VCPs for Staggered PRT Sebastián Torres and David Warde CIMMS/NSSL Data Quality MOU – Technical Interchange Meeting Fall 2008.

VCPs for Staggered PRT

Sebastián Torres and David Warde

CIMMS/NSSL

Data Quality MOU – Technical Interchange Meeting

Fall 2008

2

Outline

• Designing VCPs for Staggered PRT (recap)

– Performance indicators

• Test VCPs 14 and 15 (recap)– Design criteria

• Benefits of using shorter PRTs– Trade-offs

• A new test VCP– Performance analysis

• Recommendation andFuture Work

Staggered PRT

ra = 184 km, va = 45.1 m/s

3

VCP Performance Indicators

• Acquisition time– Dwell times

• Maximum unambiguous range– Surveillance (Z)– Doppler (V & W)

• Maximum unambiguous velocity• Spectrum width saturation• Errors of estimates– Statistical errors– Dealiasing errors

• Clutter suppression

4

PRT Choice

• Shorter PRTs– Larger Nyquist– Larger maximum

spectrum width– More samples for the

same dwell times – Lower errors of

estimates– Lower rate of

catastrophic errors– Better clutter

suppression

• Longer PRTs– Longer unambiguous

range

5

VCP Design Criterion

• Make T1 as short as possible– No-overlay condition

• ra,1 ≥ rmax

– T1 ≥ 2rmax / c

– Algorithm limitation• ra,2 ≥ rmax

– T1 ≥ 4rmax / 3c

• ra,D = ra,1 and ra,S = ra,2

– The no-overlay condition is more restrictive, but not a requirement

– The current SPRT algorithm does not handle range unfolding

6

Test VCPs for Staggered PRT

• 2007: Staggered PRT subcommittee– Two test VCPs based on VCP 12

• Intermediate and high elevations running SPRT ( = 2/3)

• Design criterion

– VCP 14: Same dwell times as VCP 12– VCP 15: Double dwell times as VCP 12 for SPRT

EL < 4 degEL > 4 deg

7

VCPs 14 and 15

8

• If we allow some overlay– ra,1 ≤ rmax ≤ ra,2

• No overlay: ra,1 = rmax

• Maximum overlay: ra,2 = rmax

– Shorter PRTs– Must have technique to recover overlaid

echoes

Overlay Trade-off

ra,2

ra,1

rmax

9

New VCP Design Criterion

• We can trade shorter PRT for increased likelihood of overlaid echoes

– Benefits are realized for elevations above 2.4 deg

Solid: oldDashed: new

10

Choosing the Dwell Times

• Dwell times must be chosen to…– Meet error requirements for reflectivity,

velocity, and spectrum width– Meet clutter filtering requirements– Satisfy operational needs

11

Dwell Times for SACHI (I)

Maximum clutter suppression based on Reflectivity requirements

12

Dwell Times for SACHI (II)

Maximum clutter suppression based on Spectrum Width requirements

13

Dwell Times for SACHI (III)

Maximum clutter suppression based on Velocity requirements

14

Performance of SACHI

• Excessively long dwell times seem to be needed to meet clutter filtering velocity requirements

– Feasible, but operationally not acceptable

• Recommend using dwell times to meet error requirements

– Longer dwell times than with VCP 12, but operationally acceptable

• We have anecdotal evidence of operators switching from VCP 12 to VCP 21 to get what they want

15

Performance of SACHI

• Only Doppler velocities are affected corresponding to gates …

– … with strong clutter contamination and … – … with velocities around 0, ±va/5, ±2va/5 and …– … where SACHI doesn’t pick the right wx “replica” and …

– … where the ORPG velocity dealiasing algorithm fails to fix spatial discontinuity

• This has not been quantified!

• Censoring of “bad velocities” is possible– Reflectivities are still good for rainfall rate estimates

• Standard errors are more than 3x better than with the Batch mode

– Spectrum widths are still good for turbulence

16

Proposed VCP

• T1 for maximum allowable overlay

• Dwell times to meet error requirements

– VCP time ~6 min

17

Proposed VCP Performance• Acquisition time– Longer dwell times lead to VCP time ~6 min

• Maximum unambiguous range and velocity– Great improvement w.r.t legacy VCPs

• Spectrum width saturation– Acceptable

• Errors of estimates– Statistical errors meet requirements– Catastrophic errors effectively handled by ORPG’s

VDA

• Clutter suppression– Meets requirements for Z and W– V dealiasing errors may be handled by ORPG’s VDA

18

Summary

• Staggered PRT provides significant benefits …

– Longer unambiguous range– Larger Nyquist velocity– More accurate reflectivity estimates

• … that must be traded for …– Longer acquisition times (~VCP 21)

• Operationally acceptable

– Increased rate of velocity dealiasing errors• Handled by ORPG’s VDA

19

Future Work

• Recommendation– Implement proposed test VCP– Collect more data cases – Process data using recommended SPRT

algorithm including SACHI and modified ORPG velocity dealiasing algorithm

– Assess data quality

• Future work– Complete evaluation of technique

to recover overlaid echoes for SPRT– Research ways to improve SACHI

Back up slides

21

VCP 12