28 September 2011 1 UTSpeaks: Progress or procrastination? Chris Riedy - 28 September, 2011
Jan 12, 2015
1
28 September 2011
UTSpeaks: Progress or procrastination?Chris Riedy - 28 September, 2011
2
Chris Riedy, UTSpeaks, 28 September 2011
(Re)engaging communities in climate change response
28 September 2011
3
Why should communities be engaged?• We will all feel the impacts of climate change• Principle – impacted communities should be empowered to influence the outcomes
28 September 2011
4
Why should communities be engaged?• We will all feel the responses• Principle – impacted communities should be empowered to influence the outcomes
28 September 2011
5
Why should communities be engaged?• Carbon politics – need bipartisan support but politicians will not move until
sufficient votes are on the line• Carbon markets – businesses respond to market pull
Photo: AYCC
28 September 2011
6
Climate Change Think TankWhat can you do?
21 September 2011Source: ACF Consumption Atlas
28 September 2011
The self• Knowledge• Values• Attitudes• Frames• Habits
The group• Friends, family, peers, communities• Media• Social norms• Art and culture• Collective decision-making
The system• Local context• Technology and
infrastructure• The financial
landscape• Rules and institutions
Three influences on what we do
8
Sometimes we can’t afford to do things that make sense
Zero carbon home Never pay an energy bill again Extra cost will pay for itself in
11 years But, adds 15% to upfront cost
Pay-as-you-save loan Loan to pay for zero carbon
features Repayments from energy
savings If you move, the loan stays
with the home
28 September 2011
9
Clean Energy Future package
Carbon price will provide some financial incentive
Micro-finance (no interest loans) for low-income households to buy energy efficient appliances
Nothing of note for other households
Need to overcome legacy of botched household insulation, Green Loans and feed-in tariff schemes Great ideas, poorly executed High consumer demand
28 September 2011
28 September 2011
The self• Knowledge• Values• Attitudes• Frames• Habits
The group• Friends, family, peers, communities• Media• Social norms• Art and culture• Collective decision-making
The system• Local context• Technology• Financial incentives
and penalties• Rules and institutions
Three influences on what we do
11
A community consensus?
“if we are to have a price on carbon and do all the things necessary for our economy and our society to adjust we need a deep and lasting community consensus about that. We don’t have it now.”
Julia Gillard, 24th June 2010
28 September 2011Photos: Mugfaker (top), Erland Howden (bottom)
12
Can we move up the spectrum of participation?• Current approach informs and (barely) consults• What would collaborative or empowered decision-making look like?
28 September 2011
13
A citizens’ assembly on climate change?• Gillard Government botched its first attempt at this idea – could it be resurrected?• World Wide Views on Global Warming, 26 September 2009
28 September 2011
28 September 2011
The self• Knowledge• Values• Attitudes• Frames• Habits
The group• Friends, family, peers, communities• Media• Social norms• Art and culture• Collective decision-making
The system• Local context• Technology• Financial incentives
and penalties• Rules and institutions
Three influences on what we do
15
Where is the inspiring vision? Futerra, Sell the Sizzle (2009)
“Threats of climate hell haven’t seemed to hold us back from running headlong towards it”
“We must build a visual and compelling vision of climate heaven”
28 September 2011
We should be framing climate change as an opportunity Better cities Healthier lifestyles Green jobs Renewable energy
superpower A resource of the
imagination (Hulme)
16
Vision in the Clean Energy Future package
Shifts in the framing From climate change to
carbon pollution to clean energy future
Similar shift towards positive visions in the US
But a slogan is not a vision and the Clean Energy Future Package does little to inspire
28 September 2011
17
Communities can’t do it alone• A polycentric approach to learn by experimenting• Action across all scales, by all sectors• But, communities can provide the spark
28 September 2011