𝑥𝑖

𝑛𝑖=1

𝑛

With 𝑥 : the average of values, n : number of tests and 𝑥𝑖 : test value

Standard deviation has been calculated with this formula :

𝜎 = √∑ (𝑥𝑖 − 𝑥)2𝑛

𝑖=1

𝑛 − 1

With σ : standard deviation, 𝑥 : average of values, n : number of tests et 𝑥𝑖 : value of test i.

Verification parameters

The verification parameters were controlled for two scenarios and each of these two scenarios for two types of

flow.

Results for each scenarios are showed in the following table.

Page 23: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

23/ 34

a) Scenario 1 : Maintain the effluent at a 50 NTU concentration corresponding to a TSS-removal of 60% or

higher of the average TSS concentration in the effluent despite daily variations using chemicals

(1) At constant maximum flow = Qmax

For this test scenario, the time period was of 6 weeks.

The results are showed in the Table 1.

Parameters After or before Hydrotech

drumfilter Mean Value Number of measures

PERFORMANCE PARAMETER

Total suspended solids reduction After 76%

standard deviation = 8% 21

OPERATIONAL PARAMETERS

Quantity of flocculant Before 70.4 L/h

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 43 days.

Period of time with a technical issue (power failure, frozen pipe,

no polymer dosing) were excluded from the mean.

Inlet flow Before 29.9 m3/hour

Standard deviation = 1.1%

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 43 days.

Period of time with a technical issue (power failure, frozen pipe,

no polymer dosing) were excluded from the mean.

Water temperature / 14.4°C

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 43 days.

Period of time with a technical issue (power failure, frozen pipe,

no polymer dosing) were excluded from the mean.

Measure of pH Before 7.4 20

After 7.6 20

Page 24: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

24/ 34

Concentration of alkalinity Before 332 21

After 292 21

Concentration of BOD

Before 248

(Min = 170, Max = 290) 6

After 141

(Min = 68, Max = 260) 6

Concentration of total phosphorus

Before 7.4

(Min = 5.9, Max = 11) 6

After 5.1

(Min = 4.1, Max = 7) 6

Concentration of TOC

Before 155

(Min = 110, Max = 200) 6

After 93.2

(Min = 67, Max = 120) 6

ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS

Energy consumption of the drumfilter

(including drumfilter and chemical

equipment)

/ 130Wh/kg TSS removed

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 43 days.

Period of time a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Percentage of operation time the filter

has been in backwash mode / 42%

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 43 days.

Period of time with a technical issue a technical issue due to pilot

line scale were excluded from the mean.

Consumption of cleaning materials / 0.5 Liter 30%HCl

0.75 Liter 2.7% NaClO

Table 1 : Parameters results for scenario 1 at constant maximum flow

Page 25: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

25/ 34

(2) At varying flow similar to true influent = Qavg

For this scenario of tests, the time period was of 9 days.

The results are showed in the Table 2 bellow.

Parameters After or before Hydrotech

drumfilter Mean Value Number of measures

PERFORMANCE PARAMETER

Total suspended solids reduction After 82%

Standard deviation = 2% 5

OPERATIONAL PARAMETERS

Quantity of flocculant Before 41.9 L/h

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 9 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Inlet flow Before Between 6m3/hour

and 29,9 m3/hour

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 9 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Water temperature / 18,6°C

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 9 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Measure of pH Before 7,26 5

After 7,38 5

Concentration of alkalinity Before 358,4 5

After 328,8 5

Concentration of BOD Before No measures

After No measures

Page 26: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

26/ 34

Concentration of total phosphorus Before No measures

After No measures

Concentration of TOC Before No measures

After No measures

ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS

Energy consumption of the full plant

(including drumfilter and chemical

equipment)

/ 212 Wh/kgTSS removed

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 9 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Percentage of operation time the filter

has been in backwash mode / 10%

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 9 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Consumption of cleaning materials / No consumption of cleaning

materials /

Table 2 : Parameters results for scenario 1 with varying flow

Page 27: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

27/ 34

b) Scenario 2 : TSS removal measured as daily average without using chemicals

(1) At constant maximum flow = Qmax

The results are showed in the Table 3 bellow.

Parameters After or before Hydrotech

drumfilter Mean Value Number of measures

PERFORMANCE PARAMETER

Total suspended solids reduction After 43%

14

OPERATIONAL PARAMETERS

Quantity of flocculant Before No use of chemicals /

Inlet flow Before 30m3/hour

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 25 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Water temperature / 14.9°C

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 25 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Measure of pH Before 7.5 14

After 7.5 14

Concentration of alkalinity Before 350.6 14

After 337.7 14

Concentration of BOD

Before 212.5

(Min = 160, Max = 230) 4

After 151

(Min = 94, Max = 190) 4

Page 28: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

28/ 34

Concentration of total phosphorus

Before 6.4

(Min = 5.6, Max = 7.5) 4

After 5.6

(Min = 5.3, Max = 6.4) 4

Concentration of TOC

Before 115

(Min = 110, Max = 120) 4

After 90.8

(Min = 64, Max = 110) 4

ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS

Energy consumption of the drumfilter / 8.7 Wh/m3

84.2 Wh/Kg TSS removed

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 25 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Percentage of operation time the filter

has been in backwash mode / 34%

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 25 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Consumption of cleaning materials /

Cleaning of filter media with

30%Hcl and 2.7% NaClO

Recorded in the logbook

Use of cleaning material 2 times during the test period

Table 3 : Parameters results for scenario 2 at constant maximum flow

Page 29: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

29/ 34

(2) At varying flow similar to true influent = Qavg

The results are showed in the Table 4 bellow.

Parameter After or before Hydrotech

drumfilter Mean Value Number of measures

PERFORMANCE PARAMETER

Total suspended solids reduction After 51%

(from 11% to 70%) 21

OPERATIONAL PARAMETERS

Quantity of flocculant Before No use of chemicals /

Inlet flow Before Between 6 m3/hour

and 29.9 m3/hour

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 48 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Water temperature / 16°C

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 48 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Measure of pH Before 7.4 21

After 7.4 21

Concentration of alkalinity Before 358.9 21

After 344.5 21

Concentration of BOD

Before 235

(Min = 200, Max = 290) 6

After 146.7

(Min = 110, Max = 170) 6

Page 30: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

30/ 34

Concentration of total phosphorus

Before 6.6

(Min = 5.4, Max = 8) 6

After 5.8

(Min = 4.6, Max = 7) 6

Concentration of TOC

Before 135

(Min = 110, Max = 150) 6

After 130

(Min = 100, Max = 200) 6

ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS

Energy consumption of the drumfilter / 14.1 Wh/m3

118.5 Wh/kg TSS removed

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 48 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Percentage of operation time the filter

has been in backwash mode / 14%

Online measurement logged with an interval of 10 seconds

during 48 days.

Period of time with a technical issue due to pilot line scale were

excluded from the mean.

Consumption of cleaning materials / 0.5 liter 30%HCl

0.5 liter 2.7% NaClO /

Table 4 : Parameters results for scenario 2 with varying flow

Page 31: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

31/ 34

Additional parameters, with comments or caveats where appropriate

No additional parameters was defined.

Recommendations for the statement of verification

The proposer may use the Statement of Verification for marketing purposes and for official approvals. It may be

included in the technical documentation of the verified technology. The proposer shall make the statement

available in full and shall not use parts of the statement for any purpose.

The proposer may refer to the Statement of Verification as follows: The XX technology was verified in the

framework of the EU Environmental Technology Verification (ETV) pilot programme for the application AA

(including purpose and matrix9) by BB Verification Body on DD.MM.YYYY. The Statement of Verification has been

registered under number NN and is accessible at the following address:

https://ec.europa.eu/environment/ecoap/etv (where appropriate, replace this address with the one of the

dedicated website designated by the Commission services.)

The proposer shall not use the ETV logo alone either on products or on published (printed, web or other) matter

other than the Statement of Verification. The ETV logo may be used on publications together with the reference

to the Statement of Verification, as provided above, as long as the meaning of ETV is correctly reflected by the

publication, avoiding in particular any confusion with endorsement or approval of the technology.

The proposer shall ensure that the verified technology continues to conform to the published Statement of

Verification. This also follows the provisions of ISO 14034, Section 5.6.2 'Validity of the verification

report/verification statement'. If any of the following changes to the verified technology have occurred, the

proposer shall report to the Verification body with the data needed to evaluate whether the conditions for

verification have changed:

change of ownership;

design changes;

change of intended application or operational conditions;

other changes likely to modify the performance results reported in the Statement of

Verification.

Substitution of one part with another with the same documented specifications is not considered a change,

unless it affects the environmental added value or one of the parameters reported in the Statement of

Verification.

The Verification Body shall evaluate reported changes and data at the cost of the proposer. If, after evaluation,

the Verification Body concludes that the conditions for verification have changed, a new verification procedure

shall be engaged by the proposer for this technology or alternatively, the Statement of Verification shall be

withdrawn.

The Statement of Verification shall be withdrawn by the Verification Body if misused by the proposer. Misuse is

defined as violation of the conditions of EU ETV pilot programme verification.

In the case of withdrawal, the Statement of Verification and verification report shall be removed from all web

sites.

In the EU ETV pilot programme, no expiration date is established on the Statement of Verification. However, the

proposer may request that the Statement of Verification and associated report be withdrawn from the web if,

Page 32: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

32/ 34

for example, the technology is no longer on the market. This request should be made in writing to the Verification

Body, committing to no future use of the Statement of Verification, reference to it or the ETV logo. The

verification Body shall communicate this request to the Commission services and the Statement of Verification

and associated report will be consequently withdrawn from the ETV website.

Page 33: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

33/ 34

The quality management process of the verification is ensured thanks to :

Review of the documents (presented in the Table 5)

Assessment of the test system

ETV inspector ETV technical

manager

External technical

experts

Proposer

Specific

verification

protocol

/ Review Review Review

Test plan Review / Review Review

Test report Review / Review Review

Verification report / Review Review Review

Statement of

verification

/ Review Review Review

Table 5 : Review of the documents process

A test system audit has been performed by Mr Oscar SAMUELSSON as a technical expert before the beginning of

the tests.

Furthermore, Rescoll applies for the ETV verification all the requirements of ISO 17020 standard and GVP v1.2,

2016. Rescoll is accredited by the French accreditation body (COFRAC) to perform ETV verifications.

[1] COFRAC, «http://www.cofrac.fr/,» [En ligne].

V. Quality assurance

VI. References

Page 34: Verification report n°180098d · Tomal/Prominent Polyrex 1.0 (Figure 4) is a turn-key automated system for batchwise preparation and metering of polymer solutions, either powdered

RESCOLL Verification report

Code : Révision : Indice : Page :

E382 22/06/2018 I

34/ 34

This is described in paragraph IV.2.3.

No test report was provided by Hydotech.

VII. Appendix 1 : Quick Scan – Verification proposal

VIII. Appendix 2 : Specific verification protocol

IX. Appendix 3 : Amendment and deviation report for

verification

X. Appendix 4 : Test plan

XI. Appendix 5 : Test report

XII. Appendix 6 : Test system assessment report